Study guide

2.3 Capital Budgeting Cash Flows

Financial Modeling & Valuation Analyst FMVA

Track your progress as you read

Finished sections get a check mark.

1 Introduction

Current Exam Facts Program Path and How to Use This Guide

2 Chapter 1: Accounting Foundations

1.1 Accounting Principles 1.2 Reading Financial Statements 1.3 Accounting Decisions in Models

3 Chapter 2: Time Value and Capital Budgeting

2.1 Time Value of Money 2.2 NPV, IRR, and Decision Rules 2.3 Capital Budgeting Cash Flows

4 Chapter 3: Cost of Capital

3.1 Capital Structure 3.2 CAPM, Beta, and Cost of Equity 3.3 WACC

5 Chapter 4: Profitability and Returns

4.1 Profitability and Margins 4.2 Returns and DuPont Analysis 4.3 Per-Share Metrics and Growth

6 Chapter 5: Liquidity, Leverage, and Cash Flow

5.1 Liquidity and Working Capital Metrics 5.2 Leverage, Coverage, and Credit 5.3 Cash Flow Statement Analysis

7 Chapter 6: Excel Fundamentals

6.1 Shortcuts, Setup, and Navigation 6.2 Core Formulas and Error Handling 6.3 Named Ranges and Workbook Hygiene

8 Chapter 7: Excel Lookups and Financial Functions

7.1 Lookup Functions 7.2 Conditional Aggregations 7.3 Financial Functions

9 Chapter 8: Excel What-If Analysis and Auditing

8.1 Goal Seek and Data Tables 8.2 Formula Auditing and Protection

10 Chapter 9: Financial Modeling Guidelines

9.1 Model Structure and Layout 9.2 Color Conventions and Formatting 9.3 Integrity Checks and Documentation

11 Chapter 10: Three-Statement Modeling

10.1 Articulating the Three Statements 10.2 Building the Income Statement 10.3 Building the Balance Sheet and Cash Flow Statement

12 Chapter 11: Circularity and Model Audit

11.1 Circular References and Iteration 11.2 Auditing and Balancing a 3-Statement Model

13 Chapter 12: Operational Modeling

12.1 Revenue and Operating Drivers 12.2 Working Capital Modeling 12.3 Capex and Depreciation

14 Chapter 13: Debt Schedules, Scenarios, and Sensitivity

13.1 Debt and Interest Schedules 13.2 Scenario Analysis 13.3 Sensitivity Analysis

15 Chapter 14: Valuation Foundations

14.1 Valuation Methods and Enterprise Value 14.2 Unlevered Free Cash Flow

16 Chapter 15: DCF Valuation

15.1 DCF Structure, WACC, and Mid-Year Convention 15.2 Terminal Value and the Equity Bridge

17 Chapter 16: Comparable Valuation

16.1 Trading Comps and Multiples 16.2 Precedent Transactions and the Football Field

18 Chapter 17: Budgeting and Forecasting

17.1 Budget Types 17.2 Forecasting Techniques 17.3 Rolling Forecasts and Variance Analysis

19 Chapter 18: Presentation and Visuals

18.1 Chart Types and Selection 18.2 Dashboards and Data Visualization 18.3 PowerPoint and Pitchbooks 18.4 Presenting Model Outputs

20 Chapter 19: Professional Ethics and Qualitative Analysis

19.1 Professional Ethics 19.2 Qualitative Business Analysis

2.3 Capital Budgeting Cash Flows

Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI

Build NPV from incremental cash flows only: ignore sunk costs; include opportunity costs, side effects, and cannibalization.

After-tax salvage = salvage − t × (salvage − book). At a 25% tax rate, $45,000 salvage and $30,000 book produce $41,250 of after-tax salvage.

Depreciation tax shield = t × Depreciation. $70,000 of depreciation at 25% tax is a $17,500 annual shield.

Net working capital invested at t = 0 is a cash outflow and is recovered as an inflow at exit; NWC is not depreciated.

Do not deduct interest in project cash flows when discounting at WACC — the after-tax cost of debt is already in the discount rate.

Last updated: August 2026

Which Cash Flows Belong in the NPV

Section 2.2 told you to accept when NPV is positive. That answer is only as good as the cash-flow vector you discount. CFI's corporate-finance treatment, and the unlevered free cash flow you will later build in DCF courses, both insist on incremental cash flows : the difference between the firm's cash flows with the project and without it. Accounting profit, allocated overhead, and "we already spent it" are not that difference.

Ignore Sunk Costs

A sunk cost is a cash outflow that has already been spent and will not be recovered whether you accept or reject. Last year's $18,000 feasibility study, a non-refundable deposit already wired, or R&D charged in a prior period does not enter Year 0 of the NPV. Managers like to "earn back" sunk costs. Capital budgeting does not. Including the $18,000 makes a good project look worse and a bad project look even worse, but it never changes the incremental decision correctly.

Include Opportunity Costs

An opportunity cost is the cash the firm forgoes by using an asset in this project instead of the next-best alternative. If the project occupies a building you could sell today for $80,000 with a book value of $50,000 and a 25% tax rate, the time-0 opportunity cost is the after-tax sale you skip:

After-tax sale = 80,000 − 0.25 × (80,000 − 50,000) = 80,000 − 7,500 = $72,500

Put −$72,500 at t = 0. Using "book value of $50,000" as the cost understates the sacrifice. Using the pre-tax $80,000 overstates it by the tax you would have paid on the $30,000 gain.

Side Effects and Cannibalization

Side effects are incremental cash flows the project causes elsewhere in the firm. Cannibalization is the common negative side effect: a new SKU steals sales from an existing SKU. If the new product takes $20,000 per year of pre-tax contribution margin from the old product, the after-tax drag at a 25% tax rate is 20,000 × (1 − 0.25) = $15,000 per year . Subtract that from project operating cash flow. Positive side effects (a new product that lifts complementary spare-parts sales) are added the same way. Allocated headquarters overhead that does not change in cash is not a side effect; extra cash overhead that does change is.

Net Working Capital

Net working capital (NWC) for project analysis is the incremental operating current assets minus incremental operating current liabilities the project requires — typically inventory + receivables − payables, not excess cash and not short-term debt. Launching a product usually invests NWC at t = 0 (or as sales ramp). That investment is a cash outflow . At the end of the project you recover NWC as inventory is sold and receivables are collected — a cash inflow . NWC is not depreciated and is not tax-deductible when invested; recovery is not taxable if you recover the same book dollars you put in. Forgetting recovery is a classic way to bias NPV down; forgetting the initial investment biases it up.

After-Tax Salvage and Book Value

When you sell a depreciable asset, the cash is not the headline salvage price. Tax applies to the gap versus book value :

After-tax salvage = salvage − t × (salvage − book)

If salvage > book, you pay tax on the gain. If salvage < book, t × (book − salvage) is a tax saving (a larger after-tax cash inflow than the salvage price). If salvage = book, there is no tax on the sale.

Worked numbers you will reuse below: salvage $45,000 , book $30,000 , t = 25% .

  • After-tax salvage = 45,000 − 0.25 × (45,000 − 30,000) = 45,000 − 3,750 = $41,250
  • Depreciation Tax Shield

Depreciation is not a cash outflow, but it reduces taxable income. The cash benefit is the depreciation tax shield :

Shield = t × Depreciation

Two equivalent operating-cash-flow identities, used throughout CFI unlevered-cash-flow work:

  • OCF = NOPAT + Depreciation
  • OCF = (Sales − cash operating costs) × (1 − t) + t × Depreciation

The second form makes the shield explicit. At t = 25% and depreciation = $70,000, the shield is $17,500 per year. Tax depreciation may follow a schedule that differs from book (for example, accelerated tax depreciation). The shield always uses tax depreciation, because that is what the tax authority allows. Straight-line to a salvage-linked book value is the clean exam setup; the identity does not change if the amounts do.

Do Not Put Interest in Project Cash Flows When You Discount at WACC

WACC already includes the after-tax cost of debt, Rd × (1 − t) , weighted by the target debt share. If you also subtract interest in the project's operating cash flows, you double-count financing: once in the cash flows, once in the discount rate. Project cash flows for a WACC-based NPV are unlevered — they are the cash the assets generate before interest, after tax as if the firm had no debt on this project. That is the same logic as unlevered free cash flow in a DCF: NOPAT + D&A − capex − ΔNWC, with no interest subtracted.

Interest belongs in the cash flows only if you switch methods (for example, a levered-equity residual cash flow discounted at the cost of equity). FMVA core capital budgeting and DCF valuation discount unlevered cash at WACC. Leave interest out.

Loading diagram... Three-Year Project Cash-Flow Timeline

Worked Three-Year Project: Capex, NWC, Operations, Salvage

A manufacturer is evaluating a machine. Put every principle above on one timeline, then compute NPV at WACC. Year-end cash flows; do not apply mid-year unless the case says cash is earned evenly.

Given

  • Item Amount
  • Machine capex at t = 0 $240,000
  • Incremental NWC at t = 0, recovered at t = 3 $30,000
  • Economic and tax life 3 years
  • Straight-line to ending book value $30,000
  • Expected salvage at t = 3 $45,000
  • Annual incremental sales $180,000
  • Annual cash operating costs $95,000
  • Tax rate t 25%
  • WACC 10%
  • Feasibility study spent last year $18,000 (sunk — ignore)
  • Step 1 — Depreciation and the Tax Shield
  • Annual depreciation = (cost − ending book) / life = (240,000 − 30,000) / 3 = $70,000
  • Depreciation tax shield = 0.25 × 70,000 = $17,500 per year
  • Step 2 — Annual Operating Cash Flow
  • EBIT = 180,000 − 95,000 − 70,000 = $15,000
  • Tax = 15,000 × 0.25 = $3,750
  • NOPAT = $11,250
  • OCF = NOPAT + depreciation = 11,250 + 70,000 = $81,250

Cross-check with the shield identity:

OCF = (180,000 − 95,000) × (1 − 0.25) + 70,000 × 0.25 = 85,000 × 0.75 + 17,500 = 63,750 + 17,500 = $81,250

There is no interest line. If someone built EBT = EBIT − interest, they have already broken the WACC method.

  • Step 3 — After-Tax Salvage and NWC Recovery at t = 3
  • After-tax salvage = 45,000 − 0.25 × (45,000 − 30,000) = $41,250
  • NWC recovery = +$30,000 (untaxed, same dollars that went out at t = 0)
  • Terminal non-operating cash = 41,250 + 30,000 = $71,250
  • Step 4 — Timeline
  • Year Capex NWC OCF After-tax salvage Project CF
  • 0 −240,000 −30,000 — — −$270,000
  • 1 — — 81,250 — $81,250
  • 2 — — 81,250 — $81,250
  • 3 — +30,000 81,250 +41,250 $152,500

The $18,000 study never appears. If the floor space had an after-tax opportunity cost, that amount would have been added to the t = 0 outflow. If the machine stole $20,000 of pre-tax margin from an old product, OCF would be $15,000 lower each year.

  • Step 5 — NPV at 10%
  • NPV = −270,000 + 81,250/1.10 + 81,250/1.21 + 152,500/1.331
  • = −270,000 + 73,863.64 + 67,148.76 + 114,575.51
  • = −$14,412

Reject. Accounting income was positive ($11,250 of NOPAT per year) and undiscounted inflows 81,250 + 81,250 + 152,500 = $315,000 exceed the $270,000 outlay, but at a 10% cost of capital the project destroys about $14,400 of value. That is the entire point of combining Section 2.1, 2.2, and 2.3: sign of profit ≠ sign of NPV .

Payback is 2 + (270,000 − 162,500) / 152,500 = 2.70 years , which might look "fine" against a three-year life. Discounted payback never arrives, because the present value of all inflows is only $255,588. Payback would have given the wrong primary decision.

Sensitivity Check (Same Costs, Higher Sales)

If incremental sales were $200,000 instead of $180,000, holding cash costs, depreciation, tax, NWC, and salvage fixed:

  • OCF = (200,000 − 95,000) × 0.75 + 17,500 = 78,750 + 17,500 = $96,250
  • Year-3 project CF = 96,250 + 41,250 + 30,000 = $167,500
  • NPV = −270,000 + 96,250/1.10 + 96,250/1.21 + 167,500/1.331 = +$22,891

The same machine accepts at $200,000 of sales. NPV lives in the cash-flow assumptions, which is why CFI drills scenario and sensitivity analysis after the three-statement and DCF cores. For this chapter, lock the method: incremental, after-tax, unlevered, NWC on and off the books, salvage taxed versus book, discount at WACC, then read the sign of NPV.

Exam Checklist for Project Cash Flows

Start from cash with the project minus cash without it.

Drop sunk costs. Add opportunity costs at after-tax resale value.

Subtract after-tax cannibalization; add after-tax complements.

Capex at t = 0 (and any mid-life capex) is an outflow; do not depreciate capex in the cash-flow row — depreciate it only to compute the tax shield.

ΔNWC: outflow when the balance rises, inflow when it falls or is recovered.

OCF = (Sales − cash costs)(1 − t) + t × (tax depreciation).

After-tax salvage = salvage − t × (salvage − book).

No interest in the cash flows when r is WACC.

Then apply NPV from Section 2.2, with Excel NPV(rate, CF1:CFn) + CF0.