Study guide

19.2 Symmetrical Components & Unbalanced Fault Analysis

PRC Registered Electrical Engineer REE

Track your progress as you read

Finished sections get a check mark.

1 Chapter 1: Overview, RA 7920 & Electrical Engineering Ethics

1.1 PRC Board of Electrical Engineering & REE Examination Overview 1.2 Republic Act No. 7920 (New Electrical Engineering Law) & License Classes 1.3 Code of Ethics & Professional Practice for Electrical Engineers

2 Chapter 2: Math — Algebra, Trig & Geometry

2.1 Algebraic Equations, Polynomials & Complex Numbers 2.2 Trigonometry — Identities, Triangles & Spherical Trig 2.3 Analytic & Solid Geometry

3 Chapter 3: Engineering Mathematics — Calculus & Differential Equations

3.1 Differential Calculus, Limits, Derivatives & Applications 3.2 Integral Calculus, Integration Techniques & Area/Volume Applications 3.3 Ordinary Differential Equations & Initial-Value Problems

4 Chapter 4: Engineering Mathematics — Advanced Math & Transform Methods

4.1 Laplace Transforms, Inverse Transforms & Circuit Applications 4.2 Fourier Series, Fourier Transforms & Frequency-Domain Analysis 4.3 Vector Analysis, Linear Algebra, Matrices & Complex Analysis

5 Chapter 5: Engineering Mathematics — Probability, Statistics & Engineering Data Analysis

5.1 Probability Theory, Counting Techniques & Bayes' Theorem 5.2 Engineering Data Analysis I — Descriptive Statistics & Probability Distributions 5.3 Engineering Data Analysis II — Confidence Intervals, Hypothesis Testing & Regression

6 Chapter 6: Engineering Mathematics — Numerical Methods & Analysis

6.1 Numerical Root-Finding & Solution of Linear Systems 6.2 Interpolation, Numerical Integration & Numerical Solution of ODEs

7 Chapter 7: ESAS — Physics, Chemistry & Computer Fundamentals

7.1 Physics for Engineers 7.2 General Chemistry & Materials Science 7.3 Computer Fundamentals, Programming & Data Logic 7.4 Logic Circuits, Switching Theory & Microprocessor Systems

8 Chapter 8: ESAS — Mechanics & Thermal-Fluid Engineering

8.1 Engineering Mechanics — Statics & Dynamics 8.2 Strength of Materials & Mechanics of Deformable Bodies 8.3 Thermal-Fluid Engineering — Thermodynamics & Fluid Mechanics

9 Chapter 9: ESAS — Engineering Economics, Management & Contracts

9.1 Engineering Economics & Depreciation 9.2 Engineering Management & Ethics 9.3 Philippine Electrical Engineering Law, Code & Contracts 9.4 Technopreneurship 101 & Management of Engineering Projects

10 Chapter 10: PEC 1 — Safety, Sizing & Protection

10.1 PEC Fundamentals, Safety Standards & Grounding/Bonding 10.2 Conductor Sizing, Ampacity Adjustment & Voltage Drop 10.3 Overcurrent Protection, Branch Circuit & Feeder Sizing 10.4 Basic Occupational Safety & Health (BOSH) and Electrical Safety Standards

11 Chapter 11: PEC 1 & 2 — Equipment & Utility Systems

11.1 PEC Equipment Installation & Wiring Methods 11.2 Utility Systems, Transformers & Switchgear 11.3 Special Occupancies & Hazardous Locations

12 Chapter 12: Electrical Professional — DC & AC Circuit Fundamentals

12.1 DC Circuit Analysis & Network Theorems 12.2 Single-Phase AC Circuits & Phasor Analysis 12.3 Balanced & Unbalanced Three-Phase AC Circuits

13 Chapter 13: Electrical Professional — EM Fields & Transients

13.1 Electrostatics, Magnetostatics & Maxwell's Equations 13.2 Electromagnetic Waves & Transmission Line Fields 13.3 First-Order & Second-Order Circuit Transients

14 Chapter 14: Electrical Professional — Electronics, Industrial Electronics & Communications

14.1 Electronics 1 & 2 — Semiconductor Devices & Analog Circuits 14.2 Electrical Apparatus & Devices — Industrial Electronics & Power Converters 14.3 Fundamentals of Electronic Communications

15 Chapter 15: Electrical Professional — Transformers & DC Machines

15.1 Single-Phase & Three-Phase Transformers 15.2 Transformer Connections & Special Transformers 15.3 DC Generators & DC Motors

16 Chapter 16: Electrical Professional — AC Synchronous & Induction Machinery

16.1 Synchronous Generators (Alternators) 16.2 Synchronous Motors & Special AC Machines 16.3 Three-Phase & Single-Phase Induction Motors

17 Chapter 17: Electrical Professional — Power Plants & Energy Conversion

17.1 Hydroelectric, Thermal & Combined Cycle Power Plants 17.2 Renewable Energy Systems & Geothermal Power Plants 17.3 Power Plant Economics, Load Curves & Energy Conversion

18 Chapter 18: Electrical Professional — Transmission & Distribution

18.1 Transmission Line Parameters & Performance Models 18.2 Mechanical Overhead Line Design, Underground Cables & Insulators 18.3 Distribution Systems, Substation Layouts & Power Flow Control

19 Chapter 19: Electrical Professional — Power System Analysis

19.1 The Per-Unit System, Base Conversion & Impedance Diagrams 19.2 Symmetrical Components & Unbalanced Fault Analysis 19.3 Load Flow, Economic Dispatch & Power System Stability

20 Chapter 20: Electrical Professional — Protection, Control, Instrumentation & Illumination

20.1 Power System Protection & Protective Relaying 20.2 Industrial Motor Control, Logic Circuits & PLC Automation 20.3 Electrical Instrumentation, Transducers & Measurement Systems 20.4 Illumination Engineering, Lighting Design & Photometrics 20.5 Feedback Control Systems & Research Methods

19.2 Symmetrical Components & Unbalanced Fault Analysis

Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI

Any set of three unbalanced phasors resolves into positive-, negative- and zero-sequence sets, with Va0 = (Va + Vb + Vc)/3 and the operator a = 1∠120°.

A three-phase balanced fault uses the positive-sequence network only; single line-to-ground connects all three sequence networks in series and gives Ia1 = Ea/(Z1 + Z2 + Z0).

Line-to-line faults connect positive and negative sequence networks in parallel with no zero-sequence involvement, so LL fault current is about 86.6% of the three-phase value.

Zero-sequence current requires a return path: a delta winding traps it and an ungrounded wye blocks it entirely, which is why transformer connection determines ground-fault current.

Faults ranked by typical frequency of occurrence are single line-to-ground (about 70–80%), line-to-line, double line-to-ground, then three-phase (about 5%), which is nevertheless usually the most severe.

Last updated: August 2026

19.2 Symmetrical Components & Unbalanced Fault Analysis

Balanced three-phase faults are the easy case and account for only about 5% of real faults. The remaining 95% are unbalanced, and the only practical way to analyse them by hand is Fortescue's method of symmetrical components , a core component of Enhanced TOS topic K, Power System Analysis (PRBEE Resolution No. 40, s. 2024 — 9.00% of the examination, 20 of the 100 Electrical Engineering items).

1. The Symmetrical Component Transformation

Any three unbalanced phasors decompose into three balanced sets:

Positive sequence (1) — three equal phasors 120° apart in the normal rotation a a a – b b b – c c c ; this is the only set present in a healthy balanced system;

Negative sequence (2) — three equal phasors 120° apart in the reversed rotation a a a – c c c – b b b ; it produces a counter-rotating field that heats generator rotors, which is why negative-sequence relays exist;

Zero sequence (0) — three equal phasors in phase ; it can flow only where a neutral or ground return path exists.

The operator a = 1 ∠ 120 ° = − 0.5 + j 0.866 a = 1\angle 120° = -0.5 + j0.866 a = 1∠120° = − 0.5 + j 0.866 satisfies a 2 = 1 ∠ 240 ° , a 3 = 1 , 1 + a + a 2 = 0 a^{2} = 1\angle 240°, \qquad a^{3} = 1, \qquad 1 + a + a^{2} = 0 a 2 = 1∠240° , a 3 = 1 , 1 + a + a 2 = 0

Synthesis (components to phase quantities): V a = V a 0 + V a 1 + V a 2 V_a = V_{a0} + V_{a1} + V_{a2} V a ​ = V a 0 ​ + V a 1 ​ + V a 2 ​ V b = V a 0 + a 2 V a 1 + a V a 2 V_b = V_{a0} + a^{2}V_{a1} + aV_{a2} V b ​ = V a 0 ​ + a 2 V a 1 ​ + a V a 2 ​ V c = V a 0 + a V a 1 + a 2 V a 2 V_c = V_{a0} + aV_{a1} + a^{2}V_{a2} V c ​ = V a 0 ​ + a V a 1 ​ + a 2 V a 2 ​

Analysis (phase quantities to components): V a 0 = 1 3 ( V a + V b + V c ) V_{a0} = \frac{1}{3}\left(V_a + V_b + V_c\right) V a 0 ​ = 3 1 ​ ( V a ​ + V b ​ + V c ​ ) V a 1 = 1 3 ( V a + a V b + a 2 V c ) V_{a1} = \frac{1}{3}\left(V_a + aV_b + a^{2}V_c\right) V a 1 ​ = 3 1 ​ ( V a ​ + a V b ​ + a 2 V c ​ ) V a 2 = 1 3 ( V a + a 2 V b + a V c ) V_{a2} = \frac{1}{3}\left(V_a + a^{2}V_b + aV_c\right) V a 2 ​ = 3 1 ​ ( V a ​ + a 2 V b ​ + a V c ​ )

Two consequences are examined repeatedly:

In a three-wire system (no neutral), I a + I b + I c = 0 I_a + I_b + I_c = 0 I a ​ + I b ​ + I c ​ = 0 , so zero-sequence current is zero by definition;

In a four-wire system the neutral carries I n = 3 I a 0 I_n = 3I_{a0} I n ​ = 3 I a 0 ​ — the neutral current is three times the zero-sequence current, not equal to it.

2. Sequence Networks

Each sequence has its own network with its own impedance.

Element Z 1 Z_1 Z 1 ​ Z 2 Z_2 Z 2 ​ Z 0 Z_0 Z 0 ​

Synchronous generator X d ′ ′ X_d'' X d ′′ ​ ≈ X d ′ ′ \approx X_d'' ≈ X d ′′ ​ Smallest; typically 0.15 0.15 0.15 – 0.6 × X 1 0.6 \times X_1 0.6 × X 1 ​

Transformer Z T Z_T Z T ​ Z T Z_T Z T ​ Z T Z_T Z T ​ , but path depends on winding connection

Transmission line Z 1 Z_1 Z 1 ​ Z 1 = Z 2 Z_1 = Z_2 Z 1 ​ = Z 2 ​ 2 2 2 – 3.5 × Z 1 3.5 \times Z_1 3.5 × Z 1 ​ (ground return path)

For static equipment — lines, cables, transformers — Z 1 = Z 2 Z_1 = Z_2 Z 1 ​ = Z 2 ​ always, because a static device cannot tell the direction of phase rotation. For rotating machines Z 2 ≠ Z 1 Z_2 \ne Z_1 Z 2 ​  = Z 1 ​ in general, though Z 2 ≈ X d ′ ′ Z_2 \approx X_d'' Z 2 ​ ≈ X d ′′ ​ is the usual working assumption.

Zero-sequence line impedance is substantially higher than positive sequence because the return path is the earth and any overhead ground wires, enclosing a much larger flux loop.

Transformer Zero-Sequence Connection Rules

This table is the single most examinable item in the topic:

  • Connection Zero-sequence path
  • Grounded wye – grounded wye Continuous through the transformer
  • Grounded wye – delta Flows on the wye side, circulates and is trapped in the delta; does not pass through
  • Delta – delta Blocked on both sides; no external zero-sequence path
  • Ungrounded wye – anything Blocked; no zero-sequence current at all
  • Grounded wye – delta (as grounding bank) Provides a deliberate zero-sequence source for ground-fault detection

A delta winding is a zero-sequence trap : it gives circulating third-harmonic and zero-sequence currents somewhere to go, which is why a delta tertiary is added to large wye-wye autotransformers.

3. Fault Types and Sequence Network Interconnection

  • Fault type Network connection Fault current expression
  • Three-phase (balanced) Positive sequence only I f = E a Z 1 I_f = \dfrac{E_a}{Z_1} I f ​ = Z 1 ​ E a ​ ​

Single line-to-ground (SLG) Z 1 Z_1 Z 1 ​ , Z 2 Z_2 Z 2 ​ , Z 0 Z_0 Z 0 ​ in series I a 1 = E a Z 1 + Z 2 + Z 0 I_{a1} = \dfrac{E_a}{Z_1+Z_2+Z_0} I a 1 ​ = Z 1 ​ + Z 2 ​ + Z 0 ​ E a ​ ​ , I a = 3 I a 1 I_a = 3I_{a1} I a ​ = 3 I a 1 ​

Line-to-line (LL) Z 1 Z_1 Z 1 ​ , Z 2 Z_2 Z 2 ​ in parallel ; no zero sequence I a 1 = E a Z 1 + Z 2 I_{a1} = \dfrac{E_a}{Z_1+Z_2} I a 1 ​ = Z 1 ​ + Z 2 ​ E a ​ ​ , I b = − j 3 I a 1 I_b = -j\sqrt{3}\,I_{a1} I b ​ = − j 3 ​ I a 1 ​

Double line-to-ground (DLG) Z 1 Z_1 Z 1 ​ in series with Z 2 ∥ Z 0 Z_2 \parallel Z_0 Z 2 ​ ∥ Z 0 ​ I a 1 = E a Z 1 + Z 2 Z 0 Z 2 + Z 0 I_{a1} = \dfrac{E_a}{Z_1 + \dfrac{Z_2Z_0}{Z_2+Z_0}} I a 1 ​ = Z 1 ​ + Z 2 ​ + Z 0 ​ Z 2 ​ Z 0 ​ ​ E a ​ ​

Open conductor Series (rather than shunt) network connection Produces negative-sequence current without high fault current

Fault-current arithmetic worth memorising: with Z 1 = Z 2 Z_1 = Z_2 Z 1 ​ = Z 2 ​ , the line-to-line fault current is I L L I 3 ϕ = 3 2 = 0.866 \frac{I_{LL}}{I_{3\phi}} = \frac{\sqrt{3}}{2} = 0.866 I 3 ϕ ​ I LL ​ ​ = 2 3 ​ ​ = 0.866

so an LL fault is always about 86.6% of the three-phase value. A single line-to-ground fault can exceed the three-phase value when Z 0 < Z 1 Z_0 < Z_1 Z 0 ​ < Z 1 ​ , which happens on solidly grounded systems close to a grounded-wye transformer — a genuine engineering result and a favourite examination trap for candidates who assume the three-phase fault is always the worst case.

Faults ranked by frequency of occurrence: SLG 70–80% , LL about 15%, DLG about 10%, and three-phase only about 5% .

4. System Grounding

  • Grounding method Ground-fault current Transient overvoltage Typical application
  • Solidly grounded Very high Low LV distribution, most utility MV
  • Low-resistance grounded Limited to 100–1000 A Moderate Industrial MV systems
  • High-resistance grounded Limited to about 5–10 A Moderate Continuous-process plants
  • Ungrounded Capacitive only High (arcing ground fault) Legacy systems; increasingly avoided

Neutral grounding impedance Z n Z_n Z n ​ appears in the zero-sequence network as 3 Z n 3Z_n 3 Z n ​ — three times, because the total zero-sequence current 3 I a 0 3I_{a0} 3 I a 0 ​ flows through it. Forgetting the factor of three is the standard error in grounded-neutral fault problems.

  • Solved Board Exam Examples
  • Example 1: Resolving Unbalanced Line Currents

A four-wire feeder carries I a = 10 ∠ 0 ° I_a = 10\angle 0° I a ​ = 10∠0° A, I b = 10 ∠ 230 ° I_b = 10\angle 230° I b ​ = 10∠230° A and I c = 10 ∠ 130 ° I_c = 10\angle 130° I c ​ = 10∠130° A. Find the zero-sequence current and the neutral current.

Solution. I a 0 = 1 3 ( I a + I b + I c ) I_{a0} = \frac{1}{3}\left(I_a + I_b + I_c\right) I a 0 ​ = 3 1 ​ ( I a ​ + I b ​ + I c ​ )

Converting to rectangular form: 10 ∠ 0 ° = 10 + j 0 10\angle 0° = 10 + j0 10∠0° = 10 + j 0 ; 10 ∠ 230 ° = − 6.428 − j 7.660 10\angle 230° = -6.428 - j7.660 10∠230° = − 6.428 − j 7.660 ; 10 ∠ 130 ° = − 6.428 + j 7.660 10\angle 130° = -6.428 + j7.660 10∠130° = − 6.428 + j 7.660 . ∑ = ( 10 − 6.428 − 6.428 ) + j ( 0 − 7.660 + 7.660 ) = − 2.856 + j 0 \sum = (10 - 6.428 - 6.428) + j(0 - 7.660 + 7.660) = -2.856 + j0 ∑ = ( 10 − 6.428 − 6.428 ) + j ( 0 − 7.660 + 7.660 ) = − 2.856 + j 0 I a 0 = − 2.856 3 = − 0.952 A = 0.952 ∠ 180 ° A I_{a0} = \frac{-2.856}{3} = \boxed{-0.952 \text{ A}} = 0.952\angle 180° \text{ A} I a 0 ​ = 3 − 2.856 ​ = − 0.952 A ​ = 0.952∠180° A

The neutral carries three times this value: I n = 3 I a 0 = 2.856 ∠ 180 ° A I_n = 3I_{a0} = \boxed{2.856\angle 180° \text{ A}} I n ​ = 3 I a 0 ​ = 2.856∠180° A ​

Had the feeder been three-wire with no neutral or ground return, I a + I b + I c I_a + I_b + I_c I a ​ + I b ​ + I c ​ would be forced to zero and no zero-sequence component could exist at all — a useful sanity check on any set of measured currents.

Example 2: Single Line-to-Ground Fault Current

At a bus, Z 1 = j 0.15 Z_1 = j0.15 Z 1 ​ = j 0.15 pu, Z 2 = j 0.15 Z_2 = j0.15 Z 2 ​ = j 0.15 pu and Z 0 = j 0.05 Z_0 = j0.05 Z 0 ​ = j 0.05 pu on a 100 MVA, 13.8 kV base. Find the SLG fault current in amperes and compare it with the three-phase fault.

Solution. For an SLG fault the sequence networks are in series: I a 1 = 1.0 j ( 0.15 + 0.15 + 0.05 ) = 1.0 j 0.35 = − j 2.857 pu I_{a1} = \frac{1.0}{j(0.15 + 0.15 + 0.05)} = \frac{1.0}{j0.35} = -j2.857 \text{ pu} I a 1 ​ = j ( 0.15 + 0.15 + 0.05 ) 1.0 ​ = j 0.35 1.0 ​ = − j 2.857 pu I a = 3 I a 1 = 8.571 pu I_a = 3I_{a1} = 8.571 \text{ pu} I a ​ = 3 I a 1 ​ = 8.571 pu I b a s e = 100 3 ( 13.8 ) = 4.184 kA ⟹ I a = 8.571 × 4.184 = 35.86 kA I_{base} = \frac{100}{\sqrt{3}(13.8)} = 4.184 \text{ kA} \implies I_a = 8.571 \times 4.184 = \boxed{35.86 \text{ kA}} I ba se ​ = 3 ​ ( 13.8 ) 100 ​ = 4.184 kA ⟹ I a ​ = 8.571 × 4.184 = 35.86 kA ​

The three-phase fault gives 1.0 / 0.15 = 6.667 1.0/0.15 = 6.667 1.0/0.15 = 6.667 pu = 27.89 = 27.89 = 27.89 kA. Because Z 0 < Z 1 Z_0 < Z_1 Z 0 ​ < Z 1 ​ , the ground fault is 28% more severe than the three-phase fault — precisely the case that defeats the "three-phase is always worst" assumption.

Example 3: Line-to-Line Fault Ratio

For a machine with Z 1 = Z 2 = j 0.20 Z_1 = Z_2 = j0.20 Z 1 ​ = Z 2 ​ = j 0.20 pu, find the ratio of line-to-line fault current to three-phase fault current.

Solution. I 3 ϕ = 1.0 0.20 = 5.0 pu I_{3\phi} = \frac{1.0}{0.20} = 5.0 \text{ pu} I 3 ϕ ​ = 0.20 1.0 ​ = 5.0 pu

For the LL fault, I a 1 = 1.0 j ( 0.20 + 0.20 ) = − j 2.5 I_{a1} = \dfrac{1.0}{j(0.20+0.20)} = -j2.5 I a 1 ​ = j ( 0.20 + 0.20 ) 1.0 ​ = − j 2.5 pu, and the faulted phase current is I b = − j 3 I a 1 ⟹ ∣ I b ∣ = 3 ( 2.5 ) = 4.330 pu I_b = -j\sqrt{3}\,I_{a1} \implies |I_b| = \sqrt{3}(2.5) = 4.330 \text{ pu} I b ​ = − j 3 ​ I a 1 ​ ⟹ ∣ I b ​ ∣ = 3 ​ ( 2.5 ) = 4.330 pu I L L I 3 ϕ = 4.330 5.0 = 0.866 \frac{I_{LL}}{I_{3\phi}} = \frac{4.330}{5.0} = \boxed{0.866} I 3 ϕ ​ I LL ​ ​ = 5.0 4.330 ​ = 0.866 ​

This √3/2 ratio holds whenever Z 1 = Z 2 Z_1 = Z_2 Z 1 ​ = Z 2 ​ , independent of the actual impedance values.

Loading diagram... Sequence Network Interconnection by Fault Type

Approximate Relative Frequency of Power System Fault Types (%)