Study guide

3.3 Laboratory Compaction Standards: Standard vs. Modified Proctor (ASTM D698, D1557)

ICC Soils Special Inspector EC

Track your progress as you read

Finished sections get a check mark.

1 Chapter 1: Special Inspection Administration & Quality Control Framework

1.1 Special Inspection Roles, Duties, and Boundaries of Authority 1.2 Construction Documents, Soils Reports, and Statement of Special Inspections 1.3 Inspection Records, Discrepancy Notification, and Escalation

2 Chapter 2: Soil Classification Systems & Field Identification

2.1 Representative Soil Sampling and Field Quality Protocols 2.2 Visual-Manual Soil Classification (ASTM D2488) 2.3 Unified Soil Classification System (USCS) and Dual Symbols (ASTM D2487)

3 Chapter 3: Laboratory Soil Mechanics & Compaction Standards

3.1 Particle Size Analysis and Gradation Curves (ASTM D422 / D6913) 3.2 Atterberg Limits and Soil Plasticity (ASTM D4318) 3.3 Laboratory Compaction Standards: Standard vs. Modified Proctor (ASTM D698, D1557)

4 Chapter 4: Grading Plans, Contours, and Earthwork Quantities

4.1 Topographic Contours, Spot Elevations, and Slope Calculations 4.2 Cut and Fill Staking, Daylight Lines, and Benching Slopes 4.3 Earthwork Quantities, Mass Haul Concepts, and Material Balance

5 Chapter 5: Site Preparation, Clearing, and Subgrade Evaluation

5.1 Site Clearing, Grubbing, Stripping, and Unsuitable Soils 5.2 Subgrade Scarification, Moisture Conditioning, and Compaction 5.3 Proofrolling Procedures, Evaluation, and Subgrade Remediation

6 Chapter 6: Excavations, Foundation Bearing, and Ground Improvement

6.1 Overexcavation, Undercuts, and Differing Subsurface Conditions 6.2 Shallow Footing Excavation and Soil Bearing Verification 6.3 Deep Foundations and Ground Improvement Inspection

7 Chapter 7: Retaining Structures, Site Drainage, and Fill Material Control

7.1 Retaining Wall Backfill, Drainage Systems, and Lateral Earth Pressures 7.2 Structural Fill Selection, Gradation, and Clod Control 7.3 Fill Placement, Lift Thickness, and Compaction Equipment Operations

8 Chapter 8: Field Density & Moisture Testing Methods

8.1 Nuclear Density Gauge Testing and Radiation Safety (ASTM D6938) 8.2 Sand Cone Density Testing and Field Volumetric Verification (ASTM D1556) 8.3 Rapid Field Moisture Methods and Laboratory Verification (ASTM D2216, D4643, D4959)

9 Chapter 9: Compaction Calculations, Quality Assurance, and Special Conditions

9.1 Field Density and Compaction Calculations 9.2 Oversize Particle Corrections (ASTM D4718) 9.3 Testing Frequency, Failed Test Resolution, and Adverse Weather Earthwork

3.3 Laboratory Compaction Standards: Standard vs. Modified Proctor (ASTM D698, D1557)

Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI

Modified Proctor (ASTM D1557) delivers approximately 56,250 ft-lbf/ft³ of compactive energy—roughly 4.54 times the 12,400 ft-lbf/ft³ energy of Standard Proctor (ASTM D698)—yielding a higher Maximum Dry Density and a lower Optimum Moisture Content.

ASTM D698 and D1557 specify Methods A (≤25% retained on the No. 4 sieve), B (≤25% retained on the 3/8-in. sieve), and C (≤30% retained on the 3/4-in. sieve), which govern whether a 4-inch or 6-inch mold is required.

The Zero Air Voids (ZAV) curve defines the theoretical 100% saturation limit for a given specific gravity; no compaction curve or test point can physically plot on or to the right of the ZAV line.

The one-point Proctor method (AASHTO T 272 / ASTM D698 Annex) allows field inspectors to rapidly match a field-compacted soil point against pre-established laboratory family curves to verify maximum density when borrow materials vary across an earthwork cut.

Last updated: September 2026

3.3 Laboratory Compaction Standards: Standard vs. Modified Proctor (ASTM D698, D1557)

Compaction is the mechanical process of densifying soil through the expulsion of air from its void spaces using dynamic mechanical effort (rolling, tamping, or vibration). Densification increases soil dry unit weight, raises shear strength, enhances slope stability, reduces future settlement under structural loads, and decreases hydraulic permeability. In modern geotechnical construction, the degree of field compaction achieved by earthwork contractors is evaluated relative to laboratory moisture-density reference standards.

Two fundamental laboratory compaction test standards govern North American building construction:

ASTM D698 ( Standard Test Methods for Laboratory Compaction Characteristics of Soil Using Standard Effort ),

ASTM D1557 ( Standard Test Methods for Laboratory Compaction Characteristics of Soil Using Modified Effort ).

The Soils Special Inspector must understand the operational mechanics, energy differentials, method selection rules, and mathematical calculations that distinguish these tests.

Historical Evolution: Standard vs. Modified Compactive Effort

In 1933, Ralph R. Proctor published landmark research demonstrating that for a given compactive energy, soil compaction is governed directly by moisture content. At low moisture, water films are thin and soil particles resist rearrangement due to interparticle friction. As water is added, it lubricates soil grains, allowing them to slide into a tighter, denser packing configuration. However, past a certain moisture threshold, water begins to fill the pore spaces and displaces solid particles. Because water is nearly incompressible, excess water resists compaction, causing dry density to drop. This parabolic relationship produces two benchmark parameters:

Maximum Dry Density (MDD or γ d , max ⁡ \gamma_{d,\max} γ d , m a x ​ ): The highest dry unit weight achievable under the specified laboratory compactive effort.

Optimum Moisture Content (OMC or w o p t w_{opt} w o pt ​ ): The specific water content at which Maximum Dry Density is attained.

During World War II, the rapid deployment of heavy military bombers (such as the B-29 Superfortress) resulted in wheel loads exceeding 50,000 to 100,000 pounds. These extreme loads caused rutting and failure on airfields compacted to traditional Proctor standards. The U.S. Army Corps of Engineers increased the laboratory compactive energy by roughly a factor of 4.5 , creating the Modified Proctor test (later standardized as ASTM D1557 ). Dry Density (pcf)

  • |
  • | /\ (MDD_Mod, OMC_Mod)
  • | / \ Modified Proctor (~56,250 ft-lbf/ft³)
  • MDD_Mod|.............* \
  • | / \ /\ (MDD_Std, OMC_Std)
  • MDD_Std|.........../........\.....* \ Standard Proctor (~12,400 ft-lbf/ft³)
  • | / \ / \
  • | / \ / \ Zero Air Voids (100% Saturation)
  • | / * \ |
  • | / \ |
  • | / \ v
  • | / \..........---------
  • +----+---------------+-------------+--------------------->
  • 0% OMC_Mod OMC_Std Water Content (w%)
  • The Fundamental Principle of Compactive Energy

When compactive effort increases (shifting from Standard to Modified Proctor):

Maximum Dry Density increases (the curve shifts upward).

Optimum Moisture Content decreases (the curve shifts to the left).

Equipment and Parameter Comparison: ASTM D698 vs. ASTM D1557

The following table details the precise equipment dimensions, drop heights, layer counts, and compactive energies mandated by ASTM:

Operational Parameter Standard Proctor (ASTM D698) Modified Proctor (ASTM D1557) Engineering Significance & Exam Notes

Rammer Mass / Weight 5.5 lbf (2.49 kg) 10.0 lbf (4.54 kg) Modified rammer is approximately 1.82× heavier than Standard.

Rammer Drop Height 12.0 inches (304.8 mm / 1.0 ft) 18.0 inches (457.2 mm / 1.5 ft) Modified drop height is 1.5× higher than Standard.

Face Diameter of Rammer 2.000 in. (50.8 mm) circular face 2.000 in. (50.8 mm) circular face Must be clean, flat, and inspected for wear.

Number of Compacted Layers 3 equal layers 5 equal layers Each layer must be scarified lightly before placing next layer.

Blows per Layer (4-in. Mold) 25 blows per layer 25 blows per layer Blows must be distributed uniformly across mold face.

Blows per Layer (6-in. Mold) 56 blows per layer 56 blows per layer Higher blow count compensates for larger volume.

Mold Diameter & Volume (4") 4.000 in. diameter; 1/30 ft³ ( 0.0333 ft 3 0.0333\text{ ft}^3 0.0333 ft 3 / 944 cm 3 944\text{ cm}^3 944 cm 3 ) 4.000 in. diameter; 1/30 ft³ ( 0.0333 ft 3 0.0333\text{ ft}^3 0.0333 ft 3 / 944 cm 3 944\text{ cm}^3 944 cm 3 ) Standard 4-inch mold with detachable extension collar.

Mold Diameter & Volume (6") 6.000 in. diameter; 1/13.33 ft³ ( 0.0750 ft 3 0.0750\text{ ft}^3 0.0750 ft 3 / 2 , 124 cm 3 2,124\text{ cm}^3 2 , 124 cm 3 ) 6.000 in. diameter; 1/13.33 ft³ ( 0.0750 ft 3 0.0750\text{ ft}^3 0.0750 ft 3 / 2 , 124 cm 3 2,124\text{ cm}^3 2 , 124 cm 3 ) Used for coarser soils under Method C.

Compactive Energy Delivered ~12,375 to 12,400 ft-lbf/ft³ ( 600 kN ⋅ m/m 3 600\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m/m}^3 600 kN ⋅ m/m 3 ) ~56,000 to 56,250 ft-lbf/ft³ ( 2 , 700 kN ⋅ m/m 3 2,700\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m/m}^3 2 , 700 kN ⋅ m/m 3 ) Modified effort is ~4.54× greater energy than Standard.

Primary Field Application Commercial building pads, light residential grading, roadway subgrades Heavy industrial slabs, airport runways, highway base course, deep structural fills

Mathematical Derivation of Compactive Effort

Compactive energy per unit volume ( E E E ) is calculated using the physical formula: E = ( Number of Blows/Layer ) × ( Number of Layers ) × ( Weight of Rammer ) × ( Drop Height ) Volume of Mold E = \frac{(\text{Number of Blows/Layer}) \times (\text{Number of Layers}) \times (\text{Weight of Rammer}) \times (\text{Drop Height})}{\text{Volume of Mold}} E = Volume of Mold ( Number of Blows/Layer ) × ( Number of Layers ) × ( Weight of Rammer ) × ( Drop Height ) ​

Standard Proctor (4-in. mold): E Std = 25 × 3 × 5.5 lbf × 1.0 ft 0.03333 ft 3 = 412.5 ft-lbf 0.03333 ft 3 = 12 , 375 ft-lbf/ft 3 ≈ 12 , 400 ft-lbf/ft 3 E_{\text{Std}} = \frac{25 \times 3 \times 5.5\text{ lbf} \times 1.0\text{ ft}}{0.03333\text{ ft}^3} = \frac{412.5\text{ ft-lbf}}{0.03333\text{ ft}^3} = 12,375\text{ ft-lbf/ft}^3 \approx 12,400\text{ ft-lbf/ft}^3 E Std ​ = 0.03333 ft 3 25 × 3 × 5.5 lbf × 1.0 ft ​ = 0.03333 ft 3 412.5 ft-lbf ​ = 12 , 375 ft-lbf/ft 3 ≈ 12 , 400 ft-lbf/ft 3

Modified Proctor (4-in. mold): E Mod = 25 × 5 × 10.0 lbf × 1.5 ft 0.03333 ft 3 = 1 , 875 ft-lbf 0.03333 ft 3 = 56 , 250 ft-lbf/ft 3 E_{\text{Mod}} = \frac{25 \times 5 \times 10.0\text{ lbf} \times 1.5\text{ ft}}{0.03333\text{ ft}^3} = \frac{1,875\text{ ft-lbf}}{0.03333\text{ ft}^3} = 56,250\text{ ft-lbf/ft}^3 E Mod ​ = 0.03333 ft 3 25 × 5 × 10.0 lbf × 1.5 ft ​ = 0.03333 ft 3 1 , 875 ft-lbf ​ = 56 , 250 ft-lbf/ft 3

Energy Ratio: E Mod E Std = 56 , 250 12 , 375 ≈ 4.54 \frac{E_{\text{Mod}}}{E_{\text{Std}}} = \frac{56,250}{12,375} \approx 4.54 E Std ​ E Mod ​ ​ = 12 , 375 56 , 250 ​ ≈ 4.54

Method Selection: Methods A, B, and C

Both ASTM D698 and ASTM D1557 specify three distinct test methods (Method A, Method B, and Method C) dictated strictly by the particle gradation of the material:

Method Gradation Criteria (Dry Mass Basis) Mold Diameter Soil Fraction Tested (Scalping Threshold) Blows per Layer Number of Layers

Method A ≤ 25 % \le 25\% ≤ 25% retained on No. 4 ( 4.75 mm 4.75\text{ mm} 4.75 mm ) sieve 4-inch ( 101.6 mm 101.6\text{ mm} 101.6 mm ) Material passing No. 4 sieve 25 blows 3 (Std) / 5 (Mod)

Method B ≤ 25 % \le 25\% ≤ 25% retained on 3/8-in. ( 9.5 mm 9.5\text{ mm} 9.5 mm ) sieve (used when more than 25 % 25\% 25% is retained on the No. 4 sieve) 4-inch ( 101.6 mm 101.6\text{ mm} 101.6 mm ) Material passing 3/8-in. sieve 25 blows 3 (Std) / 5 (Mod)

Method C ≤ 30 % \le 30\% ≤ 30% retained on 3/4-in. ( 19.0 mm 19.0\text{ mm} 19.0 mm ) sieve (used when more than 25 % 25\% 25% is retained on the 3/8-in. sieve) 6-inch ( 152.4 mm 152.4\text{ mm} 152.4 mm ) Material passing 3/4-in. sieve 56 blows 3 (Std) / 5 (Mod)

[!CRITICAL] Soils with More Than 30 % 30\% 30% Retained on the 3/4-inch Sieve: Neither ASTM D698 nor ASTM D1557 may be applied directly. If 5 % 5\% 5% to 30 % 30\% 30% oversize particles (>3/4 in.) are removed (scalped) before testing, the laboratory MDD and OMC must be mathematically adjusted using ASTM D4718 ( Standard Practice for Correction of Unit Weight and Water Content for Soils Containing Oversize Particles ). If oversize rock exceeds 30 % 30\% 30% , laboratory compaction molds cannot simulate field conditions, and fill placement must be controlled via test fill pads and procedural specifications (roller passes, lift thickness) rather than nuclear density gauge testing.

Laboratory Compaction Procedure and Curve Construction

Moisture Conditioning: At least four to five test specimens of representative soil are thoroughly blended at moisture contents spanning approximately 4% to 6% below optimum up to 2% to 4% above optimum, allowing at least two points on the dry side of optimum and two on the wet side.

Standing / Curing Time: Cohesive soils must cure in sealed containers for a minimum equilibration period (typically 16 to 24 hours for heavy clays) to allow water to distribute uniformly through the clay mineral matrix.

Compaction: The mold is secured to a rigid base. Soil is placed in 3 or 5 equal layers, and each layer is compacted with the prescribed number of blows (25 or 56) dropped cleanly through free fall. The final layer must extend slightly (approximately 1/4 in. to 3/8 in.) above the mold rim into the extension collar.

Trimming: The extension collar is removed, and excess soil is carefully shaved level with the top rim of the mold using a steel straightedge. Any gouges formed by coarse aggregate dislodging are patched with fine trimmed cuttings.

Mass and Density Calculations:

Wet unit weight (wet density): γ w e t = M w e t s o i l V m o l d = M t o t a l − M m o l d V m o l d \gamma_{wet} = \frac{M_{wet\,soil}}{V_{mold}} = \frac{M_{total} - M_{mold}}{V_{mold}} γ w e t ​ = V m o l d ​ M w e t so i l ​ ​ = V m o l d ​ M t o t a l ​ − M m o l d ​ ​

Moisture content ( w w w ) is determined by oven-drying per ASTM D2216.

Dry unit weight (dry density): γ d = γ w e t 1 + w % 100 = γ w e t 1 + w \gamma_d = \frac{\gamma_{wet}}{1 + \frac{w\%}{100}} = \frac{\gamma_{wet}}{1 + w} γ d ​ = 1 + 100 w % ​ γ w e t ​ ​ = 1 + w γ w e t ​ ​

Curve Fitting: Dry density (vertical axis) is plotted against moisture content (horizontal axis). A smooth parabolic curve is drawn through the data. The coordinates of the apex define γ d , max ⁡ \gamma_{d,\max} γ d , m a x ​ (MDD) and w o p t w_{opt} w o pt ​ (OMC) .

Soil Fabric: Compacting Dry of Optimum vs. Wet of Optimum

Compaction moisture profoundly influences the microscopic structure (fabric) of fine-grained soils, producing starkly different engineering properties at the same dry density: Dry of Optimum (Flocculated Fabric) Wet of Optimum (Dispersed Fabric)

  • +---------------------------------+ +---------------------------------+
  • | /\ \ / /| | | ============== ========== |
  • | / \ ---\ /--- / | | | =========================== |
  • | /____\ \ / /__| | | ============== ========== |
  • | (Edge-to-Face Random Matrix) | | (Face-to-Face Parallel Sheets)| |
  • +---------------------------------+ +---------------------------------+

Engineering Characteristic Compacted Dry of Optimum ( w < w o p t w < w_{opt} w < w o pt ​ ) Compacted Wet of Optimum ( w > w o p t w > w_{opt} w > w o pt ​ )

Microscopic Soil Fabric Flocculated (random, edge-to-face particle orientation) Dispersed (oriented, face-to-face parallel orientation)

Shear Strength (Initial) Higher initial shear strength; stiffer response Lower shear strength; ductile, compressible response

Sensitivity to Water High swelling potential upon wetting; prone to collapse under load Low swelling potential; stable volumetric behavior

Permeability ( k k k ) High permeability (large, open interconnected pore paths) Very low permeability (tightly packed, parallel sheets)

Preferred Earthwork Use Structural building pads, highway embankments requiring high immediate shear resistance Impermeable clay landfill liners , core trenches for earth dams, retention pond liners

Note

Landfill liners and clay containment barriers are intentionally specified to be compacted 1% to 3% wet of optimum moisture to achieve the minimum possible hydraulic conductivity ( k ≤ 1 × 10 − 7 cm/s k \le 1 \times 10^{-7}\text{ cm/s} k ≤ 1 × 1 0 − 7 cm/s ).

The Zero Air Voids (ZAV) Curve: The Physical Saturation Limit

The Zero Air Voids (ZAV) line represents the theoretical dry unit weight of soil when all air is completely excluded from the void space and the soil is 100 % 100\% 100% saturated ( S = 100 % S = 100\% S = 100% ) .

Mathematical Formulation γ z a v = G s × γ w 1 + w × G s S = G s × γ w 1 + ( w × G s ) ( when S = 1.0 ) \gamma_{zav} = \frac{G_s \times \gamma_w}{1 + \frac{w \times G_s}{S}} = \frac{G_s \times \gamma_w}{1 + (w \times G_s)} \quad (\text{when } S = 1.0) γ z a v ​ = 1 + S w × G s ​ ​ G s ​ × γ w ​ ​ = 1 + ( w × G s ​ ) G s ​ × γ w ​ ​ ( when S = 1.0 )

Where:

G s G_s G s ​ = Specific gravity of soil solids (typically 2.65 for quartz sands; 2.70 to 2.80 for clays),

γ w \gamma_w γ w ​ = Unit weight of water ( 62.4 lbf/ft 3 62.4\text{ lbf/ft}^3 62.4 lbf/ft 3 or 9.81 kN/m 3 9.81\text{ kN/m}^3 9.81 kN/m 3 ),

w w w = Water content expressed as a decimal ( w % / 100 w\% / 100 w %/100 ).

Critical Field Inspection Rule: Inviolability of the ZAV Line

It is physically impossible to expel all air from a soil using dynamic impact compaction. Trapped pore air and capillary menisci always remain ( S ≈ 80 % to 90 % S \approx 80\% \text{ to } 90\% S ≈ 80% to 90% at optimum). Consequently:

The compaction curve must always lie completely below and to the left of the ZAV curve .

A compaction curve CAN NEVER CROSS OR PLOT TO THE RIGHT OF THE ZERO AIR VOIDS LINE .

Caution

If an on-site field nuclear density gauge reading or laboratory compaction point plots ON or TO THE RIGHT of the ZAV curve, the test data is physically impossible . The Soils Special Inspector must immediately investigate. The most common errors are:

Underestimated moisture content: Oven-dry moisture was not measured accurately, or moisture was lost before testing.

Overestimated dry density: Field sand cone volume was miscalculated, or gauge depth was incorrect.

Assumed Specific Gravity ( G s G_s G s ​ ) is too low: If a soil contains heavy minerals (e.g., iron oxides with G s = 2.90 G_s = 2.90 G s ​ = 2.90 ), using an assumed G s = 2.65 G_s = 2.65 G s ​ = 2.65 falsely shifts the theoretical ZAV curve downward.

Loading diagram... Compaction Curves vs. Zero Air Voids (ZAV) Boundary

The One-Point Proctor Method and Family of Curves

On large earthwork projects, borrow excavation sources frequently transition across varying geological strata, changing from sandy silts to fat clays within a few hundred feet. A single laboratory Proctor curve cannot serve as the reference standard for an entire heterogeneous grading site.

To address borrow soil variations without waiting 24 hours for a full multi-point laboratory test, inspectors utilize the One-Point Proctor Method in conjunction with a project Family of Curves (standardized under AASHTO T 272 and ASTM D698/D1557 Annex):

Establishment of Family: Prior to mass grading, the geotechnical laboratory develops a series of full compaction curves (a "family") representing the full spectrum of soil types found across the project borrow areas.

Field One-Point Compaction: When soil type variations occur on site, the inspector retrieves a representative bulk sample from the fill area, adjusts moisture if necessary, and compacts a single specimen in a standard 4-inch or 6-inch mold using the specified ASTM compactive effort (Standard or Modified).

Curve Matching: The resulting wet density and moisture content (or dry density) point is plotted directly onto the Family of Curves template.

Identification of Applicable Curve: The unique family curve that passes directly through or parallel to the plotted one-point coordinate defines the true Maximum Dry Density (MDD) and Optimum Moisture Content (OMC) for that specific lift of soil.

  • Worked Engineering Example: Mold Calculations and Relative Compaction
  • Problem Statement

A Soils Special Inspector performs a quality assurance verification test on a compacted building pad using a 4-inch mold under ASTM D1557 Method A (Modified Proctor):

Mold Volume: V = 1 / 30.0 ft 3 = 0.03333 ft 3 V = 1/30.0\text{ ft}^3 = 0.03333\text{ ft}^3 V = 1/30.0 ft 3 = 0.03333 ft 3

  • Tare mass of empty mold: W m o l d = 4.28 lb W_{mold} = 4.28\text{ lb} W m o l d ​ = 4.28 lb
  • Mass of mold + compacted wet soil: W t o t a l = 8.54 lb W_{total} = 8.54\text{ lb} W t o t a l ​ = 8.54 lb
  • Moisture tin tare mass: M t i n = 22.40 g M_{tin} = 22.40\text{ g} M t in ​ = 22.40 g
  • Mass of tin + wet soil: M w e t + t i n = 174.60 g M_{wet+tin} = 174.60\text{ g} M w e t + t in ​ = 174.60 g

Mass of tin + oven-dry soil: M d r y + t i n = 158.20 g M_{dry+tin} = 158.20\text{ g} M d ry + t in ​ = 158.20 g

Project Specification: Structural fill must achieve at least 95.0 % 95.0\% 95.0% of Modified Proctor MDD , with moisture within ± 2.0 % \pm 2.0\% ± 2.0% of OMC.

Laboratory baseline reference from soils report: M D D = 122.4 pcf MDD = 122.4\text{ pcf} M DD = 122.4 pcf , O M C = 11.5 % OMC = 11.5\% OMC = 11.5% .

Step 1: Calculate Moisture Content ( w w w ) M w a t e r = M w e t + t i n − M d r y + t i n = 174.60 − 158.20 = 16.40 g M_{water} = M_{wet+tin} - M_{dry+tin} = 174.60 - 158.20 = 16.40\text{ g} M w a t er ​ = M w e t + t in ​ − M d ry + t in ​ = 174.60 − 158.20 = 16.40 g M d r y s o i l = M d r y + t i n − M t i n = 158.20 − 22.40 = 135.80 g M_{dry\,soil} = M_{dry+tin} - M_{tin} = 158.20 - 22.40 = 135.80\text{ g} M d ry so i l ​ = M d ry + t in ​ − M t in ​ = 158.20 − 22.40 = 135.80 g w = ( M w a t e r M d r y s o i l ) × 100 % = ( 16.40 g 135.80 g ) × 100 % = 12.08 % w = \left( \frac{M_{water}}{M_{dry\,soil}} \right) \times 100\% = \left( \frac{16.40\text{ g}}{135.80\text{ g}} \right) \times 100\% = 12.08\% w = ( M d ry so i l ​ M w a t er ​ ​ ) × 100% = ( 135.80 g 16.40 g ​ ) × 100% = 12.08%

Step 2: Calculate Wet Density ( γ w e t \gamma_{wet} γ w e t ​ ) W w e t s o i l = W t o t a l − W m o l d = 8.54 lb − 4.28 lb = 4.26 lb W_{wet\,soil} = W_{total} - W_{mold} = 8.54\text{ lb} - 4.28\text{ lb} = 4.26\text{ lb} W w e t so i l ​ = W t o t a l ​ − W m o l d ​ = 8.54 lb − 4.28 lb = 4.26 lb γ w e t = W w e t s o i l V m o l d = 4.26 lb 0.03333 ft 3 = 127.81 pcf \gamma_{wet} = \frac{W_{wet\,soil}}{V_{mold}} = \frac{4.26\text{ lb}}{0.03333\text{ ft}^3} = 127.81\text{ pcf} γ w e t ​ = V m o l d ​ W w e t so i l ​ ​ = 0.03333 ft 3 4.26 lb ​ = 127.81 pcf

Step 3: Calculate Dry Density ( γ d \gamma_d γ d ​ ) γ d = γ w e t 1 + w % 100 = 127.81 pcf 1 + 0.1208 = 127.81 1.1208 = 114.03 pcf \gamma_d = \frac{\gamma_{wet}}{1 + \frac{w\%}{100}} = \frac{127.81\text{ pcf}}{1 + 0.1208} = \frac{127.81}{1.1208} = 114.03\text{ pcf} γ d ​ = 1 + 100 w % ​ γ w e t ​ ​ = 1 + 0.1208 127.81 pcf ​ = 1.1208 127.81 ​ = 114.03 pcf

Step 4: Calculate Relative Compaction ( R C RC RC ) R C = ( γ d M D D ) × 100 % = ( 114.03 pcf 122.40 pcf ) × 100 % = 93.16 % RC = \left( \frac{\gamma_d}{MDD} \right) \times 100\% = \left( \frac{114.03\text{ pcf}}{122.40\text{ pcf}} \right) \times 100\% = 93.16\% RC = ( M DD γ d ​ ​ ) × 100% = ( 122.40 pcf 114.03 pcf ​ ) × 100% = 93.16%

Step 5: Compliance Evaluation and Nonconformance Escalation

Compaction Evaluation: The measured relative compaction is 93.2 % 93.2\% 93.2% , which falls below the specified 95.0 % 95.0\% 95.0% minimum requirement. The test FAILS.

Moisture Evaluation: The moisture content is 12.1 % 12.1\% 12.1% , which is within the specified ± 2.0 % \pm 2.0\% ± 2.0% window ( 11.5 % ± 2.0 % = 9.5 % 11.5\% \pm 2.0\% = 9.5\% 11.5% ± 2.0% = 9.5% to 13.5 % 13.5\% 13.5% ). The failure is strictly due to insufficient roller compactive effort, excessive lift thickness, or insufficient roller passes.

Special Inspector Action: Notify the grading contractor superintendent immediately on site. Log the failed test in the daily inspection report. Re-inspect and re-test the lift after the contractor re-rolls the area with additional passes.