Study guide

19.1 Ethics Principles & Decision-Making Capacity

NBME Comprehensive Basic Science Examination CBSE

Track your progress as you read

Finished sections get a check mark.

1 Introduction & Exam Navigation

1.1 Current Exam Facts & Administration 1.2 Content Blueprint & Physician Tasks 1.3 Scoring, Score Reports & Step 1 Readiness

2 Human Development

2.1 Embryology & Congenital Development Patterns 2.2 Normal Age-Related Findings & Well-Patient Care

3 Blood & Hematologic Disease

3.1 Hematopoiesis, RBC Disorders & Anemias 3.2 Hemostasis, Thrombosis & Coagulopathies 3.3 WBC Disorders, Leukemia & Lymphoma Mechanisms

4 Immune System

4.1 Innate & Adaptive Immunity Mechanisms 4.2 Hypersensitivity, Autoimmunity & Immunodeficiency 4.3 Transplant Immunology & Immune Pharmacology

5 Nervous System Anatomy & Disease

5.1 Neuroanatomy Localization & Pathways 5.2 Stroke, Infection, Demyelination & Trauma 5.3 Seizures, Movement Disorders & Neurodegeneration 5.4 Special Senses: Eye & Ear Mechanisms

6 Behavioral Health

6.1 Psychiatric Disorders & Diagnostic Patterns 6.2 Psychopharmacology Mechanisms 6.3 Neurotransmitters, Learning & Behavioral Science

7 Musculoskeletal System

7.1 Bone Physiology, Fracture Healing & Bone Pathology 7.2 Joint Disease, Rheumatology & Connective Tissue 7.3 Muscle, NMJ & Peripheral Nerve Disorders

8 Skin & Soft Tissue

8.1 Dermatopathology High-Yield Lesions 8.2 Inflammation, Wound Healing & Soft-Tissue Infection

9 Cardiovascular Pathophysiology

9.1 Cardiac Cycle, Hemodynamics & Murmurs 9.2 Ischemic Heart Disease & Cardiomyopathy 9.3 Congenital & Valvular Heart Disease 9.4 Vascular Pathology & Hypertension

10 Cardiovascular Pharmacology

10.1 Antihypertensives, Heart Failure & Antiarrhythmics 10.2 Antiplatelets, Anticoagulants & Lipid Drugs

11 Respiratory System

11.1 Pulmonary Mechanics & Gas Exchange 11.2 Obstructive, Restrictive & Vascular Lung Disease 11.3 Pulmonary Infections, Neoplasms & Respiratory Pharmacology

12 Renal Physiology & Electrolytes

12.1 Nephron Transport & Renal Physiology 12.2 Electrolyte Disorders 12.3 Acid-Base Physiology & Compensation

13 Renal Pathology

13.1 Glomerular Disease Mechanisms 13.2 Tubulointerstitial, Vascular & Stone Disease

14 Gastrointestinal System

14.1 GI Physiology, Motility & Digestion 14.2 Esophagus, Stomach & Intestinal Pathology 14.3 Liver, Biliary Tree & Pancreas 14.4 GI Microbiology, Nutrition & Malabsorption

15 Endocrine System

15.1 Hormone Signaling & Hypothalamic-Pituitary Axes 15.2 Thyroid & Parathyroid Disease 15.3 Adrenal Disorders & Steroid Pharmacology 15.4 Diabetes, Glucose Homeostasis & Metabolic Syndrome

16 Reproductive System

16.1 Male & Female Reproductive Physiology 16.2 Pregnancy, Placenta & Developmental Toxicology 16.3 Reproductive Pathology & Hormone-Related Neoplasia

17 Multisystem Processes & Disorders

17.1 Cell Injury, Inflammation & Repair 17.2 Neoplasia Principles & Tumor Biology 17.3 Infection, Sepsis & Multisystem Microbial Disease 17.4 Genetics, Inborn Errors & Environmental Toxicology

18 Biostatistics & Epidemiology

18.1 Study Design, Bias & Causation 18.2 Diagnostic Test Metrics & Screening 18.3 Epidemiology Measures & Population Health

19 Social Sciences & Communication

19.1 Ethics Principles & Decision-Making Capacity 19.2 Communication Skills & Difficult Conversations 19.3 Professionalism, Systems & Practice-Based Learning

20 Integrated Disciplines Capstone

20.1 High-Yield Microbiology Anchors Across Systems 20.2 High-Yield Biochemistry & Molecular Mechanisms 20.3 Integrated Pharmacology Strategy & Exam-Day Execution

19.1 Ethics Principles & Decision-Making Capacity

Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI

The four principles—autonomy, beneficence, nonmaleficence, and justice—frame nearly every CBSE ethics vignette; identify which principle is in conflict before choosing an action.

Decision-making capacity requires understanding, appreciation, reasoning, and expression of a choice; capacity is decision-specific and may fluctuate, whereas legal competence is a court determination.

Informed consent needs information (risks, benefits, alternatives including no treatment), capacity, and voluntariness free of coercion; emergencies allow implied consent for life-saving care.

When the patient lacks capacity, follow advance directives (living will, DPOA-HC) and then the jurisdiction’s surrogate hierarchy; minors generally need parent/guardian consent except for emancipated minors and many confidential reproductive/mental-health services.

Confidentiality yields to public-safety duties (Tarasoff-style duty to protect, reportable diseases, suspected abuse); research ethics rest on Belmont principles, IRB review, and clinical equipoise.

Last updated: August 2026

19.1 Ethics Principles & Decision-Making Capacity

Quick Answer: Name the conflicting principle(s) → assess capacity (understand, appreciate, reason, express choice) → obtain informed consent or follow advance directives/surrogates → protect confidentiality unless a clear duty to warn/report applies. Capacity is clinical and decision-specific; competence is a legal status. Emergencies permit treatment under implied consent. Research needs IRB approval, informed consent, and equipoise.

Social sciences and communication skills account for roughly 6–9% of CBSE content (Communication & Interpersonal Skills), with ethics and decision-making woven through vignettes that look clinical but hinge on process. Score by labeling the ethical problem first, then applying a stepwise algorithm rather than “what feels nice.”

The Four Principles (Beauchamp & Childress Framework)

Principle Core meaning Typical CBSE conflict

Autonomy Respect the capable patient’s informed preferences and right to refuse Patient refuses life-prolonging dialysis despite good prognosis

Beneficence Act to promote the patient’s well-being and best interests Urge indicated antibiotics for pneumonia

Nonmaleficence “Do no harm”; avoid unnecessary risk and net-harmful interventions Stop futile CPR after prolonged asystole with no recovery chance

Justice Fair allocation of scarce resources and equal treatment of like cases Triage ICU bed; equitable access regardless of insurance or status

Worked vignette — autonomy vs beneficence

A 58-year-old with capacity declines coronary angiography after a non-STEMI. The team believes angiography is “clearly best.” Answer pattern: document informed refusal, explore reasons and barriers, offer alternatives, and do not force the procedure. Beneficence does not override a capable refusal.

Worked vignette — justice

Two patients need the last ICU bed: one has higher short-term survival probability and another has greater social status. Justice prioritizes medical need and prognosis criteria, not wealth, celebrity, or personal preference of staff.

Exam tip: When two principles clash, the correct option usually (1) preserves autonomy of a capable patient, (2) uses least-harm means, or (3) follows fair triage rules—not “do whatever the family wants” if it violates a known patient preference.

Informed Consent Elements

Valid informed consent requires three pillars :

Information — nature of the intervention; material risks and benefits; reasonable alternatives (including no treatment ); expected course without intervention.

Capacity — the patient can perform the four capacities below for this decision.

Voluntariness — free of coercion, undue influence, or manipulation (including pressure from family or staff framed as “you have no real choice”).

  • Element What to document Common pitfall
  • Disclosure Diagnosis, procedure, risks, benefits, alternatives Omitting “do nothing” as an alternative
  • Understanding Patient restates key points in own words Signing a form without comprehension
  • Capacity Decision-specific assessment Equating “disagrees with doctor” with incapacity
  • Voluntariness No coercion; time for questions “Consent” under threat of discharge abandonment

Emergencies: If delay would cause serious harm and the patient cannot consent (unconscious trauma, acute MI with cardiogenic shock), treat under implied/emergency consent for life- or limb-saving care until the patient can participate or a surrogate is available. Do not perform non-urgent procedures under emergency consent.

Therapeutic privilege (withholding information because disclosure would cause severe harm) is narrowly construed and rarely the best answer; prefer graduated disclosure with support.

Decision-Making Capacity vs Competence

  • Feature Capacity Competence
  • Who decides Clinician (often with psychiatry consult if unclear) Court / legal system
  • Scope Decision-specific; may vary by complexity Global legal status (e.g., guardianship)
  • Time course Can fluctuate (delirium, intoxication, mood) Relatively stable until court revises
  • Threshold Higher for high-stakes irreversible decisions Binary legal finding
  • Four abilities (Appelbaum framework)

Understand relevant information (diagnosis, options, risks/benefits).

Appreciate that the information applies to oneself (not “people with cancer die” while denying personal illness).

Reason — weigh options consistently with one’s values; show a logical path (even if conclusion differs from the physician’s).

Express a choice — communicate a preference (verbally, writing, reliable yes/no).

High-yield traps

Disagreeing with medical advice ≠ incapacity if the four abilities are intact.

Psychosis, mania, severe depression, dementia, or delirium may impair capacity for some decisions but not automatically for all (a patient with schizophrenia may still refuse a finger-stick if they understand risks).

Intoxication: reassess after sobriety when safe; stabilize emergently if needed.

Sliding scale: consent for low-risk blood draw needs less cognitive demand than refusal of dialysis.

Worked vignette — capacity

A patient with schizophrenia refuses appendectomy for acute appendicitis, stating “surgeons implant tracking devices.” She cannot appreciate her acute illness or reason about infection risk. Lacks capacity for this decision → seek surrogate / emergency treatment pathway. Contrast: same patient calmly refuses optional cosmetic scar revision with clear understanding → likely has capacity.

Surrogates and Advance Directives

When capacity is lacking, decision-making follows known patient wishes, then appointed and default surrogates.

Instrument What it does CBSE use

Living will Written preferences for end-of-life interventions (ventilator, CPR, feeding) under specified conditions Follow if applicable to the clinical scenario

Durable power of attorney for health care (DPOA-HC / health-care proxy) Appoints a decision-maker for when the patient lacks capacity Proxy’s authority usually outranks default family hierarchy

  • POLST / MOLST Portable medical orders for seriously ill patients Actionable orders across settings
  • Oral statements Prior expressed wishes to clinicians/family Use when documented and applicable

Typical surrogate hierarchy concepts (jurisdiction-specific; know the idea for exams):

  • Court-appointed guardian
  • Health-care agent named in DPOA
  • Spouse / domestic partner
  • Adult children
  • Parents
  • Adult siblings
  • Other relatives / close friends

Surrogates should use substituted judgment (what the patient would have wanted) when known, then best interests if wishes are unknown. They cannot demand clearly futile interventions that violate professional standards; ethics/legal consultation may be needed.

Worked vignette — directives

An unconscious patient has a living will refusing mechanical ventilation in permanent vegetative state and a daughter as DPOA who demands “everything.” If criteria for the living will are met, honor the living will; the agent implements the patient’s known wishes, not the agent’s own preferences.

Death, Dying, Brain Death, and Organ Donation

The official Social Sciences outline lists death and dying and palliative care explicitly, including life support, brain death, and organ donation. These items are rule-based, so learn the definitions rather than reasoning from sentiment.

Brain death is legal death in every U.S. jurisdiction — it is not coma and not a vegetative state. Determination requires an established irreversible cause; exclusion of confounders (hypothermia, sedative or paralytic effect, severe metabolic derangement); coma with no cerebral response; absent brainstem reflexes at every level (pupillary, corneal, oculocephalic/oculovestibular, gag, cough); and a positive apnea test — no respiratory effort despite PaCO₂ rising to roughly 60 mm Hg or more.

  • State Cortex Brainstem Legal status Recovery
  • Brain death Absent Absent Dead None

Persistent vegetative state Absent Intact — sleep–wake cycles, spontaneous breathing Alive Rare beyond 12 months (traumatic) or 3 months (anoxic)

  • Coma Depressed Variable Alive Possible
  • Locked-in syndrome Intact and aware Ventral pontine lesion Alive Limited; vertical gaze and blink preserved

Spinal reflexes do not exclude brain death. Triple flexion or a Lazarus sign is generated below the foramen magnum and is a standard distractor.

Consequences that follow from the determination:

Once brain death is declared the patient is dead, so stopping the ventilator is not withdrawal of care from a living patient and surrogate consent is not required for it. Consent is required for organ donation.

Withholding and withdrawing life-sustaining treatment are ethically and legally equivalent. A time-limited trial of ventilation that is later stopped is permissible, which is why "we can never turn it off once it is on" is always a wrong answer.

Artificial nutrition and hydration are legally medical treatments and are refusable like any other.

Titrating opioids to relieve terminal dyspnea or pain is permitted even if it may hasten death — the doctrine of double effect , because the intent is symptom relief and the dose is titrated to that effect. Deliberately administering a lethal dose is a categorically different act.

Organ donation. The treating clinician should not be the one to raise donation; the trained organ procurement organization (OPO) approaches the family, preserving separation between the team managing the patient and the transplant decision. A signed donor card or first-person registry entry is legally sufficient authorization in most states even over family objection, although OPOs generally work toward family agreement. Hospice eligibility rests on a prognosis of six months or less if the disease follows its usual course, and it does not require a DNR order — a frequent distractor.

Minors and Emancipated Minors

  • Concept Rule of thumb
  • General rule Parents/guardians consent for minors; assent of older children is sought when possible

Emancipated minor Married, military, financially independent/court-emancipated (criteria vary) — can consent as an adult for medical care

Mature minor doctrine Some jurisdictions allow older adolescents to consent to certain care if they demonstrate maturity

Common confidential exceptions Reproductive health (contraception, pregnancy-related care, STI treatment), substance use, outpatient mental health — often without parental consent/notification (state-dependent)

  • Emergencies Treat life-threatening conditions without parental consent if delay is dangerous
  • Abuse Report suspected child abuse; confidentiality yields to protection

Parents generally cannot refuse clearly life-saving, low-burden treatment for a minor (e.g., transfusion for life-threatening hemorrhage in a child of Jehovah’s Witness parents). Seek emergency court order / ethics support while stabilizing; do not simply “respect parental autonomy” when the child will die from a highly effective intervention.

Confidentiality and Duty to Protect

Confidentiality is a core autonomy/privacy duty but is not absolute .

  • Situation Typical obligation
  • Ordinary clinical information Keep private; share with care team on need-to-know

Tarasoff-style duty Identifiable third party at serious risk of violence → warn/protect (notify potential victim and/or police per local law)

  • Reportable communicable diseases Report to public health as required
  • Suspected child / elder / dependent-adult abuse Mandatory reporting
  • Impaired drivers (varies) Some states mandate report of specific conditions
  • Gunshot / certain wounds Report to law enforcement as required
  • Partner notification for HIV/STI Follow public-health protocol; do not abandon patient
  • Worked vignette — Tarasoff

A psychiatric patient states he will kill his named ex-partner tonight and has a plan. Duty to protect: take steps to warn the identifiable victim and involve authorities as required; hospitalization may also be indicated. Do not only “encourage the patient to tell her himself” as the sole action.

Worked vignette — confidentiality

A competent adult asks that STI results not be shared with a spouse. Counsel about partner risk and reporting laws; do not casually disclose to the spouse outside legal public-health channels.

Research Ethics: Belmont, IRB, Equipoise

  • Belmont principle Application
  • Respect for persons Informed consent; extra protections for those with diminished autonomy
  • Beneficence Minimize risks; maximize potential benefits; risk–benefit analysis
  • Justice Fair subject selection; do not exploit vulnerable populations

IRB (Institutional Review Board): reviews protocols for ethics, risk, consent language, and subject protections before research begins and during continuing review.

Clinical equipoise: honest professional uncertainty about which arm is superior; unethical to randomize when one arm is known inferior for the study population.

Vulnerable populations: children, prisoners, pregnant persons, cognitively impaired — additional safeguards; assent + parental permission for children when applicable.

Placebos: acceptable when no proven effective therapy exists or under carefully justified designs; not when withholding known effective therapy would cause serious harm without justification.

Truth-Telling, Withholding, and Errors

Default: capable patients are entitled to accurate diagnostic and prognostic information. Withholding “to protect hope” is usually wrong if the patient wants information.

Ask preferences: some patients prefer less detail or family-mediated disclosure (cultural preferences); still confirm with the patient when possible rather than assuming.

Therapeutic privilege: rare; requires serious likelihood that disclosure would cause immediate harm (e.g., precipitating suicide in an unstable patient) and a plan to disclose later with supports.

Family requests to withhold cancer diagnosis: explore reasons; generally inform the patient unless the patient has declined information or clear harm standards are met.

Medical errors: disclose honestly, apologize appropriately, explain next steps, and report through institutional systems (expanded in §19.3).

Integration algorithm for CBSE ethics items

Is the patient capable for this decision?

If yes → honor informed consent/refusal after adequate disclosure.

If no → advance directive → designated proxy → default surrogate → best interests.

Is there an emergency exception?

Is there a reporting / duty-to-protect override of confidentiality?

Is this research (IRB/consent/equipoise) rather than clinical care?

Name the principle the correct option upholds.

Master that sequence and most ethics stems reduce to a short checklist rather than a philosophical debate.