Study guide
5.3 Constitutional Law and Case Law
NFPA Paralegal CORE Competency Exam PCCE
Track your progress as you read
Finished sections get a check mark.
1 Introduction & Exam Overview
1.1 Current Exam Facts 1.2 How to Use This Guide & Exam Strategy
2 The Paralegal Profession
2.1 Role of the Paralegal in the Legal Profession 2.2 National Paralegal Associations 2.3 Paralegal Regulation: Licensing vs Certification
3 Ethics: Code, UPL, Role & Advertising
3.1 NFPA Model Code and Rules of Professional Conduct 3.2 Unauthorized Practice of Law 3.3 Role Communication, Advertising & Solicitation
4 Ethics: Confidentiality, Privilege, Conflicts & Funds
4.1 Confidentiality 4.2 Attorney-Client Privilege and Work Product 4.3 Conflicts of Interest 4.4 Fees, Client Funds & Fiduciary Duty
5 The U.S. Legal System
5.1 Branches of Government, Terminology, Civil vs Criminal Law 5.2 Court Systems, Personnel & Court Rules 5.3 Constitutional Law and Case Law 5.4 Statutes, Codes & Administrative Law
6 Legal Research
6.1 Primary vs Secondary Sources; Mandatory vs Persuasive 6.2 Case Law Research: Reporters, Digests, Citators 6.3 Statutory and Administrative Research 6.4 CALR: Westlaw, Lexis, Shepard's, KeyCite & Free Sources 6.5 Secondary Sources as Finding Tools
7 Legal Writing, Analysis & Communication
7.1 Writing Basics, Captioning & Citation (Bluebook and ALWD) 7.2 Critical Analysis and the IRAC Method 7.3 Legal Writing Products 7.4 Communication, Interviewing, Fact-Finding & Correspondence 7.5 Client Interviewing and Evaluating Responses
8 Law Office Management & Legal Technology
8.1 Case Management, Databases, Litigation Support & Office Tools 8.2 Docketing and Calendar Control 8.3 Timekeeping, Billing, Retainers & Conflict Checks 8.4 E-Discovery, E-Filing, Word Processing & Spreadsheets 8.5 Client Files, Records Retention & File Ownership
9 Civil Litigation: Starting the Case
9.1 Civil Litigation Terminology & FRCP Overview 9.2 Jurisdiction, Venue & Filing 9.3 Parties and Third-Party Actions 9.4 Process Service
10 Civil Litigation: Discovery, Trial, Judgment & Appeal
10.1 Discovery Tools and Document Control 10.2 Federal Rules of Evidence 10.3 Pre-Trial and Trial Practice 10.4 Witnesses, Experts, Exhibits & Trial Presentations 10.5 Judgments, Enforcement & Appeals
11 Business Organizations
11.1 Entity Types and Terminology 11.2 Entity Formation and Dissolution 11.3 Foreign Corporation / Interstate Registration 11.4 Governance: Minutes, Resolutions, Annual Reports & Corporate Trail
12 Contracts
12.1 Elements of a Valid, Enforceable Contract 12.2 Contract Defenses and Discharge of Obligations 12.3 Contract Remedies 12.4 UCC Articles 1, 2, 3 & 9
13 Torts
13.1 Elements of Negligence 13.2 Intentional Torts and Strict Liability 13.3 Tort Defenses and Effects of Insurance 13.4 Tort Remedies: Damages and Injunctions
14 Criminal Law & Procedure
14.1 Elements, Sources & Classifications of Crimes 14.2 Defenses and Constitutional Rights 14.3 Search, Seizure & Suppression 14.4 Stages of Criminal Procedure and Evidence 14.5 Criminal Trial Practice and Appeals
15 Estates, Wills & Trusts
15.1 Wills: Validity, Testamentary Capacity & Revocation 15.2 Intestate Succession and Probate 15.3 Probate Administration 15.4 Trusts 15.5 Guardianship, Incapacity, Living Wills, Healthcare Proxies & Durable POA
16 Family Law
16.1 Divorce, Annulment, Separation, Property Division & Spousal Support 16.2 Custody, Visitation & Child Support 16.3 Child Support: Guidelines, Modification & Enforcement 16.4 Adoption, Paternity & Prenuptial/Postnuptial Agreements 16.5 Family Law Alternative Dispute Resolution
17 Real Estate
17.1 Ownership Types, Deeds & Types of Transfers 17.2 Title Search, Surveys, Easements, Covenants & Zoning 17.3 Financing, Mortgages, Liens & Foreclosure 17.4 Liens on Real Property: Types, Priority & Release 17.5 Landlord-Tenant, Rentals, Leases & Closings
5.3 Constitutional Law and Case Law
Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI
The U.S. Constitution is the supreme law of the land; under the Article VI Supremacy Clause a conflicting state statute or local ordinance yields to the Constitution, a federal statute, or a valid treaty.
Paralegal-facing Bill of Rights and Reconstruction clauses include due process (Fifth and Fourteenth), equal protection (Fourteenth), and the Fourth, Fifth, and Sixth Amendments in criminal cases — deep criminal procedure waits for Chapter 14.
Common law is judge-made law; stare decisis means later courts follow earlier holdings, with vertical precedent tighter than a court’s willingness to revisit its own cases.
The holding is the rule necessary to the result; dicta are the rest. A majority binds; a concurrence agrees with the result; a dissent disagrees.
A district court in the Ninth Circuit is bound by the U.S. Supreme Court and by published Ninth Circuit law, not by the Fifth Circuit or by a sister state’s high court on a federal question.
Last updated: August 2026
Constitutional law and case law are the two “unwritten-looking” sources that still bind a filing. A statute you can point to in the United States Code . A constitutional limit or a controlling opinion is just as much primary authority — and the PCCE will ask which one wins when they collide.
The Constitution as supreme law
The United States Constitution is the supreme written law of the national government. It creates the branches, enumerates (and limits) federal power, reserves a large residuum to the states and the people ( Tenth Amendment ), and then, through amendments, adds individual rights. Article VI, Clause 2 — the Supremacy Clause — says the Constitution, federal statutes made in pursuance of it, and treaties are “the supreme Law of the Land,” and that state judges are bound thereby, “any Thing in the Constitution or Laws of any State to the Contrary notwithstanding.”
Preemption is the working name for that clash. If a valid federal statute occupies a field or directly conflicts with a state statute, the state statute yields. A county ordinance cannot save the state statute. “Whichever law was passed more recently” is not the test. A state constitution can give more protection than the federal floor; it cannot authorize what the federal Constitution forbids or nullify a valid federal statute.
Judicial review, from Marbury v. Madison , is how courts enforce that hierarchy. A court does not “repeal” a statute the way a legislature does. It refuses to give the unconstitutional command effect in the case before it, and the opinion then binds lower courts as precedent.
Clauses that show up for paralegals
You do not need a constitutional-law seminar. You do need the clauses that appear in intake memos, suppression motions, civil-rights complaints, and employment files. Deep criminal procedure — warrant exceptions, Miranda applications, confrontation minutiae — is Chapter 14. Learn the labels now so those later items have a home.
Clause Where Paralegal-facing idea
Due process Fifth Amendment (federal government); Fourteenth Amendment (states) Fair procedures before deprivation of life, liberty, or property; a narrower “substantive” strand that some rights cannot be taken at all
Equal protection Fourteenth Amendment (states); the federal government is held to a similar standard through Fifth Amendment due process The government must justify classifications; race and national origin get strict scrutiny, sex intermediate scrutiny, ordinary economic lines usually rational basis
Fourth Amendment Searches and seizures Warrants, probable cause, and the exclusionary consequence in criminal cases
Fifth Amendment (criminal side) Grand jury (federal felonies), double jeopardy , self-incrimination , due process, takings The privilege against self-incrimination is why a criminal defendant need not testify
Sixth Amendment Criminal prosecutions Speedy and public trial, impartial jury, notice of the accusation, confrontation, compulsory process, assistance of counsel
- Seventh Amendment Federal civil juries Preserves a jury in federal suits at common law over twenty dollars
- Eighth Amendment Criminal No excessive bail or fines; no cruel and unusual punishment
Incorporation is the doctrine that most Bill of Rights guarantees now apply to the states through the Fourteenth Amendment’s Due Process Clause. On a national exam, do not say “the Fifth Amendment’s jury-civil guarantee applies in every state court” — the Seventh Amendment is the famous incorporation holdout. Do say that state actors must give due process and equal protection, and that a state criminal prosecution is hemmed in by the Fourth, the privilege against self-incrimination, and the Sixth.
42 U.S.C. § 1983 is the statute a civil plaintiff often uses to sue a state actor for a constitutional violation. A Bivens action is the narrower implied counterpart against some federal officers. Those captions are civil even though the underlying facts may be a search or an arrest.
Case law, common law, and stare decisis
Case law is law announced in judicial opinions. Common law is the subset (and the historical method) of judge-made rules — negligence elements, many contract doctrines, a large body of property law — that courts developed without a statute and still apply unless a statute displaces them. A statute can abolish or modify a common-law rule. A court cannot repeal a clear statute because it prefers the old common-law result.
Stare decisis (“to stand by things decided”) is the doctrine that a court follows earlier decisions. Vertical stare decisis is strict: a lower court follows a higher court in the same system. Horizontal stare decisis is a court following its own prior decisions; the Supreme Court can overrule itself, and circuit courts sometimes sit en banc to overrule a panel. Distinguishing a case on its facts is not the same as refusing to follow it.
Anatomy of an opinion
A published appellate opinion usually contains facts, a procedural history, one or more legal issues , reasoning , a holding , and a disposition (affirmed, reversed, vacated, remanded). Learn the inner labels the exam uses:
The holding is the legal rule necessary to the result on the facts before the court. That is what later courts are bound to follow.
Dicta (singular dictum ) are the rest — asides, hypotheticals, and commentary not necessary to the decision. Dicta can be persuasive. They are not the holding.
A majority opinion is joined by more than half of the judges who heard the case. It is the law of the case and, if published by a court that binds you, the law you cite as mandatory.
A plurality announces the judgment but no single reasoning commands a majority. Later courts have to read it carefully; sometimes only the result is clear.
A concurrence agrees with the result but offers different or additional reasons. It is not the majority rule unless later courts adopt it.
A dissent disagrees with the result. It binds no one. It is a roadmap for a future overruling or a certiorari petition.
Per curiam means “by the court” — an unsigned opinion, often short.
En banc means the full court (or a designated larger panel), used to resolve panel conflicts or questions of exceptional importance.
A published (precedential) circuit opinion binds the district courts in that circuit. Many unpublished or “memorandum” dispositions are not binding, though Federal Rule of Appellate Procedure 32.1 allows citation of unpublished federal opinions issued on or after January 1, 2007. Do not treat an unpublished out-of-circuit memorandum as if it overruled your circuit’s published law.
Binding versus persuasive authority
Mandatory (binding) authority is authority the court must follow. Persuasive authority is authority the court may follow if the reasoning is sound.
For a U.S. District Judge in the Central District of California deciding a federal question:
- Authority Effect
- U.S. Constitution; valid federal statute or rule Binding (the legal text itself)
- U.S. Supreme Court decision on point Binding
- Published Ninth Circuit decision on point Binding
- Published Fifth Circuit decision on the same federal issue Persuasive only
- Another Ninth Circuit district court Persuasive only (trial courts do not bind each other)
- A state high court on a federal issue Persuasive only
- A restatement, treatise, or law-review article Secondary / persuasive
Flip the system for a state trial judge on a state-law issue: that judge is bound by that state’s high court (and by the intermediate appellate court for that district, in states that treat those decisions as binding). A sister-state high court is persuasive, not mandatory. A federal district court deciding a state-law claim under diversity jurisdiction must follow the state’s highest court on that state’s law (the Erie idea). It does not get to prefer the Fifth Circuit’s guess about California law over the California Supreme Court.
That is the designed PCCE picture. A later, well-reasoned Fifth Circuit opinion does not overrule the Ninth Circuit nationwide. Only the Supreme Court (or the Ninth Circuit itself, often en banc) can free a California district judge from published Ninth Circuit law. When you shepardize or KeyCite in Chapter 6, you are looking for exactly this: is the case still good law in the court that binds us ?
Worked path. The research question is whether a particular federal limitations rule is tolled. The Ninth Circuit said yes in a 2018 published opinion. The Fifth Circuit said no in 2023. The California district judge follows the 2018 Ninth Circuit holding. The 2023 Fifth Circuit case goes in a “persuasive / contrary” paragraph, not in the “this court is bound” paragraph. If the only on-point discussion in the Ninth Circuit opinion is a footnote speculating about a hypothetical plaintiff, that footnote is dicta and the district judge must say so rather than pretend it is a holding.