Study guide
16.3 NCR, Reporting & QC Documents
IIW International Welding Inspector — Standard IWI-S
Track your progress as you read
Finished sections get a check mark.
1 Introduction & Exam Overview
1.1 About the IWI-S Qualification 1.2 Exam Structure, Routes & Scoring 1.3 How to Use This Guide
2 Inspector Role & Responsibilities
2.1 Inspector Duties Across the Weld Lifecycle 2.2 Reports, Traceability & Authority 2.3 IWI-S vs Basic and Comprehensive
3 Chapter 3: Arc Welding Processes I
3.1 Welding Technology Overview & Arc Fundamentals 3.2 MMA/SMAW Process & Flux-Coated Electrodes 3.3 MIG/MAG (GMAW) & Flux-Cored Arc Welding 3.4 TIG/GTAW Process
4 Chapter 4: Processes, Parameters & Consumables
4.1 SAW and Other Welding Processes 4.2 Cutting, Edge Preparation & Mechanisation 4.3 Heat Input, Arc Energy, Polarity & Parameters 4.4 ISO 4063 Process Numbers & Consumable Standards
5 Chapter 5: Metallurgy Foundations
5.1 Metals, Fe-C Alloys & Steel Classification 5.2 Structure of the Welded Joint & HAZ Zones 5.3 Carbon Equivalent, Hardenability & ISO/TR 15608 Groups
6 Chapter 6: Cracking Phenomena
6.1 Hydrogen Cold Cracking 6.2 Hot & Solidification Cracking 6.3 Lamellar Tearing 6.4 Fracture Types Related to Weld Defects
7 Chapter 7: Heat Treatment & Steel Families
7.1 Preheat, Interpass & PWHT 7.2 Carbon, Low-Alloy & Fine-Grain Steels 7.3 Creep-Resistant & Cryogenic Steels
8 Chapter 8: Stainless, Aluminium & Other Materials
8.1 Stainless & Heat-Resistant Steels 8.2 Aluminium & Aluminium Alloys 8.3 Nickel, Dissimilar Joints & Other Materials 8.4 Corrosion, Wear & Protective Layers
9 Chapter 9: Design & Welding Symbols
9.1 Strength of Materials Basics for Inspectors 9.2 Welded Joint Design & Preparation 9.3 ISO 2553 Welding Symbols 9.4 Fillet Throat Sizing & Structural Loading
10 Chapter 10: Fatigue, Distortion & Fabrication
10.1 Fatigue, Weld-Toe Effects & Fracture Mechanics Intro 10.2 Residual Stress & Distortion Control 10.3 Repair Welding, Plant Facilities & Health/Safety
11 Chapter 11: Weld Imperfections I
11.1 ISO 6520 Imperfection Classification 11.2 Cracks — Causes & Prevention 11.3 Porosity & Gas-Related Imperfections 11.4 Lack of Fusion & Lack of Penetration
12 Chapter 12: Weld Imperfections II
12.1 Undercut, Overlap & Shape Imperfections 12.2 Inclusions, Misalignment & Miscellaneous Defects 12.3 Evaluating Imperfections for Acceptance
13 Chapter 13: Surface NDT Methods
13.1 Visual Testing (ISO 17637) 13.2 Liquid Penetrant Testing (PT) 13.3 Magnetic Particle Testing (MT)
14 Chapter 14: Volumetric NDT & Destructive Tests
14.1 Radiographic Testing (RT) & Film Quality 14.2 Ultrasonic Testing (UT) 14.3 NDT Method Selection, IQI & ISO 9712 14.4 Destructive Testing of Welded Joints
15 Chapter 15: Codes, Acceptance & Qualification
15.1 ISO 5817 Quality Levels B/C/D 15.2 ISO 3834 Quality Requirements 15.3 WPS, WPQR & ISO 15614 15.4 Welder Qualification ISO 9606
16 Chapter 16: QA Documentation & Exam Strategy
16.1 Inspection Stages, ITPs & Hold Points 16.2 Materials Certificates, Traceability & In-Process Control 16.3 NCR, Reporting & QC Documents 16.4 Application of Standards & Practical Exam Strategy
16.3 NCR, Reporting & QC Documents
Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI
A non-conformance report (NCR) records product or process failure against specified requirements and drives disposition and actions
Corrective actions fix causes; preventive actions reduce recurrence risk—inspectors document facts and support the quality loop
Final inspection dossiers package certificates, WPS/welder evidence, ITP sign-offs, NDT and test reports for handover
Early detection is economically superior to late repair, scrap, or field failure—staged inspection protects cost and safety
IWI-S decides whether quality documents (NDT reports, material tests, production tests) support construction requirements—not only files them
Last updated: July 2026
16.3 NCR, Reporting & QC Documents
Quick Answer: When product or process fails a specified requirement , raise a non-conformance report (NCR) , record objective evidence , obtain disposition (rework, repair, use-as-is, scrap, etc.), and track corrective/preventive actions . Final acceptance rests on a dossier of certificates, qualifications, ITP releases, NDT and tests. IWI-S competence includes deciding whether those documents meet construction requirements —and understanding that early detection is far cheaper than late failure (WI2.12–2.13, IAB §3.1 reporting themes).
Inspection that never writes non-conformances is either perfect production or weak inspection. Standard-level inspectors are expected to be fluent in reporting culture : factual, timely, and linked to requirements—not personal opinions or vague “looks bad” notes.
What Is a Non-Conformance?
A non-conformance is a failure to meet a specified requirement . The requirement may come from:
- Drawings and dimensional tolerances
- WPS essential variables
- Acceptance standards (e.g., ISO 5817 quality level)
- Material specifications and certificate requirements
- ITP hold/witness obligations
- Contract specifications and statutory rules
Examples:
- Fillet throat undersize vs drawing/ISO 5817
- Crack confirmed by MT
- Wrong heat of plate welded into a pressure part
- Welder outside qualified range
- RT performed after PWHT was required before RT, or vice versa, against the ITP
- Missing 3.1 certificate where 3.1 was ordered
Non-conformance ≠ every imperfection. An imperfection within the contracted acceptance level is conforming. Calling every cosmetic ripple an NCR destroys system credibility; failing to NCR a crack destroys integrity.
NCR Content — What Good Looks Like
A usable NCR typically includes:
- Unique NCR number and date
- Item identity (drawing, weld ID, serial/heat, location)
- Requirement reference (clause, WPS no., acceptance level)
- Description of non-conformance with measurements/photos where relevant
- Discovery stage (receiving, fit-up, in-process, final, NDT)
- Immediate containment (quarantine, stop welding, mark the joint)
- Disposition proposed/approved (rework, repair procedure, use-as-is with concession, scrap, return to supplier)
- Cause analysis (when required by system severity)
- Corrective action and preventive action
- Verification of effectiveness and close-out signatures
Write so a person who was not present can reconstruct the event. Quantify: “undercut 1.2 mm deep over 40 mm on toe of weld W-17, exceeding ISO 5817 level C limit for this thickness” beats “undercut bad.”
Corrective vs Preventive Actions
- Term Intent Example
- Correction / rework / repair Fix this non-conforming item Grind and re-weld under approved repair WPS
Corrective action Eliminate cause of detected non-conformance Retrain welder; adjust fixturing; revise parameter monitoring
Preventive action Eliminate potential cause of a similar future non-conformance Add ITP surveillance on similar joints; change storage practice before humidity season
Inspectors often initiate NCRs and verify that repairs meet requirements. Root-cause ownership may sit with production or welding coordination—but the inspector should not close an NCR until objective evidence shows the item now conforms (and, where required, that actions are implemented).
Use-as-is dispositions need authorised concession from the party who owns the requirement (engineering/client)—not informal shop agreement. “Use-as-is” for a crack is almost never appropriate without a formal fitness justification outside normal IWI-S routine acceptance.
Reporting Duties (IAB §3.1 Themes)
IAB-041-type guidance treats reporting as integral to inspection. Reports may be interim (progress on long jobs) or final (handover reference). Good reports:
- Trace production parameters and responsibilities later if service problems arise
- Serve client, jurisdiction, or code structured needs
- Separate facts from opinions
- Attach or reference supporting evidence (NDT reports, certificates, photos, ITP pages)
Oral examiners love: What goes into your final report? and Who receives an NCR?
Final Inspection Dossiers
A final dossier (manufacturer’s data book, MDR, QC package—names vary) is the structured collection that supports release. Typical contents include:
- Index and drawing list with revisions
- Material certificates and traceability maps
- Consumable batch records
- WPS/WPQR and welder/welding operator qualifications
- ITP with completed sign-offs
- Inspection reports (VT and others)
- NDT reports and (where applicable) RT film packages or digital media with quality records
- Heat-treatment charts
- Pressure/leak test records
- NCR log and closed concessions
- As-built drawings or weld maps
- Certificate of compliance / release note
IWI-S is expected to review such packages for completeness and consistency—not merely stack paper. Cross-checks catch classic errors: weld ID on NDT report not on weld map; certificate heat not on map; WPS number on weld record not approved for the joint; missing PWHT chart for a code weld that requires it.
Documents IWI-S Must Decide On
Guideline competence for Standard level emphasises deciding on quality documents against construction requirements, including:
Document type Decision focus
NDT reports Method, extent, procedure, personnel qualification, acceptance standard, identification of examined welds, clear accept/reject, legibility; for RT, film/image quality verification competence (not full interpretation as a radiographer in all cases—know your role boundary)
Material test certificates Type required, grade, heat match, mechanical/chemical completeness, supplementary tests
Production tests Coupons or production test plates required by code/contract: were they welded with production parameters, tested, and results acceptable?
- Procedure & personnel records WPQR supports WPS; welder range covers production
- ITP evidence Holds released by correct parties; no skipped interventions without authorised change
“Decide on” means accept, reject, or query —with authority limits respected. If the contract requires client approval of concessions, the inspector does not silently approve use-as-is.
Economics of Early Detection
Quality cost curves are harsh:
- Receiving inspection catches wrong plate → replace plate (relatively cheap)
- Fit-up hold catches bad geometry → recut/refit (cheap vs welded repair)
- Root NDT hold catches lack of fusion → re-weld root (moderate)
- Final NDT catches buried defect → deep repair or cut-out (expensive)
- Site/service failure → shutdowns, injuries, legal exposure (catastrophic)
This is why ITPs front-load holds on materials and roots for critical work, and why inspectors who “don’t want to slow production” can create the largest delays later. Application of Standards scenarios may ask which stage would have been the most economical detection point.
- Practical Workflow When You Find a Problem
- Stop escalation of risk (containment): mark, quarantine, stop further welding if needed
- Record evidence against the requirement
- Raise NCR per site system
- Support disposition with technical facts
- Verify repair under approved method
- Confirm document updates (weld map, NDT, dossier)
- Close only with evidence
Never hide a finding to protect a schedule or a colleague. Ethical reporting is part of professional practice and oral assessment.
Exam Focus
Expect definitions of NCR vs accepted imperfection; corrective vs preventive; dossier contents; and “what do you do if the RT report accepts a weld but film quality indicators fail?” The last item tests whether you decide on documents intelligently: an NDT report is not automatically valid if quality of examination is inadequate.
You have now closed the production QA loop from ITP through certificates to NCR and dossier. The final section of this guide turns those professional habits into exam strategy : Application of Standards at 70% , PE-S practical, oral assessment, scoring rules, and a full 16-chapter checklist .