Study guide

3.10 Decision Making & Data Analysis in Reasoning

Coal India Management Trainee CIL MT

Track your progress as you read

Finished sections get a check mark.

1 Chapter 1: CIL MT Exam Overview & Coal Sector Landscape

1.1 CIL MT Exam Pattern, Marking Scheme & Strategy 1.2 Coal India Limited: Corporate Structure, Maharatna Status & Subsidiaries 1.3 Indian Coal Mining Sector, Energy Mix & Environmental Regulations

2 Chapter 2: Paper-I General Awareness, Polity & Current Affairs

2.1 Indian Constitution, Governance & Statutory Bodies 2.2 Indian Economy, Union Budget & Economic Planning 2.3 Indian Geography, Mineral Belts & Environmental Ecology 2.4 Modern Indian History, Freedom Struggle & Cultural Heritage 2.5 General Science: Physics, Chemistry & Biology Fundamentals 2.6 Inventions, Discoveries & Scientific-Technological Development 2.7 Uses of Internet, Computer Awareness & Digital Governance 2.8 National & International Organisations 2.9 Awards, Honours & Sports 2.10 Books & Authors, Important Monuments & Places of India 2.11 Ports, Power Plants & Infrastructure of India 2.12 Climate Change, SDGs, National Parks & Wildlife Sanctuaries 2.13 Flagship Government Programmes & Current Affairs Method 2.14 World Physical, Social & Economic Geography

3 Chapter 3: Paper-I Reasoning & Logical Ability

3.1 Series Completion, Coding-Decoding & Semantic Analogies 3.2 Syllogisms, Logical Deduction & Venn Diagrams 3.3 Seating Arrangements, Linear/Circular Alignments & Puzzles 3.4 Direction Sense, Blood Relations & Order/Ranking 3.5 Alphabetical & Alphanumeric Series 3.6 Statement & Conclusions, Statement & Arguments 3.7 Clocks & Calendars 3.8 Cubes, Dice & Figure Counting 3.9 Mirror Images, Water Images, Embedded Figures & Non-Verbal Series 3.10 Decision Making & Data Analysis in Reasoning

4 Chapter 4: Paper-I Numerical Ability & Quantitative Aptitude

4.1 Arithmetic Foundations: Percentages, Profit & Loss, Ratio & Proportion 4.2 Averages, Simple/Compound Interest, Alligations & Mixtures 4.3 Time & Work, Pipes & Cisterns, Time, Speed & Distance 4.4 Algebra, Mensuration, Geometry & Data Interpretation (DI) 4.5 Number System, LCM, HCF & Decimal Fractions 4.6 Surds, Indices & Simplification 4.7 Problems on Ages 4.8 Boats & Streams and Problems on Trains 4.9 Permutations & Combinations 4.10 Probability for Quantitative Aptitude

5 Chapter 5: Paper-I General English & Verbal Ability

5.1 English Grammar, Error Spotting & Sentence Correction 5.2 Vocabulary Building: Synonyms, Antonyms, Idioms & Phrases 5.3 Reading Comprehension, Cloze Tests & Para Jumbles 5.4 Fill in the Blanks, Cloze Passages & Sentence Completion 5.5 Jumbled Sentences & Sentence Improvement

6 Chapter 6: Paper-II Engineering Mathematics

6.1 Matrix Algebra, Rank & Systems of Linear Equations 6.2 Eigenvalues, Eigenvectors & the Cayley-Hamilton Theorem 6.3 Limits, Continuity, Differentiability & Mean Value Theorems 6.4 Maxima-Minima, Indeterminate Forms & Taylor Series 6.5 Definite, Improper, Double & Triple Integrals 6.6 Partial Derivatives, Total Derivative & Multivariable Optimisation 6.7 First-Order Differential Equations: Linear & Non-Linear 6.8 Higher-Order Linear Differential Equations & Engineering Applications 6.9 Laplace Transforms & Transfer-Function Methods 6.10 Probability, Conditional Probability & Bayes' Theorem 6.11 Random Variables, Distributions & Descriptive Statistics 6.12 Numerical Methods: Root Finding, Integration & ODE Solvers

7 Chapter 7: Paper-II Engineering Mechanics & Statics-Dynamics

7.1 Force Systems, Coplanar Equilibrium & Lami's Theorem 7.2 Plane Trusses, Friction Mechanics & Screws/Wedges 7.3 Centroids, Center of Gravity & Moment of Inertia 7.4 Kinematics, Kinetics of Particles & Rigid Body Dynamics 7.5 Virtual Work & Lagrange's Equation 7.6 Rolling Friction, Belt-Pulley Drives, Brakes, Clutches & Vehicle Dynamics

8 Chapter 8: Paper-II Mechanics of Materials & Structural Integrity

8.1 Simple Stresses, Strains, Elastic Moduli & Thermal Stresses 8.2 Principal Stresses, Strain Energy & Mohr's Circle 8.3 Shear Force & Bending Moment Diagrams, Beam Bending & Shear Stresses 8.4 Torsion of Circular Shafts, Springs & Column Buckling 8.5 Thin Cylinders, Spheres & Thick-Walled Pressure Vessels 8.6 Deflection of Beams: Double Integration, Macaulay & Moment-Area 8.7 Shear Centre & Unsymmetrical Bending 8.8 Strain Gauges, Rosettes & Experimental Stress Analysis 8.9 Mechanical Testing: Universal Testing Machine, Hardness & Impact

9 Chapter 9: Paper-II Theory of Machines & Mechanical Vibrations

9.1 Simple Mechanisms, Kinematic Inversions & Velocity/Acceleration Diagrams 9.2 Cams & Followers, Toothed Gearing & Epicyclic Gear Trains 9.3 Flywheels, Centrifugal/Inertia Governors & Rotor Balancing 9.4 Free, Damped & Forced Single-Degree-of-Freedom Vibrations 9.5 Gyroscopic Couple & Gyroscopic Effects

10 Chapter 10: Paper-II Machine Design & Failure Theories

10.1 Static Failure Theories & Variable/Fatigue Loading 10.2 Design of Threaded Fasteners, Welded & Riveted Joints 10.3 Design of Shafts, Keys, Couplings & Rolling/Sliding Bearings 10.4 Design of Spur, Helical, Bevel & Worm Gears 10.5 Design of Helical, Leaf & Torsion Springs 10.6 Design of Brakes & Clutches: Energy, Lining Pressure & Heat

11 Chapter 11: Paper-II Fluid Mechanics & Hydraulic Machinery

11.1 Fluid Properties, Hydrostatic Forces & Buoyancy 11.2 Fluid Kinematics, Continuity & Bernoulli's Equation 11.3 Viscous Flow in Pipes, Boundary Layer & Minor Losses 11.4 Hydraulic Turbines, Centrifugal & Reciprocating Pumps 11.5 Dimensional Analysis, Similitude & Model Testing 11.6 Control-Volume Analysis: Continuity, Momentum & Energy

12 Chapter 12: Paper-II Thermodynamics, Thermal Cycles & Turbomachinery

12.1 Fundamental Concepts, First & Second Laws of Thermodynamics 12.2 Entropy, Availability, Exergy & Properties of Pure Substances 12.3 Air-Standard Gas Power Cycles: Otto, Diesel, Dual & Brayton 12.4 Vapour Power Cycles: Ideal, Reheat & Regenerative Rankine Cycles 12.5 Thermodynamic Relations: Maxwell, Clausius-Clapeyron & Joule-Thomson 12.6 Behaviour of Ideal & Real Gases and Equations of State 12.7 Air & Gas Compressors: Reciprocating, Rotary & Multi-Stage 12.8 Steam & Gas Turbines: Impulse, Reaction & Velocity Diagrams

13 Chapter 13: Paper-II Heat Transfer, Refrigeration & Air Conditioning

13.1 Steady & Unsteady Conduction, Extended Surfaces (Fins) 13.2 Forced/Natural Convection, Radiation & Heat Exchanger LMTD/NTU 13.3 Vapour Compression & Vapour Absorption Refrigeration Systems 13.4 Psychrometric Properties, Processes & Air Conditioning Systems 13.5 Gas Refrigeration, Heat Pump Cycles & Cryogenics

14 Chapter 14: Paper-II Materials Science, Metallurgy & Manufacturing Technology

14.1 Crystal Structures, Phase Diagrams & Iron-Iron Carbide Equilibrium 14.2 Heat Treatment Processes & Engineering Alloy Steels 14.3 Casting Processes, Metal Forming & Welding Metallurgy 14.4 Metal Cutting Mechanics, Tool Life & Machine Tools 14.5 Plastic Deformation, Yield Criteria & Load Estimation in Bulk Forming 14.6 Sheet Metal Forming: Shearing, Bending & Deep Drawing 14.7 Powder Metallurgy 14.8 Brazing, Soldering & Adhesive Bonding 14.9 Non-Traditional Machining: EDM, ECM, USM, AJM, LBM & EBM 14.10 Abrasive Machining, Grinding & Superfinishing 14.11 Principles of Work Holding, Jigs & Fixtures 14.12 Economics of Machining & Tool Life Optimisation

15 Chapter 15: Paper-II Metrology, Quality Control & Industrial Engineering / OR

15.1 Limits, Fits, Tolerances, Gauges & Surface Metrology 15.2 Production Planning, Forecasting & Inventory Control Models 15.3 Operations Research: Linear Programming & Transportation/Assignment 15.4 Project Management: CPM, PERT, Network Analysis & Crashing 15.5 Comparators & Interferometry 15.6 Coordinate Measuring Machines & Machine Tool Alignment Testing 15.7 Computer Integrated Manufacturing: CAD/CAM & Integration Tools 15.8 NC/CNC Machines & CNC Part Programming 15.9 Material Requirements Planning, Scheduling & Sequencing 15.10 Queuing Theory & Simple Queuing Models 15.11 Network Flow Models: Shortest Route, Maximal Flow & Spanning Tree

3.10 Decision Making & Data Analysis in Reasoning

Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI

Decision Making and Data Analysis with charts, tables and graphs are the final two bullets of the CIL Paper-I Logical Reasoning syllabus.

In decision-making items every stated condition must be checked against every candidate, and the exceptions clause is applied only after the main conditions have failed.

The commonest trap is a candidate who satisfies every condition except one, where a stated exception then routes the case to a different authority rather than rejecting it.

Reasoning-based data analysis differs from arithmetic data interpretation in that the answer usually depends on ranking, comparison or sufficiency rather than on computing an exact value.

Last updated: August 2026

Part 1: Decision Making

A decision-making item gives a set of eligibility conditions , one or more exception clauses , and then several candidate cases . For each case you choose one of five standard responses: the candidate is selected; is not selected; the case is referred to a higher authority; data are inadequate; or some other stated routing.

The condition-matrix method

This is the only reliable approach under time pressure.

List the conditions vertically as C1, C2, C3 and so on, before reading any case.

List the exceptions separately , noting exactly which condition each exception relaxes and where it routes the case.

For each candidate, tick or cross every condition in order .

If all conditions are satisfied, the candidate qualifies.

If exactly one condition fails, check whether an exception covers that specific condition. If it does, apply the routing the exception specifies. If it does not, the candidate is rejected.

If two or more conditions fail, the candidate is rejected regardless of exceptions, unless the question says otherwise.

If any condition cannot be evaluated because the case omits the relevant fact, the answer is data inadequate .

Worked example

Conditions for selection as Management Trainee (Mechanical): C1. Holds a B.E. or B.Tech in Mechanical Engineering with at least 60% marks.

C2. Is not more than 30 years of age as on the cut-off date.

C3. Has secured the qualifying marks in both papers of the CBT.

Exceptions: E1. If C2 fails but the candidate belongs to a category entitled to age relaxation, refer the case to the Recruitment Head.

E2. If C1 fails only on the percentage but the candidate holds a postgraduate degree in the same discipline, refer to the General Manager (HR).

Case: Anand holds a B.Tech in Mechanical Engineering with 58% marks and an M.Tech in Mechanical Engineering. He is 27 years old and has qualified in both papers.

Work the matrix: C1 fails on percentage; C2 passes; C3 passes. Exactly one condition fails, and E2 addresses precisely that failure while Anand holds the required postgraduate degree. The correct response is therefore refer to the General Manager (HR) — not rejection.

This is the archetypal trap. Candidates who stop at "58% is below 60%" mark rejection and lose the mark.

Discipline points

Read all conditions before any case. Reading case-first causes conditions to be missed.

Note whether conditions are joined by and or or . An or condition needs only one branch satisfied.

Watch cut-off dates and the phrase as on , which fixes the reference date.

Never import a real-world assumption. If the case does not state a category, you may not assume one.

Part 2: Data Analysis in Reasoning

The syllabus lists Data Analysis - Charts, Tables, Graphs under Logical Reasoning as well as listing data interpretation arithmetic under Quantitative Aptitude. The reasoning version differs in emphasis: it asks about ranking, comparison, consistency and sufficiency rather than about computing an exact figure. Detailed arithmetic technique for percentages, averages and ratios in charts is covered in the Numerical Ability chapter; this section covers the reasoning layer.

Reading a table efficiently

Before answering anything, spend fifteen seconds on the structure:

What do the rows represent, and what do the columns represent?

What are the units? Tonnes, lakh tonnes and million tonnes are not interchangeable, and a mismatch is a deliberate trap.

Is any row a total or an average? Totals must not be double counted in a sum.

Are any cells blank or marked as not available? These usually make a related question data-inadequate.

Comparison without computation

Most reasoning-flavoured questions can be answered by comparison rather than calculation.

  • Question type Shortcut
  • Which entity had the largest increase? Compare differences, not ratios

Which had the largest percentage increase? Compare the ratio of change to base; a small base inflates the percentage

  • Which was consistently above average? Compute the average once, then scan
  • In how many years did X exceed Y? Scan the two columns side by side and count
  • Which entity ranked second in both years? Rank each column separately, then intersect

The single most exploited confusion is between absolute increase and percentage increase . An entity rising from 10 to 15 has an absolute increase of 5 and a percentage increase of 50%; one rising from 100 to 120 has a larger absolute increase of 20 but a smaller percentage increase of 20%. Read which one the question asks for.

Worked example

Coal despatch by four subsidiaries, in million tonnes:

  • Subsidiary Year 1 Year 2
  • P 120 138
  • Q 80 96
  • R 150 165
  • S 60 75

Which subsidiary recorded the highest percentage growth?

Compute growth ratios rather than differences: P grows by 18 on 120, which is 15%; Q by 16 on 80, which is 20%; R by 15 on 150, which is 10%; S by 15 on 60, which is 25% . The answer is S , even though R had the largest absolute despatch and P the largest absolute increase.

Which had the largest absolute increase? That is P , with 18. The two questions have different answers from the same table, which is precisely why the distinction matters.

Data sufficiency

A data-sufficiency item gives a question and two statements, asking whether the statements suffice. The standard procedure:

Evaluate statement I alone . Is the question answered?

Evaluate statement II alone , deliberately forgetting statement I.

Only if neither alone suffices, evaluate them together .

Choose among: I alone is sufficient; II alone is sufficient; either alone is sufficient; both together are needed; both together are still insufficient.

The discipline that matters is step 2 — candidates routinely carry information from statement I into their assessment of statement II and wrongly conclude that II alone suffices. Cover statement I physically on the screen if that helps.

Note also that you are asked only whether the question can be answered, not what the answer is. Recognising that a unique value is determined is enough; computing it wastes time.