Study guide
5.3 The Plateau Method, Overmasking & The Masking Dilemma
Board Certified in Hearing Instrument Sciences BC-HIS
Track your progress as you read
Finished sections get a check mark.
1 Chapter 1: Credential Overview & Exam Strategy
1.1 NBC-HIS Board Certification & NCE Exam Format 1.2 Clinical Study Framework & Pacing Strategy
2 Chapter 2: Patient Intake, Medical History, Auditory Disorders & Prevention
2.1 Case History Intake, Communication Needs & Family Dynamics 2.2 Ototoxic Medications & Systemic Medical Conditions 2.3 Outer and Middle Ear Pathologies 2.4 Inner Ear and Retrocochlear Pathologies 2.5 Noise Exposure History & Preventative Hearing Protection
3 Chapter 3: Medical Referral, Tinnitus & Patient Expectations
3.1 FDA Red Flags & Medical Referral Indications 3.2 Tinnitus Evaluation, Assessment & Hyperacusis 3.3 Patient Motivation, Readiness & Expectation Management 3.4 Auditory Deprivation, Unilateral Loss & Asymmetrical Hearing
4 Chapter 4: Otoscopy & Pure-Tone Audiometry
4.1 Otoscopic Inspection, Landmarks & Cerumen Assessment 4.2 Pure-Tone Air Conduction Audiometry & Transducers 4.3 Pure-Tone Bone Conduction Audiometry & The Occlusion Effect 4.4 Audiometric Synthesis: Degree, Configuration & Type of Loss
5 Chapter 5: Masking Theory and Clinical Protocols
5.1 Masking Principles & Interaural Attenuation 5.2 Air and Bone Conduction Masking Criteria 5.3 The Plateau Method, Overmasking & The Masking Dilemma
6 Chapter 6: Speech Audiometry & Immittance Testing
6.1 Speech Reception (SRT), Detection (SDT) & Threshold Agreement 6.2 Word Recognition Testing (WRS), PB-Max & Rollover 6.3 Immittance Audiometry, Tympanometry & Acoustic Reflexes
7 Chapter 7: Hearing Aid Form Factors, Acoustics & Components
7.1 Hearing Aid Form Factors & Style Candidacy 7.2 Acoustic Transducers, Microphones & Telecoils 7.3 Digital Signal Processing & Compression Architectures 7.4 Directionality, Noise Reduction & Frequency Lowering
8 Chapter 8: Prescriptive Targets, ANSI Specifications & Binaural Fitting
8.1 Prescriptive Fitting Rationales: NAL-NL2 vs. DSL v5 8.2 ANSI S3.22 Electroacoustic Analysis & Specifications 8.3 Binaural Amplification, Head Shadow & CROS/BiCROS Systems
9 Chapter 9: Ear Impressions, Earmold Physics, Probe-Mic & Sound-Field Verification
9.1 Ear Impression Materials & Techniques 9.2 Earmold Styles, Materials & Acoustic Modifications 9.3 Real-Ear Measurement (REM) & Probe-Microphone Physics 9.4 Speech Mapping Verification & Fitting Tolerances 9.5 Sound-Field Verification, Functional Gain & Aided Testing
10 Chapter 10: Programming, Fine-Tuning, Delivery & Troubleshooting
10.1 Hearing Instrument Programming & Patient-Driven Adjustments 10.2 Device Delivery, Orientation & Patient Handling 10.3 Troubleshooting, Maintenance, Listening Checks & Repairs
11 Chapter 11: Counseling, Aural Rehabilitation & Outcome Validation
11.1 Post-Fitting Counseling, Adjustment & Realistic Expectations 11.2 Aural Rehabilitation & Communication Strategies 11.3 Standardized Outcome Validation Measures (COSI, HHIE, IOI-HA)
12 Chapter 12: Assistive Technology, Regulatory Standards & Professional Ethics
12.1 Assistive Listening Devices (ALDs) & Wireless Connectivity 12.2 Regulatory Compliance: FDA Regulations, OTC Hearing Aids & HIPAA 12.3 NBC-HIS Code of Ethics, Scope of Practice & Interprofessional Collaboration
5.3 The Plateau Method, Overmasking & The Masking Dilemma
Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI
The Hood Plateau Method establishes true auditory thresholds by plotting test ear response against incremental non-test ear masking noise across undermasking, plateau, and overmasking zones.
A true clinical plateau is verified when the test ear threshold remains unchanged across a minimum range of 15 to 20 dB of masking noise (three consecutive 5-dB masking increments without threshold shift).
Overmasking occurs when effective masking presented to the non-test ear traverses the skull to stimulate the test ear cochlea, mathematically triggered when E M N T E ≥ B C T E + I A EM_{NTE} \ge BC_{TE} + IA E M NTE ≥ B C TE + I A .
The Masking Dilemma is an insurmountable clinical gridlock occurring in bilateral severe conductive or mixed hearing losses where the Initial Masking Level ( I M L IML I M L ) meets or exceeds the overmasking threshold, completely eliminating the plateau.
Clinicians manage the masking dilemma by switching to insert earphones to expand interaural attenuation from 40 to 60 dB, utilizing the Sensorineural Acuity Level (SAL) test, and performing immittance and electroacoustic cross-checks.
Last updated: September 2026
5.3 The Plateau Method, Overmasking & The Masking Dilemma
Note
Introducing masking noise is only the initial step in obtaining ear-specific data. To confirm that the recorded threshold is neither an undermasked shadow response nor an artificially elevated overmasked artifact, the clinician must perform a dynamic threshold search using the Hood Plateau Method . Recognizing the boundaries of the plateau—and knowing how to manage when that plateau collapses into a masking dilemma—is a hallmark of advanced clinical competence.
The Hood Plateau Method & The Concept of Effective Masking
Introduced in 1960 by British audiologist J.D. Hood, the Plateau Method provides a standardized psychophysical protocol for identifying true sensory thresholds in the presence of contralateral masking noise.
Understanding Effective Masking (EM)
Modern audiometers calibrate masking noise in Decibels of Effective Masking (dB EM) rather than Sound Pressure Level (SPL):
0 dB EM 0\text{ dB EM} 0 dB EM : The exact intensity of narrow-band noise required to just mask a pure tone presented at 0 dB HL 0\text{ dB HL} 0 dB HL in the same ear.
40 dB EM 40\text{ dB EM} 40 dB EM : Sufficient noise to just mask a 40 dB HL 40\text{ dB HL} 40 dB HL pure tone.
Under an effective masking calibration, each 1 dB 1\text{ dB} 1 dB increase in masking noise shifts the threshold of that ear by exactly 1 dB 1\text{ dB} 1 dB .
The Three Psychophysical Masking Zones
When masking noise in the non-test ear is plotted on the horizontal axis against the test ear tone threshold on the vertical axis, three distinct behavioral zones emerge: THE HOOD MASKING PLATEAU CURVE
- Test Ear Threshold (dB HL)
- ▲
- │ / Overmasking Zone
- │ / (Slope = 1:1)
- │ / EM crosses skull to TE
- │ ┌──────────────────┐
- │ │ PLATEAU ZONE │
- │ │ (Slope = 0:1) │
- │ │ True Threshold │
- │ ┌┴──────────────────┴┐
- │ / │ 15 - 20 dB Width │
- │ / └──────────────────┘
- │ / Undermasking Zone
- │ / (Slope = 1:1)
- │ / NTE still hearing tone
- │ /
- └──────────────┴───────────────────────────┴──────────────►
- 0 IML Overmask Masking Level
- Threshold in NTE (dB EM)
Undermasking Zone : The masking noise presented to the non-test ear is insufficient to prevent the non-test cochlea from detecting the crossed-over tone. As the masking noise is increased by 10 dB 10\text{ dB} 10 dB , the apparent threshold of the test ear shifts upward by 10 dB 10\text{ dB} 10 dB in a direct 1:1 ratio. The patient is still responding with their non-test ear.
Plateau Zone : The masking noise in the non-test ear is sufficiently intense to prevent the non-test cochlea from hearing the crossed tone, but not yet intense enough to cross back to the test cochlea. Across this range (typically 15 to 20 dB 15\text{ to }20\text{ dB} 15 to 20 dB wide), increasing the masking noise produces no change whatsoever in the test ear threshold (slope = 0). This unchanging response level represents the true threshold of the test ear .
Overmasking Zone : The masking noise in the non-test ear reaches such high sound pressure levels that it crosses the skull via bone conduction, entering the test ear cochlea and artificially driving up the test ear's true threshold in a 1:1 ratio.
Step-by-Step Clinical Plateau Protocol
To establish a valid plateau, the hearing instrument specialist executes a disciplined four-phase clinical sequence: STEP-BY-STEP PLATEAU PROTOCOL
- [Phase 1: Set Initial Masking Level (IML) in NTE]
- (AC: AC_NTE + 10 dB; BC: AC_NTE + OE + 10 dB)
- │
- ▼
- [Phase 2: Re-establish Test Tone Threshold in TE]
- (Present tone at original unmasked threshold level)
- │
- ┌──────────────┴──────────────┐
- ▼ ▼
- [Tone Heard?] [Tone NOT Heard?]
- │ │
- │ ▼
- │ [Raise Tone in 5 dB Steps]
- │ (Hughson-Westlake search until heard)
- │ │
- └──────────────┬──────────────┘
- │
- ▼
- [Phase 3: The 5-dB Incremental Masking Search]
- (Raise masking noise in NTE by 5 dB; re-present tone)
- │
- ┌──────────────┴──────────────┐
- ▼ ▼
- [Tone Heard?] [Tone NOT Heard?]
- │ │
- │ ▼
- │ [Raise Tone in 5 dB Steps]
- │ (Until response is restored)
- │ │
- └──────────────┬──────────────┘
- │
- ▼
- [Phase 4: Confirm Plateau Verification]
- (Must achieve 3 consecutive 5-dB masking increases
- with ZERO shift in test tone threshold = 15 dB plateau)
- │
- ▼
- [Record True Masked Threshold with Appropriate Symbol]
- Clinical Nuance: Distinguishing Plateau Shifts from Central Masking
During Phase 3, when the initial masking noise is introduced, a threshold shift of 5 dB 5\text{ dB} 5 dB is frequently observed even when no cross-hearing was occurring. This mild shift is caused by central masking —a normal neurophysiological phenomenon where low-level noise in one ear inhibits sound perception in the contralateral auditory cortex by approximately 5 dB 5\text{ dB} 5 dB . Clinicians should anticipate a 5 dB 5\text{ dB} 5 dB shift as a normal physiological reaction rather than immediate cross-hearing.
- Undermasking vs. Overmasking Mechanics
- Undermasking
Definition : Delivering a masking level in the non-test ear that falls below the intensity of the crossed-over tone ( N o i s e N T E < S i g n a l T E − I A Noise_{NTE} < Signal_{TE} - IA N o i s e NTE < S i g na l TE − I A ).
Clinical Danger : The clinician records a false, artificially sensitive threshold (the shadow curve). In unilateral profound deafness, undermasking leads to the tragic error of declaring the patient a candidate for standard amplification in a dead ear rather than directing them toward a CROS fitting, bone-anchored device, or ENT referral.
Overmasking
Definition : The masking noise presented to the non-test ear exceeds the interaural attenuation and stimulates the test ear's cochlea via bone conduction.
Mathematical Trigger for Overmasking : Overmasking occurs at the exact threshold where the effective masking level in the non-test ear equals or exceeds the bone-conduction threshold of the test ear plus interaural attenuation: E M N T E ≥ B C T E + I A \mathbf{EM_{NTE} \ge BC_{TE} + IA} E M NTE ≥ B C TE + IA
Where:
E M N T E EM_{NTE} E M NTE is the effective masking level delivered to the non-test ear.
B C T E BC_{TE} B C TE is the true bone-conduction threshold of the test ear.
I A IA I A is the interaural attenuation ( 40 dB 40\text{ dB} 40 dB for supra-aural, 60 dB 60\text{ dB} 60 dB for inserts).
Mathematical Demonstration of Overmasking
Suppose a patient has a left ear bone conduction threshold of B C T E = 20 dB HL BC_{TE} = 20\text{ dB HL} B C TE = 20 dB HL , and testing is conducted with supra-aural earphones ( I A = 40 dB IA = 40\text{ dB} I A = 40 dB ): Overmasking Threshold = B C T E ( 20 ) + I A ( 40 ) = 60 dB EM \text{Overmasking Threshold} = BC_{TE} (20) + IA (40) = \mathbf{60\text{ dB EM}} Overmasking Threshold = B C TE ( 20 ) + I A ( 40 ) = 60 dB EM
If the clinician raises the masking noise in the right ear to 60 dB EM 60\text{ dB EM} 60 dB EM or higher, the noise itself crosses the skull via bone conduction, enters the left cochlea at 20 dB HL 20\text{ dB HL} 20 dB HL , and begins elevating the left ear's pure-tone threshold. Any threshold recorded with masking ≥ 60 dB EM \ge 60\text{ dB EM} ≥ 60 dB EM is contaminated by overmasking.
The Masking Dilemma: Etiology & Clinical Gridlock
What is the Masking Dilemma?
The Masking Dilemma is an insurmountable audiometric gridlock occurring when the Initial Masking Level ( I M L IML I M L ) required to eliminate cross-hearing in the non-test ear is equal to or greater than the overmasking threshold ( E M N T E ≥ B C T E + I A EM_{NTE} \ge BC_{TE} + IA E M NTE ≥ B C TE + I A ).
When this occurs, the plateau width shrinks to zero decibels. There is no intensity level at which masking is both sufficient to prevent cross-hearing and low enough to avoid overmasking: I M L N T E ≥ B C T E + I A ⟹ Plateau Width ≤ 0 dB \mathbf{IML_{NTE} \ge BC_{TE} + IA \implies \text{Plateau Width } \le 0\text{ dB}} IM L NTE ≥ B C TE + IA ⟹ Plateau Width ≤ 0 dB ANATOMY OF THE MASKING DILEMMA
Acoustic Decibel Scale (dB HL / EM)
- 100 ──┐
- 90 ──┤
- 80 ──┤ ◄── Initial Masking Level Required (IML = AC_NTE + 10 = 80 dB)
- 70 ──┤
- 60 ──┤
- 50 ──┤ ◄── Overmasking Threshold (BC_TE + IA = 10 + 40 = 50 dB)
- 40 ──┤
- 30 ──┤ ═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════
20 ──┤ CRITICAL GRIDLOCK:
10 ──┤ IML (80 dB) is 30 dB HIGHER than Overmasking (50 dB)!
0 ──┘ Plateau is completely obliterated (-30 dB width).
- ═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════
- Clinical Etiology: Bilateral Conductive/Mixed Losses
The masking dilemma occurs almost exclusively in cases of bilateral severe conductive or mixed hearing losses , such as:
Advanced bilateral otosclerosis with stapedial footplate fixation.
Chronic bilateral otitis media with extensive ossicular chain discontinuity and effusion.
Bilateral congenital aural atresia or severe middle ear malformations.
Quantitative Proof of Plateau Obliteration
Consider a patient with bilateral otosclerosis evaluated with supra-aural earphones ( I A = 40 dB IA = 40\text{ dB} I A = 40 dB ):
Right Ear (TE) : A C = 70 dB HL AC = 70\text{ dB HL} A C = 70 dB HL , B C = 10 dB HL BC = 10\text{ dB HL} BC = 10 dB HL (Air-Bone Gap = 60 dB 60\text{ dB} 60 dB )
Left Ear (NTE) : A C = 70 dB HL AC = 70\text{ dB HL} A C = 70 dB HL , B C = 10 dB HL BC = 10\text{ dB HL} BC = 10 dB HL (Air-Bone Gap = 60 dB 60\text{ dB} 60 dB )
Calculate Air Conduction IML in Left Ear (NTE) : I M L = A C N T E + 10 = 70 + 10 = 80 dB EM IML = AC_{NTE} + 10 = 70 + 10 = \mathbf{80\text{ dB EM}} I M L = A C NTE + 10 = 70 + 10 = 80 dB EM
Calculate Overmasking Threshold for Right Ear (TE) : Overmasking Threshold = B C T E + I A = 10 + 40 = 50 dB EM \text{Overmasking Threshold} = BC_{TE} + IA = 10 + 40 = \mathbf{50\text{ dB EM}} Overmasking Threshold = B C TE + I A = 10 + 40 = 50 dB EM
Analyze the Difference :
To prevent cross-hearing, the clinician must present at least 80 dB EM 80\text{ dB EM} 80 dB EM . But introducing anything over 50 dB EM 50\text{ dB EM} 50 dB EM immediately overmasks the test ear! The clinician is caught in an inescapable trap: presenting 80 dB EM 80\text{ dB EM} 80 dB EM overmasks by 30 dB 30\text{ dB} 30 dB , while presenting < 80 dB EM < 80\text{ dB EM} < 80 dB EM undermasks.
Clinical Management of the Masking Dilemma
When confronted with a masking dilemma, the specialist cannot simply guess at bone-conduction thresholds. Several validated clinical strategies must be employed: MASKING DILEMMA RESOLUTION STRATEGIES
- [Masking Dilemma Identified]
- (IML ≥ Overmasking Threshold)
- │
- ┌──────────────────────────────┼──────────────────────────────┐
- ▼ ▼ ▼
- [Transducer Conversion] [SAL Technique] [Diagnostic Cross-Check]
- Switch from Supra-Aural Sensorineural Acuity Immittance Audiometry
- (IA = 40) to Inserts Level Test Type B Tympanograms,
- (IA = 60) Forehead BC Noise + Absent Acoustic Reflexes
- Widens Window by 20-30 dB Air-Conducted Tones Confirms Conductive Loss
- │ │ │
- └──────────────────────────────┼──────────────────────────────┘
- │
- ▼
- [Otologic Medical Referral (ENT)]
- Surgical Candidacy (Stapedectomy)
- Bone-Conduction Auditory Brainstem Response
- 1. Transducer Conversion to Insert Earphones (Primary Intervention)
The immediate, most powerful clinical intervention is replacing supra-aural earphones with deeply seated insert earphones (ER-3A/ER-3C):
IA increases from 40 dB 40\text{ dB} 40 dB to 60 dB 60\text{ dB} 60 dB (a 20 dB 20\text{ dB} 20 dB boost).
The Occlusion Effect is drastically reduced from 20 dB 20\text{ dB} 20 dB down to 0 - 5 dB 0\text{-}5\text{ dB} 0 - 5 dB at low frequencies, lowering the required I M L IML I M L .
In our otosclerosis example, raising IA to 60 dB 60\text{ dB} 60 dB shifts the overmasking threshold from 50 dB 50\text{ dB} 50 dB to 70 dB EM 70\text{ dB EM} 70 dB EM ( 10 + 60 = 70 10 + 60 = 70 10 + 60 = 70 ). Combined with the elimination of the occlusion effect, this intervention frequently reclaims a usable 10 to 20 dB 10\text{ to }20\text{ dB} 10 to 20 dB plateau where none existed.
2. The Sensorineural Acuity Level (SAL) Technique
Developed by James Jerger and Tom Tillman in 1960, the SAL test circumvents the masking dilemma entirely:
Pure-tone air-conduction thresholds are measured in both ears in the unmasked state.
A bone-conduction oscillator is placed on the center of the forehead , delivering a fixed, maximum level of narrow-band or thermal noise.
Air-conduction thresholds are re-measured while the noise is playing through the bone oscillator.
The shift in air-conduction threshold produced by the bone-conducted noise is compared against normative threshold shifts established in normal-hearing listeners.
If the patient has a pure sensorineural loss, the noise shifts their air threshold dramatically. If the patient has a severe conductive loss, the bone-conducted noise shifts the threshold by the exact normative amount, permitting calculation of true sensorineural sensitivity without earphone masking.
3. Immittance & Acoustic Reflex Cross-Checks
When behavioral masking fails, the clinician relies on objective immittance testing (the Jerger Cross-Check Principle ):
Flat Type B tympanograms with normal canal volume indicate middle ear effusion.
Type A s A_s A s (shallow) tympanograms with completely absent acoustic reflexes (probe-ear and sound-ear) corroborate ossicular fixation (otosclerosis).
Absent acoustic reflexes in the presence of normal tympanometry strongly support a bilateral conductive lesion, validating that the unmasked air-bone gaps are physiological rather than artifacts.
4. Electrophysiology and Otologic Medical Referral
If a definitive sensorineural reserve cannot be established behaviorally:
The patient must be referred to an Otolaryngologist (ENT) for medical evaluation and high-resolution temporal bone CT imaging.
Diagnostic verification can be achieved via Bone-Conduction Auditory Brainstem Response (BC-ABR) testing, which objectively identifies wave V latencies to establish cochlear thresholds without behavioral masking plateaus.