Study guide

8.2 Sales Comparison & Cost-Depreciation Approaches to Value

Florida Real Estate Broker Exam

Track your progress as you read

Finished sections get a check mark.

1 Chapter 1: Real Estate Brokerage Business & Office Operations

1.1 Broker Licensing, Qualifications & Business Entities 1.2 Brokerage Office & Branch Office Requirements 1.3 Broker Supervision, Employment Agreements & Office Policies 1.4 Advertising, Team Rules & Marketing Regulations 1.5 The Licensure Application Process, Mutual Recognition & Statutory Exemptions 1.6 Trade Names, Registration vs. Licensure, Renewal Cycles & Change of Address

2 Chapter 2: Escrow Accounts & Trust Fund Management

2.1 Escrow Account Setup, Authorized Depositories & Broker Funds 2.2 Escrow Deposit Timelines, Procedures & Third-Party Escrow 2.3 Trust Account Reconciliation, Record Retention & Accounting Violations 2.4 Conflicting Demands & The Four Escrow Dispute Settlement Procedures 2.5 The Broker's Rights in Escrowed Deposits, Commission Entitlement & Antitrust Compliance 2.6 Condominium & Cooperative Escrow: Developer Deposits and Statutory Cancellation Rights

3 Chapter 3: Florida Real Estate Law, FREC & Disciplinary Process

3.1 Florida Real Estate Commission (FREC) & DBPR Authority 3.2 The Seven-Step Administrative Disciplinary Procedure 3.3 Statutory Violations, Criminal Penalties & Administrative Sanctions 3.4 Florida Real Estate Recovery Fund

4 Chapter 4: Brokerage Relationships & Agency Law in Florida

4.1 Authorized Brokerage Relationships & Statutory Duties 4.2 Disclosure Requirements & Transitioning Relationships 4.3 Dual Agency Prohibition & Nonresidential Designated Sales Associates

5 Chapter 5: Real Estate Contracts & Listing Agreements

5.1 Contract Law Essentials & Broker Form Preparation Limits 5.2 Listing Agreements, Commission Rights & Florida Commercial Lien Laws 5.3 FAR/BAR Contract Provisions, Contingencies & Timelines 5.4 Option Contracts, Agreements for Deed & Specialty Contracts 5.5 Default, Remedies, Rescission & Assignment of Florida Real Estate Contracts

6 Chapter 6: Closing Transactions, Title & Settlement Calculations

6.1 Title Evidence, Deeds & Conveyance Requirements 6.2 Florida Transfer Taxes & Mortgage Intangible Taxes 6.3 Closing Statement Mathematics, Prorations & Debits/Credits 6.4 Reading the Closing Disclosure Page by Page 6.5 The Broker's Role at Closing: Pre-Closing Duties, Walk-Through & Post-Closing Obligations

7 Chapter 7: Real Estate Financing & Lending Compliance

7.1 Florida Mortgage Law, Lien Theory & Judicial Foreclosure 7.2 Loan Programs, Underwriting & Secondary Mortgage Market 7.3 Federal Lending Regulations: TRID, RESPA, ECOA & Fair Housing

8 Chapter 8: Real Estate Appraisal & Property Valuation

8.1 Appraisal Principles, Standards (USPAP) & Valuation Estimates 8.2 Sales Comparison & Cost-Depreciation Approaches to Value 8.3 Income Capitalization Approach & Investment Multipliers 8.4 Reconciliation, Appraisal Report Types & Florida Appraiser Licensing

9 Chapter 9: Real Estate Investment Analysis & Business Brokerage

9.1 Real Estate Investment Principles, Ratios & Leverage 9.2 Federal Income Tax Concepts, Depreciation & 1031 Exchanges 9.3 Business Brokerage, Valuation & Asset Transfers 9.4 Principal Residence Taxation & the Section 121 Exclusion

10 Chapter 10: Property Management & Florida Landlord-Tenant Law

10.1 Florida Residential Landlord and Tenant Act 10.2 Security Deposit Handling & Statutory Timelines 10.3 Florida Eviction Procedures & Lease Structures 10.4 Property Management as a Business: Markets, Skills & the Management Agreement 10.5 The Rental Process: Marketing, Tenant Screening & Fair Housing in Leasing

11 Chapter 11: Planning, Zoning & Environmental Hazards

11.1 Florida Growth Management & Comprehensive Planning 11.2 Zoning Classifications, Variances & Special Exceptions 11.3 Environmental Liabilities, Disclosures & Hazards 11.4 Subdividing & Land Development: Plats, Site Plans, Impact Fees & Deed Restrictions

12 Chapter 12: Brokerage Ownership, Business Planning & Financial Management

12.1 Capital Requirements & Brokerage Start-Up Costs 12.2 Projecting Brokerage Income: Revenue Sources & Sales Forecasting 12.3 Projecting Operating Expenses, Budgets & Desk Cost Analysis 12.4 Brokerage Tax Accounting: Cash vs. Accrual & Worker Classification 12.5 Recruiting, Selecting & Retaining Sales Associates 12.6 Sales Associate Compensation Plans & Commission Structures

13 Chapter 13: The Florida Real Estate Market & Real Estate Mathematics

13.1 Characteristics of Real Estate Markets & Florida Market Forces 13.2 Supply, Demand, Absorption Rates & the Real Estate Business Cycle 13.3 Core Real Estate Mathematics: Areas, Percentages, Rates & Legal Descriptions

8.2 Sales Comparison & Cost-Depreciation Approaches to Value

Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI

The Sales Comparison Approach is the most reliable method for residential properties and vacant land; adjustments are made strictly to comparable properties using the CBS (Comparable Better Subtract) and CIA (Comparable Inferior Add) rules.

In Sales Comparison, adjustments follow a strict hierarchy: property rights, financing terms, conditions of sale, market conditions (time), location, and physical characteristics.

The Cost-Depreciation Approach is primary for new construction and special-purpose properties; formula: Land Value + Reproduction/Replacement Cost New - Accrued Depreciation = Indicated Value.

Accrued depreciation encompasses Physical Deterioration, Functional Obsolescence, and External Obsolescence; External Obsolescence is always incurable by the property owner.

Age-life accrued depreciation is calculated as (Effective Age / Total Economic Life) multiplied by Reproduction/Replacement Cost New; land never depreciates.

Last updated: August 2026

Sales Comparison & Cost-Depreciation Approaches to Value

Quick Reference: Real estate appraisers utilize three core valuation approaches: (1) Sales Comparison Approach (best for single-family homes and vacant land), (2) Cost-Depreciation Approach (best for new construction, unique properties, and special-purpose public buildings), and (3) Income Capitalization Approach (best for income-producing commercial and multi-family assets).

1. The Sales Comparison Approach (Market Data Approach)

The Sales Comparison Approach (historically called the Market Data Approach) estimates market value by comparing the subject property with recently sold, similar properties in the same or competing submarket. It is universally recognized as the most reliable and heavily weighted approach for single-family residential homes, condominiums, and vacant residential building sites .

The Fundamental Law of Adjustments +-----------------------------------------------------------------------------+

  • | GOLDEN RULE OF ADJUSTMENTS |
  • | |
  • | 1. NEVER adjust the Subject Property! (It is the benchmark) |
  • | 2. ALWAYS adjust the COMPARABLE Sales Prices: |
  • | |
  • | * CBS Rule: Comparable BETTER ---> SUBTRACT from Comp |
  • | * CIA Rule: Comparable INFERIOR ---> ADD to Comp |
  • +-----------------------------------------------------------------------------+

Subject Property Stays Fixed: The subject property is the unvarying target being appraised; its physical characteristics and historical purchase price are never adjusted.

CBS Rule (Comparable Better → \rightarrow → Subtract): If a comparable property has a superior feature or amenity that the subject lacks (e.g., comparable has a pool, subject has no pool), subtract the market value of that feature from the comparable's sale price. Adjusted Comp Price = Comp Sale Price − Contributory Value of Feature \text{Adjusted Comp Price} = \text{Comp Sale Price} - \text{Contributory Value of Feature} Adjusted Comp Price = Comp Sale Price − Contributory Value of Feature

CIA Rule (Comparable Inferior → \rightarrow → Add): If a comparable property lacks a feature or amenity that the subject possesses (e.g., subject has an extra bathroom, comparable lacks it), add the market value of that feature to the comparable's sale price. Adjusted Comp Price = Comp Sale Price + Contributory Value of Feature \text{Adjusted Comp Price} = \text{Comp Sale Price} + \text{Contributory Value of Feature} Adjusted Comp Price = Comp Sale Price + Contributory Value of Feature

Systematic Order of Adjustments

Appraisal methodology mandates that adjustments be applied in a specific chronological sequence to account for transactional and market timing factors before physical characteristics:

Real Property Rights Conveyed: Fee simple vs. leasehold interest, life estate, or encumbered title.

Financing Terms (Cash Equivalency): Adjusts for non-market financing, seller-paid discount points, or creative interest rate buydowns.

Conditions of Sale: Adjusts for non-arm's length pressures, such as distress sales, foreclosure liquidations, or transfers between relatives.

Market Conditions (Date of Sale / Time Adjustment): Adjusts for appreciation or depreciation in the local market between the comparable's contract date and the subject's valuation date.

Location / Neighborhood: Adjusts for differences in neighborhood quality, school districts, traffic exposure, view, or waterfront access.

Physical Characteristics: Adjusts for gross living area (GLA), lot size, bedroom/bathroom count, pool, garage capacity, age, and condition.

Paired Sales Analysis (Matched Pairs Technique)

Appraisers determine the exact dollar adjustment for a specific feature using paired sales analysis . This technique compares two sales that are identical in all aspects except for one single characteristic, thereby isolating the market value contributed by that variable.

Paired Sales Example:

  • Sale 1: 2,000 sq. ft., 3 bedrooms, 2 baths, 2-car garage, no pool → \rightarrow → Sold for $380,000
  • Sale 2: 2,000 sq. ft., 3 bedrooms, 2 baths, 2-car garage, has in-ground pool → \rightarrow → Sold for $410,000

Contributory Market Value of Swimming Pool: $ 410 , 000 − $ 380 , 000 = $ 30 , 000 \text{\textdollar}410,000 - \text{\textdollar}380,000 = \mathbf{\text{\textdollar}30,000} $ 410 , 000 − $ 380 , 000 = $ 30 , 000

Step-by-Step Sales Comparison Adjustment Problem

Subject Property: 2,200 sq. ft., 3 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, 2-car garage, has a swimming pool .

Comparable Sales Data:

Comparable 1: Sold for $430,000; 2,200 sq. ft., 3 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, 2-car garage, no pool .

Comparable 2: Sold for $475,000; 2,200 sq. ft., 4 bedrooms (extra bedroom worth $15,000), 2 bathrooms, 2-car garage, has a pool .

Comparable 3: Sold for $415,000; 2,200 sq. ft., 3 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, 1-car garage (subject 2-car garage has $10,000 superior value), has a pool .

Contributory value of a swimming pool derived from market = $25,000.

  • Adjustment Element Subject Comparable 1 Comparable 2 Comparable 3
  • Sale Price Benchmark $430,000 $475,000 $415,000
  • Bedroom Count 3 Bedrooms 3 (No Adj.) 4 ( CBS: -$15,000 ) 3 (No Adj.)
  • Garage Capacity 2-Car 2-Car (No Adj.) 2-Car (No Adj.) 1-Car ( CIA: +$10,000 )
  • Swimming Pool Has Pool No Pool ( CIA: +$25,000 ) Has Pool (No Adj.) Has Pool (No Adj.)
  • Net Adjustment --- +$25,000 -$15,000 +$10,000
  • Adjusted Value --- $455,000 $460,000 $425,000
  • Reconciliation of Adjusted Values

An appraiser never averages the adjusted values mathematically. Instead, the appraiser assigns percentage weights based on which comparable required the fewest adjustments, the lowest gross adjustment percentage, and the highest degree of physical/locational similarity:

Comp 1 (Weight: 50% - most similar, single amenity adjustment): $ 455 , 000 × 0.50 = $ 227 , 500 \text{\textdollar}455,000 \times 0.50 = \text{\textdollar}227,500 $ 455 , 000 × 0.50 = $ 227 , 500

Comp 2 (Weight: 30% - recent sale, same subdivision): $ 460 , 000 × 0.30 = $ 138 , 000 \text{\textdollar}460,000 \times 0.30 = \text{\textdollar}138,000 $ 460 , 000 × 0.30 = $ 138 , 000

Comp 3 (Weight: 20% - older sale date): $ 425 , 000 × 0.20 = $ 85 , 000 \text{\textdollar}425,000 \times 0.20 = \text{\textdollar}85,000 $ 425 , 000 × 0.20 = $ 85 , 000

Indicated Value via Reconciliation: $ 227 , 500 + $ 138 , 000 + $ 85 , 000 = $ 450 , 500 \text{\textdollar}227,500 + \text{\textdollar}138,000 + \text{\textdollar}85,000 = \mathbf{\text{\textdollar}450,500} $ 227 , 500 + $ 138 , 000 + $ 85 , 000 = $ 450 , 500

2. The Cost-Depreciation Approach

The Cost-Depreciation Approach (also known as the Cost Approach or Summation Approach) is based on the principle that the value of an improved property equals the value of the land (as if vacant) plus the current cost to construct the improvements new, less all accrued depreciation.

Primary Applicability

The Cost-Depreciation Approach is the most reliable and primary valuation method for:

New Construction: Where physical deterioration is zero or negligible.

Special-Purpose / Institutional Properties: Buildings rarely bought or sold on the open market, such as public schools, churches, courthouses, libraries, fire stations, and specialized industrial plants.

Unique Architectural Properties: Structures with no comparable market sales and no income-producing capacity.

  • The Cost Approach Formula +-----------------------------------------------------------------------------+
  • | COST APPROACH VALUATION FORMULA |
  • | |
  • | Estimated Land Value (Estimated separately via Sales Comparison) |
  • | + Reproduction or Replacement Cost New of Primary Building Structure |
  • | - Accrued Depreciation (Physical + Functional + External) |
  • | + Depreciated Value of Site Improvements (Paving, landscaping, fences) |
  • | = INDICATED PROPERTY VALUE |
  • +-----------------------------------------------------------------------------+

Critical Exam Rule: LAND NEVER DEPRECIATES! Land is always valued separately using the Sales Comparison Approach based on its highest and best use as if vacant. Accrued depreciation is subtracted strictly from the cost new of the physical improvements.

Reproduction Cost vs. Replacement Cost

Cost Concept Definition When Utilized

Reproduction Cost The dollar expenditure required to construct an exact replica or duplicate of the subject structure using identical materials, architectural design, building standards, craftsmanship, and incorporating all obsolete features. Used primarily for historical landmarks, custom historic architecture, or specialized structural insurance valuations.

Replacement Cost The dollar expenditure required to construct a modern building having equivalent utility and function , using contemporary building materials, current building codes, and standard architectural designs. Used for standard appraisal practice to eliminate built-in historical functional obsolescence.

Cost Estimating Methods

Comparative-Unit (Square-Foot) Method: The most common method used by appraisers. Multiplies the gross living area (square footage) of the structure by a verified regional cost per square foot for that specific construction class (e.g., $180 per sq. ft. × \times × 2,500 sq. ft. = $450,000).

Unit-in-Place Method: Calculates the cost of structural components installed in place (cost per square foot of concrete foundation, cost per square foot of framing, cost per square foot of roofing, cost per linear foot of plumbing).

Quantity Survey Method: The most detailed, exhaustive, and precise method. An itemized engineering breakdown of every raw material item (board feet of lumber, linear feet of conduit, bags of cement), labor hours, permit fees, contractor overhead, and entrepreneurial profit.

3. The Three Types of Accrued Depreciation

Accrued Depreciation is the total loss in property value resulting from any cause relative to its reproduction or replacement cost new. +-----------------------------------------------------------------------------+

  • | THREE TYPES OF ACCRUED DEPRECIATION |
  • +-----------------------------------------------------------------------------+
  • | 1. PHYSICAL DETERIORATION --> Wear & tear, decay, weathering |
  • | * Curable: Cost to repair <= Value added (e.g., peeling paint) |
  • | * Incurable: Cost to repair > Value added / structural (e.g., foundation)|
  • | |
  • | 2. FUNCTIONAL OBSOLESCENCE --> Design flaws, outdated layout within boundary|
  • | * Curable: Economically practical to modernize (e.g., fixtures) |
  • | * Incurable: Impractical/excessive cost to fix (e.g., 4-bed/1-bath, layout)|
  • | |
  • | 3. EXTERNAL OBSOLESCENCE --> Outside property boundaries |
  • | * ALWAYS INCURABLE by property owner (e.g., flight path, toxic dump) |
  • +-----------------------------------------------------------------------------+
  • 1. Physical Deterioration

Loss in value caused by normal wear and tear, physical decay, deferred maintenance, aging of materials, and exposure to the elements:

Curable: An item where the expenditure required to cure the defect is less than or equal to the resulting increase in property value (e.g., repainting peeling exterior siding, replacing worn carpet, repairing a broken window sash).

Incurable: An item where the cost to repair exceeds the resulting value added, or structural components not scheduled for replacement during the building's economic life (e.g., deteriorating foundation footings, weakened internal load-bearing framing).

2. Functional Obsolescence

Loss in value resulting from structural, architectural, or design deficiencies, outdated technology, or over-improvements located within the property boundaries :

Curable: Outmoded or deficient features that can be economically replaced or modernized (e.g., outdated plumbing fixtures, inadequate electrical service outlets, converting an obsolete lighting system).

Incurable: Deficiencies that are structurally unfeasible or economically impractical to reconfigure (e.g., a four-bedroom house with only one bathroom; a tandem floor plan where accessing one bedroom requires walking through another; residential ceilings only 7 feet high in a modern executive submarket).

3. External (Economic / Locational) Obsolescence

Loss in value caused by negative economic, governmental, environmental, or social conditions located outside the property boundaries :

Always Incurable: External obsolescence is always incurable by the individual property owner because the owner has no legal control over off-site factors.

Examples: Property adjacent to a newly constructed expressway, residential home beneath a major airport jet landing flight path, nearby chemical plant emissions, zoning change permitting an adjacent industrial landfill, or severe neighborhood economic decline.

4. The Age-Life Depreciation Method

The Age-Life Method (also called the Straight-Line Depreciation Method) assumes that a building depreciates at a uniform, linear rate over its total estimated economic life.

Key Definitions

Chronological Age: The actual calendar age of the structure based on the date of original construction.

Effective Age: The age indicated by the structure's physical condition, maintenance, and utility. Effective age may be substantially less than chronological age if the building has been well-maintained or modernized.

Total Economic Life: The total estimated number of years the improvement will contribute value to the land.

Remaining Economic Life: The remaining period of time over which improvements are anticipated to generate economic utility ( T o t a l E c o n o m i c L i f e − E f f e c t i v e A g e Total\ Economic\ Life - Effective\ Age T o t a l E co n o mi c L i f e − E ff ec t i v e A g e ).

Age-Life Formulas Depreciation Rate per Year = 1 Total Economic Life \text{Depreciation Rate per Year} = \frac{1}{\text{Total Economic Life}} Depreciation Rate per Year = Total Economic Life 1 ​ Depreciation Percentage = Effective Age Total Economic Life \text{Depreciation Percentage} = \frac{\text{Effective Age}}{\text{Total Economic Life}} Depreciation Percentage = Total Economic Life Effective Age ​ Accrued Depreciation ($) = ( Effective Age Total Economic Life ) × Reproduction / Replacement Cost New \text{Accrued Depreciation (\$)} = \left(\frac{\text{Effective Age}}{\text{Total Economic Life}}\right) \times \text{Reproduction / Replacement Cost New} Accrued Depreciation ($) = ( Total Economic Life Effective Age ​ ) × Reproduction / Replacement Cost New Depreciated Value of Structure = Cost New − Accrued Depreciation \text{Depreciated Value of Structure} = \text{Cost New} - \text{Accrued Depreciation} Depreciated Value of Structure = Cost New − Accrued Depreciation

  • 5. Comprehensive Worked Mathematical Problems
  • Problem 1: Full Cost-Depreciation Approach Valuation

Property Facts:

Subject building measures 3,000 square feet.

Current construction replacement cost is $160 per square foot.

Chronological age is 20 years; effective age is determined by the appraiser to be 12 years .

Total estimated economic life of the building is 60 years .

Accrued external obsolescence due to adjacent highway noise is estimated at $18,000.

Depreciated value of on-site improvements (driveway, fence, landscaping) is $24,000.

Estimated market value of the land parcel (via Sales Comparison) is $110,000.

Step-by-Step Solution:

Calculate Replacement Cost New: Cost New = 3 , 000 sq. ft. × $ 160 / sq. ft. = $ 480 , 000 \text{Cost New} = 3,000\text{ sq. ft.} \times \$160/\text{sq. ft.} = \mathbf{\$480,000} Cost New = 3 , 000 sq. ft. × $160/ sq. ft. = $480 , 000

Calculate Age-Life Accrued Depreciation: Depreciation Ratio = 12 years Effective Age 60 years Total Economic Life = 0.20 (or 20 % ) \text{Depreciation Ratio} = \frac{12\text{ years Effective Age}}{60\text{ years Total Economic Life}} = 0.20\text{ (or }20\%\text{)} Depreciation Ratio = 60 years Total Economic Life 12 years Effective Age ​ = 0.20 (or 20% ) Age-Life Depreciation = $ 480 , 000 × 0.20 = $ 96 , 000 \text{Age-Life Depreciation} = \$480,000 \times 0.20 = \mathbf{\$96,000} Age-Life Depreciation = $480 , 000 × 0.20 = $96 , 000

Calculate Total Accrued Depreciation: Total Depreciation = $ 96 , 000 (Age-Life) + $ 18 , 000 (External) = $ 114 , 000 \text{Total Depreciation} = \$96,000\text{ (Age-Life)} + \$18,000\text{ (External)} = \mathbf{\$114,000} Total Depreciation = $96 , 000 (Age-Life) + $18 , 000 (External) = $114 , 000

Calculate Depreciated Value of Building Improvements: Depreciated Building = $ 480 , 000 − $ 114 , 000 = $ 366 , 000 \text{Depreciated Building} = \$480,000 - \$114,000 = \mathbf{\$366,000} Depreciated Building = $480 , 000 − $114 , 000 = $366 , 000

Add Depreciated Site Improvements: Total Depreciated Improvements = $ 366 , 000 + $ 24 , 000 = $ 390 , 000 \text{Total Depreciated Improvements} = \$366,000 + \$24,000 = \mathbf{\$390,000} Total Depreciated Improvements = $366 , 000 + $24 , 000 = $390 , 000

Add Estimated Land Value: Indicated Property Value = $ 390 , 000 + $ 110 , 000 = $ 500 , 000 \text{Indicated Property Value} = \$390,000 + \$110,000 = \mathbf{\$500,000} Indicated Property Value = $390 , 000 + $110 , 000 = $500 , 000