Study guide
5.3 Best Mode Requirement & Current Post-AIA Status
USPTO Registration Examination Patent Bar
Track your progress as you read
Finished sections get a check mark.
1 Chapter 1: Overview, Registration & MPEP Structure
1.1 Patent Bar Exam Format & Administration 1.2 Practitioner Qualifications & Eligibility 1.3 MPEP Structure & Effective Search Strategies
2 Chapter 2: Subject Matter Eligibility & Utility (35 U.S.C. § 101)
2.1 Patent-Eligible Subject Matter & Statutory Categories 2.2 Judicial Exceptions & the Alice/Mayo Framework 2.3 Utility Requirements & USPTO Utility Guidelines
3 Chapter 3: Novelty & Prior Art Under the AIA (35 U.S.C. § 102)
3.1 First-Inventor-to-File (FITF) & Effective Filing Dates 3.2 The One-Year Inventor Grace Period & Exceptions 3.3 Prior Art Types & Public Availability Standards
4 Chapter 4: Nonobviousness Analysis (35 U.S.C. § 103)
4.1 The Graham Factors & KSR Obviousness Framework 4.2 Combining Prior Art References & Motivation to Combine 4.3 Overcoming § 103 Rejections & Rule 132 Affidavits
5 Chapter 5: Specification & Disclosure Requirements (35 U.S.C. § 112(a))
5.1 Written Description Requirement 5.2 Enablement Requirement & Wands Factors 5.3 Best Mode Requirement & Current Post-AIA Status
6 Chapter 6: Claim Requirements & Definiteness (35 U.S.C. § 112(b)-(f))
6.1 Definiteness & Claim Precision 6.2 Independent & Dependent Claim Construction 6.3 Special Claim Formats: Means-Plus-Function & Markush Claims
7 Chapter 7: Application Types & Filing Procedures (MPEP Chapter 600)
7.1 Provisional Patent Applications 7.2 Nonprovisional Application Parts & Formalities 7.3 Inventor Oaths, Declarations & Assignments
8 Chapter 8: Duty of Disclosure & Information Disclosure Statements
8.1 Duty of Candor & Good Faith 8.2 Information Disclosure Statements (IDS) Requirements 8.3 Correcting Non-Disclosure & Duty Compliance
9 Chapter 9: Patent Prosecution & Office Action Responses (MPEP Chapter 700)
9.1 Initial Examination & Non-Final Office Actions 9.2 Statutory Deadlines & Extension of Time 9.3 Final Office Actions & Post-Final Practice
10 Chapter 10: Continuing Applications & Copendency
10.1 Continuation Applications 10.2 Divisional Applications 10.3 Continuation-in-Part (CIP) Applications & Priority Allocation
11 Chapter 11: Appeals & Interferences/Derivation (MPEP Chapter 1200 & 2300)
11.1 Ex Parte Appeals to the PTAB 11.2 PTAB Appeal Decisions & Judicial Review 11.3 Derivation Proceedings Under the AIA
12 Chapter 12: Post-Grant Proceedings & Corrections (MPEP Chapters 1400 & 2200)
12.1 Reissue Applications & Certificates of Correction 12.2 Ex Parte Reexamination & Supplemental Examination 12.3 Inter Partes Review (IPR) & Post-Grant Review (PGR)
13 Chapter 13: Patent Term, Maintenance Fees & Ownership
13.1 Patent Term Calculation & Patent Term Adjustment (PTA) 13.2 Maintenance Fees & Expiration 13.3 Inventorship, Ownership & Assignment Recordation 13.4 Patent Term Extension Under 35 U.S.C. § 156
14 Chapter 14: International Patent Practice & PCT (MPEP Chapter 1800)
14.1 The Patent Cooperation Treaty (PCT) Overview 14.2 PCT International Phase & Chapter I / Chapter II 14.3 National Phase Entry Under 35 U.S.C. § 371
15 Chapter 15: Special Patent Categories & Professional Conduct
15.1 Design Patents & Plant Patents 15.2 USPTO Rules of Professional Conduct 15.3 Patent Bar Exam Strategy & Open-Book Navigation Tips
16 Chapter 16: Security, Access, Representation & Filing Mechanics
16.1 Secrecy, Application Access & Foreign Filing Licenses 16.2 Representation, Power of Attorney & Correspondence 16.3 Filing Receipt, Certificates of Transmission & Signatures
17 Chapter 17: Restriction, Publication, Allowance & Office Authority
17.1 Restriction, Election, Rejoinder & Double Patenting 17.2 Publication, Preissuance Submissions & Protests 17.3 Allowance, Issue Fee & Withdrawal from Issue 17.4 Examiner Interviews, Petitions & Office Authority
18 Chapter 18: Biotechnology Disclosure & Patent Prosecution Highway
18.1 Biological Deposits & Sequence Listings 18.2 Global/IP5 Patent Prosecution Highway
19 Chapter 19: AIA Trial Practice Under the Consolidated Guide
19.1 AIA Trial Petitions, Preliminary Response & Institution 19.2 AIA Trial Discovery, Motions, Hearing & Final Decision
5.3 Best Mode Requirement & Current Post-AIA Status
Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI
The best mode requirement involves a two-prong test: a subjective prong (did the inventor contemplate a best mode at filing?) and an objective prong (did the disclosure enable POSITA to practice that best mode?).
Under the Leahy-Smith America Invents Act (AIA), 35 U.S.C. § 282(b)(3)(A) eliminated failure to disclose best mode as an affirmative defense in litigation and post-grant proceedings.
35 U.S.C. § 112(a) still retains the statutory text requiring best mode, meaning USPTO examiners must evaluate best mode during initial examination.
In practice, USPTO rejections under best mode are extremely rare during ex parte examination because examiners cannot probe the subjective state of mind of the inventor.
The AIA left the best-mode text in § 112(a) for examination but bars failure to disclose best mode from being used to cancel, invalidate, or hold a claim unenforceable.
Last updated: August 2026
5.3 Best Mode Requirement & Current Post-AIA Status
Under the statutory language of 35 U.S.C. § 112(a) , the specification 'shall set forth the best mode contemplated by the inventor or joint inventor of carrying out the invention.' The purpose of this requirement historically was to prevent an inventor from obtaining a patent monopoly while concealing from the public their preferred embodiment or superior method of practicing the invention.
The Two-Prong Best Mode Test
Evaluating compliance with the best mode requirement requires a sequential two-prong analysis established by Federal Circuit case law ( Chemcast Corp. v. Arco Industries Corp. , 913 F.2d 923 (Fed. Cir. 1990)) and detailed in MPEP § 2165 :
1. The Subjective Prong (Inventor State of Mind)
Question: Did the inventor, at the time of filing the application, actually possess or contemplate a preferred mode of practicing the claimed invention?
Nature: Entirely subjective. It focuses exclusively on what the inventor personally believed at the filing date.
Timing: Evaluated as of the application filing date. If the inventor discovered a better mode after filing, there is no requirement to update the application.
Result: If the inventor did not contemplate a best mode (believed all embodiments were equal), the analysis ends — there is no best mode violation.
2. The Objective Prong (Adequacy of Disclosure)
Question: If the inventor contemplated a best mode, did the specification disclose sufficient information to enable a POSITA to practice that best mode?
Nature: Objective. It asks whether the disclosure concealed the best mode or failed to enable POSITA to practice the inventor's preferred embodiment.
Concealment Types: Express concealment (omitting critical parameters), passive concealment (burying the best mode in a mountain of inferior alternatives without indication), or failure to disclose essential proprietary trade secret settings.
Post-AIA Statutory Change: 35 U.S.C. § 282(b)(3)(A)
The Leahy-Smith America Invents Act (AIA) , enacted on September 16, 2011, fundamentally transformed how the best mode requirement is enforced in litigation and post-grant proceedings.
Congress enacted 35 U.S.C. § 282(b)(3)(A) , which explicitly states:
'[T]he failure to disclose the best mode shall not constitute a basis on which any claim of a patent may be canceled or held invalid or otherwise unenforceable...'
Impact of AIA on Best Mode Enforcement
Forum / Context Pre-AIA (Prior to Sept 16, 2011) Post-AIA (Current Law)
Federal District Court Litigation Best mode failure invalidated patent claims NO invalidity defense permitted under § 282(b)(3)(A)
PTAB Post-Grant Review (PGR) Available ground for claim cancellation Excluded as a ground for cancellation in PGR/IPR
USPTO Ex Parte Examination Examiner evaluated and rejected under § 112 Statutory text remains in 112(a); Examiners theoretically evaluate
Duty of Candor / Inequitable Conduct Intentional concealment invalidates patent Intentional fraudulent concealment may still risk inequitable conduct
Current Examination Standard at the USPTO (MPEP § 2165)
Despite the AIA litigation bar, the statutory text of 35 U.S.C. § 112(a) still includes the requirement to set forth the best mode. As a result, USPTO examination guidelines in MPEP § 2165 maintain that examiners must still apply the requirement during initial ex parte examination.
Practical Reality of USPTO Examination
In practice, rejections under § 112(a) for lack of best mode during examination are extremely rare . Why?
Lack of Evidence: Patent examiners examine applications based solely on the written record submitted. An examiner has no mechanism during initial examination to probe the subjective mind of the inventor to determine if they contemplated a preferred mode.
Presumption of Good Faith: Unless the applicant explicitly admits on the record that they concealed their preferred embodiment, the examiner must presume the applicant complied with the requirement.
When Might an Examiner Issue a Best Mode Rejection?
An examiner will issue a best mode rejection during examination only if :
The applicant explicitly states in the specification or in a declaration under 37 CFR 1.132 that a specific un-disclosed trade secret or parameter is the preferred embodiment; or
Evidence in a parent application or companion document explicitly shows the inventor concealed their best mode.
Ethical & Inequitable Conduct Implications
Even though an infringer cannot invalidate an issued patent in court based on a best mode defense under 35 U.S.C. § 282(b)(3)(A), patent practitioners and inventors must remain compliant during drafting:
Duty of Candor (37 CFR 1.56): Intentionally misleading the USPTO or making false statements regarding preferred embodiments during prosecution can constitute inequitable conduct, rendering the entire patent unenforceable.
Foreign Filing Considerations: Many foreign patent offices (and international filing standards) scrutinize disclosure completeness. Omitting preferred operational parameters can severely damage international patent rights.