Study guide

9.5 Learning Curves: Unit and Cumulative-Average Models, Learning Rates & Applications

PE Industrial and Systems Exam

Track your progress as you read

Finished sections get a check mark.

1 Exam Overview, Strategy & Systems Foundations

1.1 PE Industrial Exam Format, Official Specification & Reference Handbook Strategy 1.2 System Analysis Tools, Process Definition, Requirements Engineering & QFD 1.3 Performance Measures: Output, Productivity, OEE, Cost & Environmental Sustainability 1.4 Process Types (Discrete, Continuous, Manufacturing, Service) & Value Analysis/Engineering

2 Optimization, Queueing, Simulation, Networks & Markov Chains

2.1 Linear Programming Formulation, Graphical Solutions & Sensitivity Analysis 2.2 Queueing Theory Models (M/M/1, M/M/s) & Little's Law Applications 2.3 Discrete-Event Simulation, Random Variates & Model Validation 2.4 Graph Theory & Network Models: Shortest Path, Minimal Spanning Tree & Maximum Flow 2.5 Markov Chains: Transition Matrices, Steady-State Probabilities & Absorbing States 2.6 Decision Trees, Expected Value & Bottleneck Analysis (Theory of Constraints)

3 Project Management & Planning

3.1 Project Scheduling with CPM and PERT: Critical Path, Float, Probability & Crashing 3.2 Project Planning & Control: Scope and WBS, Gantt Charts, Critical Chain (CCPM), Risk & Earned Value

4 Facility Layout, Space, Capacity & Material Handling

4.1 Systematic Layout Planning (SLP) & Activity Relationship (REL) Analysis 4.2 Workstation Design, Aisle Sizing & Space Requirements Planning 4.3 Capacity Analysis: Machine Requirements, Scrap Allowances & Personnel Requirements 4.4 Material Handling Equipment Selection, Unit Loads & Handling Principles

5 Site Location, Warehousing & Facility Economics

5.1 Facility Location Models: Center of Gravity & Minisum / Minimax Distance 5.2 Warehousing Systems, Storage Assignment & Order Picking Operations 5.3 Facility Life-Cycle Economics, Replacement Analysis & Rearrangement Costs

6 Demand Forecasting, Production Planning, MRP & JIT

6.1 Demand Forecasting Methods: Moving Averages, Exponential Smoothing & Error Metrics 6.2 Aggregate Planning Strategies & Master Production Scheduling (MPS) 6.3 Material Requirements Planning (MRP), Bill of Materials & Capacity Planning 6.4 Just-in-Time & Lean Production Planning: Pull Systems, Kanban Sizing, Heijunka & SMED

7 Inventory Systems, Scheduling, Logistics & Transportation Modes

7.1 Deterministic Inventory Control: Classical EOQ, EPQ & Quantity Discounts 7.2 Stochastic Inventory Management: Safety Stock, Continuous / Periodic Review & Newsvendor 7.3 Production Sequencing, Dispatching Rules & Johnson's Algorithm 7.4 Supply Chain Logistics, Transportation Simplex & Distribution Network Design 7.5 Transportation Modes, Freight Economics & the Transshipment Model

8 Engineering Economics, Break-Even Analysis & Costing Systems

8.1 Equivalence, Cash Flow Analysis & Discounted Cash Flow Metrics (PW, FW, EAC) 8.2 Rate of Return Analysis (IRR, Incremental IRR) & Benefit-Cost (B/C) Ratios 8.3 Asset Depreciation (MACRS, Straight-Line), Tax Effects & Replacement Decisions 8.4 Break-Even Analysis, Technical Capability Assessment & Costing Systems (Traditional, ABC & Standard Costs)

9 Methods Engineering, Work Measurement, Learning Curves, Line Balancing & Process Planning

9.1 Methods Analysis, Process Charting & Motion Study (Therbligs, 5S) 9.2 Worker–Machine (Man–Machine) Charts, Multiple Activity Analysis & Synchronous Servicing 9.3 Time Study Fundamentals, Performance Rating & Allowance Factors 9.4 Predetermined Motion Time Systems (PMTS, MTM, MOST) & Work Sampling 9.5 Learning Curves: Unit and Cumulative-Average Models, Learning Rates & Applications 9.6 Assembly Line Balancing, Precedence Constraints & Efficiency Heuristics 9.7 Manufacturing & Service Process Planning: Operation Selection, Sequencing, Route Sheets, Fixturing & Mistake Proofing

10 Ergonomics, Human Capacity, Occupational Safety & DART Rates

10.1 Anthropometry, Percentile Design, Workstation Ergonomics & Link Analysis 10.2 Industrial Biomechanics, the NIOSH Lifting Equation & Lifting Aids 10.3 Limits of Human Capacity & Risk-Factor Tools: Work Physiology, Strength, Range of Motion, Vision, RULA & Slip Resistance 10.4 Environmental Ergonomics (Noise, Heat, Illumination), Human-Machine Systems & OSHA Safety 10.5 Safety Codes, Standards & Voluntary Guidelines (OSHA, ANSI, NIOSH, MIL-STD) and DART Rate Calculations

11 Statistical Process Control & Process Capability

11.1 Statistical Process Control for Variables (X-bar/R and X-bar/s Charts) 11.2 Statistical Process Control for Attributes (p, np, c, and u Charts) 11.3 Process Capability Indices (Cp, Cpk, Cpm, Pp, Ppk) & Sigma Levels

12 Design of Experiments, Acceptance Sampling & Quality Systems

12.1 Design of Experiments: 2^k Factorials, ANOVA & Taguchi Robust Design 12.2 Acceptance Sampling: OC Curves, AQL, LTPD, AOQL, Z1.4/MIL-STD-105E & Dodge-Romig 12.3 Quality Systems (Deming, TQM, ISO 9000, Benchmarking), Root Cause Analysis & DMAIC

13 Reliability Engineering & Maintenance Systems

13.1 Reliability Modeling, Failure Rates (lambda) & Life Distributions (Exponential, Weibull) 13.2 System Reliability Architecture: Series, Parallel, k-out-of-n & Redundancy 13.3 Equipment Maintenance Engineering, Availability (A), MTBF/MTTR & RCM

9.5 Learning Curves: Unit and Cumulative-Average Models, Learning Rates & Applications

Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI

With learning rate r, the time per unit (or cumulative average time) falls to r times its previous value each time cumulative output doubles.

The model is T_n = T_1 × n^b with b = ln r ÷ ln 2; for an 85% curve, b = −0.2345, and for an 80% curve, b = −0.3219.

The unit (Crawford) model applies the formula to the time of the n-th unit, while the cumulative-average (Wright) model applies it to the average of the first n units; problems must say which.

Total time for the first N units under the unit model is the sum of unit times, approximately T_1 × [(N + 0.5)^(b+1) − 0.5^(b+1)] ÷ (b + 1).

Time standards set during start-up should account for learning, and labor plans and cost estimates for new products should follow the expected curve rather than the steady-state standard.

Last updated: October 2026

9.5 Learning Curves

Workers and organizations get faster with repetition. T.P. Wright documented the pattern in airframe assembly in 1936: each time cumulative production doubled , labor hours per plane fell by a roughly constant percentage. The NCEES specification lists learning curves as a Work Design topic. They matter whenever a standard, a staffing plan, or a price must be set for a new product or process.

1. The Doubling Rule and the Learning Rate

If the learning rate is r r r (for example 0.85, an "85% curve"):

T 2 n = r ⋅ T n T_{2n} = r \cdot T_n T 2 n ​ = r ⋅ T n ​

Unit 2 takes 85% of unit 1's time, unit 4 takes 85% of unit 2's, unit 8 takes 85% of unit 4's, and so on.

A lower percentage means faster learning. An 80% curve improves faster than a 90% curve.

Typical rates are about 70% to 80% for heavily manual, complex work, and 90% to 95% for highly automated or machine-paced work, where people control little of the cycle.

2. The Mathematical Model

T n = T 1 ⋅ n b , b = ln ⁡ r ln ⁡ 2 = log ⁡ r log ⁡ 2 T_n = T_1 \cdot n^{\,b}, \qquad b = \frac{\ln r}{\ln 2} = \frac{\log r}{\log 2} T n ​ = T 1 ​ ⋅ n b , b = l n 2 l n r ​ = l o g 2 l o g r ​

  • Learning rate r r r Exponent b b b
  • 95% −0.0740
  • 90% −0.1520
  • 85% −0.2345
  • 80% −0.3219
  • 75% −0.4150
  • 70% −0.5146

Two versions of the model:

Unit model (Crawford): T n T_n T n ​ is the time for the n n n -th unit. This is the more common convention in industrial engineering texts.

Cumulative-average model (Wright): T n T_n T n ​ is the average time of the first n n n units. Then total time for n n n units is n ⋅ T 1 n b = T 1 n b + 1 n \cdot T_1 n^b = T_1 n^{b+1} n ⋅ T 1 ​ n b = T 1 ​ n b + 1 .

The two give different numbers for the same r r r . Read the problem carefully; if it says "the 8th unit," use the unit model.

3. Worked Examples (Unit Model)

First unit T 1 = 100 T_1 = 100 T 1 ​ = 100 hours, 85% learning curve , so b = ln ⁡ 0.85 / ln ⁡ 2 = − 0.2345 b = \ln 0.85 / \ln 2 = -0.2345 b = ln 0.85/ ln 2 = − 0.2345 .

(a) Time for unit 8. Unit 8 is three doublings from unit 1:

T 8 = 100 × 0.85 3 = 61.4 hr (or 100 × 8 − 0.2345 = 61.4 ) T_8 = 100 \times 0.85^3 = 61.4 \text{ hr} \quad \text{(or } 100 \times 8^{-0.2345} = 61.4\text{)} T 8 ​ = 100 × 0.8 5 3 = 61.4 hr (or 100 × 8 − 0.2345 = 61.4 )

(b) Time for unit 10 (not a power of 2, so use the formula):

T 10 = 100 × 10 − 0.2345 = 58.3 hr T_{10} = 100 \times 10^{-0.2345} = 58.3 \text{ hr} T 10 ​ = 100 × 1 0 − 0.2345 = 58.3 hr

(c) Total hours for the first 10 units. Summing T 1 T_1 T 1 ​ through T 10 T_{10} T 10 ​ gives 711.6 hours. The continuous approximation is:

Total N ≈ T 1 ( N + 0.5 ) b + 1 − 0.5 b + 1 b + 1 = 100 × 10.5 0.7655 − 0.5 0.7655 0.7655 ≈ 713 hr \text{Total}_N \approx T_1 \frac{(N + 0.5)^{b+1} - 0.5^{b+1}}{b + 1} = 100 \times \frac{10.5^{0.7655} - 0.5^{0.7655}}{0.7655} \approx 713 \text{ hr} Total N ​ ≈ T 1 ​ b + 1 ( N + 0.5 ) b + 1 − 0. 5 b + 1 ​ = 100 × 0.7655 10. 5 0.7655 − 0. 5 0.7655 ​ ≈ 713 hr

which is close enough for planning.

(d) When does the time reach 40 hours? Solve 40 = 100 × n − 0.2345 40 = 100 \times n^{-0.2345} 40 = 100 × n − 0.2345 :

n = ( 0.40 ) 1 / b = 0.40 − 4.265 ≈ 49.8 n = (0.40)^{1/b} = 0.40^{-4.265} \approx 49.8 n = ( 0.40 ) 1/ b = 0.4 0 − 4.265 ≈ 49.8

so about the 50th unit .

Finding the Learning Rate from Data

If unit 1 took 50 hours and unit 4 took 32 hours, two doublings separate them:

r 2 = 32 50 = 0.64 ⇒ r = 0.80 r^2 = \frac{32}{50} = 0.64 \Rightarrow r = 0.80 r 2 = 50 32 ​ = 0.64 ⇒ r = 0.80

For units that are not a power of 2 apart, use b = ln ⁡ ( T n / T 1 ) / ln ⁡ n b = \ln(T_n/T_1)/\ln n b = ln ( T n ​ / T 1 ​ ) / ln n and then r = 2 b r = 2^b r = 2 b .

Unit vs. Cumulative-Average Model Compared

For T 1 = 100 T_1 = 100 T 1 ​ = 100 hours on an 80% curve ( b = − 0.3219 b = -0.3219 b = − 0.3219 ):

Units built n n n Unit model: time of unit n n n Cumulative-average model: average of first n n n Cumulative-average model: total for n n n units

  • 1 100.0 100.0 100
  • 2 80.0 80.0 160
  • 4 64.0 64.0 256
  • 8 51.2 51.2 410

Under the cumulative-average model, unit 2 by itself takes 160 − 100 = 60 160 - 100 = 60 160 − 100 = 60 hours, not 80. The same 80% rate therefore implies faster unit-level improvement under the Wright model than under the Crawford model. Mixing the two conventions in one problem is a common source of wrong answers.

4. Applications in Work Design and Operations

Setting time standards. A stopwatch study during start-up captures workers who are still learning. Either wait until performance levels off, or set a temporary standard that follows the curve. A standard set too early is too loose and will be easy to beat later.

Staffing and capacity planning. Early units need more labor hours, so the hours needed per week fall as cumulative output grows. Plan crews and overtime to the curve.

Cost estimating and bidding. Defense and aerospace contracts often price production lots on a learning curve. The average cost of lot 2 is lower than lot 1.

Make-or-buy and outsourcing. A supplier far down its curve may beat a new in-house line on cost.

Incentive and training programs. Compare a trainee's actual times with the expected curve to spot those who need help.

Plateaus and limits. Learning slows when the process is machine paced, when operators are replaced (turnover resets part of the learning), or after long interruptions ("forgetting"). Many organizations treat the curve as leveling off at the engineered standard.

Warning

Common exam errors:

Using b = ln ⁡ r b = \ln r b = ln r instead of ln ⁡ r / ln ⁡ 2 \ln r / \ln 2 ln r / ln 2 .

Applying the cumulative-average model when the unit model is intended.

Treating a 90% curve as faster learning than an 80% curve.

Assuming every unit falls by 15% on an 85% curve. The 15% reduction happens per doubling , not per unit.