Study guide
1.4 Technical Infeasibility, Existing-Building Ramps, and Historic Structures
ICC Accessibility Inspector / Plans Examiner 21
Track your progress as you read
Finished sections get a check mark.
1 Chapter 1: General Administrative and Scoping Provisions
1.1 Occupancy Group Accessibility and IBC Chapter 11 Scoping 1.2 General Administration: Definitions, Conventions, and Code Editions 1.3 Existing Buildings: IEBC Section 306 Alterations, Additions, and Changes of Occupancy 1.4 Technical Infeasibility, Existing-Building Ramps, and Historic Structures
2 Chapter 2: Building Blocks (ICC A117.1 Chapter 3)
2.1 Walking and Floor Surfaces, Openings, and Level Changes 2.2 Turning Space and Clear Floor Space: New Versus Existing Buildings 2.3 Knee and Toe Clearances 2.4 Unobstructed and Obstructed Reach Ranges 2.5 Protruding Objects and Vertical Clearance
3 Chapter 3: Accessible Routes — Route Scoping, Entrances, and Doors
3.1 Accessible Route Scoping, Components, Slopes, and Clear Width 3.2 Accessible Entrances: Number, Location, and Power-Operated Doors 3.3 Doors, Doorways, and Gates: Clear Width and Maneuvering Clearances 3.4 Door Hardware, Forces, Closing Speed, Door Surfaces, and Windows
4 Chapter 4: Accessible Routes — Ramps, Curb Ramps, and Conveyance
4.1 Ramps: Slopes, Landings, and Clearances 4.2 Ramp Handrails, Edge Protection, and Cross Slopes 4.3 Curb Ramps, Blended Transitions, and Detectable Warnings at Crossings 4.4 Elevators, LULA Elevators, and Platform Lifts
5 Chapter 5: Accessible Means of Egress
5.1 Accessible Means of Egress: Number, Components, Elevators, and Stairways 5.2 Elevators, Platform Lifts, Areas of Refuge, and Exterior Areas for Assisted Rescue 5.3 Two-Way Communication, Egress Signage, and Instructions
6 Chapter 6: General Site and Building Elements
6.1 Accessible Parking: Scoping, Van Spaces, Dimensions, and Signs 6.2 Passenger Loading Zones, Bus Stops, and Rail Platforms 6.3 Site Accessibility: Site Routes, Routes Through Parking, EV Charging, and Fuel Dispensers 6.4 Stairways: Treads, Risers, Nosings, Visual Contrast, and Lighting 6.5 Stair Handrails: Location, Height, Profile, Continuity, and Extensions
7 Chapter 7: Plumbing Elements and Facilities
7.1 Water Closets and Toilet Compartments 7.2 Grab Bars: Locations, Cross Sections, Spacing, Strength, and Assisted Toileting 7.3 Toilet Rooms, Lavatories, Sinks, Mirrors, Urinals, and Accessories 7.4 Bathtubs, Shower Compartments, and Seats 7.5 Plumbing Scoping: Family Rooms, Adult Changing Stations, Drinking Fountains, Laundry, and Saunas
8 Chapter 8: Communication Elements and Features
8.1 Visible Alarms and Assistive Listening Systems 8.2 Accessible Signage: Visual Characters, Raised Characters, Braille, Pictograms, and Symbols 8.3 Telephones, ATMs and Fare Machines, Two-Way Communication Systems, and Detectable Warnings
9 Chapter 9: Special Rooms and Spaces
9.1 Assembly Areas: Wheelchair Spaces, Companion Seats, Dispersion, and Lines of Sight 9.2 Dressing and Locker Rooms, Courtrooms, Detention Cells, Self-Storage, and Classroom Acoustics 9.3 Kitchens and Kitchenettes
10 Chapter 10: Built-in Furnishings and Equipment
10.1 Dining Surfaces and Work Surfaces 10.2 Sales and Service Counters and Windows 10.3 Check-Out Aisles, Food Service Lines, Benches, Storage, Charging Stations, and Gaming
11 Chapter 11: Dwelling and Sleeping Units
11.1 Scoping Accessible, Type A, and Type B Units (IBC 1108) 11.2 Type A Units (A117.1 Section 1103) 11.3 Type B Units (A117.1 Section 1104) 11.4 Accessible Units: Hotels, Dormitories, Health Care and Residential Care (A117.1 Section 1102) 11.5 Type C (Visitable) Units and Units with Communication Features
12 Chapter 12: Recreational Facilities
12.1 Swimming Pools, Wading Pools, Hot Tubs, and Spas 12.2 Play Areas and Amusement Rides 12.3 Sports Facilities, Exercise Equipment, Golf, Boating, Fishing, and Shooting Facilities
1.4 Technical Infeasibility, Existing-Building Ramps, and Historic Structures
Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI
Technically infeasible means structural conditions (removing a load-bearing member essential to the structural frame) or other physical or site constraints prevent full compliance; cost alone never qualifies.
A117.1-2017 Table 405.2 allows existing-building ramps steeper than 1:12 only where space is limited: up to 1:10 for a 6-inch maximum rise and up to 1:8 for a 3-inch maximum rise.
Historic structure alternatives apply when the authority having jurisdiction determines that compliance for routes, entrances or toilet rooms would threaten or destroy historic significance (2021 IEBC 306.7.16; 2024 IEBC 306.7.18).
Historic alternatives require one 36-inch exterior route from a site arrival point, a route to public spaces on the accessible entrance level, an unlocked or monitored accessible entrance, and one accessible single-user or family toilet room where toilets are provided.
Accessible means of egress and Type B units are not required in historic structures, and Type A units in individually owned R-2 units may meet Type B criteria.
Last updated: October 2026
1.4 Technical Infeasibility, Existing-Building Ramps, and Historic Structures
Candidates often blend three different forms of relief into one idea of "existing building exceptions." The exam separates them, so you should too:
Technical infeasibility (IBC and IEBC definitions, IEBC 306.7): permits access "to the maximum extent technically feasible."
A117.1 existing-building criteria : written exceptions such as steeper short ramps, smaller turning spaces and 54-inch existing reach ranges.
Historic structure alternatives (2021 IEBC 306.7.16; 2024 IEBC 306.7.18): reduced requirements where full compliance would threaten or destroy historic significance.
Technically Infeasible
The IBC and IEBC define technically infeasible as an alteration that has little likelihood of being accomplished because the existing structural conditions require the removal or alteration of a load-bearing member that is an essential part of the structural frame, or because other existing physical or site constraints prohibit modification or addition of elements, spaces or features that are in full and strict compliance with the minimum requirements for new construction and that are necessary to provide accessibility.
Claim Technically infeasible? Why
Widening a door requires cutting a load-bearing masonry pier essential to the frame Yes Structural condition in the definition
- A ramp landing would extend past the property line onto a public sidewalk Yes Existing site constraint
- An elevator would cost $250,000 No Cost is not in the definition
- A ramp would spoil the facade No Appearance is not in the definition (unless historic alternatives apply)
- The tenant would lose two parking spaces No Inconvenience is not a physical constraint
Even when part of a requirement is infeasible, the rest is not. If a door can reach only 31 in. of clear width because of a structural column, the designer still provides the maneuvering clearances, hardware heights and opening force that are feasible.
A117.1 Existing-Building Criteria
A117.1-2017 builds many existing-building allowances directly into its technical sections. The ramp table is the most frequently tested.
A117.1 Section 405.2 limits ramp running slope to greater than 1:20 and not steeper than 1:12. The exception reads: "In existing buildings or facilities, ramps shall be permitted to have slopes steeper than 1:12 complying with Table 405.2 where such slopes are necessary due to space limitations."
Running slope Maximum rise
Steeper than 1:12 but not steeper than 1:10 6 in.
Steeper than 1:10 but not steeper than 1:8 3 in.
There is no row for slopes steeper than 1:8. A 1:6 ramp allowance appeared in the 1991 federal ADA guidelines for historic buildings; it does not appear in A117.1-2017 or the IEBC, so a 1:6 slope is not a correct answer on this exam.
Worked Example
An existing tenant entrance has a 4-inch step and only 40 inches of available run.
At 1:12, a 4-inch rise needs 48 inches of run, which does not fit.
At 1:10, a 4-inch rise needs 40 inches of run, and 4 inches is within the 6-inch limit. This complies with Table 405.2 because space is limited.
If only 30 inches were available, the slope would be 4:30, about 1:7.5, steeper than 1:8. That is not permitted, and a different solution such as a platform lift or relocated entrance is needed.
Other existing-building criteria to tab: 60-inch turning circle (304.3.1.2), 30 x 48 clear floor space (305.3.2), 54-inch side reach for existing unaltered elements (308.3.1 Exception 1), existing or altered thresholds up to 3/4 in. with beveled edges (404.2.4), a 5/8-inch latch-side stop projection in alterations (404.2.2 Exception 2), and existing elevator cars with 16 sq ft of floor area (407.4.1 Exception).
Historic Buildings
A historic building under the IEBC is one listed, or certified as eligible for listing, in the National Register of Historic Places, designated as historic under applicable state or local law, or certified as a contributing resource within a listed or designated historic district.
The 2021 IEBC (306.7.16) and the 2024 IEBC (306.7.18) say: where compliance with the requirements for accessible routes, entrances or toilet rooms would threaten or destroy the historic significance of the historic structure, as determined by the authority having jurisdiction , the listed alternatives for that element are permitted.
2021 / 2024 Alternative requirement
306.7.16.1 / 306.7.18.1 At least one exterior accessible route, including curb ramps, from a site arrival point to an accessible entrance, 36 in. minimum width
306.7.16.2 / 306.7.18.2 An accessible route from an accessible entrance to public spaces on the level of that entrance
306.7.16.3 / 306.7.18.3 If an entrance cannot be made accessible under 306.7.5, provide an accessible entrance that is unlocked while the building is occupied, or a locked accessible entrance with a notification system or remote monitoring; IBC 1112 signs at public entrances and the accessible entrance
306.7.16.4 / 306.7.18.4 Where toilet rooms are provided, at least one accessible single-user or family/assisted-use toilet room complying with IBC 1110.2.1
- 306.7.16.5 / 306.7.18.5 Same for bathing rooms
- 306.7.16.6 / 306.7.18.6 Individually owned Type A units in R-2 may meet Type B criteria
- 306.7.16.7 / 306.7.18.7 Type B units are not required in historic buildings
Two exceptions apply to historic structures: accessible means of egress required by IBC Chapter 10 are not required, and the altered element or space is not required to be on an accessible route unless 306.7.16.1 or 306.7.16.2 requires it. Upper floors of a historic building therefore do not need an accessible route when the alternatives apply; only public spaces on the accessible entrance level must be connected.
Note
IEBC Appendix B adds supplementary provisions, including consultation with the State Historic Preservation Officer and displays located for seated viewing, but an appendix applies only where the jurisdiction adopts it. Under the base IEBC, the determination belongs to the authority having jurisdiction.
Case Study
A 1905 bank listed on the National Register becomes a restaurant. The monumental front stair cannot be ramped without destroying the facade, and the basement restrooms cannot be enlarged.
The AHJ determines that a front ramp would destroy historic significance. A side entrance with a 36-inch exterior route from the parking lot becomes the accessible entrance, unlocked while occupied. Signs comply with IBC 1112 at the front entrance and at the accessible entrance.
The dining room on the entrance level is connected by an accessible route.
One accessible single-user toilet room is provided where toilet rooms are provided.
The mezzanine bar is not required to be on an accessible route under the historic exceptions.