Study guide

3.2 Unauthorized Practice of Law

NFPA Paralegal CORE Competency Exam PCCE

Track your progress as you read

Finished sections get a check mark.

1 Introduction & Exam Overview

1.1 Current Exam Facts 1.2 How to Use This Guide & Exam Strategy

2 The Paralegal Profession

2.1 Role of the Paralegal in the Legal Profession 2.2 National Paralegal Associations 2.3 Paralegal Regulation: Licensing vs Certification

3 Ethics: Code, UPL, Role & Advertising

3.1 NFPA Model Code and Rules of Professional Conduct 3.2 Unauthorized Practice of Law 3.3 Role Communication, Advertising & Solicitation

4 Ethics: Confidentiality, Privilege, Conflicts & Funds

4.1 Confidentiality 4.2 Attorney-Client Privilege and Work Product 4.3 Conflicts of Interest 4.4 Fees, Client Funds & Fiduciary Duty

5 The U.S. Legal System

5.1 Branches of Government, Terminology, Civil vs Criminal Law 5.2 Court Systems, Personnel & Court Rules 5.3 Constitutional Law and Case Law 5.4 Statutes, Codes & Administrative Law

6 Legal Research

6.1 Primary vs Secondary Sources; Mandatory vs Persuasive 6.2 Case Law Research: Reporters, Digests, Citators 6.3 Statutory and Administrative Research 6.4 CALR: Westlaw, Lexis, Shepard's, KeyCite & Free Sources 6.5 Secondary Sources as Finding Tools

7 Legal Writing, Analysis & Communication

7.1 Writing Basics, Captioning & Citation (Bluebook and ALWD) 7.2 Critical Analysis and the IRAC Method 7.3 Legal Writing Products 7.4 Communication, Interviewing, Fact-Finding & Correspondence 7.5 Client Interviewing and Evaluating Responses

8 Law Office Management & Legal Technology

8.1 Case Management, Databases, Litigation Support & Office Tools 8.2 Docketing and Calendar Control 8.3 Timekeeping, Billing, Retainers & Conflict Checks 8.4 E-Discovery, E-Filing, Word Processing & Spreadsheets 8.5 Client Files, Records Retention & File Ownership

9 Civil Litigation: Starting the Case

9.1 Civil Litigation Terminology & FRCP Overview 9.2 Jurisdiction, Venue & Filing 9.3 Parties and Third-Party Actions 9.4 Process Service

10 Civil Litigation: Discovery, Trial, Judgment & Appeal

10.1 Discovery Tools and Document Control 10.2 Federal Rules of Evidence 10.3 Pre-Trial and Trial Practice 10.4 Witnesses, Experts, Exhibits & Trial Presentations 10.5 Judgments, Enforcement & Appeals

11 Business Organizations

11.1 Entity Types and Terminology 11.2 Entity Formation and Dissolution 11.3 Foreign Corporation / Interstate Registration 11.4 Governance: Minutes, Resolutions, Annual Reports & Corporate Trail

12 Contracts

12.1 Elements of a Valid, Enforceable Contract 12.2 Contract Defenses and Discharge of Obligations 12.3 Contract Remedies 12.4 UCC Articles 1, 2, 3 & 9

13 Torts

13.1 Elements of Negligence 13.2 Intentional Torts and Strict Liability 13.3 Tort Defenses and Effects of Insurance 13.4 Tort Remedies: Damages and Injunctions

14 Criminal Law & Procedure

14.1 Elements, Sources & Classifications of Crimes 14.2 Defenses and Constitutional Rights 14.3 Search, Seizure & Suppression 14.4 Stages of Criminal Procedure and Evidence 14.5 Criminal Trial Practice and Appeals

15 Estates, Wills & Trusts

15.1 Wills: Validity, Testamentary Capacity & Revocation 15.2 Intestate Succession and Probate 15.3 Probate Administration 15.4 Trusts 15.5 Guardianship, Incapacity, Living Wills, Healthcare Proxies & Durable POA

16 Family Law

16.1 Divorce, Annulment, Separation, Property Division & Spousal Support 16.2 Custody, Visitation & Child Support 16.3 Child Support: Guidelines, Modification & Enforcement 16.4 Adoption, Paternity & Prenuptial/Postnuptial Agreements 16.5 Family Law Alternative Dispute Resolution

17 Real Estate

17.1 Ownership Types, Deeds & Types of Transfers 17.2 Title Search, Surveys, Easements, Covenants & Zoning 17.3 Financing, Mortgages, Liens & Foreclosure 17.4 Liens on Real Property: Types, Priority & Release 17.5 Landlord-Tenant, Rentals, Leases & Closings

3.2 Unauthorized Practice of Law

Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI

NFPA EC-1.8(a) defines unauthorized practice of law as giving legal advice, accepting cases, setting fees, planning strategy, making legal decisions, taking depositions, and appearing in court.

Legal advice is applying law to a specific person’s facts and recommending a course of action; legal information is general and not tailored to that person’s situation.

Permitted paralegal work includes legal information, factual investigation, legal research, and drafting for attorney review, revision, and signature — the attorney remains responsible.

Unsupervised freelance document preparation for a member of the public, even with a “I am not a lawyer” waiver, is a classic UPL pattern.

On scenario items, the safe choice is almost always refuse the reserved act, disclose nonlawyer status, and route the request to the supervising attorney or to legal aid.

Last updated: August 2026

Unauthorized practice of law (UPL) is the practice of law by someone who does not hold a current law license. NFPA Rule 1.8 states the duty in one sentence: a paralegal shall not engage in the unauthorized practice of law. EC-1.8(a) then gives the definition the exam expects you to recite: giving legal advice , accepting cases , setting fees , planning strategy , making legal decisions , taking depositions , and appearing in court . EC-1.8(b) adds that the paralegal must comply with the UPL authority of every jurisdiction in which the paralegal provides services. States define “practice of law” in slightly different words — some by statute, some by court rule, some by case law — but the reserved-act list is stable enough for a national exam. Do not invent a state that “lets experienced paralegals set fees.”

The Code’s own definitions close the loop. Practice of law is the application of legal principles and judgment to the circumstances or objectives of a person, requiring the knowledge and skill of a person trained in the law. A traditional paralegal works with supervision by, and accountability to, a lawyer. A freelance / contract / virtual paralegal is a self-employed contractor retained by attorneys; a lawyer is still accountable. An independent paralegal provides services to consumers with no lawyer accountable. A rogue paralegal , in NFPA’s vocabulary, is a non-attorney who uses the paralegal title and serves the public in violation of state UPL rules. Limited License Legal Technicians (LLLT) , Limited License Legal Providers (LLLP) , and Legal Paraprofessionals (LP) are separate, state-created licenses. EC-1.8(c) allows expanded work only inside a program that lawfully authorizes it, and only if the paralegal follows that program’s rules. A CRP credential is not an LLLT license.

Reserved acts versus permitted work

Lawyer-reserved (UPL if the paralegal does it) Generally permitted under attorney supervision

Applying law to a client’s specific facts and recommending a course ( legal advice ) Giving legal information (general rules, court hours, what a form is for)

Accepting or rejecting a representation; forming the attorney-client relationship Completing an intake form and running a conflict check for the attorney

Setting, negotiating, or splitting the legal fee Explaining the firm’s published rate sheet and how billing generally works, then sending the fee agreement to the lawyer

Planning case strategy and making the legal decisions Collecting facts, outlining options in a memo to the attorney , and implementing the attorney’s chosen strategy

Taking a deposition as the examiner who questions the witness Scheduling the deposition, preparing an outline for the attorney, attending, and summarizing the transcript

Appearing in court as counsel; arguing a motion; entering a plea Sitting at counsel table if the court allows, handling exhibits, and whispering facts — not making the record as advocate

Signing a pleading as counsel (Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 11 territory) Drafting the pleading for the attorney to review, revise, and sign

Selecting the client’s legal theory or the grounds for a divorce or will disposition Completing a form exactly as the attorney (or, in a lawful document-preparer regime, the client) directs , without choosing the legal content

The attorney must actually supervise . ABA Model Rule 5.3 is the supervision rule; Rule 5.5 is the “do not assist UPL” rule. Rubber-stamp review — the attorney never reads the complaint, never discusses the fee, never sees the client — is not supervision. A later timekeeping chapter will cover billing the paralegal’s time; for UPL purposes, remember that even excellent, billable paralegal work becomes UPL the moment the paralegal, not the lawyer, is the one giving the advice or making the call.

The information-versus-advice trap

This is the most common PCCE UPL item. Legal information is a general statement about the law or the legal system that is not applied to a particular person’s facts and does not recommend what that person should do. “The federal district court clerk’s office is on the third floor.” “Many jurisdictions have a two-year statute of limitations for negligence, but only the attorney can tell you what applies to you.” “This is what a complaint caption looks like.” Those sentences are information.

Legal advice is the application of law to a specific person’s facts plus a recommended course. “Your wreck was 23 months ago, so file this week in state court and reject the $15,000 offer.” That sentence selects a forum, applies a limitations period, and evaluates a settlement. It is advice even if you add “I am not a lawyer,” even if you charge nothing, and even if the client is a friend, a cousin, or a Facebook stranger. A signed waiver does not convert advice into information. Pro bono status does not convert advice into information. Experience does not convert advice into information.

Work the line with the facts in front of you:

A caller asks, “How long do I have to sue my surgeon?” Information: “Medical-malpractice deadlines vary and often include a notice-of-claim step; I will have Attorney Chen call you.” Advice: “You have two years from the date of surgery, so you are fine until March.”

A current client emails, “Should I accept the insurer’s $40,000 offer?” Information / process: “I will get this to Attorney Chen today; only the attorney can advise you on settlement.” Advice: “Take it — juries in this county never give more than $25,000 for a soft-tissue case.”

A self-represented litigant in the hallway asks you to “just check” whether the affirmative defenses on a downloaded answer are the right ones. Checking and selecting defenses is legal judgment. Direct the person to the self-help center or to counsel.

ABA Formal Opinion 506 is consistent with this line. Trained intake personnel may collect facts the lawyer will use to decide eligibility and may explain how fees are charged. Whether they may answer a specific question depends on the question. On the PCCE, treat a specific “what should I do” question as reserved.

Drafting, investigation, and the signature line

Drafting is not UPL when it is done for attorney review . You may draft complaints, discovery, contracts, demand letters, and settlement releases. The attorney must exercise independent professional judgment before the document goes out, and the attorney (or the client, for a sworn verification) signs in the capacity the rules require. Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 11 attributes the pleading’s legal contentions to the attorney who signs it. A paralegal who signs “Jane Doe, Attorney for Plaintiff” has practiced law. A paralegal who signs a certificate of service as “Jane Doe, Paralegal for Attorney Chen,” if local rules allow that clerical certification, has not.

Factual investigation is permitted: locate witnesses, obtain medical records with a valid authorization, photograph a scene, prepare a chronology, and write a memo that says what the witness said. Crossing into advice happens when the memo to the client says “therefore you should sue for battery, not negligence.” Address strategy memos to the attorney .

Taking a deposition has two jobs inside it. Noticing the deposition, reserving the reporter, preparing exhibit binders, and attending are paralegal work. Examining the deponent — asking the questions, making the objections, deciding whether to go off the record — is a reserved advocacy act. A few administrative forums (for example, some Social Security hearings) authorize a nonlawyer agency representative by statute or agency rule. That is EC-1.8(c) territory. Absent that authority, do not pick up the examiner’s outline and start asking questions because “the attorney is running late.”

Unsupervised freelance document prep

A recurring fact pattern: a member of the public, not an attorney, hires a freelance paralegal to “just fill out” a will, an uncontested divorce, a bankruptcy petition, or a deed. The customer cannot afford a lawyer. The paralegal uses a widely available template, charges only a typing fee, and has the customer sign a statement that the paralegal is not an attorney.

That engagement is UPL in the ordinary jurisdiction. Selecting testamentary gifts, choosing divorce grounds, deciding which property is marital, or picking bankruptcy exemptions is legal judgment. A typing fee and a waiver do not change the character of the act. The correct move is to decline , explain that unsupervised legal document preparation for the public is the practice of law, and refer the person to a licensed attorney, a legal-aid office, or a court-authorized self-help program. If the jurisdiction has a registered Legal Document Preparer / Legal Document Assistant regime, that person may prepare documents at the client’s direction under that statute — and is usually required to be registered and bonded. A CRP title is not a substitute registration.

If instead an attorney retains the same freelance paralegal to draft the divorce packet, and the attorney reviews and signs it, the work is traditional delegated drafting. The difference is who is accountable . NFPA’s freelance definition assumes attorney accountability. Serving the public with no lawyer in the loop is the independent / rogue pattern.

Which option should the paralegal choose?

PCCE items are almost always “what should the paralegal do next?” Eliminate every option that has the paralegal exercising reserved judgment. Eliminate every option that treats a waiver, a discount, a friendship, or a lunch-hour favor as a license. Eliminate “ignore the client because paralegals may never speak to clients” — communication is allowed; advice is not. The surviving option usually has three pieces: disclose nonlawyer status , refuse the reserved act , and get the supervising attorney (or a referral) into the conversation .

Loading diagram... Information versus advice and other reserved acts