Study guide

16.1 Responsibility Accounting, Segment Reporting, and Transfer Pricing

CPA Licensure Examination Philippines, CPALE

Track your progress as you read

Finished sections get a check mark.

1 Introduction & Overview of the CPALE

0.1 CPALE Structure, Qualification, and Examination Mechanics 0.2 Study Strategy, Subject Balance, and Time Management for the Three-Day Board Exam

2 FAR: Standard Setting, Conceptual Framework, Accounting Process & Financial Statements

1.1 Standard-Setting Bodies and Regulation of the Accountancy Profession 1.2 The Conceptual Framework for Financial Reporting 1.3 The Accounting Process: Journals, Worksheet, Adjusting, Closing, and Reversing Entries 1.4 Presentation of Financial Statements

3 FAR: Cash, Receivables & Financial Asset Investments

2.1 Cash, Cash Equivalents, Petty Cash, and Bank Reconciliation 2.2 Trade and Notes Receivables: Measurement, Expected Credit Losses, and Receivable Financing 2.3 Financial Asset Investments: FVPL, FVOCI, and Amortized Cost under PFRS 9

4 FAR: Inventories, Property, Plant & Equipment, and Investment Property

3.1 Inventories & Cost of Sales 3.2 Property, Plant and Equipment, Borrowing Costs, and Impairment 3.3 Investment Property and Agriculture (PAS 40 and PAS 41)

5 FAR: Intangibles, Held for Sale, Financial Liabilities & Provisions

4.1 Intangible Assets, Research and Development, and Goodwill 4.2 Non-Current Assets Held for Sale and Discontinued Operations (PFRS 5) 4.3 Financial Liabilities: Bonds Payable, Effective Interest, and Debt Restructuring 4.4 Provisions, Contingencies, Loyalty Programs, Warranties, and Unearned Revenue

6 FAR: Equity, Share-Based Payment, Leases, Income Taxes & Employee Benefits

5.1 Shareholders' Equity & Share-Based Payments 5.2 Leases under PFRS 16: Lessee, Lessor, and Sale-and-Leaseback 5.3 Income Taxes (PAS 12) and Employee Benefits (PAS 19)

7 FAR: EPS, Cash Flows, SMEs & Small Entities, and Interim Reporting

6.1 Earnings per Share and the Statement of Cash Flows 6.2 PFRS for SMEs, PFRS for Small Entities, and Micro Entities 6.3 Interim Financial Reporting (PAS 34) and Operating Segments (PFRS 8)

8 AFAR: Partnership Formation, Operations, Changes & Liquidation

7.1 Partnership Formation, Operations & Profit/Loss Allocation 7.2 Changes in Partnership Ownership: Admission, Retirement, Death, and Incorporation 7.3 Partnership Liquidation: Lump-Sum and Installment Methods

9 AFAR: Corporate Liquidation, Home Office & Branch, and Business Combinations

8.1 Corporate Liquidation & Statement of Affairs 8.2 Home Office, Branch & Agency Accounting 8.3 Business Combinations under PFRS 3

10 AFAR: Consolidation, Joint Arrangements & Associates

9.1 Consolidated Financial Statements under PFRS 10 & PAS 27 9.2 Joint Arrangements (PFRS 11): Joint Control, Joint Operations, and Joint Ventures 9.3 Investments in Associates and Joint Ventures: The Equity Method (PAS 28)

11 AFAR: Revenue Recognition and Construction Contracts

10.1 Revenue from Contracts with Customers: The Five-Step Model (PFRS 15) 10.2 Long-Term Construction Contracts: Measuring Progress, Contract Balances, and Losses 10.3 Special Revenue Issues under PFRS 15

12 AFAR: Franchises, Consignment, Foreign Currency & Derivatives

11.1 Franchise Operations and Consignment Sales 11.2 Foreign Currency Transactions and Translation (PAS 21 and PAS 29) 11.3 Derivatives and Hedge Accounting (PFRS 9)

13 AFAR: Government, Not-for-Profit, Insurance Contracts & Service Concessions

12.1 Government Accounting: The GAM for National Government Agencies 12.2 Not-for-Profit Organizations: Net Assets, Contributions, and Sector Types 12.3 Insurance Contracts (PFRS 17) and Service Concession Arrangements

14 AFAR: Cost Accounting Systems

13.1 Cost Accumulation Systems and Job Order Costing 13.2 Process Costing and Backflush Costing 13.3 Activity-Based Costing, Joint and By-Products, and Service Department Cost Allocation

15 MS: Management Accounting, Cost Behavior & CVP Analysis

14.1 The Role of Management Accounting, Professional Ethics, and Global Trends 14.2 Cost Classifications, Cost Behavior, and Cost Estimation 14.3 Cost-Volume-Profit (CVP) Analysis

16 MS: Variable Costing, Standard Costing & Budgeting

15.1 Variable Costing versus Absorption Costing 15.2 Standard Costing & Variance Analysis 15.3 Master Budgeting, Cash Budgets, and Flexible Budgets

17 MS: Performance Measurement and Relevant Costing

16.1 Responsibility Accounting, Segment Reporting, and Transfer Pricing 16.2 Balanced Scorecard, Operational Performance, and Emerging Trends 16.3 Relevant Costing & Short-Term Tactical Decisions

18 MS: Pricing, Quantitative Techniques & Financial Statement Analysis

17.1 Pricing Decisions & Profitability Analysis 17.2 Quantitative Techniques for Decision Making 17.3 Financial Statement Analysis & Ratio Analysis

19 MS: Working Capital Management and Capital Budgeting

18.1 Working Capital: Policies, Cash Conversion Cycle, and Cash Management 18.2 Working Capital: Receivables, Inventory, and Short-Term Financing 18.3 Capital Budgeting & Investment Decisions

20 MS: Risk, Cost of Capital, Financial Markets & Economics

19.1 Risk and Return, Leverage, and Cost of Capital 19.2 Financial Markets, Long-Term Financing, and Valuation 19.3 Microeconomics, Macroeconomics, and International Trade

21 AUD: Nature of Auditing, Regulation of the Profession & Code of Ethics

20.1 Nature of Auditing, Assurance, and Information Risk 20.2 The Regulatory Framework of the Accountancy Profession 20.3 Code of Ethics: Fundamental Principles, Conceptual Framework, and Threats

22 AUD: Independence, Quality Management & Engagement Planning

21.1 Independence: Financial Interests, Relationships, Rotation, Services, and Fees 21.2 Philippine Standards on Quality Management 21.3 Pre-Engagement Activities, Client Acceptance & Audit Planning

23 AUD: Audit Risk, Fraud, Materiality & Internal Control

22.1 Audit Risk Model and Fraud Risk 22.2 Materiality: Overall, Performance, and Clearly Trivial Thresholds 22.3 Understanding the Entity & Internal Control Evaluation

24 AUD: IT Environment, Audit Evidence & Sampling

23.1 Auditing in a Computer Information Systems (CIS) Environment 23.2 Audit Evidence, Assertions, Procedures, and Documentation 23.3 Audit Sampling: Attribute, Variable, and Monetary Unit Sampling

25 AUD: Business Process Audits and Auditing Practice Problems

24.1 Substantive Testing of Business Cycles 24.2 Auditing Practice: Cash and Receivables 24.3 Auditing Practice: Inventory, Property, and Liabilities

26 AUD: Completing the Audit, Reporting & Other Assurance Services

25.1 Completing the Audit, Subsequent Events & Going Concern 25.2 The Auditor's Report: Opinions, KAM, EOM, and Comparatives 25.3 Other Assurance and Related Services Engagements

27 TAX: Principles of Taxation and Assessment Remedies

26.1 Taxation: Nature, Inherent Powers, and Limitations 26.2 The Tax System: Canons, Double Taxation, Evasion, and Sources of Tax Law 26.3 Tax Remedies: Assessment, Protest, and Appeal

28 TAX: Refunds, Collection & Prescription, Gross Income, and Fringe Benefits

27.1 Tax Remedies: Refunds, Collection, and Prescription 27.2 Gross Income: Inclusions and Exclusions 27.3 De Minimis Benefits and the Fringe Benefits Tax

29 TAX: Individual and Corporate Income Taxation

28.1 Individual Income Tax: Classification, Rates, and the 8% Option 28.2 Individual Income Tax: Deductions, Passive Income, and Capital Gains 28.3 Corporate Income Taxation under the CREATE Law

30 TAX: Estate Tax, Donor's Tax, Withholding & Special Tax Laws

29.1 Estate Tax under the NIRC as Amended by the TRAIN Law 29.2 Donor's Tax under the NIRC as Amended by the TRAIN Law 29.3 Withholding Taxes, EOPT Compliance, and Special Tax Laws

31 TAX: Value-Added Tax and Percentage Taxes

30.1 Value-Added Tax: Nature, Registration, Output Tax, and Exemptions 30.2 Value-Added Tax: Input Tax, Allocation, Withholding, and Filing 30.3 Percentage Taxes & Other Business Taxes

32 TAX: Local Taxes, DST & Excise, and Incentives & Treaties

31.1 Local Taxation and Real Property Tax 31.2 Documentary Stamp Tax and Excise Taxes 31.3 Tax Incentives under CREATE MORE and Tax Treaties

33 RFBT: Law on Obligations

32.1 Obligations: Nature, Sources, and Effects 32.2 Kinds of Obligations 32.3 Extinguishment of Obligations

34 RFBT: Contracts, Defective Contracts & Sales

33.1 Law on Contracts: Essential Requisites & Performance 33.2 Defective Contracts 33.3 Sales: Nature, Object and Price, Delivery, and Double Sales

35 RFBT: Installment Sales, Credit Transactions & Partnerships

34.1 Sales: Warranties, Installment Sales, and Redemption 34.2 Credit Transactions & Security Mechanisms 34.3 Law on Partnerships

36 RFBT: Corporations - Nature, Incorporation & Board of Directors

35.1 Corporations: Nature, Separate Personality, Classes, and Nationality 35.2 Corporations: Incorporation, Articles and Bylaws, and Corporate Powers 35.3 Corporations: Board of Directors, Officers, and Fiduciary Duties

37 RFBT: Corporations - Stockholders, Capital & Corporate Changes

36.1 Corporations: Stockholders, Meetings, and One Person Corporations 36.2 Corporations: Capital Stock, Shares, and Subscriptions 36.3 Corporations: Mergers, Dissolution, Foreign Corporations, and SEC Powers

38 RFBT: Securities Regulation, Insurance & Cooperatives

37.1 Securities Regulation, Corporate Governance, and SRC Rule 68 37.2 Insurance Law 37.3 Cooperatives under the Philippine Cooperative Code (RA 9520)

39 RFBT: Banking Laws, AMLA & Bouncing Checks

38.1 Banking Laws, Bank Secrecy & PDIC 38.2 Anti-Money Laundering Act (AMLA) 38.3 Bouncing Checks Law (BP 22)

40 RFBT: Insolvency, Competition, Data Privacy & Labor Laws

39.1 Financial Rehabilitation and Insolvency Act (FRIA) 39.2 Competition, Consumer Protection, and Government Procurement 39.3 Data Privacy, Intellectual Property, and Electronic Commerce 39.4 Ease of Doing Business, Labor Standards, and Social Security

16.1 Responsibility Accounting, Segment Reporting, and Transfer Pricing

Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI

Managers of cost, revenue, profit, and investment centers are evaluated only on the revenues, costs, and assets they control.

A segmented income statement shows contribution margin, performance margin for judging the manager, and segment margin for judging the segment, without allocating common fixed costs.

The minimum transfer price equals variable cost plus the contribution margin lost on outside sales; with idle capacity it is simply the variable cost.

ROI equals margin times turnover, but it can cause managers to reject projects that earn more than the cost of capital yet less than their current ROI.

Residual income and EVA charge a required return on invested capital, so any project earning above the hurdle rate increases them.

Last updated: September 2026

Responsibility Accounting, Segment Reporting, and Transfer Pricing

Performance measurement carries eight Management Services items (syllabus topic 1.3). This section covers decentralization and responsibility centers, segmented income statements with performance and segment margins, transfer pricing, and the investment-center measures ROI, residual income, and EVA, with a comparative example of how each measure drives decisions.

1. Responsibility Accounting & Decentralization

Decentralization is the organizational practice of delegating operational decision-making authority downward to divisional and departmental managers.

Strategic Benefits and Costs of Decentralization:

Benefits: Faster operational response to local market changes, enhanced frontline motivation and job satisfaction, training ground for executive succession, and relief of top management from day-to-day operational minutiae.

Risks: Potential duplication of support services, communication friction, and sub-optimization (where segment managers make decisions that benefit their local department while harming the overall corporate entity).

Foundational Principles:

The Controllability Principle: Managers must be evaluated exclusively on revenues, expenses, or assets over which they possess significant authority to influence within a given time frame.

Goal Congruence: The structural alignment of managerial incentives such that actions taken by individual segment managers to maximize their personal performance evaluations simultaneously maximize total enterprise wealth.

The Four Types of Responsibility Centers:

Responsibility Center Manager Accountability Evaluation Focus Primary Performance Metrics

Cost Center Costs and expenses only; no authority over revenues or capital assets Operational efficiency and cost containment Standard cost variances, flexible budget spending variances

Revenue Center Revenue generation only; no control over production or pricing costs Sales volume and revenue optimization Sales volume variances, selling price variances, market share

Profit Center Both revenues and costs; no control over capital investment assets Segment profitability and commercial margins Segment Contribution Margin, Controllable Segment Margin

Investment Center Revenues, costs, and capital invested in operating assets Long-term asset efficiency and capital wealth creation Return on Investment (ROI), Residual Income (RI), Economic Value Added (EVA)

2. Segmented Income Statements and Performance Margin

A segmented income statement separates costs by behavior and by traceability and controllability , so that a segment manager is judged only on what the manager controls:

  • Line Meaning
  • Sales Segment revenue
  • Less: Variable costs Production and selling costs that vary with volume
  • Contribution margin Available to cover fixed costs

Less: Controllable traceable fixed costs Fixed costs the segment manager can influence (for example, advertising, supervisors' salaries set by the manager)

Performance (controllable) margin Used to evaluate the manager

Less: Uncontrollable traceable fixed costs Fixed costs traceable to the segment but decided above the manager (for example, depreciation of equipment bought by headquarters)

  • Segment margin Used to evaluate the segment as an economic investment
  • Less: Common fixed costs (not allocated) Headquarters costs that would remain if the segment were dropped
  • Operating income Company as a whole

Allocating common fixed costs to segments distorts both measures and invites wrong decisions to drop profitable segments.

4. Transfer Pricing

A transfer price is the price one division charges another for goods or services. It should promote goal congruence , preserve divisional autonomy, and allow fair performance evaluation.

The minimum transfer price the selling division should accept is:

Minimum transfer price = Variable cost per unit + Opportunity cost per unit (contribution margin lost on outside sales) \text{Minimum transfer price} = \text{Variable cost per unit} + \text{Opportunity cost per unit (contribution margin lost on outside sales)} Minimum transfer price = Variable cost per unit + Opportunity cost per unit (contribution margin lost on outside sales)

The maximum price the buying division will pay is its cost of buying outside. A transfer benefits the company when the minimum is at or below the maximum.

Scheme Description Main Concern

Market-based Outside market price, sometimes less selling costs avoided on internal sales Best when a competitive market exists

Cost-based Variable cost, full cost, or cost plus a markup; standard rather than actual costs avoid passing on inefficiencies May lead to decisions that ignore opportunity costs

Negotiated Set by bargaining between division managers Time-consuming; depends on bargaining power

Dual pricing Seller credited at one price (for example, market), buyer charged another (for example, variable cost) Divisional profits do not add to company profit

Example. Division A makes a component with a variable cost of PHP 60 and sells it outside for PHP 100. Division B can buy it outside for PHP 90.

If A has idle capacity , the minimum transfer price is PHP 60 and any price from PHP 60 to PHP 90 benefits the company by PHP 30 per unit.

If A is at full capacity , the minimum is 60 + (100 - 60) = PHP 100, above B's PHP 90 outside price, so the company is better off if B buys outside.

3. Performance Evaluation Metrics for Investment Centers

For investment centers (such as autonomous operating subsidiaries or strategic business units), evaluation metrics must account for both operating income and the capital assets employed:

A. Return on Investment (ROI)

ROI = Operating Income Average Operating Assets \text{ROI} = \frac{\text{Operating Income}}{\text{Average Operating Assets}} ROI = Average Operating Assets Operating Income ​

The DuPont Decomposition Framework:

DuPont analysis disaggregates ROI into two distinct operational levers— Margin (profitability per sales peso) and Turnover (asset utilization efficiency):

ROI = Operating Profit Margin × Asset Turnover \text{ROI} = \text{Operating Profit Margin} \times \text{Asset Turnover} ROI = Operating Profit Margin × Asset Turnover

ROI = ( Operating Income Sales ) × ( Sales Average Operating Assets ) \text{ROI} = \left(\frac{\text{Operating Income}}{\text{Sales}}\right) \times \left(\frac{\text{Sales}}{\text{Average Operating Assets}}\right) ROI = ( Sales Operating Income ​ ) × ( Average Operating Assets Sales ​ )

Operating Profit Margin: Reflects management's ability to control operating costs relative to sales revenue.

Asset Turnover: Reflects management's ability to generate sales volume from each peso invested in productive operating assets.

The Sub-Optimization Dilemma of ROI:

While ROI provides a normalized percentage that facilitates comparisons across business units of different sizes, it suffers from a fundamental behavioral flaw: it encourages sub-optimization . A division manager whose current operations yield a 22% ROI will reject a new capital investment opportunity that yields 16%—even if the company's cost of capital is only 11%—because taking the project would dilute the division's average ROI. Rejecting the project harms corporate shareholders because the project earns 5% above the enterprise cost of capital.

B. Residual Income (RI)

Residual Income (RI) is the net operating income earned by an investment center in excess of the minimum required return on its operating assets:

Residual Income = Operating Income − ( Minimum Required Rate of Return × Average Operating Assets ) \text{Residual Income} = \text{Operating Income} - (\text{Minimum Required Rate of Return} \times \text{Average Operating Assets}) Residual Income = Operating Income − ( Minimum Required Rate of Return × Average Operating Assets )

Where the minimum required rate of return represents the company's cost of capital or hurdle rate.

Why Residual Income Resolves Sub-Optimization:

Residual Income aligns divisional decisions with goal congruence . A project is accepted whenever it generates a positive residual income (i.e., its return exceeds the corporate hurdle rate). Under the previous example, a project yielding 16% against an 11% hurdle rate generates positive residual income, so an RI-evaluated manager will eagerly accept the project, maximizing overall corporate value.

Limitation of Residual Income: Because RI is expressed in absolute pesos, it inherently biases evaluations in favor of large divisions. A large division with PHP 100,000,000 of assets can generate more absolute residual income than a small division with PHP 10,000,000 of assets, even if the smaller division is managed far more efficiently.

C. Economic Value Added (EVA)

Economic Value Added (EVA) is a refined, proprietary variant of residual income that adjusts accounting income to reflect true economic profit:

EVA = NOPAT − ( WACC × Total Capital Employed ) \text{EVA} = \text{NOPAT} - (\text{WACC} \times \text{Total Capital Employed}) EVA = NOPAT − ( WACC × Total Capital Employed )

Where:

NOPAT = Net Operating Profit After Taxes = Operating Income × ( 1 − T ) \text{Operating Income} \times (1 - T) Operating Income × ( 1 − T )

WACC = Weighted-Average Cost of Capital (after-tax cost of debt and cost of equity)

Total Capital Employed = Total Assets minus Current Non-Interest-Bearing Liabilities (or Total Long-Term Debt plus Shareholders' Equity)

Accounting Adjustments in EVA: EVA modifies conventional PFRS accounting by capitalizing strategic expenditures like Research and Development (R&D) and brand advertising as long-term assets rather than expensing them immediately, preventing managers from cutting vital long-term investments to artificially inflate short-term earnings.

4. Comprehensive Worked Example: Comparative Evaluation of ROI and Residual Income

Davao Holdings Corporation operates two autonomous investment centers: Division North and Division South . The corporate minimum required rate of return (hurdle rate) is 12% . Operating data for the current year are as follows:

  • Operational Parameter Division North Division South
  • Average Operating Assets PHP 10,000,000 PHP 20,000,000
  • Annual Sales Revenue PHP 25,000,000 PHP 40,000,000
  • Operating Income PHP 2,200,000 PHP 2,800,000
  • Step 1: Compute Baseline Performance Metrics

Division North:

Margin: PHP 2,200,000 / PHP 25,000,000 = 8.8 % \text{PHP }2{,}200{,}000 / \text{PHP }25{,}000{,}000 = \mathbf{8.8\%} PHP 2 , 200 , 000/ PHP 25 , 000 , 000 = 8.8%

Asset Turnover: PHP 25,000,000 / PHP 10,000,000 = 2.50 times \text{PHP }25{,}000{,}000 / \text{PHP }10{,}000{,}000 = \mathbf{2.50 \text{ times}} PHP 25 , 000 , 000/ PHP 10 , 000 , 000 = 2.50 times

Current ROI: 8.8 % × 2.50 = 22.0 % 8.8\% \times 2.50 = \mathbf{22.0\%} 8.8% × 2.50 = 22.0% (or PHP 2,200,000 / PHP 10,000,000 = 22.0 % \text{PHP }2{,}200{,}000 / \text{PHP }10{,}000{,}000 = 22.0\% PHP 2 , 200 , 000/ PHP 10 , 000 , 000 = 22.0% )

Current Residual Income: RI = PHP 2,200,000 − ( 12 % × PHP 10,000,000 ) = PHP 2,200,000 − PHP 1,200,000 = PHP 1,000,000 \text{RI} = \text{PHP }2{,}200{,}000 - (12\% \times \text{PHP }10{,}000{,}000) = \text{PHP }2{,}200{,}000 - \text{PHP }1{,}200{,}000 = \mathbf{\text{PHP }1{,}000{,}000} RI = PHP 2 , 200 , 000 − ( 12% × PHP 10 , 000 , 000 ) = PHP 2 , 200 , 000 − PHP 1 , 200 , 000 = PHP 1 , 000 , 000

Division South:

Margin: PHP 2,800,000 / PHP 40,000,000 = 7.0 % \text{PHP }2{,}800{,}000 / \text{PHP }40{,}000{,}000 = \mathbf{7.0\%} PHP 2 , 800 , 000/ PHP 40 , 000 , 000 = 7.0%

Asset Turnover: PHP 40,000,000 / PHP 20,000,000 = 2.00 times \text{PHP }40{,}000{,}000 / \text{PHP }20{,}000{,}000 = \mathbf{2.00 \text{ times}} PHP 40 , 000 , 000/ PHP 20 , 000 , 000 = 2.00 times

Current ROI: 7.0 % × 2.00 = 14.0 % 7.0\% \times 2.00 = \mathbf{14.0\%} 7.0% × 2.00 = 14.0% (or PHP 2,800,000 / PHP 20,000,000 = 14.0 % \text{PHP }2{,}800{,}000 / \text{PHP }20{,}000{,}000 = 14.0\% PHP 2 , 800 , 000/ PHP 20 , 000 , 000 = 14.0% )

Current Residual Income: RI = PHP 2,800,000 − ( 12 % × PHP 20,000,000 ) = PHP 2,800,000 − PHP 2,400,000 = PHP 400,000 \text{RI} = \text{PHP }2{,}800{,}000 - (12\% \times \text{PHP }20{,}000{,}000) = \text{PHP }2{,}800{,}000 - \text{PHP }2{,}400{,}000 = \mathbf{\text{PHP }400{,}000} RI = PHP 2 , 800 , 000 − ( 12% × PHP 20 , 000 , 000 ) = PHP 2 , 800 , 000 − PHP 2 , 400 , 000 = PHP 400 , 000

Step 2: Evaluation of an Identical Capital Investment Opportunity

Both divisions are presented with an independent capital expansion proposal requiring PHP 2,000,000 in new operating assets that will yield annual operating income of PHP 320,000 : Project ROI = PHP 320,000 PHP 2,000,000 = 16.0 % \text{Project ROI} = \frac{\text{PHP }320{,}000}{\text{PHP }2{,}000{,}000} = \mathbf{16.0\%} Project ROI = PHP 2 , 000 , 000 PHP 320 , 000 ​ = 16.0%

Because the project's 16% return exceeds the 12% corporate hurdle rate, executive leadership wants both divisions to accept the project.

Step 3: Analysis of Division North's Decision

New Operating Assets: PHP 10,000,000 + PHP 2,000,000 = PHP 12,000,000 \text{PHP }10{,}000{,}000 + \text{PHP }2{,}000{,}000 = \text{PHP }12{,}000{,}000 PHP 10 , 000 , 000 + PHP 2 , 000 , 000 = PHP 12 , 000 , 000

New Operating Income: PHP 2,200,000 + PHP 320,000 = PHP 2,520,000 \text{PHP }2{,}200{,}000 + \text{PHP }320{,}000 = \text{PHP }2{,}520{,}000 PHP 2 , 200 , 000 + PHP 320 , 000 = PHP 2 , 520 , 000

New Divisional ROI: PHP 2,520,000 / PHP 12,000,000 = 21.0 % \text{PHP }2{,}520{,}000 / \text{PHP }12{,}000{,}000 = \mathbf{21.0\%} PHP 2 , 520 , 000/ PHP 12 , 000 , 000 = 21.0% (Notice that ROI declined from 22.0% to 21.0%. Under ROI evaluation, Division North's manager will reject the project to avoid diluting the division's average return!)

New Divisional Residual Income: New RI = PHP 2,520,000 − ( 12 % × PHP 12,000,000 ) = PHP 2,520,000 − PHP 1,440,000 = PHP 1,080,000 \text{New RI} = \text{PHP }2{,}520{,}000 - (12\% \times \text{PHP }12{,}000{,}000) = \text{PHP }2{,}520{,}000 - \text{PHP }1{,}440{,}000 = \mathbf{\text{PHP }1{,}080{,}000} New RI = PHP 2 , 520 , 000 − ( 12% × PHP 12 , 000 , 000 ) = PHP 2 , 520 , 000 − PHP 1 , 440 , 000 = PHP 1 , 080 , 000 (Residual Income increases by PHP 80,000 from PHP 1,000,000 to PHP 1,080,000. Under Residual Income evaluation, Division North's manager will accept the project!)

Step 4: Analysis of Division South's Decision

New Operating Assets: PHP 20,000,000 + PHP 2,000,000 = PHP 22,000,000 \text{PHP }20{,}000{,}000 + \text{PHP }2{,}000{,}000 = \text{PHP }22{,}000{,}000 PHP 20 , 000 , 000 + PHP 2 , 000 , 000 = PHP 22 , 000 , 000

New Operating Income: PHP 2,800,000 + PHP 320,000 = PHP 3,120,000 \text{PHP }2{,}800{,}000 + \text{PHP }320{,}000 = \text{PHP }3{,}120{,}000 PHP 2 , 800 , 000 + PHP 320 , 000 = PHP 3 , 120 , 000

New Divisional ROI: PHP 3,120,000 / PHP 22,000,000 = 14.18 % \text{PHP }3{,}120{,}000 / \text{PHP }22{,}000{,}000 = \mathbf{14.18\%} PHP 3 , 120 , 000/ PHP 22 , 000 , 000 = 14.18% (Notice that ROI increased from 14.0% to 14.18%. Under ROI evaluation, Division South's manager will accept the project!)

New Divisional Residual Income: New RI = PHP 3,120,000 − ( 12 % × PHP 22,000,000 ) = PHP 3,120,000 − PHP 2,640,000 = PHP 480,000 \text{New RI} = \text{PHP }3{,}120{,}000 - (12\% \times \text{PHP }22{,}000{,}000) = \text{PHP }3{,}120{,}000 - \text{PHP }2{,}640{,}000 = \mathbf{\text{PHP }480{,}000} New RI = PHP 3 , 120 , 000 − ( 12% × PHP 22 , 000 , 000 ) = PHP 3 , 120 , 000 − PHP 2 , 640 , 000 = PHP 480 , 000 (Residual Income increases by PHP 80,000 from PHP 400,000 to PHP 480,000. Under Residual Income evaluation, Division South's manager will accept the project!)

Step 5: Summary Conclusion on Goal Congruence

This scenario demonstrates why Residual Income is superior for encouraging goal congruence: under ROI, an investment that benefits the overall enterprise (earning 16% vs. a 12% cost of capital) is rejected by high-performing divisions (Division North), creating costly organizational sub-optimization.