Study guide
11.2 Policy Appraisal Clause, Umpire Selection, Binding Awards & Alternative Dispute Resolution
New York Claims Adjuster Exam
Track your progress as you read
Finished sections get a check mark.
1 Chapter 1: New York Adjuster Licensing & Regulatory Oversight
1.1 NY DFS Authority, Superintendent Powers & Independent Adjuster Licensing (§ 2108) 1.2 License Maintenance, the Bond & Certificate Exemptions, Grounds for Revocation (§ 2110) & Temporary Permits 1.3 Regulation 64 (11 NYCRR 216) Mandatory Timelines & Unfair Claims Settlement Practices 1.4 The New York Standard Fire Policy (§ 3404), Suit Against the Insurer, Cancellation & Nonrenewal, DFS Cybersecurity & TRIA
2 Chapter 2: New York Auto Insurance Laws & No-Fault (Article 51)
2.1 NY Mandatory Motor Vehicle Liability Limits (25/50/10) & Financial Security 2.2 Article 51 No-Fault PIP: $50,000 Basic Economic Loss & Serious Injury Threshold 2.3 SUM / UM / UIM Endorsements & Regulation 64 Physical Damage Settlement Rules 2.4 The Personal Auto Policy (PP 00 01): Parts A–F, Who Is an Insured & New York Endorsements 2.5 Vehicle Parts and Construction, Repair Terminology, Regulation 79 Inspections, Rideshare & Supplemental Spousal Liability
3 Chapter 3: General Insurance Principles & Contract Law
3.1 Legal Elements of Insurance Contracts, Adhesion & Principle of Indemnity 3.2 Standard Policy Structure (DICEED), Policy Conditions & Duties After Loss 3.3 Warranties vs. Representations, Concealment, Waiver & Estoppel in Claims 3.4 Third-Party Interests, Other Insurance & Limits of Liability, Blanket vs. Specific Insurance & Construction Classes
4 Chapter 4: Property Insurance Concepts, Valuation & Coinsurance
4.1 Pure vs. Speculative Risk, Hazards, Proximate Cause & Concurrent Causation 4.2 Property Valuation Methods: ACV, Replacement Cost, Functional RC & Agreed Value 4.3 Coinsurance Formula, Step-by-Step Penalty Calculations & Practical Examples
5 Chapter 5: Homeowners & Dwelling Property Policies
5.1 Homeowners Policy Forms (HO-2 through HO-8) & Section I Coverages A–D 5.2 Section I Covered Perils, Major Exclusions & 80% Replacement Cost Settlement 5.3 Dwelling Policy Program (DP-1, DP-2, DP-3), Other Structures & Fair Rental Value 5.4 National Flood Insurance Program (NFIP), WYO, 30-Day Rule & Specialty Floaters 5.5 New York Special Provisions & Selected Homeowners and Dwelling Endorsements
6 Chapter 6: Principles of Liability, Tort Law & Personal Liability
6.1 Law of Negligence, Elements of Tort & NY Pure Comparative Fault (CPLR 14-A) 6.2 Homeowners Section II: Coverage E Personal Liability & Coverage F Medical Payments 6.3 Personal Umbrella Policies, Underlying Limits & Self-Insured Retention (SIR)
7 Chapter 7: Commercial Property & Package Policies
7.1 Building and Personal Property Coverage Form (BPP): Covered Property & Extensions 7.2 Causes of Loss Forms (Basic, Broad, Special), Business Income & Extra Expense 7.3 Businessowners Policy (BOP) Eligibility, Packaged Coverages & Endorsements 7.4 Commercial Crime (2013): Burglary, Robbery and Theft Definitions, the Eight Insuring Agreements & Discovery vs. Loss Sustained 7.5 Farm Coverage: Property Coverages A–G, Farm Liability Coverages H–J, Mobile Agricultural Equipment & Livestock 7.6 Businessowners Liability Coverage Form, Common Policy Conditions & Selected BOP Endorsements
8 Chapter 8: Commercial General Liability (CGL) & Commercial Auto
8.1 CGL Form Structure: Occurrence vs. Claims-Made, Retroactive Dates & ERPs 8.2 CGL Coverage A, B, C, Premises/Operations vs. Products-Completed Operations & Exclusions 8.3 Business Auto Coverage Form (BACF), Symbols 1–9, Liability & Physical Damage 8.4 Garage/Auto Dealers, Truckers and Motor Carrier Forms, MCS-90 & New York Commercial Auto PIP Endorsements
9 Chapter 9: Marine Insurance, Bonds & Specialty Lines
9.1 Nationwide Marine Definition, Commercial Floaters & Equipment Breakdown 9.2 Ocean Marine: Hull, Cargo, Freight, Protection & Indemnity (P&I) & General Average 9.3 Surety Bonds vs. Insurance: Principal, Obligee, Surety, Fidelity vs. Surety 9.4 Fidelity Coverages: Bond Period and Discovery Period, Employee Dishonesty Forms, ERISA Bonds, Financial Institution Bonds & Public Employee Bonds 9.5 Aviation Hull Coverages & Aircraft Liability Coverages
10 Chapter 10: The Claims Process: Investigation, Scoping & Coverage Analysis
10.1 First Notice of Loss (FNOL), Initial Intake & Coverage Verification Checklist 10.2 Reservation of Rights (ROR) Letters vs. Non-Waiver Agreements & Estoppel Prevention 10.3 On-Site Scoping Methodology, Itemized Estimating & Depreciation Calculation 10.4 Salvage Rights, Total Loss Determinations & Subrogation Recovery
11 Chapter 11: Claim Documentation, Dispute Resolution & Settlement
11.1 Physical Evidence, Chain of Custody, Recorded Statements, EUO & Sworn Proof of Loss 11.2 Policy Appraisal Clause, Umpire Selection, Binding Awards & Alternative Dispute Resolution 11.3 Claim Negotiation Principles, Release Forms, Lien Resolution & Closing Reports 11.4 Adjuster Report Writing, Claim File Documentation & the Declaratory Judgment Action
12 Chapter 12: Insurance Fraud Detection, SIU & Adjuster Ethics
12.1 Property, Casualty & Auto Fraud Red Flags, Arson Indicators & Staged Losses 12.2 Special Investigation Units (SIU), NY DFS Frauds Bureau & Penal Law § 176 12.3 Adjuster Code of Ethics, Fiduciary Duty, Regulation 169 Privacy & 18 U.S.C. §§ 1033/1034
13 Chapter 13: Accident & Health Insurance Basics
13.1 Accident & Health Claims: Accidental Injury vs. Sickness, Disability Income, Medical Expense & Long-Term Care 13.2 Classes of A&H Coverage, Limited Policies & Common Exclusions 13.3 A&H Claims Handling: Notice, Claim Forms, Proof of Loss, Physical Examination & New York Prompt Pay
14 Chapter 14: Understanding the Language of Medical Reports
14.1 Medical Terminology: Roots, Prefixes, Suffixes, Location and Movement Terms, Abbreviations & Specialties 14.2 Basic Human Anatomy, Common Injuries and Diseases & Diagnostic Tests
15 Chapter 15: Workers' Compensation Insurance
15.1 Workers' Compensation Law Types, New York Exclusive Remedy (WCL § 11), Covered Employment & Grave Injury 15.2 New York Benefits, Waiting Period, Notice and Filing Deadlines & Board Claims Reporting 15.3 The Workers' Compensation and Employers Liability Policy, Federal Acts & Other Sources of Coverage
16 Chapter 16: Specialty Liability, Excess Lines & Other Coverages
16.1 Specialty Liability: E&O, Professional, D&O, Fiduciary, Liquor/Dram Shop, EPLI, Environmental & Cyber 16.2 Excess Lines (Reg 41), Identity Theft, Watercraft, Recreational Vehicles & Difference in Conditions 16.3 Crop Insurance, Federal Multi-Peril Crop Insurance & the New York Multi-Peril Crop Adjuster License
11.2 Policy Appraisal Clause, Umpire Selection, Binding Awards & Alternative Dispute Resolution
Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI
The standard policy appraisal clause is strictly limited to resolving disagreements over the amount of loss or actual cash value, and cannot adjudicate coverage, liability, or policy interpretation.
Upon written demand for appraisal by either party, each party must select a competent, disinterested appraiser within 20 calendar days.
The two appointed appraisers must select an impartial umpire within 15 calendar days; if they fail to agree, either party may petition a court of record in the property's county to appoint the umpire.
An itemized appraisal award in writing signed by any two of the three panel members (both appraisers or one appraiser and the umpire) constitutes a final, legally binding determination of the loss value.
Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) in claims includes non-binding mediation (such as NY DFS disaster mediation programs) and adjudicative arbitration (such as mandatory No-Fault, UM/SUM, and inter-company subrogation).
Last updated: September 2026
Policy Appraisal Clause, Umpire Selection, Binding Awards & Alternative Dispute Resolution
Exam Focus: The Series 17-70 examination tests adjusters on the exact procedural timeline of the standard appraisal clause, the critical legal distinction between valuation disputes (appraisable) and coverage disputes (non-appraisable), the mechanism for judicial appointment of an umpire, and the comparative frameworks of Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR), including NY DFS disaster mediation and arbitration.
The Standard Policy Appraisal Clause: Purpose and Scope
When an insurer and an insured agree that a loss is covered under a first-party property policy but disagree on the dollar valuation of the damage, litigation is costly, slow, and burdensome. To avoid court trials over pricing disputes, the standard fire and property policy incorporates an appraisal clause .
Purpose of Appraisal
The sole purpose of the appraisal clause is to provide an expeditious, extrajudicial mechanism for resolving disagreements regarding:
- The actual cash value (ACV) of damaged property;
- The replacement cost (RC) of repairing or replacing building structures or personal property;
The specific physical amount of loss or quantity of materials damaged.
The Scope Limitation: Valuation vs. Coverage
Adjusters must understand the strict jurisdictional boundary of the appraisal clause:
Appraisal Determines Value Only: The appraisal panel has authority to calculate the dollar cost to repair or replace property damaged in an occurrence.
Appraisal Never Determines Coverage: The appraisal panel has zero legal authority to interpret insurance contract language, determine whether an exclusion applies, decide whether a loss was caused by a covered peril versus an excluded peril (causation that dictates coverage), determine whether policy conditions were breached, or rule on legal liability.
Strict Legal Precedent: Under well-established New York jurisprudence, an insurer does not waive its coverage defenses by participating in an appraisal. If an insurer asserts that a portion of the claimed damage was caused by pre-existing wear and tear or excluded earth movement, the appraisal panel may determine the total dollar cost to rebuild the structure, but a court of law retains exclusive jurisdiction to determine whether coverage exists under the terms of the policy.
The Appraisal Mechanism and Procedural Timeline
The standard policy appraisal clause follows a rigid, step-by-step procedural timeline established in standard ISO policy language and codified under New York Insurance Law § 3404 (the New York Standard Fire Policy):
Step 1: The Written Demand
Either party (the insured or the insurance company) may invoke the appraisal clause by making a formal written demand upon the other party. Neither party can unilaterally deny the other party's contractual right to appraisal if the disagreement concerns solely the amount of loss.
Step 2: Selection of Appraisers (20-Day Rule)
Upon receipt of the written demand, each party must select a competent, independent, and disinterested appraiser within 20 calendar days .
Competence: The appraiser must possess sufficient technical expertise, knowledge, and experience in construction, estimating, or personal property valuation to assess the loss accurately.
Disinterested / Impartial: The appraiser must not have a direct financial stake in the outcome of the appraisal, must not be an employee of the insurer or insured, and must not work on a contingency-fee basis tied to the percentage of the appraisal award.
Step 3: Selection of the Umpire (15-Day Rule)
Within 15 calendar days after both appraisers are appointed, they must mutually select and appoint a competent, independent, and impartial umpire .
The umpire acts as the neutral arbiter on the panel.
The umpire must be completely disinterested and free from conflicts of interest or bias toward either party.
Step 4: Judicial Appointment of Umpire
If the two chosen appraisers cannot agree upon an umpire within the 15-day window, either the insurer or the insured may petition a court of record (typically the New York State Supreme Court in the county where the damaged real or personal property is located) to appoint an umpire. A judge will evaluate candidates and designate an impartial professional (often an experienced construction consultant, retired judge, or independent engineer) to serve as the court-appointed umpire.
- Phase Timeline Responsible Parties Procedural Requirement
- Demand At time of impasse Insurer or Insured Formal written demand invoking the policy appraisal clause
Appraiser Selection Within 20 calendar days of demand Each party selects one Must choose competent, disinterested/impartial appraisers
Umpire Selection Within 15 calendar days of appointment The two appraisers Mutual selection of competent, impartial umpire
Court Appointment After 15-day impasse Either party petitions Court of record in county of loss appoints umpire
- Itemized Submission Following investigation Both appraisers State separately value and loss to each item
- Binding Award Upon evaluation Any TWO of the three Written award sets final, binding amount of loss
- The Appraisal Evaluation, Award, and Cost Allocation
- Evaluation and Itemization
Once the panel is constituted, the two appraisers independently inspect the damaged property and prepare separate, itemized estimates. The policy requires that the appraisers evaluate the loss and state separately the actual cash value and the amount of loss for each individual item or building component .
The Two-Party Binding Award Rule
Appraiser Agreement: If the insured's appraiser and the insurer's appraiser reach an agreement on the dollar amount of the loss, they prepare and execute an itemized appraisal award. The agreed award is signed by both appraisers and becomes final, non-appealable, and legally binding upon both the insurer and the insured. The umpire does not need to participate or sign.
Submission to the Umpire: If the two appraisers disagree on specific items, scopes, or unit costs, they submit only their differences to the umpire.
Any Two Must Agree: An appraisal award in writing, properly itemized, and signed by any two of the three panel members (Appraiser 1 + Appraiser 2, Appraiser 1 + Umpire, or Appraiser 2 + Umpire) establishes the final binding amount of the loss.
A dissenting appraiser cannot block or veto an award agreed upon by the other appraiser and the umpire.
Allocation of Appraisal Expenses
The standard appraisal clause establishes a strict, equitable cost-sharing structure:
Individual Appraiser Fees: Each party pays its own chosen appraiser in full (the insurer pays the insurer's appraiser; the insured pays the insured's appraiser).
Umpire and Administrative Expenses: All other expenses of the appraisal, including the umpire's professional fee, travel costs, specialized testing expenses, and facility rental costs, are split equally (50/50) between the insurer and the insured.
Role Selection Method & Deadline Responsibilities & Legal Authority Compensation Allocation
Insured's Appraiser Selected by insured within 20 days of demand Independently assesses damage; submits itemized ACV/RC estimate Paid entirely by the insured
Insurer's Appraiser Selected by insurer within 20 days of demand Independently assesses damage; submits itemized ACV/RC estimate Paid entirely by the insurer
Umpire Selected by both appraisers within 15 days (or by court) Reviews disputed items only; executes award with either appraiser Shared equally (50% insurer / 50% insured)
Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) in Insurance Claims
While contractual appraisal is the standard mechanism for first-party property valuation disputes, the insurance industry and New York regulatory frameworks rely on other Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) processes to resolve liability, coverage, and catastrophe disputes.
1. Mediation
Mediation is an informal, voluntary, non-binding negotiation process in which an impartial third party (the mediator ) facilitates communication between the disputing parties to help them achieve a mutually acceptable consensual settlement.
Key Characteristics:
The mediator has no legal authority to impose a decision , render an award, or force parties to settle.
Discussions in mediation are completely confidential and cannot be introduced into evidence in subsequent litigation.
If parties reach an agreement, they execute a legally binding settlement contract and release; if they fail to agree, both parties retain all rights to litigate or pursue appraisal.
New York DFS Disaster Mediation Programs: Following declared natural disasters (such as hurricanes, catastrophic windstorms, or severe flooding), the New York Department of Financial Services (DFS) frequently establishes special disaster mediation programs. These programs offer policyholders an expedited, cost-free, neutral forum to resolve disputes with property insurers before turning to formal court actions.
2. Arbitration
Arbitration is a formal, adjudicative ADR proceeding in which the disputing parties submit their claims, evidence, and legal arguments to an impartial arbitrator or a tripartite panel of arbitrators.
Key Characteristics:
The arbitrator acts as a private judge, conducting hearings, examining witnesses, admitting exhibits, and issuing a written arbitration award .
Binding vs. Non-Binding: Arbitration can be binding (where the arbitrator's ruling is final with virtually no right of judicial appeal, except for proven arbitrator corruption, fraud, or evident partiality) or non-binding (an advisory determination where a dissatisfied party may reject the award and demand a trial de novo ).
Mandatory Arbitration in New York:
No-Fault & SUM Arbitration: Under New York Insurance Law § 5106 and Department of Financial Services Regulation 68 , claimants and medical providers disputing No-Fault medical necessity or billings may elect binding arbitration administered by the American Arbitration Association (AAA). Under Regulation 35-D , Uninsured/Underinsured Motorist (UM/SUM) coverage disputes are also subject to binding arbitration.
Inter-Company Property Subrogation: Under New York Insurance Law § 5105 , automobile physical damage subrogation claims between signatory insurers are resolved through mandatory, binding inter-company arbitration (conducted through organizations like Arbitration Forums, Inc.), removing thousands of inter-carrier tort disputes from New York state trial courts.
ADR Dimension Contractual Appraisal Voluntary Mediation Binding Arbitration
Primary Scope Valuation / amount of loss ONLY Any dispute (coverage, value, liability) Coverage, liability, contract interpretation
Decision Maker 3-member panel (2 appraisers + 1 umpire) Neutral mediator (facilitator only) Neutral arbitrator or tripartite panel
Legal Outcome Binding award on dollar amount Non-binding; consensual settlement Legally binding award enforceable in court
Coverage Authority NO (cannot decide coverage) Yes (parties can negotiate coverage) Yes (arbitrator interprets policy and law)
Governing Authority Insurance contract & NY Ins. Law § 3404 Common law & NY DFS disaster directives Federal/NY Arbitration Acts & DFS Regulations