Study guide
6.2 Alternate Day Working, Negative Work & Wage Distribution Based on Work Done
RRB Section Controller 2026: Free Written CBT Study Guide Exam
Track your progress as you read
Finished sections get a check mark.
1 Chapter 1: Exam Overview & Operational Profile
1.1 Written CBT Pattern, Scoring & Selection 1.2 Eligibility, Documents & A-2 Medical Requirements
2 Chapter 2: Number Systems & Arithmetic Foundations
2.1 Number Systems, Divisibility Rules, Prime Factorization & Remainder Theorem 2.2 Unit Digits, Cyclicity Rules & Power Modulo Calculations 2.3 HCF and LCM Properties, Prime Factorization & Practical Word Problems 2.4 Fractions, Decimals, Surds, Indices & BODMAS Simplification
3 Chapter 3: Commercial Arithmetic: Percentages, Profit & Rates
3.1 Percentages, Fractional Equivalents, Successive Variations & Population Formulas 3.2 Cost Price, Selling Price, Profit/Loss Percentage, Dishonest Dealer & Discount Schemes 3.3 Simple Interest, Compound Interest Formulas, Annual/Semi-Annual Compounding & Difference Traps
4 Chapter 4: Ratios, Proportions, Mixtures & Partnerships
4.1 Ratios, Duplicate/Sub-Duplicate Ratios, Direct and Inverse Variations & Proportional Sharing 4.2 Averages, Change in Average, Batsman/Bowling Averages & Replacement Problems 4.3 Rule of Alligation, Removal-Replacement Mixtures & Partnership Capital-Time Sharing
5 Chapter 5: Motion Dynamics, Time, Distance & Train Logistics
5.1 Time, Speed, Distance Relations, Average Speed & Unit Conversions 5.2 Train Problems: Passing Poles, Platforms, Moving Objects & Relative Speed in Opposite/Same Directions 5.3 Upstream, Downstream Boat Velocity, Still Water Speed & Circular Track Races
6 Chapter 6: Work Efficiency, Pipes & Operational Scheduling
6.1 Individual and Group Work, Efficiency Ratios, Work Equivalences & Mandays Formula 6.2 Alternate Day Working, Negative Work & Wage Distribution Based on Work Done 6.3 Inlet and Outlet Pipes, Net Filling Rate, Alternating Flow & Tank Leakage Problems
7 Chapter 7: Algebra, Linear Equations & Progressions
7.1 Algebraic Identities, Polynomial Factorization & Systems of Linear Equations in Two Variables 7.2 Quadratic Equations, Nature of Roots, Discriminant Analysis & Maximum/Minimum Values 7.3 Arithmetic Progressions (AP), General Term, Sum of n Terms & Sequence Modeling
8 Chapter 8: Mensuration: 2D Areas & 3D Solids
8.1 Lines, Angles, Triangle Theorems, Congruence/Similarity & Circle Tangent Properties 8.2 Perimeter and Area of Quadrilaterals, Polygons, Circles & Shaded Region Problems 8.3 Surface Area and Volume of Cubes, Cuboids, Cylinders, Cones, Spheres & Melting-Recasting Solids
9 Chapter 9: Statistics, Probability & Data Interpretation
9.1 Mean, Median, Mode, Range, Mean Deviation & Standard Deviation 9.2 Permutations, Combinations, Classical Probability, Independent Events & Odds 9.3 Tabular Data Interpretation, Bar Charts, Grouped Graphs & Percentage Calculation Shortcuts 9.4 Pie Charts (Angle vs Percentage), Line Trend Graphs & Quantitative Data Sufficiency
10 Chapter 10: Multi-Source & Graphical Analysis
10.1 Multi-Source Analysis, Set Data & Arrangement 10.2 Scatter Plots, Histograms & Distribution Curves
11 Chapter 11: Deductive Logic, Statements & Binary Puzzles
11.1 Syllogisms, Sets & Possibility Conclusions 11.2 Critical Reasoning: Implicit Assumptions, Strong vs Weak Arguments & Course of Action 11.3 Binary Logic: Truth-Tellers, Liars, Alternators & Matrix Logic Deductions
12 Chapter 12: Relational, Directional, Clock & Calendar Reasoning
12.1 Direct Family Relations, Coded Blood Relations & Family Tree Tree-Mapping Methods 12.2 Cardinal & Ordinal Directions, Multi-Step Turn Paths, Pythagorean Distance & Shadow Timing 12.3 Clock Hands Angular Speed, Angle Between Hands at Given Time, Coincidence & Faulty Clocks 12.4 Odd Days Concept, Reference Date Calculations, Leap Year Rules & Repeating Calendar Years
13 Chapter 13: English Reading Comprehension
13.1 English Comprehension: Main Idea, Support & Inference 13.2 English Comprehension: Application, Structure & Style
14 Chapter 14: Mental Reasoning: Analogies & Series
14.1 Semantic, Letter & Number Analogies 14.2 Number Series: Differences, Powers & Missing Terms 14.3 Interleaved, Recursive & Wrong-Term Series
15 Chapter 15: Mental Reasoning: Coding & Ranking
15.1 Letter Shifts, Reversal & Numerical Codes 15.2 Message Intersections & Conditional Coding Tables 15.3 Ranking, People Between & Position Interchanges
16 Chapter 16: Mental Reasoning: Seating Arrangements
16.1 Linear Seating & Parallel Rows 16.2 Circular Seating, Facing & Rotational Symmetry
6.2 Alternate Day Working, Negative Work & Wage Distribution Based on Work Done
Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI
In alternate-day scheduling, work progresses in discrete multi-day cycles; calculate complete integer cycles first, determine cumulative work, and step through remaining units day-by-day.
In negative work problems (builders vs. destroyers), net cycle yield is positive, but the job terminates the instant the target is reached on a positive worker's turn; always reserve the builder's single-shift output to establish the cycle threshold.
When workers leave or join mid-project, either formulate an algebraic duration equation or utilize the Virtual Work Addition method by crediting phantom output for early departures.
When an exercise stipulates pay proportional to work, divide it using E i t i E_i t_i E i t i . Different contractual payment rules require a different model.
Contractor deficit remediation relies on the differential Chain Rule M 1 d 1 W 1 = ( M 1 + Δ M ) d 2 W 2 \frac{M_1 d_1}{W_1} = \frac{(M_1 + \Delta M) d_2}{W_2} W 1 M 1 d 1 = W 2 ( M 1 + Δ M ) d 2 to compute the precise labour reinforcement required to avert penalty clauses.
Last updated: October 2026
The Alternate Day Working Framework
In alternate-day working problems, workers do not operate simultaneously; instead, they take turns in a prescribed sequential rotation (e.g., Worker A A A on Day 1, Worker B B B on Day 2, Worker A A A on Day 3, and so on).
The Multi-Step Cycle Algorithm
Establish Total Work Units ( W W W ): Compute W = LCM ( t A , t B , … ) W = \text{LCM}(t_A, t_B, \dots) W = LCM ( t A , t B , … ) .
Determine Individual Daily Efficiencies: Compute E A = W / t A , E B = W / t B E_A = W/t_A, E_B = W/t_B E A = W / t A , E B = W / t B , etc.
Define the Base Cycle Duration & Net Cycle Output ( W cycle W_{\text{cycle}} W cycle ):
For two workers ( A A A and B B B ), the elementary cycle length is 2 days .
Work delivered in one complete 2-day cycle: W cycle = E A + E B W_{\text{cycle}} = E_A + E_B W cycle = E A + E B .
For three workers ( A , B , C A, B, C A , B , C ), the cycle length is 3 days , with W cycle = E A + E B + E C W_{\text{cycle}} = E_A + E_B + E_C W cycle = E A + E B + E C .
Calculate Maximum Completed Integer Cycles ( k k k ): k = ⌊ W W cycle ⌋ k = \left\lfloor \frac{W}{W_{\text{cycle}}} \right\rfloor k = ⌊ W cycle W ⌋
Total days elapsed during complete cycles = k × ( cycle length ) = k \times (\text{cycle length}) = k × ( cycle length ) .
Work completed during these cycles = k × W cycle = k \times W_{\text{cycle}} = k × W cycle .
Calculate Remaining Work ( R R R ): R = W − ( k × W cycle ) R = W - (k \times W_{\text{cycle}}) R = W − ( k × W cycle )
Step Through Remaining Units Sequentially:
Who begins the next cycle? If A A A starts, evaluate whether R ≤ E A R \le E_A R ≤ E A .
If R ≤ E A R \le E_A R ≤ E A , worker A A A completes the remaining work in a fractional day: Δ t = R E A \Delta t = \frac{R}{E_A} Δ t = E A R days.
If R > E A R > E_A R > E A , worker A A A works 1 full day, leaving ( R − E A ) (R - E_A) ( R − E A ) units. Worker B B B then works on the subsequent day to complete the balance in R − E A E B \frac{R - E_A}{E_B} E B R − E A days. +-----------------------------------------------------------------------------+
- | ALTERNATE WORKING CYCLE ALGORITHM |
- +-----------------------------------------------------------------------------+
- | Total Work W = LCM(t_A, t_B) |
- | Net Output per 2-Day Cycle: W_cycle = E_A + E_B |
- | │ |
- | ▼ |
- | Compute Full Cycles: k = floor(W / W_cycle) |
- | Days Elapsed = k * 2 | Work Done = k * W_cycle |
- | │ |
- | ▼ |
- | Remaining Work R = W - (k * W_cycle) |
- | │ |
- | ┌────────────────────┴────────────────────┐ |
- | ▼ (If R <= E_A) ▼ (If R > E_A) |
- | A finishes in R / E_A days A works 1 full day (R' = R - E_A) |
- | Total Time = (2k) + (R / E_A) B finishes in R' / E_B days |
- | Total Time = (2k + 1) + (R' / E_B) |
- +-----------------------------------------------------------------------------+
- Negative Work (Builders vs. Destroyers & The Peak Threshold Trap)
Negative work arises when one entity adds to progress (e.g., track construction, embankment filling, masonry wall erection) while another entity actively subtracts from it (e.g., soil erosion, water seepage, brick demolition).
Let Builder A A A complete work in x x x days ( E A = + W / x E_A = +W/x E A = + W / x ) and Destroyer B B B undo the entire work in y y y days ( E B = W / y E_B = W/y E B = W / y is the positive magnitude of removal). Assume the builder cannot finish in its first turn and x < y x<y x < y , so complete two-day cycles make positive progress. The signed destruction contribution is − E B -E_B − E B , giving net output E A − E B E_A-E_B E A − E B .
The Net Cycle Rate
In an alternating schedule where Builder A A A works on Day 1 and Destroyer B B B acts on Day 2: Net Progress per 2-Day Cycle = E A − E B > 0 \text{Net Progress per 2-Day Cycle} = E_A - E_B > 0 Net Progress per 2-Day Cycle = E A − E B > 0
Caution
THE PEAK THRESHOLD TRAP (The Monkey-Pole Paradox): A disastrous examination error is dividing total work W W W directly by net cycle progress: T trap = W E A − E B × 2 T_{\text{trap}} = \frac{W}{E_A - E_B} \times 2 T trap = E A − E B W × 2 . This formula assumes the destroyer acts on the final day! In reality, the task terminates the exact moment the target is reached on the builder's turn . The destroyer never touches the completed structure. Failing to reserve the builder's final day output will produce an erroneously inflated answer.
The Rigorous Peak Threshold Protocol
Reserve the Builder's Daily Output: Threshold Target = W − E A \text{Threshold Target} = W - E_A Threshold Target = W − E A
Compute Integer Cycles Required to Reach the Threshold: Find the smallest integer number of cycles k k k such that: k × ( E A − E B ) ≥ W − E A k \times (E_A - E_B) \ge W - E_A k × ( E A − E B ) ≥ W − E A
Evaluate Cumulative Work at the End of Cycle k k k : W k = k × ( E A − E B ) W_k = k \times (E_A - E_B) W k = k × ( E A − E B )
Days elapsed = 2 k = 2k = 2 k .
4. Complete the Final Quantum on Day ( 2 k + 1 ) (2k + 1) ( 2 k + 1 ) : The remaining work is R = W − W k R = W - W_k R = W − W k . Because W k ≥ W − E A W_k \ge W - E_A W k ≥ W − E A , we are guaranteed that R ≤ E A R \le E_A R ≤ E A . Fractional Day Required by Builder = R E A \text{Fractional Day Required by Builder} = \frac{R}{E_A} Fractional Day Required by Builder = E A R Total Days = 2 k + R E A \text{Total Days} = 2k + \frac{R}{E_A} Total Days = 2 k + E A R
Leaving and Joining Mid-Project
Real-world railway contracts frequently experience mid-project labour fluctuations. These scenarios divide into two mathematical structures: +-----------------------------------------------------------------------------+
- | MID-PROJECT WORK TURNOVER |
- +-----------------------------------------------------------------------------+
- | FORWARD DEPARTURE (Leaves x days AFTER START): |
- | Work Done = (E_A + E_B) * x |
- | Balance Work = W - [(E_A + E_B) * x] |
- | Remaining Days = Balance Work / E_B |
- +-----------------------------------------------------------------------------+
- | BACKWARD DEPARTURE (Leaves x days BEFORE COMPLETION): |
- | Method 1: Total Days T -> (T - x) * E_A + T * E_B = W |
- | Method 2: VIRTUAL WORK ADDITION SHORTCUT |
- | Credit A with 'phantom' output: W_virtual = W + (x * E_A) |
- | All workers now work full duration T: T = W_virtual / (E_A + E_B) |
- +-----------------------------------------------------------------------------+
- The Virtual Work Addition Shortcut
When a worker leaves x x x days before completion , the standard algebraic approach sets total time as T T T . A faster mental shortcut is the Virtual Work Method :
If worker A A A had not left early, they would have produced an additional x × E A x \times E_A x × E A units of work.
Add this virtual work to the actual target: W virtual = W + ( x ⋅ E A ) W_{\text{virtual}} = W + (x \cdot E_A) W virtual = W + ( x ⋅ E A ) .
Now, pretend that all workers remained on site for the entire project duration T T T .
Solve directly in one step: T = W + ( x ⋅ E A ) E total T = \frac{W + (x \cdot E_A)}{E_{\text{total}}} T = E total W + ( x ⋅ E A )
Wage Distribution Principles Based on Work Done
In the exercises here, the contract explicitly pays in proportion to work delivered . This is a stipulated arithmetic sharing rule. It is not a statement about statutory wages, time-based pay or actual railway employment terms.
The Work-Share Wage Formula
If workers A , B , A, B, A , B , and C C C work for durations t A , t B , t_A, t_B, t A , t B , and t C t_C t C with daily efficiencies E A , E B , E_A, E_B, E A , E B , and E C E_C E C : Work Delivered by Individual i = W i = E i × t i \text{Work Delivered by Individual } i = W_i = E_i \times t_i Work Delivered by Individual i = W i = E i × t i Ratio of Wages = ( E A ⋅ t A ) : ( E B ⋅ t B ) : ( E C ⋅ t C ) \text{Ratio of Wages} = (E_A \cdot t_A) : (E_B \cdot t_B) : (E_C \cdot t_C) Ratio of Wages = ( E A ⋅ t A ) : ( E B ⋅ t B ) : ( E C ⋅ t C ) Individual Wage Share = ( W i W total ) × Total Contract Amount \text{Individual Wage Share} = \left( \frac{W_i}{W_{\text{total}}} \right) \times \text{Total Contract Amount} Individual Wage Share = ( W total W i ) × Total Contract Amount
Important
The Identical Duration Rule: The ratio of wages equals the ratio of efficiencies ( E A : E B : E C E_A : E_B : E_C E A : E B : E C ) if and only if all individuals worked for the exact same number of days ( t A = t B = t C t_A = t_B = t_C t A = t B = t C ). If one worker leaves early or joins late, distributing wages by efficiency ratios alone is a critical mathematical error.
Contractor Estimates & Deadline Remediation
A fictional project may ask how many equally productive workers are needed to meet a fixed deadline. Assume unchanged hours, productivity and work specification; round a noninteger required workforce upward when only whole workers can be assigned.
Workforce Reinforcement Formula
Suppose a contractor agrees to finish a project in D D D days with an initial workforce of M 1 M_1 M 1 workers. After d 1 d_1 d 1 days, an inspection reveals that only a fraction W 1 W_1 W 1 of the total work is complete:
Remaining calendar days: d 2 = D − d 1 d_2 = D - d_1 d 2 = D − d 1 .
Remaining work: W 2 = W total − W 1 W_2 = W_{\text{total}} - W_1 W 2 = W total − W 1 .
Required total workforce M 2 M_2 M 2 to finish precisely on time: M 1 ⋅ d 1 W 1 = M 2 ⋅ d 2 W 2 ⟹ M 2 = M 1 ⋅ d 1 ⋅ W 2 W 1 ⋅ d 2 \frac{M_1 \cdot d_1}{W_1} = \frac{M_2 \cdot d_2}{W_2} \implies M_2 = \frac{M_1 \cdot d_1 \cdot W_2}{W_1 \cdot d_2} W 1 M 1 ⋅ d 1 = W 2 M 2 ⋅ d 2 ⟹ M 2 = W 1 ⋅ d 2 M 1 ⋅ d 1 ⋅ W 2 Additional Workers Required ( Δ M ) = M 2 − M 1 \text{Additional Workers Required } (\Delta M) = M_2 - M_1 Additional Workers Required ( Δ M ) = M 2 − M 1
- Worked Examples
- Worked Example 1: Alternate Day Track Relaying with Fractional Completion
Problem: Gang A can relay a standard station crossover in 12 days, while Gang B can relay the same crossover in 18 days. Due to single-line traffic constraints, they work on alternate days, with Gang A working on Day 1, Gang B on Day 2, Gang A on Day 3, and so on. In exactly how many days will the crossover relaying be completed?
Step 1: Compute Total Work Units and Efficiencies: Total Work W = LCM ( 12 , 18 ) = 36 units \text{Total Work } W = \text{LCM}(12, 18) = 36 \text{ units} Total Work W = LCM ( 12 , 18 ) = 36 units E A = 36 12 = 3 units/day , E B = 36 18 = 2 units/day E_A = \frac{36}{12} = 3 \text{ units/day}, \quad E_B = \frac{36}{18} = 2 \text{ units/day} E A = 12 36 = 3 units/day , E B = 18 36 = 2 units/day
Step 2: Determine 2-Day Cycle Output: Work per 2-day cycle = E A + E B = 3 + 2 = 5 units \text{Work per 2-day cycle } = E_A + E_B = 3 + 2 = 5 \text{ units} Work per 2-day cycle = E A + E B = 3 + 2 = 5 units
Step 3: Calculate Complete Integer Cycles: k = ⌊ 36 5 ⌋ = 7 cycles k = \left\lfloor \frac{36}{5} \right\rfloor = 7 \text{ cycles} k = ⌊ 5 36 ⌋ = 7 cycles
Elapsed time for 7 complete cycles = 7 × 2 = 14 days = 7 \times 2 = 14 \text{ days} = 7 × 2 = 14 days .
Cumulative work completed = 7 × 5 = 35 units = 7 \times 5 = 35 \text{ units} = 7 × 5 = 35 units .
Step 4: Evaluate Remaining Work: R = 36 − 35 = 1 unit R = 36 - 35 = 1 \text{ unit} R = 36 − 35 = 1 unit
Step 5: Determine Fractional Time for Gang A on Day 15: It is Gang A's turn to work. Gang A delivers 3 units per full day. Δ t = R E A = 1 unit 3 units/day = 1 3 day \Delta t = \frac{R}{E_A} = \frac{1 \text{ unit}}{3 \text{ units/day}} = \frac{1}{3} \text{ day} Δ t = E A R = 3 units/day 1 unit = 3 1 day
Conclusion: Total time taken is 14 + 1 3 = 14 1 3 days 14 + \frac{1}{3} = 14\frac{1}{3} \text{ days} 14 + 3 1 = 14 3 1 days (one third of a working day beyond 14 days; converting to hours requires the stated working-day length).
Worked Example 2: Negative Work (Embankment Construction vs. Monsoon Erosion)
Problem: A railway civil construction gang can construct a protective earth embankment along a flood-prone line in 20 days. However, heavy tidal backflow and monsoon erosion can wash away an entire completed embankment in 30 days. If the construction gang works on Day 1, tidal erosion acts on Day 2, and they alternate continuously, in how many days will the embankment be completed for the first time?
Step 1: Establish Units and Daily Rates: Total Work W = LCM ( 20 , 30 ) = 60 units \text{Total Work } W = \text{LCM}(20, 30) = 60 \text{ units} Total Work W = LCM ( 20 , 30 ) = 60 units E gang = + 60 20 = + 3 units/day , E erosion = − 60 30 = − 2 units/day E_{\text{gang}} = +\frac{60}{20} = +3 \text{ units/day}, \quad E_{\text{erosion}} = -\frac{60}{30} = -2 \text{ units/day} E gang = + 20 60 = + 3 units/day , E erosion = − 30 60 = − 2 units/day
Step 2: Determine Net Progress per 2-Day Cycle: Net Cycle Progress = ( + 3 ) + ( − 2 ) = + 1 unit every 2 days \text{Net Cycle Progress} = (+3) + (-2) = +1 \text{ unit every 2 days} Net Cycle Progress = ( + 3 ) + ( − 2 ) = + 1 unit every 2 days
Step 3: Apply the Peak Threshold Rule: Reserve the builder gang's full daily progress from the total target: Threshold Target = W − E gang = 60 − 3 = 57 units \text{Threshold Target} = W - E_{\text{gang}} = 60 - 3 = 57 \text{ units} Threshold Target = W − E gang = 60 − 3 = 57 units
Step 4: Compute Cycles Required to Reach Threshold: Cycles Required k = 57 units 1 unit/cycle = 57 cycles \text{Cycles Required } k = \frac{57 \text{ units}}{1 \text{ unit/cycle}} = 57 \text{ cycles} Cycles Required k = 1 unit/cycle 57 units = 57 cycles
Elapsed days for 57 complete cycles = 57 × 2 = 114 days = 57 \times 2 = 114 \text{ days} = 57 × 2 = 114 days .
Cumulative embankment constructed = 57 × 1 = 57 units = 57 \times 1 = 57 \text{ units} = 57 × 1 = 57 units .
Step 5: Final Advance on Day 115: On Day 115, the construction gang takes its turn: Output delivered on Day 115 = + 3 units \text{Output delivered on Day 115} = +3 \text{ units} Output delivered on Day 115 = + 3 units Cumulative Work = 57 + 3 = 60 units (100% COMPLETE!) \text{Cumulative Work} = 57 + 3 = 60 \text{ units (100\% COMPLETE!)} Cumulative Work = 57 + 3 = 60 units (100% COMPLETE!)
Because the target of 60 units is reached at the end of Day 115, the embankment is finished and handed over. Erosion does not act.
Conclusion: The embankment is completed in exactly 115 days .
(Note: Falling into the trap of ( 60 / 1 ) × 2 = 120 days (60 / 1) \times 2 = 120 \text{ days} ( 60/1 ) × 2 = 120 days overestimates the time by 5 full days!)
Worked Example 3: Wage Distribution with Early Departures
Problem: Three railway signalling technicians—A, B, and C—are contracted to overhaul an interlocking relay panel for a lump-sum contract of ₹12,000. Working alone, A can finish in 12 days, B in 15 days, and C in 20 days. All three begin work together. After 3 days, technician A leaves the site. Technicians B and C continue together, but technician B leaves 1 day before the work is finally completed. Technician C finishes the remaining balance alone. Assuming payment proportional to work delivered, calculate each technician’s share.
Step 1: Determine Total Work Units and Individual Efficiencies: Total Work W = LCM ( 12 , 15 , 20 ) = 60 units \text{Total Work } W = \text{LCM}(12, 15, 20) = 60 \text{ units} Total Work W = LCM ( 12 , 15 , 20 ) = 60 units E A = 60 12 = 5 units/day , E B = 60 15 = 4 units/day , E C = 60 20 = 3 units/day E_A = \frac{60}{12} = 5 \text{ units/day}, \quad E_B = \frac{60}{15} = 4 \text{ units/day}, \quad E_C = \frac{60}{20} = 3 \text{ units/day} E A = 12 60 = 5 units/day , E B = 15 60 = 4 units/day , E C = 20 60 = 3 units/day
Step 2: Track Progress Across Phases:
Phase 1 (First 3 days - A, B, and C together): Work done = 3 × ( E A + E B + E C ) = 3 × ( 5 + 4 + 3 ) = 3 × 12 = 36 units \text{Work done} = 3 \times (E_A + E_B + E_C) = 3 \times (5 + 4 + 3) = 3 \times 12 = 36 \text{ units} Work done = 3 × ( E A + E B + E C ) = 3 × ( 5 + 4 + 3 ) = 3 × 12 = 36 units Remaining work $= 60 - 36 = 24 \text{ units}$. Technician A departs.
Phase 3 (Final 1 day - C works alone): Technician B leaves 1 day before completion, meaning C works the last day alone: Work done by C = 1 × E C = 1 × 3 = 3 units \text{Work done by C} = 1 \times E_C = 1 \times 3 = 3 \text{ units} Work done by C = 1 × E C = 1 × 3 = 3 units
Phase 2 (Intermediate days - B and C together): Work completed in Phase 2 = 24 − 3 = 21 units \text{Work completed in Phase 2} = 24 - 3 = 21 \text{ units} Work completed in Phase 2 = 24 − 3 = 21 units Duration of Phase 2 = 21 E B + E C = 21 4 + 3 = 21 7 = 3 days \text{Duration of Phase 2} = \frac{21}{E_B + E_C} = \frac{21}{4 + 3} = \frac{21}{7} = 3 \text{ days} Duration of Phase 2 = E B + E C 21 = 4 + 3 21 = 7 21 = 3 days
Step 3: Total Days and Work Delivered by Each Technician:
Technician A: Worked 3 days in Phase 1. W A = 3 × 5 = 15 units W_A = 3 \times 5 = 15 \text{ units} W A = 3 × 5 = 15 units
Technician B: Worked in Phase 1 (3 days) + Phase 2 (3 days) = 6 days = 6 \text{ days} = 6 days . W B = 6 × 4 = 24 units W_B = 6 \times 4 = 24 \text{ units} W B = 6 × 4 = 24 units
Technician C: Worked in Phase 1 (3 days) + Phase 2 (3 days) + Phase 3 (1 day) = 7 days = 7 \text{ days} = 7 days . W C = 7 × 3 = 21 units W_C = 7 \times 3 = 21 \text{ units} W C = 7 × 3 = 21 units
(Check: 15 + 24 + 21 = 60 units 15 + 24 + 21 = 60 \text{ units} 15 + 24 + 21 = 60 units .)
Step 4: Distribute Contract Wages Proportional to Work Delivered: Wage per unit of work = INR 12 , 000 60 units = INR 200 per unit \text{Wage per unit of work} = \frac{\text{INR } 12,000}{60 \text{ units}} = \text{INR } 200 \text{ per unit} Wage per unit of work = 60 units INR 12 , 000 = INR 200 per unit Share of A = 15 × INR 200 = INR 3 , 000 \text{Share of A} = 15 \times \text{INR } 200 = \text{INR } 3,000 Share of A = 15 × INR 200 = INR 3 , 000 Share of B = 24 × INR 200 = INR 4 , 800 \text{Share of B} = 24 \times \text{INR } 200 = \text{INR } 4,800 Share of B = 24 × INR 200 = INR 4 , 800 Share of C = 21 × INR 200 = INR 4 , 200 \text{Share of C} = 21 \times \text{INR } 200 = \text{INR } 4,200 Share of C = 21 × INR 200 = INR 4 , 200
(Check: INR 3 , 000 + INR 4 , 800 + INR 4 , 200 = INR 12 , 000 \text{INR } 3,000 + \text{INR } 4,800 + \text{INR } 4,200 = \text{INR } 12,000 INR 3 , 000 + INR 4 , 800 + INR 4 , 200 = INR 12 , 000 .)
Calculation Traps & Tactical Shortcuts
The Over-Cycle Trap in Alternating Work: In problems where remaining work R R R is smaller than the next worker's single-day capacity, candidates frequently award an entire integer day rather than calculating the fraction R E \frac{R}{E} E R . If R = 2 R = 2 R = 2 units and the worker does 5 5 5 units/day, the added time is strictly + 0.4 +0.4 + 0.4 days (not + 1 +1 + 1 day).
The Builder-Destroyer Fallacy: Dividing total capacity directly by net cycle yield in negative work problems treats destruction as inevitable even after the target is met. Always deduct the builder's positive stride before computing cycle multiples.
Nominal Day Wage Splitting: When allocating contract funds, dividing money by total days present (e.g., 3 : 6 : 7 3 : 6 : 7 3 : 6 : 7 ) instead of work units produced ( 15 : 24 : 21 15 : 24 : 21 15 : 24 : 21 ) completely ignores varying skill levels and produces incorrect answers.
The peak-threshold formula assumes constant rates and positive net progress per complete cycle. If the builder can finish within its first turn, stop then; no complete cycle is needed. If the builder cannot finish in one turn and every complete cycle loses all its progress, the target is never reached under the stated repeating schedule.