Study guide

6.1 Primary vs Secondary Sources; Mandatory vs Persuasive

NFPA Paralegal CORE Competency Exam PCCE

Track your progress as you read

Finished sections get a check mark.

1 Introduction & Exam Overview

1.1 Current Exam Facts 1.2 How to Use This Guide & Exam Strategy

2 The Paralegal Profession

2.1 Role of the Paralegal in the Legal Profession 2.2 National Paralegal Associations 2.3 Paralegal Regulation: Licensing vs Certification

3 Ethics: Code, UPL, Role & Advertising

3.1 NFPA Model Code and Rules of Professional Conduct 3.2 Unauthorized Practice of Law 3.3 Role Communication, Advertising & Solicitation

4 Ethics: Confidentiality, Privilege, Conflicts & Funds

4.1 Confidentiality 4.2 Attorney-Client Privilege and Work Product 4.3 Conflicts of Interest 4.4 Fees, Client Funds & Fiduciary Duty

5 The U.S. Legal System

5.1 Branches of Government, Terminology, Civil vs Criminal Law 5.2 Court Systems, Personnel & Court Rules 5.3 Constitutional Law and Case Law 5.4 Statutes, Codes & Administrative Law

6 Legal Research

6.1 Primary vs Secondary Sources; Mandatory vs Persuasive 6.2 Case Law Research: Reporters, Digests, Citators 6.3 Statutory and Administrative Research 6.4 CALR: Westlaw, Lexis, Shepard's, KeyCite & Free Sources 6.5 Secondary Sources as Finding Tools

7 Legal Writing, Analysis & Communication

7.1 Writing Basics, Captioning & Citation (Bluebook and ALWD) 7.2 Critical Analysis and the IRAC Method 7.3 Legal Writing Products 7.4 Communication, Interviewing, Fact-Finding & Correspondence 7.5 Client Interviewing and Evaluating Responses

8 Law Office Management & Legal Technology

8.1 Case Management, Databases, Litigation Support & Office Tools 8.2 Docketing and Calendar Control 8.3 Timekeeping, Billing, Retainers & Conflict Checks 8.4 E-Discovery, E-Filing, Word Processing & Spreadsheets 8.5 Client Files, Records Retention & File Ownership

9 Civil Litigation: Starting the Case

9.1 Civil Litigation Terminology & FRCP Overview 9.2 Jurisdiction, Venue & Filing 9.3 Parties and Third-Party Actions 9.4 Process Service

10 Civil Litigation: Discovery, Trial, Judgment & Appeal

10.1 Discovery Tools and Document Control 10.2 Federal Rules of Evidence 10.3 Pre-Trial and Trial Practice 10.4 Witnesses, Experts, Exhibits & Trial Presentations 10.5 Judgments, Enforcement & Appeals

11 Business Organizations

11.1 Entity Types and Terminology 11.2 Entity Formation and Dissolution 11.3 Foreign Corporation / Interstate Registration 11.4 Governance: Minutes, Resolutions, Annual Reports & Corporate Trail

12 Contracts

12.1 Elements of a Valid, Enforceable Contract 12.2 Contract Defenses and Discharge of Obligations 12.3 Contract Remedies 12.4 UCC Articles 1, 2, 3 & 9

13 Torts

13.1 Elements of Negligence 13.2 Intentional Torts and Strict Liability 13.3 Tort Defenses and Effects of Insurance 13.4 Tort Remedies: Damages and Injunctions

14 Criminal Law & Procedure

14.1 Elements, Sources & Classifications of Crimes 14.2 Defenses and Constitutional Rights 14.3 Search, Seizure & Suppression 14.4 Stages of Criminal Procedure and Evidence 14.5 Criminal Trial Practice and Appeals

15 Estates, Wills & Trusts

15.1 Wills: Validity, Testamentary Capacity & Revocation 15.2 Intestate Succession and Probate 15.3 Probate Administration 15.4 Trusts 15.5 Guardianship, Incapacity, Living Wills, Healthcare Proxies & Durable POA

16 Family Law

16.1 Divorce, Annulment, Separation, Property Division & Spousal Support 16.2 Custody, Visitation & Child Support 16.3 Child Support: Guidelines, Modification & Enforcement 16.4 Adoption, Paternity & Prenuptial/Postnuptial Agreements 16.5 Family Law Alternative Dispute Resolution

17 Real Estate

17.1 Ownership Types, Deeds & Types of Transfers 17.2 Title Search, Surveys, Easements, Covenants & Zoning 17.3 Financing, Mortgages, Liens & Foreclosure 17.4 Liens on Real Property: Types, Priority & Release 17.5 Landlord-Tenant, Rentals, Leases & Closings

6.1 Primary vs Secondary Sources; Mandatory vs Persuasive

Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI

Primary sources are the law itself: constitutions, statutes, regulations, cases, treaties, and court rules.

Secondary sources — Am. Jur. 2d, C.J.S., ALR, Restatements, treatises, law reviews, and practice guides — explain the law and are a starting point, not usually binding.

Mandatory (binding) authority is primary law the deciding court must follow on the same issue; persuasive authority may be considered and rejected.

A Restatement section or an out-of-jurisdiction case is persuasive only unless the forum’s reviewing court has adopted that rule.

The holding binds later courts; dicta, dissents, concurrences, and encyclopedia paragraphs do not.

Last updated: August 2026

The Paralegal CORE Competency Exam (PCCE) tests legal research as a classification and workflow skill. You will not log into a live computer-assisted legal research (CALR) terminal in the Prometric room. You will be asked whether a named book, database, or opinion is primary or secondary , and whether it is mandatory (binding) or only persuasive in the court that will decide the client’s problem. Mix those two axes and you will pick the attractive wrong answer: treating American Jurisprudence, Second Edition (Am. Jur. 2d) as if it were a statute, or treating a New York opinion as if a Texas trial judge had to follow it.

Primary sources: the law itself

A primary source is the law. A government body with authority to make law issued it. The exam’s working list is:

Constitutions — the United States Constitution and each state’s constitution, plus amendments adopted through the jurisdiction’s prescribed process

Statutes — acts of Congress and of state legislatures, both as originally enacted and as later codified in a subject-matter code

Regulations (administrative rules) — rules an agency adopts under a statute that delegates rulemaking power; federal examples live in the Code of Federal Regulations (CFR)

Case law — judicial opinions, especially published opinions that a jurisdiction treats as precedent under stare decisis

Treaties — international agreements that have domestic legal force once the Constitution’s process (and any implementing statute) is complete

Court rules — including the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure (FRCP) , the Federal Rules of Evidence (FRE) , the Federal Rules of Appellate Procedure, the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure, and counterpart state rules of court

If the source is the rule a judge applies, it is primary. A section of the United States Code (U.S.C.) , a CFR part, a state supreme court opinion, a ratified treaty that is self-executing or implemented, and Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 12(b)(6) are all primary.

Primary is not a synonym for mandatory . A California Court of Appeal opinion is primary law. It binds California trial courts in that appellate district on the point decided. It is only persuasive in a Texas trial court. Train yourself to ask two separate questions on every PCCE stem: (1) Is this the law, or is it writing about the law? (2) Must this court follow it?

Municipal ordinances, interstate compacts that have been given legal effect, and some executive orders can also be primary in the narrow setting they govern. The exam still wants the six-family list above as your first cut.

Secondary sources: writing about the law

A secondary source explains, organizes, criticizes, or restates the law. It is not enacted and not a judicial holding. Memorize the families the Domain 1 blueprint names:

Source What it is What you use it for

American Jurisprudence 2d (Am. Jur. 2d) and Corpus Juris Secundum (C.J.S.) National legal encyclopedias arranged by topic Fast overview and leads to cases and statutes; not binding

American Law Reports (ALR) Long annotations that collect and analyze cases on a narrow issue across jurisdictions One of the best case-finders in print or online; the annotation itself is secondary

Restatements of the Law American Law Institute (ALI) black-letter rules, comments, and illustrations Highly persuasive; binding only after a court adopts the section

Treatises, hornbooks, and practice treatises Scholarly or practice books (Wright & Miller on federal procedure; Prosser and Keeton on torts) Depth and collected citations

Law reviews and journals Student-edited or peer-reviewed articles Policy, history, and novel arguments; almost never mandatory

Practice guides, form books, and continuing-legal-education (CLE) outlines Jurisdiction-specific how-to (Rutter, CEB, and similar) Practical starting point; cite the underlying rule, not the guide, as law

Legal dictionaries such as Black’s Law Dictionary Definitions Vocabulary, not a holding

Secondary sources are a starting point , not a substitute for the law. You open Am. Jur. 2d, C.J.S., or an ALR annotation to learn the vocabulary, to see majority and minority rules, and to harvest citations. You then read the primary authorities those sources point to, and you update those authorities with a citator. A memo that quotes only C.J.S. has given the attorney an encyclopedia, not a holding. A brief that cites only a law-review student note has given the court a student note.

Courts sometimes adopt a Restatement section as the state’s common-law rule. After that happens, what binds later courts is the adopting opinion and the state’s own cases applying it. The ALI volume on the shelf does not become a statute. Pattern jury instructions and form books are the same idea: useful, sometimes quoted, almost never independently mandatory.

Mandatory versus persuasive authority

Mandatory authority (also called binding authority ) is a primary source the deciding court must follow on the same legal issue when the material facts are not distinguishable. Persuasive authority is anything the court may consider and may reject. Stare decisis is the doctrine that a court follows its own prior holdings and the holdings of courts that sit above it. The holding — the rule necessary to the judgment — is what binds. Obiter dictum (a remark not necessary to the result), a dissent, and a concurrence are not holdings.

State trial court (state-law claim)

Imagine a Texas district court deciding a Texas negligence claim:

Mandatory: the U.S. Constitution and controlling U.S. Supreme Court decisions on any federal issue actually presented; the Texas constitution; Texas statutes and valid Texas regulations; Texas Supreme Court decisions; published decisions of the Texas intermediate appellate court for that district on questions that court has decided

Persuasive: other Texas courts of appeals; other states’ high courts; federal opinions interpreting Texas law; Restatements; treatises; law reviews; dicta; dissents

If the Texas Supreme Court has spoken, an older court-of-appeals case to the contrary is no longer the rule, even if it is still printed in the regional reporter. If only another Texas court of appeals has spoken, many Texas trial judges treat that decision as highly persuasive; it is still not automatically mandatory outside that district. The PCCE cares that you can name the difference.

Federal district court (federal question)

Imagine a federal district court in the Fifth Circuit deciding a federal statutory claim:

Mandatory: the U.S. Constitution; federal statutes and valid federal regulations; the U.S. Supreme Court; published Fifth Circuit decisions

Persuasive: other circuits; other district-court opinions (a district opinion binds the parties through law of the case or preclusion, but it does not bind the next district judge as precedent); Restatements and commentary

In a diversity case, the federal court applies state substantive law. If the state’s high court has spoken, that decision is the rule the federal court must follow on the state-law issue. If the high court has not spoken, the federal court predicts what that court would do; a sister-state case and a Restatement become persuasive tools for that prediction. The federal court does not get to invent a “better” state rule because a law review prefers it.

Federal Rule of Appellate Procedure 32.1 permits citation of federal unpublished decisions issued on or after January 1, 2007, but permission to cite is not mandatory force. A nonprecedential opinion does not bind a later panel the way a published opinion does. Check the circuit’s local rule on weight. “Unpublished, therefore useless” is too crude; “unpublished, therefore binding nationwide” is false.

Restatements and out-of-jurisdiction cases

Two designed traps:

The Restatement trap. A partner says “Restatement (Second) of Torts section 402A is the law of products liability.” It is the law only where a high court has adopted that section, and only as modified. Until adoption, the section is secondary and persuasive . After adoption, cite the adopting case and later state cases. Do not treat the ALI as a legislature.

The out-of-jurisdiction trap. A careful New York Court of Appeals contract opinion is primary (it is case law) and persuasive only in an Arizona trial court. Similarity of statutes and a silent home jurisdiction make it more persuasive. Elegant writing, a famous caption, or a partner who “likes New York commercial law” does not make it mandatory.

A third trap sits next to those two: secondary sources that quote primary sources . Am. Jur. 2d may reprint a statute. ALR may quote a holding. The quotation does not convert the encyclopedia or the annotation into primary law. Pull the statute. Pull the case.

Worked office path

A partner asks for “the law” on whether a text message can accept an offer in the state of filing. Start with a secondary source — the state contracts treatise or an ALR annotation on electronic acceptance — to frame the issue and collect citations. Pull the state’s uniform electronic-transactions statute (primary; likely mandatory). Pull the state supreme court and intermediate appellate cases, and check which appellate district you are in. Run Shepard’s or KeyCite . If the state is silent, add a neighboring high-court case and the Restatement (Second) of Contracts section on acceptance, labeled as persuasive. Never write that Am. Jur. 2d “holds” a result, and never tell the client the Restatement “is the statute.”

Loading diagram... Primary vs secondary, then mandatory vs persuasive

Relative weight a trial court gives the source (5 = must follow)