Study guide

33.2 Defective Contracts

CPA Licensure Examination Philippines, CPALE

Track your progress as you read

Finished sections get a check mark.

1 Introduction & Overview of the CPALE

0.1 CPALE Structure, Qualification, and Examination Mechanics 0.2 Study Strategy, Subject Balance, and Time Management for the Three-Day Board Exam

2 FAR: Standard Setting, Conceptual Framework, Accounting Process & Financial Statements

1.1 Standard-Setting Bodies and Regulation of the Accountancy Profession 1.2 The Conceptual Framework for Financial Reporting 1.3 The Accounting Process: Journals, Worksheet, Adjusting, Closing, and Reversing Entries 1.4 Presentation of Financial Statements

3 FAR: Cash, Receivables & Financial Asset Investments

2.1 Cash, Cash Equivalents, Petty Cash, and Bank Reconciliation 2.2 Trade and Notes Receivables: Measurement, Expected Credit Losses, and Receivable Financing 2.3 Financial Asset Investments: FVPL, FVOCI, and Amortized Cost under PFRS 9

4 FAR: Inventories, Property, Plant & Equipment, and Investment Property

3.1 Inventories & Cost of Sales 3.2 Property, Plant and Equipment, Borrowing Costs, and Impairment 3.3 Investment Property and Agriculture (PAS 40 and PAS 41)

5 FAR: Intangibles, Held for Sale, Financial Liabilities & Provisions

4.1 Intangible Assets, Research and Development, and Goodwill 4.2 Non-Current Assets Held for Sale and Discontinued Operations (PFRS 5) 4.3 Financial Liabilities: Bonds Payable, Effective Interest, and Debt Restructuring 4.4 Provisions, Contingencies, Loyalty Programs, Warranties, and Unearned Revenue

6 FAR: Equity, Share-Based Payment, Leases, Income Taxes & Employee Benefits

5.1 Shareholders' Equity & Share-Based Payments 5.2 Leases under PFRS 16: Lessee, Lessor, and Sale-and-Leaseback 5.3 Income Taxes (PAS 12) and Employee Benefits (PAS 19)

7 FAR: EPS, Cash Flows, SMEs & Small Entities, and Interim Reporting

6.1 Earnings per Share and the Statement of Cash Flows 6.2 PFRS for SMEs, PFRS for Small Entities, and Micro Entities 6.3 Interim Financial Reporting (PAS 34) and Operating Segments (PFRS 8)

8 AFAR: Partnership Formation, Operations, Changes & Liquidation

7.1 Partnership Formation, Operations & Profit/Loss Allocation 7.2 Changes in Partnership Ownership: Admission, Retirement, Death, and Incorporation 7.3 Partnership Liquidation: Lump-Sum and Installment Methods

9 AFAR: Corporate Liquidation, Home Office & Branch, and Business Combinations

8.1 Corporate Liquidation & Statement of Affairs 8.2 Home Office, Branch & Agency Accounting 8.3 Business Combinations under PFRS 3

10 AFAR: Consolidation, Joint Arrangements & Associates

9.1 Consolidated Financial Statements under PFRS 10 & PAS 27 9.2 Joint Arrangements (PFRS 11): Joint Control, Joint Operations, and Joint Ventures 9.3 Investments in Associates and Joint Ventures: The Equity Method (PAS 28)

11 AFAR: Revenue Recognition and Construction Contracts

10.1 Revenue from Contracts with Customers: The Five-Step Model (PFRS 15) 10.2 Long-Term Construction Contracts: Measuring Progress, Contract Balances, and Losses 10.3 Special Revenue Issues under PFRS 15

12 AFAR: Franchises, Consignment, Foreign Currency & Derivatives

11.1 Franchise Operations and Consignment Sales 11.2 Foreign Currency Transactions and Translation (PAS 21 and PAS 29) 11.3 Derivatives and Hedge Accounting (PFRS 9)

13 AFAR: Government, Not-for-Profit, Insurance Contracts & Service Concessions

12.1 Government Accounting: The GAM for National Government Agencies 12.2 Not-for-Profit Organizations: Net Assets, Contributions, and Sector Types 12.3 Insurance Contracts (PFRS 17) and Service Concession Arrangements

14 AFAR: Cost Accounting Systems

13.1 Cost Accumulation Systems and Job Order Costing 13.2 Process Costing and Backflush Costing 13.3 Activity-Based Costing, Joint and By-Products, and Service Department Cost Allocation

15 MS: Management Accounting, Cost Behavior & CVP Analysis

14.1 The Role of Management Accounting, Professional Ethics, and Global Trends 14.2 Cost Classifications, Cost Behavior, and Cost Estimation 14.3 Cost-Volume-Profit (CVP) Analysis

16 MS: Variable Costing, Standard Costing & Budgeting

15.1 Variable Costing versus Absorption Costing 15.2 Standard Costing & Variance Analysis 15.3 Master Budgeting, Cash Budgets, and Flexible Budgets

17 MS: Performance Measurement and Relevant Costing

16.1 Responsibility Accounting, Segment Reporting, and Transfer Pricing 16.2 Balanced Scorecard, Operational Performance, and Emerging Trends 16.3 Relevant Costing & Short-Term Tactical Decisions

18 MS: Pricing, Quantitative Techniques & Financial Statement Analysis

17.1 Pricing Decisions & Profitability Analysis 17.2 Quantitative Techniques for Decision Making 17.3 Financial Statement Analysis & Ratio Analysis

19 MS: Working Capital Management and Capital Budgeting

18.1 Working Capital: Policies, Cash Conversion Cycle, and Cash Management 18.2 Working Capital: Receivables, Inventory, and Short-Term Financing 18.3 Capital Budgeting & Investment Decisions

20 MS: Risk, Cost of Capital, Financial Markets & Economics

19.1 Risk and Return, Leverage, and Cost of Capital 19.2 Financial Markets, Long-Term Financing, and Valuation 19.3 Microeconomics, Macroeconomics, and International Trade

21 AUD: Nature of Auditing, Regulation of the Profession & Code of Ethics

20.1 Nature of Auditing, Assurance, and Information Risk 20.2 The Regulatory Framework of the Accountancy Profession 20.3 Code of Ethics: Fundamental Principles, Conceptual Framework, and Threats

22 AUD: Independence, Quality Management & Engagement Planning

21.1 Independence: Financial Interests, Relationships, Rotation, Services, and Fees 21.2 Philippine Standards on Quality Management 21.3 Pre-Engagement Activities, Client Acceptance & Audit Planning

23 AUD: Audit Risk, Fraud, Materiality & Internal Control

22.1 Audit Risk Model and Fraud Risk 22.2 Materiality: Overall, Performance, and Clearly Trivial Thresholds 22.3 Understanding the Entity & Internal Control Evaluation

24 AUD: IT Environment, Audit Evidence & Sampling

23.1 Auditing in a Computer Information Systems (CIS) Environment 23.2 Audit Evidence, Assertions, Procedures, and Documentation 23.3 Audit Sampling: Attribute, Variable, and Monetary Unit Sampling

25 AUD: Business Process Audits and Auditing Practice Problems

24.1 Substantive Testing of Business Cycles 24.2 Auditing Practice: Cash and Receivables 24.3 Auditing Practice: Inventory, Property, and Liabilities

26 AUD: Completing the Audit, Reporting & Other Assurance Services

25.1 Completing the Audit, Subsequent Events & Going Concern 25.2 The Auditor's Report: Opinions, KAM, EOM, and Comparatives 25.3 Other Assurance and Related Services Engagements

27 TAX: Principles of Taxation and Assessment Remedies

26.1 Taxation: Nature, Inherent Powers, and Limitations 26.2 The Tax System: Canons, Double Taxation, Evasion, and Sources of Tax Law 26.3 Tax Remedies: Assessment, Protest, and Appeal

28 TAX: Refunds, Collection & Prescription, Gross Income, and Fringe Benefits

27.1 Tax Remedies: Refunds, Collection, and Prescription 27.2 Gross Income: Inclusions and Exclusions 27.3 De Minimis Benefits and the Fringe Benefits Tax

29 TAX: Individual and Corporate Income Taxation

28.1 Individual Income Tax: Classification, Rates, and the 8% Option 28.2 Individual Income Tax: Deductions, Passive Income, and Capital Gains 28.3 Corporate Income Taxation under the CREATE Law

30 TAX: Estate Tax, Donor's Tax, Withholding & Special Tax Laws

29.1 Estate Tax under the NIRC as Amended by the TRAIN Law 29.2 Donor's Tax under the NIRC as Amended by the TRAIN Law 29.3 Withholding Taxes, EOPT Compliance, and Special Tax Laws

31 TAX: Value-Added Tax and Percentage Taxes

30.1 Value-Added Tax: Nature, Registration, Output Tax, and Exemptions 30.2 Value-Added Tax: Input Tax, Allocation, Withholding, and Filing 30.3 Percentage Taxes & Other Business Taxes

32 TAX: Local Taxes, DST & Excise, and Incentives & Treaties

31.1 Local Taxation and Real Property Tax 31.2 Documentary Stamp Tax and Excise Taxes 31.3 Tax Incentives under CREATE MORE and Tax Treaties

33 RFBT: Law on Obligations

32.1 Obligations: Nature, Sources, and Effects 32.2 Kinds of Obligations 32.3 Extinguishment of Obligations

34 RFBT: Contracts, Defective Contracts & Sales

33.1 Law on Contracts: Essential Requisites & Performance 33.2 Defective Contracts 33.3 Sales: Nature, Object and Price, Delivery, and Double Sales

35 RFBT: Installment Sales, Credit Transactions & Partnerships

34.1 Sales: Warranties, Installment Sales, and Redemption 34.2 Credit Transactions & Security Mechanisms 34.3 Law on Partnerships

36 RFBT: Corporations - Nature, Incorporation & Board of Directors

35.1 Corporations: Nature, Separate Personality, Classes, and Nationality 35.2 Corporations: Incorporation, Articles and Bylaws, and Corporate Powers 35.3 Corporations: Board of Directors, Officers, and Fiduciary Duties

37 RFBT: Corporations - Stockholders, Capital & Corporate Changes

36.1 Corporations: Stockholders, Meetings, and One Person Corporations 36.2 Corporations: Capital Stock, Shares, and Subscriptions 36.3 Corporations: Mergers, Dissolution, Foreign Corporations, and SEC Powers

38 RFBT: Securities Regulation, Insurance & Cooperatives

37.1 Securities Regulation, Corporate Governance, and SRC Rule 68 37.2 Insurance Law 37.3 Cooperatives under the Philippine Cooperative Code (RA 9520)

39 RFBT: Banking Laws, AMLA & Bouncing Checks

38.1 Banking Laws, Bank Secrecy & PDIC 38.2 Anti-Money Laundering Act (AMLA) 38.3 Bouncing Checks Law (BP 22)

40 RFBT: Insolvency, Competition, Data Privacy & Labor Laws

39.1 Financial Rehabilitation and Insolvency Act (FRIA) 39.2 Competition, Consumer Protection, and Government Procurement 39.3 Data Privacy, Intellectual Property, and Electronic Commerce 39.4 Ease of Doing Business, Labor Standards, and Social Security

33.2 Defective Contracts

Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI

Philippine civil law establishes four distinct classes of defective contracts in ascending order of defectiveness: Rescissible, Voidable, Unenforceable, and Void/Inexistent.

Rescissible contracts under Article 1381 are valid and enforceable until judicially rescinded; they are grounded in economic damage or lesion (such as ward contracts with lesion exceeding 25% or alienations in fraud of creditors via accion pauliana), serve as a subsidiary remedy, and prescribe in four years.

Voidable contracts under Article 1390 are valid until annulled; they arise from legal incapacity of one party or vices of consent, and may be cured through ratification, which retroactively cleanses the contract from its inception.

Unenforceable contracts under Article 1403 are valid agreements that cannot be sued upon in court unless ratified; they encompass unauthorized agency, contracts violating the Statute of Frauds (six categories), and contracts where both parties lack capacity; partial performance removes an oral agreement from the Statute of Frauds.

Void contracts under Article 1409 are null ab initio, produce no legal effect, cannot be ratified, and the defense of nullity is imprescriptible; under the in pari delicto doctrine, neither guilty party can recover or enforce performance, subject to narrow statutory exceptions for public policy, labor standards, and usurious interest.

Last updated: September 2026

Defective Contracts

Under the Civil Code of the Philippines, defective contracts are classified into four distinct, non-overlapping categories based on the gravity of their flaw, the nature of the damage caused, and the legal remedy provided. Governed by Book IV, Title II, Chapters 5 through 9 (Articles 1380 to 1422) , mastering the hierarchy and nuances of defective contracts is among the most heavily tested areas in the CPALE Regulatory Framework for Business Transactions. The Spectrum of Defective Contracts

  • (Ranked in Ascending Order of Defectiveness)
  • │
  • ┌─────────────────────┬───────────────────┴───────────────────┬─────────────────────┐
  • ▼ ▼ ▼ ▼
  • 1. Rescissible 2. Voidable 3. Unenforceable 4. Void / Inexistent
  • (Art. 1381) (Art. 1390) (Art. 1403) (Art. 1409)
  • Valid until • Valid until • Valid agreement, • Null & void ab initio
  • rescinded annulled cannot be enforced • Produces NO legal
  • Defect: External • Defect: Vitiated in court effect
  • damage / lesion / consent or legal • Defect: Lack of • Defect: Illicit object,
  • fraud of creditors incapacity of one party authority, Statute fictitious, or
  • Prescribes: 4 yrs • Prescribes: 4 yrs of Frauds, or both contrary to law
  • Remedy: Rescission • Remedy: Annulment incapacitated • Imprescriptible
  • Curable by Ratification • Curable by Ratification • Cannot be ratified
  • 1. Rescissible Contracts (Articles 1380 to 1389)
  • Legal Status and Concept

A rescissible contract is a contract that has all the essential requisites of a valid contract (consent, object, cause) and is completely valid and legally binding until rescinded by a competent court . The defect is not intrinsic to the formation of the agreement; rather, it causes economic lesion, financial damage, or prejudice to one of the contracting parties or to a third person.

Statutory Causes under Article 1381

Under Article 1381 , the following contracts are rescissible:

Contracts Entered into by Guardians with Lesion: Contracts entered into by guardians whenever the wards whom they represent suffer lesion by more than one-fourth (more than 25%) of the value of the things which are the object thereof.

Exception (Article 1386): Contracts approved by courts of justice are NOT rescissible , regardless of the lesion suffered.

Contracts Agreed upon in Representation of Absentees with Lesion: Contracts undertaken on behalf of absentees if the latter suffer lesion by more than one-fourth (more than 25%) of the value of the things.

Contracts in Fraud of Creditors ( Accion Pauliana ): Contracts undertaken in fraud of creditors when the latter cannot in any other manner collect the claims due them.

Contracts Involving Things under Litigation: Contracts which refer to things under litigation, entered into by the defendant without the knowledge and approval of the litigants or of competent judicial authority.

Other Contracts Specially Declared by Law: All other contracts specially declared by law to be subject to rescission (such as payments made in a state of insolvency under Article 1382 for obligations to whose fulfillment the debtor could not be compelled at the time they were effected).

Cardinal Principles Governing Rescission

Subsidiary Remedy (Article 1383): The action for rescission is strictly subsidiary ; it cannot be instituted except when the party suffering damage has no other legal means to obtain reparation for the same.

Mutual Restitution (Article 1385): Rescission creates the obligation to return the things which were the object of the contract, together with their fruits, and the price with its interest. Consequently, rescission can only be carried out when the person demanding rescission is in a position to restore whatever he may be obliged to return.

Bar to Rescission (Article 1385 par. 2): Rescission cannot take place when the things which are the object of the contract are legally in the possession of third persons who did not act in bad faith. In such case, the remedy is an action for damages against the person who caused the loss.

Prescriptive Period (Article 1389): The action to claim rescission must be commenced within four (4) years . The prescriptive period begins:

  • For persons under guardianship: from the termination of the ward's incapacity;
  • For absentees: from the time the domicile or whereabouts of the absentee become known;

For contracts in fraud of creditors ( accion pauliana ): from the time of discovery of the fraud.

  • 2. Voidable Contracts (Articles 1390 to 1402)
  • Legal Status and Concept

A voidable contract (also termed an annullable contract ) is valid, binding, and effective between the parties until annulled by a proper action in court . Once annulled, it is rendered void from the beginning ( retroactive effect ).

Statutory Causes under Article 1390

Under Article 1390 , the following contracts are voidable, even though there may have been no damage to the contracting parties:

Those where one of the parties is incapable of giving consent to a contract (minors, insane or demented persons, deaf-mutes who do not know how to write);

Those where the consent is vitiated by mistake, violence, intimidation, undue influence, or fraud .

Prescriptive Period for Annulment (Article 1391)

The action for annulment must be brought within four (4) years . The counting of the 4-year period begins:

  • In cases of intimidation, violence, or undue influence : from the time the defect of the consent ceases ;
  • In cases of mistake or fraud : from the time of the discovery of the same ;

In cases of contracts entered into by incapacitated persons : from the time guardianship ceases (e.g., when the minor attains 18 years of age).

Ratification ( Confirmacion , Articles 1392 to 1396)

Ratification is the voluntary act by which the injured party or their legal representative cleanses the contract of its defects, thereby waiving the right to file an action for annulment.

Forms of Ratification (Article 1393): May be express (written or oral declaration) or tacit (implied by acts implying a necessary intention to waive the right, such as accepting benefits or executing obligations under the contract after the vice has ceased).

Unilateral Nature (Article 1395): Ratification does not require the conformity of the other contracting party who caused the defect.

Retroactive Cleansing Effect (Article 1396): Ratification cleanses the contract from all its defects from the moment it was constituted , validating it retroactively ab initio .

Mutual Restitution upon Annulment (Articles 1398 and 1399)

General Rule (Article 1398): Contracting parties must restore to each other the subject matter of the contract with its fruits, and the price paid with legal interest.

Exception for Incapacitated Persons (Article 1399): When the defect of the contract consists in the incapacity of one of the parties, the incapacitated person is not obliged to make any restitution except insofar as he has been benefited by the thing or price received by him.

  • 3. Unenforceable Contracts (Articles 1403 to 1408)
  • Legal Status and Concept

An unenforceable contract is a valid agreement, but it cannot be enforced by action or sued upon in a court of justice unless it is ratified in accordance with law. Third persons cannot assail an unenforceable contract (Article 1408).

  • The Three Distinct Classes under Article 1403
  • Under Article 1403 , three classes of contracts are unenforceable: Three Classes of Unenforceable Contracts
  • │
  • ┌────────────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┐
  • ▼ ▼ ▼
  • 1. Unauthorized Contracts 2. Statute of Frauds 3. Both Parties Incapacitated
  • (Art. 1403 No. 1) (Art. 1403 No. 2) (Art. 1403 No. 3)
  • Entered into in name of • Must be evidenced by • Neither party has legal
  • another without authority written note/memo capacity to give consent
  • In excess of powers granted subscribed by party (e.g., contract between
  • Curable by principal's charged two minors)
  • ratification (Art. 1404) • Six statutory categories • Becomes voidable if one
  • Applies ONLY to wholly guardian ratifies; valid
  • executory contracts! if both guardians ratify
  • The Statute of Frauds (Article 1403 No. 2)

The Statute of Frauds requires that certain agreements must be evidenced by some note or memorandum in writing, subscribed by the party charged or by their agent; otherwise, the agreement cannot be proved in court without the consent of the other party.

The Six Contracts Covered by the Statute of Frauds

Agreement not to be performed within a year: An agreement that by its terms is not to be performed within one (1) year from the making thereof;

Special promise to answer for the debt, default, or miscarriage of another: Collateral promises of guaranty or suretyship (an original promise where the promisor assumes primary liability is outside the statute and enforceable orally);

Agreement in consideration of marriage: Agreements made in consideration of marriage, other than a mutual promise to marry (e.g., pre-nuptial property settlements or marriage settlements);

Sale of goods, chattels, or things in action at PHP 500 or more: Agreement for the sale of goods, chattels, or things in action, at a price not less than PHP 500 , unless the buyer accepts and receives part of such goods and chattels, or pays at the time some part of the purchase money;

Lease for more than one year, or sale of real property: An agreement for the leasing for a longer period than one (1) year , or for the sale of real property or of an interest therein ;

Representation as to the credit of a third person: A representation as to the credit of a third person.

The Doctrine of Part Performance

CPALE Rule: The Statute of Frauds applies EXCLUSIVELY to wholly executory contracts (contracts where neither party has performed). If there has been partial or total execution (such as partial delivery, partial payment, or possession accompanied by improvements), the contract is taken completely out of the Statute of Frauds, and oral evidence is fully admissible to prove the contract!

Waiver of the Statute of Frauds (Article 1405)

Contracts infringing the Statute of Frauds are ratified and become enforceable:

By the failure to object to the presentation of oral evidence to prove the contract during trial; or

By the acceptance of benefits under the contract.

  • 4. Void and Inexistent Contracts (Articles 1409 to 1422)
  • Legal Status and Concept

A void contract is an absolute nullity ( null and void ab initio ). It has no legal existence, produces no legal effect whatsoever , and creates no rights or obligations. It cannot be confirmed, validated, or cured by ratification.

Statutory Causes under Article 1409

Under Article 1409 , the following contracts are inexistent and void from the beginning:

Those whose cause, object, or purpose is contrary to law, morals, good customs, public order, or public policy ;

  • Those which are absolutely simulated or fictitious ;
  • Those whose cause or object did not exist at the time of the transaction;
  • Those whose object is outside the commerce of men ;
  • Those which contemplate an impossible service ;
  • Those where the intention of the parties relative to the principal object cannot be ascertained ;

Those expressly prohibited or declared void by law (e.g., sale between spouses under Article 1490; purchase of property under administration by guardians, agents, or executors under Article 1491).

Key Principles Governing Void Contracts

Imprescriptibility (Article 1410): The action or defense for the declaration of the inexistence of a contract does not prescribe . A party may raise the defense of absolute nullity at any time.

Cannot be Ratified (Article 1409 par. 2): A void contract cannot be validated by ratification or by the passage of time.

Standing of Third Persons (Article 1421): The defense of illegality of contracts is available to third persons whose interests are directly affected.

The Doctrine of In Pari Delicto (Articles 1411 and 1412)

The principle of in pari delicto ( in pari delicto potior est conditio defendentis ) dictates that when both contracting parties are in equal fault in an illegal contract, the law leaves them where it finds them . Neither party may maintain an action against the other to enforce the contract or recover what was delivered.

Classification of Illegal Act Both Parties at Fault ( In Pari Delicto ) Only One Party at Fault

Act Constitutes a Criminal Offense (Article 1411) Neither party can recover; both are subject to criminal prosecution; instruments of the crime are forfeited to the State Innocent party may recover what he has given, and is not bound to comply with his promise

Act Does Not Constitute a Crime (Article 1412) Neither party can recover what he has given or demand performance of the other's undertaking Guilty party cannot recover or demand performance; innocent party may recover what he gave without obligation to comply

Statutory Exceptions to In Pari Delicto (Where Recovery is Permitted)

To prevent injustice and advance public policy, the Civil Code explicitly permits recovery despite the illegal agreement in the following cases:

Article 1414 (Repudiation before Illegal Purpose Achieved): When money is paid or property delivered for an illegal purpose, the person who paid or delivered may recover it from the other if he repudiates the agreement before the purpose has been accomplished, or before any damage has been caused to a third person, if public interest will be subserved.

Article 1415 (Incapacitated Party): Where one of the parties to an illegal contract is incapable of giving consent, the courts may, if the interest of justice so demands, allow recovery of money or property.

Article 1416 (Prohibition for Protection of Plaintiff): When the agreement is not illegal per se but is merely prohibited, and the prohibition by law is designed for the protection of the plaintiff, he may recover what he has paid or delivered.

Article 1417 (Excess of Price Ceilings): When the price of any article or commodity is determined by statute or law (price control laws), any person paying any amount in excess of the maximum price may recover such excess.

Articles 1418 and 1419 (Labor Standards): An employee who works beyond the statutory maximum hours or accepts compensation below the statutory minimum wage may recover overtime pay or the wage deficiency, despite any contrary agreement.

Usurious Interest (Article 1413): Any person who pays interest in excess of that allowed by usury laws may recover the whole interest paid with legal interest thereon.

5. Master Comparative Matrix of Defective Contracts

The following comprehensive matrix summarizes the cardinal distinctions among the four classes of defective contracts:

Parameter Rescissible Contracts (Art. 1381) Voidable Contracts (Art. 1390) Unenforceable Contracts (Art. 1403) Void and Inexistent Contracts (Art. 1409)

Primary Cause of Defect External economic damage, lesion (>25%), or fraud of creditors Intrinsic defect: Incapacity of one party or vitiated consent (fraud, mistake, violence) Lack of authority, non-compliance with Statute of Frauds, or both parties incapacitated Illicit cause/object, fictitious contract, contrary to law/public policy

Status Prior to Legal Action Valid and binding until judicially rescinded Valid and binding until judicially annulled Valid agreement , but cannot be sued upon in court Null and void ab initio ; produces no legal effect whatsoever

Primary Legal Remedy Action for Rescission (strictly subsidiary) Action for Annulment Objection to oral evidence; motion to dismiss Action or defense for Declaration of Absolute Nullity

Curable by Ratification? NO (remedy is indemnity or restitution, not ratification) YES (express or tacit; retroactively cleanses contract) YES (by failure to object or acceptance of benefits) NO (absolute nullity cannot be ratified or validated)

Who Can Attack the Contract? Injured party, ward, absentee, or defrauded creditor Incapacitated person or party whose consent was vitiated Only contracting parties; third persons cannot assail Contracting parties and third persons directly affected

Prescriptive Period Four (4) years (from cessation of incapacity or discovery of fraud) Four (4) years (from cessation of vice or discovery of mistake/fraud) Governed by general rules on contracts once ratified IMPRESCRIPTIBLE (Article 1410: action or defense does not prescribe)

Restitution Requirement Mutual restitution of object, fruits, price, and interest Mutual restitution; incapacitated returns only beneficial amount Not applicable until contract is ratified and enforced In pari delicto applies; no recovery unless statutory exception applies

  • 6. Comprehensive Worked Problem Scenarios
  • Problem 1: Guardian Contract with Lesion and Court Approval Trap

Scenario: Mario is the legal guardian of Mateo, a 16-year-old orphan. Mateo inherited a prime commercial parcel of land in Davao City with a prevailing fair market value of PHP 12,000,000. Mario, acting as guardian on behalf of Mateo, entered into a contract of sale selling the land to Oscar for PHP 8,500,000. Mario obtained express judicial approval from the Regional Trial Court having jurisdiction over the guardianship proceedings before executing the deed of sale. Upon reaching the age of 18, Mateo discovers that the land was sold for PHP 8,500,000 when it was worth PHP 12,000,000 (a lesion of PHP 3,500,000, which is approximately 29.17% of the value). Within two years of reaching majority, Mateo files an action to rescind the contract of sale under Article 1381(1). Will the action for rescission prosper?

Analysis:

Computation of Lesion: Lesion Amount = PHP 12,000,000 − PHP 8,500,000 = PHP 3,500,000 Percentage of Lesion = PHP 3,500,000 PHP 12,000,000 = 29.17 % \begin{aligned}

  • \text{Lesion Amount} &= \text{PHP }12{,}000{,}000 - \text{PHP }8{,}500{,}000 = \text{PHP }3{,}500{,}000 \\
  • \text{Percentage of Lesion} &= \frac{\text{PHP }3{,}500{,}000}{\text{PHP }12{,}000{,}000} = 29.17\%

\end{aligned} Lesion Amount Percentage of Lesion ​ = PHP 12 , 000 , 000 − PHP 8 , 500 , 000 = PHP 3 , 500 , 000 = PHP 12 , 000 , 000 PHP 3 , 500 , 000 ​ = 29.17% ​

Because 29.17 % > 25 % 29.17\% > 25\% 29.17% > 25% (more than one-fourth), the lesion threshold under Article 1381(1) is met.

2. The Judicial Approval Exception (Article 1386): Under Article 1386 of the Civil Code: "Rescission referred to in Nos. 1 and 2 of Article 1381 shall not take place with respect to contracts approved by the courts." 3. Conclusion: Because the sale was approved by a competent court of justice prior to execution, the contract cannot be rescinded under Article 1381(1). Mateo's action for rescission will NOT prosper .

Problem 2: Statute of Frauds and Doctrine of Part Performance

Scenario: Fernando orally agreed to sell a residential house and lot in Iloilo City to Graciela for PHP 3,000,000. Graciela paid Fernando an initial down payment of PHP 300,000 in cash, and Fernando handed over the keys to the property. Graciela immediately took physical possession of the house and expended PHP 200,000 on roof repairs and painting. Two months later, Fernando received a higher offer of PHP 4,500,000 from another buyer. Fernando tendered the return of the PHP 300,000 down payment to Graciela and refused to execute a deed of absolute sale, contending that under Article 1403 No. 2(e) (Statute of Frauds), an oral agreement for the sale of real property is unenforceable. Can Graciela compel Fernando to execute the formal deed of sale?

Analysis:

Statute of Frauds Scope: Article 1403 No. 2(e) requires contracts for the sale of real property to be in writing to be enforceable.

Application of the Doctrine of Part Performance: The Statute of Frauds applies exclusively to wholly executory contracts. Where an oral contract has been partially performed, equity intervenes to prevent the statute from being used as a shield for fraud.

Acts of Partial Performance: Graciela made partial payment of PHP 300,000, took physical possession of the property with the seller's consent, and made valuable capital improvements (PHP 200,000 repairs). These acts take the oral contract completely out of the Statute of Frauds.

Right to Compel Execution (Article 1357): Because the oral contract is valid and taken out of the Statute of Frauds, Graciela has the legal right under Article 1357 to compel Fernando to execute a public instrument of sale.

Conclusion: Graciela can legally compel Fernando to execute the deed of absolute sale. Fernando's defense under the Statute of Frauds must fail.