Study guide

12.1 Gas Absorption, Stripping, and the Kremser Equation

PE Chemical Exam

Track your progress as you read

Finished sections get a check mark.

1 Introduction & Exam Overview

About the PE Chemical Exam How to Use This Guide and the NCEES Handbook

2 Chapter 1: Material Balances & Flowsheet Calculations

1.1 Degree-of-Freedom Analysis & Process Flowsheet Accounting 1.2 Steady-State Material Balances (Reactive & Non-Reactive Systems) 1.3 Recycle, Bypass, and Purge Operations

3 Chapter 2: Energy Balances & Thermochemistry

2.1 Enthalpy Accounting, Sensible Heat, and Phase Changes 2.2 Heats of Reaction, Formation, and Adiabatic Flame Temperatures 2.3 Unsteady-State Mass and Energy Balances

4 Chapter 3: Fluid Statics & Incompressible Pipe Flow

3.1 Fluid Statics, Pressure Measurement, and Manometry 3.2 Incompressible Flow, Friction Factors, and the Moody Diagram 3.3 Minor Losses, Equivalent Length, and Piping Networks 3.4 Pumps, Compressors, and NPSH Calculations

5 Chapter 4: Advanced Fluid Dynamics & Compressible Flow

4.1 Compressible Gas Flow, Sonic Velocity, and Choked Flow 4.2 Flow Measurement Devices (Orifices, Venturis, Rotameters) 4.3 Multiphase Flow and Fluidization Principles 4.4 Mixing, Agitation, and Agitator Scale-Up

6 Chapter 5: Thermodynamic Laws & Fundamental Relations

5.1 First and Second Laws, Heat Engines, and Carnot Efficiency 5.2 Entropy, Availability, and Exergy Analysis 5.3 Fundamental Property Relations and Maxwell Equations

7 Chapter 6: Real Gases & Equations of State

6.1 Volumetric Properties and Compressibility Factor Charts 6.2 Cubic Equations of State (vdW, RK, SRK, and Peng-Robinson) 6.3 Residual Properties and Enthalpy/Entropy Departure Functions

8 Chapter 7: Phase & Chemical Reaction Equilibria

7.1 Pure Component Vapor Pressure and Phase Equilibria 7.2 Vapor-Liquid Equilibrium (VLE), Raoult's Law, and Activity Coefficients 7.3 Chemical Reaction Equilibria and Equilibrium Constant Calculation

9 Chapter 8: Heat Transfer Mechanisms & Conduction

8.1 Steady-State Conduction in Planar, Cylindrical, and Spherical Geometries 8.2 Convective Heat Transfer and Dimensionless Correlations 8.3 Thermal Radiation, Emissivity, and Surface Radiation Exchange

10 Chapter 9: Heat Exchanger Design & Phase Change

9.1 Shell-and-Tube Exchanger Design, TEMA Standards, and LMTD 9.2 Effectiveness-NTU Method and Exchanger Rating 9.3 Boiling Regimes, Condensation Phenomena, and Fouling Resistances

11 Chapter 10: Mass Transfer Fundamentals & Diffusion

10.1 Molecular Diffusion, Fick's Laws, and Equimolar Counterdiffusion 10.2 Convective Mass Transfer and Film Theories 10.3 Mass Transfer Dimensionless Numbers (Sherwood, Schmidt, Peclet)

12 Chapter 11: Distillation Operations

11.1 Vapor-Liquid Equilibrium and Relative Volatility in Distillation 11.2 McCabe-Thiele Method for Binary Distillation 11.3 Packed vs Tray Columns, Flooding, and Tray Hydraulics 11.4 Multicomponent Distillation Fundamentals and Key Components

13 Chapter 12: Rate-Controlled & Equilibrium Separations

12.1 Gas Absorption, Stripping, and the Kremser Equation 12.2 Liquid-Liquid Extraction and Ternary Phase Equilibria 12.3 Adsorption, Membrane Separations, and Drying Operations 12.4 Filtration, Crystallization, and Solid-Fluid Separations

14 Chapter 13: Chemical Kinetics & Ideal Isothermal Reactors

13.1 Reaction Rates, Rate Laws, and Order of Reaction 13.2 Temperature Dependence and the Arrhenius Equation 13.3 Batch Reactors and Continuous Stirred-Tank Reactors (CSTR) 13.4 Plug Flow Reactors (PFR) and Reactor Combinations

15 Chapter 14: Non-Ideal Flow, Non-Isothermal Reactors & Catalysis

14.1 Yield, Selectivity, and Multiple Reactions (Series and Parallel) 14.2 Non-Isothermal Reactor Design and Thermal Runaway 14.3 Heterogeneous Catalysis, Thiele Modulus, and RTD Models

16 Chapter 15: Physical & Transport Properties of Fluids

15.1 Fluid Density, Specific Gravity, and Viscosity Correlations 15.2 Thermal Conductivity and Specific Heat Capacities 15.3 Estimation Methods and Corresponding States Principles

17 Chapter 16: Materials of Construction & Corrosion

16.1 Mechanical Properties and Materials Selection in Chemical Plants 16.2 Corrosion Mechanisms, Materials Degradation, and Prevention

18 Chapter 17: Process Safety & Pressure Relief Systems

17.1 Hazard Identification Methodologies (HAZOP, FMEA, What-If) 17.2 Pressure Relief Valve (PRV) and Rupture Disk Sizing 17.3 Flammability, Explosions, and Toxic Dispersion Limits 17.4 Inerting, Purging, Discharge Location, and Containment

19 Chapter 18: Process Control & Engineering Economics

18.1 Process Dynamics and Feedback Control Loops 18.2 PID Controller Tuning and Loop Stability 18.3 Chemical Plant Capital Cost Estimation and Profitability Analysis 18.4 Field Instrumentation, Control Valves, Alarms, and Safety Instrumented Systems

20 Chapter 19: Process Design, Equipment Selection & Environmental Compliance

19.1 Process Flow Diagrams, P&IDs, Scale-Up, and Plant Siting 19.2 Process Equipment Selection, Sizing, and Optimization 19.3 Emissions Evaluation, Mitigation, and Remediation

21 Chapter 20: Plant Operation, Reliability & Continuous Improvement

20.1 Operating Procedures, Startup, and Shutdown 20.2 Mechanical Integrity, Reliability, and Failure Mechanisms 20.3 Debottlenecking, Optimization, and Troubleshooting

12.1 Gas Absorption, Stripping, and the Kremser Equation

Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI

Absorption factor A = L / (m * G) determines column feasibility: when A > 1, the operating line slope (L/G) exceeds the equilibrium slope m, allowing high fractional recovery with finite stages; when A <= 1, an equilibrium pinch at the column bottom prevents complete recovery regardless of bed height.

The Kremser-Brown-Souders equation provides the exact analytical stage count for dilute, isothermal systems with linear equilibria (y = m * x): N = ln([(y_in - m * x_in)/(y_out - m * x_in)] * (1 - 1/A) + 1/A) / ln(A).

Continuous packed column height is determined by Z = H_OG * N_OG, where H_OG = G / (K_y * a) represents the overall height of a transfer unit and N_OG = (y_in - y_out) / Delta_y_lm represents the number of transfer units.

Overall resistance to mass transfer combines gas- and liquid-film resistances via 1/K_y = 1/k_y + m/k_x, which translates in transfer unit heights to H_OG = H_G + (m * G / L) * H_L = H_G + H_L / A.

For concentrated absorption systems (> 5-10 mol% solute), solute-free mole ratios (Y = y/(1-y), X = x/(1-x)) and inert carrier rates (G_s, L_s) must replace mole fractions to maintain a linear operating line: Y = (L_s / G_s) * (X - X_in) + Y_out.

Last updated: September 2026

12.1 Gas Absorption, Stripping, and the Kremser Equation

In chemical manufacturing, environmental remediation, and refining, gas absorption (scrubbing) transfers one or more soluble components from a gas stream into a relatively non-volatile liquid solvent. Conversely, stripping (desorption) transfers volatile solutes from a liquid phase into an inert or condensable stripping gas (such as steam, air, or nitrogen). Both operations rely on the same fundamental thermodynamic phase equilibria and interfacial mass transfer mechanisms governed by the NCEES PE Chemical Reference Handbook .

On the PE Chemical exam, problems frequently evaluate whether a column is operating above or below its minimum solvent rate ( ( L / G ) m i n (L/G)_{min} ( L / G ) min ​ ), require analytical calculation of theoretical stages via the Kremser-Brown-Souders equation , or demand packed column height sizing using the Height of a Transfer Unit ( H O G H_{OG} H OG ​ ) and Number of Transfer Units ( N O G N_{OG} N OG ​ ) .

1. Thermodynamic Phase Equilibria & Henry's Law

In dilute gas-liquid systems, the equilibrium distribution of a sparingly soluble gaseous solute A A A between the vapor phase (mole fraction y y y ) and the liquid phase (mole fraction x x x ) follows Henry's Law : p A = y A P = H A ′ ⋅ x A p_A = y_A P = H_A' \cdot x_A p A ​ = y A ​ P = H A ′ ​ ⋅ x A ​

Where:

p A p_A p A ​ = partial pressure of solute A A A in the gas phase ( atm \text{atm} atm , bar \text{bar} bar , or kPa \text{kPa} kPa ).

P P P = total system operating pressure ( atm \text{atm} atm , bar \text{bar} bar , or kPa \text{kPa} kPa ).

H A ′ H_A' H A ′ ​ = Henry's law constant in pressure units ( atm/mole fraction \text{atm/mole fraction} atm/mole fraction , bar \text{bar} bar , or kPa \text{kPa} kPa ).

x A x_A x A ​ = mole fraction of solute A A A in the liquid phase.

y A y_A y A ​ = mole fraction of solute A A A in the gas phase.

Dividing by total pressure P P P yields the linear equilibrium line in mole fraction coordinates: y A ∗ = m ⋅ x A y_A^* = m \cdot x_A y A ∗ ​ = m ⋅ x A ​

Where the equilibrium distribution slope m m m is: m = H A ′ P m = \frac{H_A'}{P} m = P H A ′ ​ ​

Note

Henry's Constant Sensitivity:

Henry's constant increases significantly with rising temperature (dissolution of gases in liquids is typically exothermic, Δ H s o l n < 0 \Delta H_{soln} < 0 Δ H so l n ​ < 0 ). Consequently, absorption is favored at low temperatures and high pressures (which decreases m m m , flattening the equilibrium line and maximizing liquid solubility). Conversely, stripping is favored at high temperatures and low pressures (which increases m m m , steepening the equilibrium line and driving the solute out of the liquid phase).

2. Operating Lines & Material Balances: Absorption vs. Stripping

Consider a continuous, steady-state countercurrent column. The gas phase flows upward at molar rate G G G ( mol/s \text{mol/s} mol/s or kmol/h \text{kmol/h} kmol/h ), entering at the bottom with solute mole fraction y i n y_{in} y in ​ and exiting at the top at y o u t y_{out} y o u t ​ . The liquid solvent flows downward at molar rate L L L , entering at the top with solute mole fraction x i n x_{in} x in ​ and exiting at the bottom at x o u t x_{out} x o u t ​ . Top of Column (Stage 1)

  • Liquid In (L, x_in) Gas Out (G, y_out)
  • | ^
  • v |
  • +-------------------------------+
  • | |
  • | COUNTERCURRENT |
  • | MASS TRANSFER |
  • | |
  • +-------------------------------+
  • | ^
  • v |
  • Liquid Out (L, x_out) Gas In (G, y_in)
  • Bottom of Column (Stage N)
  • Dilute System Operating Line

When the solute concentration is low ( y < 0.05 y < 0.05 y < 0.05 to 0.10 0.10 0.10 and x < 0.05 x < 0.05 x < 0.05 ), the total molar flow rates of gas ( G G G ) and liquid ( L L L ) remain essentially constant throughout the column. A steady-state solute material balance from the top of the column down to an arbitrary internal cross-section yields: G ( y − y o u t ) = L ( x − x i n ) G(y - y_{out}) = L(x - x_{in}) G ( y − y o u t ​ ) = L ( x − x in ​ )

Rearranging into the linear operating equation ( y = f ( x ) y = f(x) y = f ( x ) ): y = L G x + ( y o u t − L G x i n ) y = \frac{L}{G} x + \left( y_{out} - \frac{L}{G} x_{in} \right) y = G L ​ x + ( y o u t ​ − G L ​ x in ​ )

The slope of the operating line on an arithmetic y − x y-x y − x plot is strictly the liquid-to-gas molar flow ratio, L / G L/G L / G .

Absorption vs. Stripping Geometry

The geometric orientation of the operating line relative to the equilibrium line ( y ∗ = m x y^* = m x y ∗ = m x ) determines the direction of mass transfer:

  • Characteristic Gas Absorption (Scrubbing) Stripping (Desorption)
  • Mass Transfer Direction Gas → \to → Liquid (Solute dissolved) Liquid → \to → Gas (Solute stripped)

Driving Force y > y ∗ y > y^* y > y ∗ (Vapor bulk above equilibrium) y < y ∗ y < y^* y < y ∗ (Vapor bulk below equilibrium)

Operating Line Position Above the equilibrium line ( y > m x y > m x y > m x ) Below the equilibrium line ( y < m x y < m x y < m x )

Operating Line Slope Slope L / G > m L/G > m L / G > m (for feasible high recovery) Slope L / G < m L/G < m L / G < m (or stripping slope G / L > 1 / m G/L > 1/m G / L > 1/ m )

Solvent/Gas Criterion Requires minimum liquid rate: ( L / G ) m i n (L/G)_{min} ( L / G ) min ​ Requires minimum gas rate: ( G / L ) m i n (G/L)_{min} ( G / L ) min ​

Thermodynamic Optimum High pressure, low temperature Low pressure / vacuum, high temperature y (Gas Mole Fraction) y (Gas Mole Fraction)

  • ^
  • | / Operating Line (Slope L/G) | / Equilibrium (Slope m)
  • | / | /
  • | / | / / Operating Line (Slope L/G)
  • | / / Equilibrium (Slope m) | / /
  • | / / | / /
  • | / / | / /
  • +------------------------> x +------------------------> x
  • ABSORPTION (y > y*) STRIPPING (y < y*)
  • Minimum Solvent Rate ( L / G ) m i n (L/G)_{min} ( L / G ) min ​ in Absorption

To achieve a specified separation (reducing gas concentration from y i n y_{in} y in ​ to y o u t y_{out} y o u t ​ using a solvent entering at x i n x_{in} x in ​ ), decreasing the liquid rate L L L flattens the operating line slope L / G L/G L / G . The theoretical minimum solvent rate, ( L / G ) m i n (L/G)_{min} ( L / G ) min ​ , occurs when the operating line touches the equilibrium line at the bottom of the column, creating an equilibrium pinch point where driving force Δ y = y i n − y i n ∗ → 0 \Delta y = y_{in} - y_{in}^* \to 0 Δ y = y in ​ − y in ∗ ​ → 0 , requiring an infinite number of stages ( N → ∞ N \to \infty N → ∞ ): ( L G ) m i n = y i n − y o u t x o u t ∗ − x i n = y i n − y o u t ( y i n m ) − x i n \left( \frac{L}{G} \right)_{min} = \frac{y_{in} - y_{out}}{x_{out}^* - x_{in}} = \frac{y_{in} - y_{out}}{\left(\frac{y_{in}}{m}\right) - x_{in}} ( G L ​ ) min ​ = x o u t ∗ ​ − x in ​ y in ​ − y o u t ​ ​ = ( m y in ​ ​ ) − x in ​ y in ​ − y o u t ​ ​

If the entering solvent is pure solute-free liquid ( x i n = 0 x_{in} = 0 x in ​ = 0 ): ( L G ) m i n = m ( y i n − y o u t y i n ) = m ⋅ ( Fractional Recovery ) \left( \frac{L}{G} \right)_{min} = m \left( \frac{y_{in} - y_{out}}{y_{in}} \right) = m \cdot (\text{Fractional Recovery}) ( G L ​ ) min ​ = m ( y in ​ y in ​ − y o u t ​ ​ ) = m ⋅ ( Fractional Recovery )

In industrial process design, economic optimization balances capital equipment cost (column diameter and height) against recurring solvent circulation and regeneration utility costs. Standard practice specifies an actual operating solvent rate of: ( L G ) a c t u a l = 1.20 to 1.50 × ( L G ) m i n \left( \frac{L}{G} \right)_{actual} = 1.20 \text{ to } 1.50 \times \left( \frac{L}{G} \right)_{min} ( G L ​ ) a c t u a l ​ = 1.20 to 1.50 × ( G L ​ ) min ​

Minimum Stripping Gas Rate ( G / L ) m i n (G/L)_{min} ( G / L ) min ​ in Stripping

In a stripping column, decreasing the stripping gas rate G G G steepens the operating line ( L / G L/G L / G increases). The minimum stripping gas rate ( G / L ) m i n (G/L)_{min} ( G / L ) min ​ occurs when the operating line touches the equilibrium line at the top of the column ( x i n , y o u t ∗ = m x i n x_{in}, y_{out}^* = m x_{in} x in ​ , y o u t ∗ ​ = m x in ​ ): ( G L ) m i n = x i n − x o u t y o u t ∗ − y i n = x i n − x o u t m x i n − y i n \left( \frac{G}{L} \right)_{min} = \frac{x_{in} - x_{out}}{y_{out}^* - y_{in}} = \frac{x_{in} - x_{out}}{m x_{in} - y_{in}} ( L G ​ ) min ​ = y o u t ∗ ​ − y in ​ x in ​ − x o u t ​ ​ = m x in ​ − y in ​ x in ​ − x o u t ​ ​

3. The Absorption Factor ( A A A ) and Stripping Factor ( S S S )

The performance of equilibrium-stage and packed mass transfer columns is governed by the dimensionless ratio of the operating line slope to the equilibrium line slope.

The Absorption Factor ( A A A ) A ≡ L m ⋅ G A \equiv \frac{L}{m \cdot G} A ≡ m ⋅ G L ​

Where:

L L L = molar liquid flow rate ( kmol/h \text{kmol/h} kmol/h ).

G G G = molar gas flow rate ( kmol/h \text{kmol/h} kmol/h ).

m m m = slope of the linear equilibrium line ( y ∗ = m x y^* = m x y ∗ = m x ).

Physical Significance of A A A :

A > 1.0 A > 1.0 A > 1.0 : The operating line is steeper than the equilibrium line ( L / G > m L/G > m L / G > m ). The two lines diverge toward the bottom of the column. A high fractional solute recovery ( > 99 % > 99\% > 99% ) is theoretically and practically achievable with a finite, reasonable number of stages.

A = 1.0 A = 1.0 A = 1.0 : The operating line and equilibrium line are strictly parallel ( L / G = m L/G = m L / G = m ). The driving force remains constant across all stages. Recovery increases linearly with stage count.

A < 1.0 A < 1.0 A < 1.0 : The operating line is flatter than the equilibrium line ( L / G < m L/G < m L / G < m ). The lines pinch at the bottom of the column. Complete solute recovery is mathematically and physically impossible, even with an infinitely tall column ( N → ∞ N \to \infty N → ∞ ). The maximum possible recovery is asymptotically limited to A A A (i.e., Fractional Recovery m a x = A \text{Fractional Recovery}_{max} = A Fractional Recovery ma x ​ = A ).

Economic Optimum : In plant design, the optimal absorption factor typically ranges between 1.2 ≤ A ≤ 2.0 1.2 \le A \le 2.0 1.2 ≤ A ≤ 2.0 , with A = 1.4 A = 1.4 A = 1.4 commonly adopted as the starting rule of thumb.

The Stripping Factor ( S S S )

The stripping factor is the exact reciprocal of the absorption factor: S ≡ 1 A = m ⋅ G L S \equiv \frac{1}{A} = \frac{m \cdot G}{L} S ≡ A 1 ​ = L m ⋅ G ​

For stripping columns, S > 1.0 S > 1.0 S > 1.0 is mandatory to achieve deep solute removal without encountering an equilibrium pinch at the top of the column. The standard economic design range is 1.2 ≤ S ≤ 2.0 1.2 \le S \le 2.0 1.2 ≤ S ≤ 2.0 (optimal S ≈ 1.4 S \approx 1.4 S ≈ 1.4 ).

4. The Kremser-Brown-Souders Equations

When the equilibrium line ( y = m x y = m x y = m x ) and operating line are linear, stage-by-stage mass balances can be solved analytically. The resulting closed-form expressions are known as the Kremser-Brown-Souders (or simply Kremser) equations , heavily featured on the NCEES PE Chemical exam.

Theoretical Stages for Absorption ( A ≠ 1 A \neq 1 A  = 1 )

To calculate the number of ideal (theoretical) equilibrium stages N N N required to reduce gas composition from y i n y_{in} y in ​ to y o u t y_{out} y o u t ​ using solvent with inlet composition x i n x_{in} x in ​ : N = ln ⁡ [ ( y i n − m x i n y o u t − m x i n ) ( 1 − 1 A ) + 1 A ] ln ⁡ ( A ) N = \frac{\ln\left[ \left( \frac{y_{in} - m x_{in}}{y_{out} - m x_{in}} \right) \left( 1 - \frac{1}{A} \right) + \frac{1}{A} \right]}{\ln(A)} N = ln ( A ) ln [ ( y o u t ​ − m x in ​ y in ​ − m x in ​ ​ ) ( 1 − A 1 ​ ) + A 1 ​ ] ​

When pure, solute-free solvent is fed to the top of the column ( x i n = 0 x_{in} = 0 x in ​ = 0 ): N = ln ⁡ [ ( y i n y o u t ) ( 1 − 1 A ) + 1 A ] ln ⁡ ( A ) N = \frac{\ln\left[ \left( \frac{y_{in}}{y_{out}} \right) \left( 1 - \frac{1}{A} \right) + \frac{1}{A} \right]}{\ln(A)} N = ln ( A ) ln [ ( y o u t ​ y in ​ ​ ) ( 1 − A 1 ​ ) + A 1 ​ ] ​

Fractional Unabsorbed Solute ( ϕ A \phi_A ϕ A ​ )

The fraction of solute entering in the gas stream that escapes unabsorbed in the exiting overhead gas is: ϕ A = y o u t − m x i n y i n − m x i n = A − 1 A N + 1 − 1 \phi_A = \frac{y_{out} - m x_{in}}{y_{in} - m x_{in}} = \frac{A - 1}{A^{N+1} - 1} ϕ A ​ = y in ​ − m x in ​ y o u t ​ − m x in ​ ​ = A N + 1 − 1 A − 1 ​

For an infinite number of stages ( N → ∞ N \to \infty N → ∞ ):

If A > 1 A > 1 A > 1 : ϕ A → 0 \phi_A \to 0 ϕ A ​ → 0 (100% absorption is achievable).

If A < 1 A < 1 A < 1 : ϕ A → 1 − A \phi_A \to 1 - A ϕ A ​ → 1 − A (maximum achievable absorption is 1 − ϕ A = A 1 - \phi_A = A 1 − ϕ A ​ = A ).

Theoretical Stages for Stripping ( S ≠ 1 S \neq 1 S  = 1 )

To strip a liquid from inlet concentration x i n x_{in} x in ​ down to outlet concentration x o u t x_{out} x o u t ​ using stripping gas with solute content y i n y_{in} y in ​ : N = ln ⁡ [ ( x i n − y i n / m x o u t − y i n / m ) ( 1 − 1 S ) + 1 S ] ln ⁡ ( S ) N = \frac{\ln\left[ \left( \frac{x_{in} - y_{in}/m}{x_{out} - y_{in}/m} \right) \left( 1 - \frac{1}{S} \right) + \frac{1}{S} \right]}{\ln(S)} N = ln ( S ) ln [ ( x o u t ​ − y in ​ / m x in ​ − y in ​ / m ​ ) ( 1 − S 1 ​ ) + S 1 ​ ] ​

When clean stripping gas is utilized ( y i n = 0 y_{in} = 0 y in ​ = 0 ): N = ln ⁡ [ ( x i n x o u t ) ( 1 − 1 S ) + 1 S ] ln ⁡ ( S ) N = \frac{\ln\left[ \left( \frac{x_{in}}{x_{out}} \right) \left( 1 - \frac{1}{S} \right) + \frac{1}{S} \right]}{\ln(S)} N = ln ( S ) ln [ ( x o u t ​ x in ​ ​ ) ( 1 − S 1 ​ ) + S 1 ​ ] ​

Special Case: Balanced Capacity ( A = 1 A = 1 A = 1 or S = 1 S = 1 S = 1 )

When L / G = m L/G = m L / G = m , the operating and equilibrium lines are parallel, creating a 0 / 0 0/0 0/0 indeterminacy in the logarithmic Kremser relation. Applying L'Hôpital's rule reveals that stage count collapses to a simple ratio of overall concentration change to driving force: N = y i n − y o u t y o u t − m x i n ( for A = 1 ) N = \frac{y_{in} - y_{out}}{y_{out} - m x_{in}} \quad (\text{for } A = 1) N = y o u t ​ − m x in ​ y in ​ − y o u t ​ ​ ( for A = 1 )

5. Rate-Controlled Continuous Packed Columns: HTU and NTU

While trayed towers contact vapor and liquid in discrete equilibrium stages, packed columns provide continuous, differential contact over structured or random packing (e.g., Raschig rings, Pall rings, Mellapak). Column height is evaluated using the concept of Transfer Units . Packed Bed Column Height: Z = H_OG * N_OG

  • |==================| <--- Gas Out (y_out), Liquid In (x_in)
  • | Liquid Spray |
  • | Distributor |
  • |------------------|
  • | |
  • | PACKED BED | Z = Total Bed Height
  • | (Structured or | H_OG = Height of an Overall Gas Transfer Unit
  • | Random Rings) | N_OG = Number of Overall Gas Transfer Units
  • | |
  • |------------------|
  • | Packing Support |
  • |==================| <--- Gas In (y_in), Liquid Out (x_out)
  • Height of the Packed Bed ( Z Z Z )

The required packed height ( Z Z Z ) is the product of the Height of an Overall Transfer Unit ( H O G H_{OG} H OG ​ or H O L H_{OL} H O L ​ ) and the Number of Overall Transfer Units ( N O G N_{OG} N OG ​ or N O L N_{OL} N O L ​ ): Z = H O G ⋅ N O G = H O L ⋅ N O L Z = H_{OG} \cdot N_{OG} = H_{OL} \cdot N_{OL} Z = H OG ​ ⋅ N OG ​ = H O L ​ ⋅ N O L ​

Number of Transfer Units ( N O G N_{OG} N OG ​ )

N O G N_{OG} N OG ​ represents the overall difficulty of the separation, defined by integrating the differential driving force across the gas phase: N O G = ∫ y o u t y i n d y y − y ∗ N_{OG} = \int_{y_{out}}^{y_{in}} \frac{dy}{y - y^*} N OG ​ = ∫ y o u t ​ y in ​ ​ y − y ∗ d y ​

Where ( y − y ∗ ) (y - y^*) ( y − y ∗ ) is the local vertical distance between the operating line and the equilibrium line. For dilute systems with linear operating and equilibrium lines, this integration yields the exact logarithmic mean driving force formula: N O G = y i n − y o u t Δ y l m N_{OG} = \frac{y_{in} - y_{out}}{\Delta y_{lm}} N OG ​ = Δ y l m ​ y in ​ − y o u t ​ ​

Where the log-mean concentration difference Δ y l m \Delta y_{lm} Δ y l m ​ is: Δ y l m = ( y i n − y i n ∗ ) − ( y o u t − y o u t ∗ ) ln ⁡ [ y i n − y i n ∗ y o u t − y o u t ∗ ] \Delta y_{lm} = \frac{(y_{in} - y_{in}^*) - (y_{out} - y_{out}^*)}{\ln\left[ \frac{y_{in} - y_{in}^*}{y_{out} - y_{out}^*} \right]} Δ y l m ​ = ln [ y o u t ​ − y o u t ∗ ​ y in ​ − y in ∗ ​ ​ ] ( y in ​ − y in ∗ ​ ) − ( y o u t ​ − y o u t ∗ ​ ) ​

Here y i n ∗ = m x o u t y_{in}^* = m x_{out} y in ∗ ​ = m x o u t ​ and y o u t ∗ = m x i n y_{out}^* = m x_{in} y o u t ∗ ​ = m x in ​ .

Relationship Between N O G N_{OG} N OG ​ and Kremser Stages N N N

For linear systems with constant absorption factor A A A , the analytical relationship connecting continuous transfer units ( N O G N_{OG} N OG ​ ) to discrete theoretical stages ( N N N ) is: N O G = N ⋅ ln ⁡ ( A ) 1 − 1 A = N ⋅ A ln ⁡ ( A ) A − 1 N_{OG} = N \cdot \frac{\ln(A)}{1 - \frac{1}{A}} = N \cdot \frac{A \ln(A)}{A - 1} N OG ​ = N ⋅ 1 − A 1 ​ ln ( A ) ​ = N ⋅ A − 1 A ln ( A ) ​

When A > 1 A > 1 A > 1 : N O G > N N_{OG} > N N OG ​ > N (transfer units exceed theoretical stages).

When A = 1 A = 1 A = 1 : N O G = N N_{OG} = N N OG ​ = N .

When A < 1 A < 1 A < 1 : N O G < N N_{OG} < N N OG ​ < N .

Height of a Transfer Unit ( H O G H_{OG} H OG ​ ) and Two-Film Theory

H O G H_{OG} H OG ​ characterizes the mass transfer efficiency of the packing hardware. A smaller H O G H_{OG} H OG ​ indicates a more efficient packing requiring less height for a given separation: H O G = G m K y a H_{OG} = \frac{G_m}{K_y a} H OG ​ = K y ​ a G m ​ ​

Where:

G m G_m G m ​ = superficial molar gas mass velocity ( kmol/(m 2 ⋅ s) \text{kmol/(m}^2\cdot\text{s)} kmol/(m 2 ⋅ s) or lbmol/(ft 2 ⋅ hr) \text{lbmol/(ft}^2\cdot\text{hr)} lbmol/(ft 2 ⋅ hr) ).

K y K_y K y ​ = overall gas-phase mass transfer coefficient ( kmol/(m 2 ⋅ s ⋅ Δ y ) \text{kmol/(m}^2\cdot\text{s}\cdot\Delta y) kmol/(m 2 ⋅ s ⋅ Δ y ) ).

a a a = specific interfacial surface area of packing per unit volume ( m 2 /m 3 \text{m}^2\text{/m}^3 m 2 /m 3 ).

According to Whitman's Two-Film Theory , the overall mass transfer resistance is the sum of the individual gas-film resistance ( 1 / k y 1/k_y 1/ k y ​ ) and liquid-film resistance ( 1 / k x 1/k_x 1/ k x ​ ): 1 K y = 1 k y + m k x \frac{1}{K_y} = \frac{1}{k_y} + \frac{m}{k_x} K y ​ 1 ​ = k y ​ 1 ​ + k x ​ m ​ 1 K x = 1 m k y + 1 k x \frac{1}{K_x} = \frac{1}{m k_y} + \frac{1}{k_x} K x ​ 1 ​ = m k y ​ 1 ​ + k x ​ 1 ​

Multiplying through by flow rates expresses total transfer unit height as a function of individual film heights ( H G H_G H G ​ and H L H_L H L ​ ): H O G = H G + ( m G L ) H L = H G + S ⋅ H L = H G + H L A H_{OG} = H_G + \left( \frac{m G}{L} \right) H_L = H_G + S \cdot H_L = H_G + \frac{H_L}{A} H OG ​ = H G ​ + ( L m G ​ ) H L ​ = H G ​ + S ⋅ H L ​ = H G ​ + A H L ​ ​ H O L = H L + ( L m G ) H G = H L + A ⋅ H G H_{OL} = H_L + \left( \frac{L}{m G} \right) H_G = H_L + A \cdot H_G H O L ​ = H L ​ + ( m G L ​ ) H G ​ = H L ​ + A ⋅ H G ​

Important

Controlling Film Resistance:

Gas-Film Controlling ( m ≪ 1 m \ll 1 m ≪ 1 , highly soluble gases like NH 3 \text{NH}_3 NH 3 ​ or HCl \text{HCl} HCl in water): The equilibrium slope m m m is small, so m / k x → 0 m/k_x \to 0 m / k x ​ → 0 . Thus 1 / K y ≈ 1 / k y 1/K_y \approx 1/k_y 1/ K y ​ ≈ 1/ k y ​ , and H O G ≈ H G H_{OG} \approx H_G H OG ​ ≈ H G ​ . Turbulence in the gas phase controls the rate of absorption.

Liquid-Film Controlling ( m ≫ 1 m \gg 1 m ≫ 1 , sparingly soluble gases like O 2 \text{O}_2 O 2 ​ , CO 2 \text{CO}_2 CO 2 ​ , or hydrocarbons in water): The equilibrium slope m m m is large, so the liquid-side resistance dominates: 1 / K y ≈ m / k x 1/K_y \approx m/k_x 1/ K y ​ ≈ m / k x ​ , and H O G ≈ ( m G / L ) H L H_{OG} \approx (m G / L) H_L H OG ​ ≈ ( m G / L ) H L ​ . Liquid-phase agitation controls the separation.

6. Concentrated Gas Absorption (Solute-Free Coordinates)

When gas mixtures contain high concentrations of soluble gas ( > 5 − 10 mol % > 5-10\text{ mol}\% > 5 − 10 mol % ), significant solute transfer causes total gas flow G G G and liquid flow L L L to decrease markedly along the column height. As a result, the operating line plotted in mole fractions ( y y y vs. x x x ) becomes curved, invalidating simple linear analysis.

To restore a strictly linear operating line, balances are written in terms of solute-free mole ratios : Y ≡ y 1 − y = moles solute moles inert carrier gas Y \equiv \frac{y}{1 - y} = \frac{\text{moles solute}}{\text{moles inert carrier gas}} Y ≡ 1 − y y ​ = moles inert carrier gas moles solute ​ X ≡ x 1 − x = moles solute moles non-volatile solvent X \equiv \frac{x}{1 - x} = \frac{\text{moles solute}}{\text{moles non-volatile solvent}} X ≡ 1 − x x ​ = moles non-volatile solvent moles solute ​

Defining G s G_s G s ​ as the constant molar flow rate of inert carrier gas ( G s = G ( 1 − y ) G_s = G(1 - y) G s ​ = G ( 1 − y ) ) and L s L_s L s ​ as the constant molar flow rate of solute-free solvent ( L s = L ( 1 − x ) L_s = L(1 - x) L s ​ = L ( 1 − x ) ), the steady-state solute balance yields: G s ( Y i n − Y o u t ) = L s ( X o u t − X i n ) G_s (Y_{in} - Y_{out}) = L_s (X_{out} - X_{in}) G s ​ ( Y in ​ − Y o u t ​ ) = L s ​ ( X o u t ​ − X in ​ )

Rearranging gives the rigorous, linear operating line in ratio coordinates: Y = L s G s ( X − X i n ) + Y o u t Y = \frac{L_s}{G_s} (X - X_{in}) + Y_{out} Y = G s ​ L s ​ ​ ( X − X in ​ ) + Y o u t ​

The slope on a Y − X Y-X Y − X diagram is strictly constant at L s / G s L_s / G_s L s ​ / G s ​ .

7. Summary Comparison Table: Absorption & Stripping Column Design

Parameter / Feature Gas Absorption Gas Stripping Trayed Towers Packed Columns

Equilibrium Condition Operating line above equilibrium ( y > y ∗ y > y^* y > y ∗ ) Operating line below equilibrium ( y < y ∗ y < y^* y < y ∗ ) Discrete equilibrium stages Continuous differential contact

Governing Dimensionless Factor A = L / ( m G ) > 1.0 A = L / (m G) > 1.0 A = L / ( m G ) > 1.0 S = m G / L > 1.0 S = m G / L > 1.0 S = m G / L > 1.0 Overall tray efficiency E o = N i d e a l / N a c t u a l E_o = N_{ideal} / N_{actual} E o ​ = N i d e a l ​ / N a c t u a l ​ H O G = G / ( K y a ) H_{OG} = G / (K_y a) H OG ​ = G / ( K y ​ a ) ; Z = H O G N O G Z = H_{OG} N_{OG} Z = H OG ​ N OG ​

Optimum Operating Value A ≈ 1.4 A \approx 1.4 A ≈ 1.4 ( 1.2 − 2.0 1.2 - 2.0 1.2 − 2.0 ) S ≈ 1.4 S \approx 1.4 S ≈ 1.4 ( 1.2 − 2.0 1.2 - 2.0 1.2 − 2.0 ) Tray spacing 18 − 24 in 18-24\text{ in} 18 − 24 in ( 450 − 600 mm 450-600\text{ mm} 450 − 600 mm ) Pressure drop Δ P / Z ≈ 0.1 − 0.5 in H 2 O/ft \Delta P/Z \approx 0.1-0.5\text{ in }\text{H}_2\text{O/ft} Δ P / Z ≈ 0.1 − 0.5 in H 2 ​ O/ft

Limiting Condition ( L / G ) m i n = ( y i n − y o u t ) / ( x o u t ∗ − x i n ) (L/G)_{min} = (y_{in} - y_{out}) / (x_{out}^* - x_{in}) ( L / G ) min ​ = ( y in ​ − y o u t ​ ) / ( x o u t ∗ ​ − x in ​ ) ( G / L ) m i n = ( x i n − x o u t ) / ( y o u t ∗ − y i n ) (G/L)_{min} = (x_{in} - x_{out}) / (y_{out}^* - y_{in}) ( G / L ) min ​ = ( x in ​ − x o u t ​ ) / ( y o u t ∗ ​ − y in ​ ) Weeping at low rates, flooding at high rates Loading point, flooding point at high gas velocities

Primary Cost Trade-Off High L L L cuts stages but raises stripper reboiler duty High G G G cuts stages but raises blower power and recovery cost Lower capital for large diameters ( > 1.5 m > 1.5\text{ m} > 1.5 m ) Lower pressure drop; ideal for vacuum or corrosive fluids

  • 8. Comprehensive Worked Numerical Example: Acetone Scrubbing Column Design
  • Problem Statement

A chemical processing facility must scrub 100.0 kmol/h 100.0\text{ kmol/h} 100.0 kmol/h ( 0.02778 kmol/s 0.02778\text{ kmol/s} 0.02778 kmol/s ) of an air-acetone mixture containing 4.0 mol % 4.0\text{ mol}\% 4.0 mol % acetone ( y i n = 0.040 y_{in} = 0.040 y in ​ = 0.040 ) to achieve 95.0 % 95.0\% 95.0% removal ( y o u t = 0.0020 y_{out} = 0.0020 y o u t ​ = 0.0020 ) using pure water ( x i n = 0 x_{in} = 0 x in ​ = 0 ) at 25.0 ∘ C 25.0^\circ\text{C} 25. 0 ∘ C and 1.0 atm 1.0\text{ atm} 1.0 atm .

System Data:

  • Gas flow rate: G = 100.0 kmol/h G = 100.0\text{ kmol/h} G = 100.0 kmol/h
  • Inlet gas mole fraction: y i n = 0.040 y_{in} = 0.040 y in ​ = 0.040

Outlet gas mole fraction: y o u t = 0.040 × ( 1 − 0.950 ) = 0.0020 y_{out} = 0.040 \times (1 - 0.950) = 0.0020 y o u t ​ = 0.040 × ( 1 − 0.950 ) = 0.0020

Entering liquid mole fraction: x i n = 0.000 x_{in} = 0.000 x in ​ = 0.000

Henry's law constant: H ′ = 1.20 atm/mole fraction ⟹ m = H ′ / P = 1.20 / 1.00 = 1.20 H' = 1.20\text{ atm/mole fraction} \implies m = H'/P = 1.20 / 1.00 = 1.20 H ′ = 1.20 atm/mole fraction ⟹ m = H ′ / P = 1.20/1.00 = 1.20

Overall gas-phase transfer unit height: H O G = 0.750 m H_{OG} = 0.750\text{ m} H OG ​ = 0.750 m

Calculate:

The minimum solvent rate ( L / G ) m i n (L/G)_{min} ( L / G ) min ​ and L m i n L_{min} L min ​ in kmol/h \text{kmol/h} kmol/h .

The actual operating solvent rate L L L using a design factor of 1.40 × L m i n 1.40 \times L_{min} 1.40 × L min ​ , and the resulting liquid outlet mole fraction x o u t x_{out} x o u t ​ .

The absorption factor A A A .

The number of theoretical equilibrium stages N N N required using the Kremser equation.

The log-mean driving force Δ y l m \Delta y_{lm} Δ y l m ​ and the number of transfer units N O G N_{OG} N OG ​ .

The total required packed bed height Z Z Z in meters.

Step 1: Minimum Solvent Rate ( L / G ) m i n (L/G)_{min} ( L / G ) min ​

At the column bottom, the maximum possible liquid outlet concentration is in equilibrium with the entering gas ( y i n y_{in} y in ​ ): x o u t ∗ = y i n m = 0.040 1.20 = 0.03333 x_{out}^* = \frac{y_{in}}{m} = \frac{0.040}{1.20} = 0.03333 x o u t ∗ ​ = m y in ​ ​ = 1.20 0.040 ​ = 0.03333

Applying the minimum solvent rate formula: ( L G ) m i n = y i n − y o u t x o u t ∗ − x i n = 0.040 − 0.0020 0.03333 − 0 = 0.0380 0.03333 = 1.140 \left( \frac{L}{G} \right)_{min} = \frac{y_{in} - y_{out}}{x_{out}^* - x_{in}} = \frac{0.040 - 0.0020}{0.03333 - 0} = \frac{0.0380}{0.03333} = \mathbf{1.140} ( G L ​ ) min ​ = x o u t ∗ ​ − x in ​ y in ​ − y o u t ​ ​ = 0.03333 − 0 0.040 − 0.0020 ​ = 0.03333 0.0380 ​ = 1.140 L m i n = 1.140 × G = 1.140 × 100.0 kmol/h = 114.0 kmol/h L_{min} = 1.140 \times G = 1.140 \times 100.0\text{ kmol/h} = \mathbf{114.0\text{ kmol/h}} L min ​ = 1.140 × G = 1.140 × 100.0 kmol/h = 114.0 kmol/h

Step 2: Actual Liquid Rate and Exit Concentration

Using the design margin of 1.40 × L m i n 1.40 \times L_{min} 1.40 × L min ​ : L = 1.40 × 114.0 kmol/h = 159.6 kmol/h L = 1.40 \times 114.0\text{ kmol/h} = \mathbf{159.6\text{ kmol/h}} L = 1.40 × 114.0 kmol/h = 159.6 kmol/h L G = 159.6 100.0 = 1.596 \frac{L}{G} = \frac{159.6}{100.0} = \mathbf{1.596} G L ​ = 100.0 159.6 ​ = 1.596

From the overall solute balance: x o u t = x i n + G L ( y i n − y o u t ) = 0 + 1 1.596 ( 0.040 − 0.0020 ) = 0.0380 1.596 = 0.02381 ( 2.381 mol % ) x_{out} = x_{in} + \frac{G}{L} (y_{in} - y_{out}) = 0 + \frac{1}{1.596} (0.040 - 0.0020) = \frac{0.0380}{1.596} = \mathbf{0.02381} \quad (2.381\text{ mol}\%) x o u t ​ = x in ​ + L G ​ ( y in ​ − y o u t ​ ) = 0 + 1.596 1 ​ ( 0.040 − 0.0020 ) = 1.596 0.0380 ​ = 0.02381 ( 2.381 mol % )

Step 3: Absorption Factor ( A A A ) A = L m ⋅ G = 1.596 1.20 = 1.330 A = \frac{L}{m \cdot G} = \frac{1.596}{1.20} = \mathbf{1.330} A = m ⋅ G L ​ = 1.20 1.596 ​ = 1.330

Because A = 1.330 > 1.0 A = 1.330 > 1.0 A = 1.330 > 1.0 , the operating line is steeper than the equilibrium line, ensuring robust mass transfer without an equilibrium pinch.

Step 4: Theoretical Stages via Kremser Equation

For x i n = 0 x_{in} = 0 x in ​ = 0 : y i n y o u t = 0.040 0.0020 = 20.0 \frac{y_{in}}{y_{out}} = \frac{0.040}{0.0020} = 20.0 y o u t ​ y in ​ ​ = 0.0020 0.040 ​ = 20.0 1 − 1 A = 1 − 1 1.330 = 1 − 0.75188 = 0.24812 1 - \frac{1}{A} = 1 - \frac{1}{1.330} = 1 - 0.75188 = 0.24812 1 − A 1 ​ = 1 − 1.330 1 ​ = 1 − 0.75188 = 0.24812

Evaluating the logarithmic numerator argument: Arg = ( y i n y o u t ) ( 1 − 1 A ) + 1 A = ( 20.0 × 0.24812 ) + 0.75188 = 4.9624 + 0.75188 = 5.7143 \text{Arg} = \left( \frac{y_{in}}{y_{out}} \right) \left( 1 - \frac{1}{A} \right) + \frac{1}{A} = (20.0 \times 0.24812) + 0.75188 = 4.9624 + 0.75188 = 5.7143 Arg = ( y o u t ​ y in ​ ​ ) ( 1 − A 1 ​ ) + A 1 ​ = ( 20.0 × 0.24812 ) + 0.75188 = 4.9624 + 0.75188 = 5.7143 ln ⁡ ( Arg ) = ln ⁡ ( 5.7143 ) = 1.74297 \ln(\text{Arg}) = \ln(5.7143) = 1.74297 ln ( Arg ) = ln ( 5.7143 ) = 1.74297 ln ⁡ ( A ) = ln ⁡ ( 1.330 ) = 0.28518 \ln(A) = \ln(1.330) = 0.28518 ln ( A ) = ln ( 1.330 ) = 0.28518 N = 1.74297 0.28518 = 6.11 theoretical stages N = \frac{1.74297}{0.28518} = \mathbf{6.11\text{ theoretical stages}} N = 0.28518 1.74297 ​ = 6.11 theoretical stages

Specifying hardware requires rounding to 7 7 7 ideal stages (or ≈ 10 − 12 \approx 10-12 ≈ 10 − 12 actual trays assuming 60 % 60\% 60% tray efficiency).

Step 5: Log-Mean Driving Force and Transfer Units ( N O G N_{OG} N OG ​ )

Calculate driving forces at column terminals:

Bottom of column: Δ y 1 = y i n − y i n ∗ = y i n − m x o u t = 0.040 − ( 1.20 × 0.02381 ) = 0.040 − 0.02857 = 0.01143 \Delta y_1 = y_{in} - y_{in}^* = y_{in} - m x_{out} = 0.040 - (1.20 \times 0.02381) = 0.040 - 0.02857 = 0.01143 Δ y 1 ​ = y in ​ − y in ∗ ​ = y in ​ − m x o u t ​ = 0.040 − ( 1.20 × 0.02381 ) = 0.040 − 0.02857 = 0.01143

Top of column: Δ y 2 = y o u t − y o u t ∗ = y o u t − m x i n = 0.0020 − 0 = 0.0020 \Delta y_2 = y_{out} - y_{out}^* = y_{out} - m x_{in} = 0.0020 - 0 = 0.0020 Δ y 2 ​ = y o u t ​ − y o u t ∗ ​ = y o u t ​ − m x in ​ = 0.0020 − 0 = 0.0020

Log-mean driving force: Δ y l m = Δ y 1 − Δ y 2 ln ⁡ ( Δ y 1 / Δ y 2 ) = 0.01143 − 0.0020 ln ⁡ ( 0.01143 / 0.0020 ) = 0.00943 ln ⁡ ( 5.715 ) = 0.00943 1.7431 = 0.005410 \Delta y_{lm} = \frac{\Delta y_1 - \Delta y_2}{\ln(\Delta y_1 / \Delta y_2)} = \frac{0.01143 - 0.0020}{\ln(0.01143 / 0.0020)} = \frac{0.00943}{\ln(5.715)} = \frac{0.00943}{1.7431} = \mathbf{0.005410} Δ y l m ​ = ln ( Δ y 1 ​ /Δ y 2 ​ ) Δ y 1 ​ − Δ y 2 ​ ​ = ln ( 0.01143/0.0020 ) 0.01143 − 0.0020 ​ = ln ( 5.715 ) 0.00943 ​ = 1.7431 0.00943 ​ = 0.005410

Number of overall gas transfer units: N O G = y i n − y o u t Δ y l m = 0.040 − 0.0020 0.005410 = 0.0380 0.005410 = 7.024 transfer units N_{OG} = \frac{y_{in} - y_{out}}{\Delta y_{lm}} = \frac{0.040 - 0.0020}{0.005410} = \frac{0.0380}{0.005410} = \mathbf{7.024\text{ transfer units}} N OG ​ = Δ y l m ​ y in ​ − y o u t ​ ​ = 0.005410 0.040 − 0.0020 ​ = 0.005410 0.0380 ​ = 7.024 transfer units

(Cross-check via stage conversion: N O G = N A ln ⁡ ( A ) A − 1 = 6.112 × 1.330 × 0.28518 0.330 = 6.112 × 1.1494 = 7.025 N_{OG} = N \frac{A \ln(A)}{A - 1} = 6.112 \times \frac{1.330 \times 0.28518}{0.330} = 6.112 \times 1.1494 = 7.025 N OG ​ = N A − 1 A l n ( A ) ​ = 6.112 × 0.330 1.330 × 0.28518 ​ = 6.112 × 1.1494 = 7.025 . Matches perfectly).

Step 6: Total Packed Bed Height ( Z Z Z ) Z = H O G ⋅ N O G = 0.750 m × 7.024 = 5.27 m ( 17.3 ft ) Z = H_{OG} \cdot N_{OG} = 0.750\text{ m} \times 7.024 = \mathbf{5.27\text{ m}} \quad (17.3\text{ ft}) Z = H OG ​ ⋅ N OG ​ = 0.750 m × 7.024 = 5.27 m ( 17.3 ft )

  • 9. Critical PE Exam Traps & Pitfalls
  • Trap 1: Confusing Absorption Factor A A A with Stripping Factor S S S

Remember that A = L / ( m G ) A = L / (m G) A = L / ( m G ) , whereas S = m G / L = 1 / A S = m G / L = 1/A S = m G / L = 1/ A . In an absorption problem, you must ensure A > 1 A > 1 A > 1 for efficient operation. If an exam question asks about stripping a contaminated groundwater stream with air, you must verify that the stripping factor S > 1.0 S > 1.0 S > 1.0 . Using the absorption equation for a stripping problem inverts the logarithmic arguments, producing mathematical errors or negative stage counts.

Trap 2: Ignoring Solute-Free Coordinates in Concentrated Feeds

When feed gas contains 15 mol % 15\text{ mol}\% 15 mol % solute, mole fractions do not yield a straight operating line because G G G decreases significantly as solute dissolves. Applying the standard Kremser equation directly in mole fractions introduces errors exceeding 20 − 40 % 20-40\% 20 − 40% . You must convert to solute-free ratios: Y = y / ( 1 − y ) Y = y/(1-y) Y = y / ( 1 − y ) , X = x / ( 1 − x ) X = x/(1-x) X = x / ( 1 − x ) , G s = G ( 1 − y ) G_s = G(1-y) G s ​ = G ( 1 − y ) , and L s = L ( 1 − x ) L_s = L(1-x) L s ​ = L ( 1 − x ) .

Trap 3: Inverting the Film Resistances in H O G H_{OG} H OG ​

When combining transfer unit heights, the equilibrium slope m m m multiplies the liquid film: H O G = H G + ( m G / L ) H L = H G + H L / A H_{OG} = H_G + (m G / L) H_L = H_G + H_L / A H OG ​ = H G ​ + ( m G / L ) H L ​ = H G ​ + H L ​ / A . A common exam error is writing H O G = H G + A H L H_{OG} = H_G + A H_L H OG ​ = H G ​ + A H L ​ . Remember that if liquid solubility is very low ( m m m is huge), liquid resistance dominates the gas-phase overall height, requiring a large term multiplying H L H_L H L ​ .

Trap 4: Misidentifying the Equilibrium Pinch Location

For absorption with A < 1 A < 1 A < 1 , the operating line slope is flatter than equilibrium, pinching at the bottom of the column ( x o u t , y i n x_{out}, y_{in} x o u t ​ , y in ​ ). For stripping with S < 1 S < 1 S < 1 , the operating line is steeper than equilibrium, pinching at the top of the column ( x i n , y o u t x_{in}, y_{out} x in ​ , y o u t ​ ). Never place the pinch at the wrong end of the tower.