Study guide

7.2 Line-Item Estimating, Unit Cost Pricing, and Depreciation Application

Illinois Public Adjuster Exam

Track your progress as you read

Finished sections get a check mark.

1 Chapter 1: Illinois Public Adjuster Licensing, Contracts, Fees, and Conduct

1.1 Article XLV Scope, the Public Adjuster Definition, License Exemptions, and the Director's Powers 1.2 The Exam, Licensing Requirements, the $50,000 Bond or Letter of Credit, CE, and Discipline 1.3 The Public Adjuster Contract: Required Terms, Disclosures, Prohibited Clauses, and the Right to Void 1.4 Fee Caps, Escrow and Claim Proceeds, Solicitation Limits, Standards of Conduct, and Records

2 Chapter 2: Illinois Claims Practices and Property Insurance Regulation

2.1 Improper Claims Practices: 215 ILCS 5/154.5-154.8, Part 919 Timelines, and Section 155 2.2 Illinois Property Policy Regulation: Cancellation, Nonrenewal, Tolling, Misrepresentation, and Fire-Loss Payment Rules

3 Chapter 3: Property and Casualty Terms, Valuation, and Policy Conditions

3.1 Fundamental Legal Principles: Indemnity, Insurable Interest, and Contract Characteristics 3.2 Perils, Hazards, Direct and Indirect Loss, Earnings, Deductibles, and Limits of Liability 3.3 Valuation Methods: ACV, Replacement Cost, and Depreciation Calculations 3.4 Coinsurance Mechanics, Formulas, and Penalty Calculations 3.5 Binders, Waiver and Estoppel, Abandonment, Salvage, Bailments, Theft Terms, and Vacancy 3.6 Policy Conditions and Contract Law: Notice, Proof of Loss, Misrepresentation, Assignment, Subrogation, Mortgagee Rights, and Apportionment

4 Chapter 4: Personal Lines: Standard Fire, Dwelling, Homeowners, and Mine Subsidence

4.1 The 1943 New York Standard Fire Policy: Insuring Agreement, Conditions, Proof of Loss, and Actual Cash Value 4.2 Dwelling Policy Program: DP-1, DP-2, and DP-3 4.3 Homeowners Policy Forms: HO-2, HO-3, HO-4, HO-5, HO-6, and HO-8 4.4 Perils Insured Against and Universal Exclusions 4.5 Additional Coverages, Policy Extensions, and Homeowners Endorsements 4.6 Illinois Mine Subsidence Insurance and Earthquake Coverage

5 Chapter 5: Commercial Lines, Time Element, and Inland and Ocean Marine

5.1 Building and Personal Property (BPP) Coverage Form 5.2 Commercial Causes of Loss Forms: Basic, Broad, and Special 5.3 Business Income and Extra Expense Coverages 5.4 Commercial Package Policies, Businessowners Policies, and Special Multi-Peril Programs 5.5 Builder's Risk and Equipment Breakdown (Boiler and Machinery) Coverage 5.6 Inland and Ocean Marine: Definitions, Personal Floaters, Commercial Floaters, and Valuable Papers

6 Chapter 6: Building Construction, Systems, and Damage Assessment

6.1 Building Construction Types, Framing, and Roofing Assemblies 6.2 Electrical Systems, Plumbing, and Mechanical Infrastructure 6.3 Water Intrusion, Fire, Smoke, and Environmental Damage Mechanisms

7 Chapter 7: Claims Investigation, Estimating, Appraisal, and Professional Ethics

7.1 The Claims Investigation and Scope of Loss Preparation 7.2 Line-Item Estimating, Unit Cost Pricing, and Depreciation Application 7.3 Dispute Resolution, the Policy Appraisal Clause, and Negotiation Strategies 7.4 Fiduciary Duty, Professional Ethics, and Policyholder Advocacy

7.2 Line-Item Estimating, Unit Cost Pricing, and Depreciation Application

Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI

Line-item unit cost estimating decomposes property reconstruction into discrete, quantifiable construction tasks—incorporating materials, labor, and equipment—rather than relying on subjective lump-sum contractor bids.

Industry-standard estimating systems (such as Xactimate and Symbility) utilize localized, quarterly updated price databases reflecting local labor burdens, material retail costs, and prevailing equipment rates.

General Contractor Overhead and Profit (GCOP / '10 and 10') is warranted whenever the repair reasonably requires the coordination and supervision of multiple distinct construction trades or complex structural restoration.

In Sproull v. State Farm, 2021 IL 126446, the Illinois Supreme Court held that an insurer may not depreciate labor costs in calculating actual cash value when the policy does not define ACV to allow it.

Depreciation must reflect actual physical deterioration, obsolescence, and observable maintenance condition rather than an arbitrary mathematical formula tied solely to chronological age.

Last updated: October 2026

Construction Estimating Principles in Property Adjustment

Property insurance adjusting relies on technical construction estimating to convert observed physical damage into a precise monetary claim. In adjusting practice, two competing estimating methodologies exist: Lump-Sum Bids and Line-Item Unit-Cost Estimating .

Why Lump-Sum Bids Fail in Insurance Claims

Property owners frequently obtain general contractor bids stating a single composite price (e.g., "Repair fire damage to kitchen and living room: $85,000"). Insurance carriers universally reject lump-sum bids because:

They provide zero transparency into material quantities, labor hours, or unit prices.

Insurers cannot verify whether the bid includes non-covered items, elective architectural upgrades, or pre-existing condition repairs.

They cannot be audited against policy coverage limits, code upgrade endorsements, or deductible applications.

The Line-Item Unit-Cost Standard

The insurance industry mandates line-item unit-cost estimating . Under this methodology, every building assembly is broken down into discrete components measured in standardized units of measure. Each line item accounts for three direct cost components:

Direct Material Cost : Wholesale/retail cost of raw materials, fasteners, adhesives, and delivery charges.

Direct Labor Cost : Wages of skilled tradespersons plus labor burden (employer payroll taxes, FICA, FUTA, SUTA, workers' compensation insurance, general liability insurance, and fringe benefits).

Equipment Cost : Machinery rental, mobilization, fuel, depreciation, and operating maintenance (e.g., scaffolding, hydraulic lifts, negative air machines, HEPA dehumidifiers). ┌────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐

  • │ STANDARD UNITS OF MEASURE │
  • ├────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┤
  • │ SF (Square Foot) → Drywall, paint, flooring, siding, insulation │
  • │ SY (Square Yard) → Carpet, carpet pad (9 SF = 1 SY) │
  • │ LF (Linear Foot) → Baseboards, crown molding, gutters, pipe runs │
  • │ SQ (Square) → Roofing, house wrap (100 SF = 1 Square) │
  • │ EA (Each) → Light fixtures, doors, windows, sinks, outlets │
  • │ BF (Board Foot) → Framing lumber (1 in × 12 in × 12 in = 144 in³)│
  • │ CF (Cubic Foot) → Concrete foundations, soil removal │
  • │ HR (Hour) → Specialized forensic labor, emergency cleaning │
  • └────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┘
  • Estimating Software Systems and Localized Price Databases

Most property claims in North America are estimated using specialized estimating software systems, primarily Xactimate (developed by Verisk) and Symbility (a CoreLogic product). Understanding the internal mechanics of these software platforms is essential for public adjusters.

Local Price Databases and Monthly Market Pricing

These platforms do not use static national average prices. Instead, they publish monthly and quarterly localized price databases mapped to specific postal zip codes and metropolitan areas (e.g., separate databases for Chicago Metro, Rockford, Peoria, Springfield, and Southern Illinois). Pricing research teams monitor:

  • Local material retail and distributor surveys;
  • Prevailing union and open-shop trade labor rates;
  • Municipal sales tax rates applied to building materials;

Fuel cost indices and landfill tipping/dump fees.

Catastrophe Demand Surge Pricing

Following severe catastrophic events (such as a tornado or major hail storm), localized demand for materials and skilled labor spikes dramatically. This economic phenomenon—known as demand surge —causes market prices to rise sharply above standard price database rates. Public adjusters must monitor whether carrier adjusters are improperly applying pre-catastrophe price lists that fail to reflect actual post-disaster market realities.

Line-Item Activity Codes and Structural Anatomy

In line-item estimating, every entry combines a category code (the trade, such as DRY for drywall, CLN for cleaning, or PNT for painting), a selector code (the specific item), and an activity code (the operation).

Code Operation Description Cost Inclusions

+ (Replace) Installs new material of like kind and quality. Includes new material cost, delivery, and trade installation labor. Does NOT include tear-out.

- (Remove) Demolishes and disposes of damaged material. Includes labor to tear out, bag, wheel to dumpster, dump fees, and hauling. Material cost is $0.

& (Remove & Replace) Combines demolition and new installation. Full composite unit price: removal labor, disposal fees, new material cost, and installation labor.

R activity (Detach & Reset, often written D&R) Carefully removes undamaged item to access substrate and reinstalls it. Labor to detach undamaged fixture (e.g., light fixture, toilet, door hardware, AC disconnect) and reinstall afterward. Material cost is $0.

CLN category (Cleaning) Decontaminates or washes soot, dust, or biological grime. Specialized restoration labor and chemical cleaning agents.

PNT category (Painting) Prepares and finishes architectural surfaces. Masking, scraping, primer/sealer coat, and one or more finish coats.

Material Waste Factors

Raw building materials must be cut, shaped, and fitted, generating scrap waste. Estimators apply standardized percentage waste factors to gross measurements:

Asphalt Shingle Roofing : 10% on simple gable roofs; 15% to 20% on complex hip, valley, and dormered roofs.

Carpet & Vinyl Sheet : 10% to 15% to account for room roll widths and pattern matches.

Drywall & Siding : 5% to 10% for corner trimming and window cutouts.

Contractor General Overhead and Profit (GCOP / "10 and 10")

A central battleground in property estimating is the application of General Contractor Overhead and Profit (GCOP) , commonly known in the construction and insurance industries as "10 and 10" (10% overhead and 10% profit added to direct construction costs).

Definitions of Overhead and Profit

General Overhead (10%) : The operating costs incurred by a general contractor to maintain their business, which cannot be billed directly to a specific job (e.g., brick-and-mortar office rent, utilities, executive salaries, office staff, licensing fees, software licenses, legal and accounting fees, and general corporate liability insurance).

Contractor Profit (10%) : The fair entrepreneurial return earned by the general contractor for managing project risk, capital investment, and coordination.

Note

General overhead is distinct from job-site overhead (also known as general conditions). Job-site overhead covers expenses directly tied to a specific project—such as on-site temporary power, job-site fencing, portable restrooms, dumpster rentals, and project manager field supervision—which must be included as separate direct line items in addition to GCOP.

Illinois Standards for Applying GCOP

No Illinois statute or Department rule sets a trade-count test for GCOP. The question is whether a general contractor would reasonably be needed to repair the loss. Insurers and adjusters commonly use these industry guidelines:

The repair requires the coordination of three or more distinct construction trades (e.g., roofing, drywall, electrical, and plumbing);

The project involves complex structural, engineering, or life-safety repairs;

The scope requires extensive sequencing, permitting, and municipal code inspections over an extended construction schedule. Direct Reconstruction Costs (Materials + Labor + Equipment) $100,000.00

  • Plus General Overhead (10%) + $10,000.00
  • Subtotal $110,000.00
  • Plus General Contractor Profit (10% on Subtotal) + $11,000.00
  • ────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────
  • Total Replacement Cost Value (RCV) with GCOP $121,000.00
  • GCOP in Actual Cash Value Payments

Some insurers withhold GCOP from the initial ACV payment until the insured actually hires a general contractor. Because Illinois defines residential ACV as replacement cost at the time of loss less depreciation (50 Ill. Adm. Code 919.80(d)(8)(A)), there is a strong argument that when a general contractor would reasonably be needed, GCOP belongs in the replacement cost from which depreciation is subtracted. Courts in different jurisdictions have reached different results, and policy wording matters, so document why a general contractor is reasonably required.

Depreciation Application: Observed Condition vs Chronological Age

Depreciation represents the loss in economic value of an asset over time resulting from physical deterioration, obsolescence, and exposure. Calculating depreciation determines the Actual Cash Value (ACV) payment:

ACV = Replacement Cost Value (RCV) − Depreciation \text{ACV} = \text{Replacement Cost Value (RCV)} - \text{Depreciation} ACV = Replacement Cost Value (RCV) − Depreciation

Two Competing Approaches to Depreciation

Chronological / Straight-Line Table Method (Insurer Preference) : Depreciation % = Actual Age of Item Theoretical Useful Life Expectancy \text{Depreciation \%} = \frac{\text{Actual Age of Item}}{\text{Theoretical Useful Life Expectancy}} Depreciation % = Theoretical Useful Life Expectancy Actual Age of Item ​ Flaw : Treats physical assets as theoretical math problems. For example, assuming a 30-year asphalt roof is 15 years old, a carrier adjuster automatically applies 50% depreciation, ignoring whether the roof was in pristine condition, shaded from UV light, and well-maintained.

Actual Observed Physical Condition (Public Adjuster Advocacy) :

Depreciation is calculated based on the asset's effective age and observable physical maintenance. An item that has been meticulously maintained, cleaned, and protected exhibits far less physical deterioration than its chronological age suggests. Public adjusters argue for effective age reductions to protect policyholder equity.

Recoverable vs Non-Recoverable Depreciation

Recoverable Depreciation : Under replacement cost policies, the difference between RCV and ACV is initially withheld by the carrier. Once the policyholder completes the repairs and submits contractor invoices proving incurred expenses, the withheld depreciation is paid out (up to the actual incurred amount or the RCV cap).

Non-Recoverable Depreciation : Depreciation applied to property insured strictly on an ACV basis, personal property subject to specific limitations, or items where the policyholder elects not to replace or repair the damaged property.

The Labor Depreciation Debate: Illinois Law ( Sproull v. State Farm )

One of the most consequential legal issues in property adjusting is whether an insurance company may depreciate the cost of labor when determining Actual Cash Value.

The Legal Controversy

When replacing a damaged roof, the total cost comprises materials (shingles, felt, nails) and labor (tear-off and installation). Insurers historically depreciated both materials and labor, arguing that the "entire finished product" depreciates. Policyholders argued that labor is an intangible service that does not rust, rot, decay, or wear out over time.

The Landmark Illinois Supreme Court Precedent

In Sproull v. State Farm Fire & Casualty Co. , 2021 IL 126446, the Illinois Supreme Court addressed this issue under Illinois law. The court answered a certified question about a homeowners policy that did not define ACV, read together with the Illinois rule that ACV is replacement cost less depreciation (50 Ill. Adm. Code 919.80(d)(8)(A)). Finding the term ambiguous, the court construed it in the insured's favor: the insurer may not depreciate labor costs in calculating ACV.

Practical Application for Public Adjusters

The Sproull decision significantly increases ACV cash flows to Illinois policyholders:

If a roof replacement costs $20,000 ($10,000 materials + $10,000 labor) and the roof is 50% physically depreciated:

Improper Carrier Calculation (Depreciating Labor) : Deducts 50% from both materials ($5,000) and labor ($5,000) = Total Depreciation $10,000. ACV payment = $10,000.

Proper Illinois Calculation under Sproull : Deducts 50% from materials only ($5,000) and $0 from labor = Total Depreciation $5,000. ACV payment = $15,000.

Important

Public adjusters in Illinois must audit every carrier estimate to ensure the software's "Depreciate Labor" checkbox is toggled OFF. Depreciating labor under a policy that does not define ACV to allow it conflicts with Sproull and reduces the funds the policyholder needs to start repairs.

Preparing the Proof of Loss and Statement of Loss

The culmination of the estimating process is the preparation of the formal claim accounting documents submitted to the insurer:

Statement of Loss : An itemized accounting summary breaking down RCV, material depreciation, non-recoverable depreciation, ACV, applicable deductibles, policy sub-limit caps, prior advance payments, and net claim amounts due across each coverage division (Coverage A, B, C, and D).

Sworn Statement in Proof of Loss : A formal, notarized legal document required under policy conditions (typically due within 60 days of the insurer's written request). It establishes the policyholder's sworn declaration regarding the time and origin of the loss, the insurable interest of the claimant, title encumbrances, all other insurance contracts covering the property, and the net cash amount claimed.

Loading diagram... Illinois Property Claim Financial Waterfall (RCV to Final Settlement)