Study guide
4.3 Rule of Alligation, Removal-Replacement Mixtures & Partnership Capital-Time Sharing
RRB Section Controller 2026: Free Written CBT Study Guide Exam
Track your progress as you read
Finished sections get a check mark.
1 Chapter 1: Exam Overview & Operational Profile
1.1 Written CBT Pattern, Scoring & Selection 1.2 Eligibility, Documents & A-2 Medical Requirements
2 Chapter 2: Number Systems & Arithmetic Foundations
2.1 Number Systems, Divisibility Rules, Prime Factorization & Remainder Theorem 2.2 Unit Digits, Cyclicity Rules & Power Modulo Calculations 2.3 HCF and LCM Properties, Prime Factorization & Practical Word Problems 2.4 Fractions, Decimals, Surds, Indices & BODMAS Simplification
3 Chapter 3: Commercial Arithmetic: Percentages, Profit & Rates
3.1 Percentages, Fractional Equivalents, Successive Variations & Population Formulas 3.2 Cost Price, Selling Price, Profit/Loss Percentage, Dishonest Dealer & Discount Schemes 3.3 Simple Interest, Compound Interest Formulas, Annual/Semi-Annual Compounding & Difference Traps
4 Chapter 4: Ratios, Proportions, Mixtures & Partnerships
4.1 Ratios, Duplicate/Sub-Duplicate Ratios, Direct and Inverse Variations & Proportional Sharing 4.2 Averages, Change in Average, Batsman/Bowling Averages & Replacement Problems 4.3 Rule of Alligation, Removal-Replacement Mixtures & Partnership Capital-Time Sharing
5 Chapter 5: Motion Dynamics, Time, Distance & Train Logistics
5.1 Time, Speed, Distance Relations, Average Speed & Unit Conversions 5.2 Train Problems: Passing Poles, Platforms, Moving Objects & Relative Speed in Opposite/Same Directions 5.3 Upstream, Downstream Boat Velocity, Still Water Speed & Circular Track Races
6 Chapter 6: Work Efficiency, Pipes & Operational Scheduling
6.1 Individual and Group Work, Efficiency Ratios, Work Equivalences & Mandays Formula 6.2 Alternate Day Working, Negative Work & Wage Distribution Based on Work Done 6.3 Inlet and Outlet Pipes, Net Filling Rate, Alternating Flow & Tank Leakage Problems
7 Chapter 7: Algebra, Linear Equations & Progressions
7.1 Algebraic Identities, Polynomial Factorization & Systems of Linear Equations in Two Variables 7.2 Quadratic Equations, Nature of Roots, Discriminant Analysis & Maximum/Minimum Values 7.3 Arithmetic Progressions (AP), General Term, Sum of n Terms & Sequence Modeling
8 Chapter 8: Mensuration: 2D Areas & 3D Solids
8.1 Lines, Angles, Triangle Theorems, Congruence/Similarity & Circle Tangent Properties 8.2 Perimeter and Area of Quadrilaterals, Polygons, Circles & Shaded Region Problems 8.3 Surface Area and Volume of Cubes, Cuboids, Cylinders, Cones, Spheres & Melting-Recasting Solids
9 Chapter 9: Statistics, Probability & Data Interpretation
9.1 Mean, Median, Mode, Range, Mean Deviation & Standard Deviation 9.2 Permutations, Combinations, Classical Probability, Independent Events & Odds 9.3 Tabular Data Interpretation, Bar Charts, Grouped Graphs & Percentage Calculation Shortcuts 9.4 Pie Charts (Angle vs Percentage), Line Trend Graphs & Quantitative Data Sufficiency
10 Chapter 10: Multi-Source & Graphical Analysis
10.1 Multi-Source Analysis, Set Data & Arrangement 10.2 Scatter Plots, Histograms & Distribution Curves
11 Chapter 11: Deductive Logic, Statements & Binary Puzzles
11.1 Syllogisms, Sets & Possibility Conclusions 11.2 Critical Reasoning: Implicit Assumptions, Strong vs Weak Arguments & Course of Action 11.3 Binary Logic: Truth-Tellers, Liars, Alternators & Matrix Logic Deductions
12 Chapter 12: Relational, Directional, Clock & Calendar Reasoning
12.1 Direct Family Relations, Coded Blood Relations & Family Tree Tree-Mapping Methods 12.2 Cardinal & Ordinal Directions, Multi-Step Turn Paths, Pythagorean Distance & Shadow Timing 12.3 Clock Hands Angular Speed, Angle Between Hands at Given Time, Coincidence & Faulty Clocks 12.4 Odd Days Concept, Reference Date Calculations, Leap Year Rules & Repeating Calendar Years
13 Chapter 13: English Reading Comprehension
13.1 English Comprehension: Main Idea, Support & Inference 13.2 English Comprehension: Application, Structure & Style
14 Chapter 14: Mental Reasoning: Analogies & Series
14.1 Semantic, Letter & Number Analogies 14.2 Number Series: Differences, Powers & Missing Terms 14.3 Interleaved, Recursive & Wrong-Term Series
15 Chapter 15: Mental Reasoning: Coding & Ranking
15.1 Letter Shifts, Reversal & Numerical Codes 15.2 Message Intersections & Conditional Coding Tables 15.3 Ranking, People Between & Position Interchanges
16 Chapter 16: Mental Reasoning: Seating Arrangements
16.1 Linear Seating & Parallel Rows 16.2 Circular Seating, Facing & Rotational Symmetry
4.3 Rule of Alligation, Removal-Replacement Mixtures & Partnership Capital-Time Sharing
Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI
For a two-component mixture with both components present, alligation gives q c / q d = ( d − m ) / ( m − c ) q_c/q_d=(d-m)/(m-c) q c / q d = ( d − m ) / ( m − c ) with c < m < d c<m<d c < m < d . At an endpoint the mixture contains only the corresponding component.
Alligation applies exclusively to rate-like quantities having an identical unit denominator (cost per kg, concentration per liter, percentage return on capital).
In successive dilution/replacement, starting with pure liquid a and repeatedly replacing b units with water n times, pure liquid remaining equals a * (1 - b/a)^n.
Alloy and solution mixing problems require evaluating the fractional proportion of the key ingredient across containers before applying LCM or alligation bridges.
Under the stipulated capital-time sharing convention, use each partner’s capital multiplied by its duration. Deduct a management allowance first only when the problem specifies that arrangement.
Last updated: October 2026
- The Rule of Alligation: Theory, Diagram & Mathematical Derivation
- Conceptual Etymology and Scope
The term alligation originates from the Latin alligare , meaning "to tie together" or "to bind". It represents a graphical and algebraic technique for determining the proportion in which two ingredients of differing unit prices (or concentrations) must be blended to produce a mixture of an intermediate target price (or concentration).
Mathematical Derivation of Alligation
Let:
- c c c = unit price (or concentration) of the cheaper ingredient
- d d d = unit price (or concentration) of the dearer ingredient
- m m m = mean unit price (or concentration) of the resulting mixture ( c < m < d c < m < d c < m < d )
- q c q_c q c = quantity of the cheaper ingredient
- q d q_d q d = quantity of the dearer ingredient
The total expenditure of the blend is the sum of its individual components: c ⋅ q c + d ⋅ q d = m ( q c + q d ) c \cdot q_c + d \cdot q_d = m (q_c + q_d) c ⋅ q c + d ⋅ q d = m ( q c + q d ) c ⋅ q c + d ⋅ q d = m ⋅ q c + m ⋅ q d c \cdot q_c + d \cdot q_d = m \cdot q_c + m \cdot q_d c ⋅ q c + d ⋅ q d = m ⋅ q c + m ⋅ q d
Rearranging terms to group like quantities: d ⋅ q d − m ⋅ q d = m ⋅ q c − c ⋅ q c d \cdot q_d - m \cdot q_d = m \cdot q_c - c \cdot q_c d ⋅ q d − m ⋅ q d = m ⋅ q c − c ⋅ q c q d ( d − m ) = q c ( m − c ) q_d (d - m) = q_c (m - c) q d ( d − m ) = q c ( m − c ) q c q d = d − m m − c = Dearer Price − Mean Price Mean Price − Cheaper Price \mathbf{\frac{q_c}{q_d} = \frac{d - m}{m - c} = \frac{\text{Dearer Price} - \text{Mean Price}}{\text{Mean Price} - \text{Cheaper Price}}} q d q c = m − c d − m = Mean Price − Cheaper Price Dearer Price − Mean Price
- The Alligation Cross-Subtraction Diagram Cheaper Price (c) Dearer Price (d)
- \ /
- \ /
- --> Mean Price (m) <---
- / \
- / \
- Quantity of Cheaper (d - m) : Quantity of Dearer (m - c)
- Cardinal Rules for Valid Alligation
Identical Dimensional Baselines: All three rates ( c , d , m c, d, m c , d , m ) must share identical reference denominators. You can alligate cost per kilogram with cost per kilogram, or speed in km/h \text{km/h} km/h with speed in km/h \text{km/h} km/h . You cannot alligate cost per liter with cost per kilogram.
Bounded Mean Value: The mean value m m m must lie strictly between the cheaper and dearer inputs: c < m < d c < m < d c < m < d .
Cost Price vs. Selling Price Discipline: If a problem states that the mixture is sold at a specific selling price ( S P SP SP ) yielding a profit of P % P\% P % , you MUST convert S P SP SP to its true Cost Price ( m m m ) before alligating: m = S P 1 + P 100 = S P × 100 100 + P \mathbf{m = \frac{SP}{1 + \frac{P}{100}} = \frac{SP \times 100}{100 + P}} m = 1 + 100 P SP = 100 + P SP × 100
Warning
Never alligate cost prices of raw ingredients directly with the selling price of the mixture. Doing so embeds an artificial profit margin into the physical ratio, completely invalidating the result.
For these liquid models, assume complete uniform mixing before each withdrawal, additive volumes, no chemical reaction and 0 < b < a 0<b<a 0 < b < a .
Successive Replacement and Progressive Dilution
A classic railway quantitative pattern involves progressive drainage and dilution: a container initially holds pure fluid (such as transformer cooling oil, locomotive lubricant, or chemical weed killer), and a fixed volume is repeatedly drawn off and replaced with an adulterant (typically water or solvent). Progressive Dilution Mechanics:
Stage 0: Pure Liquid = a
Draw 'b' units of mixture, replace with 'b' units of water.
Each extraction removes a fraction (b/a) of the remaining pure liquid.
- After n operations, Pure Liquid remaining = a * (1 - b/a)^n
- The Governing Repeated-Dilution Formula
Let a vessel initially contain a a a units of pure liquid. If b b b units of the mixture are drawn off and replaced with pure water, and this operation is repeated n n n times in total, the quantity of pure liquid remaining in the vessel is: Q pure = a ( 1 − b a ) n \mathbf{Q_{\text{pure}} = a \left(1 - \frac{b}{a}\right)^n} Q pure = a ( 1 − a b ) n Q pure Total Vessel Volume ( a ) = ( 1 − b a ) n \mathbf{\frac{Q_{\text{pure}}}{\text{Total Vessel Volume } (a)} = \left(1 - \frac{b}{a}\right)^n} Total Vessel Volume ( a ) Q pure = ( 1 − a b ) n
Evaluating the Adulterant (Water) Quantity
Because the total volume of liquid in the vessel remains constant at a a a units throughout all n n n replacement cycles: Q water = a − Q pure = a [ 1 − ( 1 − b a ) n ] Q_{\text{water}} = a - Q_{\text{pure}} = a \left[1 - \left(1 - \frac{b}{a}\right)^n\right] Q water = a − Q pure = a [ 1 − ( 1 − a b ) n ] Q pure Q water = ( 1 − b a ) n 1 − ( 1 − b a ) n \mathbf{\frac{Q_{\text{pure}}}{Q_{\text{water}}} = \frac{\left(1 - \frac{b}{a}\right)^n}{1 - \left(1 - \frac{b}{a}\right)^n}} Q water Q pure = 1 − ( 1 − a b ) n ( 1 − a b ) n
Tip
Inversion Shortcut: If a question gives the final ratio of pure liquid to water after n n n operations as p : q p : q p : q , the ratio of pure liquid to total mixture is p p + q \frac{p}{p + q} p + q p . Set this equal to ( 1 − b a ) n \left(1 - \frac{b}{a}\right)^n ( 1 − a b ) n and take the n th n^{\text{th}} n th root to solve for a a a or b b b directly.
Solution Blending and Alloy Composition Merging
When combining two distinct pre-mixed solutions or metal alloys (e.g., bronze or brass bearings in railway wagon wheelsets), candidates must determine the final composition ratio of the combined bulk.
Method 1: Fractional Concentration Aggregation
Let Vessel 1 contain liquid A A A and liquid B B B in ratio x 1 : y 1 x_1 : y_1 x 1 : y 1 , with volume V 1 V_1 V 1 . Let Vessel 2 contain liquids A A A and B B B in ratio x 2 : y 2 x_2 : y_2 x 2 : y 2 , with volume V 2 V_2 V 2 :
Amount of A A A from Vessel 1: A 1 = V 1 ( x 1 x 1 + y 1 ) A_1 = V_1 \left(\frac{x_1}{x_1 + y_1}\right) A 1 = V 1 ( x 1 + y 1 x 1 )
Amount of A A A from Vessel 2: A 2 = V 2 ( x 2 x 2 + y 2 ) A_2 = V_2 \left(\frac{x_2}{x_2 + y_2}\right) A 2 = V 2 ( x 2 + y 2 x 2 )
Combined volume of A A A : A total = A 1 + A 2 A_{\text{total}} = A_1 + A_2 A total = A 1 + A 2
Combined volume of B B B : B total = ( V 1 + V 2 ) − A total B_{\text{total}} = (V_1 + V_2) - A_{\text{total}} B total = ( V 1 + V 2 ) − A total
- Final ratio: A total : B total A_{\text{total}} : B_{\text{total}} A total : B total
- Method 2: LCM Equalization Shortcut (For Equal Mixing)
When equal volumes of two mixtures are blended:
Note total parts in Vessel 1 ( S 1 = x 1 + y 1 S_1 = x_1 + y_1 S 1 = x 1 + y 1 ) and Vessel 2 ( S 2 = x 2 + y 2 S_2 = x_2 + y_2 S 2 = x 2 + y 2 ).
Find L = LCM ( S 1 , S 2 ) L = \text{LCM}(S_1, S_2) L = LCM ( S 1 , S 2 ) .
Multiply ratio terms of Vessel 1 by L S 1 \frac{L}{S_1} S 1 L , and Vessel 2 by L S 2 \frac{L}{S_2} S 2 L .
Sum the scaled antecedents and consequents directly.
Mixture Source Initial Ratio ( A : B A : B A : B ) Total Parts Multiplier ( L = 35 L = 35 L = 35 ) Scaled Ratio
- Container 1 3 : 2 3 : 2 3 : 2 5 5 5 × 7 \times 7 × 7 21 : 14 21 : 14 21 : 14
- Container 2 4 : 3 4 : 3 4 : 3 7 7 7 × 5 \times 5 × 5 20 : 15 20 : 15 20 : 15
Combined Mixture — — — ( 21 + 20 ) : ( 14 + 15 ) = 41 : 29 (21 + 20) : (14 + 15) = 41 : 29 ( 21 + 20 ) : ( 14 + 15 ) = 41 : 29
Commercial Partnership Mathematics
In railway commercial ventures, freight siding leases, container depot consortiums, and station food court concessions, multiple partners pool financial capital over varying tenures. Partnership arithmetic allocates net commercial profits or losses among stakeholders in proportion to their effective investment.
The Stipulated Capital-Time Sharing Rule
Use capital-time profit sharing only when the question states or adopts that convention. Actual partnership agreements can specify other shares; this is an aptitude model, not a general legal rule.
Profit distribution is directly proportional to both the magnitude of financial capital invested ( C C C ) and the time duration ( T T T ) for which that capital remains active in the enterprise: Profit Ratio = ( C A × T A ) : ( C B × T B ) : ( C C × T C ) \mathbf{\text{Profit Ratio} = (C_A \times T_A) : (C_B \times T_B) : (C_C \times T_C)} Profit Ratio = ( C A × T A ) : ( C B × T B ) : ( C C × T C )
Types of Commercial Partnerships
Simple Partnership: All partners invest capital for identical durations ( T A = T B = T C T_A = T_B = T_C T A = T B = T C ). Profit distributes strictly according to capital: P A : P B : P C = C A : C B : C C P_A : P_B : P_C = C_A : C_B : C_C P A : P B : P C = C A : C B : C C
Compound (Complex) Partnership: Partners invest differing capital amounts for differing time durations. Profit distributes according to capital-time products: P A : P B : P C = ( C A T A ) : ( C B T B ) : ( C C T C ) P_A : P_B : P_C = (C_A T_A) : (C_B T_B) : (C_C T_C) P A : P B : P C = ( C A T A ) : ( C B T B ) : ( C C T C )
Variable / Staggered Capital Investments: When partners inject or withdraw funds during the financial year, compute the effective capital-months: C effective = ∑ ( C i × t i ) \mathbf{C_{\text{effective}} = \sum (C_i \times t_i)} C effective = ∑ ( C i × t i )
Working (Active) vs. Sleeping (Silent) Partners
Sleeping Partner: Provides capital only, performing no operational duties.
Working Partner: Contributes capital (or expertise) and actively manages day-to-day operations. As compensation, the working partner receives an agreed salary, management allowance, or commission percentage deducted from gross profit before remaining net profits are divided in the capital-time ratio. Profit Distribution Architecture with a Working Partner:
- [Gross Annual Profit: P_gross]
- |
- v
- [Deduct: Working Partner Management Allowance (M = alpha * P_gross)]
- |
- v
- [Remaining Net Distributable Profit: P_net = P_gross - M]
- |
- v
- [Divide P_net among Partners in (C * T) Ratio]
- |
- +---> Working Partner Final Income = M + Share of P_net
- +---> Sleeping Partner Final Income = Share of P_net only
- Comprehensive Worked Operational Problems
- Worked Problem 1: Alligation in Locomotive Diesel Fuel Blending
Scenario: A railway fueling depot blends bio-diesel costing ₹84 per liter with premium high-speed diesel costing ₹96 per liter. The resulting fuel blend is supplied to a private siding freight operator at ₹99 per liter, realizing a profit of 10 % 10\% 10% . In what ratio must the fueling depot mix the bio-diesel and high-speed diesel?
Step-by-Step Mathematical Resolution:
Determine the True Cost Price ( m m m ) of the Mixture: The selling price of ₹99 includes a 10 % 10\% 10% profit margin. m = S P 1 + P 100 = 99 1 + 0.10 = 99 1.10 = INR 90 per liter m = \frac{SP}{1 + \frac{P}{100}} = \frac{99}{1 + 0.10} = \frac{99}{1.10} = \text{INR } 90\text{ per liter} m = 1 + 100 P SP = 1 + 0.10 99 = 1.10 99 = INR 90 per liter
Identify Alligation Parameters:
- Cheaper component ( c c c ) [Bio-diesel]: ₹ 84 84 84 /L
- Dearer component ( d d d ) [High-speed diesel]: ₹ 96 96 96 /L
- Mean cost price ( m m m ): ₹ 90 90 90 /L
Apply the Rule of Alligation: q c q d = d − m m − c \frac{q_c}{q_d} = \frac{d - m}{m - c} q d q c = m − c d − m q bio q high-speed = 96 − 90 90 − 84 = 6 6 = 1 1 \frac{q_{\text{bio}}}{q_{\text{high-speed}}} = \frac{96 - 90}{90 - 84} = \frac{6}{6} = \frac{1}{1} q high-speed q bio = 90 − 84 96 − 90 = 6 6 = 1 1
Conclusion: The depot must mix bio-diesel and high-speed diesel in an exact ratio of 1 : 1 1 : 1 1 : 1 .
Verification: Cost of 1 liter bio-diesel ( INR 84 \text{INR } 84 INR 84 ) + 1 liter high-speed diesel ( INR 96 \text{INR } 96 INR 96 ) = ₹ 180 180 180 for 2 liters, or ₹ 90 90 90 /L. Selling 2 liters at ₹ 99 99 99 /L yields ₹ 198 198 198 . Profit = 198 − 180 = INR 18 = 198 - 180 = \text{INR } 18 = 198 − 180 = INR 18 , which is 18 180 × 100 = 10 % \frac{18}{180} \times 100 = 10\% 180 18 × 100 = 10% (verified).
Worked Problem 2: Successive Replacement in Track Lubricant Drum
Scenario: A maintenance depot drum contains 60 liters of pure synthetic wheel-flange lubricant. An apprentice technician draws off 12 liters of the lubricant and replaces it with standard thinning solvent. This operation is repeated two more times (for a total of 3 cycles). Calculate:
The quantity of pure synthetic lubricant remaining in the drum.
The final ratio of pure lubricant to thinning solvent.
Step-by-Step Mathematical Resolution:
Identify the Given Parameters:
- Initial volume of pure liquid ( a a a ) = 60 liters = 60\text{ liters} = 60 liters
- Volume extracted and replaced in each cycle ( b b b ) = 12 liters = 12\text{ liters} = 12 liters
- Total operational cycles ( n n n ) = 3 = 3 = 3
Compute the Fractional Extraction Factor: b a = 12 60 = 1 5 = 0.20 \frac{b}{a} = \frac{12}{60} = \frac{1}{5} = 0.20 a b = 60 12 = 5 1 = 0.20 1 − b a = 1 − 1 5 = 4 5 = 0.80 1 - \frac{b}{a} = 1 - \frac{1}{5} = \frac{4}{5} = 0.80 1 − a b = 1 − 5 1 = 5 4 = 0.80
Calculate Pure Lubricant Remaining ( Q pure Q_{\text{pure}} Q pure ): Q pure = a ( 1 − b a ) n = 60 × ( 4 5 ) 3 Q_{\text{pure}} = a \left(1 - \frac{b}{a}\right)^n = 60 \times \left(\frac{4}{5}\right)^3 Q pure = a ( 1 − a b ) n = 60 × ( 5 4 ) 3 Q pure = 60 × 64 125 = 12 × 64 25 = 768 25 = 30.72 liters Q_{\text{pure}} = 60 \times \frac{64}{125} = 12 \times \frac{64}{25} = \frac{768}{25} = 30.72\text{ liters} Q pure = 60 × 125 64 = 12 × 25 64 = 25 768 = 30.72 liters
Calculate Volume of Thinning Solvent ( Q solvent Q_{\text{solvent}} Q solvent ): Q solvent = 60 − 30.72 = 29.28 liters Q_{\text{solvent}} = 60 - 30.72 = 29.28\text{ liters} Q solvent = 60 − 30.72 = 29.28 liters
Determine the Final Ratio ( Q pure : Q solvent Q_{\text{pure}} : Q_{\text{solvent}} Q pure : Q solvent ): Q pure Q solvent = 30.72 29.28 = 768 / 25 732 / 25 = 768 732 \frac{Q_{\text{pure}}}{Q_{\text{solvent}}} = \frac{30.72}{29.28} = \frac{768 / 25}{732 / 25} = \frac{768}{732} Q solvent Q pure = 29.28 30.72 = 732/25 768/25 = 732 768
Dividing both numerator and denominator by their greatest common divisor ( 12 12 12 ): 768 / 12 732 / 12 = 64 61 \frac{768 / 12}{732 / 12} = \frac{64}{61} 732/12 768/12 = 61 64
Verification via Direct Proportions: After 3 cycles, pure liquid fraction is ( 4 / 5 ) 3 = 64 / 125 (4/5)^3 = 64/125 ( 4/5 ) 3 = 64/125 . The solvent fraction is 1 − 64 / 125 = 61 / 125 1 - 64/125 = 61/125 1 − 64/125 = 61/125 . The ratio is strictly 64 : 61 64 : 61 64 : 61 .
Worked Problem 3: Multi-Partner Container Siding Venture with Working Partner
Scenario: Two logistics entrepreneurs, Partner A and Partner B, invest in a joint railway container leasing venture:
Partner A invests ₹ 40 , 000 40,000 40 , 000 for the entire 12-month annual period.
Partner B invests ₹ 60 , 000 60,000 60 , 000 , but withdraws from the venture after 8 months.
Partner A actively manages operational dispatching and receives an agreed management allowance of 15 % 15\% 15% of the gross annual profit.
The remaining profit is divided between A and B in proportion to their capital-time investments.
If the gross profit at year-end is ₹ 72 , 000 72,000 72 , 000 , determine the total income received by Partner A and Partner B respectively.
Step-by-Step Mathematical Resolution:
Evaluate Working Partner Management Allowance: M = 15 % × 72 , 000 = 15 100 × 72 , 000 = INR 10 , 800 M = 15\% \times 72,000 = \frac{15}{100} \times 72,000 = \text{INR } 10,800 M = 15% × 72 , 000 = 100 15 × 72 , 000 = INR 10 , 800
Compute Remaining Net Distributable Profit: P net = 72 , 000 − 10 , 800 = INR 61 , 200 P_{\text{net}} = 72,000 - 10,800 = \text{INR } 61,200 P net = 72 , 000 − 10 , 800 = INR 61 , 200
Calculate Capital-Time Investment Ratios:
Partner A's Capital-Time: C A × T A = 40 , 000 × 12 = 480 , 000 rupee-months C_A \times T_A = 40,000 \times 12 = 480,000\text{ rupee-months} C A × T A = 40 , 000 × 12 = 480 , 000 rupee-months
Partner B's Capital-Time: C B × T B = 60 , 000 × 8 = 480 , 000 rupee-months C_B \times T_B = 60,000 \times 8 = 480,000\text{ rupee-months} C B × T B = 60 , 000 × 8 = 480 , 000 rupee-months
Profit Sharing Ratio: P A : P B = 480 , 000 : 480 , 000 = 1 : 1 P_A : P_B = 480,000 : 480,000 = 1 : 1 P A : P B = 480 , 000 : 480 , 000 = 1 : 1
Divide Net Distributable Profit: Since the ratio is 1 : 1 1 : 1 1 : 1 , each partner receives an equal share of P net P_{\text{net}} P net : A’s share of net profit = 61 , 200 2 = INR 30 , 600 \text{A's share of net profit} = \frac{61,200}{2} = \text{INR } 30,600 A’s share of net profit = 2 61 , 200 = INR 30 , 600 B’s share of net profit = 61 , 200 2 = INR 30 , 600 \text{B's share of net profit} = \frac{61,200}{2} = \text{INR } 30,600 B’s share of net profit = 2 61 , 200 = INR 30 , 600
Calculate Total Income for Each Partner:
Partner A Total Income: Management Allowance + Net Profit Share = 10 , 800 + 30 , 600 = INR 41 , 400 \text{Management Allowance} + \text{Net Profit Share} = 10,800 + 30,600 = \text{INR } 41,400 Management Allowance + Net Profit Share = 10 , 800 + 30 , 600 = INR 41 , 400
Partner B Total Income: Net Profit Share only = INR 30 , 600 \text{Net Profit Share only} = \text{INR } 30,600 Net Profit Share only = INR 30 , 600
Verification: 41 , 400 + 30 , 600 = INR 72 , 000 (matches gross profit exactly) 41,400 + 30,600 = \text{INR } 72,000\text{ (matches gross profit exactly)} 41 , 400 + 30 , 600 = INR 72 , 000 (matches gross profit exactly)
Common Exam Traps & Operational Pitfalls
Trap Description Erroneous Approach Correct Examination Protocol
Direct Alligation with Selling Price Blending CP ingredients using SP as the center value Always divide SP by ( 1 + P / 100 ) (1 + P/100) ( 1 + P /100 ) to find the true Cost Price before alligating.
Denominator Discrepancy Alligating values with different units (e.g., speed per minute with speed per hour) Standardize all units to identical denominators before applying cross-subtraction.
Linear Replacement Fallacy Multiplying single replacement volume by n n n (e.g. 12 × 3 = 36 12 \times 3 = 36 12 × 3 = 36 L removed) Apply exponential decay a ( 1 − b / a ) n a(1 - b/a)^n a ( 1 − b / a ) n ; each cycle extracts from a progressively weaker dilution.
Distributing Gross Profit Directly Dividing gross profit before deducting the working partner's salary First subtract the working partner's management commission, then divide the remainder.