Study guide
3.1 Principles of Justification under Penal Law Article 35
New York Security Guard Study Guide Exam
Track your progress as you read
Finished sections get a check mark.
1 Chapter 1: Overview of NY Security Guard Registration & Training Regulations
1.1 NY DOS Registration & DCJS Regulation Framework 1.2 Role of the Security Guard 1.3 Mandatory DCJS Training Standards 1.4 Guard Standards of Conduct, Ethics & License Maintenance
2 Chapter 2: Legal Powers, Arrest Authority & Civil Liability
2.1 Citizen's Arrest Authority under NY CPL 140.30 2.2 Authority Limitations & Peace Officer Distinctions 2.3 Civil Liability, False Imprisonment & GBL 218
3 Chapter 3: NY Penal Law Article 35 & Use of Force Standards
3.1 Principles of Justification under Penal Law Article 35 3.2 Use of Physical Force & Continuum of Force 3.3 Deadly Physical Force & Armed Guard Restrictions
4 Chapter 4: Emergency Response & Crisis Management
4.1 Fire Safety, Response & Evacuation Protocols 4.2 Medical Emergency Response & First Aid Basics 4.3 Active Threat, Bomb Threat, Severe Weather & Incident Response
5 Chapter 5: Security Operations, Access Control & Patrol Techniques
5.1 Access Control & Visitor Management Systems 5.2 Patrol Methods, Observation & Incident Prevention 5.3 Post Orders, Site Security & Property Protection
6 Chapter 6: Communication, De-escalation & Incident Documentation
6.1 Verbal De-escalation & Conflict Resolution 6.2 Professional Incident Reporting & Notebook Maintenance 6.3 Radio Communications, Public Relations & Professional Demeanor 6.4 Pre-Assignment Exam Review & Study Checklist
3.1 Principles of Justification under Penal Law Article 35
Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI
NY Penal Law Article 35 provides an affirmative defense of justification, establishing that conduct which would otherwise constitute a crime is rendered legal when performed under statutory authorization.
PL 35.15 authorizes physical force in self-defense or defense of a third person against unlawful physical force, provided the actor reasonably believes such force is necessary.
PL 35.20 authorizes physical force in defense of premises and real property to prevent or terminate criminal trespass or burglary by unauthorized persons.
PL 35.05 defines the defense of necessity (choice of evils), permitting conduct necessary to avoid an imminent public or private injury that clearly outweighs the harm forbidden by law.
Force evaluation requires satisfying both a subjective belief (honest belief of necessity) and an objective standard (what a prudent security guard in the same position would reasonably believe).
Last updated: July 2026
3.1 Principles of Justification under Penal Law Article 35
Core Legal Doctrine: Under New York Penal Law (PL) Article 35, justification is an affirmative defense . It does not deny that the security guard committed the physical act (such as grabbing, restraining, or striking a subject), but asserts that the act was legally permissible and non-criminal because it was performed under circumstances authorized by statute to prevent harm, defend persons, or protect property.
Security guards in New York State operate as private citizens unless granted specialized statutory status (such as special patrolmen in specific municipalities). Consequently, a security guard possesses no greater statutory authority to use physical force than any private citizen under Article 35 of the New York Penal Law. Understanding the precise boundaries of justification is essential to avoiding criminal prosecution (such as assault or reckless endangerment) and civil liability (such as battery or false imprisonment).
1. The Concept of Justification as a Legal Defense
In criminal jurisprudence, a defense of justification admits that the defendant engaged in conduct that fits the statutory definition of an offense (e.g., intentionally causing physical injury under PL 120.00), but contends that the conduct was legally justified by the circumstances.
Under NY Penal Law § 35.00 , justification is a defense that the prosecution must disprove beyond a reasonable doubt once raised by the defendant. If a security guard's actions are deemed justified under Article 35, the conduct is rendered entirely lawful—it is not merely excused; it is non-criminal.
Key Statutory Provisions of Article 35
Article 35 contains several key sections that govern everyday security operations:
PL § 35.05 (Justification; Generally / Emergency / Necessity) : Authorizes conduct otherwise criminal when necessary to avoid an imminent public or private injury.
PL § 35.15 (Use of Physical Force in Defense of a Person) : Governs self-defense and the defense of third parties against unlawful physical force.
PL § 35.20 (Use of Physical Force in Defense of Premises and Real Property) : Governs the protection of land, commercial buildings, and residential structures against trespass and burglary.
PL § 35.25 (Use of Physical Force to Prevent or Terminate Larceny or Criminal Mischief) : Governs physical force used to protect personal property.
2. General Justification & The Necessity Defense (PL § 35.05)
PL § 35.05 establishes the "choice of evils" or necessity defense. Under PL § 35.05(2), conduct that would otherwise constitute an offense is justifiable when:
The conduct is necessary as an emergency measure to avoid an imminent public or private injury;
The injury about to occur is of such gravity that, according to ordinary standards of intelligence and morality, the desirability of avoiding such injury clearly outweighs the desirability of avoiding the injury sought to be prevented by the law defining the offense.
Application in Security Operations
For a security guard to invoke PL § 35.05, the threat must be imminent and non-speculative . For example, breaking a window on private property to rescue an unconscious person from a burning building or cutting a padlocked fence to extinguish a toxic chemical fire are justified under PL § 35.05. However, guards cannot claim necessity for preemptive force based on vague future threats or hypothetical risks.
3. Defense of a Person: Self-Defense & Defense of Others (PL § 35.15)
NY Penal Law § 35.15(1) establishes that a person may use physical force upon another person when, and to the extent, he or she reasonably believes such force is necessary to defend himself, herself, or a third person from what he or she reasonably believes to be the use or imminent use of unlawful physical force .
Key Rules Governing Personal Defense
Defense of Third Persons : A security guard has the exact same legal right to defend a client, tenant, visitor, or coworker as they do to defend themselves. The guard stands in the shoes of the person being defended.
The Initial Aggressor Doctrine : Physical force is not justified if the security guard was the initial aggressor. If a guard provokes a confrontation or strikes the first physical blow without unlawful provocation, the guard loses the defense of justification—unless the guard completely withdraws from the encounter and clearly communicates that withdrawal to the opponent.
Provocation Exception : Physical force is not justified if the guard's own conduct provoked the physical force with the intent to cause physical injury to the other person.
Combative Agreement : Physical force is not justified if the physical force involved was the product of a combat by agreement not authorized by law (e.g., mutually agreeing to a fistfight).
4. The Dual Standard of Reasonableness: Subjective vs. Objective
The phrase "reasonably believes" appears throughout PL Article 35. New York courts, established in the landmark Court of Appeals ruling People v. Goetz (68 N.Y.2d 96) , interpret "reasonable belief" through a dual standard consisting of two mandatory components:
The Subjective Component
The security guard must honestly and genuinely believe , at the exact moment force is applied, that physical force is necessary to defend against an imminent unlawful threat. If a guard acts out of malice, revenge, anger, or personal hatred rather than a genuine belief in necessity, the subjective test fails.
The Objective Component
The guard's belief must be objectively reasonable . The jury or legal finder of fact evaluates whether a reasonable security guard , possessing the same background, training, physical characteristics, and standing in the exact same situation with the same observable facts, would have reached the same conclusion and used the same degree of force.
Reasonableness Element Legal Focus Key Evaluation Question
Subjective Test Guard's internal state of mind Did the guard actually believe force was necessary to prevent harm?
Objective Test Reasonable person standard Would a prudent, trained guard in the exact same scenario believe force was necessary?
5. Defense of Premises and Real Property (PL § 35.20)
Security guards are frequently posted to enforce access control, prevent unauthorized entry, and protect real property. PL § 35.20 establishes specific legal authorizations based on property classification:
Preventing Trespass (PL § 35.20(1)) : A person in control of, or licensed/privileged to be on, premises may use non-deadly physical force upon another person when and to the extent reasonably necessary to prevent or terminate what is reasonably believed to be the commission or attempted commission of a criminal trespass .
Commercial & Real Property (PL § 35.20(2)) : Security guards, acting as authorized agents of the property owner or lessee, may use non-deadly physical force to eject a trespasser who refuses verbal commands to leave private property.
Limits of Force in Property Defense : Physical force used to protect property must be strictly proportional. A guard may use reasonable physical hold or guidance to escort a trespasser off premises. However, striking, tackling, or placing a non-violent trespasser in a chokehold is legally excessive and forfeits the justification defense.
6. Comprehensive Overview of Article 35 Relevant Statutes
Statute Title Authorized Scope of Force Core Condition / Restriction
PL § 35.05 Emergency Necessity Non-deadly or deadly force (situation-dependent) Imminent public/private injury; harm avoided outweighs crime committed.
PL § 35.15(1) Defense of Person Non-deadly physical force Imminent unlawful physical force against self or third party; initial aggressor excluded.
PL § 35.15(2) Deadly Force (Person) Deadly physical force Imminent deadly force, robbery, forcible rape, kidnapping; duty to retreat applies.
PL § 35.20(1)-(2) Defense of Premises Non-deadly physical force Prevent or terminate criminal trespass on real property by authorized agents.
PL § 35.20(3) Burglary of Dwelling Deadly physical force Prevent or terminate burglary of an occupied residential dwelling.
PL § 35.25 Defense of Personal Property Non-deadly physical force Prevent or terminate larceny or criminal mischief regarding personal property.