Study guide
6.3 Enforcing Fair Claim Handling: Commissioner Proceedings, Complaint Records, Bad Faith & Attorney's Fees
Hawaii Claims Adjuster Exam
Track your progress as you read
Finished sections get a check mark.
1 Chapter 1: General Insurance Principles, Contract Law & Key Terms
1.1 Risk, Perils, Hazards & Insurable Interest 1.2 Principles of Indemnity, Subrogation & Utmost Good Faith 1.3 Legal Contracts & Essential Characteristics of Insurance Policies 1.4 Key Insurance Terms: Binders, Vacancy, Theft, Salvage, Audits & Certificates
2 Chapter 2: Property Insurance Policies & Coverage Forms
2.1 Dwelling Property Policies (DP-1, DP-2, DP-3) & Basic Perils 2.2 Homeowners Policy Forms (HO-2, HO-3, HO-4, HO-5, HO-6, HO-8) 2.3 Commercial Property Forms, Causes of Loss & Endorsements 2.4 Loss Valuation Methods, Coinsurance & Settlement Provisions 2.5 Commercial Package Policy, Businessowners Policy & Equipment Breakdown 2.6 Inland Marine: Personal Floaters, Commercial Floaters & the Nationwide Marine Definition 2.7 Flood (NFIP), Earthquake & Personal Watercraft Coverage
3 Chapter 3: Liability, Auto, Workers' Compensation, Crime & Specialty Coverages
3.1 Principles of Legal Liability, Torts & Negligence 3.2 Commercial General Liability (CGL) Coverage Forms 3.3 CGL Who Is an Insured, Limits, Supplementary Payments, Conditions & Common Policy Conditions 3.4 Personal & Commercial Auto Insurance Fundamentals 3.5 Business Auto Liability, Physical Damage, Garage Coverage & Garagekeepers 3.6 Workers' Compensation Fundamentals & Employer Liability 3.7 Bonding, Fidelity & Commercial Crime Coverage 3.8 Professional Liability (Errors & Omissions), Umbrella & Excess Liability
4 Chapter 4: Policy Provisions & the Claims Adjustment Process
4.1 Policy Provisions in Practice: Duties After Loss, Proof of Loss, Mortgagee Rights, Appraisal, Arbitration & Cancellation 4.2 Adjuster Types, Duties, Agency Authority & Fiduciary Obligations 4.3 Claim Intake, First Notice of Loss, Reservation of Rights & Non-Waiver 4.4 Field Investigation, Physical Evidence, Recorded Statements & SIU Fraud Detection 4.5 Damage Evaluation, Reserving, Negotiation Techniques & Settlement Options
5 Chapter 5: Hawaii Insurance Regulation, Insurers & Adjuster Licensing (HRS Chapter 431)
5.1 Hawaii Insurance Division, Commissioner Powers, Examinations, Hearings & Penalties 5.2 Hawaii Insurer Definitions: Domestic, Foreign & Alien; Stock, Mutual & Reciprocal; Certificate of Authority; Unauthorized Insurers 5.3 Hawaii Adjuster Licensing: Definitions, License Types, Qualifications, Examination & Emergency Registration 5.4 Adjuster Records, Trust Funds, License Extension & Discipline (HRS §§ 431:9-228 to 9-240) 5.5 Hawaii Public Adjusters: Bond, Authority, Contract Requirements & Fee Limits (HRS §§ 431:9-223, 9-226, 9-244) 5.6 Hawaii Insurance Guaranty Association (HIGA): Covered Claims, Limits & Claim Handling (HRS Chapter 431, Article 16)
6 Chapter 6: Hawaii Unfair Claim Settlement Practices, Deadlines & Enforcement
6.1 Hawaii Unfair Claim Settlement Practices (HRS § 431:13-103(a)(11)) 6.2 Hawaii Claim Deadlines: 15 Working Days, 30 Calendar Days, PIP, Health Claims & How to Count Days 6.3 Enforcing Fair Claim Handling: Commissioner Proceedings, Complaint Records, Bad Faith & Attorney's Fees
7 Chapter 7: Hawaii Laws Pertinent to Property Insurance
7.1 Hawaii Property Law: Property & Marine Definitions, the Standard Fire Policy, Over-Insurance & Cancellation Notice 7.2 Hawaii Property Insurance Association (HPIA), the Hurricane Relief Fund & Catastrophe Claims
8 Chapter 8: Hawaii Laws Pertinent to Casualty Insurance: Motor Vehicle, Financial Responsibility & Workers' Compensation
8.1 Hawaii Motor Vehicle Insurance Law: Purpose, Required Coverages, 40/80/20 Limits, UM/UIM & Self-Insurance 8.2 Hawaii Personal Injury Protection (PIP), Source of Payment & the Tort Threshold 8.3 Hawaii Motor Vehicle Rates, Cancellation & Nonrenewal, and the Joint Underwriting Plan 8.4 Hawaii Motor Vehicle Financial Responsibility (HRS Chapter 287) 8.5 Hawaii Workers' Compensation Law (HRS Chapter 386): Coverage, Exclusive Remedy, Benefits & Insurer Duties
6.3 Enforcing Fair Claim Handling: Commissioner Proceedings, Complaint Records, Bad Faith & Attorney's Fees
Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI
All remedies, penalties and proceedings under HRS chapter 431, article 13 are invoked solely by the commissioner, so the statute itself gives individual claimants no private cause of action (HRS § 431:13-107).
Before ordering an insurer to cease and desist, the commissioner serves a statement of charges and a notice of hearing at least 15 days after service (HRS § 431:13-106).
Insurers must keep a complete record of all written complaints since their last examination, showing the number, line, nature, disposition and processing time of each complaint (HRS § 431:13-103(a)(12)).
In Best Place, Inc. v. Penn America Insurance Co. (1996), the Hawaii Supreme Court recognized a first-party bad faith tort for an insurer's breach of the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing.
When an insurer contests liability and is ordered by a court to pay policy benefits, the policyholder or beneficiary is awarded reasonable attorney's fees and costs in addition to the benefits (HRS § 431:10-242).
Last updated: October 2026
6.3 Enforcing Fair Claim Handling: Commissioner Proceedings, Complaint Records, Bad Faith & Attorney's Fees
Section 6.1 listed the unfair claim settlement practices, and 6.2 the deadlines. This section answers the next question: what happens when they are violated? Hawaii uses two separate enforcement tracks: an administrative track run by the Insurance Commissioner, and a civil track in the courts.
- Track 1: Commissioner Enforcement Under Article 13
- Investigation and Hearing
The commissioner may examine and investigate the affairs of every person engaged in the business of insurance in Hawaii to decide whether it has engaged in an unfair practice (HRS § 431:13-105).
If the commissioner has reason to believe a person has engaged in an unfair method of competition or unfair or deceptive act — whether or not it is specifically defined in § 431:13-103 — and a proceeding would be in the public interest, the commissioner serves a statement of charges and a notice of hearing . The hearing must be set not less than 15 days after service (§ 431:13-106(a)).
At the hearing, the person may be heard and show cause why a cease and desist order should not issue. Procedure follows chapter 91 (§ 431:13-106(b), (c)).
Orders and Penalties
- Step Provision Consequence
- Violation found after hearing § 431:13-201(a) Written findings and a cease and desist order
Violation of § 431:13-103 § 431:13-201(a)(1) Fine up to $1,000 per act, maximum $10,000 ; if the person knew or reasonably should have known it was violating § 431:13-103, up to $5,000 per act, maximum $50,000 in any six-month period
- Knowing violation § 431:13-201(a)(2) Suspension or revocation of the license
- Order challenged § 431:13-201(b) Judicial review under chapter 91
Cease and desist order violated § 431:13-202 After notice and hearing, up to $10,000 per act , suspension or revocation, or both, and no relief from other liability
The commissioner may adopt rules identifying specific prohibited practices, but the rules may not enlarge §§ 431:13-103 or 13-104 (§ 431:13-203). These powers are in addition to any other enforcement power under law (§ 431:13-204). For general code violations, § 431:2-203 separately allows fines of $100 to $10,000 per violation (5.1).
No Private Right of Action Under Article 13
All remedies, penalties and proceedings in article 13 are to be invoked solely and exclusively by the commissioner (§ 431:13-107). Hawaii courts have repeatedly held that the article does not authorize a private lawsuit. In one case, a workers' compensation insurer won summary judgment against an employee who sued for violating it. A claimant therefore cannot sue simply for "violating § 431:13-103." The same conduct can, however, be evidence in a bad faith case (Track 2).
- Complaint Records and the Complaint Process
- The Insurer's Complaint Register (§ 431:13-103(a)(12))
Failing to maintain complaint handling procedures is itself an unfair practice. Every insurer must keep a complete record of all complaints received since its last examination under § 431:2-302. The record must show:
- the total number of complaints;
- their classification by line of insurance ;
- the nature of each complaint;
- the disposition of each complaint; and
the time it took to process each complaint.
A complaint means any written communication primarily expressing a grievance. Examiners review the register during market conduct examinations.
How a Consumer Complaint Moves
The consumer files a complaint with the Insurance Division (online, by mail, or in person).
The commissioner notifies the insurer's designated agent of the complaint by certified mail (§ 431:13-103(b)) and sends a written inquiry.
The insurer or licensee answers in writing within 15 working days , addressing the concerns rather than merely acknowledging receipt (§ 431:13-103(f)).
The division reviews the file. Three or more written complaints in any 12 months charging separate violations raise a presumption of a general business practice (6.1).
The commissioner may resolve the complaint, examine the insurer, or begin a hearing under § 431:13-106.
For the adjuster, the practical rule is to write every claim file as if an examiner will read it. Include dated diary notes, copies of every response, the reasons for each decision, and proof that each deadline was met.
- Track 2: Civil Remedies in Court
- First-Party Bad Faith: Best Place v. Penn America (1996)
In Best Place, Inc. v. Penn America Insurance Co. , 82 Haw. 120, 920 P.2d 334 (1996), the Hawaii Supreme Court held that:
every insurance contract contains an implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing ;
an insurer's breach of that covenant in handling a first-party claim gives rise to an independent tort action, separate from breach of contract;
the test is objective: whether the insurer acted unreasonably in handling the claim. Malice or conscious wrongdoing is not required, but an honest mistake by itself is not bad faith — the decision must be unreasonable; and
article 13's administrative remedies are not exclusive , so an insured may bring the bad faith tort despite § 431:13-107.
Damages in a successful bad faith case can include the contract benefits, consequential economic losses, and emotional distress damages.
Third-Party (Liability) Claims
In liability insurance, the insurer's good faith duties run to its insured . An insurer that unreasonably refuses a reasonable settlement offer within limits may be liable to its insured for the resulting excess judgment. An injured third-party claimant generally has no bad faith claim of its own against the defendant's insurer. In one case, the Hawaii Supreme Court rejected a third-party claimant's bad faith claim against a self-insured rental car company because there was no insurance contract from which the duty could arise (2004).
Attorney's Fees (§ 431:10-242)
When an insurer has contested its liability under a policy and is ordered by the courts to pay benefits , the policyholder, the beneficiary, or a person who acquired their rights shall be awarded reasonable attorney's fees and costs of suit , in addition to the benefits. In motor vehicle PIP disputes, the insurer pays the attorney's fees and costs needed to collect benefits found due, separately from the benefits (§ 431:10C-304(5)).
Punitive Damages
Punitive damages are not awarded for ordinary mistakes. Under Hawaii law, they require clear and convincing evidence that the defendant acted wantonly, oppressively, with malice, or with such willful misconduct or entire want of care as to raise a presumption of conscious indifference to consequences. HIGA never pays punitive damages assessed against an insolvent insurer (5.6).
Unfair or Deceptive Acts Under Chapter 480
Federal courts applying Hawaii law have held that article 13 does not prevent consumers from bringing unfair or deceptive trade practice claims under HRS § 480-2. One example is the lava-zone surplus lines cases noted in 5.2.
Claim Handling Habits That Prevent Both Tracks
- Habit Protects against
- Calendar the 15-working-day and 30-calendar-day dates on every file (11)(B), (F), (G) violations
- Pay undisputed coverage parts immediately (11)(O) and bad faith delay claims
Explain every denial or compromise in writing with policy language (11)(P), and shows the decision was reasonable
Never label partial payments "final" (11)(Q)
Investigate before denying, and document all available information (11)(D) and the reasonableness test in Best Place
Respond substantively to every Insurance Division inquiry within 15 working days §§ 431:2-208(c), 431:13-103(f)