Study guide
14.3 Search, Seizure & Suppression
NFPA Paralegal CORE Competency Exam PCCE
Track your progress as you read
Finished sections get a check mark.
1 Introduction & Exam Overview
1.1 Current Exam Facts 1.2 How to Use This Guide & Exam Strategy
2 The Paralegal Profession
2.1 Role of the Paralegal in the Legal Profession 2.2 National Paralegal Associations 2.3 Paralegal Regulation: Licensing vs Certification
3 Ethics: Code, UPL, Role & Advertising
3.1 NFPA Model Code and Rules of Professional Conduct 3.2 Unauthorized Practice of Law 3.3 Role Communication, Advertising & Solicitation
4 Ethics: Confidentiality, Privilege, Conflicts & Funds
4.1 Confidentiality 4.2 Attorney-Client Privilege and Work Product 4.3 Conflicts of Interest 4.4 Fees, Client Funds & Fiduciary Duty
5 The U.S. Legal System
5.1 Branches of Government, Terminology, Civil vs Criminal Law 5.2 Court Systems, Personnel & Court Rules 5.3 Constitutional Law and Case Law 5.4 Statutes, Codes & Administrative Law
6 Legal Research
6.1 Primary vs Secondary Sources; Mandatory vs Persuasive 6.2 Case Law Research: Reporters, Digests, Citators 6.3 Statutory and Administrative Research 6.4 CALR: Westlaw, Lexis, Shepard's, KeyCite & Free Sources 6.5 Secondary Sources as Finding Tools
7 Legal Writing, Analysis & Communication
7.1 Writing Basics, Captioning & Citation (Bluebook and ALWD) 7.2 Critical Analysis and the IRAC Method 7.3 Legal Writing Products 7.4 Communication, Interviewing, Fact-Finding & Correspondence 7.5 Client Interviewing and Evaluating Responses
8 Law Office Management & Legal Technology
8.1 Case Management, Databases, Litigation Support & Office Tools 8.2 Docketing and Calendar Control 8.3 Timekeeping, Billing, Retainers & Conflict Checks 8.4 E-Discovery, E-Filing, Word Processing & Spreadsheets 8.5 Client Files, Records Retention & File Ownership
9 Civil Litigation: Starting the Case
9.1 Civil Litigation Terminology & FRCP Overview 9.2 Jurisdiction, Venue & Filing 9.3 Parties and Third-Party Actions 9.4 Process Service
10 Civil Litigation: Discovery, Trial, Judgment & Appeal
10.1 Discovery Tools and Document Control 10.2 Federal Rules of Evidence 10.3 Pre-Trial and Trial Practice 10.4 Witnesses, Experts, Exhibits & Trial Presentations 10.5 Judgments, Enforcement & Appeals
11 Business Organizations
11.1 Entity Types and Terminology 11.2 Entity Formation and Dissolution 11.3 Foreign Corporation / Interstate Registration 11.4 Governance: Minutes, Resolutions, Annual Reports & Corporate Trail
12 Contracts
12.1 Elements of a Valid, Enforceable Contract 12.2 Contract Defenses and Discharge of Obligations 12.3 Contract Remedies 12.4 UCC Articles 1, 2, 3 & 9
13 Torts
13.1 Elements of Negligence 13.2 Intentional Torts and Strict Liability 13.3 Tort Defenses and Effects of Insurance 13.4 Tort Remedies: Damages and Injunctions
14 Criminal Law & Procedure
14.1 Elements, Sources & Classifications of Crimes 14.2 Defenses and Constitutional Rights 14.3 Search, Seizure & Suppression 14.4 Stages of Criminal Procedure and Evidence 14.5 Criminal Trial Practice and Appeals
15 Estates, Wills & Trusts
15.1 Wills: Validity, Testamentary Capacity & Revocation 15.2 Intestate Succession and Probate 15.3 Probate Administration 15.4 Trusts 15.5 Guardianship, Incapacity, Living Wills, Healthcare Proxies & Durable POA
16 Family Law
16.1 Divorce, Annulment, Separation, Property Division & Spousal Support 16.2 Custody, Visitation & Child Support 16.3 Child Support: Guidelines, Modification & Enforcement 16.4 Adoption, Paternity & Prenuptial/Postnuptial Agreements 16.5 Family Law Alternative Dispute Resolution
17 Real Estate
17.1 Ownership Types, Deeds & Types of Transfers 17.2 Title Search, Surveys, Easements, Covenants & Zoning 17.3 Financing, Mortgages, Liens & Foreclosure 17.4 Liens on Real Property: Types, Priority & Release 17.5 Landlord-Tenant, Rentals, Leases & Closings
14.3 Search, Seizure & Suppression
Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI
A Fourth Amendment search occurs when the government invades a reasonable expectation of privacy under Katz or physically trespasses on protected property to gather information under United States v. Jones.
Arizona v. Gant limits vehicle searches incident to arrest to situations where the arrestee can reach the passenger compartment or it is reasonable to believe the vehicle holds evidence of the offense of arrest.
Riley v. California requires a warrant to search a cell phone's digital contents seized incident to arrest, and Carpenter v. United States requires one for historical cell-site location information.
The exclusionary rule is limited by the independent source, inevitable discovery, attenuation, and good-faith doctrines, and it does not apply to grand jury proceedings, civil deportation hearings, or parole revocation.
On a motion to suppress a warrantless search the government bears the burden of proving an exception applies; where officers acted under a warrant, the defendant bears the burden.
Last updated: August 2026
Section 14.2 listed the Fourth Amendment among the constitutional protections. This section is the doctrine itself, because the blueprint names Constitutional rights and Evidence as separate Criminal line items and because the motion to suppress is the single most common criminal-defense filing a paralegal staffs.
What counts as a search
There are two independent tests, and either one can make government conduct a search:
Reasonable expectation of privacy — from Katz v. United States (1967). The person must have an actual, subjective expectation of privacy that society is prepared to recognize as reasonable. Katz is the source of the line that the Fourth Amendment "protects people, not places."
Physical trespass — revived in United States v. Jones (2012). Physically occupying private property to obtain information is a search, regardless of any privacy expectation. Attaching a GPS device to a vehicle qualifies.
A seizure of property is a meaningful interference with a possessory interest. A seizure of a person occurs when, in view of all the circumstances, a reasonable person would not feel free to leave or to terminate the encounter.
Fourth Amendment rights are personal. Under Rakas v. Illinois (1978), a defendant cannot suppress evidence obtained by violating someone else's rights. Modern courts fold this "standing" question into the substantive analysis: did this defendant have a legitimate expectation of privacy in the place searched? A passenger with no possessory interest in a car may not be able to challenge the search of its trunk but can challenge the stop itself.
Warrants
A valid warrant requires four things:
Probable cause — under Illinois v. Gates (1983), a totality of the circumstances judgment that there is a fair probability contraband or evidence will be found in the place to be searched. Informant veracity, reliability, and basis of knowledge are factors, not rigid prongs.
Particularity — the warrant must describe the place to be searched and the persons or things to be seized . A warrant authorizing a search for "evidence of criminal activity" is a general warrant and invalid.
Oath or affirmation supporting the affidavit.
A neutral and detached magistrate .
Franks v. Delaware (1978) lets a defendant attack the affidavit itself: on a substantial preliminary showing that the affiant made a deliberate falsehood or acted with reckless disregard for the truth , and that the false statement was necessary to the probable cause finding , the defendant is entitled to a hearing.
Execution has its own rules — knock and announce , execution within the warrant's time limit, and a search confined to places where the described items could be. Once the named item is found, the authority to keep searching for it ends.
Warrant exceptions
Exception Scope
Search incident to lawful arrest Chimel v. California (1969): the arrestee's person and the area within immediate control. For vehicles, Arizona v. Gant (2009) narrows it — only if the arrestee is unsecured and within reaching distance of the passenger compartment, or it is reasonable to believe the vehicle contains evidence of the offense of arrest
Automobile exception Carroll v. United States (1925): probable cause that a readily mobile vehicle contains contraband or evidence. California v. Acevedo (1991) extends it to containers within the vehicle that could hold the object of the search
Exigent circumstances Hot pursuit, imminent destruction of evidence, emergency aid. Kentucky v. King (2011): police may rely on an exigency they created, so long as they did not create it by violating or threatening to violate the Fourth Amendment
Consent Schneckloth v. Bustamonte (1973): voluntariness under the totality of the circumstances; officers need not warn of the right to refuse. Consent may come from a person with actual or apparent authority, and may be limited in scope or withdrawn. Georgia v. Randolph (2006): a physically present co-occupant's express refusal defeats another occupant's consent
Plain view Lawful vantage point, lawful right of access, and incriminating character immediately apparent . Minnesota v. Dickerson (1993) recognizes a plain feel analogue during a lawful frisk
Terry stop and frisk Terry v. Ohio (1968): brief investigative detention on reasonable suspicion of criminal activity, plus a pat-down for weapons on reasonable suspicion the person is armed and dangerous. It is a weapons frisk, not an evidence search
Inventory search Routine cataloguing of a lawfully impounded vehicle or an arrestee's property, conducted under standardized procedures rather than as a pretext for investigation
Protective sweep Maryland v. Buie (1990): a quick look during an in-home arrest at spaces where a person posing a danger could hide
Special needs / administrative Border searches, school searches, probation and parole conditions, sobriety checkpoints, and regulatory inspections of closely regulated industries
The digital-device rules
Two decisions carry disproportionate exam weight because they carved digital data out of older doctrine:
Riley v. California (2014): officers generally must get a warrant to search the digital contents of a cell phone seized incident to arrest. The physical phone may be seized; its data is different in both quantity and kind.
Carpenter v. United States (2018): acquiring historical cell-site location information from a wireless carrier is a search, and generally requires a warrant rather than a lesser court order. Carpenter cut back the third-party doctrine for this category of data.
The exclusionary rule
The exclusionary rule bars evidence obtained in violation of the Fourth Amendment from the prosecution's case-in-chief . It is a judicially created remedy designed to deter police misconduct — not a personal constitutional right to a damages award. Wong Sun v. United States (1963) extends the bar to derivative evidence, the fruit of the poisonous tree .
Four doctrines cut it back, and they are the tested part:
Independent source — the evidence was also obtained through a genuinely separate, lawful route.
Inevitable discovery — Nix v. Williams (1984): the evidence would have been found lawfully anyway.
Attenuation — Brown v. Illinois (1975): the connection between the illegality and the evidence has become sufficiently remote, measured by the time elapsed, intervening circumstances, and the flagrancy of the official misconduct. Utah v. Strieff (2016) applied it to a pre-existing valid arrest warrant discovered during an unlawful stop.
Good faith — United States v. Leon (1984): objectively reasonable reliance on a warrant later found unsupported by probable cause. Extended to negligent police recordkeeping in Herring v. United States (2009) and to reliance on binding appellate precedent later overruled in Davis v. United States (2011). Leon does not save a warrant obtained by a knowingly false affidavit, one so lacking in probable cause that reliance is unreasonable, or a facially deficient one.
Where the rule does not reach: grand jury proceedings, civil deportation hearings, parole revocation, and impeachment of the defendant's own testimony. Illegally seized evidence excluded from the case-in-chief can still be used to impeach a defendant who takes the stand and denies it.
The suppression motion
Who files. The defense, by written motion, usually before trial under the jurisdiction's pretrial-motion deadline. Failing to file on time can waive the issue.
Burden allocation is worth memorizing because it flips:
Warrantless search or seizure — the search is presumptively unreasonable , so the government bears the burden of proving an exception applies.
Search under a warrant — the defendant bears the burden of showing the warrant or its execution was defective.
The hearing is an evidentiary proceeding before the judge, typically with the officers testifying. The rules of evidence are relaxed ; hearsay is often admissible at a suppression hearing. The judge decides both the historical facts and the legal conclusions.
What the paralegal assembles. This is real, concrete work: the warrant and supporting affidavit, the return and inventory, the police reports and supplements, computer-aided dispatch logs and radio traffic, body-worn and dashboard camera footage with timestamps, booking records, the property and evidence log, chain-of-custody documentation, lab submission forms, and any prior statements. Build a timeline cross-referencing report narrative against the video clock — the discrepancies between them are where suppression issues live. Track discovery requests and any Brady or Giglio material the prosecution produces.
Chain of custody matters independently of suppression: every transfer of an item from seizure through testing to the courtroom must be documented, because an unexplained gap is an authentication attack under FRE 901 even when the seizure itself was lawful.
Worked path
Officers stop a car for a broken taillight, arrest the driver on an outstanding warrant, secure him in the patrol car, then search the passenger compartment and find a phone, which they scroll through at the scene. The paralegal builds the file: the traffic-stop video, the arrest report, and the phone extraction report. Two issues surface for the attorney. First, under Gant , the vehicle search after the driver was secured is supportable only if it was reasonable to believe the car held evidence of the offense of arrest — and the offense of arrest was an unrelated warrant. Second, under Riley , scrolling the phone's contents at the scene needed a warrant regardless. The paralegal drafts the timeline, indexes the video by timestamp, and pulls the warrant and return; the attorney decides what to argue.