Study guide

2.3 Qualifications-Based Selection (QBS) & Public Contracting (G.S. 143-64.31)

North Carolina Land Surveyor NC PLS

Track your progress as you read

Finished sections get a check mark.

1 Chapter 1: North Carolina Statutory Authority & Board Administration (G.S. 89C & 21 NCAC 56)

1.1 The North Carolina State-Specific Exam: Format, Blueprint & Approved References 1.2 Statutory Framework & Board Organization (G.S. 89C & 21 NCAC 56) 1.3 Licensure Qualifications, Education & Experience Pathways (G.S. 89C-13(b)) 1.4 Professional Entity Organization, Firm Licensure & Business Rules 1.5 Continuing Professional Competency (CPC) & License Renewal

2 Chapter 2: Professional Conduct, Standard of Care & Board Enforcement

2.1 Rules of Professional Conduct (21 NCAC 56 .0701) & Advertising (.0702) 2.2 Responsible Charge, Direct Supervisory Control & Sealing (21 NCAC 56 .0701(d), .1101-.1103) 2.3 Qualifications-Based Selection (QBS) & Public Contracting (G.S. 143-64.31) 2.4 Disciplinary Procedures, Board Enforcement Powers & Penalties (G.S. 89C-21 & 89C-22)

3 Chapter 3: NC Standards of Practice for Land Surveying (21 NCAC 56.1600)

3.1 Surveying Procedures & the Record Examination Duty (21 NCAC 56 .1602(a)-(c)) 3.2 Classification of Boundary Surveys, Closure & Positional Accuracy (21 NCAC 56 .1603) 3.3 Monumentation, Tie Lines & Mapping Requirements (21 NCAC 56 .1602(d)-(h) & .1604) 3.4 Vertical Control, Topographic & Planimetric Mapping (21 NCAC 56 .1605 & .1606)

4 Chapter 4: North Carolina Plat Recording Laws & Review Officer Procedures (G.S. 47-30)

4.1 Plat Size, Reproducible Form, Title Contents & Required Plat Information (G.S. 47-30(a)-(f)) 4.2 The Surveyor Certificate, the Five (f)(11) Statements & Recording Exceptions 4.3 Review Officer Statutory Role, Powers & Certification Process (G.S. 47-30.2) 4.4 Geodetic Ties, Grid Coordinates & NC SPCS Connection (G.S. 47-30(f)(9) & 21 NCAC 56 .1602(g))

5 Chapter 5: North Carolina Boundary Law, Priority of Calls & Title History

5.1 The North Carolina Priority of Calls Hierarchy (Cherry v. Slade) 5.2 North Carolina Real Property History, Colonial Grants & the Granville District 5.3 Metes & Bounds Descriptions, Ambiguities & Deed Construction Rules 5.4 Processioning Proceedings & Boundary Dispute Resolution (G.S. Chapter 38)

6 Chapter 6: Adverse Possession, Easements, Rights-of-Way & Title Doctrines in NC

6.1 Adverse Possession & Color of Title under North Carolina Law (G.S. 1-38 & 1-40) 6.2 Real Property Claims Against the State & Public Prescriptive Immunity (G.S. 1-35) 6.3 Easements: Prescription, Implication, Necessity & Statutory Cartways (G.S. 136-68) 6.4 Public Road Dedication, Maintenance & Statutory Abandonment (G.S. 136-96)

7 Chapter 7: Riparian Rights, Water Boundaries & Coastal Surveying in North Carolina

7.1 Navigability, The Public Trust Doctrine & Riparian Rights (G.S. Chapter 146) 7.2 Non-Navigable Waters, Thread of the Stream (Filum Aquae) & Submerged Lands 7.3 Coastal Boundaries, Mean High Water Mark & Coastal Area Management Act (CAMA) 7.4 Water Boundary Movement: Accretion, Reliction, Erosion & Avulsion

8 Chapter 8: Geodetic Surveying, the NC Coordinate System & LIS/GIS Standards

8.1 The North Carolina State Plane Coordinate System (G.S. Chapter 102) & Grid Reductions 8.2 NCGS Real-Time Network & GNSS Survey Standards (21 NCAC 56 .1607) 8.3 Datums, Geoid Models & NSRS Modernization (NATRF2022 / NAPGD2022) 8.4 LIS/GIS Surveys, Classifications & the Board GIS Guidelines (21 NCAC 56 .1608)

9 Chapter 9: Incidental Streets, Drainage, Erosion Control & Stormwater (16% of the Exam)

9.1 Scope of Incidental Street & Storm Sewer Design (G.S. 89C-3(7) & the Board Guidelines) 9.2 Hydrology for Incidental Drainage: The Rational Method 9.3 Hydraulics: Sizing Swales, Ditches & Storm Conduits 9.4 Erosion & Sediment Control: The Sedimentation Pollution Control Act & 15A NCAC 04 9.5 Post-Construction Stormwater, SCMs & the NCDEQ Stormwater Design Manual 9.6 NCDOT Subdivision Roads Minimum Construction Standards

2.3 Qualifications-Based Selection (QBS) & Public Contracting (G.S. 143-64.31)

Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI

The North Carolina Mini-Brooks Act (G.S. 143-64.31) mandates that all state and local public bodies select professional land surveying firms based on demonstrated competence and qualifications without consideration of price or fees.

Public agencies must engage in strict sequential negotiation: if a fair and reasonable fee cannot be agreed upon with the highest-ranked firm, negotiations must be formally terminated in writing before initiating discussions with the second-ranked firm.

The statutory small-project exemption under G.S. 143-64.32 applies exclusively when the estimated professional fee is less than $50,000 AND the governing board formally passes a written exemption resolution.

Under 21 NCAC 56 .0701(g)(3) a licensee must comply with G.S. 143-64.31 et seq. on public fee bidding (or the federal Brooks Act, 40 U.S.C. 1101 et seq., on federal projects) and must not knowingly cooperate in anyone else's violation of it.

Simultaneous price negotiations, fee bidding contests, or 'bid shopping' by public agencies violates North Carolina statutory public contracting policy and invalidates the procurement.

Last updated: August 2026

2.3 Qualifications-Based Selection (QBS) & Public Contracting (G.S. 143-64.31)

In North Carolina, the procurement of professional land surveying, engineering, architectural, and landscape architectural services by public bodies is governed by Article 3D of General Statutes Chapter 143, commonly known as the North Carolina Mini-Brooks Act ( G.S. 143-64.31 through 143-64.34 ). The statute mandates a Qualifications-Based Selection (QBS) process, establishing as public policy that professional design and surveying services must be procured based on demonstrated competence and professional qualifications rather than competitive price bidding.

  • 1. Statutory Purpose & Scope of the Mini-Brooks Act (G.S. 143-64.31)
  • Legislative Intent

The General Assembly recognized that selecting surveyors solely on the lowest bid encourages cutting corners in records research, boundary recovery, and precision tolerances, resulting in costly boundary disputes, delayed public infrastructure projects, and clouding of public land titles.

Covered Public Entities

The Mini-Brooks Act applies to all levels of state and local government in North Carolina, including:

State Entities: State departments, agencies, institutions, the University of North Carolina system, and community colleges;

Local Governments: Counties, cities, towns, and consolidated city-counties;

Public Authorities: Sanitary districts, school boards, airport authorities, water and sewer authorities, and public transportation authorities. +-----------------------------------------------------------------------------+

  • | THE NORTH CAROLINA QBS STATUTORY MANDATE |
  • | |
  • | "It is the public policy of this State and all public subdivisions to |
  • | announce requirements for surveying services, and to select firms on |
  • | the basis of DEMONSTRATED COMPETENCE AND QUALIFICATIONS for the type |
  • | of professional services required, WITHOUT REGARD TO FEE, and thereafter |
  • | negotiate a contract for... services at a FAIR AND REASONABLE FEE." |
  • | -- G.S. 143-64.31(a) |
  • +-----------------------------------------------------------------------------+
  • 2. The Step-by-Step QBS Procurement Lifecycle

The statutory procurement workflow consists of an initial qualifications evaluation followed by a strict, sequential single-firm negotiation process: +-----------------------------------------------------------------------------+

  • | THE 5-PHASE QBS LIFECYCLE |
  • | |
  • | Phase 1: PUBLIC ANNOUNCEMENT (Request for Qualifications - RFQ) |
  • | Public notice describing scope; NO FEE REQUESTS PERMITTED |
  • | | |
  • | v |
  • | Phase 2: QUALIFICATIONS EVALUATION & RANKING |
  • | Agency evaluates competence, staff, experience -> Ranks: #1, #2, #3|
  • | | |
  • | v |
  • | Phase 3: SCOPE REFINEMENT & FEE NEGOTIATION WITH FIRM #1 |
  • | Detailed scope developed; Firm #1 submits fee proposal |
  • | | |
  • | +----------------+----------------+ |
  • | | | |
  • | [Agreement Reached] [Impasse / Deadlock] |
  • | | | |
  • | v v |
  • | Phase 4: AWARD CONTRACT Phase 5: FORMAL WRITTEN TERMINATION |
  • | Execute agreement with Firm #1 Terminate Firm #1 in writing|
  • | BEFORE negotiating with #2 |
  • +-----------------------------------------------------------------------------+
  • Key Phase Requirements

RFQ Issuance (No Cost Proposals): The public entity issues a Request for Qualifications (RFQ). The RFQ cannot ask for cost estimates, man-hour rates, fee schedules, or sealed price envelopes.

Evaluation and Ranking: The agency evaluates the submitting firms based on specialized expertise, past performance on similar public surveys, staff availability, and geodetic/equipment capabilities. The agency creates a prioritized ranking list (Firm #1, Firm #2, Firm #3).

Negotiating with Firm #1: The agency meets with Firm #1 to develop a detailed, granular scope of work. Once the exact scope is agreed upon, Firm #1 submits its fee proposal. Both parties negotiate to achieve a "fair and reasonable" compensation.

Handling Deadlock (Sequential Rule): If the agency and Firm #1 cannot agree on a fair and reasonable fee, the agency must send a formal written notice of termination of negotiations to Firm #1.

Moving to Firm #2: Only after the written termination letter is delivered to Firm #1 may the agency initiate discussions with Firm #2. The agency can never revisit or negotiate backwards with Firm #1 once terminated.

Loading diagram... North Carolina QBS Sequential Negotiation & Termination Architecture

3. Statutory Small-Project Exemption (G.S. 143-64.32)

The North Carolina General Statutes provide a specific, highly regulated exception to the mandatory QBS process under G.S. 143-64.32 .

The Dual Conditions for Exemption

An agency may exempt a project from QBS only if both of the following statutory requirements are met:

Who may exempt: G.S. 143-64.32 gives the exemption power to units of local government and the North Carolina Department of Transportation — it is not a general State-agency exemption.

Financial Threshold: The estimated professional fee must be less than fifty thousand dollars ($50,000) .

In Writing: The exemption must be in writing . The statute requires a written exemption, not any particular form of resolution, but local procurement policies commonly implement it by board resolution.

A second, larger exemption sits in G.S. 143-64.34 : State Building Commission projects, UNC capital projects, and community college projects are exempt when the estimated expenditure of public money is less than $1,500,000 . Candidates routinely confuse the $50,000 local-government threshold with this $1.5 million capital-project threshold.

Important

No Automatic Exemption: Projects with estimated fees under $50,000 are NOT automatically exempt from QBS. If a town council or county commission does not formally vote to adopt an exemption resolution, the mandatory QBS evaluation and sequential negotiation process still applies by law, regardless of the dollar amount.

4. Ethical Prohibitions on Competitive Bidding (21 NCAC 56 .0701(g)(3))

The NCBELS Rules of Professional Conduct strictly regulate licensee participation in public procurement:

Prohibition on Fee Proposals: A licensee shall not submit a competitive price proposal, fee bid, or cost estimate to any public entity subject to G.S. 143-64.31 unless the entity has officially selected and ranked that licensee as the #1 firm and initiated contract negotiations.

Unlawful Public RFQ Responses: If a public agency issues an RFQ that improperly requests cost figures or hourly rate tables from all respondents, a licensed surveyor cannot submit fees. The surveyor should inform the agency in writing of the Mini-Brooks Act mandate and submit only qualifications.

Private Contracting Contrast: The Mini-Brooks Act applies exclusively to public government entities. In private commercial transactions (e.g., surveying for a private developer or individual homeowner), competitive price bidding and lump-sum quotes are fully permissible under North Carolina law.