Study guide
4.1 Ratios, Duplicate/Sub-Duplicate Ratios, Direct and Inverse Variations & Proportional Sharing
RRB Section Controller 2026: Free Written CBT Study Guide Exam
Track your progress as you read
Finished sections get a check mark.
1 Chapter 1: Exam Overview & Operational Profile
1.1 Written CBT Pattern, Scoring & Selection 1.2 Eligibility, Documents & A-2 Medical Requirements
2 Chapter 2: Number Systems & Arithmetic Foundations
2.1 Number Systems, Divisibility Rules, Prime Factorization & Remainder Theorem 2.2 Unit Digits, Cyclicity Rules & Power Modulo Calculations 2.3 HCF and LCM Properties, Prime Factorization & Practical Word Problems 2.4 Fractions, Decimals, Surds, Indices & BODMAS Simplification
3 Chapter 3: Commercial Arithmetic: Percentages, Profit & Rates
3.1 Percentages, Fractional Equivalents, Successive Variations & Population Formulas 3.2 Cost Price, Selling Price, Profit/Loss Percentage, Dishonest Dealer & Discount Schemes 3.3 Simple Interest, Compound Interest Formulas, Annual/Semi-Annual Compounding & Difference Traps
4 Chapter 4: Ratios, Proportions, Mixtures & Partnerships
4.1 Ratios, Duplicate/Sub-Duplicate Ratios, Direct and Inverse Variations & Proportional Sharing 4.2 Averages, Change in Average, Batsman/Bowling Averages & Replacement Problems 4.3 Rule of Alligation, Removal-Replacement Mixtures & Partnership Capital-Time Sharing
5 Chapter 5: Motion Dynamics, Time, Distance & Train Logistics
5.1 Time, Speed, Distance Relations, Average Speed & Unit Conversions 5.2 Train Problems: Passing Poles, Platforms, Moving Objects & Relative Speed in Opposite/Same Directions 5.3 Upstream, Downstream Boat Velocity, Still Water Speed & Circular Track Races
6 Chapter 6: Work Efficiency, Pipes & Operational Scheduling
6.1 Individual and Group Work, Efficiency Ratios, Work Equivalences & Mandays Formula 6.2 Alternate Day Working, Negative Work & Wage Distribution Based on Work Done 6.3 Inlet and Outlet Pipes, Net Filling Rate, Alternating Flow & Tank Leakage Problems
7 Chapter 7: Algebra, Linear Equations & Progressions
7.1 Algebraic Identities, Polynomial Factorization & Systems of Linear Equations in Two Variables 7.2 Quadratic Equations, Nature of Roots, Discriminant Analysis & Maximum/Minimum Values 7.3 Arithmetic Progressions (AP), General Term, Sum of n Terms & Sequence Modeling
8 Chapter 8: Mensuration: 2D Areas & 3D Solids
8.1 Lines, Angles, Triangle Theorems, Congruence/Similarity & Circle Tangent Properties 8.2 Perimeter and Area of Quadrilaterals, Polygons, Circles & Shaded Region Problems 8.3 Surface Area and Volume of Cubes, Cuboids, Cylinders, Cones, Spheres & Melting-Recasting Solids
9 Chapter 9: Statistics, Probability & Data Interpretation
9.1 Mean, Median, Mode, Range, Mean Deviation & Standard Deviation 9.2 Permutations, Combinations, Classical Probability, Independent Events & Odds 9.3 Tabular Data Interpretation, Bar Charts, Grouped Graphs & Percentage Calculation Shortcuts 9.4 Pie Charts (Angle vs Percentage), Line Trend Graphs & Quantitative Data Sufficiency
10 Chapter 10: Multi-Source & Graphical Analysis
10.1 Multi-Source Analysis, Set Data & Arrangement 10.2 Scatter Plots, Histograms & Distribution Curves
11 Chapter 11: Deductive Logic, Statements & Binary Puzzles
11.1 Syllogisms, Sets & Possibility Conclusions 11.2 Critical Reasoning: Implicit Assumptions, Strong vs Weak Arguments & Course of Action 11.3 Binary Logic: Truth-Tellers, Liars, Alternators & Matrix Logic Deductions
12 Chapter 12: Relational, Directional, Clock & Calendar Reasoning
12.1 Direct Family Relations, Coded Blood Relations & Family Tree Tree-Mapping Methods 12.2 Cardinal & Ordinal Directions, Multi-Step Turn Paths, Pythagorean Distance & Shadow Timing 12.3 Clock Hands Angular Speed, Angle Between Hands at Given Time, Coincidence & Faulty Clocks 12.4 Odd Days Concept, Reference Date Calculations, Leap Year Rules & Repeating Calendar Years
13 Chapter 13: English Reading Comprehension
13.1 English Comprehension: Main Idea, Support & Inference 13.2 English Comprehension: Application, Structure & Style
14 Chapter 14: Mental Reasoning: Analogies & Series
14.1 Semantic, Letter & Number Analogies 14.2 Number Series: Differences, Powers & Missing Terms 14.3 Interleaved, Recursive & Wrong-Term Series
15 Chapter 15: Mental Reasoning: Coding & Ranking
15.1 Letter Shifts, Reversal & Numerical Codes 15.2 Message Intersections & Conditional Coding Tables 15.3 Ranking, People Between & Position Interchanges
16 Chapter 16: Mental Reasoning: Seating Arrangements
16.1 Linear Seating & Parallel Rows 16.2 Circular Seating, Facing & Rotational Symmetry
4.1 Ratios, Duplicate/Sub-Duplicate Ratios, Direct and Inverse Variations & Proportional Sharing
Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI
A ratio expresses the relative magnitude of two homogeneous quantities; proportion establishes equivalence between two ratios (a:b = c:d iff ad = bc).
Proportional variants include Mean Proportional (sqrt(ab)), Third Proportional (b^2 / a), and Fourth Proportional (bc / a).
Power transformations yield Duplicate (a^2 : b^2), Sub-duplicate (sqrt(a) : sqrt(b)), Triplicate (a^3 : b^3), and Sub-triplicate (cbrt(a) : cbrt(b)) ratios.
The Componendo and Dividendo rule ((a + b)/(a - b) = (c + d)/(c - d)) transforms complex rational expressions without expanding nested fractions.
Direct variation (y proportional to x) and inverse variation (y proportional to 1/x) model physical track capacity, tractive effort, and crew requirements.
Last updated: October 2026
- Fundamental Definitions of Ratio and Proportion
- The Mathematical Concept of Ratio
A ratio is an expression of the relative magnitude of two homogeneous quantities of the same kind, expressed in identical units. For two quantities a a a and b b b (where b ≠ 0 b \neq 0 b = 0 ), the ratio is denoted as: a : b = a b a : b = \frac{a}{b} a : b = b a
The first term a a a is the antecedent .
The second term b b b is the consequent .
Scale Invariance: Multiplying or dividing both terms of a ratio by any non-zero constant k k k leaves the ratio unchanged: a b = k × a k × b = a / k b / k ( k ≠ 0 ) \frac{a}{b} = \frac{k \times a}{k \times b} = \frac{a / k}{b / k} \quad (k \neq 0) b a = k × b k × a = b / k a / k ( k = 0 )
Warning
A ratio is a dimensionless pure number. Quantities compared must strictly share identical physical units. Comparing 45 km/h 45\text{ km/h} 45 km/h to 15 m/s 15\text{ m/s} 15 m/s requires converting 45 km/h = 45 × 5 18 = 12.5 m/s 45\text{ km/h} = 45 \times \frac{5}{18} = 12.5\text{ m/s} 45 km/h = 45 × 18 5 = 12.5 m/s , producing the true ratio 12.5 : 15 = 5 : 6 12.5 : 15 = 5 : 6 12.5 : 15 = 5 : 6 , not 45 : 15 = 3 : 1 45 : 15 = 3 : 1 45 : 15 = 3 : 1 .
The Mathematical Concept of Proportion
A proportion is an equation stating that two ratios are equal. If a b = c d \frac{a}{b} = \frac{c}{d} b a = d c , the four quantities a , b , c , d a, b, c, d a , b , c , d are in proportion, written as: a : b : : c : d or a : b = c : d a : b :: c : d \quad \text{or} \quad a : b = c : d a : b :: c : d or a : b = c : d
Terms a a a and d d d are called the extremes .
Terms b b b and c c c are called the means . a d = b c ⟺ Product of Extremes = Product of Means \mathbf{ad = bc \iff \text{Product of Extremes} = \text{Product of Means}} ad = bc ⟺ Product of Extremes = Product of Means
The displayed root-based proportional formulas use positive quantities. All ratio transformations require their denominators to be nonzero, including newly formed differences in componendo/dividendo.
Proportional Types and Formulas
When quantities are in continuous proportion ( a : b : : b : c a : b :: b : c a : b :: b : c ), term b b b serves as the geometric bridge between a a a and c c c :
Proportional Type Given Terms Mathematical Formulation Explicit Closed Formula
Fourth Proportional ( x x x ) Three quantities: a , b , c a, b, c a , b , c a : b = c : x ⟹ a x = b c a : b = c : x \implies ax = bc a : b = c : x ⟹ a x = b c x = b c a \mathbf{x = \frac{bc}{a}} x = a bc
Third Proportional ( x x x ) Two quantities: a , b a, b a , b a : b = b : x ⟹ a x = b 2 a : b = b : x \implies ax = b^2 a : b = b : x ⟹ a x = b 2 x = b 2 a \mathbf{x = \frac{b^2}{a}} x = a b 2
Mean Proportional ( x x x ) Two quantities: a , b a, b a , b a : x = x : b ⟹ x 2 = a b a : x = x : b \implies x^2 = ab a : x = x : b ⟹ x 2 = ab x = a b \mathbf{x = \sqrt{ab}} x = ab Continuous Proportion Flow: a : b = b : c
- Extremes: a, c ---> Product = a * c
- Means: b, b ---> Product = b^2
- Equating: b^2 = ac ===> b = sqrt(ac)
- Derived and Compounded Ratios
Railway quantitative questions frequently invoke classical power relationships that transform basic ratios:
Compounded Ratio
When two or more ratios are multiplied term-wise, antecedent by antecedent and consequent by consequent, the resulting ratio is the compounded ratio : For ( a : b ) , ( c : d ) , and ( e : f ) , Compounded Ratio = ( a × c × e ) : ( b × d × f ) \text{For } (a : b), (c : d), \text{ and } (e : f), \quad \mathbf{\text{Compounded Ratio} = (a \times c \times e) : (b \times d \times f)} For ( a : b ) , ( c : d ) , and ( e : f ) , Compounded Ratio = ( a × c × e ) : ( b × d × f )
Power and Root Transformations
Duplicate Ratio: The ratio of the squares of the original terms: Duplicate of ( a : b ) = a 2 : b 2 \text{Duplicate of } (a : b) = \mathbf{a^2 : b^2} Duplicate of ( a : b ) = a 2 : b 2
Sub-Duplicate Ratio: The ratio of the square roots of the terms: Sub-duplicate of ( a : b ) = a : b \text{Sub-duplicate of } (a : b) = \mathbf{\sqrt{a} : \sqrt{b}} Sub-duplicate of ( a : b ) = a : b
Triplicate Ratio: The ratio of the cubes of the terms: Triplicate of ( a : b ) = a 3 : b 3 \text{Triplicate of } (a : b) = \mathbf{a^3 : b^3} Triplicate of ( a : b ) = a 3 : b 3
Sub-Triplicate Ratio: The ratio of the cube roots of the terms: Sub-triplicate of ( a : b ) = a 3 : b 3 \text{Sub-triplicate of } (a : b) = \mathbf{\sqrt[3]{a} : \sqrt[3]{b}} Sub-triplicate of ( a : b ) = 3 a : 3 b
Inverse (Reciprocal) Ratio: For a two-term ratio a : b a : b a : b , the inverse is 1 a : 1 b = b : a \frac{1}{a} : \frac{1}{b} = b : a a 1 : b 1 = b : a . For three terms a : b : c a : b : c a : b : c , the reciprocal ratio is: 1 a : 1 b : 1 c = b c : c a : a b \frac{1}{a} : \frac{1}{b} : \frac{1}{c} = \mathbf{bc : ca : ab} a 1 : b 1 : c 1 = bc : ca : ab
Transformation Base Ratio: 4 : 9 4 : 9 4 : 9 Base Ratio: 8 : 27 8 : 27 8 : 27
Duplicate Ratio 4 2 : 9 2 = 16 : 81 4^2 : 9^2 = 16 : 81 4 2 : 9 2 = 16 : 81 8 2 : 27 2 = 64 : 729 8^2 : 27^2 = 64 : 729 8 2 : 2 7 2 = 64 : 729
Sub-Duplicate Ratio 4 : 9 = 2 : 3 \sqrt{4} : \sqrt{9} = 2 : 3 4 : 9 = 2 : 3 8 : 27 = 2 2 : 3 3 \sqrt{8} : \sqrt{27} = 2\sqrt{2} : 3\sqrt{3} 8 : 27 = 2 2 : 3 3
Triplicate Ratio 4 3 : 9 3 = 64 : 729 4^3 : 9^3 = 64 : 729 4 3 : 9 3 = 64 : 729 8 3 : 27 3 = 512 : 19683 8^3 : 27^3 = 512 : 19683 8 3 : 2 7 3 = 512 : 19683
Sub-Triplicate Ratio 4 3 : 9 3 \sqrt[3]{4} : \sqrt[3]{9} 3 4 : 3 9 8 3 : 27 3 = 2 : 3 \sqrt[3]{8} : \sqrt[3]{27} = 2 : 3 3 8 : 3 27 = 2 : 3
- Inverse Ratio 9 : 4 9 : 4 9 : 4 27 : 8 27 : 8 27 : 8
- Transformation Theorems: Invertendo, Alternando, Componendo & Dividendo
Given the proportion a b = c d \frac{a}{b} = \frac{c}{d} b a = d c , algebraic manipulations yield five standard classical transformation identities:
- Invertendo: Inverting antecedents and consequents: b a = d c \mathbf{\frac{b}{a} = \frac{d}{c}} a b = c d
- Alternando: Swapping the inner terms (means): a c = b d \mathbf{\frac{a}{c} = \frac{b}{d}} c a = d b
Componendo: Adding consequents to antecedents: a + b b = c + d d \frac{a + b}{b} = \frac{c + d}{d} b a + b = d c + d
Dividendo: Subtracting consequents from antecedents: a − b b = c − d d \frac{a - b}{b} = \frac{c - d}{d} b a − b = d c − d
Componendo and Dividendo (C&D Rule): Dividing the Componendo identity by the Dividendo identity: a + b a − b = c + d c − d \mathbf{\frac{a + b}{a - b} = \frac{c + d}{c - d}} a − b a + b = c − d c + d
Tip
Exam Application of Componendo and Dividendo: Whenever you encounter an equation of the form x + p + x − p x + p − x − p = k 1 \frac{\sqrt{x + p} + \sqrt{x - p}}{\sqrt{x + p} - \sqrt{x - p}} = \frac{k}{1} x + p − x − p x + p + x − p = 1 k , apply C&D directly: 2 x + p 2 x − p = k + 1 k − 1 ⟹ x + p x − p = k + 1 k − 1 \frac{2\sqrt{x + p}}{2\sqrt{x - p}} = \frac{k + 1}{k - 1} \implies \frac{\sqrt{x + p}}{\sqrt{x - p}} = \frac{k + 1}{k - 1} 2 x − p 2 x + p = k − 1 k + 1 ⟹ x − p x + p = k − 1 k + 1
Squaring both sides and applying C&D a second time isolates x x x in seconds, eliminating lengthy polynomial cross-multiplication.
Multi-Ratio Continuous Bridging ( A : B : C : D A:B:C:D A : B : C : D )
In railway allocation logistics, inputs are often quoted in overlapping pairs: for instance, locomotive allocations between Shed A and Shed B ( A : B A : B A : B ), and between Shed B and Shed C ( B : C B : C B : C ). Candidates must bridge these into a single continuous chain A : B : C A : B : C A : B : C .
The Bridging Mechanics
To bridge A : B = a : b A : B = a : b A : B = a : b and B : C = c : d B : C = c : d B : C = c : d :
Identify the common linking variable (here, B B B ).
Equate the value of B B B by scaling both ratios to the Lowest Common Multiple (LCM) of b b b and c c c .
Multiply ratio ( A : B ) (A : B) ( A : B ) by c c c , and ratio ( B : C ) (B : C) ( B : C ) by b b b : A : B = ( a × c ) : ( b × c ) A : B = (a \times c) : (b \times c) A : B = ( a × c ) : ( b × c ) B : C = ( b × c ) : ( b × d ) B : C = (b \times c) : (b \times d) B : C = ( b × c ) : ( b × d ) A : B : C = a c : b c : b d \mathbf{A : B : C = ac : bc : bd} A : B : C = ac : bc : bd
The "Empty Cell" Grid Shortcut for A : B : C : D A : B : C : D A : B : C : D
For multi-tier chains such as A : B = 2 : 3 A : B = 2 : 3 A : B = 2 : 3 , B : C = 4 : 5 B : C = 4 : 5 B : C = 4 : 5 , and C : D = 6 : 7 C : D = 6 : 7 C : D = 6 : 7 , populate a 4-column grid and fill vacant cells by extending adjacent boundary digits: A B C D
- [ 2 : 3 ] (3) (3) <--- extend 3 to the right
- (4) [ 4 : 5 ] (5) <--- extend 4 left, 5 right
- (6) (6) [ 6 : 7 ] <--- extend 6 to the left
- --------------------------
Multiply columns downward:
- A = 2 * 4 * 6 = 48
- B = 3 * 4 * 6 = 72
- C = 3 * 5 * 6 = 90
- D = 3 * 5 * 7 = 105
- --------------------------
Divide by common factor 3:
- A : B : C : D = 16 : 24 : 30 : 35
- Equality of Linear Multiples ( p A = q B = r C pA = qB = rC p A = qB = r C )
When problems specify that multiples of allocations are equal, do NOT equate them to p : q : r p : q : r p : q : r . Instead, equate to a constant k k k : p A = q B = r C = k ⟹ A = k p , B = k q , C = k r pA = qB = rC = k \implies A = \frac{k}{p}, \quad B = \frac{k}{q}, \quad C = \frac{k}{r} p A = qB = r C = k ⟹ A = p k , B = q k , C = r k A : B : C = 1 p : 1 q : 1 r = q r : p r : p q \mathbf{A : B : C = \frac{1}{p} : \frac{1}{q} : \frac{1}{r} = qr : pr : pq} A : B : C = p 1 : q 1 : r 1 = qr : pr : pq
If 2 A = 3 B = 4 C 2A = 3B = 4C 2 A = 3 B = 4 C , then A : B : C = 1 2 : 1 3 : 1 4 A : B : C = \frac{1}{2} : \frac{1}{3} : \frac{1}{4} A : B : C = 2 1 : 3 1 : 4 1 . Multiplying by LCM ( 2 , 3 , 4 ) = 12 \text{LCM}(2, 3, 4) = 12 LCM ( 2 , 3 , 4 ) = 12 yields: A : B : C = 6 : 4 : 3 A : B : C = 6 : 4 : 3 A : B : C = 6 : 4 : 3
Direct, Inverse, and Joint Variations
The following are idealized variation models. Fuel examples assume constant fuel burn per hour, and travel-time examples assume fixed distance and constant speed:
1. Direct Variation ( y ∝ x y \propto x y ∝ x )
When quantity y y y increases or decreases in direct proportion to x x x : y = k x ( k = constant of variation ) y = kx \quad (k = \text{constant of variation}) y = k x ( k = constant of variation ) y 1 x 1 = y 2 x 2 \mathbf{\frac{y_1}{x_1} = \frac{y_2}{x_2}} x 1 y 1 = x 2 y 2
Operational Example: The fuel consumed by an idling diesel locomotive varies directly with idling hours: F ∝ t F \propto t F ∝ t .
2. Inverse Variation ( y ∝ 1 x y \propto \frac{1}{x} y ∝ x 1 )
When an increase in x x x causes a proportional reduction in y y y : y = k x ⟹ x y = k y = \frac{k}{x} \implies xy = k y = x k ⟹ x y = k x 1 y 1 = x 2 y 2 \mathbf{x_1 y_1 = x_2 y_2} x 1 y 1 = x 2 y 2
Operational Example: The time taken to clear a yard fouling section varies inversely with the shunting speed: T ∝ 1 S T \propto \frac{1}{S} T ∝ S 1 .
3. Joint Variation ( z ∝ x y z \propto \frac{x}{y} z ∝ y x or z ∝ x y z \propto xy z ∝ x y )
When a dependent variable relies on multiple independent variables: z = k × x y ⟹ z 1 y 1 x 1 = z 2 y 2 x 2 z = k \times \frac{x}{y} \implies \mathbf{\frac{z_1 y_1}{x_1} = \frac{z_2 y_2}{x_2}} z = k × y x ⟹ x 1 z 1 y 1 = x 2 z 2 y 2
Stipulated model: In a fictional production exercise, output z z z varies directly with machines x x x and inversely with time per item y y y : z = k x / y z=kx/y z = k x / y . The variation must be supplied or justified; do not assume this model describes real train braking.
- Proportional Partitioning and Coin Denomination Systems
- Dividing Quantities Proportionally
To divide a total quantity Q Q Q among three entities A , B , C A, B, C A , B , C in the ratio a : b : c a : b : c a : b : c :
Compute the sum of ratio units: S = a + b + c S = a + b + c S = a + b + c .
Value of one ratio unit = Q S = \frac{Q}{S} = S Q .
Allocate shares: A = a S × Q , B = b S × Q , C = c S × Q A = \frac{a}{S} \times Q, \quad B = \frac{b}{S} \times Q, \quad C = \frac{c}{S} \times Q A = S a × Q , B = S b × Q , C = S c × Q
Coin Denomination Mathematics
Coin or token exercises may stipulate mixed face values (for example 5, 2, 1, 0.50 and 0.25 units). These are numerical denominations, not a claim about current legal tender. Questions may provide either:
The ratio of the number of coins, and the total monetary value in rupees; or
The ratio of the monetary values , and the total number of coins. Coin Problem Dual-Vector Structure:
- [Coin Count Vector] c_1 : c_2 : c_3 (Ratio of pieces)
- x x x x
- [Face Value Vector] v_1 v_2 v_3 (Rupees per piece)
- = = = =
- [Cash Value Vector] (c_1*v_1) : (c_2*v_2) : (c_3*v_3) (Rupees contribution)
- Sum of Cash Values = Total Rupee Amount
- The Solution Protocol for Coin Problems
Express the number of coins of each denomination as c 1 x , c 2 x , c 3 x c_1 x, c_2 x, c_3 x c 1 x , c 2 x , c 3 x .
Convert all face values to uniform units (preferably rupees):
- ₹5 coin = INR 5.00 = \text{INR } 5.00 = INR 5.00
- ₹2 coin = INR 2.00 = \text{INR } 2.00 = INR 2.00
- ₹1 coin = INR 1.00 = \text{INR } 1.00 = INR 1.00
- 50 paise = INR 0.50 = INR 1 2 = \text{INR } 0.50 = \text{INR } \frac{1}{2} = INR 0.50 = INR 2 1
- 25 paise = INR 0.25 = INR 1 4 = \text{INR } 0.25 = \text{INR } \frac{1}{4} = INR 0.25 = INR 4 1
Formulate the total cash equation: ∑ ( Count i × Face Value i ) = Total Cash Value \sum (\text{Count}_i \times \text{Face Value}_i) = \text{Total Cash Value} ∑ ( Count i × Face Value i ) = Total Cash Value x ( c 1 v 1 + c 2 v 2 + c 3 v 3 ) = Total Cash Value x \left(c_1 v_1 + c_2 v_2 + c_3 v_3\right) = \text{Total Cash Value} x ( c 1 v 1 + c 2 v 2 + c 3 v 3 ) = Total Cash Value
Solve for multiplier x x x , then calculate individual coin counts or monetary values.
- Comprehensive Worked Operational Problems
- Worked Problem 1: Freight Wagon Allocation Across Three Marshalling Sidings
Scenario: A divisional railway operating control office receives 1,770 empty BOXN wagons to be distributed among three loading sidings: Alpha, Beta, and Gamma. The ratio of wagons allocated to Siding Alpha and Siding Beta is 3 : 4 3 : 4 3 : 4 , while the ratio between Siding Beta and Siding Gamma is 5 : 6 5 : 6 5 : 6 . Calculate the exact number of wagons allocated to each siding.
Step-by-Step Mathematical Resolution:
Identify the Given Ratios: A : B = 3 : 4 A : B = 3 : 4 A : B = 3 : 4 B : C = 5 : 6 B : C = 5 : 6 B : C = 5 : 6
Bridge into a Continuous 3-Way Ratio ( A : B : C A : B : C A : B : C ): The common variable is B B B . The values are 4 4 4 and 5 5 5 . Their LCM is 20 20 20 .
Scale A : B A : B A : B by multiplying by 5 5 5 : A : B = ( 3 × 5 ) : ( 4 × 5 ) = 15 : 20 A : B = (3 \times 5) : (4 \times 5) = 15 : 20 A : B = ( 3 × 5 ) : ( 4 × 5 ) = 15 : 20
Scale B : C B : C B : C by multiplying by 4 4 4 : B : C = ( 5 × 4 ) : ( 6 × 4 ) = 20 : 24 B : C = (5 \times 4) : (6 \times 4) = 20 : 24 B : C = ( 5 × 4 ) : ( 6 × 4 ) = 20 : 24
Combined ratio: A : B : C = 15 : 20 : 24 A : B : C = 15 : 20 : 24 A : B : C = 15 : 20 : 24
Compute the Total Ratio Parts: Sum of parts = 15 + 20 + 24 = 59 \text{Sum of parts} = 15 + 20 + 24 = 59 Sum of parts = 15 + 20 + 24 = 59
Determine the Value of One Ratio Part: Unit Part = 1770 59 = 30 wagons \text{Unit Part} = \frac{1770}{59} = 30\text{ wagons} Unit Part = 59 1770 = 30 wagons
Calculate Individual Siding Allocations:
- Siding Alpha ( A A A ): 15 × 30 = 450 wagons 15 \times 30 = 450\text{ wagons} 15 × 30 = 450 wagons
- Siding Beta ( B B B ): 20 × 30 = 600 wagons 20 \times 30 = 600\text{ wagons} 20 × 30 = 600 wagons
- Siding Gamma ( C C C ): 24 × 30 = 720 wagons 24 \times 30 = 720\text{ wagons} 24 × 30 = 720 wagons
Verification: 450 + 600 + 720 = 1 , 770 wagons (matches total perfectly) 450 + 600 + 720 = 1,770\text{ wagons (matches total perfectly)} 450 + 600 + 720 = 1 , 770 wagons (matches total perfectly)
Worked Problem 2: Signal Cable Tendering via Componendo-Dividendo
Scenario: In an electronic interlocking procurement tender, the cost analysis parameter x x x satisfies the following radical equation: x + 5 + x − 5 x + 5 − x − 5 = 3 \frac{\sqrt{x + 5} + \sqrt{x - 5}}{\sqrt{x + 5} - \sqrt{x - 5}} = 3 x + 5 − x − 5 x + 5 + x − 5 = 3
Determine the exact value of x x x .
Step-by-Step Mathematical Resolution:
Express the Right-Hand Side as a Fraction: x + 5 + x − 5 x + 5 − x − 5 = 3 1 \frac{\sqrt{x + 5} + \sqrt{x - 5}}{\sqrt{x + 5} - \sqrt{x - 5}} = \frac{3}{1} x + 5 − x − 5 x + 5 + x − 5 = 1 3
Apply the Componendo and Dividendo Rule: ( x + 5 + x − 5 ) + ( x + 5 − x − 5 ) ( x + 5 + x − 5 ) − ( x + 5 − x − 5 ) = 3 + 1 3 − 1 \frac{(\sqrt{x + 5} + \sqrt{x - 5}) + (\sqrt{x + 5} - \sqrt{x - 5})}{(\sqrt{x + 5} + \sqrt{x - 5}) - (\sqrt{x + 5} - \sqrt{x - 5})} = \frac{3 + 1}{3 - 1} ( x + 5 + x − 5 ) − ( x + 5 − x − 5 ) ( x + 5 + x − 5 ) + ( x + 5 − x − 5 ) = 3 − 1 3 + 1
Simplify the Sums and Differences: 2 x + 5 2 x − 5 = 4 2 = 2 \frac{2\sqrt{x + 5}}{2\sqrt{x - 5}} = \frac{4}{2} = 2 2 x − 5 2 x + 5 = 2 4 = 2 x + 5 x − 5 = 2 \frac{\sqrt{x + 5}}{\sqrt{x - 5}} = 2 x − 5 x + 5 = 2
Square Both Sides to Eliminate Radicals: x + 5 x − 5 = 4 = 4 1 \frac{x + 5}{x - 5} = 4 = \frac{4}{1} x − 5 x + 5 = 4 = 1 4
Apply Componendo and Dividendo a Second Time (or Cross-Multiply): ( x + 5 ) + ( x − 5 ) ( x + 5 ) − ( x − 5 ) = 4 + 1 4 − 1 \frac{(x + 5) + (x - 5)}{(x + 5) - (x - 5)} = \frac{4 + 1}{4 - 1} ( x + 5 ) − ( x − 5 ) ( x + 5 ) + ( x − 5 ) = 4 − 1 4 + 1 2 x 10 = 5 3 ⟹ x 5 = 5 3 ⟹ x = 25 3 = 8 1 3 \frac{2x}{10} = \frac{5}{3} \implies \frac{x}{5} = \frac{5}{3} \implies x = \frac{25}{3} = 8\frac{1}{3} 10 2 x = 3 5 ⟹ 5 x = 3 5 ⟹ x = 3 25 = 8 3 1
Verification: 25 / 3 + 15 / 3 = 40 / 3 = 2 10 3 \sqrt{25/3 + 15/3} = \sqrt{40/3} = \frac{2\sqrt{10}}{\sqrt{3}} 25/3 + 15/3 = 40/3 = 3 2 10 25 / 3 − 15 / 3 = 10 / 3 = 10 3 \sqrt{25/3 - 15/3} = \sqrt{10/3} = \frac{\sqrt{10}}{\sqrt{3}} 25/3 − 15/3 = 10/3 = 3 10 2 10 3 + 10 3 2 10 3 − 10 3 = 3 10 10 = 3 (verified) \frac{\frac{2\sqrt{10}}{\sqrt{3}} + \frac{\sqrt{10}}{\sqrt{3}}}{\frac{2\sqrt{10}}{\sqrt{3}} - \frac{\sqrt{10}}{\sqrt{3}}} = \frac{3\sqrt{10}}{\sqrt{10}} = 3 \quad \text{(verified)} 3 2 10 − 3 10 3 2 10 + 3 10 = 10 3 10 = 3 (verified)
Worked Problem 3: Counts and values have different weights
A fictional box contains tokens worth 100, 50 and 25 units in count ratio 3:4:5. Their total value is 9000 units. Write their counts as 3k, 4k and 5k. The total is 300k + 200k + 125k = 625k. This would require k = 14.4, which is impossible for the stipulated integer ratio of token counts. The data are inconsistent, even though a numerical equation can be solved.
For a consistent version, change the total to 12500 units. Then k = 20 and the counts are 60, 80 and 100. Their values are 6000, 4000 and 2500, totaling 12500. Always test that a count result is a nonnegative integer; never present a fractional number of coins or people as a physical answer.
Common Exam Traps & Operational Pitfalls
Trap Description Erroneous Approach Correct Examination Protocol
Inverting Antecedent and Consequent Assuming third proportional to a , b a, b a , b is a 2 / b a^2 / b a 2 / b Third proportional to a , b a, b a , b is strictly b 2 / a b^2 / a b 2 / a because a : b = b : x a : b = b : x a : b = b : x .
Direct Coefficient Inversion Equating 2 A = 3 B = 4 C 2A = 3B = 4C 2 A = 3 B = 4 C to ratio A : B : C = 2 : 3 : 4 A : B : C = 2 : 3 : 4 A : B : C = 2 : 3 : 4 Take reciprocals: A : B : C = 1 2 : 1 3 : 1 4 = 6 : 4 : 3 A : B : C = \frac{1}{2} : \frac{1}{3} : \frac{1}{4} = 6 : 4 : 3 A : B : C = 2 1 : 3 1 : 4 1 = 6 : 4 : 3 .
Mixing Coin Count with Coin Value Setting 3 k + 4 k + 5 k = 900 3k + 4k + 5k = 900 3 k + 4 k + 5 k = 900 in coin problems Multiply each coin count by its monetary face value before summing to rupee total.
Unit Mismatch in Ratio Construction Comparing values with differing units (e.g. paise to rupees) Convert all terms to identical units prior to simplifying ratios.