Study guide
14.2 Calculating and Applying VaR
FRM Part I Financial Risk Manager Study Guide Exam
Track your progress as you read
Finished sections get a check mark.
1 Introduction & Exam Overview
1.1 Current Exam Facts 1.2 Study Strategy & Domain Weights
2 Foundations: Risk Building Blocks & Governance
2.1 Building Blocks of Risk Management 2.2 How Firms Manage Financial Risk 2.3 Governance of Risk Management 2.4 Credit Risk Transfer Mechanisms
3 Foundations: Portfolio Models, Data & ERM
3.1 MPT and the CAPM 3.2 APT and Multifactor Models 3.3 Risk Data Aggregation & Reporting 3.4 Enterprise Risk Management
4 Foundations: Disasters, Crisis & Ethics
4.1 Learning from Financial Disasters 4.2 Anatomy of the Great Financial Crisis 4.3 GARP Code of Conduct
5 Quantitative Analysis: Probability Foundations
5.1 Fundamentals of Probability 5.2 Random Variables 5.3 Common Univariate Distributions 5.4 Multivariate Random Variables
6 Quantitative Analysis: Inference & Regression
6.1 Sample Moments 6.2 Hypothesis Testing 6.3 Linear Regression 6.4 Multiple Regression
7 Quantitative Analysis: Diagnostics & Time Series
7.1 Regression Diagnostics 7.2 Stationary Time Series 7.3 Non-Stationary Time Series 7.4 Returns, Volatility & Correlation
8 Quantitative Analysis: Simulation & Machine Learning
8.1 Simulation and Bootstrapping 8.2 Machine-Learning Methods 8.3 Machine Learning and Prediction
9 Financial Markets: Institutions & Derivatives Intro
9.1 Banks 9.2 Insurance Companies and Pension Plans 9.3 Fund Management 9.4 Introduction to Derivatives
10 Financial Markets: Clearing, Futures & Hedging
10.1 Exchanges and OTC Markets 10.2 Central Clearing 10.3 Futures Markets 10.4 Using Futures for Hedging
11 Financial Markets: FX, Forwards, Commodities & Options
11.1 Foreign Exchange Markets 11.2 Pricing Financial Forwards and Futures 11.3 Commodity Forwards and Futures 11.4 Options Markets
12 Financial Markets: Option Properties, Strategies & Rates
12.1 Properties of Options 12.2 Trading Strategies 12.3 Exotic Options 12.4 Properties of Interest Rates
13 Financial Markets: Bonds, MBS, Rate Futures & Swaps
13.1 Corporate Bonds 13.2 Mortgages and Mortgage-Backed Securities 13.3 Interest Rate Futures 13.4 Swaps
14 Valuation & Risk Models: VaR, Volatility & Ratings
14.1 Measures of Financial Risk 14.2 Calculating and Applying VaR 14.3 Measuring and Monitoring Volatility 14.4 External and Internal Credit Ratings
15 Valuation & Risk Models: Credit, OpRisk & Stress
15.1 Country Risk 15.2 Measuring Credit Risk 15.3 Operational Risk 15.4 Stress Testing
16 Valuation & Risk Models: Fixed-Income Valuation
16.1 Pricing, Discounting & Arbitrage 16.2 Interest Rates 16.3 Bond Yields and Return Calculations 16.4 Duration, Convexity & DV01
17 Valuation & Risk Models: Term Structure, Options & Greeks
17.1 Non-Parallel Term Structure Shifts 17.2 Binomial Trees 17.3 The Black-Scholes-Merton Model 17.4 Option Sensitivity Measures: The Greeks
14.2 Calculating and Applying VaR
Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI
Linear portfolios (delta-one exposures) map risk-factor moves proportionally; nonlinear books (options, mortgage convexity) need delta-gamma, full revaluation, or simulation.
Historical simulation ranks actual past P&L or full revaluations; VaR is an empirical quantile and ES is the average of losses beyond that quantile—no distributional assumption required.
Delta-normal VaR uses σ_p from mapped sensitivities and a normal (or scaled) quantile; for options, a delta-gamma adjustment approximates curvature but still fails in deep nonlinear or discontinuous cases.
Monte Carlo VaR/ES flexibly handles path dependency and fat-tailed shocks but is computationally heavy and model-risk intensive.
Correlation breakdown in crises inflates portfolio VaR relative to calm-period estimates; worst-case/scenario analysis complements VaR rather than replacing a probabilistic quantile.
Last updated: August 2026
Calculating and Applying VaR
Once VaR and ES are defined, the exam asks how desks compute them. VRM–2 contrasts portfolio linearity, three workhorse engines (historical simulation, delta-normal, Monte Carlo), and the practical failures of correlation assumptions and “VaR-only” thinking.
Linear Versus Nonlinear Portfolios
A portfolio is linear (in the risk-factor approximation) if P&L is well described by first-order (“delta”) exposures: stocks, FX spot, futures, and many cash bonds over small yield moves. For linear books, a covariance-based or historical return shock maps almost one-for-one into P&L.
A portfolio is nonlinear when value depends on convexity, optionality, or thresholds: equity options, bermudan callables, mortgage-backed securities with prepayment options, credit derivatives with discontinuous default. For these, a large factor move can produce P&L far from delta × shock. Risk engines respond with:
- Full revaluation under each scenario (historical or Monte Carlo),
- Delta-gamma (quadratic) analytic approximations,
Or grid / least-squares interpolations between revaluation nodes.
- Book type Typical mapping Preferred VaR engine
- Cash equities / FX spot Linear returns Any; delta-normal is cheap
- Vanilla options Delta + gamma + vega Full reval or MC; delta-gamma OK for small moves
- Path-dependent exotics Pathwise cash flows Monte Carlo
- Mortgages / callables Prepay / rate optionality Full reval historical or MC
- Historical Simulation VaR and ES
Historical simulation (HS) applies past risk-factor moves (or past portfolio returns) to today’s positions and builds an empirical loss distribution.
Steps:
Choose a lookback window (e.g., 250 or 500 trading days) and horizon H (often 1 day).
For each historical day t, compute the simulated P&L of today’s book under the factor changes observed on day t (full revaluation or mapped returns).
Order the simulated losses from worst to best.
VaR_α is the empirical α-quantile (e.g., the 99th percentile loss).
ES_α is the average of losses strictly worse than (or at/beyond) that quantile, per your firm’s discrete convention.
Worked historical VaR/ES
Ten equally weighted historical one-day losses ($m), already sorted worst to best: 12, 9, 7, 5, 4, 3, 2, 1.5, 1, 0.5. For 90% VaR, the worst 10% is the single worst day → VaR_0.90 = 12 . ES_0.90 = 12 . For 80% VaR, the worst 20% covers {12, 9}; if VaR is defined as the milder edge of that tail band under a common discrete rule, desks often set VaR_0.80 = 9 and ES_0.80 = (12 + 9) / 2 = 10.5 . Exact percentile interpolation varies by vendor; GARP cares that you know quantile versus tail average .
Strengths: no parametric distribution; naturally captures fat tails and some nonlinearities if you full-revalue; easy to explain to non-quants. Weaknesses: trapped in the sample (no worse crash than history); equal weight on old and new days unless you use weighted HS / age-weighted schemes; slow to reflect a new volatility regime unless the window is short (which then worsens quantile noise).
Delta-Normal VaR for Linear and Nonlinear Books
Delta-normal (variance-covariance) VaR assumes risk-factor returns are jointly normal (or elliptical) and maps positions through linear sensitivities.
For a linear portfolio, portfolio variance is σ_p² = wᵀΣw (or δᵀΣδ for dollar deltas). With zero mean over a short horizon,
VaR_α ≈ z_α × σ_p × V
where z_α is the standard normal quantile (1.65 for 95%, 2.33 for 99%).
Worked linear delta-normal
Two-asset book: dollar exposures x₁ = $40m, x₂ = $60m. Daily volatilities σ₁ = 1.2%, σ₂ = 0.8%, correlation ρ = 0.40.
σ_p² = (0.40)²(0.012)² + (0.60)²(0.008)² + 2(0.40)(0.60)(0.012)(0.008)(0.40)
Compute term-by-term:
- x₁²σ₁² = 0.16 × 0.000144 = 0.00002304
- x₂²σ₂² = 0.36 × 0.000064 = 0.00002304
- 2 x₁ x₂ σ₁ σ₂ ρ = 2 × 0.40 × 0.60 × 0.012 × 0.008 × 0.40 = 0.000018432
σ_p² = 0.000064512 → σ_p ≈ 0.00803 (0.803% of portfolio notional if weights are on $100m). One-day 99% VaR ≈ 2.33 × 0.00803 × 100m ≈ $1.87 million .
- Nonlinear (delta-gamma) sketch
- For an option-like position, a second-order Taylor expansion gives
- ΔV ≈ δ ΔS + (1/2) Γ (ΔS)² + …
Under normal ΔS, the quadratic term makes ΔV non-normal (chi-square–like component). Cornish-Fisher or moment-matching adjustments shift the VaR quantile; alternatively, compute Var(ΔV) including gamma terms and still apply a normal z—faster but biased for large moves. Exam point: delta-normal alone misprices large moves in options ; use delta-gamma carefully or switch to full revaluation.
Limits of delta-normal
Assumes elliptical/normal factors → thin tails unless you fatten z.
Linear (or local quadratic) mapping fails for barriers, digitals, and mortgage convexity spikes.
Requires a full PSD covariance matrix; estimated correlations are noisy.
Does not naturally produce ES without extra tail assumptions.
Blind to liquidity jumps and gap risk overnight.
Monte Carlo VaR and ES
Monte Carlo (MC) draws risk-factor scenarios from a specified joint distribution (possibly with fat tails, stochastic vol, or copulas), revalues the book in each draw, and reads VaR/ES from the simulated loss histogram.
Pros:
Handles nonlinear and path-dependent products.
Can embed regime switches , jumps, and stressed correlations .
Produces a full loss distribution → ES is immediate.
Cons:
Model risk in the data-generating process dominates.
Computationally expensive for full revaluation of complex books (hence proxy Greeks, adjoint AD, or least-squares MC).
Simulation noise in far-tail ES needs many paths or importance sampling.
Can create false precision if governance does not challenge inputs.
Correlation Breakdown and Crisis VaR
In calm markets, diversification “works”: average pairwise equity correlations might be 0.3–0.5. In crises, correlations often spike toward 1 as common factors dominate— correlation breakdown from the risk manager’s hopeful calibration, not from mathematics failing. A covariance matrix estimated in a quiet window then understates portfolio σ_p and VaR exactly when capital is most needed.
Mitigations tested on FRM items: use stressed VaR windows (2008-style), EWMA/GARCH correlations that react faster, factor models with a dominant market factor, floored correlations, and scenario add-ons that set ρ = 1 for key pairs.
Worst-Case Analysis Versus VaR
VaR answers a probabilistic question at a chosen α. Worst-case (or max-loss / scenario) analysis asks what happens under an adversarially chosen shock set—sometimes within a uncertainty set for factors (robust optimization), sometimes as named historical scenarios (1987, 1998, 2008, COVID crash).
- Lens Output Use
- VaR / ES Quantile / tail mean under a model or history Limits, capital, disclosure
- Historical stress P&L under a named path Board narrative, reverse stress
- Hypothetical worst case P&L under extreme but plausible shifts Concentration / basis risk
- Robust max-loss Supremum loss in an uncertainty set Model-risk aware limits
Worst-case numbers are usually larger than VaR and are not probabilities. Regulators and GARP expect both: VaR/ES for routine statistical control, scenarios for “what the quantile missed.” Never treat a 99% VaR as a maximum loss.