Study guide
20.3 Air-Cooled vs Water-Cooled Systems
Florida HVAC Contractor License Class A/B
Track your progress as you read
Finished sections get a check mark.
1 Introduction & Exam Overview
1.1 Current Exam Facts & License Classes 1.2 Exam Format, Open-Book Rules & Pearson VUE 1.3 Eligibility, Experience Paths & Financial Responsibility
2 Establishing the Contracting Business
2.1 Business Organizational Structure 2.2 Business Plan, Marketplace & License Scope 2.3 Professionals, Fixed Assets & Bonding
3 Insurance for Florida HVAC Contractors
3.1 Obtaining Insurance (GL, Workers' Compensation & Bonds) 3.2 Coverages, Limits & Policy Language 3.3 Maintaining Insurance & CILB Certificate-Holder Rules
4 Overhead, Staffing & Markets
4.1 Developing the Business, Staffing & Markets 4.2 Determining Business Overhead (FICA, FUTA, SUTA, Workers' Comp, Rent & Utilities) 4.3 Determining Outsourced Services
5 Bids, Proposals & Estimating
5.1 Preparing Bids and Proposals 5.2 AIA Documents, Offers & Contract Components 5.3 Labor Productivity, Overhead & Project Costing
6 Purchasing, Invoices, Draws & Safety Programs
6.1 Purchasing Materials, UCC & Inventory (FIFO) 6.2 Invoices, Draw Requests & Percentage of Completion 6.3 Developing a Safety Program (OSHA, SDS & Drug Testing)
7 Managing Contracts
7.1 Contract Law, Scope & Completion Schedules 7.2 Florida Lien Law Inside Contracting 7.3 Mediation, Arbitration, Tort Law & Risk
8 Managing Trade Operations
8.1 Scheduling Trade Operations (CPM, RFI & Submittals) 8.2 OSHA Records, Document Retainage & Penalties 8.3 Takeoffs, Equipment Lease vs Purchase & Inventory
9 Accounting I: Receivables, Payables & Cash
9.1 Managing Accounts Receivable 9.2 Managing Accounts Payable & Discounts 9.3 Cash Flow, Banking & Financial Ratios
10 Accounting II: Taxes, Job Cost & Payroll
10.1 Filing Tax Forms & Returns 10.2 Tracking Job Costs 10.3 Payroll, Employment Taxes & Garnishments
11 Managing Human Resources
11.1 Hiring, I-9, Background Checks & Discrimination 11.2 HR Policies, OSHA & Drug-Test Chain of Custody 11.3 Evaluating Employees
12 Florida Contractor Law: Chapter 489 & 61G4
12.1 Chapter 489: Certified vs Registered & Qualifying Agents 12.2 61G4 Board Rules, Advertising & Discipline 12.3 Qualifying Agent Duties, Supervision & Additional Entities
13 Florida Construction Lien Law (Chapter 713)
13.1 Construction Lien Overview & Claimants 13.2 Notices to Owner, Time Limits & Perfecting Liens 13.3 Payment Bonds, Waivers & Claims of Lien
14 Financial Responsibility, CE & Federal Rules
14.1 Financial Responsibility & the 660 FICO Rule 14.2 Continuing Education & Biennial Renewal 14.3 Federal Employment, Immigration, OSHA & Environmental Rules
15 Plans, Specs & Equipment Selection
15.1 Reading Plans, Specifications, Symbols & Scales 15.2 Recommending Plan Changes & Equipment Types 15.3 EER, SEER, ARI Listings & Cost Effectiveness
16 Energy Codes, Loads & Thermal Resistance
16.1 Florida Energy Codes, R-Values & U-Factors 16.2 Determining HVAC Heating & Cooling Loads 16.3 Applying Energy Conservation, Fan Curves & Pump Curves
17 HVAC System & Duct Design
17.1 Designing HVAC Systems (Psychrometrics, Enthalpy & Airflow) 17.2 Designing Duct Systems & Insulation 17.3 Selecting Equipment, Location & Codes
18 Piping, Pumps, Boilers, Controls & Rigging Design
18.1 Pipe Sizing, Valves, Fittings, Sealants & Layout 18.2 Control Requirements, Fan Motors, CFM & Compressor Capacity 18.3 Pumps, Boilers, Steam, Fuel & Pipe Insulation 18.4 Grease Ducts, Live Loads, Rigging & Mechanical Equipment
19 Sheet Metal Duct Fabrication
19.1 Fabricating Rectangular & Round Ducts 19.2 Seams, Locks, Taping, Mastics & Liners 19.3 Fittings, Outlets & Grilles 19.4 Kitchen Hoods, Exhausts & Drain Pans
20 Split, Package & Heat Pump Installation
20.1 Installing Split & Package Air Conditioners 20.2 Installing Split & Package Heat Pumps 20.3 Air-Cooled vs Water-Cooled Systems
21 Large Systems, Chillers & Towers
21.1 Installing by Tonnage & Class A vs Class B Limits 21.2 Chilled Water, Water Towers & Secondary Coolant 21.3 Centrifugal, Absorption & Ammonia Systems
22 Refrigeration, Coolers, Ventilation & Controls Install
22.1 Low, Medium & Ultra-Low Temperature Systems & EPA Rules 22.2 Walk-In & Reach-In Coolers 22.3 Ventilation, Exhaust, Makeup Air, Grease Ducts & Kitchen Exhaust 22.4 Geothermal, Pneumatic & DDC Controls, TAB & Smoke Tests
23 Condensers, Compressors & Air Handlers
23.1 Installing Air-Cooled & Water-Cooled Condensers 23.2 Hermetic, Semi-Hermetic & Centrifugal Compressors 23.3 Air Handlers, Evaporators, Heat Exchangers, Receivers & Heat Strips
24 Duct, Fans, Filters & Terminals
24.1 Installing Sheet Metal, Fiberglass & Flexible Duct 24.2 Fans, Blowers, Motors, Grilles, Registers & Fire Dampers 24.3 Filters, Flues, Warm-Air, Gas & Fuel-Oil Appliances
25 Refrigerant Piping & Joining
25.1 Refrigerant Piping, Copper Tubing & Pipe Sizing 25.2 Brazing, Welding, Flaring, Swaging & Soldering 25.3 Steel Pipe, Plastic Pipe, Threading & Oxy-Acetylene 25.4 Hangers, Supports, Horizontally Supported Piping & Pressure Testing
26 Metering Devices & Line Components
26.1 TXVs, Capillary Tubes, Reversing Valves & Metering Devices 26.2 Liquid, Suction & Heat-Pump Dryers, Filters & Oil Traps 26.3 Receivers, Heat Strips, Gas/Oil Appliances & Related Accessories
27 Controls Installation
27.1 Pressure, Temperature, Humidity & Bellows Controls 27.2 Thermostats, Humidistats, Pneumatic & Solid-State Controls 27.3 Transformers, Capacitors, Contactors, Relays & Safety Disconnects 27.4 Defrost Components, Starters, Solenoids & Limit Switches
28 Motors, Wiring & Electrical Installation
28.1 Wiring Single-Phase & Three-Phase Equipment 28.2 Motor Types, Protection, Controllers, Belts & Pulleys 28.3 Geothermal Loops, Surge Protectors, Phase Monitors & Plastic Pipe
29 Diagnostic Analysis: Refrigeration
29.1 Pressure-Enthalpy Diagrams & Operating Pressures 29.2 Air Volumes, Enthalpy, Wet-Bulb & Dry-Bulb 29.3 Leak Detection & Refrigeration Test Instruments
30 Diagnostic Analysis: Electrical & Instruments
30.1 Current Draw, Voltage, Power & Motor Terminals 30.2 Testing Relays, Capacitors, Starters, Transformers & Defrost Stats 30.3 Using Amprobes, Velometers, Pitot Tubes, Manometers & Gauges
31 Recovery, Repair & Calibration
31.1 Nitrogen & Gas Regulators, Recovery & Retrofit 31.2 Repairing Hermetic, Semi-Hermetic, Centrifugal Compressors & Blowers 31.3 Calibrating Thermostats, Pressure Switches & Pneumatic Controls 31.4 Superheat, Safety Cutouts, Defrost Clocks & Freezer Controls
32 Mechanical Service & Cleaning
32.1 Belts, Pulleys, Motor Rotation & Seized Compressors 32.2 Crankcase & Evaporator Pressure Regulators & Unloaders 32.3 Cleaning Towers, Condensers, Foreign Matter & Condensate Drains
33 Jobsite Safety & Equipment
33.1 PPE: Hearing, Head, Eye, Face & Respiratory Protection 33.2 Lockout/Tagout, Warning Signs, Toxic Materials & Ventilation 33.3 Rigging, Hoists, Cranes, Forklifts, Backhoes & Excavation 33.4 Ladders, Scaffolds, Tools & Air Compressors
34 Energy Management
34.1 Envelope, Duct Pressure & Blower-Door Testing 34.2 Efficient Equipment, Zoning, ERVs, Wi-Fi Thermostats & Green Buildings 34.3 Energy Forms, R/U Factors, Window Heat Gain & Florida Load Calcs
35 Indoor Air Quality
35.1 Ventilation, Filtration, Humidity, UV & Air Cleaners 35.2 Contaminants, Source Control, TAB & Human Health Effects
20.3 Air-Cooled vs Water-Cooled Systems
Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI
An air-cooled system rejects condenser heat to outdoor air with a fan; a water-cooled system rejects condenser heat to condenser water that is usually cooled in a cooling tower (FBC Mechanical 2023 Section 908).
At a 10°F condenser-water range, flow is about 2.4 gpm per ton: GPM = Btu/h ÷ (500 × ΔT). A 20-ton water-cooled unit at 10°F range needs 48 gpm.
Cooling-tower range is entering minus leaving condenser water (often 95°F to 85°F); approach is leaving condenser water minus outdoor wet-bulb (85°F leaving and 78°F WB is a 7°F approach).
Air-cooled outdoor units and towers both take FBC Mechanical 301.15 wind resistance, listing clearances, and 304.10 grade/pad rules. Class B may install either type only through 25 tons of cooling and 500,000 Btu of heating in any one system; a 30-ton water-cooled package is Class A.
Last updated: August 2026
20.3 Air-Cooled vs Water-Cooled Systems
The last two Trade Area C items in this chapter are installing air-cooled systems and installing water-cooled systems . Chapters 21 and 23 pick up large chillers, remote condensers, and centrifugal machines. Here you must name the heat-rejection path , size the condenser water when there is water, keep Florida wind and clearances honest, and apply the Class B 25-ton fence. Refrigeration & Air Conditioning Technology , 9th Edition (2021), FBC Mechanical 2023 (including Section 908 cooling towers, evaporative condensers, and fluid coolers), and F.S. 489.105 are the references.
Quick Answer: Air-cooled condensers dump heat to outdoor air . Water-cooled condensers dump heat to water , almost always a cooling-tower loop, at about 2.4 gpm per ton for a 10°F range . Both need listing clearances and 301.15 wind resistance. Class B installs either type only up to 25 tons / 500,000 Btu in any one system .
Air-cooled heat rejection
An air-cooled condenser is a coil plus a fan. Refrigerant condenses inside the tubes; outdoor air carries the heat away. Every split condensing unit in 20.1 and every air-cooled package or heat pump in 20.1–20.2 is this machine. Install rules that actually change capacity:
Listing clearances on sides, top, and discharge. A 12-inch side yard when the IOM says 24 inches recirculates hot air into the entering face, raises condensing temperature, cuts capacity, and trips high pressure on a 95°F Florida afternoon.
Discharge path. Do not bury an RTU in a penthouse well or a decorative screen that returns its own 20-degree-hotter plume to the coil. That is the P-h failure from Chapter 17, now as an install defect.
Pad and wind. 304.10 : slab 3 inches above grade (or 6 inches suspended). 301.15 : resist FBC Building wind pressures with listed straps, clips, or through-bolts. HVHZ (Miami-Dade/Broward) adds product-approval discipline; the rest of Florida still does not get a loose condenser on pavers. 301.16 : flood elevation.
Airflow across the coil. Dirty fins, bent guards, and landscaping that grows into the intake are maintenance (later chapters) and also install if you set the unit in a hedge on day one.
Package versus remote. A packaged air-cooled RTU has the condenser in the same cabinet as the evaporator. A remote air-cooled condenser sits on the roof with refrigerant piping back to an indoor compressor — still air-cooled, still 301.15, still nitrogen-purged piping (20.1). Class B’s 25-ton cap applies to the system , not to “the small box on the roof.”
Air-cooled machines do not need condenser-water pumps, towers, or 908 blowdown piping. They do still need 307 condensate from the evaporator (indoor coil or package drain pan). Do not confuse condenser-fan water (there is none) with evaporator condensate.
Water-cooled heat rejection
A water-cooled condenser transfers refrigerant heat into a water stream. Common construction is tube-in-tube , shell-and-tube , or shell-and-coil (Trade D will install the vessel; Trade C is the system). That water then goes to:
- A cooling tower (open recirculating — the usual HVAC plant),
- A closed-circuit fluid cooler (coil in the tower, process water stays closed),
Rarely, once-through city or well water — wasteful, generally inconsistent with energy and water rules, and still requiring backflow protection on a potable makeup ( 301.11 points plumbing connections to the Florida Plumbing Code).
FBC Mechanical Section 908 governs cooling towers, evaporative condensers, and fluid coolers: support, drainage of overflow and blowdown to an approved location (not a parking-lot nuisance and not a mystery sanitary tap), makeup water, and placement so discharge air and drift do not dump onto intakes, neighbors, or the tower’s own inlet. Tower fans and cabinets on a Florida roof are wind-exposed appliances under 301.15 . Indoor water-cooled package units still need a water-regulating valve or pump, strainer, and drain; they do not magically become “no outdoor equipment” jobs if the tower sits on the roof.
Range and approach are the two tower numbers the exam likes.
Range = condenser-water entering the tower minus leaving the tower (which is also condenser leaving minus entering at the machine). A common design is 95°F in / 85°F out , a 10°F range .
Approach = tower leaving water minus outdoor wet-bulb . If leaving water is 85°F and ambient WB is 78°F , approach is 7°F . You cannot leave below wet-bulb; a 1°F approach is a fantasy on a budget tower.
Condenser-water flow for water, at a stated ΔT, is the same 500-constant as Chapter 18:
- GPM = Btu/h 500 × Δ T \text{GPM} = \dfrac{\text{Btu/h}}{500 \times \Delta T} GPM = 500 × Δ T Btu/h
- At 10°F range , each 12,000 Btu/h (1 ton) needs
- 12,000 / ( 500 × 10 ) = 2.4 gpm 12{,}000 / (500 \times 10) = 2.4\ \text{gpm} 12 , 000/ ( 500 × 10 ) = 2.4 gpm
Worked example. A 20-ton water-cooled packaged unit — legal Class B, right at the cooling cap if it is one system — at 10°F range:
GPM = 20 × 2.4 = 48 gpm \text{GPM} = 20 \times 2.4 = 48\ \text{gpm} GPM = 20 × 2.4 = 48 gpm
Or 240,000 / 5,000 = 48 240{,}000 / 5{,}000 = 48 240 , 000/5 , 000 = 48 gpm. Pipe, pump, and tower fill have to make 48 gpm at the real head , not “a 3/4-inch hose because it is only 20 tons.” If the same machine is specified at a 15°F range , flow drops to 240,000 / 7,500 = 32 240{,}000 / 7{,}500 = 32 240 , 000/7 , 500 = 32 gpm — but only if the condenser and tower are rated at 15°F. Inventing a bigger ΔT to save pipe is how you leave the manufacturer’s table.
A 30-ton water-cooled package is 360,000 Btu/h cooling — Class A . Class B still answers the 2.4 gpm/ton question; Class B does not install that 30-ton system . Two independent 15-ton water-cooled packages, each with its own loop, can be Class B if they are truly separate systems.
Side-by-side and Florida constraints
- Topic Air-cooled Water-cooled
- Heat sink Outdoor air across a refrigerant coil Water, usually a cooling tower (FBC Mech 908 )
- Outdoor kit Condensing unit or RTU condenser section Tower or fluid cooler; indoor package possible
- Typical water flow None at the condenser ~2.4 gpm/ton at 10°F range
Capacity killer Recirculated discharge, blocked coil, high outdoor dry-bulb High outdoor wet-bulb , scaled tubes, low gpm, recirculated tower air
- Wind / pad 301.15 , 304.10 3-inch slab Same on the tower and any outdoor condenser
- Condensate (evaporator) 307 still required 307 still required plus tower overflow/blowdown
- Once-through city water Not applicable Generally not the HVAC design; backflow if makeup is potable
- Class B 25 tons / 500,000 Btu per system Same cap; 25 tons is 300,000 Btu/h
Clearances on water-cooled indoor packages still include service access ( 306 ) and manufacturer tube-pull space. Guards ( 304.11 ) still apply on roofs. Vibration isolation ( 301.13 ) still needs supplemental restraint so a spring-mounted tower does not walk in a hurricane — isolation without restraint is the 301.13 trap.
Air-cooled is simpler to install and dominate Florida residential and light commercial work because wet-bulb is high (towers lose approach) and freeze-up is rare but scaling, Legionella control, and tower water treatment are real operating costs. Water-cooled still wins on large plants (Chapter 21) where a 95°F air-cooled condensing temperature would crush kW/ton. The exam item is: name the sink, size the water if any, anchor against Florida wind, stay inside the license .
Electrical reminder. Condenser fans and tower fans are HVAC equipment. Power wiring stays inside F.S. 489.105: dedicated HVAC circuits, single-phase disconnect replace/reconnect, low-voltage controls. A three-phase 20-ton tower starter that is not those exceptions is an electrical-contractor conversation even when Class B may set the 20-ton package.
Florida HVAC scenario
A certified Class B qualifier in Duval County (Zone 2A) is asked to replace a failed air-cooled 20-ton RTU on a medical office with a water-cooled 20-ton package “because the new one is quieter.” Cooling tons stay at 20 — still Class B. The drawings now add a roof cooling tower , 48 gpm at 10°F range, makeup with no backflow, blowdown piped to a sanitary vent, and the tower set on isolation springs with no seismic/wind snubbers. Four install problems: (1) 301.15 / 301.13 — springs without restraint in a wind-borne-debris region; (2) 908 drainage — blowdown is not a sanitary vent tap any more than evaporator condensate is; (3) 301.11 — potable makeup needs a plumbing-code backflow preventer, which is not an HVAC license to run new potable water; (4) tower clearance so discharge does not re-enter the intake. If the salesman “upsized” to 30 tons while he was at it, Class B is over regardless of gpm math. Keep the 20-ton, size 48 gpm, restrain the tower, dispose of blowdown legally, and do not sell a sanitary connection as a convenience.
Traps: (1) Calling a package RTU water-cooled because it has a 307 condensate drain. (2) Using 4 gpm/ton on a 10°F-range problem. (3) Once-through city water as the default. (4) Ignoring 301.15 on towers. (5) Class B on a 30-ton water-cooled “because water-cooled is indoor.”