Study guide
6.2 Fluctuating Stresses, Failure Criteria & Cumulative Damage
PE Mechanical: Machine Design and Materials Exam
Track your progress as you read
Finished sections get a check mark.
1 Chapter 1: Basic Engineering Practice: Drawings, Economics & Design Methodology
1.1 Engineering Terms, Symbols, Drawing Interpretation & Conventions 1.2 Project Management & Engineering Economics 1.3 Design Methodology, Risk Assessment & Safety
2 Chapter 2: Physical & Mechanical Properties of Engineering Materials
2.1 Stress-Strain Relationships & Fundamental Mechanical Properties 2.2 Physical Properties, Temperature Effects, Hardness, Impact Toughness & Creep
3 Chapter 3: Mechanics of Materials: Fundamental Loadings & Deflections
3.1 Axial Loading, Normal Stress & Statically Indeterminate Members 3.2 Direct Shear, Bearing & Transverse Shear in Beams 3.3 Torsion of Shafts, Power Transmission & Thin-Walled Tubes 3.4 Beam Bending Stresses & Deflection Analysis
4 Chapter 4: Mechanics of Materials: Stability, Multiaxial Stress & Thermal Effects
4.1 Column Buckling & Elastic/Inelastic Instability 4.2 Combined Loading, Principal Stresses & Mohr's Circle 4.3 Thermal Stresses & Interference Stresses
5 Chapter 5: Failure Theories: Static Yielding & Fracture Mechanics
5.1 Static Failure Theories for Ductile Materials: von Mises & Tresca 5.2 Static Failure Theories for Brittle Materials & Fracture Mechanics
6 Chapter 6: Fatigue Analysis & Dynamic Failure
6.1 High-Cycle Fatigue, S-N Curves & Marin Modifying Factors 6.2 Fluctuating Stresses, Failure Criteria & Cumulative Damage
7 Chapter 7: Mechanical Attachments: Fasteners & Bolted Joints
7.1 Threaded Fasteners, Proof Strength & Preload Mechanics 7.2 Bolted Joint Stiffness, External Loading & Separation 7.3 Non-Threaded Fasteners: Keys, Pins, Clevises, Retaining Rings, Rivets, Lugs & Anchors
8 Chapter 8: Mechanical Attachments: Permanent Joints & Bonding
8.1 Welded Joints & Weld Group Stress Analysis 8.2 Brazing, Soldering & Structural Adhesive Bonding
9 Chapter 9: Power Transmission: Shafts & Gearing
9.1 Transmission Shaft Design, Critical Speeds & Deflection 9.2 Spur Gears: Geometry, Kinematics & AGMA Stress Equations 9.3 Helical, Bevel & Worm Gearing
10 Chapter 10: Power Transmission: Bearings, Flexible Drives, Friction Devices & Prime Movers
10.1 Rolling-Element Bearings & L10 Life Calculations 10.2 Hydrodynamic Journal Bearings & Lubrication Regimes 10.3 Belts, Roller Chains & Flexible Drives 10.4 Clutches, Brakes & Power Screws 10.5 Electric Motors, Engines & Flywheels
11 Chapter 11: Mechanical Components: Pressure Vessels & Structural Systems
11.1 Pressure Vessels & Piping: Thin and Thick Walls, ASME VIII and B31 11.2 Mechanical Springs: Helical, Belleville & Leaf Springs 11.3 Structural Trusses, Rigid Frames & Energy Methods
12 Chapter 12: Mechanical Dynamics, Vibrations & Fluid Power
12.1 Single-Degree-of-Freedom Vibrations & Resonance 12.2 Vibration Isolation, Multi-DOF Systems & Transmissibility 12.3 Fluid Power Systems: Hydraulics & Pneumatics
13 Chapter 13: Kinematics, Mechatronics & Control Systems
13.1 Mechanism Kinematics, Linkages, Cams & Simple Machines 13.2 Basic Mechatronics, Sensors & Closed-Loop Controls
14 Chapter 14: Supportive Knowledge: Fits, Tolerances & Manufacturing Methods
14.1 Limits, Fits & Geometric Dimensioning & Tolerancing (GD&T) 14.2 Manufacturing Methods, Machinability, Heat Treatment & Assembly
15 Chapter 15: Supportive Knowledge: Codes, Computation, Testing & Corrosion
15.1 Engineering Codes & Standards 15.2 Computational Methods: FEA & Numerical Analysis 15.3 Instrumentation, Testing, Inspection & Quality 15.4 Chemical Processes: Corrosion, Oxidation & Embrittlement
6.2 Fluctuating Stresses, Failure Criteria & Cumulative Damage
Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI
General fluctuating stresses are characterized by two independent components: the alternating stress amplitude σ a = ∣ σ max − σ min ∣ / 2 \sigma_a = |\sigma_{\max} - \sigma_{\min}|/2 σ a = ∣ σ m a x − σ m i n ∣/2 and the mean stress σ m = ( σ max + σ min ) / 2 \sigma_m = (\sigma_{\max} + \sigma_{\min})/2 σ m = ( σ m a x + σ m i n ) /2 , with the stress ratio R = σ min / σ max R = \sigma_{\min}/\sigma_{\max} R = σ m i n / σ m a x defining the cyclic regime.
On the Haigh diagram ( σ a \sigma_a σ a vs σ m \sigma_m σ m ), the Modified Goodman line provides a linear, conservative design boundary connecting S e S_e S e to S u t S_{ut} S u t ; the Gerber parabola offers the most accurate mean fit to experimental test data for ductile metals; and the Soderberg line represents an overly conservative criterion penalizing mean stress against yield strength S y S_y S y .
A mandatory first-cycle yielding check must always be performed using the Langer line σ a + σ m ≤ S y / n y \sigma_a + \sigma_m \le S_y / n_y σ a + σ m ≤ S y / n y (equivalent to σ max ≤ S y / n y \sigma_{\max} \le S_y / n_y σ m a x ≤ S y / n y ) to guarantee that the mechanical component does not suffer permanent gross plastic deformation during startup or peak cycle transients.
Under multiaxial fluctuating states combining cyclic bending and torsion, equivalent von Mises alternating stress σ a ′ = σ a 2 + 3 τ a 2 \sigma_a' = \sqrt{\sigma_a^2 + 3\tau_a^2} σ a ′ = σ a 2 + 3 τ a 2 and mean stress σ m ′ = σ m 2 + 3 τ m 2 \sigma_m' = \sqrt{\sigma_m^2 + 3\tau_m^2} σ m ′ = σ m 2 + 3 τ m 2 allow direct evaluation against classical uniaxial fatigue failure criteria.
The Palmgren-Miner linear damage rule accumulates cycle ratios ∑ ( n i / N i ) = D \sum (n_i / N_i) = D ∑ ( n i / N i ) = D , predicting failure when D ≥ 1.0 D \ge 1.0 D ≥ 1.0 ; however, it ignores load sequence effects, meaning high-to-low loading sequences accelerate damage and cause premature failure at D < 1.0 D < 1.0 D < 1.0 .
Last updated: October 2026
6.2 Fluctuating Stresses, Failure Criteria & Cumulative Damage
In practical mechanical systems, dynamic stresses rarely cycle symmetrically about a zero mean value. Connecting rods, turbine blades, pressurized pipes, and gear teeth experience fluctuating stresses characterized by combined steady (mean) loads and cyclic (alternating) loads. Evaluating components under non-zero mean stress requires specialized failure criteria plotted on the Haigh diagram, rigorous checks against initial yielding via the Langer line, and cumulative damage models for variable-amplitude spectrum loading.
Fluctuating Stress Components & Terminology
A general cyclic stress history fluctuating periodically between a maximum tensile stress σ max \sigma_{\max} σ m a x and a minimum stress σ min \sigma_{\min} σ m i n is decomposed into two distinct, orthogonal mathematical components: Stress ^
- | _---_ _---_
- sigma_max +---------/-------'\------------------/-------'\----------+
- | / | \ / | \
- | | | | | | | | 2 * sigma_a
- sigma_m + - - - - + - - -|- - -+ - - - - - - -+ - - -|- - -+ - - - -+ (Stress Range Delta sigma)
- | | | | | | | |
- | \ | / \ | /
- sigma_min +---------\_______/------------------\_______/----------+
- | |
- +----------------+------------------------------------------> Time
- |<--- Period T --->|
- Mathematical Definitions
Alternating Stress Amplitude ( σ a \sigma_a σ a ) :
The cyclic half-range that drives crack propagation: σ a = ∣ σ max − σ min ∣ 2 \sigma_a = \frac{|\sigma_{\max} - \sigma_{\min}|}{2} σ a = 2 ∣ σ m a x − σ m i n ∣
Mean Stress ( σ m \sigma_m σ m ) :
The static, time-invariant baseline stress level: σ m = σ max + σ min 2 \sigma_m = \frac{\sigma_{\max} + \sigma_{\min}}{2} σ m = 2 σ m a x + σ m i n
Stress Range ( Δ σ \Delta \sigma Δ σ ) :
The full peak-to-peak excursion: Δ σ = σ max − σ min = 2 σ a \Delta \sigma = \sigma_{\max} - \sigma_{\min} = 2\sigma_a Δ σ = σ m a x − σ m i n = 2 σ a
Stress Ratio ( R R R ) :
The ratio of minimum stress to maximum stress, serving as the universal descriptor of cyclic loading regime: R = σ min σ max R = \frac{\sigma_{\min}}{\sigma_{\max}} R = σ m a x σ m i n
Amplitude Ratio ( A A A ) :
The ratio of alternating stress to mean stress: A = σ a σ m = σ max − σ min σ max + σ min = 1 − R 1 + R A = \frac{\sigma_a}{\sigma_m} = \frac{\sigma_{\max} - \sigma_{\min}}{\sigma_{\max} + \sigma_{\min}} = \frac{1 - R}{1 + R} A = σ m σ a = σ m a x + σ m i n σ m a x − σ m i n = 1 + R 1 − R
Standard Benchmark Loading Regimes
Loading Condition Stress Ratio ( R R R ) Amplitude Ratio ( A A A ) Characteristics & Examples
Completely Reversed R = − 1 R = -1 R = − 1 A = ∞ A = \infty A = ∞ σ m = 0 \sigma_m = 0 σ m = 0 , σ max = − σ min \sigma_{\max} = -\sigma_{\min} σ m a x = − σ m i n ; rotating shafts in pure bending
Repeated / Pulsating R = 0 R = 0 R = 0 A = 1 A = 1 A = 1 σ min = 0 \sigma_{\min} = 0 σ m i n = 0 , σ m = σ a = σ max / 2 \sigma_m = \sigma_a = \sigma_{\max}/2 σ m = σ a = σ m a x /2 ; gear teeth, cam followers
Static Constant R = 1 R = 1 R = 1 A = 0 A = 0 A = 0 σ a = 0 \sigma_a = 0 σ a = 0 , σ m = σ max \sigma_m = \sigma_{\max} σ m = σ m a x ; deadweight structural tension
Tension--Tension 0 < R < 1 0 < R < 1 0 < R < 1 0 < A < 1 0 < A < 1 0 < A < 1 Both limits tensile; pressure vessel fluctuating between high/low pressure
Tension--Compression − 1 < R < 0 -1 < R < 0 − 1 < R < 0 1 < A < ∞ 1 < A < \infty 1 < A < ∞ Peak is tensile, valley is compressive; connecting rods with unequal strokes
Physical Impact of Mean Stress
Tensile Mean Stress ( σ m > 0 \sigma_m > 0 σ m > 0 ) : Highly detrimental. Tensile mean stress pulls microcrack faces apart, facilitating Mode I crack opening, accelerating Stage II crack growth, and dramatically lowering the allowable alternating fatigue strength.
Compressive Mean Stress ( σ m < 0 \sigma_m < 0 σ m < 0 ) : Highly beneficial. Compressive mean stress forces crack faces tightly shut, impeding crack propagation. In machine design, compressive mean stress is usually treated conservatively by ignoring the beneficial effect and setting σ m = 0 \sigma_m = 0 σ m = 0 (so σ a ≤ S e \sigma_a \le S_e σ a ≤ S e ).
Fatigue Failure Criteria on the Haigh Diagram
The Haigh diagram plots alternating stress amplitude ( σ a \sigma_a σ a ) on the vertical axis against mean stress ( σ m \sigma_m σ m ) on the horizontal axis. Any cyclic stress state is represented as a discrete point ( σ m , σ a ) (\sigma_m, \sigma_a) ( σ m , σ a ) . When a component operates under proportional loading, the operating locus is a straight load line radiating from the origin with slope equal to the amplitude ratio: r = σ a σ m = A = 1 − R 1 + R r = \frac{\sigma_a}{\sigma_m} = A = \frac{1 - R}{1 + R} r = σ m σ a = A = 1 + R 1 − R Alternating Stress (sigma_a) ^
- |
- S_e +-------------------------\
- | \ ---\
- | \ ---\ Gerber Parabola
- | \ Modified Goodman ---\
- | \ ---\
- | \ ---\
- | \ ---\
- +-------+-------------------+--------------------+---> Mean Stress (sigma_m)
- 0 S_y S_ut S_ut
- ^ ^
- Soderberg Line Goodman & Gerber Intercept
Four classical failure theories define allowable operating boundaries in the first quadrant ( σ m ≥ 0 , σ a ≥ 0 \sigma_m \ge 0, \sigma_a \ge 0 σ m ≥ 0 , σ a ≥ 0 ):
1. Modified Goodman Criterion
The Modified Goodman relation connects the fully corrected endurance limit S e S_e S e on the σ a \sigma_a σ a -axis to the ultimate tensile strength S u t S_{ut} S u t on the σ m \sigma_m σ m -axis via a straight line: σ a S e + σ m S u t = 1 n G \frac{\sigma_a}{S_e} + \frac{\sigma_m}{S_{ut}} = \frac{1}{n_G} S e σ a + S u t σ m = n G 1
Solving for the Goodman factor of safety n G n_G n G along a constant load line ( r = σ a / σ m r = \sigma_a / \sigma_m r = σ a / σ m ): n G = 1 σ a S e + σ m S u t = S e S u t σ a S u t + σ m S e n_G = \frac{1}{\frac{\sigma_a}{S_e} + \frac{\sigma_m}{S_{ut}}} = \frac{S_e S_{ut}}{\sigma_a S_{ut} + \sigma_m S_e} n G = S e σ a + S u t σ m 1 = σ a S u t + σ m S e S e S u t
Note
The Modified Goodman criterion is by far the most widely adopted design tool in industrial mechanical engineering. Because almost all experimental fatigue failure points for ductile metals lie above the Goodman line, it provides a safe, conservative lower bound.
2. Soderberg Criterion
The Soderberg line connects the endurance limit S e S_e S e to the tensile yield strength S y S_y S y : σ a S e + σ m S y = 1 n S ⟹ n S = S e S y σ a S y + σ m S e \frac{\sigma_a}{S_e} + \frac{\sigma_m}{S_y} = \frac{1}{n_S} \implies n_S = \frac{S_e S_y}{\sigma_a S_y + \sigma_m S_e} S e σ a + S y σ m = n S 1 ⟹ n S = σ a S y + σ m S e S e S y
The Soderberg criterion is overly conservative because it heavily penalizes mean stress by replacing S u t S_{ut} S u t with S y S_y S y . While it guarantees that static yielding will never occur, it unnecessarily inflates component dimensions and weight.
3. Gerber Parabola
The Gerber criterion models the relationship as a parabolic curve connecting S e S_e S e to S u t S_{ut} S u t : n σ a S e + ( n σ m S u t ) 2 = 1 \frac{n \sigma_a}{S_e} + \left(\frac{n \sigma_m}{S_{ut}}\right)^2 = 1 S e n σ a + ( S u t n σ m ) 2 = 1
Rearranging into standard quadratic form A n 2 + B n − 1 = 0 A n^2 + B n - 1 = 0 A n 2 + B n − 1 = 0 : ( σ m S u t ) 2 n 2 + ( σ a S e ) n − 1 = 0 \left(\frac{\sigma_m}{S_{ut}}\right)^2 n^2 + \left(\frac{\sigma_a}{S_e}\right) n - 1 = 0 ( S u t σ m ) 2 n 2 + ( S e σ a ) n − 1 = 0
Applying the quadratic formula yields the Gerber factor of safety n Gerber n_{\text{Gerber}} n Gerber : n Gerber = − σ a S e + ( σ a S e ) 2 + 4 ( σ m S u t ) 2 2 ( σ m S u t ) 2 = 1 2 ( S u t σ m ) 2 ( σ a S e ) [ − 1 + 1 + ( 2 σ m S e σ a S u t ) 2 ] n_{\text{Gerber}} = \frac{-\frac{\sigma_a}{S_e} + \sqrt{\left(\frac{\sigma_a}{S_e}\right)^2 + 4\left(\frac{\sigma_m}{S_{ut}}\right)^2}}{2\left(\frac{\sigma_m}{S_{ut}}\right)^2} = \frac{1}{2}\left(\frac{S_{ut}}{\sigma_m}\right)^2 \left(\frac{\sigma_a}{S_e}\right) \left[-1 + \sqrt{1 + \left(\frac{2 \sigma_m S_e}{\sigma_a S_{ut}}\right)^2}\right] n Gerber = 2 ( S u t σ m ) 2 − S e σ a + ( S e σ a ) 2 + 4 ( S u t σ m ) 2 = 2 1 ( σ m S u t ) 2 ( S e σ a ) − 1 + 1 + ( σ a S u t 2 σ m S e ) 2
The Gerber parabola accurately models the mean of experimental failure points for ductile alloys. However, because it represents an average fit, roughly 50% of real test specimens fail below the Gerber curve. Consequently, it must be paired with higher design factors of safety in mission-critical applications.
4. ASME Elliptic Criterion
The ASME Elliptic criterion connects S e S_e S e and S y S_y S y through a quarter-ellipse: ( n σ a S e ) 2 + ( n σ m S y ) 2 = 1 \left(\frac{n \sigma_a}{S_e}\right)^2 + \left(\frac{n \sigma_m}{S_y}\right)^2 = 1 ( S e n σ a ) 2 + ( S y n σ m ) 2 = 1
Solving directly for the ASME Elliptic factor of safety n E n_E n E : n E = 1 ( σ a S e ) 2 + ( σ m S y ) 2 n_E = \frac{1}{\sqrt{\left(\frac{\sigma_a}{S_e}\right)^2 + \left(\frac{\sigma_m}{S_y}\right)^2}} n E = ( S e σ a ) 2 + ( S y σ m ) 2 1
The ASME Elliptic curve is a smooth envelope that ends at S y S_y S y , but near the mean-stress axis it lies outside the Langer yield line, so the first-cycle yield check below is still required (Shigley pairs every fatigue criterion, including ASME Elliptic, with the Langer line).
The Langer Static Yield Line Check
Fatigue failure criteria dictate whether a component will develop propagating cracks over millions of cycles. However, fatigue criteria do not prevent gross plastic deformation or yielding during the very first load cycle. If the maximum peak stress σ max = σ m + σ a \sigma_{\max} = \sigma_m + \sigma_a σ m a x = σ m + σ a exceeds the material's yield strength S y S_y S y , the part will undergo permanent structural deformation immediately upon startup. Alternating Stress (sigma_a) ^
- |
- S_y +------------\
- | ---\ Langer Static Yield Line
- S_e +------\ ---\ (Slope = -1)
- | ---\ ---\
- | Safe ---\ ---\
- | Operating ---\ ---\
- | Zone ---\ ---\
- +-----------------------+----------+---> Mean Stress (sigma_m)
- 0 S_e S_y
The Langer static yield line forms an absolute upper ceiling on the Haigh diagram connecting ( 0 , S y ) (0, S_y) ( 0 , S y ) to ( S y , 0 ) (S_y, 0) ( S y , 0 ) with a constant slope of − 1 -1 − 1 : σ a + σ m ≤ S y n y ⟺ σ max ≤ S y n y \sigma_a + \sigma_m \le \frac{S_y}{n_y} \iff \sigma_{\max} \le \frac{S_y}{n_y} σ a + σ m ≤ n y S y ⟺ σ m a x ≤ n y S y
Solving for the static yield safety factor n y n_y n y : n y = S y σ a + σ m = S y σ max n_y = \frac{S_y}{\sigma_a + \sigma_m} = \frac{S_y}{\sigma_{\max}} n y = σ a + σ m S y = σ m a x S y
Important
The Complete Design Rule: The true allowable design space on the Haigh diagram is bounded by the inner envelope of the chosen fatigue curve (Modified Goodman, Gerber, or ASME Elliptic) AND the Langer static yield line:
n design = min ( n fatigue , n y ) n_{\text{design}} = \min(n_{\text{fatigue}}, n_y) n design = min ( n fatigue , n y )
Steep load lines (alternating stress dominant) usually make fatigue govern, while shallow load lines (large tensile mean stress) can make first-cycle yielding govern. The crossover depends on S e S_e S e , S u t S_{ut} S u t and S y S_y S y , so always compute both factors and report the smaller.
Multiaxial Fatigue & Fluctuating Stresses
Many machine elements experience combined fluctuating multiaxial stresses. A classic example is a power transmission shaft subjected to a completely reversed bending moment ( M M M ) combined with a steady drive torque ( T T T ), generating alternating normal bending stresses σ a \sigma_a σ a and steady torsional shear stresses τ m \tau_m τ m .
Equivalent von Mises Alternating & Mean Stresses
For synchronous, in-phase cyclic multiaxial stresses, the alternating and mean stress states are independently converted into scalar von Mises equivalent stresses:
Equivalent Alternating von Mises Stress ( σ a ′ \sigma_a' σ a ′ ) : σ a ′ = σ a 2 + 3 τ a 2 \sigma_a' = \sqrt{\sigma_a^2 + 3\tau_a^2} σ a ′ = σ a 2 + 3 τ a 2
Equivalent Mean von Mises Stress ( σ m ′ \sigma_m' σ m ′ ) : σ m ′ = σ m 2 + 3 τ m 2 \sigma_m' = \sqrt{\sigma_m^2 + 3\tau_m^2} σ m ′ = σ m 2 + 3 τ m 2
Once σ a ′ \sigma_a' σ a ′ and σ m ′ \sigma_m' σ m ′ are computed, they are inserted directly into the uniaxial fatigue failure equations: σ a ′ S e + σ m ′ S u t = 1 n G (Modified Goodman with von Mises) \frac{\sigma_a'}{S_e} + \frac{\sigma_m'}{S_{ut}} = \frac{1}{n_G} \quad \text{(Modified Goodman with von Mises)} S e σ a ′ + S u t σ m ′ = n G 1 (Modified Goodman with von Mises) σ a ′ + σ m ′ ≤ S y n y (Langer Yield with von Mises) \sigma_a' + \sigma_m' \le \frac{S_y}{n_y} \quad \text{(Langer Yield with von Mises)} σ a ′ + σ m ′ ≤ n y S y (Langer Yield with von Mises)
Sines Method for Combined Cyclic Torsion & Bending
Extensive experimental testing shows that steady mean torsional shear stresses have virtually zero detrimental effect on the fatigue endurance limit of ductile metals. Sines formulated an alternative criterion that incorporates hydrostatic mean stress while excluding steady shear: σ a ′ S e + C m ( σ x , m + σ y , m + σ z , m ) S u t ≤ 1 n \frac{\sigma_a'}{S_e} + \frac{C_m (\sigma_{x,m} + \sigma_{y,m} + \sigma_{z,m})}{S_{ut}} \le \frac{1}{n} S e σ a ′ + S u t C m ( σ x , m + σ y , m + σ z , m ) ≤ n 1
Under pure steady torque τ m \tau_m τ m (where normal mean stresses are zero: σ x , m = σ y , m = 0 \sigma_{x,m} = \sigma_{y,m} = 0 σ x , m = σ y , m = 0 ), the mean term vanishes completely, predicting that steady torque does not degrade alternating bending fatigue resistance.
Cumulative Fatigue Damage: The Palmgren-Miner Linear Damage Rule
Real-world mechanical systems operate under variable-amplitude spectrum loading rather than constant stress amplitudes. An automobile suspension encounters smooth asphalt, expansion joints, and occasional severe potholes; an aircraft wing experiences taxiing, climb gust turbulence, cruising, and landing impact. Stress ^ Block 1: n1 cycles at sigma_1 Block 2: n2 at sigma_2
- | +----+ +----+ +----+ +--+ +--+ +--+
- | | | | | | | | | | | | |
- | | | | | | | +--+ +--+ | | | | | |
- +-------+----+---+----+---+----+--+--+--+--+----+--+--+--+--+--+---> Time
- Block 3: n3
- The Palmgren-Miner Rule
The Palmgren-Miner linear damage hypothesis assumes that each individual load cycle at stress amplitude σ i \sigma_i σ i consumes a constant fraction of the component's total fatigue life: Cycle Ratio for Block i = n i N i \text{Cycle Ratio for Block } i = \frac{n_i}{N_i} Cycle Ratio for Block i = N i n i
where:
n i n_i n i is the number of cycles applied at stress amplitude σ i \sigma_i σ i .
N i N_i N i is the fatigue life (cycles to failure) if stress amplitude σ i \sigma_i σ i operated alone, calculated from Basquin's equation N i = ( σ i / a ) 1 / b N_i = (\sigma_i / a)^{1/b} N i = ( σ i / a ) 1/ b .
The total cumulative damage fraction D D D is the linear summation across all k k k spectrum blocks: D = ∑ i = 1 k n i N i D = \sum_{i=1}^k \frac{n_i}{N_i} D = i = 1 ∑ k N i n i
Failure is predicted when cumulative damage reaches unity: D ≥ 1.0 D \ge 1.0 D ≥ 1.0
If the cumulative damage accrued over an operational inspection interval is D D D , the remaining useful life fraction is ( 1 − D ) (1 - D) ( 1 − D ) . If block j j j continues until failure, the remaining allowable cycles n remaining , j n_{\text{remaining}, j} n remaining , j is: n remaining , j = ( 1 − D ) N j n_{\text{remaining}, j} = (1 - D) N_j n remaining , j = ( 1 − D ) N j
Critical Limitations & Load Sequencing Effects
While widely specified in design codes for its mathematical simplicity, Miner's rule possesses major engineering limitations:
Linearity & Commutativity Assumption : Miner's rule assumes damage accumulates linearly and independently of loading sequence ( A → B A \to B A → B accumulates identical damage to B → A B \to A B → A ). In reality, fatigue damage is non-linear.
High-to-Low Sequencing ( H → L H \to L H → L ) : When high-stress cycles occur early in service life, they rapidly initiate Stage I microcracks and generate adverse tensile residual stresses at notch roots. Subsequent low-stress cycles—which normally would require millions of cycles to nucleate a crack—immediately propagate the pre-existing crack. Under high-to-low loading, failure occurs at damage fractions significantly below unity:
D failure ≈ 0.50 to 0.80 D_{\text{failure}} \approx 0.50\text{ to }0.80 D failure ≈ 0.50 to 0.80
Low-to-High Sequencing ( L → H L \to H L → H ) : Early cycles applied at low stress amplitudes can produce cyclic strain hardening (strain aging) and blunt microcrack tips (the coaxing effect ). The component can endure cumulative damage fractions exceeding unity:
D failure ≈ 1.20 to 1.60 D_{\text{failure}} \approx 1.20\text{ to }1.60 D failure ≈ 1.20 to 1.60
Sub-Endurance Limit Cycling : In constant-amplitude testing, cycles below S e S_e S e cause zero damage ( N = ∞ N = \infty N = ∞ ). In spectrum loading, once an early overload initiates a crack, subsequent stress cycles below the original endurance limit continue to propagate the crack, contributing actively to cumulative damage.
Comparison Table: Classical Fatigue Failure Criteria
Criterion Governing Formula Intercepts on Haigh Diagram Design Conservatism Primary Application
Soderberg σ a S e + σ m S y = 1 n \frac{\sigma_a}{S_e} + \frac{\sigma_m}{S_y} = \frac{1}{n} S e σ a + S y σ m = n 1 ( S y , 0 ) (S_y, 0) ( S y , 0 ) and ( 0 , S e ) (0, S_e) ( 0 , S e ) Overly conservative; penalizes mean stress heavily Structural civil codes, heavy machinery where zero yielding is allowed
Modified Goodman σ a S e + σ m S u t = 1 n \frac{\sigma_a}{S_e} + \frac{\sigma_m}{S_{ut}} = \frac{1}{n} S e σ a + S u t σ m = n 1 ( S u t , 0 ) (S_{ut}, 0) ( S u t , 0 ) and ( 0 , S e ) (0, S_e) ( 0 , S e ) Conservative; safe lower bound for ductile metals Standard mechanical engineering machine design (shafts, links)
Gerber Parabola n σ a S e + ( n σ m S u t ) 2 = 1 \frac{n \sigma_a}{S_e} + \left(\frac{n \sigma_m}{S_{ut}}\right)^2 = 1 S e n σ a + ( S u t n σ m ) 2 = 1 ( S u t , 0 ) (S_{ut}, 0) ( S u t , 0 ) and ( 0 , S e ) (0, S_e) ( 0 , S e ) Best-fit to mean test data; 50% fail below line Aerospace, high-performance engines, failure analysis
ASME Elliptic ( n σ a S e ) 2 + ( n σ m S y ) 2 = 1 \left(\frac{n \sigma_a}{S_e}\right)^2 + \left(\frac{n \sigma_m}{S_y}\right)^2 = 1 ( S e n σ a ) 2 + ( S y n σ m ) 2 = 1 ( S y , 0 ) (S_y, 0) ( S y , 0 ) and ( 0 , S e ) (0, S_e) ( 0 , S e ) Fits ductile test data well; still needs a Langer check Shaft design (from the former ANSI/ASME B106.1M shaft standard)
Langer Yield Line σ a + σ m ≤ S y n y \sigma_a + \sigma_m \le \frac{S_y}{n_y} σ a + σ m ≤ n y S y ( S y , 0 ) (S_y, 0) ( S y , 0 ) and ( 0 , S y ) (0, S_y) ( 0 , S y ) Exact static yield limit (slope = − 1 -1 − 1 ) Mandatory companion check to prevent initial cycle plastic yield
Realistic Worked Engineering Scenario: Actuator Linkage Under Spectrum Loading P_min = 3,000 lbf P_max = 15,000 lbf
- +===================[ Actuator Tie Rod ]===================+
- | Area A = 0.375 in^2 | Cold-Rolled AISI 1020 Steel |
- | S_ut = 68.0 kpsi | S_y = 57.0 kpsi |
- | Fully Modified Axial Endurance Limit: S_e = 22.0 kpsi |
- | Fatigue Stress Concentration Factor: K_f = 1.35 |
- +=========================================================+
- Problem Statement
A structural tie rod in an automated packaging mechanism is subjected to a cyclic axial force fluctuating between P max = 15 , 000 lbf P_{\max} = 15,000\text{ lbf} P m a x = 15 , 000 lbf (tension) and P min = 3 , 000 lbf P_{\min} = 3,000\text{ lbf} P m i n = 3 , 000 lbf (tension). The rod is fabricated from cold-rolled AISI 1020 steel:
- Ultimate tensile strength: S u t = 68.0 kpsi S_{ut} = 68.0\text{ kpsi} S u t = 68.0 kpsi
- Yield strength: S y = 57.0 kpsi S_y = 57.0\text{ kpsi} S y = 57.0 kpsi
- Fully corrected axial endurance limit: S e = 22.0 kpsi S_e = 22.0\text{ kpsi} S e = 22.0 kpsi
- Critical cross-sectional area: A = 0.375 in 2 A = 0.375\text{ in}^2 A = 0.375 in 2
- Fatigue stress concentration factor at mounting eyelet: K f = 1.35 K_f = 1.35 K f = 1.35
Calculate:
Nominal and peak alternating and mean stresses ( σ a , σ m \sigma_a, \sigma_m σ a , σ m ), stress ratio R R R , and amplitude ratio A A A .
The first-cycle static yield factor of safety n y n_y n y using the Langer line.
The fatigue factor of safety n G n_G n G using the Modified Goodman criterion.
The fatigue factor of safety n Gerber n_{\text{Gerber}} n Gerber using the Gerber parabola.
The cumulative damage fraction D D D and remaining life if the rod subsequently experiences a three-block variable load spectrum:
Block 1: n 1 = 30 , 000 n_1 = 30,000 n 1 = 30 , 000 cycles at a stress level where N 1 = 150 , 000 N_1 = 150,000 N 1 = 150 , 000 cycles
Block 2: n 2 = 120 , 000 n_2 = 120,000 n 2 = 120 , 000 cycles at a stress level where N 2 = 400 , 000 N_2 = 400,000 N 2 = 400 , 000 cycles
Block 3: n 3 = 500 , 000 n_3 = 500,000 n 3 = 500 , 000 cycles at a stress level where N 3 = 2 , 500 , 000 N_3 = 2,500,000 N 3 = 2 , 500 , 000 cycles
- Step-by-Step Mathematical Solution
- Step 1: Stress Components & Ratios
Nominal maximum and minimum axial stresses: σ max , 0 = P max A = 15 , 000 lbf 0.375 in 2 = 40 , 000 psi = 40.0 kpsi \sigma_{\max,0} = \frac{P_{\max}}{A} = \frac{15,000\text{ lbf}}{0.375\text{ in}^2} = 40,000\text{ psi} = 40.0\text{ kpsi} σ m a x , 0 = A P m a x = 0.375 in 2 15 , 000 lbf = 40 , 000 psi = 40.0 kpsi σ min , 0 = P min A = 3 , 000 lbf 0.375 in 2 = 8 , 000 psi = 8.0 kpsi \sigma_{\min,0} = \frac{P_{\min}}{A} = \frac{3,000\text{ lbf}}{0.375\text{ in}^2} = 8,000\text{ psi} = 8.0\text{ kpsi} σ m i n , 0 = A P m i n = 0.375 in 2 3 , 000 lbf = 8 , 000 psi = 8.0 kpsi
Stress ratio R R R : R = σ min , 0 σ max , 0 = 8.0 kpsi 40.0 kpsi = 0.200 (Tension–Tension Loading) R = \frac{\sigma_{\min,0}}{\sigma_{\max,0}} = \frac{8.0\text{ kpsi}}{40.0\text{ kpsi}} = 0.200 \quad \text{(Tension--Tension Loading)} R = σ m a x , 0 σ m i n , 0 = 40.0 kpsi 8.0 kpsi = 0.200 (Tension–Tension Loading)
Nominal alternating and mean stresses: σ a , 0 = σ max , 0 − σ min , 0 2 = 40.0 − 8.0 2 = 16.0 kpsi \sigma_{a,0} = \frac{\sigma_{\max,0} - \sigma_{\min,0}}{2} = \frac{40.0 - 8.0}{2} = 16.0\text{ kpsi} σ a , 0 = 2 σ m a x , 0 − σ m i n , 0 = 2 40.0 − 8.0 = 16.0 kpsi σ m , 0 = σ max , 0 + σ min , 0 2 = 40.0 + 8.0 2 = 24.0 kpsi \sigma_{m,0} = \frac{\sigma_{\max,0} + \sigma_{\min,0}}{2} = \frac{40.0 + 8.0}{2} = 24.0\text{ kpsi} σ m , 0 = 2 σ m a x , 0 + σ m i n , 0 = 2 40.0 + 8.0 = 24.0 kpsi
Amplitude ratio A A A : A = σ a σ m = 16.0 24.0 = 0.667 A = \frac{\sigma_a}{\sigma_m} = \frac{16.0}{24.0} = 0.667 A = σ m σ a = 24.0 16.0 = 0.667
Actual peak stresses incorporating fatigue stress concentration K f = 1.35 K_f = 1.35 K f = 1.35 : σ a = K f σ a , 0 = 1.35 × 16.0 kpsi = 21.60 kpsi \sigma_a = K_f \sigma_{a,0} = 1.35 \times 16.0\text{ kpsi} = 21.60\text{ kpsi} σ a = K f σ a , 0 = 1.35 × 16.0 kpsi = 21.60 kpsi σ m = K f σ m , 0 = 1.35 × 24.0 kpsi = 32.40 kpsi \sigma_m = K_f \sigma_{m,0} = 1.35 \times 24.0\text{ kpsi} = 32.40\text{ kpsi} σ m = K f σ m , 0 = 1.35 × 24.0 kpsi = 32.40 kpsi σ max = σ a + σ m = 21.60 + 32.40 = 54.00 kpsi \sigma_{\max} = \sigma_a + \sigma_m = 21.60 + 32.40 = 54.00\text{ kpsi} σ m a x = σ a + σ m = 21.60 + 32.40 = 54.00 kpsi
Step 2: First-Cycle Yield Check (Langer Line)
Check whether peak transient stress causes plastic yield during initial application: n y = S y σ max = S y σ a + σ m = 57.0 kpsi 54.0 kpsi = 1.056 ≈ 1.06 n_y = \frac{S_y}{\sigma_{\max}} = \frac{S_y}{\sigma_a + \sigma_m} = \frac{57.0\text{ kpsi}}{54.0\text{ kpsi}} = 1.056 \approx 1.06 n y = σ m a x S y = σ a + σ m S y = 54.0 kpsi 57.0 kpsi = 1.056 ≈ 1.06
Because n y = 1.06 > 1.0 n_y = 1.06 > 1.0 n y = 1.06 > 1.0 , the tie rod will not yield on the first load application.
Step 3: Fatigue Factor of Safety: Modified Goodman
Applying the Modified Goodman equation: σ a S e + σ m S u t = 1 n G \frac{\sigma_a}{S_e} + \frac{\sigma_m}{S_{ut}} = \frac{1}{n_G} S e σ a + S u t σ m = n G 1 21.60 kpsi 22.00 kpsi + 32.40 kpsi 68.00 kpsi = 0.98182 + 0.47647 = 1.45829 \frac{21.60\text{ kpsi}}{22.00\text{ kpsi}} + \frac{32.40\text{ kpsi}}{68.00\text{ kpsi}} = 0.98182 + 0.47647 = 1.45829 22.00 kpsi 21.60 kpsi + 68.00 kpsi 32.40 kpsi = 0.98182 + 0.47647 = 1.45829 n G = 1 1.45829 = 0.686 ≈ 0.69 n_G = \frac{1}{1.45829} = 0.686 \approx 0.69 n G = 1.45829 1 = 0.686 ≈ 0.69
Because n G = 0.69 < 1.0 n_G = 0.69 < 1.0 n G = 0.69 < 1.0 , the Modified Goodman criterion predicts fatigue failure prior to infinite life ( N < 10 6 N < 10^6 N < 1 0 6 cycles) .
Step 4: Fatigue Factor of Safety: Gerber Parabola
Applying the Gerber equation in quadratic form: ( σ m S u t ) 2 n 2 + ( σ a S e ) n − 1 = 0 \left(\frac{\sigma_m}{S_{ut}}\right)^2 n^2 + \left(\frac{\sigma_a}{S_e}\right) n - 1 = 0 ( S u t σ m ) 2 n 2 + ( S e σ a ) n − 1 = 0
Compute coefficients: σ m S u t = 32.40 68.00 = 0.47647 ⟹ ( σ m S u t ) 2 = 0.22702 \frac{\sigma_m}{S_{ut}} = \frac{32.40}{68.00} = 0.47647 \implies \left(\frac{\sigma_m}{S_{ut}}\right)^2 = 0.22702 S u t σ m = 68.00 32.40 = 0.47647 ⟹ ( S u t σ m ) 2 = 0.22702 σ a S e = 21.60 22.00 = 0.98182 \frac{\sigma_a}{S_e} = \frac{21.60}{22.00} = 0.98182 S e σ a = 22.00 21.60 = 0.98182
Quadratic equation: 0.22702 n 2 + 0.98182 n − 1 = 0 0.22702 n^2 + 0.98182 n - 1 = 0 0.22702 n 2 + 0.98182 n − 1 = 0 n Gerber = − 0.98182 + ( 0.98182 ) 2 − 4 ( 0.22702 ) ( − 1 ) 2 ( 0.22702 ) = − 0.98182 + 0.96397 + 0.90808 0.45404 n_{\text{Gerber}} = \frac{-0.98182 + \sqrt{(0.98182)^2 - 4(0.22702)(-1)}}{2(0.22702)} = \frac{-0.98182 + \sqrt{0.96397 + 0.90808}}{0.45404} n Gerber = 2 ( 0.22702 ) − 0.98182 + ( 0.98182 ) 2 − 4 ( 0.22702 ) ( − 1 ) = 0.45404 − 0.98182 + 0.96397 + 0.90808 n Gerber = − 0.98182 + 1.87205 0.45404 = − 0.98182 + 1.36823 0.45404 = 0.38641 0.45404 = 0.851 ≈ 0.85 n_{\text{Gerber}} = \frac{-0.98182 + \sqrt{1.87205}}{0.45404} = \frac{-0.98182 + 1.36823}{0.45404} = \frac{0.38641}{0.45404} = 0.851 \approx 0.85 n Gerber = 0.45404 − 0.98182 + 1.87205 = 0.45404 − 0.98182 + 1.36823 = 0.45404 0.38641 = 0.851 ≈ 0.85
While Gerber is less conservative than Goodman ( 0.85 0.85 0.85 vs 0.69 0.69 0.69 ), it also confirms n < 1.0 n < 1.0 n < 1.0 , predicting finite life.
Step 5: Cumulative Damage Analysis (Palmgren-Miner)
Evaluating the three spectrum loading blocks: D 1 = n 1 N 1 = 30 , 000 150 , 000 = 0.200 D_1 = \frac{n_1}{N_1} = \frac{30,000}{150,000} = 0.200 D 1 = N 1 n 1 = 150 , 000 30 , 000 = 0.200 D 2 = n 2 N 2 = 120 , 000 400 , 000 = 0.300 D_2 = \frac{n_2}{N_2} = \frac{120,000}{400,000} = 0.300 D 2 = N 2 n 2 = 400 , 000 120 , 000 = 0.300 D 3 = n 3 N 3 = 500 , 000 2 , 500 , 000 = 0.200 D_3 = \frac{n_3}{N_3} = \frac{500,000}{2,500,000} = 0.200 D 3 = N 3 n 3 = 2 , 500 , 000 500 , 000 = 0.200
Total cumulative damage fraction accrued: D = D 1 + D 2 + D 3 = 0.200 + 0.300 + 0.200 = 0.700 D = D_1 + D_2 + D_3 = 0.200 + 0.300 + 0.200 = 0.700 D = D 1 + D 2 + D 3 = 0.200 + 0.300 + 0.200 = 0.700
Remaining Damage Capacity : Damage Margin = 1.000 − D = 1.000 − 0.700 = 0.300 ( 30 % remaining life ) \text{Damage Margin} = 1.000 - D = 1.000 - 0.700 = 0.300 \quad (30\% \text{ remaining life}) Damage Margin = 1.000 − D = 1.000 − 0.700 = 0.300 ( 30% remaining life )
Remaining Cycle Capacity Under Block 2 Conditions :
If the linkage continues operating exclusively under the Block 2 loading regime: n remaining , 2 = ( 1.000 − D ) × N 2 = 0.300 × 400 , 000 = 120 , 000 cycles n_{\text{remaining}, 2} = (1.000 - D) \times N_2 = 0.300 \times 400,000 = 120,000\text{ cycles} n remaining , 2 = ( 1.000 − D ) × N 2 = 0.300 × 400 , 000 = 120 , 000 cycles
Load Sequencing Caution : If Block 1 (the highest stress level) was applied first in the machine's life, early microcracking can cause failure at a damage sum well below 1.0 (values of about 0.5 to 0.8 are often reported). At D = 0.70 D = 0.70 D = 0.70 , the tie rod is entering its critical wear-out phase and must be slated for immediate non-destructive ultrasonic inspection or scheduled replacement.