Study guide

9.2 Use of Chinese: Logical Errors and Ambiguity (句子辨析:邏輯錯誤與歧義)

Common Recruitment Examination CRE

Track your progress as you read

Finished sections get a check mark.

1 Chapter 1: CRE Structure, Eligibility, Administration, and the BLNST

1.1 What the CRE Is, Who Can Sit It, and Which Grades Need It 1.2 Paper Formats, Grading, Equivalent Results, and Result Certificates 1.3 Sittings, Applications, Exam-Day Rules, and Pacing 1.4 The BLNST, Your Results, and What Happens After the CRE

2 Chapter 2: Use of English — Reading Comprehension

2.1 Reading Strategy, Gist Identification, and Passage Architecture 2.2 Detail Retrieval, Drawing Inferences, and Author Tone 2.3 Vocabulary in Context, Nuance, and Figurative Language

3 Chapter 3: Use of English — Error Identification & Grammar Foundations

3.1 Grammatical Errors: Subject-Verb Agreement, Tense, and Mood 3.2 Syntax Errors: Misplaced Modifiers, Parallelism, and Prepositions 3.3 Lexical and Stylistic Errors: Diction, Redundancy, and Word Choice

4 Chapter 4: Use of English — Sentence Completion & Paragraph Improvement

4.1 Sentence Completion: Structural Connectives, Subordinate Clauses, and Collocations 4.2 Paragraph Improvement: Cohesion, Flow, and Sentence Combining 4.3 Paragraph Improvement: Revision for Conciseness, Tone, and Clarity

5 Chapter 5: Aptitude Test — Verbal & Deductive Reasoning

5.1 Verbal Reasoning: True, False, and Cannot Tell Methodology 5.2 Deductive Reasoning: Categorical Logic, Syllogisms, and Conditionals 5.3 Relational Logic, Sequencing, and Analytical Elimination

6 Chapter 6: Aptitude Test — Data Sufficiency & Numerical Reasoning

6.1 Data Sufficiency: The CRE Two-Clue Format 6.2 Data Sufficiency: Hidden Anchors, Redundant Clues, and Other Traps 6.3 Numerical Reasoning: Arithmetic, Geometric, and Multi-Tier Sequences

7 Chapter 7: Aptitude Test — Interpretation of Tables & Graphs

7.1 Statistical Tables: Rapid Extraction, Percentages, and Proportions 7.2 Bar Charts, Line Graphs, and Trend Extrapolation 7.3 Multi-Data Synthesis, Composite Tables, and Common Distractors

8 Chapter 8: Use of Chinese — Reading Comprehension and Character Recognition (閱讀理解與字詞辨識)

8.1 Use of Chinese: Article Reading (文章閱讀) 8.2 Use of Chinese: Short Extract Reading (片段╱語段閱讀) 8.3 Use of Chinese: Wrongly Written Characters (字詞辨識:錯別字) 8.4 Use of Chinese: Matching Simplified and Traditional Characters (字詞辨識:簡化字)

9 Chapter 9: Use of Chinese — Sentence Analysis and Usage (句子辨析與詞句運用)

9.1 Use of Chinese: Structural Sentence Errors (句子辨析:語病) 9.2 Use of Chinese: Logical Errors and Ambiguity (句子辨析:邏輯錯誤與歧義) 9.3 Use of Chinese: Near-Synonyms and Word Choice (詞句運用:詞語選用) 9.4 Use of Chinese: Idioms, Connectives, and Polite Forms (詞句運用:成語、關聯詞與敬謙辭) 9.5 Use of Chinese: Sentence Filling and Sentence Ordering (詞句運用:句子填充與排序)

9.2 Use of Chinese: Logical Errors and Ambiguity (句子辨析:邏輯錯誤與歧義)

Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI

In the CSB sample, 「只有水量合適,農作物才能豐收。今年農作物沒有豐收,所以今年水量不合適」 is a logical error, because 只有……才…… sets a necessary condition and a failed harvest can have other causes.

Listing overlapping categories, as in 服務對象是男性和中下階層, mixes two classification standards (分類標準不一) and is a logical error.

A sentence that calls ten predictions 完全準確 and then admits one 有點差誤 contradicts itself (自相矛盾).

Stacked negatives such as 防止……不再 or 難免不 can reverse the intended meaning, so count every negative word before accepting a sentence.

Structural ambiguity (歧義), as in 三個部門的主管, arises when a phrase can be grouped in two ways.

Last updated: October 2026

9.2 Use of Chinese: Logical Errors and Ambiguity (句子辨析:邏輯錯誤與歧義)

Quick Answer: Some 句子辨析 items ask you to find the sentence that does or does not contain a logical error (邏輯錯誤). A logically faulty sentence can be grammatically perfect. Check for faulty conditional reasoning (only 只有……才……, 只要……就……), overlapping categories in a list, self-contradiction , too many negatives , illogical judgements and ambiguity .

  • The official sample, explained
  • 選出 沒有 犯邏輯錯誤的句子。
  • A 只有水量合適,農作物才能豐收。今年農作物沒有豐收,所以今年水量不合適。
  • B 在世界教育史上,中國是很早出現學校的一個國家。
  • C 這間公司的服務對象是男性和中下階層。
  • D 他的十個預測完全準確,只是最後一個有點差誤。
  • 答案:B

Sentence Fault Explanation

A Faulty conditional reasoning 只有 P 才 Q makes P necessary for Q: a good harvest requires suitable water. A poor harvest does not prove the water was unsuitable, because pests or weather could be the cause

B None The sentence says China was one of the countries where schools appeared very early. It makes a careful claim, not an absolute "first"

C Overlapping categories 男性 (sex) and 中下階層 (social class) are classified by different standards and overlap. Men from the lower and middle classes belong to both groups

  • D Self-contradiction 完全準確 (completely accurate) cannot coexist with 最後一個有點差誤 (the last one slightly off)
  • Type 1: faulty conditional reasoning

Chinese conditional connectives carry exact logical meanings (see also Section 5.2):

  • Connective Logical meaning Valid inference Invalid inference
  • 只要 P,就 Q P is sufficient for Q P happened, so Q happens Q happened, so P happened

只有 P,才 Q P is necessary for Q P did not happen, so Q does not happen P happened, so Q happens; or Q did not happen, so P did not happen

除非 P,否則不 Q Same as 只有 P 才 Q Without P, no Q With P, therefore Q

The official sample's sentence A reasons from "no harvest" to "no suitable water". That runs the necessary condition the wrong way. A second common fault is mixing the pairs, such as 只有……就…… or 只要……才……. These are both grammatical mismatches and logical errors.

Type 2: overlapping categories (並列不當)

Items joined by 和, 及, 與 or listed with 、 must be parallel and non-overlapping :

Different standards: 男性和中下階層 (sex and class).

Whole and part listed together: 本港居民和新界居民. 新界居民 are already 本港居民.

Category and member listed together: 蔬菜和白菜. 白菜 is a kind of 蔬菜.

The fix is to use one standard (男性和女性) or to restructure (本港居民,特別是新界居民).

Type 3: self-contradiction (自相矛盾)

Watch for absolute words followed by exceptions, and for numbers that cannot all be true:

全部 or 完全 followed by 只是……有誤 or 部分.

出席率接近百分之一百二十: an attendance rate cannot exceed 100 per cent.

唯一……之一: 唯一 means the only one, so it cannot be combined with 之一 (one of several). By contrast, 最……之一 (one of the most) is acceptable.

大約……整整: an approximate and an exact quantity in the same phrase.

Type 4: too many negatives (否定失當)

Count every negative word, including those built into verbs such as 防止, 避免, 禁止, 杜絕 and 否認:

  • Faulty sentence Problem Correction
  • 為了防止私隱資料不再外洩…… 防止 plus 不再 reverses the meaning 防止私隱資料外洩
  • 我們不能否認這不是一個好機會。 Three negatives amount to one, which reverses the intended meaning 我們不能否認這是一個好機會

新同事難免不犯錯,大家應多包容。 難免 already means "can hardly avoid"; adding 不 says new colleagues will not make mistakes 新同事難免犯錯

Type 5: illogical judgements (判斷不當)

A "是" sentence must equate things of the same kind:

香港的氣候是一個溫暖潮濕的地方。 Climate is not a place, so the fix is 香港的氣候溫暖潮濕.

本署的宗旨是一個以民為本的部門。 A mission (宗旨) is not a department, so the fix is 本署的宗旨是以民為本.

Type 6: ambiguity (歧義)

A sentence is ambiguous if it can be read in two ways:

  • Ambiguous sentence Two readings Clear version
  • 三個部門的主管出席了會議。 Three managers, or the managers of three departments 三名部門主管 or 來自三個部門的主管
  • 他和秘書的上司開會。 He met (the secretary's boss), or (his and the secretary's) boss held a meeting 他跟秘書的上司開會
  • 他走了一個多小時。 He walked for over an hour, or he left over an hour ago 他步行了一個多小時 / 他已離開了一個多小時
  • A checklist for logic items

Find the claim words: 只有, 只要, 除非, 一定, 全部, 唯一, 之一 and numbers.

Test conditionals with the table in Type 1.

Check lists for overlapping or unequal categories.

Count the negatives and work out the overall meaning.

Check "是" sentences : are both sides the same kind of thing?

Try a second reading of any noun phrase with a number or 和.

Combining logic and structure checks

On the paper you will not be told whether an item tests structure or logic. The stem simply says 選出有語病的句子 or 選出沒有犯邏輯錯誤的句子. Run the structural checks from Section 9.1 first, because they are quicker. If every sentence is structurally sound, switch to the logic checks above. In the official logic sample, every sentence is grammatical, so only the logic checklist separates them. Practise by writing your own sentence for each of the six types; producing an error is the surest way to recognise it under time pressure.

Loading diagram... Checking a sentence for logical errors