Study guide

14.5 Reviewing Drainage Plans & Evaluating Design Alternatives

Landscape Architect Registration Examination L.A.R.E.

Track your progress as you read

Finished sections get a check mark.

1 Chapter 1: Project Management, Legal Framework & Contracts

1.1 Professional Practice, Ethics & the HSW Mandate 1.2 Standard of Care, Responsible Charge & Sealing Documents 1.3 Professional Services Agreements & Contract Clauses 1.4 Fee Structures, Compensation Models & Billing 1.5 Project Scheduling, CPM & Budget Management 1.6 Risk Management, Professional Liability & Insurance

2 Chapter 2: Site Inventory, Surveying & Regulatory Framework

2.1 Boundary Surveys, Legal Descriptions & Survey Datums 2.2 Topographic Surveys, Easements & Encumbrances 2.3 Desktop Inventory, GIS Data & Field Reconnaissance 2.4 Policy Documents & Prior Planning Studies 2.5 Adjacent Land Use & Contextual Data Collection 2.6 Stakeholder Engagement & Public Participation 2.7 Zoning Frameworks, Dimensional Standards & FAR 2.8 Parking Standards, Buffer Yards & Zoning Relief 2.9 Clean Water Act Permitting & NEPA Review 2.10 ESA, Floodplain, Coastal & Historic Preservation Compliance

3 Chapter 3: Physical, Contextual & Environmental Site Analysis

3.1 Scoping Site Analysis & Synthesizing Opportunities and Constraints 3.2 Geotechnical Investigation & Soil Classification Systems 3.3 Problematic Soil Conditions & Agronomic Soil Quality 3.4 Topographic Interpretation & Slope Suitability 3.5 Watershed Mechanics, Stream Order & FEMA Flood Hazard Zones 3.6 Wetland Delineation, Classification & Riparian Buffers 3.7 Utility Analysis & Infrastructure Capacity 3.8 Visual Resource & Viewshed Analysis 3.9 Contextual Analysis: Appropriate Use & Future Development Impacts 3.10 Microclimates, Solar Orientation & Vegetation Analysis

4 Chapter 4: Stewardship, Climate Resiliency & Design Principles

4.1 SITES v2 & LEED Site Credit Rating Systems 4.2 Life-Cycle Assessment, Embodied Carbon & Ecosystem Services 4.3 Climate Resiliency, Adaptation & Urban Heat Island Mitigation 4.4 Environmental Justice & Social Equity in Site Design 4.5 Cultural Landscapes, Historic Preservation & Adaptive Reuse

5 Chapter 5: Master Planning, Programming & Land Use

5.1 Project Visioning, Goal Setting & Space Programming 5.2 Carrying Capacity Analysis & NRPA Park Classification Standards 5.3 Site Suitability Synthesis & Opportunities/Constraints Mapping 5.4 Land Use Allocation & Development Scenario Evaluation 5.5 Master Plan Deliverables & Design Guidelines 5.6 Capital Improvement Programming, Phasing & Implementation

6 Chapter 6: Schematic Design & Spatial Organization

6.1 Design Intent, Conceptual Diagrams & Form Generation 6.2 Basis of Design, Alternatives Evaluation & the Preferred Scheme 6.3 Spatial Hierarchy, Outdoor Rooms & Proportion 6.4 Pedestrian Circulation Networks & Environmental Wayfinding 6.5 ADA & PROWAG Accessible Route Design 6.6 Multimodal Transportation, Vehicular Circulation & Parking Layout

7 Chapter 7: Design Development, Materials & Planting Systems

7.1 Paving Systems: Rigid, Flexible & Unit Pavers 7.2 Retaining Walls, Earth Pressure & Wall Drainage 7.3 Wall System Selection, Fences, Screens & Gates 7.4 Site Furnishings: Selection, Materiality & Anchoring 7.5 Exterior Lighting, Photometrics, Dark Sky & Electrical Safety 7.6 Public Playground Safety: CPSC & ASTM Standards 7.7 Planting Design Principles & Ecological Matching 7.8 Water Conservation, Xeriscaping & Irrigation System Principles 7.9 Opinions of Probable Cost & Value Engineering

8 Chapter 8: Construction Drawings, Layout & Detailing

8.1 Drawing Set Hierarchy, Sheet Standards & Drafting Conventions 8.2 Interdisciplinary Coordination & QA/QC Review 8.3 Demolition Plans & Tree Protection Requirements 8.4 Site Preparation: Clearing, Grubbing, Topsoil & Utility Abandonment 8.5 Layout, Dimensioning & Materials Plans 8.6 Planting Plans, Plant Schedules & Installation Details 8.7 Technical Detailing: Pavements, Curbs & Joint Assemblies 8.8 Retaining Wall, Stair & Ramp Detailing Standards

9 Chapter 9: Construction Specifications & Bidding

9.1 CSI MasterFormat Divisions & SectionFormat Structure 9.2 Specification Writing Methods & the Drawings–Specifications Relationship 9.3 Project Manual, General Conditions & Front-End Documents 9.4 Bid Requirements, Bid Forms & Addenda Management 9.5 Pre-Bid Procedures, Bid Opening & Contractor Evaluation

10 Chapter 10: Construction Administration, Submittals & Changes

10.1 Pre-Construction Conference & Construction Administration Authority 10.2 Initial Decision Maker, Communication Protocols & Project Records 10.3 Submittals, Shop Drawings, Product Data & Samples 10.4 Requests for Information (RFIs) & Technical Clarifications 10.5 Change Orders, Construction Change Directives & Claims

11 Chapter 11: Field Observation, Quality Control & Close-Out

11.1 Field Observations, Site Reports & Non-Conforming Work 11.2 Quality Control, Material Testing & Inspections 11.3 Substantial Completion, Punch Lists & Retainage 11.4 Project Close-Out, Guarantees, Warranties & Final Acceptance

12 Chapter 12: Contour Interpretation, Grading & Earthwork Calculations

12.1 Contour Rules & Topographic Landform Interpretation 12.2 Spot Elevations & Contour Interpolation Calculations 12.3 Slope Formulas, Maximum Gradients & Cross Slopes 12.4 Earthwork Calculations: Average End Area & Grid Methods 12.5 Cut and Fill Balancing, Shrinkage, Swell & Mass Haul 12.6 Reviewing Grading Design: Error Detection & Constructability

13 Chapter 13: Stormwater Hydrology, Runoff & BMP Design

13.1 Hydrologic Cycle, Watershed Delineation & Time of Concentration 13.2 Peak Runoff Estimation: The Rational Method (Q = CiA) 13.3 NRCS Curve Number Method & Runoff Hydrographs 13.4 LID Principles, Water Quality Volume & Bioretention Design 13.5 Bioswales, Permeable Pavement, Green Roofs & Harvesting

14 Chapter 14: Site Drainage Systems, Hydraulics & Erosion Control

14.1 Open Channel Hydraulics, Manning’s Equation & Swale Design 14.2 Gutter Flow, Spread & Roadway Inlet Hydraulics 14.3 Subsurface Drainage, Catch Basins & Pipe Invert Calculations 14.4 Stormwater Storage: Detention, Retention & Water Quality Basins 14.5 Reviewing Drainage Plans & Evaluating Design Alternatives 14.6 Erosion Mechanics, RUSLE & the NPDES/SWPPP Framework 14.7 Erosion & Sediment Control BMPs, Basins & Site Stabilization

14.5 Reviewing Drainage Plans & Evaluating Design Alternatives

Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI

Drainage review verifies continuity first: every inlet must connect to a downstream structure, and the system must terminate at a legal, capable outfall.

Pipe inverts must fall continuously downstream, and any run showing a rising or flat invert is a fatal error regardless of what the pipe sizes indicate.

Pipe sizes may only stay the same or increase in the downstream direction; a reduction downstream creates a hydraulic bottleneck and a surcharge point.

Design velocity in a storm sewer should generally fall between about 2.5 and 10 feet per second: below that range solids deposit, above it the pipe and structures abrade.

A sag inlet has no alternate flow path when it clogs, so it requires a clogging factor in sizing plus a flanking inlet or an overland overflow relief route.

Last updated: September 2026

1. Review as a Distinct Skill

The Drainage Systems content area contains three tasks: preparing a drainage plan and profile, designing and selecting components, and Review Drainage Plans (e.g., evaluate existing design or design alternatives) . The third is tested separately because reviewing requires a different discipline than designing: you are looking for the condition that cannot be true , not for the solution you would have chosen.

  • 2. The Drainage Review Sequence
  • Step 1 — System continuity

Trace the entire network from the most upstream inlet to the outfall.

Does every inlet connect to a downstream structure?

Does every pipe segment have a structure at each end?

Does the system terminate at a legal and capable outfall — a public storm main with capacity, a receiving watercourse, or a designed basin?

Does any branch dead-end?

The outfall is the most commonly missed item. A beautifully detailed network that discharges into a neighbor's yard, into a system with no remaining capacity, or onto an unarmored slope has no outfall.

Step 2 — Drainage area accounting

Do the delineated sub-areas sum to the total contributing area, including offsite area that drains through?

Are runoff coefficients or curve numbers consistent with the proposed land cover, not the existing?

Is each area assigned to the structure that actually receives it?

Unassigned area is the classic hydrologic error: a 0.4-acre strip that belongs to no sub-area still generates runoff, and it arrives somewhere.

Step 3 — Invert and profile verification

This is where review finds fatal errors:

  • Check Failure signature
  • Inverts fall continuously downstream Any upstream invert lower than the one below it
  • Pipe slope meets the design minimum A run at 0.2% where 0.5% was required
  • Minimum cover is maintained Pipe crown too near finished grade under traffic
  • Crown-to-crown or 0.1 ft drop across structures No drop shown where the pipe size increases
  • Pipe size never decreases downstream A 24-inch run discharging into an 18-inch run
  • Outfall invert is above the receiving water normal level Submerged outfall with no analysis

Pipe size may increase or stay constant downstream; it may never decrease. A downstream reduction creates a bottleneck, surcharges the upstream structures, and can blow manhole lids.

Crown matching. When pipe size increases at a structure, matching the crowns (rather than the inverts) prevents the smaller upstream pipe from backing up into the larger one. This lowers the upstream invert and must be carried through the profile.

Step 4 — Capacity and velocity

Is each segment sized for the required design storm, with the design storm stated?

Is velocity within the acceptable band?

  • Velocity Consequence
  • Below ~2.5 ft/s Solids settle; the pipe silts and eventually blocks
  • ~2.5 to 10 ft/s Acceptable working range
  • Above ~10 ft/s Abrasion of pipe invert, structure damage, outfall scour

Minimum slope requirements exist to achieve the self-cleansing velocity, which is why a flat pipe fails even when its capacity calculation passes.

Step 5 — Structure spacing, inlet type, and sag conditions

Is structure spacing within the jurisdiction's maximum for cleaning access (commonly 300 to 400 feet)?

Is there a structure at every change in size, slope, direction, or material?

Is inlet type matched to condition? Curb inlets stay clear of debris and suit continuous-grade streets; grate inlets capture more flow per foot but clog; combination inlets are used where both capture and clogging resistance are needed.

Are sag (low point) inlets sized with a clogging factor?

A sag inlet is the critical review item. On a continuous grade, flow bypassing a clogged inlet simply continues to the next one. In a sag there is no next inlet — water rises until it finds an overland path, which may be a doorway. Sag conditions require a clogging factor in sizing plus either a flanking inlet or a designed overland relief route.

Step 6 — Outfall condition and erosion

Is energy dissipation provided (riprap apron, stilling basin, plunge pool) sized for the outlet velocity?

Is the receiving channel stable at the discharge velocity?

Is the outfall above the receiving water's normal level, or has tailwater been analyzed?

Are downstream property rights and drainage easements in place?

Step 7 — Interdisciplinary and code checks

Do storm structures conflict with trees, utilities, footings, or the accessible route?

Are grates in pedestrian areas compliant — openings not permitting passage of a 1/2-inch sphere, with elongated openings oriented perpendicular to the dominant direction of travel?

Are structures outside the accessible route where possible, and flush where not?

3. Evaluating Drainage Alternatives

When comparing surface, subsurface, and hybrid approaches, use a consistent set:

  • Criterion Surface (swales, sheet flow) Subsurface (piped) Hybrid / LID
  • Capital cost Lowest Highest Moderate
  • Land consumption Highest Lowest Moderate
  • Water quality treatment Good (filtration, infiltration) None inherent Best
  • Maintenance burden Mowing, sediment removal, visible Inspection, jetting, hidden Vegetation plus structure
  • Failure visibility Visible and gradual Hidden until it surcharges Visible
  • Peak attenuation Some None inherent Substantial
  • Conflict with program Occupies usable surface None at surface Occupies surface
  • Accessibility Can obstruct routes None at surface Can obstruct routes

Standard evaluation logic. Surface conveyance is preferred where land is available, because it is cheaper, provides treatment and attenuation, and fails visibly. Piped conveyance is used where the surface is needed for program, where grades cannot achieve a swale, or where velocity would exceed a vegetated lining. Most real projects are hybrids: LID cells and swales manage frequent small storms and water quality, while a piped system conveys the larger design storm safely.

The maintenance question decides more alternatives than the hydraulics do. An owner with no vegetation maintenance capability will not sustain a bioswale network, and a bioswale that is not maintained becomes a mowed ditch with none of the treatment benefit it was credited for. Evaluate against the owner's actual operations capability, not the ideal one.

4. Exam Traps & Pitfalls

Not tracing to the outfall. A system without a legal, capable outfall is not a system.

Accepting a downstream pipe size reduction. Sizes may hold or increase downstream, never decrease.

Checking capacity but not velocity. Below about 2.5 ft/s the pipe silts; above about 10 ft/s it abrades.

Treating a sag inlet like an on-grade inlet. A sag has no bypass path and needs a clogging factor plus relief.

Matching inverts where the pipe size increases. Match crowns so the smaller pipe does not back up.

Ignoring offsite contributing area. Area that drains through the site is part of the system.

Selecting an alternative the owner cannot maintain. Maintenance capability is a design criterion.