Study guide
11.3 Evaluating Employees
Florida HVAC Contractor License Class A/B
Track your progress as you read
Finished sections get a check mark.
1 Introduction & Exam Overview
1.1 Current Exam Facts & License Classes 1.2 Exam Format, Open-Book Rules & Pearson VUE 1.3 Eligibility, Experience Paths & Financial Responsibility
2 Establishing the Contracting Business
2.1 Business Organizational Structure 2.2 Business Plan, Marketplace & License Scope 2.3 Professionals, Fixed Assets & Bonding
3 Insurance for Florida HVAC Contractors
3.1 Obtaining Insurance (GL, Workers' Compensation & Bonds) 3.2 Coverages, Limits & Policy Language 3.3 Maintaining Insurance & CILB Certificate-Holder Rules
4 Overhead, Staffing & Markets
4.1 Developing the Business, Staffing & Markets 4.2 Determining Business Overhead (FICA, FUTA, SUTA, Workers' Comp, Rent & Utilities) 4.3 Determining Outsourced Services
5 Bids, Proposals & Estimating
5.1 Preparing Bids and Proposals 5.2 AIA Documents, Offers & Contract Components 5.3 Labor Productivity, Overhead & Project Costing
6 Purchasing, Invoices, Draws & Safety Programs
6.1 Purchasing Materials, UCC & Inventory (FIFO) 6.2 Invoices, Draw Requests & Percentage of Completion 6.3 Developing a Safety Program (OSHA, SDS & Drug Testing)
7 Managing Contracts
7.1 Contract Law, Scope & Completion Schedules 7.2 Florida Lien Law Inside Contracting 7.3 Mediation, Arbitration, Tort Law & Risk
8 Managing Trade Operations
8.1 Scheduling Trade Operations (CPM, RFI & Submittals) 8.2 OSHA Records, Document Retainage & Penalties 8.3 Takeoffs, Equipment Lease vs Purchase & Inventory
9 Accounting I: Receivables, Payables & Cash
9.1 Managing Accounts Receivable 9.2 Managing Accounts Payable & Discounts 9.3 Cash Flow, Banking & Financial Ratios
10 Accounting II: Taxes, Job Cost & Payroll
10.1 Filing Tax Forms & Returns 10.2 Tracking Job Costs 10.3 Payroll, Employment Taxes & Garnishments
11 Managing Human Resources
11.1 Hiring, I-9, Background Checks & Discrimination 11.2 HR Policies, OSHA & Drug-Test Chain of Custody 11.3 Evaluating Employees
12 Florida Contractor Law: Chapter 489 & 61G4
12.1 Chapter 489: Certified vs Registered & Qualifying Agents 12.2 61G4 Board Rules, Advertising & Discipline 12.3 Qualifying Agent Duties, Supervision & Additional Entities
13 Florida Construction Lien Law (Chapter 713)
13.1 Construction Lien Overview & Claimants 13.2 Notices to Owner, Time Limits & Perfecting Liens 13.3 Payment Bonds, Waivers & Claims of Lien
14 Financial Responsibility, CE & Federal Rules
14.1 Financial Responsibility & the 660 FICO Rule 14.2 Continuing Education & Biennial Renewal 14.3 Federal Employment, Immigration, OSHA & Environmental Rules
15 Plans, Specs & Equipment Selection
15.1 Reading Plans, Specifications, Symbols & Scales 15.2 Recommending Plan Changes & Equipment Types 15.3 EER, SEER, ARI Listings & Cost Effectiveness
16 Energy Codes, Loads & Thermal Resistance
16.1 Florida Energy Codes, R-Values & U-Factors 16.2 Determining HVAC Heating & Cooling Loads 16.3 Applying Energy Conservation, Fan Curves & Pump Curves
17 HVAC System & Duct Design
17.1 Designing HVAC Systems (Psychrometrics, Enthalpy & Airflow) 17.2 Designing Duct Systems & Insulation 17.3 Selecting Equipment, Location & Codes
18 Piping, Pumps, Boilers, Controls & Rigging Design
18.1 Pipe Sizing, Valves, Fittings, Sealants & Layout 18.2 Control Requirements, Fan Motors, CFM & Compressor Capacity 18.3 Pumps, Boilers, Steam, Fuel & Pipe Insulation 18.4 Grease Ducts, Live Loads, Rigging & Mechanical Equipment
19 Sheet Metal Duct Fabrication
19.1 Fabricating Rectangular & Round Ducts 19.2 Seams, Locks, Taping, Mastics & Liners 19.3 Fittings, Outlets & Grilles 19.4 Kitchen Hoods, Exhausts & Drain Pans
20 Split, Package & Heat Pump Installation
20.1 Installing Split & Package Air Conditioners 20.2 Installing Split & Package Heat Pumps 20.3 Air-Cooled vs Water-Cooled Systems
21 Large Systems, Chillers & Towers
21.1 Installing by Tonnage & Class A vs Class B Limits 21.2 Chilled Water, Water Towers & Secondary Coolant 21.3 Centrifugal, Absorption & Ammonia Systems
22 Refrigeration, Coolers, Ventilation & Controls Install
22.1 Low, Medium & Ultra-Low Temperature Systems & EPA Rules 22.2 Walk-In & Reach-In Coolers 22.3 Ventilation, Exhaust, Makeup Air, Grease Ducts & Kitchen Exhaust 22.4 Geothermal, Pneumatic & DDC Controls, TAB & Smoke Tests
23 Condensers, Compressors & Air Handlers
23.1 Installing Air-Cooled & Water-Cooled Condensers 23.2 Hermetic, Semi-Hermetic & Centrifugal Compressors 23.3 Air Handlers, Evaporators, Heat Exchangers, Receivers & Heat Strips
24 Duct, Fans, Filters & Terminals
24.1 Installing Sheet Metal, Fiberglass & Flexible Duct 24.2 Fans, Blowers, Motors, Grilles, Registers & Fire Dampers 24.3 Filters, Flues, Warm-Air, Gas & Fuel-Oil Appliances
25 Refrigerant Piping & Joining
25.1 Refrigerant Piping, Copper Tubing & Pipe Sizing 25.2 Brazing, Welding, Flaring, Swaging & Soldering 25.3 Steel Pipe, Plastic Pipe, Threading & Oxy-Acetylene 25.4 Hangers, Supports, Horizontally Supported Piping & Pressure Testing
26 Metering Devices & Line Components
26.1 TXVs, Capillary Tubes, Reversing Valves & Metering Devices 26.2 Liquid, Suction & Heat-Pump Dryers, Filters & Oil Traps 26.3 Receivers, Heat Strips, Gas/Oil Appliances & Related Accessories
27 Controls Installation
27.1 Pressure, Temperature, Humidity & Bellows Controls 27.2 Thermostats, Humidistats, Pneumatic & Solid-State Controls 27.3 Transformers, Capacitors, Contactors, Relays & Safety Disconnects 27.4 Defrost Components, Starters, Solenoids & Limit Switches
28 Motors, Wiring & Electrical Installation
28.1 Wiring Single-Phase & Three-Phase Equipment 28.2 Motor Types, Protection, Controllers, Belts & Pulleys 28.3 Geothermal Loops, Surge Protectors, Phase Monitors & Plastic Pipe
29 Diagnostic Analysis: Refrigeration
29.1 Pressure-Enthalpy Diagrams & Operating Pressures 29.2 Air Volumes, Enthalpy, Wet-Bulb & Dry-Bulb 29.3 Leak Detection & Refrigeration Test Instruments
30 Diagnostic Analysis: Electrical & Instruments
30.1 Current Draw, Voltage, Power & Motor Terminals 30.2 Testing Relays, Capacitors, Starters, Transformers & Defrost Stats 30.3 Using Amprobes, Velometers, Pitot Tubes, Manometers & Gauges
31 Recovery, Repair & Calibration
31.1 Nitrogen & Gas Regulators, Recovery & Retrofit 31.2 Repairing Hermetic, Semi-Hermetic, Centrifugal Compressors & Blowers 31.3 Calibrating Thermostats, Pressure Switches & Pneumatic Controls 31.4 Superheat, Safety Cutouts, Defrost Clocks & Freezer Controls
32 Mechanical Service & Cleaning
32.1 Belts, Pulleys, Motor Rotation & Seized Compressors 32.2 Crankcase & Evaporator Pressure Regulators & Unloaders 32.3 Cleaning Towers, Condensers, Foreign Matter & Condensate Drains
33 Jobsite Safety & Equipment
33.1 PPE: Hearing, Head, Eye, Face & Respiratory Protection 33.2 Lockout/Tagout, Warning Signs, Toxic Materials & Ventilation 33.3 Rigging, Hoists, Cranes, Forklifts, Backhoes & Excavation 33.4 Ladders, Scaffolds, Tools & Air Compressors
34 Energy Management
34.1 Envelope, Duct Pressure & Blower-Door Testing 34.2 Efficient Equipment, Zoning, ERVs, Wi-Fi Thermostats & Green Buildings 34.3 Energy Forms, R/U Factors, Window Heat Gain & Florida Load Calcs
35 Indoor Air Quality
35.1 Ventilation, Filtration, Humidity, UV & Air Cleaners 35.2 Contaminants, Source Control, TAB & Human Health Effects
11.3 Evaluating Employees
Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI
B&F Area E item 3 is evaluate employees under employment and labor laws. Florida is at-will, but evaluations, handbooks, and oral promises can create evidence of pretext, implied contract, or discrimination if they are not job-related and consistent.
Write essential functions into the job description before you rate anyone. HVAC measures that survive scrutiny include callback rate, incomplete tickets, current EPA Section 608 certification, safety incidents, van incidents, and documentation quality — not age, leave, or workers' compensation history.
Progressive discipline (coaching, written warning, suspension, termination) is not required by Florida statute, but contemporaneous written warnings are how you prove misconduct for reemployment-assistance (unemployment) purposes under Chapter 443 and how you defend a discrimination charge.
Unsatisfactory performance (slow, needs more training) usually still lets a claimant collect unemployment; willful or repeated misconduct after warning may disqualify. Retaliation for a workers' compensation claim, an OSHA 11(c) complaint, or a private-sector whistleblower report under F.S. 448.102 is unlawful even in an at-will shop.
Florida has no statute requiring same-day final wages; pay on the next regular payday. ADA evaluation means rating essential functions and running the interactive process for a reasonable accommodation, not using a disability or a workers' compensation file as the reason for a poor review.
Last updated: August 2026
11.3 Evaluating Employees
B&F Area E item 3 is evaluate employees , still under employment and labor laws . Hiring (11.1) and policies (11.2) fail in the field if the qualifier never writes down what "good tech" means and then fires people by vibe. Evaluation is how you assign trucks, approve raises, document overtime abuse, and defend the unemployment claim that hits the reemployment tax rate. It is also how you prove — or accidentally disprove — that a termination was for a lawful reason in an at-will state.
Florida at-will means you may generally end employment for any lawful reason or for no reason. You may not end it for an unlawful reason: race, color, religion, sex, pregnancy, national origin, age, handicap, or marital status (F.S. 760.10 and the parallel federal statutes), retaliation for workers' compensation, OSHA 11(c) , jury duty, USERRA military service, or a private-sector whistleblower report under F.S. 448.102 (objecting to illegal activity, refusing to participate, or reporting to an appropriate agency). A review that says "too old for roofs," "too many comp claims," or "always pregnant" is not an evaluation. It is a plaintiff's exhibit.
Job descriptions are the evaluation instrument
You cannot fairly rate what you never defined. Before the first review, the file should contain a job description of essential functions : recover and charge to EPA 608 rules, braze, read a manometer, complete a ticket the same day, drive a van with a valid license, wear required PPE, and — for the Class A shop — work on boilers, unfired pressure vessels, or large tonnage when that is actually the job. Class B's 25-ton / 500,000 Btu limit changes which systems the person installs; it does not change how you document attendance. EPA Section 608 certification is a federal qualification for refrigerant work, not a CILB license, and it belongs on the evaluation if the job handles refrigerant.
ADA evaluation is the essential-functions test. Rate whether the person can perform those functions with or without reasonable accommodation . If a tech returns from a knee injury and asks for a mechanical lift or a temporary no-attic restriction, you engage in the interactive process . "We don't accommodate field people" is not undue hardship. Undue hardship is a fact-specific showing of significant difficulty or expense, not a slogan. Do not ask for genetic information (GINA) or a full medical file you do not need. Medical information, when you lawfully have it, is stored separate from the general personnel file.
What to measure on an HVAC crew
Subjective "attitude" scores, used alone, are how two techs with the same callback rate get different ratings because one is the owner's nephew. Prefer numbers the Contractors Manual world understands:
Measure Why it is job-related Exam trap
Callback / incomplete-ticket rate Directly tied to workmanship and warranty cost Do not count a callback caused by a wrong factory part against only the oldest tech
Safety incidents and near-miss reports 1926 program and 11(c) Never score someone down for reporting a hazard
Current EPA 608 and any required driver's license Legal qualification for the work Lapsed 608 is a qualification issue, not a national-origin issue
Timekeeping and overtime honesty FLSA; non-exempt techs Do not praise unpaid off-clock paperwork
Van incidents and GPS policy compliance FCRA/MVR hiring plus ongoing duty Apply the same points to every driver
Documentation quality (photos, model/serial, refrigerant log) Warranty, EPA recordkeeping, Chapter 713 billing support Do not invent a "younger techs just get phones" standard
Review on a fixed cycle (90 days for new hires, then at least annually) and when a triggering event happens (failed recovery, customer assault complaint, second no-call/no-show). Have both the supervisor and the employee sign. If the employee refuses, note the refusal. Contemporaneous notes beat a reconstructed file built the week after the EEOC charge arrives.
Progressive discipline, handbooks, and implied contract
Florida does not require progressive discipline. Many HVAC shops still use it because Chapter 443 unemployment (reemployment assistance) and discrimination defense both reward a paper trail:
Coaching / verbal counseling , noted in the file the same day.
Written warning tied to a specific rule (late, missing recovery log, no fall protection on a 12-foot package unit).
Final written warning or unpaid suspension , with a date by which the behavior must change.
Termination , with a memo that quotes the policy and the prior warnings.
A performance improvement plan (PIP) is a written version of step 2 or 3 with measurable goals (callback rate under X, 608 recert by date Y). If the handbook says employees will receive three warnings, you have handed the claimant an implied contract argument. Keep the at-will disclaimer , say discipline may be skipped for serious misconduct (theft, violence, working on live conductors without lockout), and then actually follow your own procedure for ordinary issues.
Worked unemployment example. Tech A is written up in January, March, and April for no-call/no-show, then terminated in May. That pattern is the kind of misconduct — willful or wanton, or repeated after warning — that can disqualify a Chapter 443 claimant. Tech B is terminated because "he's getting slow and we're a young shop," with no prior reviews, after 22 years and a recent workers' compensation ankle claim. Tech B is likely eligible for benefits (poor performance, not misconduct), and the file now also looks like ADEA plus 440 retaliation. The employer's reemployment tax experience rating moves with charged benefits. Document the lawful reason before the discharge, not after.
Termination, final pay, and references
Collect keys, van, recovery machine, and refrigerant. Disable after-hours shop codes. Pay all wages earned , including overtime already worked. Florida has no statute requiring same-day or next-day final wages for private employers; pay on the next regular payday . Do not deduct for unreturned tools unless you have a lawful, written, and actually valid wage-deduction path — the exam trap is docking a final check below minimum wage. Accrued PTO follows the written policy; if the handbook says unused vacation is paid at separation, pay it.
References. Florida employers have a qualified privilege for good-faith, fact-based references. Many shops still confirm only dates and title. Do not volunteer a medical diagnosis or a drug-test metabolite. Do not blackball someone for filing a workers' compensation claim.
WARN Act (60-day notice of a plant closing or mass layoff) is a 100-employee federal statute most single HVAC shops never hit. Do not import it into a three-person residential discharge.
What you may not use the evaluation to do
Punish protected activity. A drop in the rating the week after a 440 claim, an OSHA complaint, an FCHR charge, or a 448.102 report is retaliation evidence even if the person was not a star. Constructive discharge (making conditions so intolerable a reasonable person would quit) is still a discharge for these purposes.
Skip the ADA interactive process because "eval season is a bad time."
Rank by age, pregnancy, or marital status in a layoff. If you must reduce staff, use a written, job-related matrix (license, 608, safety record, productivity) applied the same way to everyone, and keep the matrix.
Misclassify the person as a 1099 after a bad review so you can avoid unemployment. Chapter 440 and the IRS tests in the staffing chapter still apply.
Ignore FLSA in the evaluation of hours. If you praise a non-exempt tech for "always finishing paperwork at home unpaid," you have documented wage theft. Forty hours is still the overtime trigger; salary is still not an automatic exemption for a person whose primary duty is brazing and troubleshooting.
Florida HVAC scenario
Treasure Coast Mechanical, certified Class A, employs 18 people (Title VII / ADA / F.S. 760.10 apply; ADEA does not yet, because ADEA is 20 employees — but 760.10 still lists age at 15, so do not treat 18 as an age-discrimination-free zone under Florida law). The qualifier wants to remove a 61-year-old service manager who has become sharp with customers. The personnel file has two glowing reviews and nothing since a workers' compensation shoulder claim last fall. The qualifier writes a same-day evaluation: "Lacks energy. Not a good fit for our image. Possible light-duty issues." That sentence block is age, disability, and retaliation evidence stacked on an empty file.
The lawful path is the one Area E is testing. Restate the essential functions (customer communication, complete tickets, safety, 608, supervision of apprentices). Give a job-related written warning for documented customer complaints, with examples and dates. Offer a PIP with a 30-day check. If the conduct continues, terminate for that conduct, pay the next regular payday, and tell the unemployment office the truth with the warnings attached. If the real issue is the shoulder, start the ADA interactive process , not a personality review. If the real issue is the comp claim, you do not have a lawful evaluation — you have a 440 retaliation problem. Class A tonnage and boilers do not change that analysis; a Class B shop running 4-ton changeouts uses the same labor law and the same B&F item.