Study guide
12.2 Likelihood of Failure, Likelihood of Impact & ISA Risk Matrix Rating
ISA Board Certified Master Arborist BCMA
Track your progress as you read
Finished sections get a check mark.
1 Chapter 1: The BCMA Exam & How to Prepare
1.1 The BCMA Exam: Format, Eligibility, Fees & the Current Content Outline
2 Chapter 2: Tree Biology, Physiology & Anatomy
2.1 Cellular Anatomy, Meristems, Vascular Architecture & Secondary Growth 2.2 Photosynthesis, Respiration & Carbohydrate Allocation Dynamics 2.3 CODIT (Compartmentalization of Decay in Trees) & Reaction Wood 2.4 Tree Life Stages, Decline Spirals, Veteran Tree Management & Propagation
3 Chapter 3: Soil Science, Soil Chemistry & the Rhizosphere
3.1 Soil Physical Properties, Texture, Structure & Bulk Density 3.2 Soil Chemistry: Cation Exchange Capacity (CEC), pH & Salinity 3.3 The Rhizosphere, Soil Food Web & Mycorrhizal Relationships 3.4 Urban, Disturbed & Engineered Soils: Structural Soils and Suspended Pavement 3.5 Soil–Water Interactions: Drainage Diagnosis, Perched Water & Remediation Design
4 Chapter 4: Abiotic Disorders & Tree Nutrition
4.1 Abiotic Environmental Stresses: Moisture, Temperature & Chemical Injury 4.2 Mechanical Injury, Hardware Damage, Root Defects & Lightning Injury 4.3 Chemical Stress Beyond Herbicides: Growth Regulators, Adjuvants, Salts, Metals & Air Pollutants 4.4 Essential Nutrients, Deficiencies, Toxicities & Element Mobility
5 Chapter 5: Biotic Disorders: Pathogens, Pests & Tree Defense
5.1 The Disease Triangle, Disease Cycles & Pest Life Cycles 5.2 Biotic Tree Pathogens: Wood Decay Fungi, Vascular Wilts & Cankers 5.3 Arthropod Pests: Feeding Guilds, Signs, Symptoms & Field Recognition 5.4 Tree Defense Responses to Biotic Injury: Constitutive, Induced & Structural
6 Chapter 6: Plant Identification, Selection & Urban Ecology
6.1 Dendrological Classification, Botanical Nomenclature & Morphological Keys 6.2 Species-Site Matching, Environmental Tolerances & Urban Forest Ecology 6.3 Ecological Interactions & Climate-Adaptive Selection: Succession, Allelopathy & Assisted Migration
7 Chapter 7: Systematic Arboricultural Diagnosis
7.1 The Systematic 5-Step Diagnostic Protocol & Clinical Signs vs Symptoms 7.2 Field Sampling Protocols, Laboratory Testing & Diagnostic Data Interpretation 7.3 Advanced Diagnostic Testing: Resistance Drilling, Sonic Tomography & Pulling Tests
8 Chapter 8: ANSI A300 Pruning Standards & Canopy Architecture
8.1 Biological Response to Pruning, Branch Anatomy & ANSI A300 Pruning Cuts 8.2 Structural Pruning of Young and Developing Trees: Architecture & Subordination 8.3 Mature Tree Canopy Management: Dosage Limits, Methods & Specialty Pruning 8.4 Pruning Tools, Sanitation & Writing Enforceable Pruning Specifications
9 Chapter 9: Plant Health Care (PHC) & Integrated Pest Management
9.1 Plant Health Care Concepts, Phenological Monitoring & Action Thresholds 9.2 Biological Controls, Cultural Management Tactics & Mechanical Interventions 9.3 Chemical Tactics, Modes of Action, Application Methods & Pollinator Protection
10 Chapter 10: Soil Treatment, Water Relations, Planting & Transplanting
10.1 Soil Compaction Remediation: Pneumatic Excavation, Vertical Mulching & Amendments 10.2 Tree Water Relations, Transpiration Dynamics, Moisture Sensing & Irrigation Design 10.3 Nursery Stock Evaluation, Planting Depth, Root Preparation & ANSI A300 Part 6 10.4 Transplanting Established Trees: Advance Root Pruning, Tree Spades & Post-Planting Care
11 Chapter 11: Support Systems, Lightning Protection, Climbing, Rigging & Removal
11.1 Tree Support Systems: Dynamic vs Static Cabling, Bracing Rods & Guying (ANSI A300 Part 3) 11.2 Tree Lightning Protection Systems: Theory, Components & Installation (ANSI A300 Part 4) 11.3 Climbing Systems (SRS/MRS), Rigging Physics, Vector Forces & Controlled Removal 11.4 Tree Removal Work Planning: Site Assessment, Method Selection & Traffic Control
12 Chapter 12: Tree Risk Assessment & Management
12.1 Tree Risk Assessment Framework: Levels 1, 2, and 3 (ISA BMP & TRAQ) 12.2 Likelihood of Failure, Likelihood of Impact & ISA Risk Matrix Rating 12.3 Risk Mitigation Alternatives, Residual Risk & Client Communication 12.4 Risk Reporting, Documentation, Inspection Cycles & Programmatic Risk Management
13 Chapter 13: Plant Appraisal (CTLA) & Valuation Methodologies
13.1 Principles of Plant Appraisal (CTLA 10th Ed): Cost, Sales & Income Approaches 13.2 The Trunk Formula Technique (TFT): Formulas, Depreciation & Unit Costs 13.3 Appraisal Casework: Casualty Loss, Eminent Domain, Trespass & Defensibility
14 Chapter 14: Trees & Construction
14.1 Pre-Construction Planning: Tree Surveys, Preservation Plans & Suitability 14.2 Tree Protection Zones (TPZ), Critical Root Zones (CRZ) & Barrier Protocols 14.3 Pre-Construction Treatment Prescriptions & Clearance Preparation 14.4 Construction Impact Monitoring, Engineering Alternatives & Post-Care
15 Chapter 15: Tree Inventories & Urban Forest Management Plans
15.1 Urban Forest Inventories, GIS Mapping & Strategic Management Plans 15.2 Implementing the Urban Forest Management Plan: Service Levels, Budgeting, Ordinances & Performance Metrics
16 Chapter 16: Worker Safety & ANSI Z133
16.1 ANSI Z133 Safety Standards: Job Briefings, PPE, Drop Zones & Chipper Safety 16.2 Electrical Hazards: Minimum Approach Distances (MAD) & Emergency Protocols 16.3 Chain Saw Safety, Work Positioning Aloft & Aerial Rescue Readiness 16.4 Tool, Rope & Equipment Inspection, Maintenance and Retirement Criteria 16.5 Safety Program Management: Training, Competency, Emergency Response & Incident Investigation
17 Chapter 17: Business Relations, Law & Professional Ethics
17.1 ISA Code of Ethics, Legal Liability, Boundary Trees & Expert Testimony 17.2 Contracts, Proposals, Specifications & Business Operations 17.3 Regulatory Compliance: Licensing, Pesticide Law, Employment & Environmental Restrictions
12.2 Likelihood of Failure, Likelihood of Impact & ISA Risk Matrix Rating
Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI
The ISA TRAQ method employs a standardized two-tiered qualitative matrix system combining Likelihood of Failure and Likelihood of Impact (Matrix 1) to derive Likelihood of Failure & Impact, which is subsequently paired with Consequences of Failure (Matrix 2) to establish the final Risk Rating.
Likelihood of Failure is categorized across four defined thresholds: Improbable (unlikely under normal weather), Possible (could fail under normal weather), Probable (expected to fail under normal weather), and Imminent (failure has started or will occur momentarily within the time frame).
Consequences of Failure are scaled from Negligible through Minor, Significant, to Severe based on property value, personal injury potential, and critical infrastructure disruption.
Biomechanical shell adequacy in hollow stems is evaluated using Claus Mattheck's residual wall thickness ratio (t/R >= 0.30 to 0.33); when t/R drops below 0.30 or cavity opening width exceeds 30% of trunk circumference, shell buckling and torsional failure risks escalate dramatically.
Root plate anchorage failure is diagnosed by distinguishing natural self-correcting phototropic sweep (with reaction wood and upright leader) from recent mechanical lean marked by soil mounding, root breakage, and tension fissures.
Last updated: September 2026
12.2 Likelihood of Failure, Likelihood of Impact & ISA Risk Matrix Rating
The ISA Tree Risk Assessment Qualified (TRAQ) methodology eliminates arbitrary numerical point-scoring systems in favor of an objective, standardized two-matrix qualitative rating system . By separating the likelihood of an event from the magnitude of its consequences, the TRAQ framework allows the Board Certified Master Arborist (BCMA) to systematically evaluate structural defects, aerodynamic wind loads, and target exposure. Mastering this system requires deep familiarity with the definitions of likelihood, consequence tiers, matrix lookup mechanics, and the underlying biomechanical failure criteria of woody stems.
The ISA Qualitative Risk Framework THE TWO-TIERED ISA TRAQ RISK MATRIX FLOW
- +------------------------+ +------------------------+
- | Likelihood of Failure | | Likelihood of Impact |
- | (Improbable, Possible, | x | (Very Low, Low, |
- | Probable, Imminent) | | Medium, High) |
- +------------------------+ +------------------------+
- | |
- +--------------+---------------+
- |
- v
- ============================
- MATRIX 1: LIKELIHOOD MATRIX
- Yields: Likelihood of Failure & Impact
- (Unlikely, Somewhat Likely, Likely, Very Likely)
- ============================
- |
- +--------------+---------------+
- | |
- v v
- +-------------------------+ +-------------------------+
- | Likelihood of Failure | | Consequences of Fail |
- | & Impact | x | (Negligible, Minor, |
- | (from Matrix 1) | | Significant, Severe) |
- +-------------------------+ +-------------------------+
- | |
- +--------------+---------------+
- |
- v
- ============================
- MATRIX 2: RISK RATING MATRIX
- Yields: FINAL RISK RATING
- (Low, Moderate, High, Extreme)
- ============================
- The Standard Assessment Time Frame
Under ISA TRAQ standards, risk ratings are evaluated against a standard specified time frame—typically 1 year (12 months) unless explicitly stated otherwise. Likelihood of failure cannot be judged indefinitely because trees continually produce compensatory wood (reaction wood and woundwood), compartmentalize decay, or suffer progressive structural degradation. All likelihood ratings assume normal, expected regional weather conditions within that time frame, excluding catastrophic, design-exceeding phenomena like F4/F5 tornadoes or Category 4/5 hurricanes unless specific storm-hardening standards are under study.
- Categorizing Likelihood & Consequences
- Likelihood of Failure Categories
Improbable: Failure is not expected under normal, ambient weather conditions within the specified time frame (e.g., sound trunk, healthy branch union, minor superficial wound).
Possible: Failure could occur under normal weather conditions, but it is unlikely during the specified time frame (e.g., moderate cavity with adequate sound shell thickness, stable codominant stems with slight included bark).
Probable: Failure is expected under normal, anticipated weather conditions within the specified time frame (e.g., extensive basal rot exceeding failure thresholds, major dead scaffold branch overextended over a high-use area, active longitudinal shear crack).
Imminent: Failure has started, is actively occurring, or is expected momentarily under ambient weather conditions (e.g., freshly heaved root plate with snapped tension roots, stem fractured halfway through, split crotch actively opening and closing in the wind). Requires immediate emergency target exclusion or tree felling.
Likelihood of Impact Categories
Target impact likelihood depends on the occupancy rate and target location relative to the tree part's fall zone:
Very Low: The target zone is rarely or never occupied; targets are seldom present, or the tree part would fall into an unoccupied brush area or remote woodland.
Low: Infrequent or temporary occupancy (e.g., secondary maintenance trail, rarely visited corner of a residential backyard, access road used once weekly).
Medium: Intermittent or recurring occupancy (e.g., suburban driveway, park walking path, picnic table with predictable daily or weekend use, semi-frequented parking stalls).
High: Constant, continuous, or predictable high-density occupancy (e.g., primary occupied residence, day care facility, elementary school classroom, heavily traveled multi-lane arterial highway, primary rail line).
Matrix 1: Likelihood Matrix Lookup
Matrix 1 synthesizes the Likelihood of Failure and the Likelihood of Impact to establish the combined Likelihood of Failure & Impact :
Likelihood of Failure Likelihood of Impact: Very Low Likelihood of Impact: Low Likelihood of Impact: Medium Likelihood of Impact: High
- Imminent Unlikely Somewhat Likely Likely Very Likely
- Probable Unlikely Unlikely Somewhat Likely Likely
- Possible Unlikely Unlikely Unlikely Somewhat Likely
- Improbable Unlikely Unlikely Unlikely Unlikely
- Consequences of Failure Categories
Consequences are based on the value of property, the potential for personal injury, and the disruption of critical societal infrastructure:
Negligible: Minor, low-cost property damage that is easily repaired or replaced (e.g., damaged turf, broken landscape shrub, broken clay flowerpot); no personal injury.
Minor: Low-to-moderate repairable property damage (e.g., crushed chain-link fence, dented garden shed roof, cracked windshield); minor personal injury requiring basic first aid on scene.
Significant: Substantial structural property damage (e.g., crushed vehicle, structural penetration of residential roof, damaged outbuilding); serious personal injury requiring emergency medical hospitalization; disruption of secondary public roads or localized utility distribution lines.
Severe: Catastrophic structural collapse of an occupied primary residence, school, or commercial building; permanent disabling personal injury or loss of human life; prolonged disruption of critical lifeline utilities (e.g., municipal water supply mains, regional high-voltage transmission lines, hospital power feed).
Matrix 2: Risk Rating Matrix Lookup
Matrix 2 pairs the Likelihood of Failure & Impact (derived from Matrix 1) with the Consequences of Failure to generate the final qualitative Risk Rating :
Likelihood of Failure & Impact Consequences: Negligible Consequences: Minor Consequences: Significant Consequences: Severe
- Very Likely Low Moderate High Extreme
- Likely Low Moderate High High
- Somewhat Likely Low Low Moderate Moderate
- Unlikely Low Low Low Low
- Understanding the Final Risk Ratings
Low Risk: Low failure likelihood or negligible consequences. Minor defects that require no immediate intervention; standard routine re-inspection cycle.
Moderate Risk: Mitigation actions are typically recommended, but work can be scheduled as part of standard planned maintenance budgets.
High Risk: Serious defects with high target occupancy. Requires prompt mitigation (pruning, target management, cabling, or removal) within days to weeks.
Extreme Risk: Imminent failure threatening high-value targets or human life with severe consequences. Demands immediate emergency intervention (evacuation, street closure, target exclusion, or immediate felling).
Biomechanical Assessment of Key Structural Defects
A qualitative risk rating must be grounded in precise biomechanical analysis of wood strength, geometry, and loading dynamics. HOLLOW CYLINDER & T/R BUCKLING THRESHOLD
- +-----------------------------+ <--- Outer Radius (R)
- | SOUND WOOD SHELL |
- | +---------------------+ | <--- Residual Wall Thickness (t)
- | | | |
- | | INTERNAL CAVITY | |
- | | (DECAY COLUMN) | |
- | | | |
- | +---------------------+ |
- | t / R >= 0.30 - 0.33 |
- +-----------------------------+
- [t/R < 0.30]: Thin shell undergoes tangential buckling (flattening)
- [Open Cavity > 30% Circumference]: Torsional shear failure occurs
- 1. Internal Wood Decay & Stem Hollows: The t/R Ratio
Trees are optimized composite load-bearing columns. When internal heartwood decays, the trunk functions mechanically as a hollow tube or cylinder. In classic engineering beam theory, the outer fibers of a cylinder resist the vast majority of bending moments, while the central core experiences minimal stress.
Mattheck's t/R Criterion: German biomechanicist Claus Mattheck established the foundational rule of thumb for hollow stem stability: t R ≥ 0.30 to 0.33 \frac{t}{R} \ge 0.30\text{ to }0.33 R t ≥ 0.30 to 0.33 where t is the residual sound wood shell thickness and R is the radius of the stem (or t/D ≥ 0.15, where D is diameter).
Mechanisms of Shell Buckling: As long as the sound wood shell thickness is at least 30% to 33% of the trunk radius, the trunk retains substantial bending strength. However, when decay progresses and t/R falls below 0.30 , the outer shell becomes vulnerable to transverse shell buckling (flattening/kinking) . Under wind loads, compressive forces on the leeward side cause the thin shell to buckle outward or collapse inward like a crushed aluminum can, leading to catastrophic snap-off.
Cavity Openings and Circumferential Disruption: The t/R ratio assumes a complete, closed cylinder of sound wood. If the cavity is open to the exterior (an open cavity or "C-shaped" cross-section):
The 30% Opening Rule: If the circumferential width of the cavity opening (C(cavity)) exceeds 30% of the total trunk circumference (C(cavity) / C(trunk) > 0.30, or an opening arc > 120°), the cross-section loses its closed-tube structural efficiency.
Torsional Shear Failure: Under swirling, turbulent winds, trees experience intense torsional twisting. An open cavity cannot transmit shear stresses circumferentially; the edges of the opening curl inward or slide past each other, leading to rapid longitudinal splitting and collapse.
Longitudinal versus Circumferential Decay: Fungi that form vertical, cylindrical decay columns within heartwood (e.g., Laetiporus , Phaeolus ) leave outer sapwood rings intact, maintaining functional beam capacity. In contrast, fungi or defects that spread circumferentially or cause ring shake (delamination between annual rings) destroy the composite shear transfer between wood layers, multiplying failure risk.
2. Cracks and Mechanical Fissures
Cracks represent planar mechanical separations of wood fibers and are among the most dangerous structural defects: STRUCTURAL CRACK TYPES & FAILURE SIGNATURES
- [Transverse Tensile Crack] [Ribbed Shear Crack (Longitudinal)]
- (Horizontally Across Grain) (Vertically Along Grain)
- | |
- v v
- Xylem fibers pulled apart - Formed by torsional twisting
- Ultimate tensile yield exceeded - Tree forms longitudinal woundwood ribs
- Failure IMMINENT under wind - "Ram's horns" if curled into cavity
Transverse Tensile Cracks: Cracks that run horizontally across the wood grain on the tension side of a leaning stem or bend. These indicate that the wood fibers have exceeded their ultimate tensile yield strength and have physically torn apart. A transverse tensile crack indicates active, imminent mechanical failure ; the remaining section cannot sustain additional wind load.
Ribbed Longitudinal Cracks (Shear Cracks): Vertical cracks running along the grain, frequently associated with internal decay or frost action. Under wind-induced twisting (torsion), the opposing sides of the crack slide back and forth. The tree attempts to stabilize the shear crack by forming pronounced longitudinal ridges of dense woundwood ( woundwood ribs or "ram's horns" if the woundwood curls inward into an internal hollow).
Frost Cracks: Radial longitudinal splits initiated from internal wood wounds during rapid temperature drops in sub-zero winter conditions. While aesthetically alarming, frost cracks that form sound external woundwood ribs without internal decay rarely cause whole-tree failure.
3. Codominant Stems with Included Bark
Codominant stems occur when two or more stems of similar diameter arise from a single junction without a dominant leader:
Anatomy of the Union: In a structurally sound U-shaped branch junction, wood fibers from the branch and trunk grow together and interlock across the branch bark ridge, forming a strong mechanical collar.
The Included Bark Mechanism: In a narrow, V-shaped codominant junction, the stems press tightly against each other as they expand radially. Instead of interlocking xylem, the bark is pinched and folded inward between the stems ( included bark ).
The Compressive Wedge: The trapped bark acts as a continuous internal mechanical wedge. With every millimeter of annual radial growth, the expanding stems push each other apart, generating high internal tensile stresses across the apex of the crotch.
Asynchronous Sway & Dynamic Cleavage: During storm events, wind causes the two codominant canopies to sway asynchronously (out of phase). The stems pull apart, subjecting the unjoined crotch to massive cleavage forces. The junction is held together only by a thin band of outer sapwood along the lateral perimeter, resulting in high probability of catastrophic splitting. CODOMINANT UNION BIOMECHANICS
- U-Shaped Sound Union V-Shaped with Included Bark
- \ / \ /
- \ / \ /
- \ BBR / <-- Interlocking Xylem \ ! / <-- Trapped Bark Wedge
- \ / Branch Bark Ridge \ / (No Fiber Union)
- | | V <----- Compressive Cleavage
- | | / \
- 4. Leaning Trees and Root Plate Stability
Distinguishing between benign, adaptive leaning trees and unstable, failing leaning trees is one of the most critical diagnostic challenges for the BCMA:
Diagnostic Feature Self-Correcting Phototropic Lean Recent Mechanical Failure Lean
Trunk Morphology Curved trunk ("sweep"); vertical crown reorientation Completely straight trunk tilting uniformly from ground
Reaction Wood Abundant compression (conifers) or tension (hardwoods) Insufficient time to develop compensatory reaction wood
Soil / Root Flare Intact, undisturbed soil line; strong buttress flares Fresh soil mounding, heaved turf on tension side
Root Integrity Structural roots sound, anchored, and grafted Freshly snapped structural roots; soil fissures
Canopy Architecture Upper branches adapted vertically to sunlight Upper canopy tilted at identical angle to trunk