Study guide

32.1 Obligations: Nature, Sources, and Effects

CPA Licensure Examination Philippines, CPALE

Track your progress as you read

Finished sections get a check mark.

1 Introduction & Overview of the CPALE

0.1 CPALE Structure, Qualification, and Examination Mechanics 0.2 Study Strategy, Subject Balance, and Time Management for the Three-Day Board Exam

2 FAR: Standard Setting, Conceptual Framework, Accounting Process & Financial Statements

1.1 Standard-Setting Bodies and Regulation of the Accountancy Profession 1.2 The Conceptual Framework for Financial Reporting 1.3 The Accounting Process: Journals, Worksheet, Adjusting, Closing, and Reversing Entries 1.4 Presentation of Financial Statements

3 FAR: Cash, Receivables & Financial Asset Investments

2.1 Cash, Cash Equivalents, Petty Cash, and Bank Reconciliation 2.2 Trade and Notes Receivables: Measurement, Expected Credit Losses, and Receivable Financing 2.3 Financial Asset Investments: FVPL, FVOCI, and Amortized Cost under PFRS 9

4 FAR: Inventories, Property, Plant & Equipment, and Investment Property

3.1 Inventories & Cost of Sales 3.2 Property, Plant and Equipment, Borrowing Costs, and Impairment 3.3 Investment Property and Agriculture (PAS 40 and PAS 41)

5 FAR: Intangibles, Held for Sale, Financial Liabilities & Provisions

4.1 Intangible Assets, Research and Development, and Goodwill 4.2 Non-Current Assets Held for Sale and Discontinued Operations (PFRS 5) 4.3 Financial Liabilities: Bonds Payable, Effective Interest, and Debt Restructuring 4.4 Provisions, Contingencies, Loyalty Programs, Warranties, and Unearned Revenue

6 FAR: Equity, Share-Based Payment, Leases, Income Taxes & Employee Benefits

5.1 Shareholders' Equity & Share-Based Payments 5.2 Leases under PFRS 16: Lessee, Lessor, and Sale-and-Leaseback 5.3 Income Taxes (PAS 12) and Employee Benefits (PAS 19)

7 FAR: EPS, Cash Flows, SMEs & Small Entities, and Interim Reporting

6.1 Earnings per Share and the Statement of Cash Flows 6.2 PFRS for SMEs, PFRS for Small Entities, and Micro Entities 6.3 Interim Financial Reporting (PAS 34) and Operating Segments (PFRS 8)

8 AFAR: Partnership Formation, Operations, Changes & Liquidation

7.1 Partnership Formation, Operations & Profit/Loss Allocation 7.2 Changes in Partnership Ownership: Admission, Retirement, Death, and Incorporation 7.3 Partnership Liquidation: Lump-Sum and Installment Methods

9 AFAR: Corporate Liquidation, Home Office & Branch, and Business Combinations

8.1 Corporate Liquidation & Statement of Affairs 8.2 Home Office, Branch & Agency Accounting 8.3 Business Combinations under PFRS 3

10 AFAR: Consolidation, Joint Arrangements & Associates

9.1 Consolidated Financial Statements under PFRS 10 & PAS 27 9.2 Joint Arrangements (PFRS 11): Joint Control, Joint Operations, and Joint Ventures 9.3 Investments in Associates and Joint Ventures: The Equity Method (PAS 28)

11 AFAR: Revenue Recognition and Construction Contracts

10.1 Revenue from Contracts with Customers: The Five-Step Model (PFRS 15) 10.2 Long-Term Construction Contracts: Measuring Progress, Contract Balances, and Losses 10.3 Special Revenue Issues under PFRS 15

12 AFAR: Franchises, Consignment, Foreign Currency & Derivatives

11.1 Franchise Operations and Consignment Sales 11.2 Foreign Currency Transactions and Translation (PAS 21 and PAS 29) 11.3 Derivatives and Hedge Accounting (PFRS 9)

13 AFAR: Government, Not-for-Profit, Insurance Contracts & Service Concessions

12.1 Government Accounting: The GAM for National Government Agencies 12.2 Not-for-Profit Organizations: Net Assets, Contributions, and Sector Types 12.3 Insurance Contracts (PFRS 17) and Service Concession Arrangements

14 AFAR: Cost Accounting Systems

13.1 Cost Accumulation Systems and Job Order Costing 13.2 Process Costing and Backflush Costing 13.3 Activity-Based Costing, Joint and By-Products, and Service Department Cost Allocation

15 MS: Management Accounting, Cost Behavior & CVP Analysis

14.1 The Role of Management Accounting, Professional Ethics, and Global Trends 14.2 Cost Classifications, Cost Behavior, and Cost Estimation 14.3 Cost-Volume-Profit (CVP) Analysis

16 MS: Variable Costing, Standard Costing & Budgeting

15.1 Variable Costing versus Absorption Costing 15.2 Standard Costing & Variance Analysis 15.3 Master Budgeting, Cash Budgets, and Flexible Budgets

17 MS: Performance Measurement and Relevant Costing

16.1 Responsibility Accounting, Segment Reporting, and Transfer Pricing 16.2 Balanced Scorecard, Operational Performance, and Emerging Trends 16.3 Relevant Costing & Short-Term Tactical Decisions

18 MS: Pricing, Quantitative Techniques & Financial Statement Analysis

17.1 Pricing Decisions & Profitability Analysis 17.2 Quantitative Techniques for Decision Making 17.3 Financial Statement Analysis & Ratio Analysis

19 MS: Working Capital Management and Capital Budgeting

18.1 Working Capital: Policies, Cash Conversion Cycle, and Cash Management 18.2 Working Capital: Receivables, Inventory, and Short-Term Financing 18.3 Capital Budgeting & Investment Decisions

20 MS: Risk, Cost of Capital, Financial Markets & Economics

19.1 Risk and Return, Leverage, and Cost of Capital 19.2 Financial Markets, Long-Term Financing, and Valuation 19.3 Microeconomics, Macroeconomics, and International Trade

21 AUD: Nature of Auditing, Regulation of the Profession & Code of Ethics

20.1 Nature of Auditing, Assurance, and Information Risk 20.2 The Regulatory Framework of the Accountancy Profession 20.3 Code of Ethics: Fundamental Principles, Conceptual Framework, and Threats

22 AUD: Independence, Quality Management & Engagement Planning

21.1 Independence: Financial Interests, Relationships, Rotation, Services, and Fees 21.2 Philippine Standards on Quality Management 21.3 Pre-Engagement Activities, Client Acceptance & Audit Planning

23 AUD: Audit Risk, Fraud, Materiality & Internal Control

22.1 Audit Risk Model and Fraud Risk 22.2 Materiality: Overall, Performance, and Clearly Trivial Thresholds 22.3 Understanding the Entity & Internal Control Evaluation

24 AUD: IT Environment, Audit Evidence & Sampling

23.1 Auditing in a Computer Information Systems (CIS) Environment 23.2 Audit Evidence, Assertions, Procedures, and Documentation 23.3 Audit Sampling: Attribute, Variable, and Monetary Unit Sampling

25 AUD: Business Process Audits and Auditing Practice Problems

24.1 Substantive Testing of Business Cycles 24.2 Auditing Practice: Cash and Receivables 24.3 Auditing Practice: Inventory, Property, and Liabilities

26 AUD: Completing the Audit, Reporting & Other Assurance Services

25.1 Completing the Audit, Subsequent Events & Going Concern 25.2 The Auditor's Report: Opinions, KAM, EOM, and Comparatives 25.3 Other Assurance and Related Services Engagements

27 TAX: Principles of Taxation and Assessment Remedies

26.1 Taxation: Nature, Inherent Powers, and Limitations 26.2 The Tax System: Canons, Double Taxation, Evasion, and Sources of Tax Law 26.3 Tax Remedies: Assessment, Protest, and Appeal

28 TAX: Refunds, Collection & Prescription, Gross Income, and Fringe Benefits

27.1 Tax Remedies: Refunds, Collection, and Prescription 27.2 Gross Income: Inclusions and Exclusions 27.3 De Minimis Benefits and the Fringe Benefits Tax

29 TAX: Individual and Corporate Income Taxation

28.1 Individual Income Tax: Classification, Rates, and the 8% Option 28.2 Individual Income Tax: Deductions, Passive Income, and Capital Gains 28.3 Corporate Income Taxation under the CREATE Law

30 TAX: Estate Tax, Donor's Tax, Withholding & Special Tax Laws

29.1 Estate Tax under the NIRC as Amended by the TRAIN Law 29.2 Donor's Tax under the NIRC as Amended by the TRAIN Law 29.3 Withholding Taxes, EOPT Compliance, and Special Tax Laws

31 TAX: Value-Added Tax and Percentage Taxes

30.1 Value-Added Tax: Nature, Registration, Output Tax, and Exemptions 30.2 Value-Added Tax: Input Tax, Allocation, Withholding, and Filing 30.3 Percentage Taxes & Other Business Taxes

32 TAX: Local Taxes, DST & Excise, and Incentives & Treaties

31.1 Local Taxation and Real Property Tax 31.2 Documentary Stamp Tax and Excise Taxes 31.3 Tax Incentives under CREATE MORE and Tax Treaties

33 RFBT: Law on Obligations

32.1 Obligations: Nature, Sources, and Effects 32.2 Kinds of Obligations 32.3 Extinguishment of Obligations

34 RFBT: Contracts, Defective Contracts & Sales

33.1 Law on Contracts: Essential Requisites & Performance 33.2 Defective Contracts 33.3 Sales: Nature, Object and Price, Delivery, and Double Sales

35 RFBT: Installment Sales, Credit Transactions & Partnerships

34.1 Sales: Warranties, Installment Sales, and Redemption 34.2 Credit Transactions & Security Mechanisms 34.3 Law on Partnerships

36 RFBT: Corporations - Nature, Incorporation & Board of Directors

35.1 Corporations: Nature, Separate Personality, Classes, and Nationality 35.2 Corporations: Incorporation, Articles and Bylaws, and Corporate Powers 35.3 Corporations: Board of Directors, Officers, and Fiduciary Duties

37 RFBT: Corporations - Stockholders, Capital & Corporate Changes

36.1 Corporations: Stockholders, Meetings, and One Person Corporations 36.2 Corporations: Capital Stock, Shares, and Subscriptions 36.3 Corporations: Mergers, Dissolution, Foreign Corporations, and SEC Powers

38 RFBT: Securities Regulation, Insurance & Cooperatives

37.1 Securities Regulation, Corporate Governance, and SRC Rule 68 37.2 Insurance Law 37.3 Cooperatives under the Philippine Cooperative Code (RA 9520)

39 RFBT: Banking Laws, AMLA & Bouncing Checks

38.1 Banking Laws, Bank Secrecy & PDIC 38.2 Anti-Money Laundering Act (AMLA) 38.3 Bouncing Checks Law (BP 22)

40 RFBT: Insolvency, Competition, Data Privacy & Labor Laws

39.1 Financial Rehabilitation and Insolvency Act (FRIA) 39.2 Competition, Consumer Protection, and Government Procurement 39.3 Data Privacy, Intellectual Property, and Electronic Commerce 39.4 Ease of Doing Business, Labor Standards, and Social Security

32.1 Obligations: Nature, Sources, and Effects

Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI

Under Article 1157 of the Civil Code, civil obligations arise exclusively from five sources: law, contracts, quasi-contracts (negotiorum gestio and solutio indebiti), delicts (crimes under the Revised Penal Code), and quasi-delicts (torts under Article 2176).

Breach of obligations under Article 1170 occurs through fraud (dolo), negligence (culpa), delay (mora), or contravention of the tenor; waiver of an action for future fraud is void under Article 1171.

Demand (judicial or extrajudicial) by the creditor is indispensable to place the debtor in legal delay (mora solvendi), unless the law or obligation expressly declares demand unnecessary, time is of the essence, demand would be useless, or reciprocal obligations are involved.

A debtor is not liable for loss caused by a fortuitous event unless the law or contract provides otherwise, the nature of the obligation requires assumption of risk, or the debtor was already in delay or at fault.

Last updated: September 2026

Obligations: Nature, Sources, and Effects

An obligation is a juridical necessity to give, to do, or not to do (Article 1156). This section covers the requisites and sources of obligations under Book IV of the Civil Code, the duties of the debtor in obligations to give and to do, the grounds for liability (fraud, negligence, delay, and contravention of the tenor), damages, and fortuitous events.

  • 1. Juridical Nature and Essential Requisites of an Obligation
  • Definition under Article 1156
  • Article 1156 defines an obligation as: "An obligation is a juridical necessity to give, to do or not to do."

The term "juridical necessity" means that in case of non-compliance, the courts of justice may be called upon to enforce fulfillment or to award damages for the breach. If an obligation is not enforceable by judicial action, it is not a civil obligation. The Four Essential Requisites

  • │
  • ┌─────────────────────┬──────────────┴──────────────┬─────────────────────┐
  • ▼ ▼ ▼ ▼
  • Active Subject Passive Subject Prestation Efficient Cause
  • (Creditor) (Debtor) (Object) (Vinculum Juris)
  • Entitled to demand Bound to perform Conduct: to give, The juridical tie
  • performance the prestation to do, or not to do created by Art. 1157
  • The Four Indispensable Requisites ( Elements )

Every valid civil obligation requires four concurrent elements:

Active Subject ( Creditor or Obligee ): The party possessing the legal right or power to demand the fulfillment of the prestation.

Passive Subject ( Debtor or Obligor ): The party bound by the legal duty to render or fulfill the prestation.

Object or Prestation: The particular conduct or behavior required to be observed by the debtor. It may consist of: (a) giving (restitution, delivery of property); (b) doing (rendering personal or professional services); or (c) not doing (abstaining from certain acts, such as non-compete agreements). The prestation must be licit, physically and legally possible, and determinate or determinable.

Efficient Cause or Juridical Tie ( Vinculum Juris ): The legal bond by virtue of which the debtor becomes bound to the creditor. It is established exclusively by one of the sources recognized by law.

Civil Obligations vs. Natural Obligations

Civil Obligations (Article 1156): Derive their binding force from positive law and grant the creditor a right of action in a court of justice to compel performance.

Natural Obligations (Articles 1423 to 1430): Grounded not in positive law, but in equity and natural justice. They do not grant a right of action to enforce performance; however, after voluntary fulfillment by the obligor, they authorize the retention of what has been delivered or rendered by reason thereof.

2. The Five Exclusive Sources of Obligations (Article 1157)

Under Article 1157 , obligations arise exclusively from:

  • Law ( Ex Lege )
  • Contracts ( Ex Contractu )
  • Quasi-contracts ( Quasi Ex Contractu )
  • Acts or omissions punished by law ( Delicts or Ex Delicto )
  • Quasi-delicts ( Culpa Aquiliana or Ex Quasi Delicto ) Article 1157 Sources
  • │
  • ┌──────────────────┬────────────────┼──────────────────┬──────────────────┐
  • ▼ ▼ ▼ ▼ ▼
  • Law Contracts Quasi-Contracts Delicts Quasi-Delicts
  • (Express only) (Good faith; (Unjust enrichment; (Crime / RPC; (Tort / Art. 2176;
  • Art. 1158 force of law) gestio / indebiti) civil liability) no contract)
  • Art. 1159 Arts. 2144, 2154 Art. 1161, RPC Art. 1162
  • 1. Obligations Derived from Law (Article 1158)

Obligations derived from law are never presumed . Only those expressly determined in the Civil Code or in special statutes (such as the National Internal Revenue Code, the Labor Code, or the Family Code) are demandable, and they are governed exclusively by the precepts of the law which establishes them.

2. Obligations Arising from Contracts (Article 1159)

Obligations arising from contracts have the force of law between the contracting parties and must be complied with in good faith . While parties enjoy autonomy of contract (liberty of terms), their agreements cannot violate law, morals, good customs, public order, or public policy (Article 1306).

3. Obligations Arising from Quasi-Contracts (Articles 2142 to 2175)

A quasi-contract is a lawful, voluntary, and unilateral act based on the equitable principle that no one shall be unjustly enriched or benefited at the expense of another ( nemo cum alterius detrimento locupletari potest ). Unlike contracts, there is no meeting of minds. The two principal nominate quasi-contracts are:

Negotiorum Gestio (Article 2144): Arises whenever a person voluntarily takes charge of the agency or management of the business or property of another, without any power or authority from the latter, where the property or business was neglected or abandoned. The owner must reimburse the gestor for necessary and useful expenses.

Solutio Indebiti (Article 2154): Arises when something is received when there is no right to demand it, and it was unduly delivered through mistake. The recipient incurs the obligation to return it.

4. Obligations Arising from Delicts / Crimes (Article 1161)

Every person criminally liable for a felony is also civilly liable under Article 100 of the Revised Penal Code (RPC) . Civil liability arising from crimes comprises:

  • Restitution: The return of the specific thing taken, even if found in possession of a third person;
  • Reparation of the damage caused: Assessment of price and material damage when restitution is impossible; and

Indemnification for consequential damages: Payment of actual, moral, nominal, temperate, liquidated, or exemplary damages suffered by the victim or their family.

5. Obligations Arising from Quasi-Delicts / Torts (Article 2176)

A quasi-delict is an act or omission causing damage to another person through fault or negligence, where no pre-existing contractual relation exists between the parties. The requisites are: (a) damage suffered by the plaintiff; (b) fault or negligence of the defendant ( culpa ); and (c) direct causal relation (proximate cause) between the fault/negligence and the resulting damage.

Comparative Matrix: The Three Forms of Negligence (Culpa)

Feature Culpa Contractual (Contractual Fault) Culpa Aquiliana (Civil Tort / Quasi-Delict) Culpa Criminal (Criminal Negligence)

Source of Obligation Pre-existing contract breached by negligence Autonomous civil wrong under Article 2176 Crime defined under Article 365 of the Revised Penal Code

Relationship of Parties Pre-existing contractual privity No pre-existing contractual privity required None required

Burden of Proof Preponderance of evidence; breach proves liability Preponderance of evidence; plaintiff must prove defendant's fault Proof beyond reasonable doubt

Defense of Good Father of Family in Selection/Supervision of Employees NOT AVAILABLE as a complete defense (only mitigates damages) AVAILABLE as a complete defense to relieve employer of liability (Art. 2180) NOT AVAILABLE ; employer's subsidiary civil liability is absolute if employee is insolvent

  • 3. Nature and Effect of Obligations: Standard of Care & Duties of Debtor
  • Determinate vs. Indeterminate (Generic) Things

The duties of a debtor differ sharply depending on whether the object is determinate or generic:

Determinate (Specific) Thing: An object distinctively individualized and physically segregated from all others of the same class (e.g., "the 2024 Toyota Land Cruiser with engine number ABC-12345").

Indeterminate (Generic) Thing: An object designated only by its class, genus, or species, without individual physical segregation (e.g., "a 2024 Toyota Land Cruiser" or "100 cavans of sinandomeng rice").

Statutory Duty Obligation to Deliver a Determinate Thing Obligation to Deliver a Generic Thing

Standard of Care Preserve the thing with the diligence of a good father of a family (ordinary diligence), unless the law or contract requires extraordinary diligence (Art. 1163) Deliver a thing of the quality intended; creditor cannot demand superior quality, nor can debtor deliver inferior quality (Art. 1246)

Duty to Deliver Fruits Deliver all fruits (natural, industrial, civil) from the time the obligation to deliver arises (Art. 1164) No specific duty to deliver specific fruits prior to delivery

Duty to Deliver Accessions & Accessories Must deliver all accessions and accessories, even if not mentioned (Art. 1166) Not applicable until generic thing is segregated and individualized

Effect of Fortuitous Loss Obligation is extinguished if lost without debtor's fault prior to mora (Art. 1262) Obligation is NOT extinguished ; genus nunquam perit (genus never perishes) (Art. 1263)

Creditor's Remedy on Default Compel specific performance, plus damages (Art. 1165 par. 1) Ask that the obligation be complied with at the expense of the debtor, plus damages (Art. 1165 par. 2)

Right to the Fruits (Article 1164)

The creditor has a personal right to the fruits of the thing from the time the obligation to deliver it arises. However, the creditor acquires a real right (ownership enforceable against the whole world) over the thing and its fruits only upon actual or constructive delivery . Obligation to Deliver Arises ⟶ Personal Right Acquired (enforceable only against debtor) Actual or Constructive Delivery ⟶ Real Right Acquired (ownership enforceable against the world) \begin{aligned}

\text{Obligation to Deliver Arises} &\longrightarrow \text{Personal Right Acquired (enforceable only against debtor)} \\

\text{Actual or Constructive Delivery} &\longrightarrow \text{Real Right Acquired (ownership enforceable against the world)}

\end{aligned} Obligation to Deliver Arises Actual or Constructive Delivery ​ ⟶ Personal Right Acquired (enforceable only against debtor) ⟶ Real Right Acquired (ownership enforceable against the world) ​

4. Grounds for Liability in Performance (Article 1170)

Under Article 1170 , liability for damages is incurred by any person who in the performance of their obligation is guilty of:

  • Fraud ( Dolo )
  • Negligence ( Culpa )
  • Delay ( Mora )
  • Contravention of the tenor of the obligation
  • 1. Fraud ( Dolo )

Fraud is the deliberate or intentional evasion of the normal fulfillment of an obligation.

Dolo Causante (Causal Fraud, Article 1338): Fraud employed at the inception of the contract to obtain consent. It vitiates consent and renders the contract voidable .

Dolo Incidente (Incidental Fraud, Article 1170 & 1344 par. 2): Fraud committed in the actual performance or fulfillment of an existing obligation. It does not affect the validity of the contract, but renders the guilty party liable for damages .

CPALE Rule (Article 1171): Responsibility arising from fraud is demandable in all obligations. Any waiver of an action for future fraud is VOID . In contrast, a waiver of an action for past fraud is perfectly valid, as it constitutes a lawful act of forgiveness or condonation by the creditor.

2. Negligence ( Culpa )

Under Article 1173 , fault or negligence consists in the omission of that diligence which is required by the nature of the obligation and corresponds to the circumstances of the persons, of the time, and of the place. Future negligence may generally be waived, provided the waiver does not involve gross negligence amounting to fraud.

3. Delay ( Mora )

Mora is the legal delay in the fulfillment of an obligation. It takes three distinct forms:

Mora Solvendi: Delay on the part of the debtor. It is divided into mora solvendi ex re (obligations to give) and mora solvendi ex personae (obligations to do).

Mora Accipiendi: Delay on the part of the creditor to accept the performance of the obligation without lawful justification.

Compensatio Morae: Delay of both parties in reciprocal obligations. The delay of one neutralizes the delay of the other; neither party is in legal delay until the other performs or tenders performance.

The Mandatory Demand Rule and Statutory Exceptions (Article 1169)

The cardinal rule under Philippine law is: "No demand, no delay." The mere arrival of the due date does not automatically put the debtor in default. To constitute legal delay ( mora solvendi ), the creditor must make a demand (either judicial by filing a complaint, or extrajudicial through a written/oral demand letter).

Under Article 1169 , demand is NOT required to incur delay in four exclusive instances:

Express Declaration by Law: The statute explicitly provides that delay sets in automatically upon the date specified (e.g., payment of taxes under the NIRC on April 15);

Express Declaration by the Obligation: The contract explicitly states that demand is unnecessary (a mere fixed due date is insufficient; the clause must state: "delay sets in without need of demand" );

Time is of the Essence: From the nature and circumstances of the obligation, the designation of time was a controlling motive for the establishment of the contract (e.g., delivery of a wedding gown on the morning of the ceremony);

Demand would be Useless: When the debtor has made performance impossible through their own act, fault, or conveyance to a third party;

Reciprocal Obligations: From the moment one party fulfills their obligation, delay by the other begins automatically without need of demand.

  • 5. Fortuitous Events ( Caso Fortuito / Force Majeure, Article 1174)
  • Definition and Requisites

Under Article 1174 , a fortuitous event is an occurrence that could not be foreseen, or which, though foreseen, was inevitable. It encompasses both acts of God (natural calamities like typhoons, earthquakes, volcanic eruptions) and acts of man (war, armed robbery, sovereign state acts).

To successfully invoke a fortuitous event to extinguish liability, four requisites must concur:

The cause of the unforeseen and unexpected occurrence, or the failure of the debtor to comply with their obligation, must be independent of the human will;

It must be impossible to foresee the event, or if it could be foreseen, it must have been impossible to avoid;

The occurrence must be such as to render it impossible for the debtor to fulfill their obligation in a normal manner; and

The obligor must be free from any participation in the aggravation of the injury resulting to the creditor (free from concurrent fraud, negligence, or delay).

Statutory Exceptions Where Debtor Remains Liable Despite Fortuitous Event

Under Article 1174, the debtor remains fully liable for loss or damages despite a fortuitous event in the following cases:

When expressly declared by law:

When the debtor is already in legal delay ( mora ) at the time the fortuitous event occurs (Article 1165 par. 3);

When the debtor has promised to deliver the same determinate thing to two or more persons who do not have the same interest (Article 1165 par. 3);

When the obligation arises from a criminal offense ( delict ) , unless the creditor refused to accept the thing without justification after tender (Article 1268);

When the bailee in commodatum devotes the thing to a purpose different from that agreed upon, or keeps it longer than stipulated (Article 1942);

  • When expressly stipulated by the parties in the contract (assumption of risk clause);
  • When the nature of the obligation requires the assumption of risk (e.g., insurance contracts);

When the thing to be delivered is indeterminate or generic ( genus nunquam perit , Article 1263).

6. Worked Problem: Demand and Fortuitous Loss

Scenario: Victor sold a specific breeding stallion named "Pegasus" to Walter for PHP 500,000, payable upon delivery. The contract stipulated that delivery would take place at Victor's ranch on August 15, 2026. August 15 passed without Walter demanding delivery or offering payment, and Victor did not deliver the stallion. On August 20, 2026, a lightning strike struck the stable during an unprecedented storm, killing Pegasus instantly. Walter demands that Victor deliver another breeding stallion or pay damages. Is Victor liable?

Analysis:

Nature of Object: Pegasus is a determinate (specific) thing .

Default Analysis under Article 1169: Merely fixing August 15 as the delivery date did not place Victor in automatic delay ( mora ). The contract did not expressly declare that delay sets in without demand, nor was time of the essence. Because Walter made no demand on or after August 15, Victor was not in legal delay ( mora solvendi ).

Fortuitous Event Analysis under Articles 1174 and 1262: A lightning strike is a classic act of God (fortuitous event). Because the specific thing was destroyed without Victor's fault and prior to legal delay, the obligation to deliver Pegasus is completely extinguished .

Conclusion: Victor is not liable to deliver another stallion (generic replacement is inapplicable to determinate objects) and is not liable for damages. Since the contract was reciprocal and unperformed, Walter is likewise relieved of the obligation to pay PHP 500,000.