Study guide

3.4 Project Evaluation, Depreciation, and Benefit-Cost Analysis

PRC Civil Engineer Licensure Examination CELE

Track your progress as you read

Finished sections get a check mark.

1 Chapter 1: Examination Overview, RA 544 & Professional Practice

1.1 CELE Structure, Format, Scoring, and 2026 Subject Order 1.2 Republic Act No. 544: The Civil Engineering Law and Board Regulations 1.3 Civil Engineering Ethics, Contracts, and Professional Practice

2 Chapter 2: Engineering Mathematics, Numerical Methods & Physics

2.1 Advanced Algebra, Progressions & Word Problems 2.2 Trigonometry and Analytical Geometry 2.3 Differential and Integral Calculus 2.4 Differential Equations and Numerical Methods 2.5 Series, Hyperbolic Functions, Multivariable Calculus, and Laplace Transforms 2.6 Numerical Methods: Linear Systems, Interpolation, Curve Fitting, and ODE Solvers 2.7 Physics for Engineers: Kinematics, Newton's Laws, Work-Energy, and Momentum

3 Chapter 3: Engineering Data Analysis & Engineering Economy

3.1 Engineering Data Analysis and Statistical Applications 3.2 Parameter Estimation, Linear Regression, Correlation, and Queuing Models 3.3 Engineering Economy: Time Value of Money and Interest Formulas 3.4 Project Evaluation, Depreciation, and Benefit-Cost Analysis

4 Chapter 4: Surveying Fundamentals, Construction Layout & Route Surveying

4.1 Errors, Corrections, and Pacing/Taping 4.2 Leveling, Earthworks, and Mass Haul Diagrams 4.3 Traverse Computations, Balancing, and Area Determinations 4.4 Route Surveying: Horizontal and Vertical Curves

5 Chapter 5: Highway & Transportation Engineering

5.1 Highway Geometric Design and Sight Distances 5.2 Traffic Engineering, Flow Fundamentals, and Pavement Design 5.3 Highway Policy, Route Location, Drainage, and Earthwork Slopes 5.4 Transportation Planning, Network Analysis, and Intermodal Systems

6 Chapter 6: Construction Materials, Methods, Management & Safety

6.1 Materials for Construction: Concrete, Formwork, Masonry, Steel, and Wood Products 6.2 Construction Equipment, Formwork, and Construction Methods 6.3 Construction Occupational Safety and Health: RA 11058 and DOLE DO 13 6.4 Construction Project Management, CPM/PERT, and Resource Scheduling 6.5 Construction Principles: Design Requirements, Project Organization, Cost Control, and Value Engineering 6.6 Quantity Surveying, Unit Cost Analysis, and Project Cost Estimates 6.7 Construction Trades and Specialties: Plumbing, Plastics, Doors and Windows, Finishes, and Electrical

7 Chapter 7: Fluid Properties, Hydrostatics & Buoyancy

7.1 Fluid Properties, Units, and Pressure Measurement 7.2 Hydrostatic Pressure on Plane and Curved Surfaces 7.3 Buoyancy, Flotation, and Accelerated Fluid Masses

8 Chapter 8: Hydrodynamics, Pipe Flow, Open Channels & Water Supply

8.1 Fluid Dynamics: Continuity and Energy Equations 8.2 Flow Measurement: Orifices, Weirs, and Venturi Meters 8.3 Fluid Flow in Pipes, Friction Losses, and Pipe Networks 8.4 Open Channel Flow, Manning's Equation, and Hydraulic Jump 8.5 Water Supply: Demand, Storage, Pumping, Distribution, and Treatment

9 Chapter 9: Soil Properties, Seepage & Stresses in Soil Mass

9.1 Soil Composition, Weight-Volume Phase Relationships 9.2 Soil Classification Systems (USCS & AASHTO) and Atterberg Limits 9.3 Soil Permeability, Seepage, Flow Nets, and Effective Stress 9.4 Stresses in Soil Mass, Stress Distribution, and Immediate and Secondary Settlement

10 Chapter 10: Consolidation, Soil Strength, Earth Pressures & Foundations

10.1 Soil Compaction and Soil Compressibility/Consolidation 10.2 Shear Strength of Soils and Mohr-Coulomb Failure Criteria 10.3 Lateral Earth Pressures (Rankine & Coulomb) and Retaining Walls 10.4 Shallow and Deep Foundation Bearing Capacity and Slope Stability

11 Chapter 11: Engineering Mechanics & Statics

11.1 Force Systems, Resultants, and Equilibrium of Rigid Bodies 11.2 Centroids, Moments of Inertia, and Friction 11.3 Cables, Trusses, and Internal Forces in Members

12 Chapter 12: Strength of Materials

12.1 Axial Stress, Strain, and Deformation 12.2 Torsion, Flanged Bolt Couplings, and Thin-Walled Pressure Vessels 12.3 Beam Stresses: Flexural and Transverse Shear 12.4 Beam Deflections, Combined Stresses, and Mohr's Circle

13 Chapter 13: Structural Analysis & NSCP Load Criteria

13.1 Indeterminate Structures: Approximate and Classical Methods 13.2 Moment Distribution Method and Slope Deflection 13.3 Influence Lines for Determinate and Indeterminate Structures 13.4 NSCP Minimum Design Loads: Dead, Live, Wind, and Earthquake

14 Chapter 14: Reinforced Concrete Design (NSCP 2015 / USD)

14.1 Ultimate Strength Design (USD) Principles and Singly Reinforced Beams 14.2 Doubly Reinforced Beams and T-Beams 14.3 Shear and Diagonal Tension, Stirrup Design, and Development Length 14.4 Reinforced Concrete Columns and Isolated Footing Design

15 Chapter 15: Steel, Timber & Prestressed Design and Materials Testing

15.1 Structural Steel Tension Members and Connections 15.2 Structural Steel Compression Members and Beam Design 15.3 Timber Design Principles, Working Stress, and Sawn Lumber Beams 15.4 Prestressed Concrete Fundamentals and Prestress Losses 15.5 Construction Materials Testing and Concrete Mix Proportioning

3.4 Project Evaluation, Depreciation, and Benefit-Cost Analysis

Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI

The Present Worth method requires comparing alternatives over identical service lives (Least Common Multiple or fixed study period); Annual Worth natively circumvents this limitation under cyclic repeatability.

Benefit-Cost Ratio (BCR) analysis for public works requires incremental evaluation (ΔB / ΔC ≥ 1.0) among alternatives ordered by increasing initial cost; choosing based solely on highest standalone BCR is a classic engineering economic fallacy.

Straight-Line (SL) depreciation produces uniform yearly write-offs, whereas accelerated methods (SOYD, DDB) provide larger deductions early in asset life to optimize tax shielding and cash flows.

Double Declining Balance (DDB) applies a fixed rate of 2 / n to the beginning-of-year book value without initial salvage value deduction, but depreciation must terminate once book value reaches salvage value (BV ≥ SV).

Last updated: October 2026

3.4 Project Evaluation, Depreciation, and Benefit-Cost Analysis

Civil engineering infrastructure proposals—whether transportation corridors, flood abatement channels, wastewater treatment facilities, or heavy construction equipment investments—require rigorous economic evaluation to justify capital allocation. Engineers must select the most viable design alternative using systematic comparison criteria, establish accurate asset depreciation schedules for tax accounting and equipment replacement, and apply Benefit-Cost analysis to validate public works projects.

  • Project Evaluation Methods & Economic Comparison
  • Minimum Attractive Rate of Return (MARR)

The Minimum Attractive Rate of Return (MARR) , or hurdle rate, represents the lowest internal rate of return an engineering project must earn to justify capital investment. MARR is established by organizational management based on the weighted average cost of capital (WACC), market opportunity costs, and project risk premiums.

1. Present Worth (PW) Method

The Present Worth method discounts all anticipated cash inflows and outflows to t = 0 t = 0 t = 0 using the MARR ( i i i ): P W = ∑ t = 0 n C F t ( 1 + i ) − t = PW of Inflows − PW of Outflows PW = \sum_{t=0}^{n} CF_t (1 + i)^{-t} = \text{PW of Inflows} - \text{PW of Outflows} P W = ∑ t = 0 n ​ C F t ​ ( 1 + i ) − t = PW of Inflows − PW of Outflows

Decision Rule for Independent Projects: Accept if P W ≥ 0 PW \ge 0 P W ≥ 0 .

Mutually Exclusive Alternatives: Select the alternative with the highest algebraically positive P W PW P W (or lowest present worth of costs for service projects).

Important

The Equal Service Life Requirement: When comparing mutually exclusive alternatives with different lifespans using Present Worth, the alternatives must be evaluated over an identical study period . This is achieved by either using the Least Common Multiple (LCM) of their service lives (assuming cyclic replacement) or a fixed management planning horizon with assumed terminal salvage values. Failure to equalize lifespans invalidates PW comparisons.

2. Annual Worth (AW) Method / Equivalent Uniform Annual Cost (EUAC)

The Annual Worth method converts all life-cycle cash flows into an equivalent uniform annual series over the project service life: A W = P W ( A / P , i , n ) = − F C ( A / P , i , n ) + S V ( A / F , i , n ) − A AW = PW(A/P, i, n) = -FC(A/P, i, n) + SV(A/F, i, n) - A A W = P W ( A / P , i , n ) = − FC ( A / P , i , n ) + S V ( A / F , i , n ) − A Using the identity ( A / F ) = ( A / P ) − i (A/F) = (A/P) - i ( A / F ) = ( A / P ) − i , this can be expressed in terms of Capital Recovery with Return ( C R CR CR ) : A W = − ( F C − S V ) ( A / P , i , n ) − S V ( i ) − A AW = -(FC - SV)(A/P, i, n) - SV(i) - A A W = − ( FC − S V ) ( A / P , i , n ) − S V ( i ) − A

The Cyclic Repeatability Advantage: Unlike the PW method, the Annual Worth method does not require calculating the LCM of lives when comparing alternatives with unequal lifespans, provided that the service requirements repeat under identical economic conditions.

3. Future Worth (FW) Method

The Future Worth method compounds all net cash flows to the end of the study period n n n : F W = P W ( 1 + i ) n = ∑ t = 0 n C F t ( 1 + i ) n − t FW = PW(1 + i)^n = \sum_{t=0}^n CF_t (1 + i)^{n - t} F W = P W ( 1 + i ) n = ∑ t = 0 n ​ C F t ​ ( 1 + i ) n − t

4. Internal Rate of Return (IRR) Method

The Internal Rate of Return (IRR, i ∗ i^* i ∗ ) is the breakeven discount rate that equates the present worth of cash inflows to the present worth of cash outflows ( P W = 0 PW = 0 P W = 0 ): ∑ t = 0 n C F t ( 1 + i ∗ ) − t = 0 \sum_{t=0}^n CF_t (1 + i^*)^{-t} = 0 ∑ t = 0 n ​ C F t ​ ( 1 + i ∗ ) − t = 0

Independent Project Rule: Accept if I R R ≥ M A R R IRR \ge MARR I RR ≥ M A RR .

Mutually Exclusive Alternatives: The alternative with the highest individual IRR is not necessarily the optimal choice due to scale-of-investment differences. Engineers must perform Incremental IRR Analysis ( Δ I R R \Delta IRR Δ I RR ) : Δ P W B − A ( i ∗ ) = 0 \Delta PW_{B - A}(i^*) = 0 Δ P W B − A ​ ( i ∗ ) = 0 If Δ I R R ≥ M A R R \Delta IRR \ge MARR Δ I RR ≥ M A RR , the additional capital investment in the higher-cost project is economically justified.

5. Payback Period Analysis

The payback period measures the time required for accumulated net project revenues to recover the initial capital investment:

Simple Payback Period ( n p n_p n p ​ ): Ignores time value of money ( i = 0 i = 0 i = 0 ): n p = Initial Investment F C Net Annual Cash Flow A n_p = \frac{\text{Initial Investment } FC}{\text{Net Annual Cash Flow } A} n p ​ = Net Annual Cash Flow A Initial Investment FC ​

Discounted Payback Period: Accounts for time value of money by identifying the year where cumulative discounted cash flows become non-negative.

Limitations: Payback ignores all cash flows generated after the payback cutoff date and fails to measure overall economic profitability.

Benefit-Cost Ratio (BCR) Analysis for Public Infrastructure

Public civil infrastructure projects (funded by DPWH, local government units, or multilateral development banks) are evaluated using Benefit-Cost Analysis to ensure societal welfare exceeds public expenditures.

Cash Flow Classifications in Public Projects

User Benefits ( B B B ): Direct and indirect cost savings and utility gains realized by the public (e.g., travel time reductions, vehicle operating cost savings, reduced flood inundation damages, accident rate reductions).

User Disbenefits ( D D D ): Negative societal impacts caused by the project (e.g., traffic congestion during construction, noise pollution, loss of agricultural land, visual intrusion).

Agency Capital Recovery ( C R CR CR ): Equivalent uniform annual capital investment cost of construction minus residual salvage value: C R = ( F C − S V ) ( A / P , i , n ) + S V ( i ) CR = (FC - SV)(A/P, i, n) + SV(i) CR = ( FC − S V ) ( A / P , i , n ) + S V ( i ) .

Agency Operating & Maintenance ( O & M O\&M O & M , or C C C ): Annual government expenditures required to inspect, repair, and operate the facility.

Conventional vs. Modified Benefit-Cost Ratio

Conventional Benefit-Cost Ratio: B C R = B − D C R + O & M = Net Societal Benefits Total Public Agency Costs BCR = \frac{B - D}{CR + O\&M} = \frac{\text{Net Societal Benefits}}{\text{Total Public Agency Costs}} BCR = CR + O & M B − D ​ = Total Public Agency Costs Net Societal Benefits ​

Modified Benefit-Cost Ratio: Subtracts annual operating costs from the numerator: B C R mod = B − D − O & M C R BCR_{\text{mod}} = \frac{B - D - O\&M}{CR} BC R mod ​ = CR B − D − O & M ​ For any viable project, both ratios yield consistent decisions: B C R ≥ 1.0 BCR \ge 1.0 BCR ≥ 1.0 and B C R mod ≥ 1.0 BCR_{\text{mod}} \ge 1.0 BC R mod ​ ≥ 1.0 .

Incremental Benefit-Cost Analysis Protocol (Mutually Exclusive Alternatives)

Selecting the project with the highest standalone B C R BCR BCR is a severe engineering error because it favors small, cheap proposals over comprehensive regional infrastructure solutions. The proper incremental evaluation protocol is:

Rank Alternatives: Order all mutually exclusive alternatives by ascending initial capital cost ( F C FC FC ). Include the "Do-Nothing" baseline.

Screen Individual Viability: Compute the standalone B C R BCR BCR for each alternative against "Do-Nothing". Eliminate any alternative with B C R < 1.0 BCR < 1.0 BCR < 1.0 .

Incremental Comparison: Take the lowest-cost acceptable alternative as the current benchmark ( A A A ) and compare it with the next higher-cost alternative ( B B B ): Δ B / Δ C = B B − B A E U A C B − E U A C A = Δ B − Δ D Δ C R + Δ O & M \Delta B / \Delta C = \frac{B_B - B_A}{EUAC_B - EUAC_A} = \frac{\Delta B - \Delta D}{\Delta CR + \Delta O\&M} Δ B /Δ C = E U A C B ​ − E U A C A ​ B B ​ − B A ​ ​ = Δ CR + Δ O & M Δ B − Δ D ​

Selection Rule:

If Δ B / Δ C ≥ 1.0 \Delta B / \Delta C \ge 1.0 Δ B /Δ C ≥ 1.0 , the incremental investment is economically justified; alternative B B B becomes the new benchmark.

If Δ B / Δ C < 1.0 \Delta B / \Delta C < 1.0 Δ B /Δ C < 1.0 , the incremental investment is rejected; alternative A A A remains the benchmark.

Repeat across all candidates until the optimal investment is confirmed.

Asset Depreciation Methods & Book Value Modeling

Depreciation represents the systematic non-cash accounting allocation of an asset's capital acquisition cost over its productive service life due to wear, physical deterioration, or technical obsolescence.

Fundamental Terminology

First Cost ( F C FC FC , or C 0 C_0 C 0 ​ ): Total delivered, installed cost of the asset at t = 0 t = 0 t = 0 .

Salvage Value ( S V SV S V , or C n C_n C n ​ ): Net estimated market or scrap value at the end of useful life n n n .

Useful Life ( n n n ): Anticipated operational lifespan in years or production units.

Annual Depreciation ( D m D_m D m ​ ): Depreciation deduction taken during year m m m .

Book Value ( B V m BV_m B V m ​ ): Unallocated capital balance remaining at the end of year m m m : B V m = F C − ∑ j = 1 m D j = B V m − 1 − D m BV_m = FC - \sum_{j=1}^m D_j = BV_{m-1} - D_m B V m ​ = FC − ∑ j = 1 m ​ D j ​ = B V m − 1 ​ − D m ​

1. Straight-Line (SL) Depreciation

Allocates equal depreciation across each year of useful life: D m = D = F C − S V n D_m = D = \frac{FC - SV}{n} D m ​ = D = n FC − S V ​ B V m = F C − m ⋅ D = F C − m ( F C − S V n ) BV_m = FC - m \cdot D = FC - m \left(\frac{FC - SV}{n}\right) B V m ​ = FC − m ⋅ D = FC − m ( n FC − S V ​ )

2. Sum-of-the-Years-Digits (SOYD) Depreciation

An accelerated method applying a decreasing fraction to the constant depreciable base ( F C − S V FC - SV FC − S V ). The denominator is the triangular sum of year digits S S S : S = ∑ j = 1 n j = n ( n + 1 ) 2 S = \sum_{j=1}^n j = \frac{n(n + 1)}{2} S = ∑ j = 1 n ​ j = 2 n ( n + 1 ) ​ D m = ( n − m + 1 S ) ( F C − S V ) D_m = \left(\frac{n - m + 1}{S}\right) (FC - SV) D m ​ = ( S n − m + 1 ​ ) ( FC − S V ) B V m = F C − ( F C − S V ) [ m ( 2 n − m + 1 ) 2 S ] = S V + ( F C − S V ) [ ( n − m ) ( n − m + 1 ) 2 S ] BV_m = FC - (FC - SV) \left[ \frac{m(2n - m + 1)}{2S} \right] = SV + (FC - SV) \left[ \frac{(n - m)(n - m + 1)}{2S} \right] B V m ​ = FC − ( FC − S V ) [ 2 S m ( 2 n − m + 1 ) ​ ] = S V + ( FC − S V ) [ 2 S ( n − m ) ( n − m + 1 ) ​ ]

3. Declining Balance (DB) & Double Declining Balance (DDB) Methods

Accelerated methods applying a constant percentage rate d d d to the diminishing unrecovered book value B V m − 1 BV_{m-1} B V m − 1 ​ :

Constant Depreciation Rate ( d d d ):

  • For general Declining Balance: d = 1 − S V F C n d = 1 - \sqrt[n]{\frac{SV}{FC}} d = 1 − n FC S V ​ ​
  • For Double Declining Balance: d = 2 n ( 200 % / n ) d = \frac{2}{n} \; (200\% / n) d = n 2 ​ ( 200%/ n )
  • Annual Depreciation: D m = d ⋅ B V m − 1 D_m = d \cdot BV_{m-1} D m ​ = d ⋅ B V m − 1 ​
  • Book Value at Year m m m : B V m = F C ( 1 − d ) m BV_m = FC(1 - d)^m B V m ​ = FC ( 1 − d ) m

Caution

The DDB Salvage Value Rule: In DDB, the salvage value S V SV S V is not deducted from F C FC FC when computing the annual depreciation rate or initial year depreciation ( D 1 = d ⋅ F C D_1 = d \cdot FC D 1 ​ = d ⋅ FC ). However, an asset can never be depreciated below its salvage value . In later years, if B V m − 1 − D m < S V BV_{m-1} - D_m < SV B V m − 1 ​ − D m ​ < S V , the depreciation deduction is capped at D m = B V m − 1 − S V D_m = BV_{m-1} - SV D m ​ = B V m − 1 ​ − S V , forcing B V m = S V BV_m = SV B V m ​ = S V .

Comprehensive Comparison of Depreciation Methods

Feature Straight Line (SL) Sum-of-the-Years-Digits (SOYD) Double Declining Balance (DDB)

Depreciation Rate Constant: 1 / n 1/n 1/ n Decreasing: n − m + 1 S \frac{n - m + 1}{S} S n − m + 1 ​ Constant: 2 / n 2/n 2/ n

Depreciable Base Constant: ( F C − S V ) (FC - SV) ( FC − S V ) Constant: ( F C − S V ) (FC - SV) ( FC − S V ) Declining: B V m − 1 BV_{m-1} B V m − 1 ​

Salvage Value in Formula Explicitly subtracted Explicitly subtracted Not subtracted in formula; acts as a floor

  • Early Cash Flow Benefit Low tax shield Moderate accelerated tax shield Maximum early tax shield
  • Break-Even Analysis in Engineering Operations

Break-even analysis identifies the activity volume (production units, machine operating hours, kilometers of roadway paved) where total project revenues equal total costs, or where two competing equipment options incur identical total costs.

Single-System Break-Even Volume

Total Cost T C = F C f + v ⋅ Q \text{Total Cost } TC = FC_f + v \cdot Q Total Cost TC = F C f ​ + v ⋅ Q Total Revenue T R = p ⋅ Q \text{Total Revenue } TR = p \cdot Q Total Revenue TR = p ⋅ Q Setting T R = T C TR = TC TR = TC yields the Break-Even Quantity ( Q B E Q_{BE} Q BE ​ ) : Q B E = F C f p − v Q_{BE} = \frac{FC_f}{p - v} Q BE ​ = p − v F C f ​ ​ where F C f FC_f F C f ​ is fixed cost, v v v is variable cost per unit, and p p p is unit selling price ( p − v p - v p − v is unit contribution margin).

Two-Alternative Equipment Selection Break-Even

When choosing between Option 1 (low fixed cost, high variable operating cost) and Option 2 (high capital investment, automated low variable cost): T C 1 = F C 1 + v 1 ⋅ Q = T C 2 = F C 2 + v 2 ⋅ Q TC_1 = FC_1 + v_1 \cdot Q = TC_2 = FC_2 + v_2 \cdot Q T C 1 ​ = F C 1 ​ + v 1 ​ ⋅ Q = T C 2 ​ = F C 2 ​ + v 2 ​ ⋅ Q Q breakeven = F C 2 − F C 1 v 1 − v 2 Q_{\text{breakeven}} = \frac{FC_2 - FC_1}{v_1 - v_2} Q breakeven ​ = v 1 ​ − v 2 ​ F C 2 ​ − F C 1 ​ ​

If anticipated operational volume Q > Q breakeven Q > Q_{\text{breakeven}} Q > Q breakeven ​ , select the capital-intensive Option 2.

If anticipated volume Q < Q breakeven Q < Q_{\text{breakeven}} Q < Q breakeven ​ , select the low-capital Option 1.

Equipment Replacement and Retirement

Replacement studies compare a defender , the asset now owned, with a challenger , the best available replacement. Four rules keep the analysis correct:

Sunk costs are ignored. The defender's original price and book value do not matter. Only its current market value counts, as the opportunity cost of keeping it.

Outsider viewpoint. Treat the defender as if it were bought today at its market value.

Economic service life. For each asset, find the life that minimizes the equivalent uniform annual cost (EUAC) . Capital recovery falls with longer life, while operating and maintenance costs rise.

Compare minimum EUACs. Keep the defender while its marginal cost for the next year is below the challenger's minimum EUAC.

Example. A dump truck can be sold today for PHP 900,000 or in one year for PHP 700,000. Next year it will cost PHP 260,000 to operate. At i = 10 % i = 10\% i = 10% , the marginal cost of keeping it one more year is:

900,000 ( 1.10 ) − 700,000 + 260,000 = 990,000 − 700,000 + 260,000 = PHP 550,000 900{,}000(1.10) - 700{,}000 + 260{,}000 = 990{,}000 - 700{,}000 + 260{,}000 = \text{PHP }550{,}000 900 , 000 ( 1.10 ) − 700 , 000 + 260 , 000 = 990 , 000 − 700 , 000 + 260 , 000 = PHP 550 , 000

If a new truck's minimum EUAC is PHP 610,000, keep the old truck for another year. If it is PHP 520,000, replace now.

Depreciation and Income Taxes

Depreciation is not a cash flow, but it reduces taxable income and therefore taxes. For each year:

Taxable income = Revenue − Operating costs − Depreciation \text{Taxable income} = \text{Revenue} - \text{Operating costs} - \text{Depreciation} Taxable income = Revenue − Operating costs − Depreciation Tax = t × Taxable income \text{Tax} = t \times \text{Taxable income} Tax = t × Taxable income After-tax cash flow (ATCF) = Revenue − Operating costs − Tax \text{After-tax cash flow (ATCF)} = \text{Revenue} - \text{Operating costs} - \text{Tax} After-tax cash flow (ATCF) = Revenue − Operating costs − Tax

The annual tax saving from depreciation, the depreciation tax shield , is t × D t \times D t × D .

Example. A crane earns net revenue of PHP 1,500,000 per year before tax. Straight-line depreciation is PHP 500,000 and the tax rate is 25%. Taxable income is 1,500,000 − 500,000 = 1,000,000 1{,}500{,}000 - 500{,}000 = 1{,}000{,}000 1 , 500 , 000 − 500 , 000 = 1 , 000 , 000 , so the tax is PHP 250,000. The ATCF is 1,500,000 − 250,000 = PHP 1,250,000 1{,}500{,}000 - 250{,}000 = \text{PHP }1{,}250{,}000 1 , 500 , 000 − 250 , 000 = PHP 1 , 250 , 000 . The tax shield is 0.25 × 500,000 = PHP 125,000 0.25 \times 500{,}000 = \text{PHP }125{,}000 0.25 × 500 , 000 = PHP 125 , 000 . Accelerated methods move these savings to earlier years, which raises present worth.

  • Worked Engineering Evaluation Examples
  • Example 1: Incremental Benefit-Cost Analysis

A regional flood control agency must evaluate two mutually exclusive flood alleviation bypass proposals with a 25 -year 25\text{-year} 25 -year design life and a MARR of 8 % 8\% 8% . The cash flow estimates are summarized below:

Parameter Baseline (Do-Nothing) Channel Plan A Channel Plan B

Initial Construction Cost PHP 0 \text{PHP }0 PHP 0 PHP 20 , 000 , 000 \text{PHP }20,000,000 PHP 20 , 000 , 000 PHP 32 , 000 , 000 \text{PHP }32,000,000 PHP 32 , 000 , 000

Annual Maintenance Cost PHP 0 \text{PHP }0 PHP 0 PHP 500 , 000 \text{PHP }500,000 PHP 500 , 000 PHP 800 , 000 \text{PHP }800,000 PHP 800 , 000

Annual Flood Damage Protection (Benefits) PHP 0 \text{PHP }0 PHP 0 PHP 2 , 800 , 000 \text{PHP }2,800,000 PHP 2 , 800 , 000 PHP 4 , 300 , 000 \text{PHP }4,300,000 PHP 4 , 300 , 000

Capital Recovery factor: ( A / P , 8 % , 25 ) = 0.08 ( 1.08 ) 25 ( 1.08 ) 25 − 1 = 0.08 ( 6.848475 ) 5.848475 = 0.093679 (A/P, 8\%, 25) = \frac{0.08(1.08)^{25}}{(1.08)^{25} - 1} = \frac{0.08(6.848475)}{5.848475} = 0.093679 ( A / P , 8% , 25 ) = ( 1.08 ) 25 − 1 0.08 ( 1.08 ) 25 ​ = 5.848475 0.08 ( 6.848475 ) ​ = 0.093679 .

Solution:

Equivalent Uniform Annual Cost (EUAC):

EUAC A = 20 , 000 , 000 ( 0.093679 ) + 500 , 000 = 1 , 873 , 580 + 500 , 000 = PHP 2 , 373 , 580 \text{EUAC}_A = 20,000,000(0.093679) + 500,000 = 1,873,580 + 500,000 = \text{PHP }2,373,580 EUAC A ​ = 20 , 000 , 000 ( 0.093679 ) + 500 , 000 = 1 , 873 , 580 + 500 , 000 = PHP 2 , 373 , 580

EUAC B = 32 , 000 , 000 ( 0.093679 ) + 800 , 000 = 2 , 997 , 728 + 800 , 000 = PHP 3 , 797 , 728 \text{EUAC}_B = 32,000,000(0.093679) + 800,000 = 2,997,728 + 800,000 = \text{PHP }3,797,728 EUAC B ​ = 32 , 000 , 000 ( 0.093679 ) + 800 , 000 = 2 , 997 , 728 + 800 , 000 = PHP 3 , 797 , 728

Standalone Benefit-Cost Ratios:

B C R A = 2 , 800 , 000 2 , 373 , 580 = 1.180 > 1.0 ( Plan A is acceptable ) BCR_A = \frac{2,800,000}{2,373,580} = 1.180 > 1.0 \quad (\text{Plan A is acceptable}) BC R A ​ = 2 , 373 , 580 2 , 800 , 000 ​ = 1.180 > 1.0 ( Plan A is acceptable )

B C R B = 4 , 300 , 000 3 , 797 , 728 = 1.132 > 1.0 ( Plan B is acceptable ) BCR_B = \frac{4,300,000}{3,797,728} = 1.132 > 1.0 \quad (\text{Plan B is acceptable}) BC R B ​ = 3 , 797 , 728 4 , 300 , 000 ​ = 1.132 > 1.0 ( Plan B is acceptable )

Incremental Benefit-Cost Evaluation ( Δ B − A \Delta B - A Δ B − A ): Δ Initial Cost = 32 , 000 , 000 − 20 , 000 , 000 = PHP 12 , 000 , 000 \Delta \text{Initial Cost} = 32,000,000 - 20,000,000 = \text{PHP }12,000,000 Δ Initial Cost = 32 , 000 , 000 − 20 , 000 , 000 = PHP 12 , 000 , 000 Δ EUAC = 3 , 797 , 728 − 2 , 373 , 580 = PHP 1 , 424 , 148 \Delta \text{EUAC} = 3,797,728 - 2,373,580 = \text{PHP }1,424,148 Δ EUAC = 3 , 797 , 728 − 2 , 373 , 580 = PHP 1 , 424 , 148 Δ Benefits = 4 , 300 , 000 − 2 , 800 , 000 = PHP 1 , 500 , 000 \Delta \text{Benefits} = 4,300,000 - 2,800,000 = \text{PHP }1,500,000 Δ Benefits = 4 , 300 , 000 − 2 , 800 , 000 = PHP 1 , 500 , 000 Δ B Δ C = 1 , 500 , 000 1 , 424 , 148 = 1.053 > 1.0 \frac{\Delta B}{\Delta C} = \frac{1,500,000}{1,424,148} = 1.053 > 1.0 Δ C Δ B ​ = 1 , 424 , 148 1 , 500 , 000 ​ = 1.053 > 1.0

Conclusion: Even though Plan A exhibits a higher standalone ratio ( 1.18 > 1.13 1.18 > 1.13 1.18 > 1.13 ), the incremental benefit-cost ratio Δ B / Δ C = 1.053 ≥ 1.0 \Delta B / \Delta C = 1.053 \ge 1.0 Δ B /Δ C = 1.053 ≥ 1.0 confirms that the extra PHP 12 , 000 , 000 \text{PHP }12,000,000 PHP 12 , 000 , 000 investment in Plan B is fully justified by the additional flood protection provided. Select Channel Plan B .

Example 2: Heavy Equipment Depreciation Comparison

A heavy hydraulic excavator is acquired by a quarry operator for an initial cost of PHP 6 , 000 , 000 \text{PHP }6,000,000 PHP 6 , 000 , 000 with an anticipated service life of n = 5 years n = 5\text{ years} n = 5 years and an estimated terminal salvage value of PHP 600 , 000 \text{PHP }600,000 PHP 600 , 000 . Construct the complete Year 2 depreciation and book value comparison using Straight Line, SOYD, and Double Declining Balance.

Solution:

Straight Line (SL): D = 6 , 000 , 000 − 600 , 000 5 = 5 , 400 , 000 5 = PHP 1 , 080 , 000 per year D = \frac{6,000,000 - 600,000}{5} = \frac{5,400,000}{5} = \text{PHP }1,080,000\text{ per year} D = 5 6 , 000 , 000 − 600 , 000 ​ = 5 5 , 400 , 000 ​ = PHP 1 , 080 , 000 per year B V 2 = 6 , 000 , 000 − 2 ( 1 , 080 , 000 ) = PHP 3 , 840 , 000 BV_2 = 6,000,000 - 2(1,080,000) = \text{PHP }3,840,000 B V 2 ​ = 6 , 000 , 000 − 2 ( 1 , 080 , 000 ) = PHP 3 , 840 , 000

Sum-of-the-Years-Digits (SOYD): S = 5 ( 6 ) 2 = 15 S = \frac{5(6)}{2} = 15 S = 2 5 ( 6 ) ​ = 15

Year 1: D 1 = ( 5 / 15 ) × 5 , 400 , 000 = PHP 1 , 800 , 000 ⟹ B V 1 = 6 , 000 , 000 − 1 , 800 , 000 = PHP 4 , 200 , 000 D_1 = (5/15) \times 5,400,000 = \text{PHP }1,800,000 \implies BV_1 = 6,000,000 - 1,800,000 = \text{PHP }4,200,000 D 1 ​ = ( 5/15 ) × 5 , 400 , 000 = PHP 1 , 800 , 000 ⟹ B V 1 ​ = 6 , 000 , 000 − 1 , 800 , 000 = PHP 4 , 200 , 000

Year 2: D 2 = ( 4 / 15 ) × 5 , 400 , 000 = PHP 1 , 440 , 000 ⟹ B V 2 = 4 , 200 , 000 − 1 , 440 , 000 = PHP 2 , 760 , 000 D_2 = (4/15) \times 5,400,000 = \text{PHP }1,440,000 \implies BV_2 = 4,200,000 - 1,440,000 = \text{PHP }2,760,000 D 2 ​ = ( 4/15 ) × 5 , 400 , 000 = PHP 1 , 440 , 000 ⟹ B V 2 ​ = 4 , 200 , 000 − 1 , 440 , 000 = PHP 2 , 760 , 000

Double Declining Balance (DDB): d = 2 n = 2 5 = 0.40 = 40 % d = \frac{2}{n} = \frac{2}{5} = 0.40 = 40\% d = n 2 ​ = 5 2 ​ = 0.40 = 40%

Year 1: D 1 = 0.40 × 6 , 000 , 000 = PHP 2 , 400 , 000 ⟹ B V 1 = 6 , 000 , 000 − 2 , 400 , 000 = PHP 3 , 600 , 000 D_1 = 0.40 \times 6,000,000 = \text{PHP }2,400,000 \implies BV_1 = 6,000,000 - 2,400,000 = \text{PHP }3,600,000 D 1 ​ = 0.40 × 6 , 000 , 000 = PHP 2 , 400 , 000 ⟹ B V 1 ​ = 6 , 000 , 000 − 2 , 400 , 000 = PHP 3 , 600 , 000

Year 2: D 2 = 0.40 × 3 , 600 , 000 = PHP 1 , 440 , 000 ⟹ B V 2 = 3 , 600 , 000 − 1 , 440 , 000 = PHP 2 , 160 , 000 D_2 = 0.40 \times 3,600,000 = \text{PHP }1,440,000 \implies BV_2 = 3,600,000 - 1,440,000 = \text{PHP }2,160,000 D 2 ​ = 0.40 × 3 , 600 , 000 = PHP 1 , 440 , 000 ⟹ B V 2 ​ = 3 , 600 , 000 − 1 , 440 , 000 = PHP 2 , 160 , 000 (Since B V 2 = 2 , 160 , 000 > 600 , 000 BV_2 = 2,160,000 > 600,000 B V 2 ​ = 2 , 160 , 000 > 600 , 000 , no salvage floor truncation occurs in Year 2).

Board Exam Traps & Common Errors

Warning

Common Exam Trap 1: Subtracting salvage value in Double Declining Balance. Candidates mistakenly compute Year 1 DDB depreciation as d ⋅ ( F C − S V ) = 0.40 × ( 6 , 000 , 000 − 600 , 000 ) = 2 , 160 , 000 d \cdot (FC - SV) = 0.40 \times (6,000,000 - 600,000) = 2,160,000 d ⋅ ( FC − S V ) = 0.40 × ( 6 , 000 , 000 − 600 , 000 ) = 2 , 160 , 000 . Salvage value is strictly omitted from the DDB annual formula; it functions solely as a terminal floor below which book value cannot decline.

Warning

Common Exam Trap 2: Selecting projects based on the highest individual Benefit-Cost Ratio. Standalone BCR cannot evaluate mutually exclusive projects of differing scales. A small project with F C = PHP 100 , 000 FC = \text{PHP }100,000 FC = PHP 100 , 000 and B = PHP 200 , 000 B = \text{PHP }200,000 B = PHP 200 , 000 has B C R = 2.0 BCR = 2.0 BCR = 2.0 , but generates only PHP 100,000 net benefits, whereas a larger proposal with F C = PHP 10 , 000 , 000 FC = \text{PHP }10,000,000 FC = PHP 10 , 000 , 000 and B = PHP 15 , 000 , 000 B = \text{PHP }15,000,000 B = PHP 15 , 000 , 000 has B C R = 1.5 BCR = 1.5 BCR = 1.5 but generates PHP 5,000,000 in societal wealth. Incremental analysis is mandatory.

Warning

Common Exam Trap 3: Comparing unequal lives with Present Worth without Least Common Multiple (LCM). If Machine A lasts 3 years and Machine B lasts 6 years, evaluating their present worth directly over 3 and 6 years produces invalid comparisons. You must either evaluate Machine A over two successive 3-year replacement cycles to match Machine B's 6-year life, or use the Annual Worth method.

Loading diagram... Incremental Benefit-Cost Ratio (ΔB / ΔC) Decision Tree for Public Projects