Study guide

2.4 Loss Valuation Methods, Coinsurance & Settlement Provisions

Hawaii Claims Adjuster Exam

Track your progress as you read

Finished sections get a check mark.

1 Chapter 1: General Insurance Principles, Contract Law & Key Terms

1.1 Risk, Perils, Hazards & Insurable Interest 1.2 Principles of Indemnity, Subrogation & Utmost Good Faith 1.3 Legal Contracts & Essential Characteristics of Insurance Policies 1.4 Key Insurance Terms: Binders, Vacancy, Theft, Salvage, Audits & Certificates

2 Chapter 2: Property Insurance Policies & Coverage Forms

2.1 Dwelling Property Policies (DP-1, DP-2, DP-3) & Basic Perils 2.2 Homeowners Policy Forms (HO-2, HO-3, HO-4, HO-5, HO-6, HO-8) 2.3 Commercial Property Forms, Causes of Loss & Endorsements 2.4 Loss Valuation Methods, Coinsurance & Settlement Provisions 2.5 Commercial Package Policy, Businessowners Policy & Equipment Breakdown 2.6 Inland Marine: Personal Floaters, Commercial Floaters & the Nationwide Marine Definition 2.7 Flood (NFIP), Earthquake & Personal Watercraft Coverage

3 Chapter 3: Liability, Auto, Workers' Compensation, Crime & Specialty Coverages

3.1 Principles of Legal Liability, Torts & Negligence 3.2 Commercial General Liability (CGL) Coverage Forms 3.3 CGL Who Is an Insured, Limits, Supplementary Payments, Conditions & Common Policy Conditions 3.4 Personal & Commercial Auto Insurance Fundamentals 3.5 Business Auto Liability, Physical Damage, Garage Coverage & Garagekeepers 3.6 Workers' Compensation Fundamentals & Employer Liability 3.7 Bonding, Fidelity & Commercial Crime Coverage 3.8 Professional Liability (Errors & Omissions), Umbrella & Excess Liability

4 Chapter 4: Policy Provisions & the Claims Adjustment Process

4.1 Policy Provisions in Practice: Duties After Loss, Proof of Loss, Mortgagee Rights, Appraisal, Arbitration & Cancellation 4.2 Adjuster Types, Duties, Agency Authority & Fiduciary Obligations 4.3 Claim Intake, First Notice of Loss, Reservation of Rights & Non-Waiver 4.4 Field Investigation, Physical Evidence, Recorded Statements & SIU Fraud Detection 4.5 Damage Evaluation, Reserving, Negotiation Techniques & Settlement Options

5 Chapter 5: Hawaii Insurance Regulation, Insurers & Adjuster Licensing (HRS Chapter 431)

5.1 Hawaii Insurance Division, Commissioner Powers, Examinations, Hearings & Penalties 5.2 Hawaii Insurer Definitions: Domestic, Foreign & Alien; Stock, Mutual & Reciprocal; Certificate of Authority; Unauthorized Insurers 5.3 Hawaii Adjuster Licensing: Definitions, License Types, Qualifications, Examination & Emergency Registration 5.4 Adjuster Records, Trust Funds, License Extension & Discipline (HRS §§ 431:9-228 to 9-240) 5.5 Hawaii Public Adjusters: Bond, Authority, Contract Requirements & Fee Limits (HRS §§ 431:9-223, 9-226, 9-244) 5.6 Hawaii Insurance Guaranty Association (HIGA): Covered Claims, Limits & Claim Handling (HRS Chapter 431, Article 16)

6 Chapter 6: Hawaii Unfair Claim Settlement Practices, Deadlines & Enforcement

6.1 Hawaii Unfair Claim Settlement Practices (HRS § 431:13-103(a)(11)) 6.2 Hawaii Claim Deadlines: 15 Working Days, 30 Calendar Days, PIP, Health Claims & How to Count Days 6.3 Enforcing Fair Claim Handling: Commissioner Proceedings, Complaint Records, Bad Faith & Attorney's Fees

7 Chapter 7: Hawaii Laws Pertinent to Property Insurance

7.1 Hawaii Property Law: Property & Marine Definitions, the Standard Fire Policy, Over-Insurance & Cancellation Notice 7.2 Hawaii Property Insurance Association (HPIA), the Hurricane Relief Fund & Catastrophe Claims

8 Chapter 8: Hawaii Laws Pertinent to Casualty Insurance: Motor Vehicle, Financial Responsibility & Workers' Compensation

8.1 Hawaii Motor Vehicle Insurance Law: Purpose, Required Coverages, 40/80/20 Limits, UM/UIM & Self-Insurance 8.2 Hawaii Personal Injury Protection (PIP), Source of Payment & the Tort Threshold 8.3 Hawaii Motor Vehicle Rates, Cancellation & Nonrenewal, and the Joint Underwriting Plan 8.4 Hawaii Motor Vehicle Financial Responsibility (HRS Chapter 287) 8.5 Hawaii Workers' Compensation Law (HRS Chapter 386): Coverage, Exclusive Remedy, Benefits & Insurer Duties

2.4 Loss Valuation Methods, Coinsurance & Settlement Provisions

Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI

Actual Cash Value (ACV) calculates loss as Replacement Cost minus physical depreciation, reflecting traditional indemnity principles.

The Coinsurance Formula determines partial loss recovery: (Insurance Carried / Insurance Required) × Loss minus Deductible, where Insurance Required equals Property Value multiplied by the Coinsurance Percentage.

Coinsurance penalties bite on partial losses; when the whole property is destroyed, the coinsurance calculation always reaches the limit, so the insurer pays the full limit of insurance.

Under pro-rata other insurance clauses, multiple concurrent policies share a loss proportionally based on their individual policy limits relative to the total combined insurance limits.

Hawaii has no valued policy law; instead, HRS § 431:10E-102 prohibits knowingly selling property insurance above actual cash value, with exceptions for replacement cost and ordinance or law coverage.

Last updated: October 2026

Loss Valuation Methods, Coinsurance & Settlement Provisions

Quick Summary: Property claims adjustment hinges on three core settlement concepts: establishing the correct loss valuation method (Actual Cash Value vs. Replacement Cost), applying the coinsurance formula to determine whether an underinsurance penalty applies to partial losses, and executing apportionment calculations when multiple concurrent policies cover the same loss.

Fundamentals of Property Loss Valuation

When covered property sustains direct physical damage, the adjuster must establish the dollar amount of indemnification. Several distinct valuation methods exist in property insurance: +-------------------------------------------------------------------------+

  • | PROPERTY VALUATION METHODS |
  • +-------------------------------------------------------------------------+
  • | Actual Cash Value (ACV): Replacement Cost - Depreciation |
  • | Replacement Cost (RC): New materials/labor, NO depreciation |
  • | Functional Replacement Cost: Modern equivalent functional materials |
  • | Agreed Value: Agreed sum; suspends coinsurance clause |
  • | Stated Amount: Max value for rating; pays least of ACV, |
  • | repair cost, or stated limit |
  • | Valued Policy Laws: Statutory full face payout on total loss |
  • | (Hawaii is NOT a valued policy state) |
  • +-------------------------------------------------------------------------+
  • 1–4. ACV, Replacement Cost, Functional Replacement Cost and Agreed Value (Recap)

Section 1.2 teaches these four methods with worked examples. In brief:

Method How a loss is valued Key adjuster point

Actual cash value Replacement cost new minus depreciation for age, wear and obsolescence A 15-year-old roof with a 20-year life is 75% depreciated

Replacement cost Cost to repair or replace with like kind and quality, with no depreciation Paid in two steps: ACV first, then the holdback once repairs are completed

Functional replacement cost Cost to replace with modern, functionally equivalent materials Used for older homes (for example, the HO-8)

Agreed value Value agreed in advance for the scheduled property Suspends the coinsurance condition for the agreed period

The broad evidence rule. Some courts do not limit actual cash value to replacement cost less depreciation. Instead, they consider all evidence bearing on value, such as market value, rental value, location, assessed value, income production and obsolescence. Check the policy's definition of actual cash value and the governing case law before choosing a method.

5. Stated Amount

Commonly used in classic automobile and commercial vehicle insurance. The insured states a maximum value for the property to establish the policy premium. However, stated amount does NOT guarantee payment of that stated value . In the event of a total loss, the contract dictates that the insurer will pay the LEAST of:

  • The stated amount;
  • The Actual Cash Value at the time of loss; or

The cost to repair or replace the property with like kind and quality.

6. Valued Policy Laws & Hawaii Doctrine

Some states enforce Valued Policy Laws , which mandate that if real property is completely destroyed by a specified peril (usually fire), the insurer must pay the full face amount of the policy, regardless of actual cash value or replacement cost.

Hawaii State Law Distinction: Hawaii has no valued policy law. Its insurance code takes the opposite approach. HRS § 431:10E-102 defines over-insurance as insuring property against the same hazard for more than its actual cash value (replacement cost less proper depreciation) as of the effective or renewal date, and it prohibits anyone from knowingly selling or negotiating such insurance. HRS § 431:10E-103 exempts replacement cost coverage and demolition or ordinance coverage. On a total loss, the insurer pays the loss as valued under the policy (ACV or replacement cost) up to the limit. An owner cannot collect $500,000 by insuring a $200,000 building for that amount (see 7.1).

The Coinsurance Provision & Mathematical Calculations

The Coinsurance Clause encourages policyholders to insure property to full value (typically 80%, 90%, or 100% of its replacement cost or ACV). Because the vast majority of property losses are partial rather than total, property owners would be tempted to buy small amounts of coverage (e.g., a $50,000 policy on a $500,000 building) if coinsurance did not penalize underinsurance.

The Universal Coinsurance Formula

Claim Payment = ( Insurance Carried (Did) Insurance Required (Should) ) × Loss − Deductible \text{Claim Payment} = \left( \frac{\text{Insurance Carried (Did)}}{\text{Insurance Required (Should)}} \right) \times \text{Loss} - \text{Deductible} Claim Payment = ( Insurance Required (Should) Insurance Carried (Did) ​ ) × Loss − Deductible Where: Insurance Required (Should) = Replacement Cost of Property × Coinsurance Percentage \text{Insurance Required (Should)} = \text{Replacement Cost of Property} \times \text{Coinsurance Percentage} Insurance Required (Should) = Replacement Cost of Property × Coinsurance Percentage

Step-by-Step Worked Adjuster Calculations +-------------------------------------------------------------------------+

  • | COINSURANCE DECISION TREE |
  • +-------------------------------------------------------------------------+
  • | Step 1: Calculate 'Should' (Property Value at loss x Coinsurance %) |
  • | Step 2: Compare 'Did' (Carried) to 'Should' (Required) |
  • | - If Did >= Should: Pay 100% of Loss minus Deductible |
  • | - If Did < Should: Apply Coinsurance Ratio (Did / Should) |
  • | Step 3: Multiply Loss by Coinsurance Ratio |
  • | Step 4: Subtract Deductible (Paid by insured first) |
  • | Step 5: Verify payment does not exceed Policy Limit |
  • +-------------------------------------------------------------------------+
  • Case 1: Coinsurance Penalty Applied (Underinsured Risk)

Property Valuation: Commercial warehouse with a Replacement Cost of $500,000 .

Policy Terms: 80% Coinsurance Clause; $300,000 Policy Limit carried; $2,500 Deductible.

Loss Details: Covered electrical fire causes $80,000 in physical damage.

Calculation Steps:

Determine Insurance Required (Should): Should = $ 500 , 000 × 80 % = $ 400 , 000 \text{Should} = \$500,000 \times 80\% = \$400,000 Should = $500 , 000 × 80% = $400 , 000

Determine Insurance Carried (Did): Did = $ 300 , 000 \text{Did} = \$300,000 Did = $300 , 000

Calculate Coinsurance Ratio: Ratio = Did Should = $ 300 , 000 $ 400 , 000 = 0.75 (or 75 % ) \text{Ratio} = \frac{\text{Did}}{\text{Should}} = \frac{\$300,000}{\$400,000} = 0.75 \text{ (or } 75\% \text{)} Ratio = Should Did ​ = $400 , 000 $300 , 000 ​ = 0.75 (or 75% )

Apply Ratio to Loss Amount: $ 80 , 000 × 0.75 = $ 60 , 000 \$80,000 \times 0.75 = \$60,000 $80 , 000 × 0.75 = $60 , 000

Apply Deductible: Net Settlement = $ 60 , 000 − $ 2 , 500 = $ 57 , 500 \text{Net Settlement} = \$60,000 - \$2,500 = \$57,500 Net Settlement = $60 , 000 − $2 , 500 = $57 , 500

Adjuster Financial Analysis: Because the insured carried only 75% of the required coverage, the insurer pays only 75% of the loss. The insured absorbs a $20,000 coinsurance penalty plus the $2,500 deductible , paying $22,500 out-of-pocket on an $80,000 claim.

Case 2: Coinsurance Requirement Fully Met (No Penalty)

Property Valuation: Same $500,000 commercial building (80% Coinsurance requirement = $400,000).

Policy Terms: $400,000 Policy Limit carried; $2,500 Deductible.

Loss Details: Covered fire causes $80,000 in damage.

Calculation Steps:

Coinsurance Ratio: Ratio = $ 400 , 000 $ 400 , 000 = 1.0 (or 100 % ) \text{Ratio} = \frac{\$400,000}{\$400,000} = 1.0 \text{ (or } 100\% \text{)} Ratio = $400 , 000 $400 , 000 ​ = 1.0 (or 100% )

Apply Ratio to Loss: $ 80 , 000 × 1.0 = $ 80 , 000 \$80,000 \times 1.0 = \$80,000 $80 , 000 × 1.0 = $80 , 000

Apply Deductible: Net Settlement = $ 80 , 000 − $ 2 , 500 = $ 77 , 500 \text{Net Settlement} = \$80,000 - \$2,500 = \$77,500 Net Settlement = $80 , 000 − $2 , 500 = $77 , 500

Adjuster Financial Analysis: Zero penalty applies because the insured satisfied the 80% threshold.

Case 3: Total Loss Dynamic

Consider what happens if the building in Case 1 (carrying $300,000 with a $400,000 requirement) suffers a total loss of $500,000 .

Applying Coinsurance Ratio to Loss: 0.75 × $ 500,000 = $ 375,000 0.75 \times \text{\textdollar}500{,}000 = \text{\textdollar}375{,}000 0.75 × $ 500 , 000 = $ 375 , 000

Subtract the Deductible: ISO's coinsurance steps subtract the deductible from that figure: $375,000 − $2,500 = $372,500.

Apply the Limit of Insurance: The insurer never pays more than the $300,000 limit, so it pays $300,000 .

Adjuster Principle: In a total loss, the coinsurance figure always reaches the limit of insurance, because the insured carries less than the full value. The insured therefore receives the full limit. The coinsurance penalty is felt in partial losses, where the proportional reduction actually lowers the payment.

Apportionment & Other Insurance Provisions

When two or more property insurance policies cover the same property, the claims adjuster must determine how the loss is shared to prevent over-indemnification.

1. Pro-Rata Liability (Contribution by Limits)

The standard clause in property insurance. Each insurer pays the proportion that its policy limit bears to the total combined insurance limits across all applicable policies. Company’s Proportional Share = ( Policy Limit of that Company Total Limits of All Applicable Policies ) × Loss \text{Company's Proportional Share} = \left( \frac{\text{Policy Limit of that Company}}{\text{Total Limits of All Applicable Policies}} \right) \times \text{Loss} Company’s Proportional Share = ( Total Limits of All Applicable Policies Policy Limit of that Company ​ ) × Loss

Worked Pro-Rata Adjuster Problem

A commercial property is covered by two concurrent property policies:

Carrier A: $300,000 policy limit.

Carrier B: $100,000 policy limit.

Total Insurance in Force: $300,000 + $100,000 = $400,000.

Covered Loss: A burst pipe causes $60,000 in covered damage. (Assume no deductible for this illustration).

Calculation:

Carrier A Proportion: Carrier A Share = $ 300 , 000 $ 400 , 000 = 0.75 (75%) ⟹ 0.75 × $ 60 , 000 = $ 45 , 000 \text{Carrier A Share} = \frac{\$300,000}{\$400,000} = 0.75 \text{ (75\%) } \implies 0.75 \times \$60,000 = \$45,000 Carrier A Share = $400 , 000 $300 , 000 ​ = 0.75 (75%) ⟹ 0.75 × $60 , 000 = $45 , 000

Carrier B Proportion: Carrier B Share = $ 100 , 000 $ 400 , 000 = 0.25 (25%) ⟹ 0.25 × $ 60 , 000 = $ 15 , 000 \text{Carrier B Share} = \frac{\$100,000}{\$400,000} = 0.25 \text{ (25\%) } \implies 0.25 \times \$60,000 = \$15,000 Carrier B Share = $400 , 000 $100 , 000 ​ = 0.25 (25%) ⟹ 0.25 × $60 , 000 = $15 , 000

Total Indemnification: $45,000 + $15,000 = $60,000 (loss paid in full).

2. Primary vs. Excess Insurance

Under primary and excess provisions, the primary policy pays first up to its full policy limit. If the loss exceeds the primary policy limit, the excess policy pays the remaining balance up to its own policy limit. Excess insurance never pays until the primary policy's limits are completely exhausted.

3. Contribution by Equal Shares

More common in liability insurance, under contribution by equal shares, each insurer contributes an equal dollar amount toward the loss until the loss is completely paid or each company's policy limit is reached.