Study guide
2.2 Static Failure Theories for Ductile and Brittle Materials
PE Mechanical Exam
Track your progress as you read
Finished sections get a check mark.
1 Chapter 1: Exam Overview, Reference Handbook & Mechanical Engineering Fundamentals
1.1 NCEES PE Mechanical CBT Format, Three Disciplines & Reference Handbook Strategy 1.2 Engineering Economics, Cash Flow & Project Evaluation and Scheduling 1.3 Units, Dimensional Analysis & Physical Constants 1.4 Statics, Dynamics & Mechanical Equilibrium
2 Chapter 2: Mechanical Design & Analysis (Stress, Failure Theories & Components)
2.1 Stress, Strain, Principal Stresses & Combined Loading 2.2 Static Failure Theories for Ductile and Brittle Materials 2.3 Fatigue Analysis, S-N Curves & Fluctuating Stresses 2.4 Pressure Vessels, Column Buckling & Spring Design 2.5 Threaded Fasteners, Welded Connections & Mechanical Joints
3 Chapter 3: Mechanical Power Transmission, Mechanisms & Vibrations
3.1 Shaft Sizing, Torsional Deflection & Critical Speeds 3.2 Spur, Helical, Bevel & Worm Gears and Epicyclic Gear Trains 3.3 Rolling-Element & Journal Bearings, Power Screws, Clutches, Brakes & Flywheels 3.4 Four-Bar Linkages, Cam-Follower Systems & Kinematics 3.5 Single-DOF and 2-DOF Vibrations, Damping & Dynamic Balancing
4 Chapter 4: Thermal & Fluid Systems
4.1 Fluid Statics, Manometry, Submerged Surfaces & Buoyancy 4.2 Incompressible Pipe Flow, Darcy-Weisbach & Minor Losses 4.3 Pump Selection, System Curves, NPSH & Cavitation 4.4 Steady & Transient Conduction, Forced & Natural Convection 4.5 Radiation Heat Transfer, View Factors & Heat Exchanger Sizing (LMTD/NTU)
5 Chapter 5: Power Plants & Energy Conversion Systems
5.1 Thermodynamic Properties, Pure Substances & 1st/2nd Laws 5.2 Vapor Power Cycles (Rankine, Superheat, Reheat & Regeneration) 5.3 Gas Power Cycles (Brayton, Otto, Diesel, Dual & Combined Cycle) 5.4 Combustion Stoichiometry, Flue Gas Analysis & Thermochemistry 5.5 Turbomachinery, Compressible Flow & Nozzles, Renewables & Energy Storage
6 Chapter 6: HVAC & Refrigeration Systems
6.1 Psychrometric Principles & Air-Conditioning Processes 6.2 Cooling & Heating Load Calculations (CLTD/SCL/CLF & Heat Balance) 6.3 Vapor-Compression Refrigeration Cycles & Refrigerant Properties 6.4 Refrigeration Equipment (Compressors, Evaporators, Condensers, Expansion Devices) & Safety Codes 6.5 Air Distribution, Duct Design, Fans & Hydronic Water Networks 6.6 Energy Recovery Devices, HVAC Acoustics & Vibration Isolation
7 Chapter 7: Materials, Manufacturing & Processing
7.1 Ferrous/Non-Ferrous Metals, Polymers, Ceramics & Composites 7.2 Iron-Carbon Equilibrium Phase Diagram & Heat Treatment Processes 7.3 Corrosion, Wear, Creep, Hydrogen Embrittlement & Fracture Mechanics 7.4 Casting, Metal Forming, Forging, Stamping & Powder Metallurgy 7.5 Machining Dynamics, Tool Wear, Welding Metallurgy & Non-Destructive Examination (NDE)
8 Chapter 8: Measurements, Controls, Codes & Engineering Ethics
8.1 Temperature, Pressure, Flow & Strain Transducers and Signal Conditioning 8.2 Feedback Control Loops, PID Tuning, Frequency Response & Stability 8.3 ASME Boiler & Pressure Vessel Code, ASHRAE, OSHA & NFPA Safety Standards 8.4 NCEES Model Rules, Engineering Ethics & Professional Seal Liability
2.2 Static Failure Theories for Ductile and Brittle Materials
Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI
Ductile materials (defined by true fracture strain ϵ f ≥ 0.05 \epsilon_f \ge 0.05 ϵ f ≥ 0.05 ) fail by macroscopic shear yielding along crystallographic slip planes, whereas brittle materials ( ϵ f < 0.05 \epsilon_f < 0.05 ϵ f < 0.05 ) fail by tensile cleavage fracture without significant plastic strain.
The Maximum Shear Stress (MSS / Tresca) theory is conservative, postulating that yield occurs when absolute maximum shear stress reaches shear yield strength: τ max, abs ≥ S y / 2 \tau_{\text{max, abs}} \ge S_y / 2 τ max, abs ≥ S y /2 .
The Distortion Energy (DE / von Mises) theory isolates shear distortion energy from hydrostatic stress, predicting yield when effective stress σ ′ = σ 1 2 − σ 1 σ 2 + σ 2 2 ≥ S y \sigma' = \sqrt{\sigma_1^2 - \sigma_1\sigma_2 + \sigma_2^2} \ge S_y σ ′ = σ 1 2 − σ 1 σ 2 + σ 2 2 ≥ S y . Under pure shear, von Mises predicts S s y = S y / 3 ≈ 0.577 S y S_{sy} = S_y / \sqrt{3} \approx 0.577 S_y S sy = S y / 3 ≈ 0.577 S y , providing 15.5 % 15.5\% 15.5% greater allowable load capacity than Tresca ( S s y = 0.500 S y S_{sy} = 0.500 S_y S sy = 0.500 S y ).
Brittle materials exhibit asymmetric compressive-to-tensile strength ratios ( S u c ≫ S u t S_{uc} \gg S_{ut} S u c ≫ S u t ); the Modified Mohr (MM) theory provides the most accurate experimental match across all four quadrants, outperforming the overly conservative Coulomb-Mohr and the unsafe Rankine (Maximum Normal Stress) criteria.
Safety factors are defined as n = Strength / Stress n = \text{Strength} / \text{Stress} n = Strength / Stress ; calculating n n n requires strict alignment with the appropriate failure surface boundary and material class.
Last updated: August 2026
Static Failure Theories for Ductile and Brittle Materials
Predicting whether a machine element will survive multiaxial static loading requires relating complex stress tensors ( σ x , σ y , σ z , τ x y , τ y z , τ z x ) (\sigma_x, \sigma_y, \sigma_z, \tau_{xy}, \tau_{yz}, \tau_{zx}) ( σ x , σ y , σ z , τ x y , τ yz , τ z x ) to standard uniaxial tensile test properties: yield strength ( S y S_y S y ), ultimate tensile strength ( S u t S_{ut} S u t ), and ultimate compressive strength ( S u c S_{uc} S u c ). Because materials exhibit fundamentally different failure physics depending on ductility, selecting the correct failure theory is vital.
1. Material Ductility Classification Criterion
Materials are classified based on their true plastic strain at fracture ϵ f \epsilon_f ϵ f (or percent elongation in a standard 2-inch tensile gauge length): +-----------------------------------------------------------------------------+
- | DUCTILE VS. BRITTLE CLASSIFICATION |
- | |
- | [DUCTILE MATERIALS] ---> \epsilon_f \ge 0.05 (Elongation \ge 5\%) |
- | - Examples: Structural steels, aluminum, |
- | copper, brass, titanium alloys |
- | - Failure Mode: Shear slip / plastic yielding|
- | - Theories: Tresca (MSS) & von Mises (DE) |
- | |
- | [BRITTLE MATERIALS] ---> \epsilon_f < 0.05 (Elongation < 5\%) |
- | - Examples: Gray cast iron, hardened tool |
- | steels, ceramics, structural glass |
- | - Failure Mode: Tensile cleavage fracture |
- | - Theories: Rankine (MNS), BCM, Mod-Mohr |
- +-----------------------------------------------------------------------------+
- 2. Ductile Yield Failure Theories: Tresca (MSS) vs. von Mises (DE)
- 1. Maximum Shear Stress Theory (MSS / Tresca Criterion)
Formulated by Henri Tresca, this theory assumes yielding begins when the absolute maximum shear stress in a multiaxial element reaches the maximum shear stress at yielding in a standard uniaxial tensile specimen ( S y / 2 S_y / 2 S y /2 ). τ max, abs = σ 1 − σ 3 2 = S y 2 n ⟹ σ 1 − σ 3 = S y n \tau_{\text{max, abs}} = \frac{\sigma_1 - \sigma_3}{2} = \frac{S_y}{2 n} \implies \sigma_1 - \sigma_3 = \frac{S_y}{n} τ max, abs = 2 σ 1 − σ 3 = 2 n S y ⟹ σ 1 − σ 3 = n S y
In 2D Plane Stress (with σ A , σ B \sigma_A, \sigma_B σ A , σ B and out-of-plane σ z = 0 \sigma_z = 0 σ z = 0 ):
Quadrant 1 ( σ A , σ B > 0 \sigma_A, \sigma_B > 0 σ A , σ B > 0 ): σ 1 = σ A , σ 3 = 0 ⟹ n = S y σ A \sigma_1 = \sigma_A, \sigma_3 = 0 \implies n = \frac{S_y}{\sigma_A} σ 1 = σ A , σ 3 = 0 ⟹ n = σ A S y
Quadrant 3 ( σ A , σ B < 0 \sigma_A, \sigma_B < 0 σ A , σ B < 0 ): σ 1 = 0 , σ 3 = σ B ⟹ n = S y ∣ σ B ∣ \sigma_1 = 0, \sigma_3 = \sigma_B \implies n = \frac{S_y}{|\sigma_B|} σ 1 = 0 , σ 3 = σ B ⟹ n = ∣ σ B ∣ S y
Quadrants 2 & 4 (Opposite signs, σ A > 0 > σ B \sigma_A > 0 > \sigma_B σ A > 0 > σ B ): σ 1 = σ A , σ 3 = σ B ⟹ n = S y σ A − σ B \sigma_1 = \sigma_A, \sigma_3 = \sigma_B \implies n = \frac{S_y}{\sigma_A - \sigma_B} σ 1 = σ A , σ 3 = σ B ⟹ n = σ A − σ B S y
2. Distortion Energy Theory (DE / von Mises / Hencky-Huber)
Proposed by Richard von Mises, this theory recognizes that total strain energy density ( u u u ) consists of volumetric strain energy ( u v u_v u v , caused by hydrostatic pressure that changes volume without causing shear yield) and distortion strain energy ( u d u_d u d , caused by deviatoric stress that alters shape). +-----------------------------------------------------------------------------+
- | DISTORTION ENERGY FORMULATION (von Mises) |
- | |
- | Total Strain Energy Density: u = u_v + u_d |
- | |
- | Distortion Energy Density: u_d = \frac{1+\nu}{3E} \left[\sigma'^2\right] |
- | |
- | von Mises Effective Stress: \sigma' \le \frac{S_y}{n} |
- +-----------------------------------------------------------------------------+
3D General Stress Tensor: σ ′ = 1 2 ( σ x − σ y ) 2 + ( σ y − σ z ) 2 + ( σ z − σ x ) 2 + 6 ( τ x y 2 + τ y z 2 + τ z x 2 ) \sigma' = \frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}\sqrt{(\sigma_x - \sigma_y)^2 + (\sigma_y - \sigma_z)^2 + (\sigma_z - \sigma_x)^2 + 6(\tau_{xy}^2 + \tau_{yz}^2 + \tau_{zx}^2)} σ ′ = 2 1 ( σ x − σ y ) 2 + ( σ y − σ z ) 2 + ( σ z − σ x ) 2 + 6 ( τ x y 2 + τ yz 2 + τ z x 2 )
2D Plane Stress State ( σ z = τ x z = τ y z = 0 \sigma_z = \tau_{xz} = \tau_{yz} = 0 σ z = τ x z = τ yz = 0 ): σ ′ = σ x 2 − σ x σ y + σ y 2 + 3 τ x y 2 = σ 1 2 − σ 1 σ 2 + σ 2 2 \sigma' = \sqrt{\sigma_x^2 - \sigma_x \sigma_y + \sigma_y^2 + 3\tau_{xy}^2} = \sqrt{\sigma_1^2 - \sigma_1 \sigma_2 + \sigma_2^2} σ ′ = σ x 2 − σ x σ y + σ y 2 + 3 τ x y 2 = σ 1 2 − σ 1 σ 2 + σ 2 2
- Factor of Safety ( n n n ): n = S y σ ′ n = \frac{S_y}{\sigma'} n = σ ′ S y
- Comparison & The Pure Shear Advantage (15.5% Rule) \sigma_2
- ^
- | von Mises Ellipse
- +----+----+ /---\
- | | | / \
- -------+----+----+-[-------]--------> \sigma_1
- | | | \ /
- +----+----+ \---/
- | Tresca Hexagon
Consider a shaft in pure shear τ \tau τ (where principal stresses are σ 1 = + τ , σ 2 = − τ , σ 3 = 0 \sigma_1 = +\tau, \sigma_2 = -\tau, \sigma_3 = 0 σ 1 = + τ , σ 2 = − τ , σ 3 = 0 ):
Tresca (MSS): τ max, abs = τ − ( − τ ) 2 = τ = S y 2 ⟹ S s y = 0.500 S y \tau_{\text{max, abs}} = \frac{\tau - (-\tau)}{2} = \tau = \frac{S_y}{2} \implies S_{sy} = 0.500 S_y τ max, abs = 2 τ − ( − τ ) = τ = 2 S y ⟹ S sy = 0.500 S y
von Mises (DE): σ ′ = τ 2 − τ ( − τ ) + ( − τ ) 2 = 3 τ 2 = 3 τ = S y ⟹ S s y = S y 3 ≈ 0.577 S y \sigma' = \sqrt{\tau^2 - \tau(-\tau) + (-\tau)^2} = \sqrt{3\tau^2} = \sqrt{3}\tau = S_y \implies S_{sy} = \frac{S_y}{\sqrt{3}} \approx 0.577 S_y σ ′ = τ 2 − τ ( − τ ) + ( − τ ) 2 = 3 τ 2 = 3 τ = S y ⟹ S sy = 3 S y ≈ 0.577 S y Capacity Increase = 0.57735 − 0.50000 0.50000 = + 15.47 % ≈ 15.5 % \text{Capacity Increase} = \frac{0.57735 - 0.50000}{0.50000} = +15.47\% \approx 15.5\% Capacity Increase = 0.50000 0.57735 − 0.50000 = + 15.47% ≈ 15.5%
Note
The von Mises ellipse completely encloses the Tresca hexagon, touching it at six points (pure uniaxial tension/compression and equal biaxial tension/compression). Everywhere else, von Mises permits higher allowable loads while remaining exceptionally safe and consistent with physical test data for ductile metals.
3. Brittle Static Failure Theories: Rankine, Coulomb-Mohr & Modified Mohr
Brittle materials (such as ASTM Class 20-60 Gray Cast Irons) possess compressive strengths significantly higher than their tensile strengths ( S u c ≈ 3 S_{uc} \approx 3 S u c ≈ 3 to 4 × S u t 4 \times S_{ut} 4 × S u t ). Therefore, symmetric ductile theories cannot be used. +-----------------------------------------------------------------------------+
- | BRITTLE FAILURE THEORIES |
- | |
- | 1. Maximum Normal Stress (Rankine): |
- | \sigma_1 \ge \frac{S_{ut}}{n} \quad \text{or} \quad |\sigma_3| \ge \frac{S_{uc}}{n} |
- | * Unsafe in Quadrant 4 (ignores shear-assisted cleavage). |
- | |
- | 2. Brittle Coulomb-Mohr (BCM): |
- | - Quadrant 1 (\sigma_1 \ge \sigma_2 \ge 0): n = S_{ut} / \sigma_1 |
| - Quadrant 4 (\sigma_1 \ge 0 \ge \sigma_2): \frac{\sigma_1}{S_{ut}} - \frac{\sigma_2}{S_{uc}} = \frac{1}{n} |
- | - Quadrant 3 (0 \ge \sigma_1 \ge \sigma_2): n = S_{uc} / |\sigma_2| |
- | * Conservative straight-line boundary. |
- | |
- | 3. Modified Mohr (MM) Theory (Recommended for PE Exam): |
- | - Quadrant 1: n = S_{ut} / \sigma_1 |
- | - Quadrant 4 (When |\sigma_2 / \sigma_1| \le 1): n = S_{ut} / \sigma_1 |
- | - Quadrant 4 (When |\sigma_2 / \sigma_1| > 1): |
- | \frac{(S_{uc} - S_{ut})\sigma_1}{S_{uc} S_{ut}} - \frac{\sigma_2}{S_{uc}} = \frac{1}{n} |
- | - Quadrant 3: n = S_{uc} / |\sigma_2| |
- +-----------------------------------------------------------------------------+ \sigma_2
- ^
- | Rankine Square (Unsafe in Q4)
- +-----------------+-----------------+
- | | |
- | | Quadrant 1 |
- | | |
- ------------+-----------------+-----------------+-------------> \sigma_1
- | | Modified Mohr (MM)
- | Quadrant 4 | Coulomb-Mohr (BCM)
- | |
- +-----------------+
- |
- 4. Failure Theory Selection Decision Matrix
Material Characteristic Recommended Theory Alternative Theory Rationale & Practical Use
Ductile ( % EL ≥ 5 % \%\text{EL} \ge 5\% % EL ≥ 5% ) Distortion Energy (von Mises) Maximum Shear Stress (Tresca) von Mises is most accurate for ductile metals; Tresca is preferred when conservative design codes mandate it.
Ductile ( S y t ≠ S y c S_{yt} \neq S_{yc} S y t = S yc ) Ductile Coulomb-Mohr None Used for unusual ductile materials with asymmetric yield strengths (e.g. magnesium alloys, plastics).
Brittle ( % EL < 5 % \%\text{EL} < 5\% % EL < 5% ) Modified Mohr (MM) Brittle Coulomb-Mohr (BCM) Modified Mohr matches empirical biaxial fracture data for gray cast iron with high precision.
Brittle ( S u t = S u c S_{ut} = S_{uc} S u t = S u c ) Maximum Normal Stress (Rankine) Modified Mohr Applicable to structural glass, isotropic ceramics, or rock mechanics.
- 5. Step-by-Step Worked Engineering Problem
- Problem Statement
A critical machine bracket is evaluated under plane stress. Finite element analysis establishes the surface stresses: σ x = 120 MPa , σ y = − 50 MPa , τ x y = 45 MPa \sigma_x = 120\text{ MPa}, \sigma_y = -50\text{ MPa}, \tau_{xy} = 45\text{ MPa} σ x = 120 MPa , σ y = − 50 MPa , τ x y = 45 MPa .
Part A: Calculate the safety factor n n n if manufactured from ductile AISI 1040 cold-drawn steel ( S y = 490 MPa S_y = 490\text{ MPa} S y = 490 MPa ) using both (1) Tresca and (2) von Mises.
Part B: Calculate the safety factor n n n if cast from brittle ASTM Class 30 gray iron ( S u t = 210 MPa , S u c = 750 MPa S_{ut} = 210\text{ MPa}, S_{uc} = 750\text{ MPa} S u t = 210 MPa , S u c = 750 MPa ) using (1) Coulomb-Mohr and (2) Modified Mohr.
Step 1: Principal Stress Determination σ avg = 120 + ( − 50 ) 2 = 35.0 MPa \sigma_{\text{avg}} = \frac{120 + (-50)}{2} = 35.0\text{ MPa} σ avg = 2 120 + ( − 50 ) = 35.0 MPa R = ( 120 − ( − 50 ) 2 ) 2 + 45 2 = ( 85 ) 2 + 45 2 = 7225 + 2025 = 96.177 MPa R = \sqrt{\left(\frac{120 - (-50)}{2}\right)^2 + 45^2} = \sqrt{(85)^2 + 45^2} = \sqrt{7225 + 2025} = 96.177\text{ MPa} R = ( 2 120 − ( − 50 ) ) 2 + 4 5 2 = ( 85 ) 2 + 4 5 2 = 7225 + 2025 = 96.177 MPa σ 1 = 35.0 + 96.177 = 131.18 MPa \sigma_1 = 35.0 + 96.177 = 131.18\text{ MPa} σ 1 = 35.0 + 96.177 = 131.18 MPa σ 2 = 35.0 − 96.177 = − 61.18 MPa \sigma_2 = 35.0 - 96.177 = -61.18\text{ MPa} σ 2 = 35.0 − 96.177 = − 61.18 MPa σ 3 = 0 MPa \sigma_3 = 0\text{ MPa} σ 3 = 0 MPa
Part A: Ductile Steel ( S y = 490 MPa S_y = 490\text{ MPa} S y = 490 MPa )
Tresca (MSS): Since σ 1 > 0 \sigma_1 > 0 σ 1 > 0 and σ 2 < 0 \sigma_2 < 0 σ 2 < 0 , σ 3 = σ 2 = − 61.18 MPa \sigma_3 = \sigma_2 = -61.18\text{ MPa} σ 3 = σ 2 = − 61.18 MPa : τ max, abs = σ 1 − σ 2 2 = 131.18 − ( − 61.18 ) 2 = 96.18 MPa \tau_{\text{max, abs}} = \frac{\sigma_1 - \sigma_2}{2} = \frac{131.18 - (-61.18)}{2} = 96.18\text{ MPa} τ max, abs = 2 σ 1 − σ 2 = 2 131.18 − ( − 61.18 ) = 96.18 MPa n MSS = S y σ 1 − σ 2 = 490 192.36 = 2.55 n_{\text{MSS}} = \frac{S_y}{\sigma_1 - \sigma_2} = \frac{490}{192.36} = 2.55 n MSS = σ 1 − σ 2 S y = 192.36 490 = 2.55
von Mises (DE): σ ′ = σ 1 2 − σ 1 σ 2 + σ 2 2 = ( 131.18 ) 2 − ( 131.18 ) ( − 61.18 ) + ( − 61.18 ) 2 \sigma' = \sqrt{\sigma_1^2 - \sigma_1\sigma_2 + \sigma_2^2} = \sqrt{(131.18)^2 - (131.18)(-61.18) + (-61.18)^2} σ ′ = σ 1 2 − σ 1 σ 2 + σ 2 2 = ( 131.18 ) 2 − ( 131.18 ) ( − 61.18 ) + ( − 61.18 ) 2 σ ′ = 17208.19 + 8025.59 + 3742.99 = 28976.77 = 170.23 MPa \sigma' = \sqrt{17208.19 + 8025.59 + 3742.99} = \sqrt{28976.77} = 170.23\text{ MPa} σ ′ = 17208.19 + 8025.59 + 3742.99 = 28976.77 = 170.23 MPa n DE = S y σ ′ = 490 170.23 = 2.88 n_{\text{DE}} = \frac{S_y}{\sigma'} = \frac{490}{170.23} = 2.88 n DE = σ ′ S y = 170.23 490 = 2.88
Part B: Brittle Cast Iron ( S u t = 210 MPa , S u c = 750 MPa S_{ut} = 210\text{ MPa}, S_{uc} = 750\text{ MPa} S u t = 210 MPa , S u c = 750 MPa )
Here σ 1 = 131.18 MPa > 0 \sigma_1 = 131.18\text{ MPa} > 0 σ 1 = 131.18 MPa > 0 and σ 2 = − 61.18 MPa < 0 \sigma_2 = -61.18\text{ MPa} < 0 σ 2 = − 61.18 MPa < 0 (Quadrant 4).
Brittle Coulomb-Mohr (BCM): 1 n = σ 1 S u t − σ 2 S u c = 131.18 210 − − 61.18 750 = 0.6247 + 0.0816 = 0.7063 ⟹ n BCM = 1 0.7063 = 1.42 \frac{1}{n} = \frac{\sigma_1}{S_{ut}} - \frac{\sigma_2}{S_{uc}} = \frac{131.18}{210} - \frac{-61.18}{750} = 0.6247 + 0.0816 = 0.7063 \implies n_{\text{BCM}} = \frac{1}{0.7063} = 1.42 n 1 = S u t σ 1 − S u c σ 2 = 210 131.18 − 750 − 61.18 = 0.6247 + 0.0816 = 0.7063 ⟹ n BCM = 0.7063 1 = 1.42
Modified Mohr (MM): Check slope ratio: ∣ σ 2 σ 1 ∣ = 61.18 131.18 = 0.466 ≤ 1.0 \left|\frac{\sigma_2}{\sigma_1}\right| = \frac{61.18}{131.18} = 0.466 \le 1.0 σ 1 σ 2 = 131.18 61.18 = 0.466 ≤ 1.0 .
Because ∣ σ 2 / σ 1 ∣ ≤ 1 |\sigma_2 / \sigma_1| \le 1 ∣ σ 2 / σ 1 ∣ ≤ 1 , failure is governed purely by the tensile strength line: n MM = S u t σ 1 = 210 131.18 = 1.60 n_{\text{MM}} = \frac{S_{ut}}{\sigma_1} = \frac{210}{131.18} = 1.60 n MM = σ 1 S u t = 131.18 210 = 1.60
6. Common Exam Traps & PE Pro-Tips
Trap 1 — Using 2D von Mises in 3D Stress Fields: In a pressurized thick pipe where radial stress σ r ≠ 0 \sigma_r \neq 0 σ r = 0 , you cannot drop σ 3 \sigma_3 σ 3 . You must use the full 3D von Mises equation.
Trap 2 — Applying von Mises to Cast Iron: Never use ductile yield theories on gray cast iron or ceramics. Brittle materials do not yield; they shatter under tensile cleavage.
Trap 3 — Forgetting Quadrant 4 Check in Modified Mohr: If ∣ σ 2 / σ 1 ∣ > 1 |\sigma_2 / \sigma_1| > 1 ∣ σ 2 / σ 1 ∣ > 1 , you must switch to the second Quadrant 4 equation containing ( S u c − S u t ) (S_{uc} - S_{ut}) ( S u c − S u t ) .