Study guide

14.4 Reinforced Concrete Columns and Isolated Footing Design

PRC Civil Engineer Licensure Examination CELE

Track your progress as you read

Finished sections get a check mark.

1 Chapter 1: Examination Overview, RA 544 & Professional Practice

1.1 CELE Structure, Format, Scoring, and 2026 Subject Order 1.2 Republic Act No. 544: The Civil Engineering Law and Board Regulations 1.3 Civil Engineering Ethics, Contracts, and Professional Practice

2 Chapter 2: Engineering Mathematics, Numerical Methods & Physics

2.1 Advanced Algebra, Progressions & Word Problems 2.2 Trigonometry and Analytical Geometry 2.3 Differential and Integral Calculus 2.4 Differential Equations and Numerical Methods 2.5 Series, Hyperbolic Functions, Multivariable Calculus, and Laplace Transforms 2.6 Numerical Methods: Linear Systems, Interpolation, Curve Fitting, and ODE Solvers 2.7 Physics for Engineers: Kinematics, Newton's Laws, Work-Energy, and Momentum

3 Chapter 3: Engineering Data Analysis & Engineering Economy

3.1 Engineering Data Analysis and Statistical Applications 3.2 Parameter Estimation, Linear Regression, Correlation, and Queuing Models 3.3 Engineering Economy: Time Value of Money and Interest Formulas 3.4 Project Evaluation, Depreciation, and Benefit-Cost Analysis

4 Chapter 4: Surveying Fundamentals, Construction Layout & Route Surveying

4.1 Errors, Corrections, and Pacing/Taping 4.2 Leveling, Earthworks, and Mass Haul Diagrams 4.3 Traverse Computations, Balancing, and Area Determinations 4.4 Route Surveying: Horizontal and Vertical Curves

5 Chapter 5: Highway & Transportation Engineering

5.1 Highway Geometric Design and Sight Distances 5.2 Traffic Engineering, Flow Fundamentals, and Pavement Design 5.3 Highway Policy, Route Location, Drainage, and Earthwork Slopes 5.4 Transportation Planning, Network Analysis, and Intermodal Systems

6 Chapter 6: Construction Materials, Methods, Management & Safety

6.1 Materials for Construction: Concrete, Formwork, Masonry, Steel, and Wood Products 6.2 Construction Equipment, Formwork, and Construction Methods 6.3 Construction Occupational Safety and Health: RA 11058 and DOLE DO 13 6.4 Construction Project Management, CPM/PERT, and Resource Scheduling 6.5 Construction Principles: Design Requirements, Project Organization, Cost Control, and Value Engineering 6.6 Quantity Surveying, Unit Cost Analysis, and Project Cost Estimates 6.7 Construction Trades and Specialties: Plumbing, Plastics, Doors and Windows, Finishes, and Electrical

7 Chapter 7: Fluid Properties, Hydrostatics & Buoyancy

7.1 Fluid Properties, Units, and Pressure Measurement 7.2 Hydrostatic Pressure on Plane and Curved Surfaces 7.3 Buoyancy, Flotation, and Accelerated Fluid Masses

8 Chapter 8: Hydrodynamics, Pipe Flow, Open Channels & Water Supply

8.1 Fluid Dynamics: Continuity and Energy Equations 8.2 Flow Measurement: Orifices, Weirs, and Venturi Meters 8.3 Fluid Flow in Pipes, Friction Losses, and Pipe Networks 8.4 Open Channel Flow, Manning's Equation, and Hydraulic Jump 8.5 Water Supply: Demand, Storage, Pumping, Distribution, and Treatment

9 Chapter 9: Soil Properties, Seepage & Stresses in Soil Mass

9.1 Soil Composition, Weight-Volume Phase Relationships 9.2 Soil Classification Systems (USCS & AASHTO) and Atterberg Limits 9.3 Soil Permeability, Seepage, Flow Nets, and Effective Stress 9.4 Stresses in Soil Mass, Stress Distribution, and Immediate and Secondary Settlement

10 Chapter 10: Consolidation, Soil Strength, Earth Pressures & Foundations

10.1 Soil Compaction and Soil Compressibility/Consolidation 10.2 Shear Strength of Soils and Mohr-Coulomb Failure Criteria 10.3 Lateral Earth Pressures (Rankine & Coulomb) and Retaining Walls 10.4 Shallow and Deep Foundation Bearing Capacity and Slope Stability

11 Chapter 11: Engineering Mechanics & Statics

11.1 Force Systems, Resultants, and Equilibrium of Rigid Bodies 11.2 Centroids, Moments of Inertia, and Friction 11.3 Cables, Trusses, and Internal Forces in Members

12 Chapter 12: Strength of Materials

12.1 Axial Stress, Strain, and Deformation 12.2 Torsion, Flanged Bolt Couplings, and Thin-Walled Pressure Vessels 12.3 Beam Stresses: Flexural and Transverse Shear 12.4 Beam Deflections, Combined Stresses, and Mohr's Circle

13 Chapter 13: Structural Analysis & NSCP Load Criteria

13.1 Indeterminate Structures: Approximate and Classical Methods 13.2 Moment Distribution Method and Slope Deflection 13.3 Influence Lines for Determinate and Indeterminate Structures 13.4 NSCP Minimum Design Loads: Dead, Live, Wind, and Earthquake

14 Chapter 14: Reinforced Concrete Design (NSCP 2015 / USD)

14.1 Ultimate Strength Design (USD) Principles and Singly Reinforced Beams 14.2 Doubly Reinforced Beams and T-Beams 14.3 Shear and Diagonal Tension, Stirrup Design, and Development Length 14.4 Reinforced Concrete Columns and Isolated Footing Design

15 Chapter 15: Steel, Timber & Prestressed Design and Materials Testing

15.1 Structural Steel Tension Members and Connections 15.2 Structural Steel Compression Members and Beam Design 15.3 Timber Design Principles, Working Stress, and Sawn Lumber Beams 15.4 Prestressed Concrete Fundamentals and Prestress Losses 15.5 Construction Materials Testing and Concrete Mix Proportioning

14.4 Reinforced Concrete Columns and Isolated Footing Design

Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI

NSCP 2015 limits the longitudinal reinforcement ratio in compression members to 0.01 ≤ ρ g ≤ 0.08 0.01 \le \rho_g \le 0.08 0.01 ≤ ρ g ​ ≤ 0.08 , though practical seismic construction limits ρ g \rho_g ρ g ​ to 0.04 to prevent severe rebar congestion at lap splices.

To account for minimum accidental eccentricities, maximum design axial compressive strength is reduced to ϕ P n , max ⁡ = 0.80 ϕ P 0 \phi P_{n,\max} = 0.80 \phi P_0 ϕ P n , m a x ​ = 0.80 ϕ P 0 ​ with ϕ = 0.65 \phi = 0.65 ϕ = 0.65 for tied columns, and ϕ P n , max ⁡ = 0.85 ϕ P 0 \phi P_{n,\max} = 0.85 \phi P_0 ϕ P n , m a x ​ = 0.85 ϕ P 0 ​ with ϕ = 0.75 \phi = 0.75 ϕ = 0.75 for spiral columns, where P 0 = 0.85 f c ′ ( A g − A s t ) + f y A s t P_0 = 0.85 f'_c (A_g - A_{st}) + f_y A_{st} P 0 ​ = 0.85 f c ′ ​ ( A g ​ − A s t ​ ) + f y ​ A s t ​ .

Lateral tie spacing in tied columns must not exceed min ⁡ ( 16 d b , 48 d tie , least column dimension ) \min(16 d_b, 48 d_{\text{tie}}, \text{least column dimension}) min ( 16 d b ​ , 48 d tie ​ , least column dimension ) ; circular spirals must satisfy a volumetric ratio ρ s ≥ 0.45 ( A g A c h − 1 ) f c ′ f y t \rho_s \ge 0.45 \left(\frac{A_g}{A_{ch}} - 1\right)\frac{f'_c}{f_{yt}} ρ s ​ ≥ 0.45 ( A c h ​ A g ​ ​ − 1 ) f y t ​ f c ′ ​ ​ .

Isolated footing plan dimensions are sized using unfactored service loads ( D + L D + L D + L ) and net allowable soil bearing capacity ( q net q_{\text{net}} q net ​ ), whereas footing thickness and flexural reinforcement are designed using factored soil bearing pressure ( q u = P u / A footing q_u = P_u / A_{\text{footing}} q u ​ = P u ​ / A footing ​ ).

Footing structural depth is governed by two shear checks: one-way (wide beam) shear at distance d d d from the column face, and two-way (punching) shear along a critical perimeter b 0 b_0 b 0 ​ located at distance d / 2 d/2 d /2 from all column faces.

Last updated: October 2026

14.4 Reinforced Concrete Columns and Isolated Footing Design

Columns and footings form the structural spine and foundation of reinforced concrete buildings. Columns transfer accumulated floor gravity and lateral loads down to the substructure, while spread footings disperse concentrated column loads safely into the supporting soil strata. In Philippine civil engineering licensure examinations, mastering the axial-flexural capacities of tied and spiral columns and navigating the dual shear criteria ( wide beam shear vs. punching shear ) for isolated footings are among the most heavily weighted proficiencies.

1. Classification and Reinforcement Limits of Columns

Reinforced concrete compression members are classified by their transverse confinement into:

Tied Columns: Longitudinal bars are enclosed by individual closed lateral ties. Failure is sudden once the concrete shell spalls and longitudinal bars buckle outward.

Spiral Columns: Longitudinal bars are enclosed by a continuous closely spaced helical spiral. After the outer concrete shell spalls, the spiral core undergoes triaxial compression, providing extraordinary post-yield ductility, load maintenance, and energy absorption.

Longitudinal Reinforcement Limits (NSCP 2015 Section 410.6.1)

Gross reinforcement ratio: 0.01 ≤ ρ g ≤ 0.08 0.01 \le \rho_g \le 0.08 0.01 ≤ ρ g ​ ≤ 0.08 , where ρ g = A s t A g \rho_g = \frac{A_{st}}{A_g} ρ g ​ = A g ​ A s t ​ ​ .

Practical Limit: In building design and high-seismic zones, engineers restrict ρ g \rho_g ρ g ​ to a maximum of 0.04 0.04 0.04 ( 4 % 4\% 4% ) to avoid severe rebar congestion at beam-column joint lap splices.

Minimum number of longitudinal bars:

Minimum 4 bars for rectangular or circular tied columns.

Minimum 6 bars for spiral columns or columns enclosed by circular ties.

Minimum 3 bars for triangular tied columns.

2. Transverse Reinforcement Detailing

Lateral Ties (NSCP 2015 Section 425.7.2):

Tie Bar Diameter:

At least ϕ 10 mm \phi 10\text{ mm} ϕ 10 mm ties for enclosing longitudinal bars ≤ ϕ 32 mm \le \phi 32\text{ mm} ≤ ϕ 32 mm .

At least ϕ 12 mm \phi 12\text{ mm} ϕ 12 mm ties for enclosing longitudinal bars ≥ ϕ 36 mm \ge \phi 36\text{ mm} ≥ ϕ 36 mm or bundled bars.

Maximum Vertical Tie Spacing ( s s s ): s ≤ min ⁡ ( 16 d b , 48 d tie , least lateral column dimension ) s \le \min(16 d_b, \quad 48 d_{\text{tie}}, \quad \text{least lateral column dimension}) s ≤ min ( 16 d b ​ , 48 d tie ​ , least lateral column dimension ) where d b d_b d b ​ is the diameter of the smallest longitudinal bar and d tie d_{\text{tie}} d tie ​ is the tie diameter.

Spirals (NSCP 2015 Section 425.7.3):

Minimum spiral bar diameter: 10 mm 10\text{ mm} 10 mm .

Clear spacing between spiral turns: 25 mm ≤ s clear ≤ 75 mm 25\text{ mm} \le s_{\text{clear}} \le 75\text{ mm} 25 mm ≤ s clear ​ ≤ 75 mm .

Volumetric Ratio of Spiral Reinforcement ( ρ s \rho_s ρ s ​ ): ρ s ≥ 0.45 ( A g A c h − 1 ) f c ′ f y t \rho_s \ge 0.45 \left(\frac{A_g}{A_{ch}} - 1\right) \frac{f'_c}{f_{yt}} ρ s ​ ≥ 0.45 ( A c h ​ A g ​ ​ − 1 ) f y t ​ f c ′ ​ ​ Where:

A g = π D 2 4 A_g = \frac{\pi D^2}{4} A g ​ = 4 π D 2 ​ = gross area of column.

A c h = π D c 2 4 A_{ch} = \frac{\pi D_c^2}{4} A c h ​ = 4 π D c 2 ​ ​ = core area measured to the outside diameter ( D c D_c D c ​ ) of the spiral.

The actual volumetric spiral ratio for pitch s s s is: ρ s = 4 A s p D c s \rho_s = \frac{4 A_{sp}}{D_c s} ρ s ​ = D c ​ s 4 A s p ​ ​ , where A s p A_{sp} A s p ​ is the cross-sectional area of the spiral bar.

  • 3. Axial Compressive Capacity Formulations
  • Pure Axial Compressive Strength ( P 0 P_0 P 0 ​ )

Under ideal concentric compression (zero eccentricity), both concrete and steel reach their yield capacities simultaneously:

P 0 = 0.85 f c ′ ( A g − A s t ) + f y A s t P_0 = 0.85 f'_c (A_g - A_{st}) + f_y A_{st} P 0 ​ = 0.85 f c ′ ​ ( A g ​ − A s t ​ ) + f y ​ A s t ​

Where ( A g − A s t ) (A_g - A_{st}) ( A g ​ − A s t ​ ) represents the net concrete compressive area.

Accidental Eccentricity Reductions and Design Strengths

In actual structures, columns are never perfectly plumb or concentrically loaded. Imperfections, construction tolerances, and moments from framing induce unintentional eccentricities ( e / h ≈ 0.10 e/h \approx 0.10 e / h ≈ 0.10 for tied; 0.05 0.05 0.05 for spiral). NSCP 2015 accounts for this by applying an eccentricity reduction factor ( 0.80 0.80 0.80 for tied; 0.85 0.85 0.85 for spiral) along with strength reduction factors:

Column Type Strength Reduction Factor ϕ \phi ϕ Maximum Factored Design Axial Strength ϕ P n , max ⁡ \phi P_{n,\max} ϕ P n , m a x ​

Tied Columns ϕ = 0.65 \phi = 0.65 ϕ = 0.65 ϕ P n , max ⁡ = 0.80 ϕ [ 0.85 f c ′ ( A g − A s t ) + f y A s t ] \phi P_{n,\max} = 0.80 \phi [0.85 f'_c (A_g - A_{st}) + f_y A_{st}] ϕ P n , m a x ​ = 0.80 ϕ [ 0.85 f c ′ ​ ( A g ​ − A s t ​ ) + f y ​ A s t ​ ]

Spiral Columns ϕ = 0.75 \phi = 0.75 ϕ = 0.75 ϕ P n , max ⁡ = 0.85 ϕ [ 0.85 f c ′ ( A g − A s t ) + f y A s t ] \phi P_{n,\max} = 0.85 \phi [0.85 f'_c (A_g - A_{st}) + f_y A_{st}] ϕ P n , m a x ​ = 0.85 ϕ [ 0.85 f c ′ ​ ( A g ​ − A s t ​ ) + f y ​ A s t ​ ]

  • 4. Column Interaction Diagrams and Slenderness
  • P n − M n P_n - M_n P n ​ − M n ​ Interaction Diagram

A column subjected to combined axial compression and bending moment must satisfy ϕ P n ≥ P u \phi P_n \ge P_u ϕ P n ​ ≥ P u ​ and ϕ M n ≥ M u \phi M_n \ge M_u ϕ M n ​ ≥ M u ​ . The capacity envelope is represented by a Column Interaction Diagram :

Point A (Pure Axial Compression): P n = P 0 P_n = P_0 P n ​ = P 0 ​ ; truncated at ϕ P n , max ⁡ \phi P_{n,\max} ϕ P n , m a x ​ to reflect accidental eccentricity.

Point B (Compression-Controlled Region): Failure initiated by concrete crushing before steel yields ( ϕ = 0.65 \phi = 0.65 ϕ = 0.65 tied / 0.75 0.75 0.75 spiral).

Point C (Balanced Point P b , M b P_b, M_b P b ​ , M b ​ ): Extreme concrete reaches ϵ u = 0.003 \epsilon_u = 0.003 ϵ u ​ = 0.003 exactly when tension steel reaches ϵ y = f y / E s \epsilon_y = f_y / E_s ϵ y ​ = f y ​ / E s ​ .

Point D (Tension-Controlled Region): Tension steel yields substantially ( ϵ t ≥ 0.005 \epsilon_t \ge 0.005 ϵ t ​ ≥ 0.005 ) prior to concrete crushing ( ϕ = 0.90 \phi = 0.90 ϕ = 0.90 ).

Point E (Pure Flexure): P u = 0 , M n = M 0 P_u = 0, M_n = M_0 P u ​ = 0 , M n ​ = M 0 ​ .

Slenderness Effects ( k l u / r k l_u / r k l u ​ / r )

Columns are classified as short (slenderness neglected) or slender (secondary P − Δ P-\Delta P − Δ and P − δ P-\delta P − δ moments must be magnified):

Radius of gyration: r ≈ 0.30 h r \approx 0.30 h r ≈ 0.30 h for rectangular columns; r ≈ 0.25 D r \approx 0.25 D r ≈ 0.25 D for circular columns.

Non-Sway Frames: Slenderness may be neglected if: k l u r ≤ 34 − 12 ( M 1 M 2 ) ≤ 40 \frac{k l_u}{r} \le 34 - 12 \left(\frac{M_1}{M_2}\right) \le 40 r k l u ​ ​ ≤ 34 − 12 ( M 2 ​ M 1 ​ ​ ) ≤ 40 (where M 1 / M 2 M_1/M_2 M 1 ​ / M 2 ​ is positive for single curvature bending and negative for double curvature) .

Sway Frames: Slenderness may be neglected if k l u r < 22 \frac{k l_u}{r} < 22 r k l u ​ ​ < 22 .

5. Isolated Spread Footing Design

Isolated spread footings distribute concentrated column loads into the soil. The design process involves two fundamentally different load stages:

Serviceability Limit State (Unfactored Loads): Used to determine the footing plan dimensions ( B × L f B \times L_f B × L f ​ ) so that soil pressure does not exceed allowable soil bearing capacity ( q a q_a q a ​ ).

Ultimate Strength Limit State (Factored Loads): Used to determine footing thickness ( h , d h, d h , d ) and reinforcement area ( A s A_s A s ​ ) using factored soil pressure ( q u q_u q u ​ ).

Sizing Footing Plan Area

Net allowable soil bearing pressure accounts for the weight of the concrete footing and soil surcharge:

q net = q allow − γ concrete h f − γ soil D s q_{\text{net}} = q_{\text{allow}} - \gamma_{\text{concrete}} h_f - \gamma_{\text{soil}} D_s q net ​ = q allow ​ − γ concrete ​ h f ​ − γ soil ​ D s ​

A footing = B × L f ≥ P service q net = D + L q net A_{\text{footing}} = B \times L_f \ge \frac{P_{\text{service}}}{q_{\text{net}}} = \frac{D + L}{q_{\text{net}}} A footing ​ = B × L f ​ ≥ q net ​ P service ​ ​ = q net ​ D + L ​

Factored Soil Pressure for Structural Sizing ( q u q_u q u ​ )

q u = P u A actual = 1.2 D + 1.6 L B × L f q_u = \frac{P_u}{A_{\text{actual}}} = \frac{1.2 D + 1.6 L}{B \times L_f} q u ​ = A actual ​ P u ​ ​ = B × L f ​ 1.2 D + 1.6 L ​

6. Critical Sections for Footing Shear Checks

Footing depth ( d d d ) is determined by shear without shear reinforcement (stirrups are rarely placed in footings). Two distinct shear mechanisms must be checked:

A. One-Way (Wide-Beam) Shear

Critical Section: Evaluated along a vertical plane extending across the full footing width at a distance d d d from the face of the column .

Concrete shear capacity: ϕ V c = ϕ ( 0.17 λ f c ′ B d ) \phi V_c = \phi \left(0.17 \lambda \sqrt{f'_c} B d\right) ϕ V c ​ = ϕ ( 0.17 λ f c ′ ​ ​ B d ) with ϕ = 0.75 \phi = 0.75 ϕ = 0.75 .

Factored shear demand: V u 1 = q u × B × ( x − d ) V_{u1} = q_u \times B \times (x - d) V u 1 ​ = q u ​ × B × ( x − d ) , where x x x is the cantilever overhang distance from the column face.

B. Two-Way (Punching) Shear

Critical Section: Evaluated along a perimeter b 0 b_0 b 0 ​ located at a distance d / 2 d/2 d /2 from all faces of the column .

For a rectangular column c 1 × c 2 c_1 \times c_2 c 1 ​ × c 2 ​ : b 0 = 2 ( c 1 + d ) + 2 ( c 2 + d ) b_0 = 2(c_1 + d) + 2(c_2 + d) b 0 ​ = 2 ( c 1 ​ + d ) + 2 ( c 2 ​ + d )

Factored punching shear demand: V u 2 = P u − q u ( c 1 + d ) ( c 2 + d ) V_{u2} = P_u - q_u (c_1 + d)(c_2 + d) V u 2 ​ = P u ​ − q u ​ ( c 1 ​ + d ) ( c 2 ​ + d )

Punching shear strength is the minimum of three NSCP 2015 criteria ( ϕ = 0.75 \phi = 0.75 ϕ = 0.75 ): V c = min ⁡ { 0.17 ( 1 + 2 β c ) λ f c ′ b 0 d 0.083 ( α s d b 0 + 2 ) λ f c ′ b 0 d 0.33 λ f c ′ b 0 d V_c = \min \begin{cases} 0.17 \left(1 + \frac{2}{\beta_c}\right) \lambda \sqrt{f'_c} b_0 d \\ 0.083 \left(\frac{\alpha_s d}{b_0} + 2\right) \lambda \sqrt{f'_c} b_0 d \\ 0.33 \lambda \sqrt{f'_c} b_0 d \end{cases} V c ​ = min ⎩ ⎨ ⎧ ​ 0.17 ( 1 + β c ​ 2 ​ ) λ f c ′ ​ ​ b 0 ​ d 0.083 ( b 0 ​ α s ​ d ​ + 2 ) λ f c ′ ​ ​ b 0 ​ d 0.33 λ f c ′ ​ ​ b 0 ​ d ​ Where:

β c = long side of column short side of column \beta_c = \frac{\text{long side of column}}{\text{short side of column}} β c ​ = short side of column long side of column ​ .

α s = 40 \alpha_s = 40 α s ​ = 40 for interior columns; 30 30 30 for edge columns; 20 20 20 for corner columns.

7. Footing Flexural Design

Critical Section for Flexure: Located directly at the face of the column (or halfway between center and edge of masonry walls; or at the face of steel base plates).

Factored moment: M u = q u × B × x 2 2 M_u = q_u \times B \times \frac{x^2}{2} M u ​ = q u ​ × B × 2 x 2 ​ , where x x x is the cantilever projection.

Required A s A_s A s ​ is calculated using beam flexural design formulas.

Minimum shrinkage and temperature reinforcement: A s , min ⁡ = 0.0018 B h A_{s,\min} = 0.0018 B h A s , m i n ​ = 0.0018 B h (for Grade 420 steel).

Reinforcement Distribution in Rectangular Footings:

Long direction steel is distributed uniformly across width B B B .

Short direction steel is concentrated in a central band of width B B B : A s , band A s , total = 2 β + 1 \frac{A_{s,\text{band}}}{A_{s,\text{total}}} = \frac{2}{\beta + 1} A s , total ​ A s , band ​ ​ = β + 1 2 ​ where β = L f / B \beta = L_f / B β = L f ​ / B .

8. Loads on Piled Foundations and Pile Caps

The TOS item "determine loads on piled foundations" is usually solved with the rigid-cap assumption : the cap is stiff, and every pile carries axial load only. For n n n identical vertical piles under a vertical load P P P (including cap weight) and moments M x M_x M x ​ and M y M_y M y ​ about the pile-group centroid:

R i = P n ± M x y i ∑ y 2 ± M y x i ∑ x 2 R_i = \frac{P}{n} \pm \frac{M_x\, y_i}{\sum y^2} \pm \frac{M_y\, x_i}{\sum x^2} R i ​ = n P ​ ± ∑ y 2 M x ​ y i ​ ​ ± ∑ x 2 M y ​ x i ​ ​

Here x i x_i x i ​ and y i y_i y i ​ are each pile's distances from the group centroid. A negative R i R_i R i ​ means the pile is in tension (uplift) .

Example. A cap on 6 piles in two rows of three carries P = 2,400 kN P = 2{,}400\text{ kN} P = 2 , 400 kN and M y = 360 kN ⋅ m M_y = 360\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m} M y ​ = 360 kN ⋅ m . The pile spacing is 1.2 m 1.2\text{ m} 1.2 m , so x = − 1.2 , 0 , + 1.2 m x = -1.2, 0, +1.2\text{ m} x = − 1.2 , 0 , + 1.2 m in each row. Then ∑ x 2 = 4 ( 1.2 ) 2 = 5.76 m 2 \sum x^2 = 4(1.2)^2 = 5.76\text{ m}^2 ∑ x 2 = 4 ( 1.2 ) 2 = 5.76 m 2 .

Corner piles on the side of the moment: R = 2,400 / 6 + 360 ( 1.2 ) / 5.76 = 400 + 75 = 475 kN R = 2{,}400/6 + 360(1.2)/5.76 = 400 + 75 = 475\text{ kN} R = 2 , 400/6 + 360 ( 1.2 ) /5.76 = 400 + 75 = 475 kN .

Opposite side: 400 − 75 = 325 kN 400 - 75 = 325\text{ kN} 400 − 75 = 325 kN .

Center piles: 400 kN 400\text{ kN} 400 kN .

Pile cap design checks:

Choose the number of piles so that the maximum service-load pile reaction does not exceed the allowable pile capacity.

Check punching shear around the column at d / 2 d/2 d /2 , and around corner piles.

Check one-way shear at d d d from the column face. Pile reactions whose centers lie within the critical section are excluded, following the ACI rule for piles partly inside it.

Design flexure at the column face using the factored pile reactions outside that face.

  • 9. Comprehensive Worked Examples
  • Worked Example 1: Tied Column Design Axial Capacity and Detailing

Problem: A short square tied column has dimensions 400 mm × 400 mm 400\text{ mm} \times 400\text{ mm} 400 mm × 400 mm and is reinforced with 8 − ϕ 25 mm 8 - \phi 25\text{ mm} 8 − ϕ 25 mm longitudinal bars ( A s t = 8 × 490.87 = 3927 mm 2 A_{st} = 8 \times 490.87 = 3927\text{ mm}^2 A s t ​ = 8 × 490.87 = 3927 mm 2 ). Specified materials are f c ′ = 28 MPa f'_c = 28\text{ MPa} f c ′ ​ = 28 MPa and f y = 420 MPa f_y = 420\text{ MPa} f y ​ = 420 MPa . Using 10 mm 10\text{ mm} 10 mm ties:

(a) Verify longitudinal reinforcement ratio limits.

(b) Compute the maximum nominal axial strength P n , max ⁡ P_{n,\max} P n , m a x ​ and design axial strength ϕ P n , max ⁡ \phi P_{n,\max} ϕ P n , m a x ​ .

(c) Determine the maximum vertical spacing of lateral ties.

Solution:

Step 1: Check Reinforcement Ratio: A g = 400 × 400 = 160 , 000 mm 2 A_g = 400 \times 400 = 160,000\text{ mm}^2 A g ​ = 400 × 400 = 160 , 000 mm 2 ρ g = A s t A g = 3927 160 , 000 = 0.02454 ( 2.45 % \rho_g = \frac{A_{st}}{A_g} = \frac{3927}{160,000} = 0.02454 \quad (2.45\% ρ g ​ = A g ​ A s t ​ ​ = 160 , 000 3927 ​ = 0.02454 ( 2.45% Since 0.01 ≤ 0.02454 ≤ 0.08 0.01 \le 0.02454 \le 0.08 0.01 ≤ 0.02454 ≤ 0.08 (and < 0.04 < 0.04 < 0.04 ), reinforcement limits are satisfied.

Step 2: Compute Axial Compressive Strength: Net concrete area: A g − A s t = 160 , 000 − 3927 = 156 , 073 mm 2 A_g - A_{st} = 160,000 - 3927 = 156,073\text{ mm}^2 A g ​ − A s t ​ = 160 , 000 − 3927 = 156 , 073 mm 2 . P 0 = 0.85 f c ′ ( A g − A s t ) + f y A s t P_0 = 0.85 f'_c (A_g - A_{st}) + f_y A_{st} P 0 ​ = 0.85 f c ′ ​ ( A g ​ − A s t ​ ) + f y ​ A s t ​ P 0 = 0.85 ( 28 ) ( 156 , 073 ) + 420 ( 3927 ) = 3 , 714 , 537 + 1 , 649 , 340 = 5 , 363 , 877 N = 5363.88 kN P_0 = 0.85(28)(156,073) + 420(3927) = 3,714,537 + 1,649,340 = 5,363,877\text{ N} = 5363.88\text{ kN} P 0 ​ = 0.85 ( 28 ) ( 156 , 073 ) + 420 ( 3927 ) = 3 , 714 , 537 + 1 , 649 , 340 = 5 , 363 , 877 N = 5363.88 kN

For a tied column ( ϕ = 0.65 \phi = 0.65 ϕ = 0.65 ): P n , max ⁡ = 0.80 P 0 = 0.80 × 5363.88 = 4291.1 kN P_{n,\max} = 0.80 P_0 = 0.80 \times 5363.88 = 4291.1\text{ kN} P n , m a x ​ = 0.80 P 0 ​ = 0.80 × 5363.88 = 4291.1 kN ϕ P n , max ⁡ = 0.80 ϕ P 0 = 0.80 × 0.65 × 5363.88 = 2789.2 kN \phi P_{n,\max} = 0.80 \phi P_0 = 0.80 \times 0.65 \times 5363.88 = 2789.2\text{ kN} ϕ P n , m a x ​ = 0.80 ϕ P 0 ​ = 0.80 × 0.65 × 5363.88 = 2789.2 kN

Step 3: Maximum Tie Spacing:

16 d b = 16 × 25 mm = 400 mm 16 d_b = 16 \times 25\text{ mm} = 400\text{ mm} 16 d b ​ = 16 × 25 mm = 400 mm

48 d tie = 48 × 10 mm = 480 mm 48 d_{\text{tie}} = 48 \times 10\text{ mm} = 480\text{ mm} 48 d tie ​ = 48 × 10 mm = 480 mm

Least column lateral dimension = 400 mm = 400\text{ mm} = 400 mm s max ⁡ = min ⁡ ( 400 , 480 , 400 ) = 400 mm s_{\max} = \min(400, 480, 400) = 400\text{ mm} s m a x ​ = min ( 400 , 480 , 400 ) = 400 mm Selection: Provide ϕ 10 mm \phi 10\text{ mm} ϕ 10 mm ties at 400 mm 400\text{ mm} 400 mm on centers.

Worked Example 2: Isolated Spread Footing Punching Shear Check

Problem: A square isolated footing supports a 450 mm × 450 mm 450\text{ mm} \times 450\text{ mm} 450 mm × 450 mm interior column carrying factored axial load P u = 1800 kN P_u = 1800\text{ kN} P u ​ = 1800 kN . The footing plan is 2.5 m × 2.5 m 2.5\text{ m} \times 2.5\text{ m} 2.5 m × 2.5 m with effective depth d = 350 mm d = 350\text{ mm} d = 350 mm . Concrete compressive strength is f c ′ = 21 MPa f'_c = 21\text{ MPa} f c ′ ​ = 21 MPa (normal-weight). Verify if the footing thickness is adequate for two-way punching shear.

Solution:

Step 1: Factored Soil Pressure ( q u q_u q u ​ ): q u = P u B 2 = 1800 kN 2.5 × 2.5 = 1800 6.25 = 288.0 kN/m 2 = 0.288 MPa q_u = \frac{P_u}{B^2} = \frac{1800\text{ kN}}{2.5 \times 2.5} = \frac{1800}{6.25} = 288.0\text{ kN/m}^2 = 0.288\text{ MPa} q u ​ = B 2 P u ​ ​ = 2.5 × 2.5 1800 kN ​ = 6.25 1800 ​ = 288.0 kN/m 2 = 0.288 MPa

Step 2: Critical Punching Perimeter ( b 0 b_0 b 0 ​ ): The critical perimeter is located at d / 2 = 350 / 2 = 175 mm d/2 = 350/2 = 175\text{ mm} d /2 = 350/2 = 175 mm from the column face: c 1 + d = 450 + 350 = 800 mm c_1 + d = 450 + 350 = 800\text{ mm} c 1 ​ + d = 450 + 350 = 800 mm b 0 = 4 × ( c 1 + d ) = 4 × 800 = 3200 mm b_0 = 4 \times (c_1 + d) = 4 \times 800 = 3200\text{ mm} b 0 ​ = 4 × ( c 1 ​ + d ) = 4 × 800 = 3200 mm

Step 3: Factored Punching Shear Demand ( V u 2 V_{u2} V u 2 ​ ): V u 2 = P u − q u ( c 1 + d ) 2 = 1800 − 288.0 × ( 0.80 ) 2 = 1800 − 184.32 = 1615.68 kN V_{u2} = P_u - q_u (c_1 + d)^2 = 1800 - 288.0 \times (0.80)^2 = 1800 - 184.32 = 1615.68\text{ kN} V u 2 ​ = P u ​ − q u ​ ( c 1 ​ + d ) 2 = 1800 − 288.0 × ( 0.80 ) 2 = 1800 − 184.32 = 1615.68 kN

Step 4: Nominal Punching Shear Capacity ( V c V_c V c ​ ): For a square column, β c = 450 / 450 = 1.0 \beta_c = 450/450 = 1.0 β c ​ = 450/450 = 1.0 . Interior column α s = 40 \alpha_s = 40 α s ​ = 40 .

V c 1 = 0.17 ( 1 + 2 1.0 ) ( 1.0 ) 21 ( 3200 ) ( 350 ) × 10 − 3 = 0.51 21 ( 1120 ) = 2616.4 kN V_{c1} = 0.17 \left(1 + \frac{2}{1.0}\right) (1.0)\sqrt{21} (3200)(350) \times 10^{-3} = 0.51 \sqrt{21} (1120) = 2616.4\text{ kN} V c 1 ​ = 0.17 ( 1 + 1.0 2 ​ ) ( 1.0 ) 21 ​ ( 3200 ) ( 350 ) × 1 0 − 3 = 0.51 21 ​ ( 1120 ) = 2616.4 kN

V c 2 = 0.083 ( 40 × 350 3200 + 2 ) 21 ( 1120 ) = 0.083 ( 4.375 + 2 ) ( 4.5826 ) ( 1120 ) = 2717.3 kN V_{c2} = 0.083 \left(\frac{40 \times 350}{3200} + 2\right) \sqrt{21} (1120) = 0.083(4.375 + 2)(4.5826)(1120) = 2717.3\text{ kN} V c 2 ​ = 0.083 ( 3200 40 × 350 ​ + 2 ) 21 ​ ( 1120 ) = 0.083 ( 4.375 + 2 ) ( 4.5826 ) ( 1120 ) = 2717.3 kN

V c 3 = 0.33 ( 1.0 ) 21 ( 3200 ) ( 350 ) × 10 − 3 = 0.33 × 4.5826 × 1120 = 1693.7 kN V_{c3} = 0.33 (1.0)\sqrt{21} (3200)(350) \times 10^{-3} = 0.33 \times 4.5826 \times 1120 = 1693.7\text{ kN} V c 3 ​ = 0.33 ( 1.0 ) 21 ​ ( 3200 ) ( 350 ) × 1 0 − 3 = 0.33 × 4.5826 × 1120 = 1693.7 kN The governing concrete shear strength is V c = 1693.7 kN V_c = 1693.7\text{ kN} V c ​ = 1693.7 kN .

Step 5: Design Capacity and Check: ϕ V c = 0.75 × 1693.7 kN = 1270.28 kN \phi V_c = 0.75 \times 1693.7\text{ kN} = 1270.28\text{ kN} ϕ V c ​ = 0.75 × 1693.7 kN = 1270.28 kN Comparison: Factored demand V u 2 = 1615.68 kN > ϕ V c = 1270.28 kN V_{u2} = 1615.68\text{ kN} > \phi V_c = 1270.28\text{ kN} V u 2 ​ = 1615.68 kN > ϕ V c ​ = 1270.28 kN . Result: The section is inadequate in punching shear! The footing effective depth d d d must be increased (to approximately d ≥ 410 mm d \ge 410\text{ mm} d ≥ 410 mm ) to satisfy ϕ V c ≥ V u 2 \phi V_c \ge V_{u2} ϕ V c ​ ≥ V u 2 ​ .

10. Licensure Exam Pitfalls & Review Notes

Warning

Pitfall 1: Service vs. Factored Loads in Footing Design Always remember: Footing base area ( B × L f B \times L_f B × L f ​ ) is determined using UNFACTORED service loads ( D + L D + L D + L ) divided by allowable soil bearing capacity ( q a q_a q a ​ ). Footing thickness ( d d d ) and bending reinforcement ( A s A_s A s ​ ) are designed using FACTORED loads ( 1.2 D + 1.6 L 1.2 D + 1.6 L 1.2 D + 1.6 L ) and factored pressure ( q u q_u q u ​ ). Mixing these two stages is one of the most common errors in the CELE.

Caution

Pitfall 2: Accidental Eccentricity Factors ( 0.80 0.80 0.80 vs. 0.85 0.85 0.85 ) Tied columns use ϕ P n , max ⁡ = 0.80 ϕ P 0 \phi P_{n,\max} = 0.80 \phi P_0 ϕ P n , m a x ​ = 0.80 ϕ P 0 ​ with ϕ = 0.65 \phi = 0.65 ϕ = 0.65 (overall reduction factor = 0.80 × 0.65 = 0.52 = 0.80 \times 0.65 = 0.52 = 0.80 × 0.65 = 0.52 ). Spiral columns use ϕ P n , max ⁡ = 0.85 ϕ P 0 \phi P_{n,\max} = 0.85 \phi P_0 ϕ P n , m a x ​ = 0.85 ϕ P 0 ​ with ϕ = 0.75 \phi = 0.75 ϕ = 0.75 (overall reduction factor = 0.85 × 0.75 = 0.6375 = 0.85 \times 0.75 = 0.6375 = 0.85 × 0.75 = 0.6375 ). Do not interchange these two factors!

Tip

Pitfall 3: Subtracting Soil Upward Force from Punching Demand In two-way shear, the factored upward soil pressure acting directly beneath the critical punching pyramid ( q u × [ c 1 + d ] [ c 2 + d ] q_u \times [c_1 + d][c_2 + d] q u ​ × [ c 1 ​ + d ] [ c 2 ​ + d ] ) acts upward and directly counteracts downward column punching. Subtract this force from P u P_u P u ​ to get the net punching shear force V u 2 V_{u2} V u 2 ​ .

Loading diagram... Critical Sections for Spread Footing Design