Study guide

8.2 Logic — Assumptions, Conclusions & Syllogisms

Philippine Civil Service Exam CSE-PPT

Track your progress as you read

Finished sections get a check mark.

1 Introduction & Exam Strategy

1.1 Exam Facts, Format & Scoring 1.2 How to Study & Test-Taking Strategy

2 Vocabulary & Word Meaning

2.1 English Vocabulary 2.2 Filipino Vocabulary — Talasalitaan 2.3 Idioms, Idyoma & Word Usage

3 Grammar & Correct Usage

3.1 English Grammar 3.2 Filipino Grammar - Balarila 3.3 Error Recognition & Correct Usage

4 Sentence Completion & Paragraph Organization

4.1 Sentence Completion 4.2 Paragraph Organization & Coherence 4.3 Spelling & Mechanics

5 Reading Comprehension

5.1 English Reading Comprehension 5.2 Filipino Reading Comprehension - Pagbasa at Pag-unawa

6 Numerical Foundations

6.1 Operations, Order of Operations & Number Sense 6.2 Percentages, Ratio, Proportion & Averages 6.3 Measurement, Conversions & Basic Algebra

7 Numerical Word Problems & Sequences

7.1 Word Problems I: Rate, Distance, Work, and Mixture 7.2 Word Problems II: Age, Money, Percentage Change, and Interest 7.3 Number & Letter Sequences and Series

8 Word Analogy & Logical Reasoning

8.1 Word Analogy 8.2 Logic — Assumptions, Conclusions & Syllogisms 8.3 Abstract, Symbolic & Figural Reasoning

9 Data Interpretation & Problem Solving

9.1 Data Interpretation 9.2 Analytical Problem Solving 9.3 Critical Reasoning & Decision Rules

10 Philippine Constitution & Ethics

10.1 1987 Philippine Constitution 10.2 RA 6713 — Code of Conduct & Ethical Standards

11 Peace, Human Rights & Environment

11.1 Peace & Human Rights Concepts 11.2 Environment Management & Protection

8.2 Logic — Assumptions, Conclusions & Syllogisms

Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI

An assumption is an unstated premise the argument needs to work; confirm it with the negation test — negate the statement and if the argument collapses, it was required.

A valid conclusion must be true in every case the premises allow; 'must be true' is stricter than 'could be true' or 'is probably true.'

Categorical syllogism rules: two 'all' premises can chain (All A are B, All B are C, so All A are C), but two 'some' premises prove nothing universal.

If-then logic: modus ponens (affirm the if, get the then) and modus tollens (deny the then, deny the if) are valid; affirming the consequent and denying the antecedent are fallacies.

The most tested fallacy is post hoc (false cause): assuming that because B followed A, A caused B.

Last updated: July 2026

Assumptions: the Unstated Premise

An assumption is a premise the author never states out loud but the argument silently depends on. Consider: "We should hold the training online to save on venue costs." The stated claim is that going online saves money on a venue. The hidden assumption is that holding the training online actually costs less than renting a venue . If that were false, the whole recommendation falls apart.

The most reliable tool is the negation test . Take a candidate assumption, negate it, and reinsert it into the argument. If the negation destroys the argument, the statement was a required assumption; if the argument still stands, it was not needed. Negating "online costs less than a venue" gives "online costs the same or more" — which kills the reason to go online, so the assumption is required.

Watch for advertising-style items: "Buy our vitamins for a healthier life" assumes the vitamins actually contribute to better health . The claim is meaningless without that bridge belief.

Conclusions: What MUST Be True

A valid conclusion is one that is true in every situation the premises permit — not merely one that could be true or seems likely . This distinction decides most conclusion items.

Worked example: "An office requires every new hire to attend orientation. Maria is a new hire." Because the rule covers every new hire and Maria is one, the conclusion " Maria must attend the orientation " is forced. Compare a weaker stem: "Some employees are union members" does not let you conclude anything about a specific named employee.

Categorical Syllogisms: All, Some, No

A syllogism joins two premises to force a conclusion. The quantifiers all , some , and no behave by fixed rules. Validity depends on form , not on whether the sentences are factually true.

  • Premise 1 Premise 2 Valid conclusion
  • All A are B All B are C All A are C
  • Some A are B All B are C Some A are C
  • No A are B All C are A No C are B
  • All A are B Some B are C (nothing certain about A)
  • Some A are B Some B are C (no valid conclusion)

Key rules to memorize:

Two universal affirmatives (all...all) chain cleanly.

A some premise yields at most a some conclusion — never an all .

Two some premises together prove nothing .

A no (negative) premise carries the negative into the conclusion.

Worked example: All birds have feathers. A penguin is a bird. This is All-A-are-B plus "penguin is an A," so " a penguin has feathers " is valid. Another: Some teachers are writers. All writers are creative. The bridge term is "writers": some teachers fall inside "writers," and all writers are creative, so some teachers are creative — a some conclusion, never "all teachers are creative."

Negative example: No heroes are cowards. All soldiers in the unit are heroes. Since every soldier is a hero, and no hero is a coward, no soldier in the unit is a coward .

A classic trap: If all managers are employees, and some employees are union members, you cannot conclude that any manager is a union member. The correct statement is the cautious one: " some managers may or may not be union members " — the overlap is undetermined.

If-Then Logic

An if-then (conditional) statement "If P then Q" supports two valid moves and two fallacies:

Modus ponens (valid): P is true, therefore Q. ("If it rains, class is cancelled. It rained. So class is cancelled.")

Modus tollens (valid): Q is false, therefore P is false. ("Class was not cancelled, so it did not rain.")

Affirming the consequent (fallacy): Q is true, therefore P — invalid.

Denying the antecedent (fallacy): P is false, therefore Q is false — invalid.

The contrapositive "If not Q then not P" is always logically equivalent to the original.

Logical Fallacies (High-Yield)

The CSE most often tests post hoc, ergo propter hoc — the false-cause fallacy: assuming that because B came after A, A caused B. When a manager says, "Attendance improved after we offered free coffee, so the coffee caused it," the flaw is treating sequence as causation ; a co-occurring change (a new bonus, seasonal effect) could be the real cause. Likewise, "Crime fell after streetlights were installed, therefore streetlights reduce crime" is weakened most by revealing a new police patrol started at the same time . Other tested fallacies: hasty generalization (a broad claim from too few cases), false dilemma (only two options when more exist), and circular reasoning (the conclusion restates a premise).

Converse and Inverse Errors

From "If a worker is tardy three times, then he is suspended," you may not conclude "if he is suspended, he was tardy three times" (the converse ) — he could be suspended for a different reason. Nor may you conclude "if he is not tardy three times, he is not suspended" (the inverse ). Only the contrapositive — "if he is not suspended, he was not tardy three times" — is guaranteed true. On the exam, a distractor that swaps the if and the then , or negates both parts without flipping them, is testing exactly this error, so read conditional conclusions letter by letter before choosing.