Study guide

10.2 KPIs & Characteristics of Good Metrics

IOSH Managing Safely Exam

Track your progress as you read

Finished sections get a check mark.

1 Introduction & Exam Overview

1.1 What Is IOSH Managing Safely? 1.2 Exam Format & Dual Assessment 1.3 Certificate Validity & Study Plan

2 Chapter 1: Introducing Managing Safely

2.1 Moral, Legal & Financial Reasons 2.2 The Accident Cost Iceberg 2.3 Responsibility & Accountability

3 Chapter 2: Assessing Risks

3.1 Hazard, Hazardous Event & Risk 3.2 Five Steps of Risk Assessment 3.3 The 5×5 Likelihood × Consequence Matrix 3.4 Residual Risk, Suitable & Sufficient, Review

4 Chapter 3: Controlling Risks

4.1 ERICPD Hierarchy of Control 4.2 Reasonably Practicable 4.3 Safe Systems of Work (SSoW) 4.4 Permits to Work

5 Chapter 4: Understanding Responsibilities

5.1 Criminal vs Civil Law 5.2 Employer & Employee Duties 5.3 Enforcement, Improvement & Prohibition Notices 5.4 Knowledge Tests & Management Systems (HSG65 / ISO 45001)

6 Chapter 5: Hazard Categories, Noise, Vibration & Substances

6.1 Six Hazard Categories 6.2 Noise Hazards & Action Values 6.3 Hand-Arm & Whole-Body Vibration 6.4 Hazardous Substances, Asbestos & LEV

7 Chapter 6: Work at Height, Manual Handling, Fire & Electricity

7.1 Work at Height 7.2 Manual Handling, Slips & Trips 7.3 Fire Safety Basics 7.4 Electricity Hazards

8 Chapter 7: Stress, Work Equipment & Other Hazards

8.1 Work-Related Stress & Psychosocial Hazards 8.2 Work Equipment & Machinery 8.3 Confined Spaces, Workplace Transport & Welfare

9 Chapter 8: Investigating Incidents

9.1 Accidents, Incidents & Near Misses 9.2 Immediate, Underlying & Root Causes 9.3 Four-Step Investigation Process 9.4 RIDDOR Reporting Overview

10 Chapter 9: Measuring Performance

10.1 Active (Proactive) vs Reactive Indicators 10.2 KPIs & Characteristics of Good Metrics 10.3 Auditing the Safety Management System 10.4 Calculating Injury Incidence & Frequency Rates 10.5 Inspections & Benchmarking

11 Chapter 10: Protecting the Environment

11.1 Environmental Basics: Pollution, Waste & Duty of Care 11.2 Reducing Environmental Impact & Environmental Management Systems

12 Chapter 11: Risk Assessment Project & Exam Day

12.1 Project Requirements & Marking 12.2 Worked Example: Four-Hazard Assessment 12.3 Written Assessment Strategy & High-Yield Review

10.2 KPIs & Characteristics of Good Metrics

Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI

Useful H&S KPIs are specific, measurable, achievable, relevant, and time-bound (SMART-style) and should drive action, not only reports.

A balanced set covers people, process, plant, and performance — not only injury frequency.

Pitfalls include vanity metrics, gaming, only lagging measures, and targets that encourage under-reporting.

KPIs sit primarily in the Check stage of Plan-Do-Check-Act and feed Act (improvement) and re-planning.

A worked shift from only Accident Frequency Rate (AFR) to a mix of leading indicators shows stronger management control.

Last updated: August 2026

10.2 KPIs & Characteristics of Good Metrics

Quick Answer: Good H&S KPIs are SMART (specific, measurable, achievable, relevant, time-bound) and lead to action . Use a balanced set across people, process, plant, and performance . Avoid vanity metrics, gaming, and only lagging injury rates. KPIs support the Check stage of Plan-Do-Check-Act. Prefer a mix of leading indicators over AFR alone.

Knowing active versus reactive is step one. Step two is choosing key performance indicators (KPIs) that busy managers will actually use. A KPI is a small number of measures that tell you whether you are on track against objectives. In health and safety, bad KPIs create theatre; good KPIs create learning and timely control.

What makes a useful H&S KPI

Apply SMART-style tests (wording varies slightly by employer; the idea is consistent):

  • Characteristic Meaning for H&S Weak example Stronger example
  • Specific Clear what is counted “Improve safety” “Close inspection actions within 14 days”

Measurable Data can be collected consistently “Better culture” (undefined) “Near-miss reports per month with investigation started within 48 hours”

Achievable Realistic with resources “Zero every risk forever” “100% of high-risk tasks covered by in-date risk assessment by Q2”

Relevant Linked to real risk and duties Counting posters only % of statutory thorough examinations completed in date

  • Time-bound Period and deadline clear “Sometime this year” “By end of each calendar month”
  • Leads to action — the sixth test

A metric that never changes a decision is decoration . Ask:

Who reviews it?

What threshold triggers action?

What do we do when it is red?

Does the team understand it?

If the board only receives a green traffic light with no narrative, the KPI has failed the action test.

Balanced set: people, process, plant, performance

Relying on one number (usually accident frequency) is fragile. A practical balance for managers:

Dimension Focus Example KPIs

People Competence, engagement, behaviour support % training in date; induction completion; observation of safe behaviours; near-miss participation rate

Process Systems and procedures working % risk assessments current; PTW audit compliance; investigation quality scores; procedure reviews completed

Plant Workplace and equipment integrity Inspection completion rate; statutory exam compliance; defects open >30 days; guarding checks

Performance Outcomes and results Injury/ill-health rates; days lost; RIDDOR events; damage costs; enforcement outcomes

People + process + plant lean active/leading . Performance often includes reactive/lagging outcomes. Together they answer: Are our people ready? Are our systems alive? Is our plant safe? Are outcomes improving?

Building a small local dashboard (example)

A department manager might track monthly:

  • People: % of team with in-date role-critical training
  • Process: % of risk assessments within review date
  • Plant: Planned workplace inspections completed / planned
  • Plant/process: Open high-priority defects aged over 14 days
  • Performance: First-aid + lost-time injuries (count and rate)
  • People/culture: Near-miss reports with feedback closed to reporter

That is enough for a 15-minute review without drowning in spreadsheets.

Pitfalls — how good intentions go wrong

Pitfall What it looks like Why it hurts

Vanity metrics Poster counts, “safety days held,” likes on a safety app with no link to risk Looks busy; little effect on serious hazards

Gaming Reclassifying injuries, delaying reports, excluding contractors, changing definitions mid-year Rate improves on paper while risk stays high

Only lagging Dashboard is 100% AFR / LTIs No early warning; success depends on luck

Targets that encourage under-reporting Bonus solely for “zero accidents”; public shaming of reporters Silence; hidden harm; fake culture

  • Too many KPIs 40 measures, none reviewed Noise; nothing managed
  • Unowned metrics Data collected by H&S team, ignored by line managers No operational accountability
  • Activity without quality 200 toolbox talks of poor content Tick-box culture
  • Comparing unequal rates Celebrating lower AFR without normalising hours or risk profile False comfort

Exam angle: If a vignette describes a bonus for zero injuries and then falling report rates, identify under-reporting risk and recommend leading indicators + just culture .

Linking KPIs to Plan-Do-Check-Act (Check stage)

HSG65-style Plan-Do-Check-Act (and similar management cycles) places measurement firmly in Check , which then feeds Act and re-planning.

PDCA stage H&S activity Role of KPIs

Plan Policy, risk assessments, objectives, resources Set KPI definitions and targets aligned to significant risks

  • Do Implement controls, train, supervise, maintain Generate the activities that leading KPIs count
  • Check Monitor, inspect, audit, investigate, measure KPIs live here — compare plan vs reality
  • Act Review, improve, update assessments and plans KPI trends drive corrective and preventive action

Managers should not treat KPIs as an annual report decoration. Monthly Check conversations: What do the numbers say? What did we verify on the ground? What will we change?

  • Worked example: shifting from only AFR to a mixed set
  • Starting point (weak)

A warehouse tracks one number: Accident Frequency Rate (AFR) (or similar lost-time frequency). Last year AFR fell. Leadership celebrates. Nobody notices that:

  • Temporary agency hours rose (different reporting habits)
  • Near-miss forms stopped arriving after a supervisor mocked a reporter
  • Three racking inspections were skipped in peak season
  • Several risk assessments still refer to old layout before a mezzanine was added

The AFR looked good because harm was not yet realised and some events may not have been recorded.

Improved KPI set (stronger)

  • KPI Type Target example Action trigger
  • AFR / LTI rate Lagging (performance) Trend down year-on-year Any LTI → investigation + leading KPI review

Near-miss reports with closed feedback Leading (people) Stable or rising quality reports Drop >30% QoQ → culture check

% RA current for warehouse tasks Leading (process) ≥95% Below 90% → freeze non-critical changes until reviewed

Planned inspections completed Leading (plant/process) 100% of plan Missed week → escalate to operations manager

High-priority defects open >14 days Leading (plant) Zero aged critical defects Daily review until cleared

Agency induction completion before first shift Leading (people) 100% Any breach → stop work for individual until inducted

  • What changes in behaviour
  • Supervisors are scored on inspection completion and defect age , not only “no accidents on my shift.”

H&S and operations jointly review near-miss quality , not only volume.

Layout change triggers process KPI (risk assessment currency), preventing silent obsolescence.

AFR remains on the dashboard as a truth check on outcomes, not the only scoreboard.

One-year narrative for the exam

Before: Single lagging KPI → false comfort.

After: Balanced people/process/plant/performance set → earlier detection of skipped inspections, stale assessments, and reporting fear.

Result concept: Even if AFR is stable for a while, system health is visible and manageable.

Practical rules for writing KPIs (manager toolkit)

Start from significant risks — not from what is easy to count.

Prefer rates or percentages where volume fluctuates (hours worked, headcount).

Define the numerator and denominator in one sentence.

Set review frequency (weekly operational, monthly management, annual board).

Pair every lagging KPI with at least one leading KPI in the same risk area.

Publish definitions so gaming by redefinition is harder.

Reward learning and closure of actions , not silence.

Manager checklist

Are our top five KPIs SMART and owned by named managers?

Do we cover people, process, plant, and performance?

Could anyone hit a target by hiding bad news?

Do red KPIs automatically create actions with deadlines?

Is AFR (or equivalent) supported by leading measures, not worshipped alone?

Choose fewer, better metrics; put them in the Check stage; and use them to change work — that is the Managing Safely standard for performance measurement beyond a single accident rate.