Study guide
14.2 Non-Isothermal Reactor Design and Thermal Runaway
PE Chemical Exam
Track your progress as you read
Finished sections get a check mark.
1 Introduction & Exam Overview
About the PE Chemical Exam How to Use This Guide and the NCEES Handbook
2 Chapter 1: Material Balances & Flowsheet Calculations
1.1 Degree-of-Freedom Analysis & Process Flowsheet Accounting 1.2 Steady-State Material Balances (Reactive & Non-Reactive Systems) 1.3 Recycle, Bypass, and Purge Operations
3 Chapter 2: Energy Balances & Thermochemistry
2.1 Enthalpy Accounting, Sensible Heat, and Phase Changes 2.2 Heats of Reaction, Formation, and Adiabatic Flame Temperatures 2.3 Unsteady-State Mass and Energy Balances
4 Chapter 3: Fluid Statics & Incompressible Pipe Flow
3.1 Fluid Statics, Pressure Measurement, and Manometry 3.2 Incompressible Flow, Friction Factors, and the Moody Diagram 3.3 Minor Losses, Equivalent Length, and Piping Networks 3.4 Pumps, Compressors, and NPSH Calculations
5 Chapter 4: Advanced Fluid Dynamics & Compressible Flow
4.1 Compressible Gas Flow, Sonic Velocity, and Choked Flow 4.2 Flow Measurement Devices (Orifices, Venturis, Rotameters) 4.3 Multiphase Flow and Fluidization Principles 4.4 Mixing, Agitation, and Agitator Scale-Up
6 Chapter 5: Thermodynamic Laws & Fundamental Relations
5.1 First and Second Laws, Heat Engines, and Carnot Efficiency 5.2 Entropy, Availability, and Exergy Analysis 5.3 Fundamental Property Relations and Maxwell Equations
7 Chapter 6: Real Gases & Equations of State
6.1 Volumetric Properties and Compressibility Factor Charts 6.2 Cubic Equations of State (vdW, RK, SRK, and Peng-Robinson) 6.3 Residual Properties and Enthalpy/Entropy Departure Functions
8 Chapter 7: Phase & Chemical Reaction Equilibria
7.1 Pure Component Vapor Pressure and Phase Equilibria 7.2 Vapor-Liquid Equilibrium (VLE), Raoult's Law, and Activity Coefficients 7.3 Chemical Reaction Equilibria and Equilibrium Constant Calculation
9 Chapter 8: Heat Transfer Mechanisms & Conduction
8.1 Steady-State Conduction in Planar, Cylindrical, and Spherical Geometries 8.2 Convective Heat Transfer and Dimensionless Correlations 8.3 Thermal Radiation, Emissivity, and Surface Radiation Exchange
10 Chapter 9: Heat Exchanger Design & Phase Change
9.1 Shell-and-Tube Exchanger Design, TEMA Standards, and LMTD 9.2 Effectiveness-NTU Method and Exchanger Rating 9.3 Boiling Regimes, Condensation Phenomena, and Fouling Resistances
11 Chapter 10: Mass Transfer Fundamentals & Diffusion
10.1 Molecular Diffusion, Fick's Laws, and Equimolar Counterdiffusion 10.2 Convective Mass Transfer and Film Theories 10.3 Mass Transfer Dimensionless Numbers (Sherwood, Schmidt, Peclet)
12 Chapter 11: Distillation Operations
11.1 Vapor-Liquid Equilibrium and Relative Volatility in Distillation 11.2 McCabe-Thiele Method for Binary Distillation 11.3 Packed vs Tray Columns, Flooding, and Tray Hydraulics 11.4 Multicomponent Distillation Fundamentals and Key Components
13 Chapter 12: Rate-Controlled & Equilibrium Separations
12.1 Gas Absorption, Stripping, and the Kremser Equation 12.2 Liquid-Liquid Extraction and Ternary Phase Equilibria 12.3 Adsorption, Membrane Separations, and Drying Operations 12.4 Filtration, Crystallization, and Solid-Fluid Separations
14 Chapter 13: Chemical Kinetics & Ideal Isothermal Reactors
13.1 Reaction Rates, Rate Laws, and Order of Reaction 13.2 Temperature Dependence and the Arrhenius Equation 13.3 Batch Reactors and Continuous Stirred-Tank Reactors (CSTR) 13.4 Plug Flow Reactors (PFR) and Reactor Combinations
15 Chapter 14: Non-Ideal Flow, Non-Isothermal Reactors & Catalysis
14.1 Yield, Selectivity, and Multiple Reactions (Series and Parallel) 14.2 Non-Isothermal Reactor Design and Thermal Runaway 14.3 Heterogeneous Catalysis, Thiele Modulus, and RTD Models
16 Chapter 15: Physical & Transport Properties of Fluids
15.1 Fluid Density, Specific Gravity, and Viscosity Correlations 15.2 Thermal Conductivity and Specific Heat Capacities 15.3 Estimation Methods and Corresponding States Principles
17 Chapter 16: Materials of Construction & Corrosion
16.1 Mechanical Properties and Materials Selection in Chemical Plants 16.2 Corrosion Mechanisms, Materials Degradation, and Prevention
18 Chapter 17: Process Safety & Pressure Relief Systems
17.1 Hazard Identification Methodologies (HAZOP, FMEA, What-If) 17.2 Pressure Relief Valve (PRV) and Rupture Disk Sizing 17.3 Flammability, Explosions, and Toxic Dispersion Limits 17.4 Inerting, Purging, Discharge Location, and Containment
19 Chapter 18: Process Control & Engineering Economics
18.1 Process Dynamics and Feedback Control Loops 18.2 PID Controller Tuning and Loop Stability 18.3 Chemical Plant Capital Cost Estimation and Profitability Analysis 18.4 Field Instrumentation, Control Valves, Alarms, and Safety Instrumented Systems
20 Chapter 19: Process Design, Equipment Selection & Environmental Compliance
19.1 Process Flow Diagrams, P&IDs, Scale-Up, and Plant Siting 19.2 Process Equipment Selection, Sizing, and Optimization 19.3 Emissions Evaluation, Mitigation, and Remediation
21 Chapter 20: Plant Operation, Reliability & Continuous Improvement
20.1 Operating Procedures, Startup, and Shutdown 20.2 Mechanical Integrity, Reliability, and Failure Mechanisms 20.3 Debottlenecking, Optimization, and Troubleshooting
14.2 Non-Isothermal Reactor Design and Thermal Runaway
Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI
The steady-state macroscopic thermal energy balance couples reactor conversion and temperature: for PFRs, sum(F_i * C_p,i) * dT/dV = (-Delta_H_rxn) * (-r_A) - U * a * (T - T_a); for CSTRs, heat generation G(T) = (-Delta_H_rxn) * F_A0 * X must exactly balance heat removal R(T) = m_dot * C_p * (T - T_0) + U * A * (T - T_a).
The adiabatic temperature rise Delta_T_ad = (-Delta_H_rxn) * C_A0 / (rho * C_p) defines the maximum thermodynamic temperature increase achievable under zero heat removal (Q = 0, X = 1), establishing a vital baseline for process safety, runway potential, and pressure relief sizing.
Because reaction rate constants follow non-linear Arrhenius temperature dependence while heat removal is strictly linear, exothermic CSTRs can exhibit multiple steady states (up to three operating points: extinguished, unstable intermediate, and ignited).
According to the van Heerden stability criterion, a steady state in a CSTR is thermally stable if and only if the slope of the heat removal line exceeds the slope of the heat generation curve (dR/dT > dG/dT); when dG/dT > dR/dT, any upward temperature fluctuation causes thermal runaway.
In cooled tubular reactors, exothermic reactions exhibit extreme parametric sensitivity and form localized temperature hot spots along the tube axis where local heat release exceeds cooling capacity (G > R), requiring catalyst bed dilution, co-current coolant flow, or multi-stage injection.
Last updated: September 2026
14.2 Non-Isothermal Reactor Design and Thermal Runaway
While textbook problems frequently assume isothermal operation, commercial chemical reactors are seldom isothermal. Industrial reactions involve substantial heats of reaction ( Δ H r x n \Delta H_{rxn} Δ H r x n )—ranging from mildly exothermic polymerizations to highly exothermic oxidations, chlorinations, and nitrations exceeding − 200 kJ/mol -200 \text{ kJ/mol} − 200 kJ/mol . Because reaction rates increase exponentially with temperature according to the Arrhenius equation , heat released by reaction accelerates kinetics, releasing more heat and establishing a dangerous positive feedback loop.
Mastering non-isothermal reactor design on the NCEES PE Chemical Exam requires formulating coupled mass and energy balances, calculating the adiabatic temperature rise ( Δ T a d \Delta T_{ad} Δ T a d ), determining thermal stability and multiple steady states using the van Heerden criterion , and mitigating parametric sensitivity and hot spots in cooled tubular reactors.
1. General Steady-State Energy Balance for Flow Reactors
Applying the First Law of Thermodynamics to an open, steady-state continuous reactor with negligible kinetic and potential energy changes: Q ˙ − W ˙ s + ∑ i n F i , i n H i , i n − ∑ o u t F i , o u t H i , o u t = 0 \dot{Q} - \dot{W}_s + \sum_{in} F_{i,in} H_{i,in} - \sum_{out} F_{i,out} H_{i,out} = 0 Q ˙ − W ˙ s + in ∑ F i , in H i , in − o u t ∑ F i , o u t H i , o u t = 0
Neglecting shaft work ( W ˙ s ≈ 0 \dot{W}_s \approx 0 W ˙ s ≈ 0 ) and expressing enthalpies relative to an arbitrary reference temperature T R T_R T R where heat of reaction is Δ H r x n ( T R ) \Delta H_{rxn}(T_R) Δ H r x n ( T R ) : Q ˙ − F A 0 X Δ H r x n ( T R ) − ∑ i F i C p , i ( T − T 0 ) = 0 \dot{Q} - F_{A0} X \Delta H_{rxn}(T_R) - \sum_{i} F_i C_{p,i} (T - T_0) = 0 Q ˙ − F A 0 X Δ H r x n ( T R ) − i ∑ F i C p , i ( T − T 0 ) = 0
Where:
Q ˙ \dot{Q} Q ˙ = rate of heat transfer through cooling coils or jackets ( kW \text{kW} kW or Btu/hr \text{Btu/hr} Btu/hr ).
F A 0 F_{A0} F A 0 = molar feed rate of limiting reactant A A A ( mol/s \text{mol/s} mol/s or lbmol/hr \text{lbmol/hr} lbmol/hr ).
X X X = fractional conversion of reactant A A A .
Δ H r x n ( T R ) \Delta H_{rxn}(T_R) Δ H r x n ( T R ) = enthalpy of reaction at reference temperature T R T_R T R ( kJ/mol \text{kJ/mol} kJ/mol or Btu/lbmol \text{Btu/lbmol} Btu/lbmol ), defined such that Δ H r x n < 0 \Delta H_{rxn} < 0 Δ H r x n < 0 for exothermic reactions.
C p , i C_{p,i} C p , i = mean molar heat capacity of species i i i ( J/(mol ⋅ K) \text{J/(mol}\cdot\text{K)} J/(mol ⋅ K) or Btu/(lbmol ⋅ ∘ F) \text{Btu/(lbmol}\cdot^\circ\text{F)} Btu/(lbmol ⋅ ∘ F) ).
T 0 T_0 T 0 = reactor feed inlet temperature. COUPLED NON-ISOTHERMAL DYNAMICS
- +------------------------+
- | Mass Balance: X = f(T) |
- +------------------------+
- | ^
- Arrhenius k(T) | | Heat Generation
- increases rate v | Delta_H_rxn * r_A
- +------------------------+
- | Energy Balance: T = f(X)|
- +------------------------+
- 2. Adiabatic Reactor Operation & Adiabatic Temperature Rise
When a reactor is thermally insulated or operates with zero heat transfer ( Q ˙ = 0 \dot{Q} = 0 Q ˙ = 0 ), the operation is adiabatic . All energy released by exothermic reaction must heat the flowing process fluid.
Conversion-Temperature Relationship in Adiabatic Flow
Setting Q ˙ = 0 \dot{Q} = 0 Q ˙ = 0 and assuming constant average heat capacities: T = T 0 + [ ( − Δ H r x n ) F A 0 ∑ i F i 0 C p , i ] X = T 0 + [ ( − Δ H r x n ) C A 0 ρ C p ] X T = T_0 + \left[ \frac{(-\Delta H_{rxn}) F_{A0}}{\sum_i F_{i0} C_{p,i}} \right] X = T_0 + \left[ \frac{(-\Delta H_{rxn}) C_{A0}}{\rho C_p} \right] X T = T 0 + [ ∑ i F i 0 C p , i ( − Δ H r x n ) F A 0 ] X = T 0 + [ ρ C p ( − Δ H r x n ) C A 0 ] X
Where:
ρ \rho ρ = process fluid density ( kg/m 3 \text{kg/m}^3 kg/m 3 or lb/ft 3 \text{lb/ft}^3 lb/ft 3 ).
C p C_p C p = specific heat capacity of process mixture ( kJ/(kg ⋅ K) \text{kJ/(kg}\cdot\text{K)} kJ/(kg ⋅ K) or Btu/(lb ⋅ ∘ F) \text{Btu/(lb}\cdot^\circ\text{F)} Btu/(lb ⋅ ∘ F) ).
The Adiabatic Temperature Rise ( Δ T a d \Delta T_{ad} Δ T a d )
The adiabatic temperature rise ( Δ T a d \Delta T_{ad} Δ T a d ) represents the total theoretical temperature change if the limiting reactant were 100 % 100\% 100% converted ( X = 1.0 X = 1.0 X = 1.0 ) under complete adiabatic conditions: Δ T a d ≡ ( − Δ H r x n ) C A 0 ρ C p = ( − Δ H r x n ) y A 0 ∑ θ i C p , i \Delta T_{ad} \equiv \frac{(-\Delta H_{rxn}) C_{A0}}{\rho C_p} = \frac{(-\Delta H_{rxn}) y_{A0}}{\sum \theta_i C_{p,i}} Δ T a d ≡ ρ C p ( − Δ H r x n ) C A 0 = ∑ θ i C p , i ( − Δ H r x n ) y A 0
Thus, at any intermediate conversion X X X : T = T 0 + Δ T a d ⋅ X T = T_0 + \Delta T_{ad} \cdot X T = T 0 + Δ T a d ⋅ X
Note
Safety Significance of Δ T a d \Delta T_{ad} Δ T a d :
In chemical plant safety and HAZOP reviews , Δ T a d \Delta T_{ad} Δ T a d represents the worst-case runaway temperature if coolant flow is completely lost (cooling failure). If T 0 + Δ T a d T_0 + \Delta T_{ad} T 0 + Δ T a d exceeds the boiling point of the solvent or the decomposition threshold of reactants/products, the reactor vessel can violently overpressurize, mandating emergency relief sizing ( DIERS standards ).
Reversible Exothermic Reactions: The Thermodynamic Ceiling
For reversible exothermic reactions (such as ammonia synthesis or sulfur dioxide oxidation):
According to Le Chatelier's principle , increasing temperature shifts equilibrium toward reactants, reducing the maximum thermodynamic equilibrium conversion ( X e q X_{eq} X e q ).
However, kinetic rate constants increase with temperature.
In an adiabatic PFR, as conversion proceeds, temperature rises along the operating line T = T 0 + Δ T a d X T = T_0 + \Delta T_{ad} X T = T 0 + Δ T a d X . The reaction proceeds rapidly at first, but slows as it approaches the falling equilibrium conversion curve X e q ( T ) X_{eq}(T) X e q ( T ) , eventually reaching a complete thermodynamic standstill.
To achieve high conversions industrially, reactors employ multistage adiabatic beds with interstage cooling (heat exchangers or cold-shot gas quenching). Reversible Exothermic Reaction: Equilibrium Ceiling
- Conversion (X)
- ^
- 1.0| \ Equilibrium Curve X_eq(T)
- | \
- | \ / Operating Line: T = T_0 + Delta_T_ad * X
- | \ /
- | \ / <--- Equilibrium Pinch (Reaction Rate -> 0)
- | x
- | / \
- +----------------------------------------> Temperature (T)
- T_0
- 3. CSTR Heat Balances: Heat Generation G ( T ) G(T) G ( T ) vs. Heat Removal R ( T ) R(T) R ( T )
In a non-adiabatic continuous stirred-tank reactor equipped with an internal cooling coil or external heat transfer jacket, the steady-state thermal balance is conceptualized by plotting heat generated ( G ( T ) G(T) G ( T ) ) versus heat removed ( R ( T ) R(T) R ( T ) ) as functions of temperature.
Heat Generation Curve: G ( T ) G(T) G ( T )
The total rate of heat released by reaction is: G ( T ) = ( − Δ H r x n ) ⋅ F A 0 ⋅ X ( T ) G(T) = (-\Delta H_{rxn}) \cdot F_{A0} \cdot X(T) G ( T ) = ( − Δ H r x n ) ⋅ F A 0 ⋅ X ( T )
For an irreversible first-order liquid-phase reaction where X = τ k ( T ) 1 + τ k ( T ) X = \frac{\tau k(T)}{1 + \tau k(T)} X = 1 + τ k ( T ) τ k ( T ) and k ( T ) = A e − E / R T k(T) = A e^{-E / RT} k ( T ) = A e − E / RT : G ( T ) = ( − Δ H r x n ) F A 0 [ τ A e − E / R T 1 + τ A e − E / R T ] G(T) = (-\Delta H_{rxn}) F_{A0} \left[ \frac{\tau A e^{-E / RT}}{1 + \tau A e^{-E / RT}} \right] G ( T ) = ( − Δ H r x n ) F A 0 [ 1 + τ A e − E / RT τ A e − E / RT ]
Behavior of G ( T ) G(T) G ( T ) :
As T → 0 T \to 0 T → 0 : k ( T ) → 0 ⟹ X → 0 ⟹ G ( T ) → 0 k(T) \to 0 \implies X \to 0 \implies G(T) \to 0 k ( T ) → 0 ⟹ X → 0 ⟹ G ( T ) → 0 .
In intermediate temperature ranges: k ( T ) k(T) k ( T ) increases exponentially, causing G ( T ) G(T) G ( T ) to curve sharply upward.
As T → ∞ T \to \infty T → ∞ : k ( T ) → ∞ ⟹ X → 1.0 k(T) \to \infty \implies X \to 1.0 k ( T ) → ∞ ⟹ X → 1.0 . The reaction becomes feed-limited, and G ( T ) G(T) G ( T ) asymptotes to the maximum ceiling ( − Δ H r x n ) F A 0 (-\Delta H_{rxn}) F_{A0} ( − Δ H r x n ) F A 0 .
Therefore, G ( T ) G(T) G ( T ) is an S-shaped (sigmoidal) curve .
Heat Removal Line: R ( T ) R(T) R ( T )
Heat is removed from the CSTR via two mechanisms: sensible heating of the flowing fluid from T 0 T_0 T 0 to T T T , and heat transfer across jacket/coil area A c A_c A c to coolant at temperature T a T_a T a : R ( T ) = m ˙ C p ( T − T 0 ) + U A c ( T − T a ) R(T) = \dot{m} C_p (T - T_0) + U A_c (T - T_a) R ( T ) = m ˙ C p ( T − T 0 ) + U A c ( T − T a )
Factoring temperature T T T : R ( T ) = ( m ˙ C p + U A c ) T − ( m ˙ C p T 0 + U A c T a ) R(T) = (\dot{m} C_p + U A_c) T - (\dot{m} C_p T_0 + U A_c T_a) R ( T ) = ( m ˙ C p + U A c ) T − ( m ˙ C p T 0 + U A c T a )
Defining the combined heat removal parameter C R = m ˙ C p + U A c C_R = \dot{m} C_p + U A_c C R = m ˙ C p + U A c and the weighted coolant/feed temperature T c ′ T_c' T c ′ : T c ′ = m ˙ C p T 0 + U A c T a m ˙ C p + U A c T_c' = \frac{\dot{m} C_p T_0 + U A_c T_a}{\dot{m} C_p + U A_c} T c ′ = m ˙ C p + U A c m ˙ C p T 0 + U A c T a
Yields the linear relation: R ( T ) = ( m ˙ C p + U A c ) ( T − T c ′ ) R(T) = (\dot{m} C_p + U A_c) (T - T_c') R ( T ) = ( m ˙ C p + U A c ) ( T − T c ′ )
Behavior of R ( T ) R(T) R ( T ) :
R ( T ) R(T) R ( T ) is a strictly straight line with a constant positive slope equal to ( m ˙ C p + U A c ) (\dot{m} C_p + U A_c) ( m ˙ C p + U A c ) and an x-intercept at T c ′ T_c' T c ′ . Multiple Steady States: Heat Generation G(T) vs Removal R(T)
- Heat Rate
- ^
- | R(T) [Straight Line, Slope = m_dot*Cp + UA]
- | /
- | / /---\ G(T) [S-Shaped Sigmoidal]
- | / / \
- | / / ----- Ceiling: (-Delta_H)*F_A0
- | / /
- | (3)* / (3) = Ignited State (Stable)
- | / / (2) = Saddle Point (Unstable!)
- | / * (2) (1) = Extinguished State (Stable)
- | / /
- | (1)* /
- | / /
- +------------*---------------------------> Temperature (T)
- T_c'
- 4. Multiple Steady States and the van Heerden Stability Criterion
At steady state, heat generation must equal heat removal: G ( T ) = R ( T ) G(T) = R(T) G ( T ) = R ( T ) . Because G ( T ) G(T) G ( T ) is sigmoidal and R ( T ) R(T) R ( T ) is linear, they can intersect at one, two, or three distinct operating temperatures .
The Three Steady States
When three intersections exist ( T 1 < T 2 < T 3 T_1 < T_2 < T_3 T 1 < T 2 < T 3 ):
Point 1 ( T 1 T_1 T 1 , Extinguished State): Low temperature, low conversion ( X < 10 % X < 10\% X < 10% ). The reaction proceeds sluggishly, generating minimal heat.
Point 2 ( T 2 T_2 T 2 , Intermediate State): Moderate temperature, intermediate conversion. This state is physically unstable.
Point 3 ( T 3 T_3 T 3 , Ignited State): High temperature, high conversion ( X > 90 % X > 90\% X > 90% ). The reaction is vigorous and nearly complete.
The van Heerden Stability Criterion
To determine whether an operating steady state is stable against transient perturbations, consider an infinitesimal temperature disturbance d T dT d T :
If temperature increases to T + d T T + dT T + d T , the reactor is stable only if heat removal exceeds heat generation ( R > G R > G R > G ), cooling the reactor back to T T T .
If temperature decreases to T − d T T - dT T − d T , the reactor is stable only if heat generation exceeds heat removal ( G > R G > R G > R ), warming the reactor back to T T T .
Mathematically, stability requires that the slope of the removal line be steeper than the slope of the generation curve at the intersection point: d R d T > d G d T ( Stable Steady State ) \mathbf{\frac{dR}{dT} > \frac{dG}{dT}} \quad (\text{Stable Steady State}) dT dR > dT dG ( Stable Steady State ) d R d T < d G d T ( Unstable Steady State ) \frac{dR}{dT} < \frac{dG}{dT} \quad (\text{Unstable Steady State}) d T d R < d T d G ( Unstable Steady State )
Steady State Physical Condition van Heerden Slope Check Stability Classification
Point 1 ( T 1 T_1 T 1 ) Low T T T , low conversion d R d T > d G d T \frac{dR}{dT} > \frac{dG}{dT} d T d R > d T d G Stable (extinguished operating regime)
Point 2 ( T 2 T_2 T 2 ) Intermediate T T T d R d T < d G d T \frac{dR}{dT} < \frac{dG}{dT} d T d R < d T d G Unstable (saddle point; moves to T 1 T_1 T 1 or T 3 T_3 T 3 )
Point 3 ( T 3 T_3 T 3 ) High T T T , high conversion d R d T > d G d T \frac{dR}{dT} > \frac{dG}{dT} d T d R > d T d G Stable (ignited operating regime)
Ignition, Extinction, and Hysteresis
Shifting feed temperature T 0 T_0 T 0 or coolant temperature T a T_a T a translates the removal line R ( T ) R(T) R ( T ) horizontally:
Ignition: Starting at low temperature ( T 1 T_1 T 1 ), gradually raising T 0 T_0 T 0 shifts R ( T ) R(T) R ( T ) to the right until the line is tangent to the lower knee of G ( T ) G(T) G ( T ) . Any further heating causes a sudden, discontinuous jump from the low branch up to the ignited state T 3 T_3 T 3 ( ignition temperature , T i g n T_{ign} T i g n ).
Extinction: Starting from the ignited state ( T 3 T_3 T 3 ), cooling the reactor shifts R ( T ) R(T) R ( T ) to the left until it becomes tangent to the upper knee of G ( T ) G(T) G ( T ) . Further cooling causes an abrupt crash back to the extinguished state T 1 T_1 T 1 ( extinction temperature , T e x t T_{ext} T e x t ).
Because T e x t < T i g n T_{ext} < T_{ign} T e x t < T i g n , the system exhibits thermal hysteresis .
5. Plug Flow Reactors with Heat Exchange & Thermal Runaway
In a tubular plug flow reactor with active wall cooling (e.g., shell-and-tube packed reactor with molten salt or boiling water in the jacket): d T d V = ( − Δ H r x n ) ( − r A ) − U a ( T − T a ) ∑ F i C p , i \frac{dT}{dV} = \frac{(-\Delta H_{rxn}) (-r_A) - U a (T - T_a)}{\sum F_i C_{p,i}} d V d T = ∑ F i C p , i ( − Δ H r x n ) ( − r A ) − U a ( T − T a )
Where a a a is the heat transfer area per unit reactor volume ( a = 4 / D t u b e a = 4 / D_{tube} a = 4/ D t u b e for circular tubes).
Hot-Spot Formation along the Tube Length
At the reactor inlet ( z = 0 z = 0 z = 0 ), reactant concentration C A C_A C A is at its maximum, causing high reaction rate ( − r A ) (-r_A) ( − r A ) and intense heat release.
If heat generation initially exceeds heat removal capacity: ( − Δ H r x n ) ( − r A ) > U a ( T − T a ) (-\Delta H_{rxn})(-r_A) > U a (T - T_a) ( − Δ H r x n ) ( − r A ) > U a ( T − T a ) , the fluid temperature rises sharply ( d T / d V > 0 dT/dV > 0 d T / d V > 0 ).
As A A A is consumed along the tube, ( − r A ) (-r_A) ( − r A ) decreases while the driving force ( T − T a ) (T - T_a) ( T − T a ) increases.
Eventually, heat removal catches up to heat generation: ( − Δ H r x n ) ( − r A ) = U a ( T − T a ) (-\Delta H_{rxn})(-r_A) = U a (T - T_a) ( − Δ H r x n ) ( − r A ) = U a ( T − T a ) , where d T / d V = 0 dT/dV = 0 d T / d V = 0 . This peak temperature is the reactor hot spot ( T m a x T_{max} T ma x ).
Beyond the hot spot, heat removal dominates, and fluid temperature drops toward T a T_a T a . Temperature Profile in a Cooled Tubular Reactor: Hot Spot
- Temp (T)
- ^
- | Hot Spot (T_max, dT/dV = 0)
- | /\
- | / \
- | / \
- | T_0 / \------------------ Coolant Temp (T_a)
- | *----------/
- |
- +----------------------------------------> Tube Length (z)
- Parametric Sensitivity
A reactor exhibits parametric sensitivity when a minor perturbation in an operational parameter (such as a 2 ∘ C 2^\circ\text{C} 2 ∘ C rise in feed temperature T 0 T_0 T 0 , a 1 % 1\% 1% increase in feed concentration C A 0 C_{A0} C A 0 , or a small drop in coolant flow) causes a disproportionate, catastrophic spike in the hot-spot temperature (often Δ T h o t s p o t > 50 − 100 ∘ C \Delta T_{hotspot} > 50-100^\circ\text{C} Δ T h o t s p o t > 50 − 10 0 ∘ C ). When temperature spirals out of control, the condition is termed thermal runaway .
6. Summary Comparison Table: Reactor Thermal Regimes
Operating Regime Mathematical Energy Balance Temperature Profile / Behavior Primary Operational Hazard
Isothermal Q ˙ = F A 0 X Δ H r x n \dot{Q} = F_{A0} X \Delta H_{rxn} Q ˙ = F A 0 X Δ H r x n T = constant T = \text{constant} T = constant along reactor Over-optimistic sizing; difficult to achieve at large scale
Adiabatic Flow T = T 0 + Δ T a d ⋅ X T = T_0 + \Delta T_{ad} \cdot X T = T 0 + Δ T a d ⋅ X Monotonic rise (exothermic) or drop (endothermic) Uncontrolled temperature if runaway conversion occurs
CSTR with Heat Exchange G ( T ) = R ( T ) G(T) = R(T) G ( T ) = R ( T ) ; d R / d T > d G / d T dR/dT > dG/dT d R / d T > d G / d T Uniform tank temperature; possible multiple steady states Ignition to high-temperature state; loss of cooling
PFR with Wall Cooling d T d V = ( − Δ H ) r A − U a ( T − T a ) ∑ F C p \frac{dT}{dV} = \frac{(-\Delta H) r_A - U a (T - T_a)}{\sum F C_p} d V d T = ∑ F C p ( − Δ H ) r A − U a ( T − T a ) Forms localized hot spot ( d T / d V = 0 dT/dV = 0 d T / d V = 0 ) along tube length Extreme parametric sensitivity; catalyst sintering/deactivation
- 7. Comprehensive Step-by-Step Worked Numerical Example: CSTR Thermal Stability
- Problem Statement
An exothermic liquid-phase isomerization reaction A → B A \to B A → B takes place in an ideal 1.50 m 3 1.50 \text{ m}^3 1.50 m 3 CSTR equipped with an internal cooling coil. The reaction is first-order in A A A with rate constant: k ( T ) = 2.00 × 10 9 exp ( − 6 , 500 T ) min − 1 ( T in Kelvin ) k(T) = 2.00 \times 10^9 \exp\left( -\frac{6,500}{T} \right) \text{ min}^{-1} \quad (T \text{ in Kelvin}) k ( T ) = 2.00 × 1 0 9 exp ( − T 6 , 500 ) min − 1 ( T in Kelvin )
Process Data:
Feed flow rate: v 0 = 0.050 m 3 / min v_0 = 0.050 \text{ m}^3/\text{min} v 0 = 0.050 m 3 / min ( 50.0 L/min 50.0 \text{ L/min} 50.0 L/min )
Inlet reactant concentration: C A 0 = 2.00 kmol/m 3 C_{A0} = 2.00 \text{ kmol/m}^3 C A 0 = 2.00 kmol/m 3 ( 2 , 000 mol/m 3 2,000 \text{ mol/m}^3 2 , 000 mol/m 3 )
Molar feed rate: F A 0 = v 0 C A 0 = 0.050 × 2.00 = 0.100 kmol/min = 1.667 mol/s F_{A0} = v_0 C_{A0} = 0.050 \times 2.00 = 0.100 \text{ kmol/min} = 1.667 \text{ mol/s} F A 0 = v 0 C A 0 = 0.050 × 2.00 = 0.100 kmol/min = 1.667 mol/s
Heat of reaction: Δ H r x n = − 90 , 000 kJ/kmol \Delta H_{rxn} = -90,000 \text{ kJ/kmol} Δ H r x n = − 90 , 000 kJ/kmol ( − 90.0 kJ/mol -90.0 \text{ kJ/mol} − 90.0 kJ/mol )
- Fluid density: ρ = 1 , 000 kg/m 3 \rho = 1,000 \text{ kg/m}^3 ρ = 1 , 000 kg/m 3
- Fluid heat capacity: C p = 4.00 kJ/(kg ⋅ K) C_p = 4.00 \text{ kJ/(kg}\cdot\text{K)} C p = 4.00 kJ/(kg ⋅ K)
Volumetric heat capacity: ρ C p = 4 , 000 kJ/(m 3 ⋅ K) \rho C_p = 4,000 \text{ kJ/(m}^3\cdot\text{K)} ρ C p = 4 , 000 kJ/(m 3 ⋅ K)
Total fluid heat capacity rate: m ˙ C p = v 0 ρ C p = 0.050 × 4 , 000 = 200.0 kJ/(min ⋅ K) \dot{m} C_p = v_0 \rho C_p = 0.050 \times 4,000 = 200.0 \text{ kJ/(min}\cdot\text{K)} m ˙ C p = v 0 ρ C p = 0.050 × 4 , 000 = 200.0 kJ/(min ⋅ K)
Feed temperature: T 0 = 300.0 K T_0 = 300.0 \text{ K} T 0 = 300.0 K
Cooling coil overall heat transfer capacity: U A c = 300.0 kJ/(min ⋅ K) U A_c = 300.0 \text{ kJ/(min}\cdot\text{K)} U A c = 300.0 kJ/(min ⋅ K)
Coolant temperature: T a = 285.0 K T_a = 285.0 \text{ K} T a = 285.0 K
Calculate:
The adiabatic temperature rise Δ T a d \Delta T_{ad} Δ T a d .
The heat removal slope and zero-removal intercept temperature T c ′ T_c' T c ′ .
The heat removal rate R ( T ) R(T) R ( T ) and heat generation rate G ( T ) G(T) G ( T ) at candidate operating temperatures T = 310.0 K T = 310.0 \text{ K} T = 310.0 K , T = 330.0 K T = 330.0 \text{ K} T = 330.0 K , and T = 360.0 K T = 360.0 \text{ K} T = 360.0 K .
Identify whether a steady state exists near T = 330.0 K T = 330.0 \text{ K} T = 330.0 K , and verify its thermal stability using the van Heerden criterion.
Step 1: Adiabatic Temperature Rise Δ T a d = ( − Δ H r x n ) C A 0 ρ C p = 90 , 000 kJ/kmol × 2.00 kmol/m 3 4 , 000 kJ/(m 3 ⋅ K) = 180 , 000 4 , 000 = 45.0 K \Delta T_{ad} = \frac{(-\Delta H_{rxn}) C_{A0}}{\rho C_p} = \frac{90,000 \text{ kJ/kmol} \times 2.00 \text{ kmol/m}^3}{4,000 \text{ kJ/(m}^3\cdot\text{K)}} = \frac{180,000}{4,000} = \mathbf{45.0 \text{ K}} Δ T a d = ρ C p ( − Δ H r x n ) C A 0 = 4 , 000 kJ/(m 3 ⋅ K) 90 , 000 kJ/kmol × 2.00 kmol/m 3 = 4 , 000 180 , 000 = 45.0 K
If cooling completely fails and the reactor reaches full conversion ( X = 1.0 X = 1.0 X = 1.0 ), the maximum adiabatic temperature is T m a x , a d = T 0 + Δ T a d = 300.0 + 45.0 = 345.0 K T_{max, ad} = T_0 + \Delta T_{ad} = 300.0 + 45.0 = \mathbf{345.0 \text{ K}} T ma x , a d = T 0 + Δ T a d = 300.0 + 45.0 = 345.0 K .
Step 2: Heat Removal Function R ( T ) R(T) R ( T )
The total slope of the removal line is: Slope = m ˙ C p + U A c = 200.0 + 300.0 = 500.0 kJ/(min ⋅ K) \text{Slope} = \dot{m} C_p + U A_c = 200.0 + 300.0 = \mathbf{500.0 \text{ kJ/(min}\cdot\text{K)}} Slope = m ˙ C p + U A c = 200.0 + 300.0 = 500.0 kJ/(min ⋅ K)
The effective weighted coolant/feed temperature T c ′ T_c' T c ′ is: T c ′ = m ˙ C p T 0 + U A c T a m ˙ C p + U A c = ( 200.0 × 300.0 ) + ( 300.0 × 285.0 ) 500.0 = 60 , 000 + 85 , 500 500.0 = 145 , 500 500.0 = 291.0 K T_c' = \frac{\dot{m} C_p T_0 + U A_c T_a}{\dot{m} C_p + U A_c} = \frac{(200.0 \times 300.0) + (300.0 \times 285.0)}{500.0} = \frac{60,000 + 85,500}{500.0} = \frac{145,500}{500.0} = \mathbf{291.0 \text{ K}} T c ′ = m ˙ C p + U A c m ˙ C p T 0 + U A c T a = 500.0 ( 200.0 × 300.0 ) + ( 300.0 × 285.0 ) = 500.0 60 , 000 + 85 , 500 = 500.0 145 , 500 = 291.0 K
Thus, the heat removal equation is: R ( T ) = 500.0 ⋅ ( T − 291.0 ) kJ/min R(T) = 500.0 \cdot (T - 291.0) \text{ kJ/min} R ( T ) = 500.0 ⋅ ( T − 291.0 ) kJ/min
Step 3: Space Time and Heat Generation Function G ( T ) G(T) G ( T )
The reactor space time is: τ = V v 0 = 1.50 m 3 0.050 m 3 / min = 30.0 min \tau = \frac{V}{v_0} = \frac{1.50 \text{ m}^3}{0.050 \text{ m}^3/\text{min}} = \mathbf{30.0 \text{ min}} τ = v 0 V = 0.050 m 3 / min 1.50 m 3 = 30.0 min
The maximum possible heat generation rate at complete conversion ( X = 1.0 X = 1.0 X = 1.0 ) is: G m a x = ( − Δ H r x n ) F A 0 = 90 , 000 kJ/kmol × 0.100 kmol/min = 9 , 000.0 kJ/min G_{max} = (-\Delta H_{rxn}) F_{A0} = 90,000 \text{ kJ/kmol} \times 0.100 \text{ kmol/min} = \mathbf{9,000.0 \text{ kJ/min}} G ma x = ( − Δ H r x n ) F A 0 = 90 , 000 kJ/kmol × 0.100 kmol/min = 9 , 000.0 kJ/min
At any temperature T T T : k ( T ) = 2.00 × 10 9 exp ( − 6 , 500 T ) k(T) = 2.00 \times 10^9 \exp\left( -\frac{6,500}{T} \right) k ( T ) = 2.00 × 1 0 9 exp ( − T 6 , 500 ) X ( T ) = τ k ( T ) 1 + τ k ( T ) = 30.0 k ( T ) 1 + 30.0 k ( T ) X(T) = \frac{\tau k(T)}{1 + \tau k(T)} = \frac{30.0 k(T)}{1 + 30.0 k(T)} X ( T ) = 1 + τ k ( T ) τ k ( T ) = 1 + 30.0 k ( T ) 30.0 k ( T ) G ( T ) = 9 , 000.0 ⋅ X ( T ) kJ/min G(T) = 9,000.0 \cdot X(T) \text{ kJ/min} G ( T ) = 9 , 000.0 ⋅ X ( T ) kJ/min
Now, evaluate k ( T ) k(T) k ( T ) , X ( T ) X(T) X ( T ) , G ( T ) G(T) G ( T ) , and R ( T ) R(T) R ( T ) across the candidate temperatures:
At T = 310.0 K T = 310.0 \text{ K} T = 310.0 K :
6 , 500 310.0 = 20.9677 ⟹ exp ( − 20.9677 ) = 7.831 × 10 − 10 \frac{6,500}{310.0} = 20.9677 \implies \exp(-20.9677) = 7.831 \times 10^{-10} 310.0 6 , 500 = 20.9677 ⟹ exp ( − 20.9677 ) = 7.831 × 1 0 − 10
k ( 310 ) = 2.00 × 10 9 × 7.831 × 10 − 10 = 1.566 min − 1 k(310) = 2.00 \times 10^9 \times 7.831 \times 10^{-10} = 1.566 \text{ min}^{-1} k ( 310 ) = 2.00 × 1 0 9 × 7.831 × 1 0 − 10 = 1.566 min − 1
τ k = 30.0 × 1.566 = 46.98 \tau k = 30.0 \times 1.566 = 46.98 τ k = 30.0 × 1.566 = 46.98
X = 46.98 1 + 46.98 = 46.98 47.98 = 0.9792 X = \frac{46.98}{1 + 46.98} = \frac{46.98}{47.98} = 0.9792 X = 1 + 46.98 46.98 = 47.98 46.98 = 0.9792
G ( 310 ) = 9 , 000.0 × 0.9792 = 8 , 812.8 kJ/min G(310) = 9,000.0 \times 0.9792 = 8,812.8 \text{ kJ/min} G ( 310 ) = 9 , 000.0 × 0.9792 = 8 , 812.8 kJ/min
R ( 310 ) = 500.0 × ( 310.0 − 291.0 ) = 500.0 × 19.0 = 9 , 500.0 kJ/min R(310) = 500.0 \times (310.0 - 291.0) = 500.0 \times 19.0 = 9,500.0 \text{ kJ/min} R ( 310 ) = 500.0 × ( 310.0 − 291.0 ) = 500.0 × 19.0 = 9 , 500.0 kJ/min
Here R > G R > G R > G (net cooling of − 687.2 kJ/min -687.2 \text{ kJ/min} − 687.2 kJ/min ).
At T = 330.0 K T = 330.0 \text{ K} T = 330.0 K :
6 , 500 330.0 = 19.6970 ⟹ exp ( − 19.6970 ) = 2.7834 × 10 − 9 \frac{6,500}{330.0} = 19.6970 \implies \exp(-19.6970) = 2.7834 \times 10^{-9} 330.0 6 , 500 = 19.6970 ⟹ exp ( − 19.6970 ) = 2.7834 × 1 0 − 9
k ( 330 ) = 2.00 × 10 9 × 2.7834 × 10 − 9 = 5.567 min − 1 k(330) = 2.00 \times 10^9 \times 2.7834 \times 10^{-9} = 5.567 \text{ min}^{-1} k ( 330 ) = 2.00 × 1 0 9 × 2.7834 × 1 0 − 9 = 5.567 min − 1
- τ k = 30.0 × 5.567 = 167.0 \tau k = 30.0 \times 5.567 = 167.0 τ k = 30.0 × 5.567 = 167.0
- X = 167.0 1 + 167.0 = 0.9940 X = \frac{167.0}{1 + 167.0} = 0.9940 X = 1 + 167.0 167.0 = 0.9940
G ( 330 ) = 9 , 000.0 × 0.9940 = 8 , 946.0 kJ/min G(330) = 9,000.0 \times 0.9940 = 8,946.0 \text{ kJ/min} G ( 330 ) = 9 , 000.0 × 0.9940 = 8 , 946.0 kJ/min
R ( 330 ) = 500.0 × ( 330.0 − 291.0 ) = 500.0 × 39.0 = 19 , 500.0 kJ/min R(330) = 500.0 \times (330.0 - 291.0) = 500.0 \times 39.0 = 19,500.0 \text{ kJ/min} R ( 330 ) = 500.0 × ( 330.0 − 291.0 ) = 500.0 × 39.0 = 19 , 500.0 kJ/min
At high temperature, heat removal vastly exceeds heat generation ( R ≫ G R \gg G R ≫ G ).
Let us find the precise intersection where G ( T ) = R ( T ) G(T) = R(T) G ( T ) = R ( T ) :
At T = 308.6 K T = 308.6 \text{ K} T = 308.6 K :
R ( 308.6 ) = 500.0 × ( 308.6 − 291.0 ) = 500.0 × 17.6 = 8 , 800.0 kJ/min R(308.6) = 500.0 \times (308.6 - 291.0) = 500.0 \times 17.6 = 8,800.0 \text{ kJ/min} R ( 308.6 ) = 500.0 × ( 308.6 − 291.0 ) = 500.0 × 17.6 = 8 , 800.0 kJ/min
At T = 308.6 K T = 308.6 \text{ K} T = 308.6 K , 6500 / 308.6 = 21.06286 ⟹ k = 1.424 min − 1 ⟹ τ k = 42.71 ⟹ X = 0.9771 ⟹ G = 9 , 000 × 0.9771 = 8 , 794 kJ/min ≈ R 6500/308.6 = 21.06286 \implies k = 1.424 \text{ min}^{-1} \implies \tau k = 42.71 \implies X = 0.9771 \implies G = 9,000 \times 0.9771 = 8,794 \text{ kJ/min} \approx R 6500/308.6 = 21.06286 ⟹ k = 1.424 min − 1 ⟹ τ k = 42.71 ⟹ X = 0.9771 ⟹ G = 9 , 000 × 0.9771 = 8 , 794 kJ/min ≈ R .
Step 4: van Heerden Stability Check
At the operating steady state ( T ≈ 308.6 K T \approx 308.6 \text{ K} T ≈ 308.6 K ):
The slope of the heat removal line is constant: d R d T = 500.0 kJ/(min ⋅ K) \frac{dR}{dT} = \mathbf{500.0 \text{ kJ/(min}\cdot\text{K)}} d T d R = 500.0 kJ/(min ⋅ K) .
To evaluate d G d T \frac{dG}{dT} d T d G : d G d T = G m a x d X d T = G m a x τ d k d T ( 1 + τ k ) 2 = G m a x τ k ( E R T 2 ) ( 1 + τ k ) 2 \frac{dG}{dT} = G_{max} \frac{dX}{dT} = G_{max} \frac{\tau \frac{dk}{dT}}{(1 + \tau k)^2} = G_{max} \frac{\tau k \left( \frac{E}{R T^2} \right)}{(1 + \tau k)^2} d T d G = G ma x d T d X = G ma x ( 1 + τ k ) 2 τ d T d k = G ma x ( 1 + τ k ) 2 τ k ( R T 2 E ) At T = 308.6 K T = 308.6 \text{ K} T = 308.6 K , E R T 2 = 6 , 500 ( 308.6 ) 2 = 6 , 500 95 , 234 = 0.06825 K − 1 \frac{E}{R T^2} = \frac{6,500}{(308.6)^2} = \frac{6,500}{95,234} = 0.06825 \text{ K}^{-1} R T 2 E = ( 308.6 ) 2 6 , 500 = 95 , 234 6 , 500 = 0.06825 K − 1 .
With τ k = 42.71 \tau k = 42.71 τ k = 42.71 : d G d T = 9 , 000.0 × 42.71 × 0.06825 ( 1 + 42.71 ) 2 = 9 , 000.0 × 2.915 ( 43.71 ) 2 = 9 , 000.0 × 2.915 1 , 910.6 = 9 , 000.0 × 0.001526 = 13.73 kJ/(min ⋅ K) \frac{dG}{dT} = 9,000.0 \times \frac{42.71 \times 0.06825}{(1 + 42.71)^2} = 9,000.0 \times \frac{2.915}{(43.71)^2} = 9,000.0 \times \frac{2.915}{1,910.6} = 9,000.0 \times 0.001526 = \mathbf{13.73 \text{ kJ/(min}\cdot\text{K)}} d T d G = 9 , 000.0 × ( 1 + 42.71 ) 2 42.71 × 0.06825 = 9 , 000.0 × ( 43.71 ) 2 2.915 = 9 , 000.0 × 1 , 910.6 2.915 = 9 , 000.0 × 0.001526 = 13.73 kJ/(min ⋅ K)
Comparing slopes: d R d T = 500.0 ≫ d G d T = 13.73 kJ/(min ⋅ K) \frac{dR}{dT} = 500.0 \gg \frac{dG}{dT} = 13.73 \text{ kJ/(min}\cdot\text{K)} d T d R = 500.0 ≫ d T d G = 13.73 kJ/(min ⋅ K)
Because d R d T > d G d T \frac{dR}{dT} > \frac{dG}{dT} d T d R > d T d G , the steady state is exceptionally stable . Any minor temperature surge creates strong net cooling, driving the reactor back to equilibrium.
- 8. Critical PE Exam Traps & Pitfalls
- Trap 1: Forgetting Solvent and Inert Heat Capacities in Δ T a d \Delta T_{ad} Δ T a d
In dilute liquid-phase reactions, the heat capacity in the denominator of Δ T a d = ( − Δ H r x n ) C A 0 / ( ρ C p ) \Delta T_{ad} = (-\Delta H_{rxn}) C_{A0} / (\rho C_p) Δ T a d = ( − Δ H r x n ) C A 0 / ( ρ C p ) is that of the entire mixture (essentially the solvent). A classic exam blunder is calculating ρ C p \rho C_p ρ C p using only the tiny molar mass and heat capacity of solute A A A , yielding absurdly inflated temperature rises in the thousands of degrees.
Trap 2: Assuming the Middle Steady State is Usable
When an exothermic CSTR exhibits three steady states ( T 1 < T 2 < T 3 T_1 < T_2 < T_3 T 1 < T 2 < T 3 ), candidate engineers often select T 2 T_2 T 2 because it provides a moderate conversion without extreme temperatures. However, T 2 T_2 T 2 is fundamentally unstable ( d G / d T > d R / d T dG/dT > dR/dT d G / d T > d R / d T ). A controller cannot hold a reactor at an open-loop unstable saddle point without dynamic closed-loop feedback.
Trap 3: Inverting the van Heerden Criterion
Always remember: Cooling must respond faster than heating . Therefore, d R d T > d G d T \frac{dR}{dT} > \frac{dG}{dT} d T d R > d T d G is required for stability. If the generation curve is steeper than the cooling line, a positive perturbation Δ T \Delta T Δ T generates more incremental heat than the jacket can remove, causing runaway.
Trap 4: Neglecting Coolant Temperature Changes along Jackets
In tubular reactors, assuming the coolant temperature T a T_a T a is constant is only valid for boiling water jackets (where phase change fixes T T T ). For single-phase liquid coolants (like cooling water or heat transfer oils), the coolant warms up along the reactor, which degrades heat transfer driving force ( T − T a ) (T - T_a) ( T − T a ) and can turn a stable reactor into a runaway hot spot.