Study guide

4.2 Combining Prior Art References & Motivation to Combine

USPTO Registration Examination Patent Bar

Track your progress as you read

Finished sections get a check mark.

1 Chapter 1: Overview, Registration & MPEP Structure

1.1 Patent Bar Exam Format & Administration 1.2 Practitioner Qualifications & Eligibility 1.3 MPEP Structure & Effective Search Strategies

2 Chapter 2: Subject Matter Eligibility & Utility (35 U.S.C. § 101)

2.1 Patent-Eligible Subject Matter & Statutory Categories 2.2 Judicial Exceptions & the Alice/Mayo Framework 2.3 Utility Requirements & USPTO Utility Guidelines

3 Chapter 3: Novelty & Prior Art Under the AIA (35 U.S.C. § 102)

3.1 First-Inventor-to-File (FITF) & Effective Filing Dates 3.2 The One-Year Inventor Grace Period & Exceptions 3.3 Prior Art Types & Public Availability Standards

4 Chapter 4: Nonobviousness Analysis (35 U.S.C. § 103)

4.1 The Graham Factors & KSR Obviousness Framework 4.2 Combining Prior Art References & Motivation to Combine 4.3 Overcoming § 103 Rejections & Rule 132 Affidavits

5 Chapter 5: Specification & Disclosure Requirements (35 U.S.C. § 112(a))

5.1 Written Description Requirement 5.2 Enablement Requirement & Wands Factors 5.3 Best Mode Requirement & Current Post-AIA Status

6 Chapter 6: Claim Requirements & Definiteness (35 U.S.C. § 112(b)-(f))

6.1 Definiteness & Claim Precision 6.2 Independent & Dependent Claim Construction 6.3 Special Claim Formats: Means-Plus-Function & Markush Claims

7 Chapter 7: Application Types & Filing Procedures (MPEP Chapter 600)

7.1 Provisional Patent Applications 7.2 Nonprovisional Application Parts & Formalities 7.3 Inventor Oaths, Declarations & Assignments

8 Chapter 8: Duty of Disclosure & Information Disclosure Statements

8.1 Duty of Candor & Good Faith 8.2 Information Disclosure Statements (IDS) Requirements 8.3 Correcting Non-Disclosure & Duty Compliance

9 Chapter 9: Patent Prosecution & Office Action Responses (MPEP Chapter 700)

9.1 Initial Examination & Non-Final Office Actions 9.2 Statutory Deadlines & Extension of Time 9.3 Final Office Actions & Post-Final Practice

10 Chapter 10: Continuing Applications & Copendency

10.1 Continuation Applications 10.2 Divisional Applications 10.3 Continuation-in-Part (CIP) Applications & Priority Allocation

11 Chapter 11: Appeals & Interferences/Derivation (MPEP Chapter 1200 & 2300)

11.1 Ex Parte Appeals to the PTAB 11.2 PTAB Appeal Decisions & Judicial Review 11.3 Derivation Proceedings Under the AIA

12 Chapter 12: Post-Grant Proceedings & Corrections (MPEP Chapters 1400 & 2200)

12.1 Reissue Applications & Certificates of Correction 12.2 Ex Parte Reexamination & Supplemental Examination 12.3 Inter Partes Review (IPR) & Post-Grant Review (PGR)

13 Chapter 13: Patent Term, Maintenance Fees & Ownership

13.1 Patent Term Calculation & Patent Term Adjustment (PTA) 13.2 Maintenance Fees & Expiration 13.3 Inventorship, Ownership & Assignment Recordation 13.4 Patent Term Extension Under 35 U.S.C. § 156

14 Chapter 14: International Patent Practice & PCT (MPEP Chapter 1800)

14.1 The Patent Cooperation Treaty (PCT) Overview 14.2 PCT International Phase & Chapter I / Chapter II 14.3 National Phase Entry Under 35 U.S.C. § 371

15 Chapter 15: Special Patent Categories & Professional Conduct

15.1 Design Patents & Plant Patents 15.2 USPTO Rules of Professional Conduct 15.3 Patent Bar Exam Strategy & Open-Book Navigation Tips

16 Chapter 16: Security, Access, Representation & Filing Mechanics

16.1 Secrecy, Application Access & Foreign Filing Licenses 16.2 Representation, Power of Attorney & Correspondence 16.3 Filing Receipt, Certificates of Transmission & Signatures

17 Chapter 17: Restriction, Publication, Allowance & Office Authority

17.1 Restriction, Election, Rejoinder & Double Patenting 17.2 Publication, Preissuance Submissions & Protests 17.3 Allowance, Issue Fee & Withdrawal from Issue 17.4 Examiner Interviews, Petitions & Office Authority

18 Chapter 18: Biotechnology Disclosure & Patent Prosecution Highway

18.1 Biological Deposits & Sequence Listings 18.2 Global/IP5 Patent Prosecution Highway

19 Chapter 19: AIA Trial Practice Under the Consolidated Guide

19.1 AIA Trial Petitions, Preliminary Response & Institution 19.2 AIA Trial Discovery, Motions, Hearing & Final Decision

4.2 Combining Prior Art References & Motivation to Combine

Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI

Prior art must qualify as analogous art under a two-part test: (1) same field of endeavor, or (2) reasonably pertinent to the particular problem faced by the inventor.

Combining references under § 103 requires showing both a motivation to combine and a reasonable expectation of success.

A prior art reference 'teaches away' if it discourages a POSITA from following the path taken by the applicant or leads them in a contrary direction.

Secondary considerations require a demonstrated 'nexus'—a direct causal connection between the novel claimed features and the objective evidence (e.g., commercial success).

Unexpected results must show superior technical performance in kind or degree compared to the closest prior art.

Last updated: August 2026

  • 4.2 Combining Prior Art References & Motivation to Combine
  • The Analogous Art Doctrine (MPEP § 2141.01(a))

Before a prior art reference can be combined with another reference under 35 U.S.C. § 103, it must qualify as "analogous art." The USPTO applies a strict two-prong test to determine whether a reference constitutes analogous art:

Prong 1: Field of Endeavor: Is the prior art reference from the same field of endeavor as the claimed invention, regardless of the specific problem addressed?

Prong 2: Reasonably Pertinent to the Problem: If the reference is not from the same field of endeavor, is it nevertheless reasonably pertinent to the particular problem with which the inventor was involved?

A reference is reasonably pertinent if it is one that a person of ordinary skill in the art (POSITA) would naturally look to for a solution to the specific problem facing the inventor. For example, in In re Bigio , 381 F.3d 1320 (Fed. Cir. 2004), a tooth-brushing structure was evaluated against prior art hairbrushes because both involved bristles mounted on hand-held substrates, placing them within a shared broader field of endeavor. Conversely, in In re Klein , 647 F.3d 1343 (Fed. Cir. 2011), references dealing with fixed-ratio liquid dividers were held not analogous to a claimed standing water divider because the prior art references failed to address the specific problem of dividing fluid from a standing, unpressurized source.

Analyzing the Field of Endeavor vs. Problem Solved

When evaluating Prong 1, examiners and practitioners look to the structure, function, and explicit disclosures of the prior art reference rather than its labeled title alone. If the reference originates from the same technical industry or discipline (e.g., semiconductor fabrication), it automatically satisfies Prong 1 even if it solves a different sub-problem.

When evaluating Prong 2, the inquiry focuses on the specific problem disclosed in the patent application. If an inventor is attempting to reduce mechanical friction in a high-speed hinge, references from aerospace engineering, automotive suspension, or office furniture hinges may all qualify under Prong 2 if they address friction reduction mechanisms, even though they belong to distinct commercial fields.

Motivation to Combine & Reasonable Expectation of Success

To establish a valid obviousness rejection when combining multiple prior art references, an Examiner must demonstrate both:

A clear motivation to combine or modify the references (supported by one of the MPEP § 2143 rational underpinnings).

A reasonable expectation of success in achieving the claimed combination (MPEP § 2143.02).

Post- KSR , motivation need not be explicitly stated within the four corners of the prior art references; it can arise from market forces, design trends, scientific principles, or the background knowledge of a POSITA. However, Examiner speculation is strictly improper. The Examiner must articulate an explicit, reasoned explanation grounded in factual evidence. Furthermore, a reasonable expectation of success does not require absolute certainty or guaranteed results, but it demands more than a mere speculative hope. If unpredictable chemical reactions or complex biological interactions prevent a POSITA from expecting success, the combination is nonobvious.

Articulating a Sound Motivation under MPEP § 2143

Under MPEP § 2143, the Examiner must articulate a clear rationale explaining why a POSITA would have been prompted to combine the primary reference with the secondary reference. Standard rationales include:

Design Incentives: Replacing a heavy metal casing with a lightweight composite polymer to improve portability or fuel efficiency.

Market Demand: Adapting a desktop software user interface for touch-screen mobile devices based on consumer preference.

Predictable Combination: Combining a known heating element with a known fluid pump where each component performs its conventional, expected function without unexpected synergistic interaction.

The Teaching Away Doctrine (MPEP § 2145)

A prior art reference cannot support an obviousness rejection if it "teaches away" from the claimed invention. Under MPEP § 2145 and Federal Circuit precedent ( In re Gurley ):

A reference teaches away if a person of ordinary skill in the art, upon reading the reference, would be discouraged from following the path set out in the reference, or led in a direction contrary to the path taken by the applicant.

  • Prior Art Condition Qualifies as Teaching Away? Legal Effect under § 103
  • Explicit Warning / Criticism Yes Defeats obviousness rejection; reference discredits combination
  • Technical Incompatibility Yes Rebuts Examiner's proposed modification rationale
  • Mere Preference for Alternative No Reference remains valid prior art; alternative is not a teaching away
  • Silence on Secondary Feature No Reference does not discourage combination
  • Distinguishing Teaching Away from Mere Preference

Examiners frequently cite prior art that discloses multiple embodiments or alternatives. It is a fundamental rule of patent law that a reference's disclosure of a preferred embodiment does not constitute a teaching away from its non-preferred embodiments. To establish a genuine teaching away, the reference must contain explicit statements disparaging the proposed modification (e.g., "adding water to this solvent mixture causes immediate decomposition") or demonstrating technical failure.

Secondary Considerations & Objective Evidence (MPEP § 716)

Secondary considerations (objective evidence of nonobviousness) must always be considered by Examiners when presented, as established by Graham v. John Deere . Objective evidence can overcome even a strong prima facie case of obviousness.

The five primary categories of objective evidence under MPEP § 716 are:

Commercial Success: Widespread market acceptance of the claimed product. To carry evidentiary weight, the applicant MUST establish a nexus —a direct causal relationship between the claimed novel features and the commercial success (rather than advertising, brand recognition, or market positioning).

Long-Felt But Unsolved Need: Evidence that the industry faced a persistent problem for an extended period, which others attempted but failed to solve until the applicant's invention.

Failure of Others: Documented unsuccessful efforts by competitors or research institutions to achieve the claimed result.

Copying by Competitors: Competitors explicitly copying the applicant's proprietary design or product rather than relying on prior art.

Unexpected Results: Achieving properties or capabilities superior in kind or degree compared to what POSITA would have predicted ( In re Soni ).

Establishing the Legal Nexus Requirement

Under MPEP § 716.01(b), objective evidence of nonobviousness is entitled to no weight unless the applicant proves a legal nexus . A nexus is a demonstrated causal connection between the submitted evidence and the claimed invention.

For instance, if an applicant submits sales figures demonstrating $50 million in revenue, but the commercial product includes unclaimed promotional features or benefits from an enormous marketing budget, the Examiner will discount the evidence for lack of nexus. To establish nexus, the applicant must present a declaration under 37 C.F.R. § 1.132 demonstrating that consumers purchased the product specifically because of the technical features recited in the patent claims.

Loading diagram... Analogous Art Determination & Combination Evaluation Workflow