Study guide

6.2 Basis of Design, Alternatives Evaluation & the Preferred Scheme

Landscape Architect Registration Examination L.A.R.E.

Track your progress as you read

Finished sections get a check mark.

1 Chapter 1: Project Management, Legal Framework & Contracts

1.1 Professional Practice, Ethics & the HSW Mandate 1.2 Standard of Care, Responsible Charge & Sealing Documents 1.3 Professional Services Agreements & Contract Clauses 1.4 Fee Structures, Compensation Models & Billing 1.5 Project Scheduling, CPM & Budget Management 1.6 Risk Management, Professional Liability & Insurance

2 Chapter 2: Site Inventory, Surveying & Regulatory Framework

2.1 Boundary Surveys, Legal Descriptions & Survey Datums 2.2 Topographic Surveys, Easements & Encumbrances 2.3 Desktop Inventory, GIS Data & Field Reconnaissance 2.4 Policy Documents & Prior Planning Studies 2.5 Adjacent Land Use & Contextual Data Collection 2.6 Stakeholder Engagement & Public Participation 2.7 Zoning Frameworks, Dimensional Standards & FAR 2.8 Parking Standards, Buffer Yards & Zoning Relief 2.9 Clean Water Act Permitting & NEPA Review 2.10 ESA, Floodplain, Coastal & Historic Preservation Compliance

3 Chapter 3: Physical, Contextual & Environmental Site Analysis

3.1 Scoping Site Analysis & Synthesizing Opportunities and Constraints 3.2 Geotechnical Investigation & Soil Classification Systems 3.3 Problematic Soil Conditions & Agronomic Soil Quality 3.4 Topographic Interpretation & Slope Suitability 3.5 Watershed Mechanics, Stream Order & FEMA Flood Hazard Zones 3.6 Wetland Delineation, Classification & Riparian Buffers 3.7 Utility Analysis & Infrastructure Capacity 3.8 Visual Resource & Viewshed Analysis 3.9 Contextual Analysis: Appropriate Use & Future Development Impacts 3.10 Microclimates, Solar Orientation & Vegetation Analysis

4 Chapter 4: Stewardship, Climate Resiliency & Design Principles

4.1 SITES v2 & LEED Site Credit Rating Systems 4.2 Life-Cycle Assessment, Embodied Carbon & Ecosystem Services 4.3 Climate Resiliency, Adaptation & Urban Heat Island Mitigation 4.4 Environmental Justice & Social Equity in Site Design 4.5 Cultural Landscapes, Historic Preservation & Adaptive Reuse

5 Chapter 5: Master Planning, Programming & Land Use

5.1 Project Visioning, Goal Setting & Space Programming 5.2 Carrying Capacity Analysis & NRPA Park Classification Standards 5.3 Site Suitability Synthesis & Opportunities/Constraints Mapping 5.4 Land Use Allocation & Development Scenario Evaluation 5.5 Master Plan Deliverables & Design Guidelines 5.6 Capital Improvement Programming, Phasing & Implementation

6 Chapter 6: Schematic Design & Spatial Organization

6.1 Design Intent, Conceptual Diagrams & Form Generation 6.2 Basis of Design, Alternatives Evaluation & the Preferred Scheme 6.3 Spatial Hierarchy, Outdoor Rooms & Proportion 6.4 Pedestrian Circulation Networks & Environmental Wayfinding 6.5 ADA & PROWAG Accessible Route Design 6.6 Multimodal Transportation, Vehicular Circulation & Parking Layout

7 Chapter 7: Design Development, Materials & Planting Systems

7.1 Paving Systems: Rigid, Flexible & Unit Pavers 7.2 Retaining Walls, Earth Pressure & Wall Drainage 7.3 Wall System Selection, Fences, Screens & Gates 7.4 Site Furnishings: Selection, Materiality & Anchoring 7.5 Exterior Lighting, Photometrics, Dark Sky & Electrical Safety 7.6 Public Playground Safety: CPSC & ASTM Standards 7.7 Planting Design Principles & Ecological Matching 7.8 Water Conservation, Xeriscaping & Irrigation System Principles 7.9 Opinions of Probable Cost & Value Engineering

8 Chapter 8: Construction Drawings, Layout & Detailing

8.1 Drawing Set Hierarchy, Sheet Standards & Drafting Conventions 8.2 Interdisciplinary Coordination & QA/QC Review 8.3 Demolition Plans & Tree Protection Requirements 8.4 Site Preparation: Clearing, Grubbing, Topsoil & Utility Abandonment 8.5 Layout, Dimensioning & Materials Plans 8.6 Planting Plans, Plant Schedules & Installation Details 8.7 Technical Detailing: Pavements, Curbs & Joint Assemblies 8.8 Retaining Wall, Stair & Ramp Detailing Standards

9 Chapter 9: Construction Specifications & Bidding

9.1 CSI MasterFormat Divisions & SectionFormat Structure 9.2 Specification Writing Methods & the Drawings–Specifications Relationship 9.3 Project Manual, General Conditions & Front-End Documents 9.4 Bid Requirements, Bid Forms & Addenda Management 9.5 Pre-Bid Procedures, Bid Opening & Contractor Evaluation

10 Chapter 10: Construction Administration, Submittals & Changes

10.1 Pre-Construction Conference & Construction Administration Authority 10.2 Initial Decision Maker, Communication Protocols & Project Records 10.3 Submittals, Shop Drawings, Product Data & Samples 10.4 Requests for Information (RFIs) & Technical Clarifications 10.5 Change Orders, Construction Change Directives & Claims

11 Chapter 11: Field Observation, Quality Control & Close-Out

11.1 Field Observations, Site Reports & Non-Conforming Work 11.2 Quality Control, Material Testing & Inspections 11.3 Substantial Completion, Punch Lists & Retainage 11.4 Project Close-Out, Guarantees, Warranties & Final Acceptance

12 Chapter 12: Contour Interpretation, Grading & Earthwork Calculations

12.1 Contour Rules & Topographic Landform Interpretation 12.2 Spot Elevations & Contour Interpolation Calculations 12.3 Slope Formulas, Maximum Gradients & Cross Slopes 12.4 Earthwork Calculations: Average End Area & Grid Methods 12.5 Cut and Fill Balancing, Shrinkage, Swell & Mass Haul 12.6 Reviewing Grading Design: Error Detection & Constructability

13 Chapter 13: Stormwater Hydrology, Runoff & BMP Design

13.1 Hydrologic Cycle, Watershed Delineation & Time of Concentration 13.2 Peak Runoff Estimation: The Rational Method (Q = CiA) 13.3 NRCS Curve Number Method & Runoff Hydrographs 13.4 LID Principles, Water Quality Volume & Bioretention Design 13.5 Bioswales, Permeable Pavement, Green Roofs & Harvesting

14 Chapter 14: Site Drainage Systems, Hydraulics & Erosion Control

14.1 Open Channel Hydraulics, Manning’s Equation & Swale Design 14.2 Gutter Flow, Spread & Roadway Inlet Hydraulics 14.3 Subsurface Drainage, Catch Basins & Pipe Invert Calculations 14.4 Stormwater Storage: Detention, Retention & Water Quality Basins 14.5 Reviewing Drainage Plans & Evaluating Design Alternatives 14.6 Erosion Mechanics, RUSLE & the NPDES/SWPPP Framework 14.7 Erosion & Sediment Control BMPs, Basins & Site Stabilization

6.2 Basis of Design, Alternatives Evaluation & the Preferred Scheme

Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI

The Basis of Design records the criteria, assumptions, standards, and performance targets a design must satisfy, and is the document against which alternatives are evaluated and later changes are measured.

Design alternatives must be genuinely distinct in organizing concept, not variations in furniture layout, or the evaluation produces a predetermined result.

Evaluation criteria and their weights must be fixed and agreed before alternatives are scored, because weights assigned after scoring simply ratify a preference.

A weighted evaluation matrix documents the reasoning behind a selection; its value is the recorded rationale, not the arithmetic total.

Refinement of the preferred alternative should incorporate the strongest features of the rejected schemes rather than discarding them wholesale.

Last updated: September 2026

1. Three Tasks, One Workflow

The Schematic Design content area carries 28% of the Planning and Design section and includes three sequential tasks that the exam treats as one professional workflow:

  • Create the Basis for Design — fix the criteria before drawing
  • Evaluate Design Alternatives — test distinct schemes against those criteria
  • Refine Selected Alternatives — develop the preferred scheme and absorb the best of the rejects

Skipping the first step is what makes the second step meaningless.

2. The Basis of Design Document

The Basis of Design (BOD) is the written record of what the design must achieve and the assumptions on which it rests. It is distinct from the program: the program states what (quantities, uses, areas); the BOD states how well and under what constraints .

A landscape BOD typically records:

Category Content

Performance criteria Stormwater release rate and water quality volume, accessible route standards, illumination levels, capacity targets, maintenance level of service

Applicable standards Adopted codes, ADA/PROWAG, CPSC and ASTM for play, NPDES permit conditions, agency design manuals with edition dates

Design assumptions Assumed soil bearing, seasonal high water table, design storm, design vehicle, projected user counts

Owner requirements Operations and maintenance capability, budget, phasing, durability and life expectancy

Site constraints carried forward Absolute constraints from the analysis synthesis, easements, prior commitments

Why it matters later. During construction administration, an RFI or substitution request is evaluated against the Basis of Design. When the BOD states "planting soil shall achieve an infiltration rate of not less than 2 inches per hour," a substitution proposing a heavier media has a documented standard to fail against. Without a BOD, the argument becomes a matter of taste.

The BOD is also the instrument that makes design assumptions falsifiable . Stating "assumed seasonal high water table at 48 inches, to be confirmed by geotechnical investigation" converts a hidden assumption into a tracked verification item.

3. Generating Genuinely Distinct Alternatives

The most common failure in alternatives evaluation is the straw man : presenting one developed scheme and two deliberately weak options so that the preferred scheme wins. Reviewers and clients recognize this, and it destroys the credibility of the process.

Distinct alternatives differ in organizing concept , not in detail:

Genuinely distinct Not distinct

Concentrated development on the upland with the lowland preserved, versus dispersed development across both The same plan with the parking rotated

Vehicular access from the north arterial versus from the south local street The same access with a different curb radius

Stormwater managed in a single regional basin versus distributed LID cells The same basin with different planting

Program organized around a central commons versus along a linear spine The same commons with different paving

Each alternative must be developed to comparable resolution . Comparing a fully studied scheme against two sketches is a straw man by another route.

  • 4. Evaluation: Criteria, Weights, and the Matrix
  • The sequence that makes evaluation honest
  • Define criteria from the Basis of Design and the program goals
  • Assign weights reflecting relative importance, with the client and stakeholders
  • Lock criteria and weights before scoring
  • Score each alternative against each criterion, with a written rationale for each score
  • Compute and review , then interrogate the result

Weights must precede scoring. Assigning weights after the scores are known allows the evaluator to tune the weights until the preferred scheme wins, which converts an analytical tool into a justification device.

A worked structure

  • Criterion Weight Alt A raw Alt A wtd Alt B raw Alt B wtd Alt C raw Alt C wtd
  • Habitat and tree canopy preservation 25% 3 0.75 5 1.25 4 1.00
  • Capital cost 20% 5 1.00 2 0.40 3 0.60
  • Accessibility and connectivity 20% 4 0.80 3 0.60 5 1.00
  • Stormwater performance 15% 2 0.30 5 0.75 4 0.60
  • Operations and maintenance burden 10% 4 0.40 2 0.20 3 0.30
  • Phasing flexibility 10% 3 0.30 3 0.30 5 0.50
  • Total 100% 3.55 3.50 4.00

Alternative C scores highest, but the matrix's real output is the pattern : A is cheap and easy to maintain but performs poorly ecologically; B is the ecological performer at the highest cost; C is balanced and the most phasable. That pattern, not the decimal, is what the client decides on.

Read the matrix, do not obey it. Scores within roughly 10% of each other are not meaningfully different given the subjectivity of raw scoring. When totals are that close, the decision should be made on the criterion the client cares about most, and that reasoning should be recorded.

Sensitivity testing

A defensible evaluation includes a check: if the weight on the single most contested criterion is raised or lowered by 10 percentage points, does the ranking change? If it does, the selection is weight-driven rather than performance-driven, and that fact must be disclosed.

5. Refining the Selected Alternative

Refinement is not simply drawing the winner at a larger scale. Three moves define it:

Absorb the best features of the rejected schemes. If Alternative B's distributed stormwater approach outperformed C's, the refined C should adopt it where compatible. Alternatives are a source of ideas, not a tournament with one survivor.

Resolve the weaknesses the matrix exposed. The criteria on which the preferred scheme scored lowest are the refinement agenda.

Test the refined scheme against the Basis of Design again. Refinement introduces change, and change can break a performance criterion that the original scheme satisfied.

The deliverable is a single refined schematic plan with supporting sections, a program confirmation, a preliminary opinion of probable cost, and a written record of why this scheme was selected. That written record is what protects the decision when a new stakeholder joins the project six months later and asks why the other option was not chosen.

6. Exam Traps & Pitfalls

Scoring before weighting. Weights set after scores are known ratify a preference rather than test one.

Straw-man alternatives. Options must differ in organizing concept and be developed to comparable resolution.

Treating the matrix total as the decision. Totals within about 10% are not meaningfully different.

Discarding rejected schemes entirely. Refinement should absorb their strongest features.

Confusing the program with the Basis of Design. The program states quantities; the BOD states performance criteria and assumptions.