Study guide

1.5 Classifying the Common Causes of Occupational Accidents

PECB ISO 45001 Lead Auditor Exam

Track your progress as you read

Finished sections get a check mark.

1 Introduction & Exam Overview

About the PECB ISO 45001 Lead Auditor Exam

2 Chapter 1: OH&S Management Systems & ISO 45001 Fundamentals

1.1 OHSAS 18001 to ISO 45001:2018 Evolution & Annex SL Structure 1.2 Core OH&S Terminology & Definitions 1.3 The PDCA Cycle & Risk-Based Thinking in OH&S 1.4 Organizations, Human Rights & Labour Practices in OH&S 1.5 Classifying the Common Causes of Occupational Accidents

3 Chapter 2: Organizational Context & Worker Leadership (Clauses 4 & 5)

2.1 Clause 4: Organizational Context, Interested Parties & Scope 2.2 Clause 5.1–5.3: Leadership, Commitment & OH&S Policy 2.3 Clause 5.4: Worker Consultation & Participation

4 Chapter 3: Planning for Hazard Identification & Risk Assessment (Clause 6.1)

3.1 Clause 6.1.1–6.1.2.1: Proactive Hazard Identification Methodologies 3.2 Clause 6.1.2.2–6.1.2.3: Assessment of OH&S Risks & Opportunities 3.3 Clause 6.1.3: Legal and Other Compliance Obligations

5 Chapter 4: OH&S Objectives & Support Mechanisms (Clauses 6.2 & 7)

4.1 Clause 6.2: Measurable OH&S Objectives & Planning to Achieve Them 4.2 Clause 7.1–7.4: Competence, Awareness & Communication 4.3 Clause 7.5: Documented Information Control & Retention

6 Chapter 5: Operational Planning & The Hierarchy of Controls (Clause 8.1)

5.1 Clause 8.1.1–8.1.2: Operational Controls & The Hierarchy of Controls 5.2 Clause 8.1.3: Management of Change Processes 5.3 Clause 8.1.4: Procurement, Contractors & Outsourcing Controls

7 Chapter 6: Emergency Response & Performance Evaluation (Clauses 8.2 & 9.1)

6.1 Clause 8.2: Emergency Preparedness, Response & Drills 6.2 Clause 9.1.1: Monitoring, Measurement, Analysis & OH&S Performance 6.3 Clause 9.1.2: Evaluation of Legal and Regulatory Compliance

8 Chapter 7: Internal Audit, Management Review & Improvement (Clauses 9.2, 9.3 & 10)

7.1 Clause 9.2: Internal Audit Programme & Auditor Impartiality 7.2 Clause 9.3: Management Review Inputs, Outputs & Governance 7.3 Clause 10: Incident Investigation, Nonconformity & Corrective Action

9 Chapter 8: Principles of Auditing & Audit Programme Management (ISO 19011)

8.1 Seven Principles of Auditing under ISO 19011 8.2 Managing an Audit Programme: Planning, Risks & Resources 8.3 Certification Cycles & Audit Types under ISO/IEC 17021-1 8.4 Materiality & Reasonable Assurance in OH&S MS Audits 8.5 The Audit Risk Model: Inherent, Control & Detection Risk 8.6 Legal Implications, Irregularities & Auditor Negligence

10 Chapter 9: Audit Preparation & Stage 1 Audit Execution

9.1 Initiating the Audit, Team Roles & Feasibility Determination 9.2 Stage 1 Audit: Objectives, Documentation Review & Readiness Assessment 9.3 Developing the Audit Plan, Checklists & Sampling Plan 9.4 Terms of the Audit Engagement, Initial Contact & Cultural Considerations 9.5 The Seven Types of Audit Evidence 9.6 Audit Working Papers & Audit Test Plans

11 Chapter 10: Conducting Stage 2 On-Site Audit & Evidence Collection

10.1 Opening Meeting Protocol & On-Site Audit Coordination 10.2 Interviewing Techniques for Workers & Management 10.3 Observation of Workplaces & Audit Sampling Methodologies 10.4 Conflict Resolution & Managing Difficult Audit Situations

12 Chapter 11: Audit Trails, Evidence Triangulation & Nonconformity Writing

11.1 Following Audit Trails & Triangulating Evidence 11.2 Grading Findings: Major NC, Minor NC & Opportunities for Improvement 11.3 Drafting Auditable Nonconformity Reports (NCRs) 11.4 Benefit of the Doubt, Anomalies & the Full Findings Spectrum

13 Chapter 12: Audit Closing, Corrective Action Verification & Auditor Ethics

12.1 Closing Meeting Conduct & Formal Audit Reporting 12.2 Root Cause Analysis Evaluation & Corrective Action Follow-Up 12.3 Auditor Competence, CPD & PECB Code of Ethics 12.4 Quality Review of Audit Documentation & Report Approval

1.5 Classifying the Common Causes of Occupational Accidents

Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI

ISO 45001 distinguishes an incident (an occurrence arising out of work that could or does result in injury and ill health) from an accident, which is an incident where injury or ill health actually occurred.

The classical causation methodology separates immediate causes (unsafe acts and unsafe conditions) from underlying or basic causes (personal and job factors) and from root causes (management system failures).

Heinrich's domino theory and 300:29:1 ratio popularised near-miss reporting, while Bird's 1969 study produced the 600:30:10:1 ratio using a far larger data set.

Reason's Swiss cheese model reframes accidents as the alignment of latent organizational conditions with active failures, which is why ISO 45001 Clause 10.2 requires the organization to look beyond the injured worker.

An auditor must treat "worker carelessness" as an unfinished analysis: stopping at an unsafe act leaves the management system cause undetected and the corrective action ineffective.

Last updated: September 2026

1.5 Classifying the Common Causes of Occupational Accidents

PECB requires the auditor to know the methodology used to classify the common causes of occupational accidents and the relationship of hazard and workplace . This knowledge is what allows you to judge, on the spot, whether an auditee's incident investigation under Clause 10.2 is genuine analysis or a paperwork exercise ending in "operator error".

1. Vocabulary First: Incident, Accident, Near Miss

ISO 45001:2018 Clause 3.35 defines an incident as an occurrence arising out of, or in the course of, work that could or does result in injury and ill health. Two notes attached to that definition carry the whole classification scheme:

An incident where injury and ill health occurs is commonly referred to as an "accident" .

An incident where no injury and ill health occurs, but has the potential to do so , may be referred to as a "near miss", "near hit" or "close call" .

  • Term Harm occurred? Potential for harm? ISO 45001 treatment
  • Accident Yes Yes An incident (3.35) — investigate under 10.2
  • Near miss / near hit / close call No Yes An incident (3.35) — investigate under 10.2
  • Nonconformity Not necessarily — Non-fulfilment of a requirement (3.34)

The examinable consequence: ISO 45001 has one operative term, "incident", and it covers both accidents and near misses. An organization whose procedure requires investigation only where a person was hurt has narrowed the scope of Clause 10.2 and is nonconforming — near misses are incidents and must be within the process.

Hazard and workplace

Clause 3.19 defines a hazard as a source with a potential to cause injury and ill health. Clause 3.6 defines a workplace as a place under the control of the organization where a person needs to be or go for work purposes. The relationship examined by PECB is one of exposure : a hazard produces risk only where a worker's presence in a workplace creates exposure to it. This is why hazard identification under Clause 6.1.2.1 must consider workplace design, equipment, work organization, social factors, and situations arising outside the immediate workplace that can adversely affect health and safety within it.

2. The Cause Hierarchy: Immediate, Underlying, Root

The dominant classification methodology sorts causes into three tiers. Auditors use it as a scoring rubric against any investigation report.

Tier 1 — Immediate (direct) causes

The acts and conditions present at the moment of the event.

Unsafe acts (behaviour): operating without authority, bypassing an interlock, failing to isolate energy, removing a guard, working at speed, incorrect PPE use, horseplay.

Unsafe conditions (physical state): defective tools, inadequate machine guarding, poor housekeeping, insufficient ventilation, inadequate illumination, excessive noise, exposed live conductors, unstable stacking.

Tier 2 — Underlying (basic) causes

Why the act or condition existed.

Personal factors: inadequate physical or mental capability, lack of knowledge or skill, stress, fatigue, improper motivation, unfamiliarity with the task.

Job/system factors: inadequate supervision, deficient engineering design, defective procurement, inadequate maintenance, worn tools, poor work standards, abuse or misuse tolerated over time.

Tier 3 — Root causes

The management system deficiencies that allowed the underlying causes to persist: absent or inadequate standards, standards not communicated, standards not enforced, no verification of compliance, no competence assessment, no management of change, no worker consultation mechanism.

Only Tier 3 generates a corrective action that prevents recurrence. Correcting Tier 1 is correction , not corrective action — a distinction ISO 45001 Clause 10.2 draws explicitly and one the exam tests repeatedly.

  • Investigation stops at… Typical corrective action offered Auditor verdict
  • Immediate cause "Retrain the worker"; "issue a warning" Inadequate — recurrence certain
  • Underlying cause "Revise the maintenance schedule" Partial — system gap untested
  • Root cause "Standard absent; establish, communicate, verify" Acceptable
  • 3. The Three Causation Models You Are Expected to Recognise
  • Heinrich's domino theory and the 300:29:1 ratio (1931)

H. W. Heinrich modelled an accident as five falling dominoes: ancestry/social environment → fault of person → unsafe act or unsafe condition → accident → injury. Removing the middle domino (the unsafe act/condition) stops the sequence. From reviewing insurance claims he proposed that for every 1 major injury there are 29 minor injuries and 300 no-injury accidents .

Its contribution: it created the case for investigating near misses — the 300 events are free information about the mechanism that will eventually produce the 1.

Its defect: Heinrich attributed roughly 88% of accidents to unsafe acts by people, which drives blame-based investigation. Modern practice, and ISO 45001, reject that emphasis.

Bird's accident ratio (1969)

Frank E. Bird Jr. analysed 1.75 million incident reports across 297 companies and produced the ratio 1 serious injury : 10 minor injuries : 30 property damage accidents : 600 near misses . Bird's contribution was the loss causation model , adding lack of control by management as the first domino — the direct conceptual ancestor of a management-system standard.

Reason's Swiss cheese model (1990)

James Reason distinguishes:

Active failures — unsafe acts by people in direct contact with the system, whose effects are felt immediately.

Latent conditions — "resident pathogens" created by decisions taken far upstream: understaffing, poor design, unworkable procedures, production pressure, deficient training budgets.

Defences are layers of cheese; holes are weaknesses that open and close. An accident occurs when holes in successive layers momentarily align. Latent conditions are the root causes; active failures are the immediate causes. This is the model that best explains the ISO 45001 requirement in Clause 10.2 to determine whether similar incidents exist or could potentially occur, and to review the effectiveness of existing controls rather than the conduct of the injured person.

4. Audit Application

When sampling incident records, test the investigation against the hierarchy:

Scope test: does the process capture near misses, ill health, and incidents involving contractors and visitors — or only lost-time injuries to employees?

Depth test: does the analysis reach a management system cause, or terminate at the worker?

Consultation test: Clause 5.4 requires participation of non-managerial workers in incident investigation. Was the workforce involved, or was the report written by the safety department alone?

Hierarchy test: Clause 10.2 requires the organization to determine and implement action, including corrective action, in accordance with the hierarchy of controls . An action plan consisting only of retraining and a toolbox talk sits entirely at the administrative tier and has not applied the hierarchy.

Effectiveness test: was the effectiveness of the corrective action reviewed, and were the risks and opportunities re-evaluated?

Worked example. A worker suffers a hand laceration clearing a jam in a conveyor. The investigation records the cause as "employee reached into machine while running — disciplinary warning issued". An auditor applies the hierarchy: the immediate cause is the unsafe act; the underlying cause is that jams occur several times per shift and the isolation procedure takes eleven minutes, creating production pressure; the root cause is that no management of change was performed when throughput was increased and the guard interlock design was never reassessed. The corrective action offered addresses only the immediate cause and sits at the administrative tier. The auditor raises a nonconformity against Clause 10.2 — the organization did not determine the root causes of the incident and did not act in accordance with the hierarchy of controls — and notes the Clause 8.1.3 management-of-change failure as a linked audit trail.

Loading diagram... Cause Classification Hierarchy and Corresponding Corrective Action Depth