Study guide
9.3 Critical Reasoning & Decision Rules
Philippine Civil Service Exam CSE-PPT
Track your progress as you read
Finished sections get a check mark.
1 Introduction & Exam Strategy
1.1 Exam Facts, Format & Scoring 1.2 How to Study & Test-Taking Strategy
2 Vocabulary & Word Meaning
2.1 English Vocabulary 2.2 Filipino Vocabulary — Talasalitaan 2.3 Idioms, Idyoma & Word Usage
3 Grammar & Correct Usage
3.1 English Grammar 3.2 Filipino Grammar - Balarila 3.3 Error Recognition & Correct Usage
4 Sentence Completion & Paragraph Organization
4.1 Sentence Completion 4.2 Paragraph Organization & Coherence 4.3 Spelling & Mechanics
5 Reading Comprehension
5.1 English Reading Comprehension 5.2 Filipino Reading Comprehension - Pagbasa at Pag-unawa
6 Numerical Foundations
6.1 Operations, Order of Operations & Number Sense 6.2 Percentages, Ratio, Proportion & Averages 6.3 Measurement, Conversions & Basic Algebra
7 Numerical Word Problems & Sequences
7.1 Word Problems I: Rate, Distance, Work, and Mixture 7.2 Word Problems II: Age, Money, Percentage Change, and Interest 7.3 Number & Letter Sequences and Series
8 Word Analogy & Logical Reasoning
8.1 Word Analogy 8.2 Logic — Assumptions, Conclusions & Syllogisms 8.3 Abstract, Symbolic & Figural Reasoning
9 Data Interpretation & Problem Solving
9.1 Data Interpretation 9.2 Analytical Problem Solving 9.3 Critical Reasoning & Decision Rules
10 Philippine Constitution & Ethics
10.1 1987 Philippine Constitution 10.2 RA 6713 — Code of Conduct & Ethical Standards
11 Peace, Human Rights & Environment
11.1 Peace & Human Rights Concepts 11.2 Environment Management & Protection
9.3 Critical Reasoning & Decision Rules
Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI
An argument is premises plus a conclusion; an assumption is the unstated premise the conclusion needs to hold.
To weaken a causal claim, supply an alternative cause; the fact that B happened after A does not prove A caused B (the post hoc fallacy).
Under an 'all of the following' (AND) rule, missing even one condition disqualifies - strength in one area cannot offset a failure in another.
The strongest argument is relevant to the exact question, evidence-based rather than emotional, and free of unstated leaps.
Discard irrelevant facts - anything the stated rule or question never mentions - before you decide.
Last updated: July 2026
Judging Arguments and Deciding by the Rules
The final strand of analytical ability asks you to reason critically : pick the strongest argument, decide who qualifies under a stated rule, separate cause from coincidence, and ignore facts that do not matter. Every argument has two parts - premises (the support) and a conclusion (the claim). Your task is not to agree or disagree personally but to judge whether the reasoning holds and which option best answers the exact question.
Assumptions, strengthening, and weakening
An assumption is an unstated premise the conclusion silently needs. To strengthen an argument, an option adds support or rules out an alternative; to weaken it, an option exposes a gap or offers a competing explanation.
Worked example. A report says, 'Crime dropped after more streetlights were installed; therefore streetlights reduce crime.' Which fact would most weaken it? 'A new police patrol program began at the same time as the streetlights' is strongest, because it supplies an alternative cause for the drop, so the lights may deserve no credit. Facts like 'the streetlights were energy-efficient LEDs' or 'residents liked the brighter streets' are irrelevant to whether crime actually fell.
Cause versus correlation (the post hoc trap)
A favorite CSE trap is assuming that because B happened after A, A caused B. A manager reasons, 'Attendance improved after we offered free coffee, so the coffee caused it.' The flaw is mistaking sequence for causation (the post hoc fallacy) - attendance might have risen because of a new bonus, better weather, or a looming deadline. Correlation is not causation. To justify a causal claim you must rule out other changes, show a plausible mechanism, and see the pattern repeat across cases.
Worked example - strengthening. 'Offices that adopted a queue-number system cut waiting time, so our office should adopt it.' The option that most strengthens the plan is 'Three offices similar in size and workload to ours cut waiting time by 30% after adopting the system' - it shows the result repeats in comparable settings . A weak option such as 'the system uses a modern touchscreen' names a feature, not an outcome.
Deciding under stated rules
Many items give you a rule and ask you to apply it exactly. Consider a scholarship whose applicant qualifies only if all three conditions are met: R1 a General Weighted Average (GWA) of at least 85 ; R2 annual family income of at most PHP 200,000 ; R3 enrolled full-time .
Applicant GWA Family income Enrollment Qualifies?
- Aldo 88 180,000 Full-time Yes - meets all three
- Bea 90 250,000 Full-time No - fails R2 (income)
- Cita 84 150,000 Full-time No - fails R1 (GWA)
- Dino 87 190,000 Part-time No - fails R3 (enrollment)
Only Aldo satisfies R1, R2, and R3. The discipline is that an 'all of the following' rule fails the moment one condition is missed - a 90 GWA cannot rescue Bea's over-limit income. When a rule uses ' or ', by contrast, meeting any one condition is enough.
Necessary versus sufficient conditions
A subtle CSE distinction is between a necessary condition (required, but not enough on its own) and a sufficient condition (enough by itself). 'You must be 18 to take the CSE' is necessary - being 18 does not guarantee a passing rating, but you cannot sit the exam without it. 'Scoring 80.00 guarantees eligibility' is sufficient - reaching it settles the outcome. Watch for the reversal trap: from 'all passers scored at least 80' you may not conclude 'everyone who scored 80 passed on this attempt' unless the rule says the condition is both necessary and sufficient.
Spotting irrelevant information
Good decisions ignore facts that do not bear on the rule. In the scholarship above, an applicant's course, hometown, or age is irrelevant, because none appears in R1-R3. Suppose a fifth applicant, Elsa, has GWA 92, income 150,000, and full-time status, but the item adds that she 'lives four hours from the school'. Distance is not one of R1-R3, so it changes nothing: Elsa qualifies . Exam items often bury one useful number among several distractors; cross out anything the rule never mentions before you decide.
Choosing the strongest argument
The strongest argument is (1) directly relevant to the exact question, (2) based on fact or sound logic rather than emotion, and (3) complete , not dependent on an unstated leap. Weak arguments appeal to feelings ('everyone will be upset'), drift off-topic, or rest on unverifiable claims.
- Argument type Sign Verdict
- Relevant + evidence cites a fact that answers the question Strong
- Emotional appeal plays on fear, pity, or popularity Weak
- Irrelevant true but off the question Weak
- Overgeneralization 'always' or 'never' from one case Weak
- A structured decision approach
State the question precisely - what is being decided?
List the criteria and mark each as 'must' (AND) or 'any' (OR).
Screen each option against every criterion and eliminate on the first failure.
Discard irrelevant facts that no criterion mentions.
Pick the choice that is relevant, evidence-based, and complete.
Follow those five steps and critical-reasoning items - often the 'hard'-tagged questions - become a mechanical checklist rather than a matter of opinion.