Study guide
4.4 Special Factors, Accommodations vs. Modifications & Secondary Transition Planning
NYSTCE Students with Disabilities CST 060
Track your progress as you read
Finished sections get a check mark.
1 Chapter 1: Foundations of Special Education & Legal Mandates
1.1 NYSTCE 060 Exam Structure, Scoring & NY Certification Pathways 1.2 Federal Legislation & Core Principles: IDEA, Section 504, ADA & FAPE/LRE 1.3 Procedural Safeguards, Prior Written Notice, Due Process & Confidentiality 1.4 Special Education Roles, Multidisciplinary Teams, Paraprofessionals & Family Partnerships
2 Chapter 2: Characteristics of Disabilities & Learner Development
2.1 High-Incidence Disabilities: Learning Disabilities, Speech-Language & OHI (ADHD) 2.2 Intellectual Disabilities, Autism Spectrum Disorder & Emotional Disabilities 2.3 Low-Incidence, Sensory Impairments, Physical/Health Disabilities & TBI 2.4 Developmental Domains, Cultural Diversity & Distinguishing Difference from Disability
3 Chapter 3: Assessment, Prereferral & Eligibility Determination
3.1 Assessment Terminology, Formal/Informal Measures & Psychometric Principles 3.2 Prereferral Interventions, Multi-Tiered System of Supports (MTSS) & Response to Intervention (RtI) 3.3 Comprehensive Nondiscriminatory Evaluation & Multidisciplinary Procedures 3.4 Eligibility Determination & New York State Continuum of Special Education Services
4 Chapter 4: IEP Development, Implementation & Progress Monitoring
4.1 The Committee on Special Education (CSE) & Mandated IEP Components in New York 4.2 Present Levels of Academic Achievement and Functional Performance (PLAAFP) Across 4 Need Areas 4.3 Measurable Annual Goals, Benchmarks, Progress Monitoring & Data-Based Decisions 4.4 Special Factors, Accommodations vs. Modifications & Secondary Transition Planning
5 Chapter 5: Learning Environment & Positive Behavioral Interventions
5.1 Proactive Classroom Management, Structured Routines & Accessible Physical Design 5.2 Multi-Tiered Positive Behavioral Interventions and Supports (PBIS) & Reinforcement Systems 5.3 Functional Behavioral Assessment (FBA), Behavioral Functions & Behavior Intervention Plans (BIP) 5.4 Crisis De-escalation, IDEA Disciplinary Protections & Manifestation Determination Reviews (MDR)
6 Chapter 6: Specially Designed Instruction, UDL & Inclusive Co-Teaching
6.1 Specially Designed Instruction (SDI) & Aligning to NYS P-12 Learning Standards 6.2 Universal Design for Learning (UDL) & Differentiated Instructional Frameworks 6.3 Integrated Co-Teaching (ICT) Models, Co-Planning & Collaborative Delivery in New York 6.4 Assistive Technology Continuum, Specialized Instructional Materials (NIMAS/AIM) & UDL Tools
7 Chapter 7: Evidence-Based Academic Instruction & Learning Strategies
7.1 Evidence-Based Reading Instruction: Structured Literacy, Decoding, Fluency & Comprehension 7.2 Evidence-Based Written Expression: SRSD, Sentence Scaffolds, Drafting & Written Mechanics 7.3 Mathematics Instruction: Concrete-Representational-Abstract (CRA) Sequence & Schema-Based Problem Solving 7.4 Cognitive/Metacognitive Learning Strategies, Executive Function Supports & Study/Test-Taking Skills
8 Chapter 8: Communication, Social & Functional Living Skills
8.1 Communication Development, Pragmatics & Augmentative and Alternative Communication (AAC) 8.2 Explicit Social Skills Instruction, Social Stories, Peer-Mediated Supports & Inclusion 8.3 Functional Life Skills, Task Analysis, Chaining, Prompting Hierarchies & Community-Based Instruction (CBI) 8.4 Self-Determination, Self-Advocacy, Student-Led IEPs & Interagency Post-Secondary Collaboration
9 Chapter 9: Mastering the Constructed-Response Case Study
9.1 NYSTCE 060 Constructed-Response Design, Artifact Structure & NYSED 4-Level Scoring Rubric 9.2 Methodical Artifact Analysis: Synthesizing Student Profiles, Data, Work Samples & Needs Identification 9.3 Formulating High-Impact Evidence-Based Interventions & Theoretical/Pedagogical Rationales 9.4 Score Point 4 Model Response, Official Rubric Critique & Exam Traps
10 Chapter 10: Historical Foundations, Professional Growth, Resources & Advocacy
10.1 Historical and Philosophical Foundations, Contemporary Issues & Research 10.2 Reflective Practice, Professional Development & Research-Validated Sources 10.3 Local, State & National Services, Organizations & Student Advocacy
11 Chapter 11: Educational Impact, Medical Factors, Families & Communities
11.1 Similarities and Differences & How Disabilities Influence Education and Life 11.2 Medications, Medical Conditions & Sensory Factors That Affect Learning 11.3 Family and Community Roles in Development, Learning & Daily Living
12 Chapter 12: Rapport, Instructional Grouping & Accessible Learning Environments
12.1 Teacher Attitudes, Rapport & Communication Adjustments 12.2 Academic Success in One-to-One, Small-Group & Large-Group Settings 12.3 Barriers to Accessibility and Acceptance & Environmental Adaptations
13 Chapter 13: Assessment Communication, Content Vocabulary & Integrated Life Skills
13.1 Communicating Assessment Results & Maintaining Educational Records 13.2 Teaching Essential Concepts, Vocabulary & Content Across the General Curriculum 13.3 Integrating Affective, Social, Career & Life Skills with Academic Curricula
14 Chapter 14: School-Year Transitions & Constructed-Response Intervention Recommendations
14.1 Promoting Successful Transitions Across School Environments 14.2 Recommending Behavioral Interventions from Case-Study Data 14.3 Recommending Reading, Writing, Mathematics & Content-Vocabulary Interventions from Case-Study Data 14.4 Recommending Communication, Social & Functional Skill Interventions from Case-Study Data
4.4 Special Factors, Accommodations vs. Modifications & Secondary Transition Planning
Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI
Under IDEA (34 CFR § 300.324) and 8 NYCRR Part 200.4(d)(3), the CSE must explicitly document consideration of five Special Factors: (1) behavior impeding learning (PBIS/BIP), (2) limited English proficiency, (3) blindness/visual impairment (Braille instruction presumption), (4) communication needs (Deaf/Hard of Hearing), and (5) assistive technology.
Accommodations alter how a student accesses instruction or demonstrates competence without reducing curriculum standards or changing the construct being measured, whereas modifications alter what is learned by changing curricular expectations, lowering construct complexity, and potentially jeopardizing a standard Regents diploma.
New York testing accommodations must be documented with precise conditions, types, and implementation settings; on reading comprehension assessments, 'tests read aloud' is severely restricted unless the student's disability prevents decoding and test specifications permit it.
Secondary transition planning in New York State is legally mandated to begin in the IEP in effect when the student turns 15 years old (earlier than the federal IDEA mandate of age 16).
Transition plans require measurable postsecondary goals in education/training, employment, and independent living based on age-appropriate transition assessments, accompanied by a coordinated set of activities and prior written parental consent before inviting adult agencies (e.g., ACCES-VR, OPWDD).
Last updated: September 2026
4.4 Special Factors, Accommodations vs. Modifications & Secondary Transition Planning
Quick Summary: In crafting a comprehensive IEP, the CSE must systematically consider five statutory Special Factors, distinguish rigorously between accommodations and modifications, and establish secondary transition plans. In New York State, secondary transition planning begins earlier than federal law requires—in the IEP in effect when the student turns 15 years old. Special educators must master the legal parameters of testing accommodations, postsecondary goals, coordinated transition activities, and adult service agency linkages.
Every IEP must be tailored not only to general academic standards, but to the unique statutory, environmental, and developmental characteristics of the individual learner. The Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and Part 200 of the Regulations of the Commissioner of Education of the State of New York (8 NYCRR Part 200) establish explicit safeguards to ensure that specialized communication, linguistic, technological, and postsecondary transition needs are systematically addressed.
The Five Special Factors under IDEA and New York Regulations
Under IDEA (34 CFR § 300.324[a][2]) and 8 NYCRR Part 200.4(d)(3), the CSE must formally consider five Special Factors for every student during initial IEP development and at every annual review: The 5 Mandatory Special Factors
- +-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
- | 1. BEHAVIOR IMPEDING LEARNING |
- | - If behavior impedes student or peer learning, CSE must consider positive behavioral |
- | interventions and supports (PBIS) and conduct an FBA to develop a formal BIP. |
- +-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
- | 2. LIMITED ENGLISH PROFICIENCY (LEP / MULTILINGUAL LEARNERS) |
- | - CSE must consider the child's language needs as they relate to the IEP (ENL, |
- | bilingual special education, native language assessment data). |
- +-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
- | 3. BLINDNESS OR VISUAL IMPAIRMENT |
- | - Statutory presumption: Must provide instruction in Braille and the use of Braille |
- | unless an evaluation of current and future literacy needs rules it inappropriate. |
- +-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
- | 4. COMMUNICATION NEEDS (DEAF / HARD OF HEARING) |
- | - Must consider language and communication mode, opportunities for direct communication |
- | with peers and professionals in student's mode, and full academic potential. |
- +-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
- | 5. ASSISTIVE TECHNOLOGY (AT) |
- | - CSE must evaluate whether student requires AT devices (low-, mid-, high-tech) and |
- | AT services across instructional, communicative, and testing environments. |
- +-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
- Clinical and Legal Analysis of the 5 Factors
Behavior Impeding Learning: When a student's conduct disrupts their own learning or the learning of others, the CSE must consider positive behavioral interventions, strategies, and supports (PBIS). In New York, under 8 NYCRR § 200.22, if the student exhibits persistent behaviors that impede learning, the CSE must conduct a formal Functional Behavioral Assessment (FBA) and develop a targeted Behavior Intervention Plan (BIP) .
Limited English Proficiency: For a student identified as an English Language Learner (ELL) / Multilingual Learner (ML), the CSE must examine how English language acquisition interacts with the disability. The IEP must specify whether specialized instruction will be delivered bilingually or with English as a New Language (ENL) scaffolds, ensuring language acquisition is never misidentified as a cognitive deficit.
Blindness or Visual Impairment (The Braille Presumption): Under 34 CFR § 300.324(a)(2)(iii) and 8 NYCRR Part 200.4(d)(3)(iii), there is a legal presumption in favor of Braille instruction . The CSE must provide instruction in Braille and the use of Braille unless an evaluation of the student's reading and writing skills, needs, and future literacy needs (e.g., progressive degenerative vision loss) demonstrates that Braille is not appropriate. The presence of residual vision alone cannot justify omitting Braille instruction.
Communication Needs: For students who are Deaf or Hard of Hearing, the CSE must evaluate the child's language and communication needs, opportunities for direct communication with peers and professional personnel in the child's language and communication mode (e.g., American Sign Language [ASL], cued speech, auditory-oral), academic level, and the full range of needs.
Assistive Technology: The CSE must consider whether the student requires Assistive Technology Devices (any item, piece of equipment, or product used to increase, maintain, or improve functional capabilities) or Assistive Technology Services (services that directly assist in the selection, acquisition, or use of an AT device). The AT continuum ranges from low-tech (pencil grips, slant boards) to mid-tech (audio recorders, talking calculators) to high-tech (eye-gaze communication devices, dynamic display AAC tablets, screen-reading software).
Accommodations vs. Modifications: The Crucial Construct Distinction
A critical competency tested on the NYSTCE CST (060) is the distinction between accommodations and modifications . Conflating these two concepts has severe legal, pedagogical, and high school diploma consequences. Accommodations vs. Modifications Spectrum
- +-----------------------------------------+ +-----------------------------------------+
- | ACCOMMODATIONS | | MODIFICATIONS |
- | Changes HOW the student learns or | | Changes WHAT the student is expected |
- | demonstrates mastery. | | to learn. |
- | | | |
- | - Standards: Preserves identical grade | | - Standards: Fundamentally lowers or |
- | level learning expectations. | | alters curriculum standards. |
- | - Construct: Preserves test construct | | - Construct: Alters construct validity |
- | validity. | | and cognitive complexity. |
- | - Diploma: Fully preserves eligibility | | - Diploma: May jeopardize standard |
- | for standard NYS Regents Diploma. | | high school diploma (Regents/Local). |
- +-----------------------------------------+ +-----------------------------------------+
- Comprehensive Comparison Table
Dimension Accommodations Modifications
Core Definition Adjustments to instructional delivery, student response mode, environmental setting, or timing that remove physical, sensory, or processing barriers without altering the curriculum standard or construct measured . Fundamental alterations to the educational curriculum, performance standards, or assessment task that reduce the breadth, depth, or cognitive complexity of what is taught or evaluated .
Curriculum Standard Student is held to the identical grade-level standards (NYS Next Generation Learning Standards) as general education peers. Student is held to lowered, alternative, or modified standards (e.g., learning foundational 3rd-grade math in a 9th-grade algebra course).
Test Construct Preserves construct validity. A student with dyslexia using text-to-speech on a science exam is still measured on scientific comprehension, not decoding. Alters construct validity. Eliminating all multisyllabic reading comprehension questions from a reading test alters what the test measures.
Grading & Reporting Graded against identical grade-level rubrics; no asterisks or modified grading notations on report cards or transcripts. Graded against individualized or lowered standards; may require specialized progress reporting indicators.
High School Diploma Impact Allows the student to fulfill standard graduation requirements and earn a New York State Regents or Local Diploma . Pervasive modifications may prevent the student from earning standard Regents credits, steering them toward the New York State Alternate Assessment (NYSAA) and Skills and Achievement Commencement Credential (SACC).
Concrete Examples Extended time (1.5x); separate testing location; large print text; speech-to-text software; preferential seating; visual checklists; noise-cancelling headphones. Reducing reading assignments from an 8th-grade novel to a 2nd-grade picture book; eliminating all essay questions on an exam; grading solely on effort; testing on 5 vocabulary words instead of 20.
Testing Accommodations in New York State
Testing accommodations provide students with disabilities equitable access to demonstrate their knowledge on local classroom quizzes, standardized commercial tests, and New York State assessments (Grades 3–8 ELA/Math, Regents Examinations).
Core Principles of NY Testing Accommodations
Documented Specificity: Accommodations cannot be written vaguely (e.g., "extended time as needed" ). Under NYSED guidelines, the IEP must state:
- Type of accommodation: (e.g., Extended Time, Separate Location, Tests Read);
- Conditions / Multiplier: (e.g., "1.5x extended time" or "double time [2.0x]" );
Test categories / settings: (e.g., "For all state and local tests requiring reading passages exceeding 200 words or timed written responses" ).
The "Tests Read" Restriction on Reading Comprehension:
On tests designed to measure basic reading decoding and comprehension (such as the Grades 3–8 NYS ELA Assessments), having the test read aloud alters the construct of the exam (converting a reading test into a listening comprehension test).
NYSED Policy: The "Tests Read" (or Text-to-Speech) accommodation is permitted on state ELA tests only when documented on the IEP due to a profound reading disability or severe visual impairment . Even when permitted, state scoring protocols may restrict the reading of specific foundational decoding sections as specified in state testing manuals. On content-area exams (Social Studies, Science, Math word problems), "Tests Read" is fully permissible because reading decoding is not the construct being tested.
Separate Location Provisions: Must specify the environmental criteria (e.g., "Separate location with minimal visual distractions in a small group of no more than 8 students" ).
Secondary Transition Planning in New York State (8 NYCRR Part 200.4[d][2][ix])
Secondary transition planning is a coordinated, results-oriented process designed to facilitate the student's movement from school to post-school activities, including postsecondary education, vocational education, integrated employment, continuing and adult education, adult services, independent living, and community participation.
The Critical New York Age Mandate: Age 15
NY Regulatory Mandate (8 NYCRR § 200.4[d][2][ix]): Under federal IDEA law (34 CFR § 300.320[b]), transition planning must begin not later than the first IEP to be in effect when the student turns 16 . However, New York State law is more stringent: transition planning must be included in the IEP in effect when the student turns 15 years of age (or younger if deemed appropriate by the CSE). Secondary Transition Architecture
- +-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
- | 1. AGE-APPROPRIATE TRANSITION ASSESSMENTS |
- | - Formal and informal assessments of vocational interests, aptitudes, adaptive living, |
- | and self-determination (e.g., Casey Life Skills, O*NET Interest Profiler). |
- +-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
- |
- v
- +-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
- | 2. MEASURABLE POSTSECONDARY GOALS (After High School) |
- | - Must be post-school outcomes (what student WILL do after graduation/exit): |
- | a) Education and Training (e.g., 2-year college, vocational trade school, on-the-job) |
- | b) Employment (e.g., competitive integrated employment, supported employment) |
- | c) Independent Living Skills (where appropriate: residential, financial, community) |
- +-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
- |
- v
- +-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
- | 3. COORDINATED SET OF TRANSITION ACTIVITIES |
- | - Coordinated activities spanning: (1) Instruction, (2) Related Services, |
- | (3) Community Experiences, (4) Employment / Post-School Living, (5) Daily Living |
- | Skills (if needed), and (6) Functional Vocational Evaluation. |
- +-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
- |
- v
- +-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
- | 4. PARTICIPATING OUTSIDE ADULT AGENCIES (Agency Linkages) |
- | - Involves adult service agencies (ACCES-VR, OPWDD, OMH). |
- | - MANDATORY: District MUST obtain WRITTEN PARENTAL CONSENT prior to inviting agency! |
- +-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
- Core Components of the Secondary Transition Plan
Student Invitation and Active Participation: The school district must invite the student to the CSE meeting whenever transition services will be discussed. If the student does not attend, the CSE must take active steps to ensure the student's preferences and interests are gathered and considered.
Age-Appropriate Transition Assessments: The foundation of transition planning. Evaluators administer vocational interest inventories, career aptitude batteries, situational work assessments, adaptive living scales (e.g., Vineland-3), and student self-determination surveys.
Measurable Postsecondary Goals: Must articulate outcomes that occur after exit from secondary school . Annual IEP goals must directly support the achievement of these postsecondary targets.
Defective (Not Postsecondary): "Student will pass 10th-grade English and graduate high school." (These are high school graduation steps, not postsecondary outcomes).
Compliant Postsecondary Education Goal: "Upon graduation from high school, Marcus will enroll in a two-year Associate Degree program in Automotive Technology at an accredited community college."
Compliant Postsecondary Employment Goal: "Upon completion of postsecondary vocational training, Marcus will obtain competitive integrated employment as an automotive technician."
Compliant Independent Living Goal: "Upon exiting high school, Marcus will independently manage his daily schedule, transportation, and personal finances using digital smartphone applications."
Coordinated Set of Transition Activities (8 NYCRR § 200.1[fff]): Actionable steps delivered during high school to prepare the student for their postsecondary goals across six statutory areas:
Instruction: Dual-enrollment coursework, career and technical education (CTE) courses, self-advocacy seminars.
Related Services: Travel training, orientation and mobility, transition counseling.
Community Experiences: Field trips to college disability resource offices, opening a bank account, using public bus routes.
Employment & Post-School Adult Living: Structured work-study internships, job shadowing, resume building, interview practice.
Daily Living Skills: Meal preparation, personal budgeting, laundry, independent medication management.
Functional Vocational Evaluation: Practical situational work assessments in authentic community job sites.
Agency Linkages and the Strict Consent Mandate: Transition planning requires connecting students with adult service agencies before graduation, including:
ACCES-VR (Adult Career and Continuing Education Services-Vocational Rehabilitation): New York State agency funding vocational training, job coaching, assistive technology, and college tuition support for individuals with disabilities.
OPWDD (Office for People With Developmental Disabilities): New York State agency providing lifelong residential, day habilitation, and employment support for individuals with intellectual disabilities, autism, and developmental conditions.
OMH (Office of Mental Health): Community mental health and supported housing services.
High-Stakes Legal Rule: Under 34 CFR § 300.321(b)(3) and 8 NYCRR Part 200.5, the school district must obtain written parental consent (or written consent from an adult student age 18+) before inviting a representative of any participating outside adult agency to a CSE meeting. Sending an invitation to ACCES-VR without prior written consent violates parental confidentiality safeguards under FERPA and IDEA.