Study guide
10.3 Nature of Science: Theories, Laws, Scientific Dispositions & Science–Technology–Society
FTCE Elementary Education K-6 060
Track your progress as you read
Finished sections get a check mark.
1 Chapter 1: FTCE 060 Exam Overview, Structure & Strategy
1.1 FTCE 060 Test Structure, Registration, Scoring & Retake Rules 1.2 Integrated Elementary Content Pedagogy & Preparation Strategy
2 Chapter 2: Emergent Literacy, Phonics, and Word Recognition
2.1 Emergent Literacy, Oral Language & Phonological Awareness 2.2 Stages of Word Recognition & Phonics Decoding 2.3 Syllable Types, Morphology & High-Frequency Word Mastery
3 Chapter 3: Reading Fluency, Vocabulary, and Text Comprehension
3.1 Components of Reading Fluency & Evidence-Based Instruction 3.2 Tiered Vocabulary Acquisition & Cross-Curricular Integration 3.3 Comprehension Facilitation, Text Structures & Non-Print Formats
4 Chapter 4: Literary Analysis, Genres, and Informational Text Evaluation
4.1 Literary Genres, Story Elements & Culturally Diverse Literature 4.2 Literary Devices, Figurative Language & Author Craft 4.3 Informational & Argumentative Analysis: Claims, Evidence & Rhetorical Appeals
5 Chapter 5: The Writing Process, Literacy Assessment, Intervention & Communication
5.1 Developmental Stages & Modes of Writing 5.2 Stages of the Writing Process & Instructional Writing Conventions 5.3 Literacy Assessment Systems: Assessment Types, IRIs, Error Analysis & Communicating Results 5.4 Tiered Intervention (MTSS) & Classroom Organizational Formats 5.5 Communication & Media Literacy: Speaking, Listening, Research & Multimedia
6 Chapter 6: Social Science Instruction, Historical Sources, Historical Thinking & Ancient Civilizations
6.1 Effective Social Science Instruction: Inquiry, Planning, Assessment & Learning Environments 6.2 Primary & Secondary Sources, Sourcing, Bias & Propaganda 6.3 Historical Thinking: Chronology, Timelines & Cause-and-Effect 6.4 Early & Classical Civilizations and Global Cultural Contributions
7 Chapter 7: Exploration, U.S. Historical Eras, and Florida History
7.1 Age of Exploration, Colonization & Cultural Encounters 7.2 Key Eras in U.S. History, Expansion & Immigration Patterns 7.3 Florida History: Native Peoples, Colonial Rule, Statehood & Development
8 Chapter 8: Geography Systems, Spatial Analysis, and Human-Environment Interaction
8.1 The Six Essential Elements of Geography & Spatial Analysis Tools 8.2 Physical Geography, Climate Zones & Human Environmental Adaptation 8.3 Population Dynamics, Human Migration & Economic Transportation Networks
9 Chapter 9: Civics, Government Systems, the Legal System & Economic Principles
9.1 Federal, State, and Local Government Structures & Separation of Powers 9.2 Florida State Government & the U.S. Legal System 9.3 Foundational Documents, the Constitution & Citizen Rights 9.4 The U.S. Electoral System & Civic Participation 9.5 Scarcity, Productive Resources, Economic Systems & Market Dynamics 9.6 Money, Banking, Consumer Decisions & Global Interdependence
10 Chapter 10: Science Instruction, Inquiry, and the Nature of Science
10.1 Effective Science Instruction & The 5E Inquiry Model 10.2 Classroom Laboratory Safety, Scientific Tools & Measurement Systems 10.3 Nature of Science: Theories, Laws, Scientific Dispositions & Science–Technology–Society 10.4 Scientific Investigations: Types, Variables, Controls & Data
11 Chapter 11: Physical Sciences: Matter, Energy, and Force Interactions
11.1 Physical Properties of Matter, States & Chemical Changes 11.2 Energy Forms, Conservation & Thermal Heat Transfer 11.3 Electrical Circuits, Magnetism & Contact vs. Non-Contact Forces
12 Chapter 12: Earth and Space Systems and Planetary Processes
12.1 Geologic Formations, Rock Cycle & Soil Horizons 12.2 Atmospheric Systems, Water Cycle, Weather & Climate 12.3 Sun-Earth-Moon System, Celestial Patterns & Space Exploration
13 Chapter 13: Life Science: Cells, Classification, Organisms, and Human Health
13.1 Characteristics of Life, Cell Theory & Plant vs. Animal Cells 13.2 Classifying Living Things & Comparing Animal Organ Systems 13.3 Infectious Disease Agents, Immune Defense & Major Body Systems 13.4 Heredity, Punnett Squares, Natural Selection & Adaptations 13.5 Ecosystem Dynamics, Photosynthesis & Life Cycles
14 Chapter 14: Numbers, Place Value, and Base-Ten Operations
14.1 Prime and Composite Numbers, Factors, Multiples & Integer Arithmetic 14.2 Place Value Strategies, Base-Ten Decomposing & Regrouping 14.3 Fractions, Decimals, Percentages & Multiple Visual Models
15 Chapter 15: Algebraic Reasoning, Equations, and Proportionality
15.1 Numerical Patterns, Function Tables & Linear Relationships 15.2 Algebraic Expressions, Properties of Operations & Equation Solving 15.3 Ratios, Unit Rates, Proportions & Multistep Applications
16 Chapter 16: Measurement, Data Interpretation, and Elementary Statistics
16.1 Customary and Metric Measurement Systems, Time, Money & Estimation 16.2 Data Analysis: Frequency Tables, Dot/Line Plots, Histograms & Box Plots 16.3 Measures of Central Tendency, Variability & Elementary Probability
17 Chapter 17: Geometric Concepts and Student Mathematical Reasoning
17.1 2D Geometric Figures, Coordinate Geometry, Perimeter & Area 17.2 Three-Dimensional Figures, Geometric Nets, Surface Area & Volume 17.3 The CRA Instructional Progression, Stages of Fluency & Diagnostic Error Analysis
10.3 Nature of Science: Theories, Laws, Scientific Dispositions & Science–Technology–Society
Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI
Scientific knowledge is empirically based, durable yet tentative, creative, and shaped by its social and cultural context; Pluto's 2006 reclassification shows how models are revised with new evidence.
Scientific laws describe what happens under stated conditions, and theories explain why and how; theories never 'graduate' into laws.
Scientific inquiry seeks to answer questions about the natural world, while the engineering design process seeks solutions to human problems within criteria and constraints.
Scientific dispositions include curiosity, openness to new ideas, appropriate skepticism, objectivity, persistence, and cooperation.
Science interacts with society through cultural, ethical, economic, political, and global factors, such as decisions about Florida's water supply.
Last updated: September 2026
Nature of Science: Theories, Laws, Scientific Dispositions & Science–Technology–Society
Scientific literacy encompasses more than memorizing biological taxonomy or balancing chemical formulas; it requires a deep understanding of what science is as a human way of knowing. This epistemic understanding is termed the Nature of Science (NOS) . In elementary education, developing NOS concepts dispels the false impression that science is an infallible, unchanging body of absolute facts. Instead, children discover that science is a dynamic, creative, evidence-driven discipline characterized by skepticism, empirical validation, intellectual openness, and continuous refinement.
Core Tenets of the Nature of Science (NOS)
Extensive research by science education organizations (including the National Science Teaching Association [NSTA] and the American Association for the Advancement of Science [AAAS]) defines five foundational tenets of the Nature of Science for elementary learners: CORE TENETS OF THE NATURE OF SCIENCE
- ┌────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐
- │ 1. EMPIRICALLY BASED: Grounded in observations of the natural world. │
- │ Scientific claims must be supported by verifiable, testable data. │
- ├────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┤
- │ 2. TENTATIVE YET DURABLE: Knowledge is reliable and robust, but remains│
- │ open to revision or replacement when novel empirical evidence arises│
- ├────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┤
- │ 3. CREATIVE & INFERENTIAL: Scientists use imagination, logic, and │
- │ inferential reasoning to interpret data (not just rote recording). │
- ├────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┤
- │ 4. SOCIALLY & CULTURALLY EMBEDDED: Practiced within cultural, ethical, │
- │ and historical contexts; influenced by societal needs and values. │
- ├────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┤
- │ 5. THEORETICALLY INFLUENCED: Observations are shaped by prior knowledge│
- │ and theoretical frameworks (science avoids absolute pure neutrality)│
- └────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┘
- 1. Empirical Foundation
Science is grounded exclusively in the natural, physical universe. All scientific claims, models, and conclusions must be rooted in empirical evidence —data obtained directly through sensory perception or scientific instrumentation. Claims that cannot be tested, measured, or falsified lie outside the boundaries of science.
2. Tentative Yet Durable Nature
Scientific knowledge exhibits a unique balance between durability and tentativeness:
Durable : Established scientific concepts (such as the Heliocentric Model or Cell Theory) are durable because they are backed by centuries of converging empirical evidence, rigorous peer critique, and repeated verification.
Tentative : No scientific idea is considered permanently immune to modification. If new technological instruments yield anomalous data, or if an improved theoretical framework better explains existing observations, scientific models are revised. A historical example in elementary science is the modification of the Solar System model: Pluto was reclassified from a major planet to a dwarf planet by the International Astronomical Union in 2006 based on discoveries of other massive Kuiper Belt objects (e.g., Eris).
3. Creativity and Human Imagination
A common student misconception portrays scientists as emotionless data loggers following mechanical instructions. In truth, science requires profound human creativity—inventing testable hypotheses, conceptualizing novel experimental designs, interpreting ambiguous graphs, and visualizing unseeable structures (such as atoms, DNA helices, or black holes).
4. Social and Cultural Contexts
Science does not occur in a vacuum; it is conducted by human beings operating within historical, economic, and cultural frameworks. Societal values determine which research initiatives receive funding (e.g., renewable energy research, vaccine development), while ethical standards constrain scientific procedures.
Scientific Theories vs. Scientific Laws: Resolving the Hierarchy Misconception
Perhaps the most widespread and persistent misconception in elementary science education is the belief that scientific knowledge follows a hierarchical progression: Hypothesis (unproven idea) ⟶ Theory (partially proven) ⟶ Law (proven fact beyond doubt) \text{Hypothesis (unproven idea)} \longrightarrow \text{Theory (partially proven)} \longrightarrow \text{Law (proven fact beyond doubt)} Hypothesis (unproven idea) ⟶ Theory (partially proven) ⟶ Law (proven fact beyond doubt)
This progression is entirely false . In authentic science, theories and laws are two fundamentally distinct, parallel categories of knowledge that perform completely different epistemic functions. Theories never graduate into laws, and laws never degrade into theories. THEORIES VS. LAWS: PARALLEL CATEGORIES OF KNOWLEDGE
- ┌─────────────────────────────────────┬─────────────────────────────────────┐
- │ SCIENTIFIC LAWS │ SCIENTIFIC THEORIES │
- │ (Descriptions of What) │ (Explanations of Why) │
- ├─────────────────────────────────────┼─────────────────────────────────────┤
- │ • Concise statement or equation │ • Comprehensive, overarching model │
- │ • Summarizes an observable pattern │ • Explains the underlying mechanism │
- │ • Predicts WHAT happens under │ • Explains HOW and WHY phenomena │
- │ specified conditions │ occur based on vast evidence │
- │ • Often mathematical │ • Synthesizes multiple tested ideas │
- │ • Example: Law of Universal │ • Example: General Theory of │
- │ Gravitation (F = G*m1*m2/r²) │ Relativity (Spacetime curvature) │
- └─────────────────────────────────────┴─────────────────────────────────────┘
- ▲ │
- │ ▼
- └────── Theories EXPLAIN how Laws operate ──┘
- (THEORIES NEVER BECOME LAWS)
- Scientific Laws: Describing Observable Patterns ("What Happens")
A scientific law is a concise descriptive statement or mathematical relationship that summarizes a regular, universal pattern observed in the natural world under specified conditions. Laws state what happens, reliably and within stated conditions, but they do not explain the underlying causal mechanism.
Examples :
Newton's Law of Universal Gravitation describes the mathematical relationship between the masses of two bodies, their distance, and the attractive force (F = G (m₁ m₂)/r²). It accurately predicts where a satellite will travel, but Newton himself admitted it did not explain what gravity actually is or how mass acts across empty space.
The Law of Conservation of Energy dictates that energy cannot be created or destroyed, only transformed from one form to another.
Mendel's Law of Independent Assortment describes the predictable distribution of alleles during gamete formation.
Scientific Theories: Explaining Natural Phenomena ("Why and How")
A scientific theory is an extensive, well-substantiated explanation of some aspect of the natural world, supported by a vast body of empirical evidence, verified hypotheses, logical inferences, and natural laws. Theories answer the causal questions of how and why natural phenomena occur.
Examples :
The Germ Theory of Disease explains that infectious diseases are caused by the proliferation of specific pathogenic microorganisms invading host tissues.
The Theory of Plate Tectonics explains the underlying geophysical mechanisms (mantle convection, subduction, seafloor spreading) that cause earthquakes, volcanic arcs, and mountain building.
The Theory of Evolution by Natural Selection explains how populations adapt and biodiversity diverges over deep time through differential reproductive success.
The Atomic Theory explains the chemical behavior of matter based on the interaction of subatomic particles.
The True Relationship: Theories Explain Laws
Instead of a hierarchy where theories become laws, theories provide the comprehensive explanatory framework that makes sense of laws! For example, the Kinetic Molecular Theory of Matter explains why the gas laws (Boyle's, Charles's, and Gay-Lussac's laws) work: when a gas is heated at constant volume, gas particles absorb kinetic energy, collide more frequently and violently with the container walls, and thereby increase internal pressure.
Comparison Table: Scientific Theories vs. Scientific Laws
Attribute Scientific Law Scientific Theory Common Misconception Correct Epistemological Reality
Core Definition Concise, often mathematical description of an observable natural pattern Comprehensive, evidence-based explanation of natural phenomena "Laws are absolute facts, while theories are educated guesses." Both are grounded in vast empirical evidence; both are accepted scientific knowledge.
Primary Question Answered Answers WHAT happens under specific physical conditions Answers HOW and WHY natural phenomena occur "A theory is an unproven hypothesis that becomes a law when proven." Theories explain mechanisms; laws describe patterns. Theories NEVER become laws.
Format & Expression Often expressed as a concise mathematical equation or rule Expressed as an overarching conceptual framework, model, or paradigm "Laws are absolute truth and never change." Both laws and theories can be revised or refined if anomalous empirical data emerges.
Classic Examples Law of Gravitation, Newton's Laws of Motion, Conservation of Mass Plate Tectonics Theory, Germ Theory, Atomic Theory, Theory of Evolution "Evolution is just a theory, so it isn't established science." Calling something a theory in science signifies the highest level of explanatory validation.
Elementary Classroom Analogy The rules of the road (e.g., speed limits, stop signs describe what happens) The mechanical engineering manual explaining how the engine and brakes operate Confusing the description of behavior with the mechanical explanation of operation Laws summarize behavior; theories explain the inner mechanical workings.
Scientific Inquiry vs. The Engineering Design Process
Elementary STEM education integrates science with technology, engineering, and mathematics. However, educators must maintain clear distinctions between the goals and methodologies of Scientific Inquiry and the Engineering Design Process (EDP) : SCIENTIFIC INQUIRY VS. ENGINEERING DESIGN
- ┌─────────────────────────────────────┬─────────────────────────────────────┐
- │ SCIENTIFIC INQUIRY │ ENGINEERING DESIGN PROCESS │
- │ (Seeks to Answer Questions) │ (Seeks to Solve Problems) │
- ├─────────────────────────────────────┼─────────────────────────────────────┤
- │ 1. Ask a testable question │ 1. Identify a human problem/need │
- │ 2. Research background knowledge │ 2. Define criteria and constraints │
- │ 3. Formulate a testable hypothesis │ 3. Brainstorm alternative solutions │
- │ 4. Design & conduct a controlled │ 4. Build a physical prototype │
- │ experiment testing variables │ 5. Test prototype under constraints │
- │ 5. Collect & analyze empirical data │ 6. Evaluate failure points & redesign│
- │ 6. Draw conclusions & communicate │ 7. Optimize and communicate solution│
- └─────────────────────────────────────┴─────────────────────────────────────┘
Scientific Inquiry : Driven by curiosity about the natural world. The goal is to discover new knowledge, construct explanations, and answer questions (e.g., "Which type of soil absorbs water most rapidly?" ).
Engineering Design : Driven by human needs and practical constraints (cost, materials, time, safety). The goal is to design, test, build, and optimize a product, system, or process (e.g., "Design an erosion barrier using local natural materials to prevent playground soil from washing into the storm drain during heavy rain" ).
Attitudes and Dispositions Behind Scientific Thinking
Subtest 603 asks you to identify and analyze the attitudes and dispositions that underlie scientific thinking. Teachers model and reinforce them explicitly:
Disposition What it looks like in a student Teacher move
Curiosity Asks "What would happen if…?" and wants to investigate Keep a class "wonder wall" of student questions to investigate
Openness to new ideas Revises a prediction when evidence contradicts it Praise changes of mind that are based on evidence
Appropriate skepticism Asks "How do you know?" and wants evidence before accepting a claim Have students evaluate a claim in an advertisement or on a website
Objectivity and honesty Records data as observed, even when it contradicts the prediction Discuss why "unexpected" results still count
Persistence Repeats trials and troubleshoots failed designs Frame failed engineering prototypes as information
Cooperation Shares data and builds on teammates' ideas Assign roles such as materials manager, recorder, and timekeeper
Skepticism is not cynicism: scientists doubt claims that lack evidence but accept well-supported conclusions.
Science as an Interdisciplinary STEM Process
Science is connected to technology, engineering, and mathematics (STEM). Scientists use technology (microscopes, probes, satellites) and mathematics (measurement, graphing, statistics) to answer questions, and engineers apply scientific knowledge to design solutions. An elementary STEM task, such as designing a shade structure that keeps a thermometer coolest in the sun, uses science (heat transfer), engineering (design, build, test, improve), mathematics (recording and graphing temperatures), and technology (digital thermometers).
Interactions of Science, Technology, and Society
Science and technology shape society, and society shapes which science gets done. The Subtest 603 skill names cultural, ethical, economic, political, and global factors:
Ethical : Should a new medical technology be used, and who decides? How should animals in research be treated?
Economic : Research funding follows needs and markets, as when hurricane-prediction technology improves because coastal economies depend on it.
Political : Laws and regulations, such as clean-water rules or restrictions on pesticides, rest on scientific evidence and public decisions.
Cultural : Communities value and use natural resources differently.
Global : Problems such as ocean pollution, disease outbreaks, and climate cross national borders and require international cooperation.
Classroom example: after studying the Everglades, students debate how Florida should balance water for farms, cities, and wildlife, using scientific evidence to support their positions.