Study guide

1.3 The Erie Doctrine & Federal Common Law

Multistate Bar Examination MBE

Track your progress as you read

Finished sections get a check mark.

1 MBE Overview, Scoring & Study Strategy

0.1 About the Multistate Bar Examination 0.2 MBE Question Mechanics & Test Pacing 0.3 High-Yield Preparation & Error Analysis Strategy

2 Civil Procedure I: Subject-Matter Jurisdiction, Removal & Governing Law

1.1 Subject-Matter Jurisdiction: Federal Question & Diversity 1.2 Supplemental Jurisdiction & Removal 1.3 The Erie Doctrine & Federal Common Law

3 Civil Procedure II: Personal Jurisdiction, Venue & Provisional Relief

2.1 Personal Jurisdiction & Service of Process 2.2 Venue, Transfer & Forum Non Conveniens 2.3 Preliminary Injunctions, TROs & Pretrial Conferences

4 Civil Procedure III: Pleadings, Joinder & Class Actions

3.1 Pleadings, Amendments & Rule 11 3.2 Joinder of Claims & Parties, Intervention & Interpleader 3.3 Class Actions & the Class Action Fairness Act

5 Civil Procedure IV: Discovery, Pretrial Motions & Jury Trials

4.1 Discovery, Disclosure & Sanctions 4.2 Rule 12 Motions, Summary Judgment, Defaults & Dismissals 4.3 Jury Trials: The Right to a Jury, Selection, Instructions & Verdicts

6 Civil Procedure V: Post-Trial Motions, Preclusion & Appeals

5.1 Judgment as a Matter of Law, New Trials & Relief from Judgment 5.2 Claim & Issue Preclusion 5.3 Appealability & Standards of Review

7 Constitutional Law I: The Federal Judicial Power

6.1 Judicial Review, Federal Jurisdiction & State Sovereign Immunity 6.2 Justiciability: Standing, Ripeness, Mootness & Political Questions

8 Constitutional Law II: The Powers of Congress

7.1 Enumerated Powers: Commerce, Taxing & Spending 7.2 War, Foreign Affairs, Civil Rights Enforcement & Other Congressional Powers

9 Constitutional Law III: The Presidency & Separation of Powers

8.1 Presidential Powers: Chief Executive, Commander in Chief, Foreign Affairs & Appointments 8.2 Interbranch Relations: Nondelegation, Presentment, Legislative Limits & Immunities

10 Constitutional Law IV: Federalism & State Power

9.1 The Tenth Amendment, Anti-Commandeering & Intergovernmental Immunities 9.2 Preemption, the Dormant Commerce Clause & Congressional Authorization

11 Constitutional Law V: State Action, Due Process & Equal Protection

10.1 State Action & Procedural Due Process 10.2 Substantive Due Process: Fundamental Rights & Other Liberty Interests 10.3 Equal Protection: Classifications, Scrutiny & Fundamental Rights

12 Constitutional Law VI: Takings & Other Economic Protections

11.1 The Takings Clause 11.2 Contracts Clause, Ex Post Facto Laws, Bills of Attainder & Privileges and Immunities

13 Constitutional Law VII: First Amendment Freedoms

12.1 Freedom of Religion: Establishment & Free Exercise 12.2 Freedom of Speech: Content Regulation, Forums, Unprotected Categories & Commercial Speech 12.3 Speech in Government Settings, Expressive Conduct, Prior Restraints, Press & Association

14 Contracts I: Formation—Offer, Acceptance & Consideration

13.1 Governing Law, Offers & Termination of the Power of Acceptance 13.2 Acceptance, Silence, Unilateral Contracts & the Battle of the Forms 13.3 Consideration, Modification, Promissory Estoppel & Restitution

15 Contracts II: Defenses to Enforcement

14.1 Capacity, Duress, Undue Influence, Unconscionability, Illegality & Public Policy 14.2 Mistake, Misunderstanding, Misrepresentation & Nondisclosure 14.3 The Statute of Frauds

16 Contracts III: Contract Terms, Interpretation & Warranties

15.1 Parol Evidence, Interpretation & Implied Terms 15.2 Warranties in the Sale of Goods

17 Contracts IV: Conditions, Performance & Breach

16.1 Conditions & Excuse of Conditions 16.2 Substantial Performance, Material Breach, Repudiation & Adequate Assurance 16.3 UCC Performance: Tender, Rejection, Cure, Revocation, Installments & Risk of Loss

18 Contracts V: Excuse, Discharge & Remedies

17.1 Impossibility, Impracticability, Frustration & Discharge 17.2 Expectation Damages, Consequential Damages, Mitigation & UCC Damage Formulas 17.3 Reliance, Restitution, Liquidated Damages, Specific Performance & Rescission

19 Contracts VI: Third-Party Beneficiaries, Assignment & Delegation

18.1 Third-Party Beneficiaries 18.2 Assignment of Rights & Delegation of Duties

20 Criminal Law I: General Principles, Defenses, Inchoate Crimes & Parties

19.1 Criminal Acts, Mental States, Mistake, Causation & Jurisdiction 19.2 Responsibility & Defenses: Insanity, Intoxication, Infancy, Justification & Excuse 19.3 Inchoate Crimes: Solicitation, Conspiracy & Attempt 19.4 Parties to Crime: Principals, Accomplices & Accessories After the Fact

21 Criminal Law II: Homicide, Property Crimes & Crimes Against the Person

20.1 Homicide: Murder, Felony Murder & Manslaughter 20.2 Theft Offenses, Receiving Stolen Property, Robbery & Burglary 20.3 Assault, Battery, Sexual Offenses, Kidnapping, Arson & Possession Offenses

22 Criminal Procedure I: The Fourth Amendment & the Exclusionary Rule

21.1 Fourth Amendment: Searches, Seizures, Arrests & Warrants 21.2 Exceptions to the Warrant Requirement & Special Needs Searches 21.3 The Exclusionary Rule, Standing & Fruit of the Poisonous Tree

23 Criminal Procedure II: Confessions, Identification & the Right to Counsel

22.1 Confessions, Miranda & the Privilege Against Self-Incrimination 22.2 Pretrial Identification & the Sixth Amendment Right to Counsel

24 Criminal Procedure III: Trial Rights, Pleas, Double Jeopardy, Punishment & Appeals

23.1 Fair Trial, Jury & Confrontation Rights, Guilty Pleas & Burdens of Proof 23.2 Double Jeopardy, Cruel & Unusual Punishment, Appeal & Error

25 Evidence I: Presenting Evidence, Relevance & Witnesses

24.1 Introducing Evidence: Judge & Jury, Objections, Judicial Notice & Presumptions 24.2 Relevance, Rule 403 & Real, Demonstrative & Illustrative Evidence 24.3 Witnesses: Competency, Mode of Examination, Refreshing Recollection & Exclusion

26 Evidence II: Impeachment, Character & Other Acts

25.1 Impeachment: Bias, Inconsistent Statements, Capacity, Contradiction & Rehabilitation 25.2 Impeachment by Character for Truthfulness, Specific Instances & Criminal Convictions 25.3 Character Evidence: The Propensity Ban, Criminal-Case Exceptions & Methods of Proof 25.4 Other Crimes, Wrongs & Acts; Habit & Routine Practice; Sexual Misconduct Rules

27 Evidence III: Opinions, Authentication, Documents, Privileges & Policy Exclusions

26.1 Lay & Expert Opinion Testimony 26.2 Authentication & Identification 26.3 Best Evidence Rule, Summaries & the Rule of Completeness 26.4 Privileges: Attorney-Client, Spousal, Psychotherapist & Other Privileges 26.5 Policy Exclusions: Remedial Measures, Compromise, Medical Payments, Pleas & Insurance

28 Evidence IV: Hearsay & Its Exceptions

27.1 The Hearsay Definition & Statements That Are Not Hearsay 27.2 Hearsay Exclusions: Prior Statements of Testifying Witnesses & Opposing Party Statements 27.3 Hearsay Exceptions Not Requiring Unavailability (FRE 803) 27.4 Unavailability Exceptions, Residual Exception, Multiple Hearsay & Confrontation

29 Real Property I: Estates, Concurrent Ownership & Leaseholds

28.1 Present Estates, Future Interests & Waste 28.2 Rule Against Perpetuities, Restraints on Alienation, Fair Housing & Conflicts of Law 28.3 Concurrent Ownership: Tenancy in Common, Joint Tenancy & Tenancy by the Entirety 28.4 Landlord & Tenant: Tenancies, Duties, Remedies & Transfers

30 Real Property II: Rights in Land

29.1 Easements, Profits & Licenses 29.2 Real Covenants, Equitable Servitudes & Common Interest Communities 29.3 Fixtures 29.4 Support, Water Rights & Zoning

31 Real Property III: Real Estate Contracts

30.1 Real Estate Contracts: Brokers, Formation, Performance & Remedies 30.2 Marketable Title, Equitable Conversion, Options, Disclosure & Merger

32 Real Property IV: Mortgages & Security Devices

31.1 Mortgages & Security Devices: Theories, Pre-Foreclosure Rights & Transfers 31.2 Discharge, Foreclosure, Redemption & Priorities

33 Real Property V: Titles

32.1 Adverse Possession 32.2 Deeds, Delivery, Title Covenants & Transfers at Death 32.3 Recording Acts, Title Assurance & Liens

34 Torts I: Intentional Torts

33.1 Intent & Intentional Torts Against the Person 33.2 Intentional Torts Against Property 33.3 Defenses & Privileges for Intentional Torts

35 Torts II: Negligence—Duty, Standard of Care & Proof

34.1 Duty: Foreseeable Plaintiffs, Failure to Act & Control of Others 34.2 Standard of Care, Custom, Negligence Per Se & Res Ipsa Loquitur

36 Torts III: Negligence—Causation, Damages & Limits on Liability

35.1 Actual Cause, Joint & Several Liability, Contribution & Indemnity 35.2 Proximate Cause, Damages, Survival & Wrongful Death 35.3 Owners & Occupiers of Land 35.4 Negligent Infliction of Emotional Distress, Intangible Harms & Pure Economic Loss

37 Torts IV: Vicarious Liability & Negligence Defenses

36.1 Vicarious Liability: Employees, Independent Contractors & Others 36.2 Defenses to Negligence: Comparative Fault, Assumption of Risk & Immunities

38 Torts V: Strict Liability & Products Liability

37.1 Strict Liability: Animals & Abnormally Dangerous Activities 37.2 Products Liability: Theories, Defects & Defenses

39 Torts VI: Nuisance, Defamation, Privacy & Economic Torts

38.1 Private & Public Nuisance 38.2 Defamation & Invasion of Privacy 38.3 Misrepresentation & Interference with Business Relations

1.3 The Erie Doctrine & Federal Common Law

Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI

Under the Erie doctrine (Erie R.R. v. Tompkins), federal courts sitting in diversity apply state substantive law and federal procedural law under the Rules of Decision Act (28 U.S.C. § 1652).

Under Hanna v. Plumer, when a Federal Rule of Civil Procedure or federal statute directly conflicts with state law, the federal rule controls if it is constitutional and valid under the Rules Enabling Act (28 U.S.C. § 2072) as a rule that really regulates procedure.

In unguided Erie choices where no federal rule controls, courts apply the outcome-determinative test (York) as modified by the twin aims of Erie (Hanna): discouraging forum shopping and avoiding inequitable administration of the laws, while balancing countervailing federal interests (Byrd).

Statutes of limitations, tolling rules, state choice-of-law rules (Klaxon), elements of claims, burdens of proof, and excessiveness of verdict standards (Gasperini) are strictly substantive state law.

Federal common law is restricted to narrow enclaves of uniquely federal interests, including interstate boundary and water disputes, foreign affairs, admiralty, and the rights and obligations of the United States.

Last updated: September 2026

1.3 The Erie Doctrine & Federal Common Law

When a federal district court exercises diversity of citizenship jurisdiction under 28 U.S.C. § 1332, it sits as a court of the forum state. The fundamental constitutional problem this creates is: Which law applies—state law or federal law?

The framework governing this question is known as the Erie Doctrine , originating from the landmark Supreme Court decision in Erie Railroad Co. v. Tompkins (1938).

Foundational Principles: Erie R.R. v. Tompkins

For nearly a century prior to Erie , under Swift v. Tyson (1842), federal courts sitting in diversity applied state statutory law, but were free to formulate their own "federal general common law" on matters of general commercial law and torts. This created severe forum-shopping problems: out-of-state litigants could select federal court specifically to exploit favorable federal judge-made rules unavailable to in-state litigants in state courts.

Core Holdings of Erie

In Erie , the Supreme Court overruled Swift on statutory and constitutional grounds:

Statutory Command: Under the Rules of Decision Act (28 U.S.C. § 1652) , the "laws of the several states" include not only state statutes, but also the decisions of the highest state courts (state common law).

Constitutional Command: The federal government possesses only enumerated powers under the Constitution. Neither Congress nor the federal judiciary has the constitutional authority to declare general substantive common law rules for the states in areas outside federal legislative competence.

The Core Rule: A federal court sitting in diversity must apply state substantive law and federal procedural law .

The Analytical Framework for Choice of Law

Determining whether a rule is substantive or procedural is one of the most frequently tested concepts on the MBE. Modern Erie analysis follows a two-track inquiry established in Hanna v. Plumer (1965): ERIE CHOICE-OF-LAW FLOWCHART

  • ┌─────────────────────────────────────────┐
  • │ Is there an applicable Federal Rule │
  • │ of Civil Procedure or Federal Statute │
  • │ directly on point? (Hanna) │
  • └────────────────────┬────────────────────┘
  • │
  • YES │ NO
  • ┌─────────┴─────────┐
  • ▼ ▼
  • GUIDED HANNA ANALYSIS UNGUIDED ERIE ANALYSIS
  • │ │
  • ▼ ▼

Is the Federal Rule valid Is the state rule substantive?

under Rules Enabling Act (Guaranty Trust / Byrd / Hanna)

(§ 2072: does not abridge, │ Evaluate Twin Aims of Erie:

enlarge, modify subst. right)? │ 1. Avoid forum shopping?

│ │ 2. Avoid inequity?

  • ▼ │ │
  • FEDERAL RULE APPLIES │ ▼
  • │ STATE LAW APPLIES
  • │ (if substantive/outcome)
  • Step 1: The Guided Erie Analysis ( Hanna Analysis)

First, determine whether there is an applicable federal statute or Federal Rule of Civil Procedure that is on point and directly conflicts with the state practice (e.g., FRCP 4 service of process, FRCP 8 pleading standards, FRCP 35 physical examinations, or FRCP 38 jury demands):

If an FRCP applies and conflicts: The federal rule controls , provided it is valid under the Rules Enabling Act (28 U.S.C. § 2072) and constitutional.

Rules Enabling Act Standard: Under § 2072(b), procedural rules promulgated by the Supreme Court "shall not abridge, enlarge or modify any substantive right."

High Deference: The Supreme Court has never invalidated a Federal Rule of Civil Procedure under the Rules Enabling Act. If the rule "really regulates procedure"—the judicial process for enforcing rights and duties—it is valid and governs, even if it alters the litigation's outcome ( Burlington Northern R.R. v. Woods ; Shady Grove Orthopedic Associates v. Allstate Insurance Co. ).

Recent Application ( Berk v. Choy , 2026): The Supreme Court held that Delaware's requirement that a medical-malpractice plaintiff file an expert affidavit of merit with the complaint does not apply in a federal diversity case. Rule 8 (reinforced by Rule 12) already answers what a plaintiff must provide at the outset—a short and plain statement of the claim, not evidence—and Rule 8 is valid under the Rules Enabling Act, so it displaces the contrary state requirement.

Step 2: The Unguided Erie Analysis (Relatively Unguided Choice)

If there is no federal rule or statute directly on point , the court faces an unguided Erie choice. The court must evaluate whether the state rule is substantive or procedural through three historical doctrines synthesized in Hanna :

1. The Outcome-Determinative Test ( Guaranty Trust Co. v. York )

In Guaranty Trust Co. v. York (1945), the Court asked: Does the choice of rule substantially determine the outcome of the litigation? If applying federal practice instead of state law would significantly alter the outcome, the state law is substantive and must apply. Under this test, state statutes of limitations were held to be substantive.

2. Countervailing Federal Interests / Balancing ( Byrd v. Blue Ridge )

In Byrd v. Blue Ridge Rural Electric Cooperative, Inc. (1958), the Court held that even if a state rule appears outcome-determinative, the court must balance the state interest against the essential characteristics and independent integrity of the federal judicial system . The Court held that the federal policy favoring jury decisions under the Seventh Amendment outweighed a state practice requiring judges to decide worker's compensation statutory immunity.

3. The "Twin Aims" of Erie ( Hanna v. Plumer )

In Hanna , the Court clarified that outcome-determinative impact must not be viewed in hindsight. Instead, it must be evaluated from the perspective of a litigant at the outset of the action, in light of the twin aims of Erie :

Discouragement of Forum Shopping: Would applying federal law incentivize a plaintiff to choose federal court over state court to gain a substantive legal advantage?

Avoidance of Inequitable Administration of the Laws: Would applying federal law cause an unfair discrimination against in-state citizens who cannot invoke diversity jurisdiction?

If answering "yes" to these inquiries, the state law is substantive and the federal court must apply state law.

Substantive vs. Procedural Classifications Under Erie

Decades of Supreme Court precedent have firmly classified specific recurring issues:

Legal Issue Classification Governing Law Controlling Precedent Doctrinal Rationale

Statutes of Limitations Substantive State Law Guaranty Trust Co. v. York (1945) Outcome-determinative; determines whether an action can survive.

Tolling Rules for Limitations Substantive State Law Walker v. Armco Steel Corp. (1980) State rule requiring service to toll limitations controls over FRCP 3 filing.

Choice-of-Law Rules Substantive State Law Klaxon Co. v. Stentor Electric Mfg. Co. (1941) Federal court must apply the choice-of-law rules of the state in which it sits.

Elements of Claim / Defense Substantive State Law Erie R.R. v. Tompkins (1938) Defines rights, duties, and actionable wrongdoing.

Burdens of Proof / Presumptions Substantive State Law Cities Service Oil Co. v. Dunlap (1939) Affects the substantive weight and proof required for a cause of action.

Standard for Verdict Excessiveness Substantive State Law Gasperini v. Center for Humanities (1996) State "deviates materially" standard applies at trial; federal abuse of discretion applies on appeal.

Right to Jury Trial (7th Amendment) Procedural Federal Law Byrd v. Blue Ridge (1958) Seventh Amendment jury allocation is an essential federal characteristic.

Service of Process Mechanics Procedural Federal Law Hanna v. Plumer (1965) FRCP 4 is a valid procedural rule that controls over state personal service laws.

Pleading & Affidavit-of-Merit Requirements Federal Rule Controls Federal Law Berk v. Choy (2026); FRCP 8 and 12 Rule 8 governs what a complaint must contain, so a state rule requiring an expert affidavit to be filed with the complaint does not apply in federal court.

Discovery Devices & Sanctions Procedural Federal Law FRCP 26–37 Regulates intra-court information exchange and conduct.

The Klaxon Choice-of-Law Rule

A critical MBE rule from Klaxon Co. v. Stentor Electric Mfg. Co. (1941): A federal district court sitting in diversity must apply the conflict-of-laws (choice-of-law) rules of the state in which it sits :

If a federal court in State A hears a diversity dispute regarding an accident in State B, the federal court does not pick which law applies based on federal principles. It applies State A's choice-of-law rules to decide whether State A or State B substantive law applies.

Transferred Cases Under § 1404(a): If a case is transferred for convenience from a proper venue in State A to State B under § 1404(a), the transferee court in State B must apply the choice-of-law rules of State A ( Van Dusen v. Barrack ).

Ascertaining State Law: The Erie Guess

When applying state substantive law, federal courts must follow the published decisions of the state's highest court (e.g., State Supreme Court):

Unresolved State Law: If the state's highest court has not addressed an issue, the federal court must make an "Erie guess" predicting how the state's highest court would decide the question today.

Persuasive Authority: The court considers intermediate state appellate decisions, state trial court rulings, decisions from other jurisdictions, Restatements of Law, and scholarly treatises.

Certification: Many states provide certification procedures whereby a federal court can formalize an unsettled question of state law and certify it directly to the state supreme court for a definitive answer.

Federal Common Law

Although there is no general federal common law, narrow enclaves of specialized federal common law exist where federal courts create substantive rules of decision to protect uniquely federal interests :

Interstate Controversies: Boundary disputes and interstate water allocation disputes between sovereign states ( Kansas v. Colorado ).

Admiralty and Maritime Disputes: Maritime contracts and torts on navigable waters under Article III, § 2.

Foreign Affairs and International Relations: Act of state doctrine, foreign sovereign immunity, and international treaty relations.

Rights and Obligations of the United States: Commercial paper issued by the United States ( Clearfield Trust Co. v. United States ), federal procurement contracts, and government contractor tort immunity ( Boyle v. United Technologies Corp. ).