Study guide

35.1 Actual Cause, Joint & Several Liability, Contribution & Indemnity

Multistate Bar Examination MBE

Track your progress as you read

Finished sections get a check mark.

1 MBE Overview, Scoring & Study Strategy

0.1 About the Multistate Bar Examination 0.2 MBE Question Mechanics & Test Pacing 0.3 High-Yield Preparation & Error Analysis Strategy

2 Civil Procedure I: Subject-Matter Jurisdiction, Removal & Governing Law

1.1 Subject-Matter Jurisdiction: Federal Question & Diversity 1.2 Supplemental Jurisdiction & Removal 1.3 The Erie Doctrine & Federal Common Law

3 Civil Procedure II: Personal Jurisdiction, Venue & Provisional Relief

2.1 Personal Jurisdiction & Service of Process 2.2 Venue, Transfer & Forum Non Conveniens 2.3 Preliminary Injunctions, TROs & Pretrial Conferences

4 Civil Procedure III: Pleadings, Joinder & Class Actions

3.1 Pleadings, Amendments & Rule 11 3.2 Joinder of Claims & Parties, Intervention & Interpleader 3.3 Class Actions & the Class Action Fairness Act

5 Civil Procedure IV: Discovery, Pretrial Motions & Jury Trials

4.1 Discovery, Disclosure & Sanctions 4.2 Rule 12 Motions, Summary Judgment, Defaults & Dismissals 4.3 Jury Trials: The Right to a Jury, Selection, Instructions & Verdicts

6 Civil Procedure V: Post-Trial Motions, Preclusion & Appeals

5.1 Judgment as a Matter of Law, New Trials & Relief from Judgment 5.2 Claim & Issue Preclusion 5.3 Appealability & Standards of Review

7 Constitutional Law I: The Federal Judicial Power

6.1 Judicial Review, Federal Jurisdiction & State Sovereign Immunity 6.2 Justiciability: Standing, Ripeness, Mootness & Political Questions

8 Constitutional Law II: The Powers of Congress

7.1 Enumerated Powers: Commerce, Taxing & Spending 7.2 War, Foreign Affairs, Civil Rights Enforcement & Other Congressional Powers

9 Constitutional Law III: The Presidency & Separation of Powers

8.1 Presidential Powers: Chief Executive, Commander in Chief, Foreign Affairs & Appointments 8.2 Interbranch Relations: Nondelegation, Presentment, Legislative Limits & Immunities

10 Constitutional Law IV: Federalism & State Power

9.1 The Tenth Amendment, Anti-Commandeering & Intergovernmental Immunities 9.2 Preemption, the Dormant Commerce Clause & Congressional Authorization

11 Constitutional Law V: State Action, Due Process & Equal Protection

10.1 State Action & Procedural Due Process 10.2 Substantive Due Process: Fundamental Rights & Other Liberty Interests 10.3 Equal Protection: Classifications, Scrutiny & Fundamental Rights

12 Constitutional Law VI: Takings & Other Economic Protections

11.1 The Takings Clause 11.2 Contracts Clause, Ex Post Facto Laws, Bills of Attainder & Privileges and Immunities

13 Constitutional Law VII: First Amendment Freedoms

12.1 Freedom of Religion: Establishment & Free Exercise 12.2 Freedom of Speech: Content Regulation, Forums, Unprotected Categories & Commercial Speech 12.3 Speech in Government Settings, Expressive Conduct, Prior Restraints, Press & Association

14 Contracts I: Formation—Offer, Acceptance & Consideration

13.1 Governing Law, Offers & Termination of the Power of Acceptance 13.2 Acceptance, Silence, Unilateral Contracts & the Battle of the Forms 13.3 Consideration, Modification, Promissory Estoppel & Restitution

15 Contracts II: Defenses to Enforcement

14.1 Capacity, Duress, Undue Influence, Unconscionability, Illegality & Public Policy 14.2 Mistake, Misunderstanding, Misrepresentation & Nondisclosure 14.3 The Statute of Frauds

16 Contracts III: Contract Terms, Interpretation & Warranties

15.1 Parol Evidence, Interpretation & Implied Terms 15.2 Warranties in the Sale of Goods

17 Contracts IV: Conditions, Performance & Breach

16.1 Conditions & Excuse of Conditions 16.2 Substantial Performance, Material Breach, Repudiation & Adequate Assurance 16.3 UCC Performance: Tender, Rejection, Cure, Revocation, Installments & Risk of Loss

18 Contracts V: Excuse, Discharge & Remedies

17.1 Impossibility, Impracticability, Frustration & Discharge 17.2 Expectation Damages, Consequential Damages, Mitigation & UCC Damage Formulas 17.3 Reliance, Restitution, Liquidated Damages, Specific Performance & Rescission

19 Contracts VI: Third-Party Beneficiaries, Assignment & Delegation

18.1 Third-Party Beneficiaries 18.2 Assignment of Rights & Delegation of Duties

20 Criminal Law I: General Principles, Defenses, Inchoate Crimes & Parties

19.1 Criminal Acts, Mental States, Mistake, Causation & Jurisdiction 19.2 Responsibility & Defenses: Insanity, Intoxication, Infancy, Justification & Excuse 19.3 Inchoate Crimes: Solicitation, Conspiracy & Attempt 19.4 Parties to Crime: Principals, Accomplices & Accessories After the Fact

21 Criminal Law II: Homicide, Property Crimes & Crimes Against the Person

20.1 Homicide: Murder, Felony Murder & Manslaughter 20.2 Theft Offenses, Receiving Stolen Property, Robbery & Burglary 20.3 Assault, Battery, Sexual Offenses, Kidnapping, Arson & Possession Offenses

22 Criminal Procedure I: The Fourth Amendment & the Exclusionary Rule

21.1 Fourth Amendment: Searches, Seizures, Arrests & Warrants 21.2 Exceptions to the Warrant Requirement & Special Needs Searches 21.3 The Exclusionary Rule, Standing & Fruit of the Poisonous Tree

23 Criminal Procedure II: Confessions, Identification & the Right to Counsel

22.1 Confessions, Miranda & the Privilege Against Self-Incrimination 22.2 Pretrial Identification & the Sixth Amendment Right to Counsel

24 Criminal Procedure III: Trial Rights, Pleas, Double Jeopardy, Punishment & Appeals

23.1 Fair Trial, Jury & Confrontation Rights, Guilty Pleas & Burdens of Proof 23.2 Double Jeopardy, Cruel & Unusual Punishment, Appeal & Error

25 Evidence I: Presenting Evidence, Relevance & Witnesses

24.1 Introducing Evidence: Judge & Jury, Objections, Judicial Notice & Presumptions 24.2 Relevance, Rule 403 & Real, Demonstrative & Illustrative Evidence 24.3 Witnesses: Competency, Mode of Examination, Refreshing Recollection & Exclusion

26 Evidence II: Impeachment, Character & Other Acts

25.1 Impeachment: Bias, Inconsistent Statements, Capacity, Contradiction & Rehabilitation 25.2 Impeachment by Character for Truthfulness, Specific Instances & Criminal Convictions 25.3 Character Evidence: The Propensity Ban, Criminal-Case Exceptions & Methods of Proof 25.4 Other Crimes, Wrongs & Acts; Habit & Routine Practice; Sexual Misconduct Rules

27 Evidence III: Opinions, Authentication, Documents, Privileges & Policy Exclusions

26.1 Lay & Expert Opinion Testimony 26.2 Authentication & Identification 26.3 Best Evidence Rule, Summaries & the Rule of Completeness 26.4 Privileges: Attorney-Client, Spousal, Psychotherapist & Other Privileges 26.5 Policy Exclusions: Remedial Measures, Compromise, Medical Payments, Pleas & Insurance

28 Evidence IV: Hearsay & Its Exceptions

27.1 The Hearsay Definition & Statements That Are Not Hearsay 27.2 Hearsay Exclusions: Prior Statements of Testifying Witnesses & Opposing Party Statements 27.3 Hearsay Exceptions Not Requiring Unavailability (FRE 803) 27.4 Unavailability Exceptions, Residual Exception, Multiple Hearsay & Confrontation

29 Real Property I: Estates, Concurrent Ownership & Leaseholds

28.1 Present Estates, Future Interests & Waste 28.2 Rule Against Perpetuities, Restraints on Alienation, Fair Housing & Conflicts of Law 28.3 Concurrent Ownership: Tenancy in Common, Joint Tenancy & Tenancy by the Entirety 28.4 Landlord & Tenant: Tenancies, Duties, Remedies & Transfers

30 Real Property II: Rights in Land

29.1 Easements, Profits & Licenses 29.2 Real Covenants, Equitable Servitudes & Common Interest Communities 29.3 Fixtures 29.4 Support, Water Rights & Zoning

31 Real Property III: Real Estate Contracts

30.1 Real Estate Contracts: Brokers, Formation, Performance & Remedies 30.2 Marketable Title, Equitable Conversion, Options, Disclosure & Merger

32 Real Property IV: Mortgages & Security Devices

31.1 Mortgages & Security Devices: Theories, Pre-Foreclosure Rights & Transfers 31.2 Discharge, Foreclosure, Redemption & Priorities

33 Real Property V: Titles

32.1 Adverse Possession 32.2 Deeds, Delivery, Title Covenants & Transfers at Death 32.3 Recording Acts, Title Assurance & Liens

34 Torts I: Intentional Torts

33.1 Intent & Intentional Torts Against the Person 33.2 Intentional Torts Against Property 33.3 Defenses & Privileges for Intentional Torts

35 Torts II: Negligence—Duty, Standard of Care & Proof

34.1 Duty: Foreseeable Plaintiffs, Failure to Act & Control of Others 34.2 Standard of Care, Custom, Negligence Per Se & Res Ipsa Loquitur

36 Torts III: Negligence—Causation, Damages & Limits on Liability

35.1 Actual Cause, Joint & Several Liability, Contribution & Indemnity 35.2 Proximate Cause, Damages, Survival & Wrongful Death 35.3 Owners & Occupiers of Land 35.4 Negligent Infliction of Emotional Distress, Intangible Harms & Pure Economic Loss

37 Torts IV: Vicarious Liability & Negligence Defenses

36.1 Vicarious Liability: Employees, Independent Contractors & Others 36.2 Defenses to Negligence: Comparative Fault, Assumption of Risk & Immunities

38 Torts V: Strict Liability & Products Liability

37.1 Strict Liability: Animals & Abnormally Dangerous Activities 37.2 Products Liability: Theories, Defects & Defenses

39 Torts VI: Nuisance, Defamation, Privacy & Economic Torts

38.1 Private & Public Nuisance 38.2 Defamation & Invasion of Privacy 38.3 Misrepresentation & Interference with Business Relations

35.1 Actual Cause, Joint & Several Liability, Contribution & Indemnity

Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI

Actual cause usually requires but-for causation, but when multiple sufficient causes combine to produce a harm, each is an actual cause if it would have been sufficient alone or was a substantial factor.

When two or more defendants acted negligently and only one caused the harm, alternative liability shifts the burden to each defendant to prove it did not cause the injury, and some courts apply market share liability to makers of fungible products such as DES.

Many states allow a patient to recover for a lost chance of survival or recovery caused by medical negligence, usually in proportion to the chance lost.

Tortfeasors who cause a single indivisible injury are jointly and severally liable for the full damages, while damages for a divisible injury are apportioned by causation; NCBE tells examinees to assume joint and several liability with pure comparative negligence unless a question says otherwise.

A defendant who pays more than its share may obtain contribution based on comparative fault, or full indemnity when it was only vicariously or secondarily liable, and a settlement with one tortfeasor reduces the others' liability under the jurisdiction's pro tanto, pro rata, or comparative-share rule.

Last updated: September 2026

35.1 Actual Cause, Joint & Several Liability, Contribution & Indemnity

Actual cause asks whether the defendant's negligence in fact contributed to the plaintiff's harm. When more than one person contributed, the next questions are how much each defendant owes the plaintiff and how defendants share the loss among themselves. NCBE's outline tells examinees to assume joint and several liability, with pure comparative negligence, unless a question states otherwise.

Actual Cause (Cause-in-Fact)

Actual cause connects the defendant's breached duty to the plaintiff's ultimate physical injury. Without an empirical link between breach and harm, liability cannot attach.

The "But-For" Test

The standard test for actual cause is the "but-for" test : Would the plaintiff's injury have occurred but for the defendant's negligent act or omission?

If the injury would have occurred anyway, the defendant's act is not an actual cause.

If the injury would have been prevented had the defendant exercised reasonable care, actual cause is established.

Special Tests for Complex Causation

When multiple actors or independent causes are present, the traditional but-for test breaks down, requiring specialized legal doctrines: ┌────────────────────────────────┐

  • │ Actual Cause Tests │
  • └───────────────┬────────────────┘
  • │
  • ┌────────────────────────┬───────────────┴────────────────┬────────────────────────┐
  • ▼ ▼ ▼ ▼
  • ┌──────────────────┐ ┌──────────────────┐ ┌──────────────────┐ ┌──────────────────┐
  • │ But-For Test │ │Substantial Factor│ │ Alternative │ │ Market Share │
  • │ (Standard rule) │ │ (Kingston rule) │ │ Liability │ │ Liability │
  • ├──────────────────┤ ├──────────────────┤ ├──────────────────┤ ├──────────────────┤
  • │Breach essential │ │Multiple concurrent│ │Summers v. Tice: │ │Sindell v. Abbott:│
  • │to occurrence of │ │sufficient causes │ │2+ negligent actors│ │Fungible products │
  • │injury │ │merge (2 fires) │ │Burden shifts to D│ │Share of market = │
  • │ │ │Both held liable │ │Joint & several │ │percentage fault │
  • └──────────────────┘ └──────────────────┘ └──────────────────┘ └──────────────────┘

The Substantial Factor Test (Multiple Sufficient Causes):

Applies when two or more independent forces, acts, or fires combine to produce a single, indivisible injury, and either force alone would have been sufficient to cause the entire damage.

Under Kingston v. Chicago & N.W. Ry. (Wis. 1927), if a defendant negligently starts a fire that merges with another fire of human origin, and the combined blaze consumes the plaintiff's house, the defendant is liable if their fire was a substantial factor in producing the loss.

Alternative Liability ( Summers v. Tice ):

Applies when two or more defendants act negligently toward the plaintiff, but the resulting injury was caused by only one of them, and it is impossible to establish which defendant fired the fatal shot or caused the harm.

Summers v. Tice (Cal. 1948): Two hunters negligently fired shotguns simultaneously in the direction of the plaintiff; a birdshot pellet struck the plaintiff's eye. Because both defendants breached their duty of care, the court shifted the burden of proof to each defendant to prove that their pellet did not strike the plaintiff. If neither can exonerate themselves, both are held jointly and severally liable .

Market Share Liability ( Sindell v. Abbott Laboratories ):

Applies in products liability and toxic torts involving a fungible product manufactured identically by multiple companies (e.g., the anti-miscarriage drug DES). Where the plaintiff cannot identify the specific manufacturer due to the passage of decades, courts that accept the doctrine hold manufacturers liable in proportion to their share of the relevant market , unless a manufacturer proves it could not have made the product the plaintiff's mother took. Many states reject market share liability, and courts that accept it generally limit it to fungible products such as DES.

Joint and Several Liability, Contribution & Indemnity

When multiple tortfeasors cause harm to a plaintiff, procedural and substantive rules govern how damages are collected and allocated among the defendants. ┌────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐

  • │ ALLOCATION OF MULTI-PARTY LOSS │
  • ├────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┤
  • │ JOINT & SEVERAL LIABILITY │
  • │ - Plaintiff can collect 100% of indivisible damages from ANY defendant. │
  • │ - Multiple tortfeasors cause a single indivisible injury. │
  • │ │
  • │ CONTRIBUTION (Sharing of Loss) │
  • │ - Shifts proportional excess among jointly liable tortfeasors. │
  • │ - Allocated based on COMPARATIVE FAULT percentages. │
  • │ - NOT available to intentional wrongdoers. │
  • │ │
  • │ INDEMNITY (100% Shifting of Loss) │
  • │ - Shifts ENTIRE financial burden to the party who should justly bear it. │
  • │ - Classic grounds: (1) Vicarious liability; (2) Products retailer chain. │
  • └────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┘
  • 1. Joint and Several Liability

Under joint and several liability , when two or more tortfeasors combine to produce a single, indivisible injury, each tortfeasor is independently liable to the plaintiff for the entire full amount of damages (100%).

Plaintiff's Recovery: The plaintiff can choose to execute the entire judgment against one defendant, split collection among them, or sue all together.

Single Satisfaction Rule: The plaintiff is entitled to only one full satisfaction of the judgment. Once the plaintiff receives 100% of the damages, the judgment is satisfied, and no further collection from other defendants is permitted.

Release vs. Satisfaction:

Release: At common law, releasing one joint tortfeasor released all of them. Today, a release or settlement with one tortfeasor does not discharge the others unless the agreement so provides. How much the nonsettling defendants' liability is reduced depends on the jurisdiction's approach, described below.

Satisfaction: The actual physical receipt of full compensation; permanently discharges all tortfeasors.

2. Contribution (Proportional Loss Sharing)

Contribution is an equitable remedy available among joint tortfeasors who are jointly and severally liable:

Mechanism: A defendant who pays more than their proportional equitable share of the judgment may bring a claim for contribution against the other joint tortfeasors to recover the excess.

Modern Allocation: Under modern comparative fault rules, contribution is apportioned strictly based on each tortfeasor's percentage of comparative fault as determined by the jury.

Intentional Tortfeasors Barred: Under the traditional rule and the Uniform Contribution Among Tortfeasors Act, an intentional tortfeasor may not obtain contribution from negligent co-defendants.

3. Indemnity (100% Shifting of Loss)

Unlike contribution, which divides loss proportionally, indemnity shifts 100% of the entire economic burden from a defendant who paid the judgment to another party who should equitably bear the entire loss.

Indemnity is commonly available in three situations:

Vicarious Liability: An employer held vicariously liable under respondeat superior for an employee's tort is entitled to 100% indemnity against the negligent employee.

Products Liability Distribution Chain: An innocent retail seller or wholesaler held strictly liable for selling a defective product is entitled to 100% indemnity against the upstream commercial manufacturer who designed or produced the defect.

Contractual Indemnity: An express contractual hold-harmless agreement where one party agrees to indemnify another for tort liability.

  • More on Causation and Apportionment
  • Loss of Chance

Under the traditional all-or-nothing approach, a patient whose original chance of survival was 50% or less cannot prove that a doctor's negligence more likely than not caused the death. Many states now allow recovery for the lost chance itself ( Herskovits v. Group Health Cooperative of Puget Sound , Wash. 1983). Under the common proportional approach, damages equal the full value of the claim multiplied by the percentage of the chance lost ( Matsuyama v. Birnbaum , Mass. 2008). Other states reject the doctrine.

Divisible and Indivisible Harm

Divisible harm: When the harm can reasonably be divided—for example, when two factories each kill an identifiable portion of a neighbor's fish, or two drivers cause separate injuries in separate collisions—each defendant is liable only for the part it caused.

Indivisible harm: When the harm cannot reasonably be divided, such as a single death or a house destroyed by merged fires, the tortfeasors are jointly and severally liable.

Burden of proof: When several defendants' tortious conduct combined to cause harm, a defendant who claims the harm can be divided generally bears the burden of proving how to divide it.

Concert of action: People who act together under a common plan, such as drivers engaged in a street race, are jointly liable for harm caused by any of them.

Modern Limits on Joint and Several Liability

Many states have abolished or limited joint and several liability. Some make each defendant liable only for its percentage of fault; others keep joint and several liability only for defendants whose fault exceeds a threshold or only for economic damages; and some reallocate an insolvent defendant's share among the remaining parties. On the MBE, apply joint and several liability unless the question says otherwise.

Effect of Settlements

Approach How a Settlement Affects Nonsettling Defendants

Pro tanto The plaintiff's claim is reduced by the amount paid. Under the Uniform Contribution Among Tortfeasors Act (1955), a good-faith settlement also protects the settling tortfeasor from contribution claims.

Pro rata The claim is reduced by the settling tortfeasor's equal (per capita) share of liability.

Comparative share The claim is reduced by the settling tortfeasor's percentage of fault, regardless of the amount paid ( McDermott, Inc. v. AmClyde , 1994, in admiralty).

For example, suppose a plaintiff's damages are $100,000, Defendant A is 60% at fault, and Defendant B is 40% at fault, and the plaintiff settles with B for $20,000. Under the pro tanto approach, A owes $80,000. Under the comparative-share approach, A owes $60,000, and the plaintiff bears the cost of having settled cheaply with B.