Study guide
16.3 Relevant Costing & Short-Term Tactical Decisions
CPA Licensure Examination Philippines, CPALE
Track your progress as you read
Finished sections get a check mark.
1 Introduction & Overview of the CPALE
0.1 CPALE Structure, Qualification, and Examination Mechanics 0.2 Study Strategy, Subject Balance, and Time Management for the Three-Day Board Exam
2 FAR: Standard Setting, Conceptual Framework, Accounting Process & Financial Statements
1.1 Standard-Setting Bodies and Regulation of the Accountancy Profession 1.2 The Conceptual Framework for Financial Reporting 1.3 The Accounting Process: Journals, Worksheet, Adjusting, Closing, and Reversing Entries 1.4 Presentation of Financial Statements
3 FAR: Cash, Receivables & Financial Asset Investments
2.1 Cash, Cash Equivalents, Petty Cash, and Bank Reconciliation 2.2 Trade and Notes Receivables: Measurement, Expected Credit Losses, and Receivable Financing 2.3 Financial Asset Investments: FVPL, FVOCI, and Amortized Cost under PFRS 9
4 FAR: Inventories, Property, Plant & Equipment, and Investment Property
3.1 Inventories & Cost of Sales 3.2 Property, Plant and Equipment, Borrowing Costs, and Impairment 3.3 Investment Property and Agriculture (PAS 40 and PAS 41)
5 FAR: Intangibles, Held for Sale, Financial Liabilities & Provisions
4.1 Intangible Assets, Research and Development, and Goodwill 4.2 Non-Current Assets Held for Sale and Discontinued Operations (PFRS 5) 4.3 Financial Liabilities: Bonds Payable, Effective Interest, and Debt Restructuring 4.4 Provisions, Contingencies, Loyalty Programs, Warranties, and Unearned Revenue
6 FAR: Equity, Share-Based Payment, Leases, Income Taxes & Employee Benefits
5.1 Shareholders' Equity & Share-Based Payments 5.2 Leases under PFRS 16: Lessee, Lessor, and Sale-and-Leaseback 5.3 Income Taxes (PAS 12) and Employee Benefits (PAS 19)
7 FAR: EPS, Cash Flows, SMEs & Small Entities, and Interim Reporting
6.1 Earnings per Share and the Statement of Cash Flows 6.2 PFRS for SMEs, PFRS for Small Entities, and Micro Entities 6.3 Interim Financial Reporting (PAS 34) and Operating Segments (PFRS 8)
8 AFAR: Partnership Formation, Operations, Changes & Liquidation
7.1 Partnership Formation, Operations & Profit/Loss Allocation 7.2 Changes in Partnership Ownership: Admission, Retirement, Death, and Incorporation 7.3 Partnership Liquidation: Lump-Sum and Installment Methods
9 AFAR: Corporate Liquidation, Home Office & Branch, and Business Combinations
8.1 Corporate Liquidation & Statement of Affairs 8.2 Home Office, Branch & Agency Accounting 8.3 Business Combinations under PFRS 3
10 AFAR: Consolidation, Joint Arrangements & Associates
9.1 Consolidated Financial Statements under PFRS 10 & PAS 27 9.2 Joint Arrangements (PFRS 11): Joint Control, Joint Operations, and Joint Ventures 9.3 Investments in Associates and Joint Ventures: The Equity Method (PAS 28)
11 AFAR: Revenue Recognition and Construction Contracts
10.1 Revenue from Contracts with Customers: The Five-Step Model (PFRS 15) 10.2 Long-Term Construction Contracts: Measuring Progress, Contract Balances, and Losses 10.3 Special Revenue Issues under PFRS 15
12 AFAR: Franchises, Consignment, Foreign Currency & Derivatives
11.1 Franchise Operations and Consignment Sales 11.2 Foreign Currency Transactions and Translation (PAS 21 and PAS 29) 11.3 Derivatives and Hedge Accounting (PFRS 9)
13 AFAR: Government, Not-for-Profit, Insurance Contracts & Service Concessions
12.1 Government Accounting: The GAM for National Government Agencies 12.2 Not-for-Profit Organizations: Net Assets, Contributions, and Sector Types 12.3 Insurance Contracts (PFRS 17) and Service Concession Arrangements
14 AFAR: Cost Accounting Systems
13.1 Cost Accumulation Systems and Job Order Costing 13.2 Process Costing and Backflush Costing 13.3 Activity-Based Costing, Joint and By-Products, and Service Department Cost Allocation
15 MS: Management Accounting, Cost Behavior & CVP Analysis
14.1 The Role of Management Accounting, Professional Ethics, and Global Trends 14.2 Cost Classifications, Cost Behavior, and Cost Estimation 14.3 Cost-Volume-Profit (CVP) Analysis
16 MS: Variable Costing, Standard Costing & Budgeting
15.1 Variable Costing versus Absorption Costing 15.2 Standard Costing & Variance Analysis 15.3 Master Budgeting, Cash Budgets, and Flexible Budgets
17 MS: Performance Measurement and Relevant Costing
16.1 Responsibility Accounting, Segment Reporting, and Transfer Pricing 16.2 Balanced Scorecard, Operational Performance, and Emerging Trends 16.3 Relevant Costing & Short-Term Tactical Decisions
18 MS: Pricing, Quantitative Techniques & Financial Statement Analysis
17.1 Pricing Decisions & Profitability Analysis 17.2 Quantitative Techniques for Decision Making 17.3 Financial Statement Analysis & Ratio Analysis
19 MS: Working Capital Management and Capital Budgeting
18.1 Working Capital: Policies, Cash Conversion Cycle, and Cash Management 18.2 Working Capital: Receivables, Inventory, and Short-Term Financing 18.3 Capital Budgeting & Investment Decisions
20 MS: Risk, Cost of Capital, Financial Markets & Economics
19.1 Risk and Return, Leverage, and Cost of Capital 19.2 Financial Markets, Long-Term Financing, and Valuation 19.3 Microeconomics, Macroeconomics, and International Trade
21 AUD: Nature of Auditing, Regulation of the Profession & Code of Ethics
20.1 Nature of Auditing, Assurance, and Information Risk 20.2 The Regulatory Framework of the Accountancy Profession 20.3 Code of Ethics: Fundamental Principles, Conceptual Framework, and Threats
22 AUD: Independence, Quality Management & Engagement Planning
21.1 Independence: Financial Interests, Relationships, Rotation, Services, and Fees 21.2 Philippine Standards on Quality Management 21.3 Pre-Engagement Activities, Client Acceptance & Audit Planning
23 AUD: Audit Risk, Fraud, Materiality & Internal Control
22.1 Audit Risk Model and Fraud Risk 22.2 Materiality: Overall, Performance, and Clearly Trivial Thresholds 22.3 Understanding the Entity & Internal Control Evaluation
24 AUD: IT Environment, Audit Evidence & Sampling
23.1 Auditing in a Computer Information Systems (CIS) Environment 23.2 Audit Evidence, Assertions, Procedures, and Documentation 23.3 Audit Sampling: Attribute, Variable, and Monetary Unit Sampling
25 AUD: Business Process Audits and Auditing Practice Problems
24.1 Substantive Testing of Business Cycles 24.2 Auditing Practice: Cash and Receivables 24.3 Auditing Practice: Inventory, Property, and Liabilities
26 AUD: Completing the Audit, Reporting & Other Assurance Services
25.1 Completing the Audit, Subsequent Events & Going Concern 25.2 The Auditor's Report: Opinions, KAM, EOM, and Comparatives 25.3 Other Assurance and Related Services Engagements
27 TAX: Principles of Taxation and Assessment Remedies
26.1 Taxation: Nature, Inherent Powers, and Limitations 26.2 The Tax System: Canons, Double Taxation, Evasion, and Sources of Tax Law 26.3 Tax Remedies: Assessment, Protest, and Appeal
28 TAX: Refunds, Collection & Prescription, Gross Income, and Fringe Benefits
27.1 Tax Remedies: Refunds, Collection, and Prescription 27.2 Gross Income: Inclusions and Exclusions 27.3 De Minimis Benefits and the Fringe Benefits Tax
29 TAX: Individual and Corporate Income Taxation
28.1 Individual Income Tax: Classification, Rates, and the 8% Option 28.2 Individual Income Tax: Deductions, Passive Income, and Capital Gains 28.3 Corporate Income Taxation under the CREATE Law
30 TAX: Estate Tax, Donor's Tax, Withholding & Special Tax Laws
29.1 Estate Tax under the NIRC as Amended by the TRAIN Law 29.2 Donor's Tax under the NIRC as Amended by the TRAIN Law 29.3 Withholding Taxes, EOPT Compliance, and Special Tax Laws
31 TAX: Value-Added Tax and Percentage Taxes
30.1 Value-Added Tax: Nature, Registration, Output Tax, and Exemptions 30.2 Value-Added Tax: Input Tax, Allocation, Withholding, and Filing 30.3 Percentage Taxes & Other Business Taxes
32 TAX: Local Taxes, DST & Excise, and Incentives & Treaties
31.1 Local Taxation and Real Property Tax 31.2 Documentary Stamp Tax and Excise Taxes 31.3 Tax Incentives under CREATE MORE and Tax Treaties
33 RFBT: Law on Obligations
32.1 Obligations: Nature, Sources, and Effects 32.2 Kinds of Obligations 32.3 Extinguishment of Obligations
34 RFBT: Contracts, Defective Contracts & Sales
33.1 Law on Contracts: Essential Requisites & Performance 33.2 Defective Contracts 33.3 Sales: Nature, Object and Price, Delivery, and Double Sales
35 RFBT: Installment Sales, Credit Transactions & Partnerships
34.1 Sales: Warranties, Installment Sales, and Redemption 34.2 Credit Transactions & Security Mechanisms 34.3 Law on Partnerships
36 RFBT: Corporations - Nature, Incorporation & Board of Directors
35.1 Corporations: Nature, Separate Personality, Classes, and Nationality 35.2 Corporations: Incorporation, Articles and Bylaws, and Corporate Powers 35.3 Corporations: Board of Directors, Officers, and Fiduciary Duties
37 RFBT: Corporations - Stockholders, Capital & Corporate Changes
36.1 Corporations: Stockholders, Meetings, and One Person Corporations 36.2 Corporations: Capital Stock, Shares, and Subscriptions 36.3 Corporations: Mergers, Dissolution, Foreign Corporations, and SEC Powers
38 RFBT: Securities Regulation, Insurance & Cooperatives
37.1 Securities Regulation, Corporate Governance, and SRC Rule 68 37.2 Insurance Law 37.3 Cooperatives under the Philippine Cooperative Code (RA 9520)
39 RFBT: Banking Laws, AMLA & Bouncing Checks
38.1 Banking Laws, Bank Secrecy & PDIC 38.2 Anti-Money Laundering Act (AMLA) 38.3 Bouncing Checks Law (BP 22)
40 RFBT: Insolvency, Competition, Data Privacy & Labor Laws
39.1 Financial Rehabilitation and Insolvency Act (FRIA) 39.2 Competition, Consumer Protection, and Government Procurement 39.3 Data Privacy, Intellectual Property, and Electronic Commerce 39.4 Ease of Doing Business, Labor Standards, and Social Security
16.3 Relevant Costing & Short-Term Tactical Decisions
Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI
Relevant costs and revenues are strictly future oriented and differ among the alternative courses of action being evaluated, meaning past sunk costs, committed future obligations, and unavoidable allocated corporate overhead must be eliminated from tactical decision models.
Opportunity costs represent the net economic benefit forgone by selecting one alternative over the next best alternative; although not recorded in financial accounting general ledgers, they are indispensable in management decision analysis when operating near or at capacity constraints.
Special order decisions hinge on whether the entity possesses idle productive capacity: with excess capacity, the minimum acceptable price equals incremental variable production plus traceable avoidable costs; at full capacity, the minimum price must also compensate for lost regular contribution margin.
Segment retention decisions require evaluating segment margin (contribution margin minus traceable avoidable fixed costs); dropping an apparently unprofitable segment that exhibits a positive segment margin reduces overall enterprise operating profit because common allocated fixed costs remain intact.
When multiple products compete for constrained production factors (e.g., machine hours, labor hours, raw material units), profit maximization is achieved by ranking and producing products with the highest contribution margin per unit of the limiting constraint, rather than the highest contribution margin per unit of output or highest contribution margin ratio.
Last updated: September 2026
Relevant Costing & Short-Term Tactical Decisions
Short-term tactical decision making requires management accountants to identify, assemble, and analyze relevant data to choose among competing operational alternatives. Unlike external financial reporting governed by Philippine Financial Reporting Standards (PFRS), which mandates full absorption costing and historical cost matching, internal decision analysis relies on relevant costing (differential analysis). On the CPALE, mastering relevant costing ensures candidates can quickly cut through irrelevant data clutter and evaluate the true incremental profit impact of operational choices.
1. Principles of Relevance in Managerial Decisions
For a financial item to be classified as relevant to a business decision, it must simultaneously satisfy two indispensable criteria:
Future-Oriented : The cost or revenue must be an expected future cash flow or outlay.
Differential (Incremental) : The cost or revenue must differ among the alternatives under consideration. Criteria for Cost Relevance
- │
- ┌────────────────────────────┴────────────────────────────┐
- ▼ ▼
Is it an expected future cash flow? Does it differ among alternatives?
- │ │
- NO ────┼────► IRRELEVANT (Sunk Cost) NO ────┼────► IRRELEVANT (Unavoidable)
- │ │
- YES YES
- │ │
- └────────────────────────────┬────────────────────────────┘
- ▼
- RELEVANT COST / REVENUE
- Categories of Irrelevant Costs
Sunk Costs : Costs that have already been incurred and cannot be avoided or altered by any present or future decision. Examples include historical acquisition costs of machinery, accumulated depreciation, past book values, and previously incurred research and development outlays.
Future Costs that Do Not Differ : Expected future expenditures that will be incurred regardless of which alternative is chosen (e.g., general factory rent, property insurance under an existing non-cancellable plant lease).
Allocated Common Fixed Costs : Arbitrary prorations of enterprise-wide executive salaries, central IT, or corporate legal overhead that will persist in total whether a division or product line is retained or terminated.
Opportunity Costs
An opportunity cost represents the maximum net contribution or benefit forgone by selecting one course of action over the next best alternative. Although opportunity costs are never recognized in the general ledger or reported on PFRS financial statements (as they do not represent actual historical outlays), they are critically relevant in management accounting whenever facilities, labor, or funds operate at or near full capacity.
Qualitative Factors
Quantitative analysis must be complemented by qualitative considerations:
Employee Morale : Plant closures or component outsourcing may trigger layoffs and union friction.
Product Quality & Reliability : External vendors may compromise manufacturing tolerances or delivery schedules.
Customer Relations & Brand Perception : Discontinuing a product line may alienate loyal corporate clients who expect a comprehensive product suite.
Supplier Dependency : Outsourcing a core component gives external suppliers future pricing leverage.
2. Tactical Decision Model 1: Make or Buy (Outsourcing Decisions)
In a make-or-buy decision, management evaluates whether to manufacture an assembly component internally or purchase it from an external supplier.
Relevant Decision Framework
Relevant Costs to Make : Direct materials, direct labor, variable factory overhead, traceable avoidable fixed overhead (e.g., specialized tooling rentals, supervisory salaries that would be eliminated), plus the opportunity cost of released production capacity.
Relevant Costs to Buy : The purchase price quoted by the external supplier, incoming freight, receiving and inspection costs, and contract administration.
Irrelevant Costs : Unavoidable general fixed overhead that will continue regardless of the decision.
Worked Example: Make or Buy with Opportunity Cost
Scenario : Cebu Electronics Inc. currently manufactures 20,000 units 20{,}000\text{ units} 20 , 000 units of a subassembly (Component X-40) annually. The per-unit absorption cost to manufacture is:
- Direct materials: PHP 45 \text{PHP }45 PHP 45
- Direct labor: PHP 30 \text{PHP }30 PHP 30
- Variable factory overhead: PHP 15 \text{PHP }15 PHP 15
Fixed factory overhead (allocated): PHP 35 \text{PHP }35 PHP 35 (Total absorption cost: PHP 125 \text{PHP }125 PHP 125 )
An external vendor offers to supply 20,000 units 20{,}000\text{ units} 20 , 000 units of Component X-40 at a delivered price of PHP 105 per unit \text{PHP }105\text{ per unit} PHP 105 per unit . Analysis reveals that of the PHP 35 \text{PHP }35 PHP 35 fixed overhead, PHP 10 \text{PHP }10 PHP 10 is direct supervisor salary that can be eliminated if the component is outsourced, while the remaining PHP 25 \text{PHP }25 PHP 25 represents allocated plant depreciation and general factory insurance that will persist. Furthermore, if Component X-40 is outsourced, the freed manufacturing floor space can be rented to a neighboring business for PHP 180,000 per year \text{PHP }180{,}000\text{ per year} PHP 180 , 000 per year . Differential Cost Analysis: Make vs Buy
- (20,000 Units)
- ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
- Cost Element Make (PHP) Buy (PHP) Differential
- ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
- Purchase Price (20,000 * PHP 105) 0 2,100,000 + 2,100,000
- Direct Materials (20,000 * PHP 45) 900,000 0 - 900,000
- Direct Labor (20,000 * PHP 30) 600,000 0 - 600,000
- Variable Overhead (20,000 * PHP 15) 300,000 0 - 300,000
- Avoidable Fixed Overhead (20,000 * 10) 200,000 0 - 200,000
- Unavoidable Fixed Overhead (20,000 * 25) 500,000 500,000 0
- Opportunity Cost (Rental Income Foregone) 180,000 0 - 180,000
- ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
- Total Relevant Cost PHP 2,180,000 PHP 2,100,000 - PHP 80,000
- ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Decision : Buy from the external supplier. Outsourcing yields a net financial advantage of PHP 80,000 annually. Note that the PHP 500,000 \text{PHP }500{,}000 PHP 500 , 000 unavoidable fixed overhead is identical under both alternatives and is properly excluded from the differential advantage.
3. Tactical Decision Model 2: Accept or Reject a Special Order
A special order represents a one-time request for a batch of goods at a discounted selling price outside regular distribution channels.
Analytical Decision Rules
When Operating with Excess (Idle) Capacity :
Existing fixed overhead will be incurred regardless and is irrelevant .
Only incremental variable manufacturing costs, special tooling/setup costs, and order-specific distribution expenses are relevant.
Decision Rule : Accept if: Special Order Price > Incremental Variable Cost per Unit \text{Special Order Price} > \text{Incremental Variable Cost per Unit} Special Order Price > Incremental Variable Cost per Unit .
When Operating at Full Capacity :
Producing the special order requires displacing regular sales units.
Opportunity Cost : Lost contribution margin from regular sales sacrificed.
Decision Rule : Accept if: Special Price ≥ Incremental Variable Cost + Lost Regular Contribution Margin per Unit \text{Special Price} \ge \text{Incremental Variable Cost} + \text{Lost Regular Contribution Margin per Unit} Special Price ≥ Incremental Variable Cost + Lost Regular Contribution Margin per Unit
Worked Example: Special Order under Full vs Excess Capacity
Scenario : Davao Furniture Corp. produces ergonomic office chairs selling regularly for PHP 2,500 each \text{PHP }2{,}500\text{ each} PHP 2 , 500 each . Unit variable costs are PHP 1,400 \text{PHP }1{,}400 PHP 1 , 400 (manufacturing PHP 1,200 \text{PHP }1{,}200 PHP 1 , 200 , sales commission PHP 200 \text{PHP }200 PHP 200 ), and fixed manufacturing overhead is PHP 500 per unit \text{PHP }500\text{ per unit} PHP 500 per unit based on normal capacity of 10,000 chairs 10{,}000\text{ chairs} 10 , 000 chairs . A foreign corporation offers to purchase 1,500 chairs 1{,}500\text{ chairs} 1 , 500 chairs at a special price of PHP 1,600 each \text{PHP }1{,}600\text{ each} PHP 1 , 600 each . The special order requires additional customized branding costing PHP 100 per chair \text{PHP }100\text{ per chair} PHP 100 per chair , but incurs no regular sales commission.
Case A: Excess Capacity Exists (Current production = 8,000 chairs) :
Incremental Revenue: PHP 1,600 \text{PHP }1{,}600 PHP 1 , 600
Incremental Cost: Variable manufacturing ( PHP 1,200 \text{PHP }1{,}200 PHP 1 , 200 ) + + + Custom branding ( PHP 100 \text{PHP }100 PHP 100 ) = PHP 1,300 = \text{PHP }1{,}300 = PHP 1 , 300
Net Incremental Gain per Chair: PHP 1,600 − PHP 1,300 = PHP 300 \text{PHP }1{,}600 - \text{PHP }1{,}300 = \text{PHP }300 PHP 1 , 600 − PHP 1 , 300 = PHP 300
Total Profit Impact: 1,500 × PHP 300 = + PHP 450,000 1{,}500 \times \text{PHP }300 = +\text{PHP }450{,}000 1 , 500 × PHP 300 = + PHP 450 , 000 . Accept the special order.
Case B: Full Capacity (Current production = 10,000 chairs; 1,500 regular chairs displaced) :
Lost regular contribution margin per chair: PHP 2,500 − PHP 1,400 = PHP 1,100 \text{PHP }2{,}500 - \text{PHP }1{,}400 = \text{PHP }1{,}100 PHP 2 , 500 − PHP 1 , 400 = PHP 1 , 100
Minimum Acceptable Price: Incremental Cost ( PHP 1,300 ) + Lost Regular CM ( PHP 1,100 ) = PHP 2,400 \text{Incremental Cost } (\text{PHP }1{,}300) + \text{Lost Regular CM } (\text{PHP }1{,}100) = \text{PHP }2{,}400 Incremental Cost ( PHP 1 , 300 ) + Lost Regular CM ( PHP 1 , 100 ) = PHP 2 , 400
At PHP 1,600 \text{PHP }1{,}600 PHP 1 , 600 , the company suffers a net loss of PHP 800 per chair \text{PHP }800\text{ per chair} PHP 800 per chair ( 1,500 × PHP 800 = − PHP 1,200,000 1{,}500 \times \text{PHP }800 = -\text{PHP }1{,}200{,}000 1 , 500 × PHP 800 = − PHP 1 , 200 , 000 ). Reject the special order.
4. Tactical Decision Model 3: Drop or Keep a Segment or Product Line
When a product line, department, or business territory reports an operating loss on standard absorption financial reports, executive management may be tempted to eliminate it. Relevant costing requires evaluating the Segment Margin .
The Segment Margin Hierarchy
Sales Revenue − Variable Expenses = Contribution Margin \text{Sales Revenue} - \text{Variable Expenses} = \text{Contribution Margin} Sales Revenue − Variable Expenses = Contribution Margin
Contribution Margin − Traceable Avoidable Fixed Costs = Segment Margin \text{Contribution Margin} - \text{Traceable Avoidable Fixed Costs} = \text{Segment Margin} Contribution Margin − Traceable Avoidable Fixed Costs = Segment Margin
Segment Margin − Common Allocated Fixed Costs = Net Operating Income (Loss) \text{Segment Margin} - \text{Common Allocated Fixed Costs} = \text{Net Operating Income (Loss)} Segment Margin − Common Allocated Fixed Costs = Net Operating Income (Loss)
Traceable (Direct) Fixed Costs : Costs directly caused by the segment that disappear if the segment is eliminated (e.g., segment advertising, store rent, equipment lease).
Common (Indirect) Fixed Costs : Enterprise costs supporting multiple segments that will not change in total if one segment is dropped (e.g., company headquarters rent, president's salary).
The Golden Rule : An entity should keep any segment that generates a positive Segment Margin ( Segment Margin > 0 \text{Segment Margin} > 0 Segment Margin > 0 ), because that positive margin contributes toward absorbing common fixed costs. Dropping it would reallocate the common fixed costs across remaining segments and decrease total company operating profit by the amount of the lost segment margin.
Worked Example: Segment Retention Analysis
Scenario : Iloilo Trading Company operates three product lines with the following annual results:
- Line Item Product Line Alpha (PHP) Product Line Beta (PHP) Product Line Gamma (PHP) Total Enterprise (PHP)
- Sales Revenue 1,200,000 800,000 500,000 2,500,000
- Variable Expenses (600,000) (480,000) (350,000) (1,430,000)
- Contribution Margin 600,000 320,000 150,000 1,070,000
- Traceable Avoidable Fixed (250,000) (180,000) (90,000) (520,000)
- Segment Margin 350,000 140,000 60,000 550,000
- Common Allocated Fixed (160,000) (110,000) (80,000) (350,000)
- Net Operating Income (Loss) 190,000 30,000 (20,000) 200,000
Management wants to drop Product Line Gamma because of its PHP 20,000 \text{PHP }20{,}000 PHP 20 , 000 operating loss.
If Gamma is dropped, its PHP 150,000 \text{PHP }150{,}000 PHP 150 , 000 contribution margin is lost, and PHP 90,000 \text{PHP }90{,}000 PHP 90 , 000 of traceable fixed costs are saved.
Net loss in operating profit: Lost Segment Margin = PHP 60,000 \text{Lost Segment Margin} = \text{PHP }60{,}000 Lost Segment Margin = PHP 60 , 000 .
The PHP 80,000 \text{PHP }80{,}000 PHP 80 , 000 common fixed cost will simply be reallocated to Alpha and Beta, reducing total enterprise profit from PHP 200,000 \text{PHP }200{,}000 PHP 200 , 000 down to PHP 140,000 \text{PHP }140{,}000 PHP 140 , 000 .
Decision : Retain Product Line Gamma.
5. Tactical Decision Model 4: Sell as Is or Process Further (Joint Products)
In joint manufacturing operations (e.g., petroleum refining, meat processing, chemical synthesis), multiple distinct products emerge simultaneously from a common input at the split-off point .
The Sunk Joint Cost Fallacy
Joint Production Costs incurred up to the split-off point are past, sunk expenditures that cannot be altered by subsequent processing decisions. Any allocation of joint costs (via physical measure, sales value at split-off, or net realizable value) is strictly for inventory valuation and completely irrelevant to the sell-or-process-further decision.
Decision Rule : Process a joint product beyond the split-off point if and only if: Incremental Revenue from Further Processing > Incremental Processing Cost \text{Incremental Revenue from Further Processing} > \text{Incremental Processing Cost} Incremental Revenue from Further Processing > Incremental Processing Cost Incremental Revenue = Final Sales Value after Processing − Sales Value at Split-off \text{Incremental Revenue} = \text{Final Sales Value after Processing} - \text{Sales Value at Split-off} Incremental Revenue = Final Sales Value after Processing − Sales Value at Split-off
Worked Example: Chemical Joint Processing
Scenario : ChemLab Philippines processes raw chemicals incurring joint processing costs of PHP 1,200,000 \text{PHP }1{,}200{,}000 PHP 1 , 200 , 000 up to the split-off point, where 10,000 liters of Product X and 5,000 liters of Product Y emerge:
Joint Product Quantity Sales Value at Split-off Allocated Joint Cost Additional Processing Cost Final Sales Value
- Product X 10,000 L PHP 150 / L PHP 800,000 PHP 40 / L PHP 200 / L
- Product Y 5,000 L PHP 80 / L PHP 400,000 PHP 55 / L PHP 130 / L
Analysis for Product X :
Incremental Revenue: PHP 200 − PHP 150 = PHP 50 per liter \text{PHP }200 - \text{PHP }150 = \text{PHP }50\text{ per liter} PHP 200 − PHP 150 = PHP 50 per liter
Incremental Cost: PHP 40 per liter \text{PHP }40\text{ per liter} PHP 40 per liter
Incremental Gain: PHP 50 − PHP 40 = + PHP 10 per liter × 10,000 L = + PHP 100,000 \text{PHP }50 - \text{PHP }40 = +\text{PHP }10\text{ per liter} \times 10{,}000\text{ L} = +\text{PHP }100{,}000 PHP 50 − PHP 40 = + PHP 10 per liter × 10 , 000 L = + PHP 100 , 000 .
Decision for X: Process further into final chemical.
Analysis for Product Y :
Incremental Revenue: PHP 130 − PHP 80 = PHP 50 per liter \text{PHP }130 - \text{PHP }80 = \text{PHP }50\text{ per liter} PHP 130 − PHP 80 = PHP 50 per liter
Incremental Cost: PHP 55 per liter \text{PHP }55\text{ per liter} PHP 55 per liter
Incremental Loss: PHP 50 − PHP 55 = − PHP 5 per liter × 5,000 L = − PHP 25,000 \text{PHP }50 - \text{PHP }55 = -\text{PHP }5\text{ per liter} \times 5{,}000\text{ L} = -\text{PHP }25{,}000 PHP 50 − PHP 55 = − PHP 5 per liter × 5 , 000 L = − PHP 25 , 000 .
Decision for Y: Sell at split-off point.
6. Tactical Decision Model 5: Product Mix under Capacity Constraints
When customer demand exceeds production capacity, a business faces a bottleneck or limiting constraint (e.g., machine hours, skilled direct labor hours, raw material supply). Under capacity restrictions, the product with the highest unit contribution margin or highest contribution margin ratio is not necessarily the most profitable.
The Optimization Rule
Total enterprise operating profit is maximized by prioritizing the product that generates the highest Contribution Margin per Unit of the Constrained Resource :
CM per Constrained Resource Unit = Unit Selling Price − Unit Variable Cost Constrained Resource Required per Unit \text{CM per Constrained Resource Unit} = \frac{\text{Unit Selling Price} - \text{Unit Variable Cost}}{\text{Constrained Resource Required per Unit}} CM per Constrained Resource Unit = Constrained Resource Required per Unit Unit Selling Price − Unit Variable Cost
Worked Example: Allocating Machine Hours
Scenario : Pampanga Precision Engineering manufactures two precision components utilizing a specialized computer-numeric-control (CNC) milling machine. Total available machine capacity is 6,000 hours 6{,}000\text{ hours} 6 , 000 hours per month.
- Data Element Component Standard Component Deluxe
- Unit Selling Price PHP 500 PHP 900
- Unit Variable Cost (PHP 320) (PHP 600)
- Unit Contribution Margin PHP 180 PHP 300
- Machine Hours Required per Unit 1.5 hours 1.5\text{ hours} 1.5 hours 3.0 hours 3.0\text{ hours} 3.0 hours
Monthly Market Demand 3,000 units 3{,}000\text{ units} 3 , 000 units 1,500 units 1{,}500\text{ units} 1 , 500 units
Evaluation :
While Component Deluxe yields a higher unit contribution margin ( PHP 300 \text{PHP }300 PHP 300 vs PHP 180 \text{PHP }180 PHP 180 ), we must compute the return per machine hour: CM per Machine Hour (Standard) = PHP 180 1.5 hours = PHP 120 per hour \text{CM per Machine Hour (Standard)} = \frac{\text{PHP }180}{1.5\text{ hours}} = \text{PHP }120\text{ per hour} CM per Machine Hour (Standard) = 1.5 hours PHP 180 = PHP 120 per hour CM per Machine Hour (Deluxe) = PHP 300 3.0 hours = PHP 100 per hour \text{CM per Machine Hour (Deluxe)} = \frac{\text{PHP }300}{3.0\text{ hours}} = \text{PHP }100\text{ per hour} CM per Machine Hour (Deluxe) = 3.0 hours PHP 300 = PHP 100 per hour
Ranking : Component Standard is ranked First ; Component Deluxe is ranked Second .
Optimal Production Schedule :
Satisfy maximum demand for Component Standard: 3,000 units × 1.5 hours = 4,500 machine hours 3{,}000\text{ units} \times 1.5\text{ hours} = 4{,}500\text{ machine hours} 3 , 000 units × 1.5 hours = 4 , 500 machine hours
Allocate remaining hours to Component Deluxe: Remaining Hours = 6,000 − 4,500 = 1,500 machine hours \text{Remaining Hours} = 6{,}000 - 4{,}500 = 1{,}500\text{ machine hours} Remaining Hours = 6 , 000 − 4 , 500 = 1 , 500 machine hours Deluxe Units to Produce = 1,500 hours 3.0 hours/unit = 500 units \text{Deluxe Units to Produce} = \frac{1{,}500\text{ hours}}{3.0\text{ hours/unit}} = 500\text{ units} Deluxe Units to Produce = 3.0 hours/unit 1 , 500 hours = 500 units
Total Contribution Margin Generated : ( 3,000 × PHP 180 ) + ( 500 × PHP 300 ) = PHP 540,000 + PHP 150,000 = PHP 690,000 (3{,}000 \times \text{PHP }180) + (500 \times \text{PHP }300) = \text{PHP }540{,}000 + \text{PHP }150{,}000 = \text{PHP }690{,}000 ( 3 , 000 × PHP 180 ) + ( 500 × PHP 300 ) = PHP 540 , 000 + PHP 150 , 000 = PHP 690 , 000